Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Love Letters

Rate this book
When her sister falls gravely ill, twenty-year-old Marlena Wenger takes on the responsibility of caring for her infant niece, Angel Rose. Worried that this turn of events portends a more complicated future than he is prepared for, her beau ends their relationship. Marlena is devastated, but is determined to give Angel Rose the best care possible.

Though from the Beachy Amish herself, Marlena meets Ellie Bitner, an Old Order Amish mother who offers quilting and needlepoint classes. They soon form a bond, and Marlena is drawn into the circle of Ellie's family. Ellie's handsome cousin seems rather taken with Marlena, but after her recent breakup, she is cautious where her feelings are concerned.

But things begin to change when Ellie's young son Jacob discovers an older homeless man camped out in the nearby abandoned mill. Suffering from some cognitive disorder, the man has few prospects and fewer possessions--among them a small clutch of letters apparently from his own courting days. Could these letters be the key to the old man's identity? And can they bring healing and hope to Marlena and Ellie as well?

345 pages, Paperback

First published January 1, 1944

328 people are currently reading
2329 people want to read

About the author

Beverly Lewis

259 books3,022 followers
Librarian Note: There is more than one author in the Goodreads database with this name.

Beverly Lewis, raised in Pennsylvania Amish country and both a schoolteacher and an accomplished musician, has been an award-winning author for over a dozen years. Her acclaimed novel, The Preacher's Daughter, was a 2006 Quill Book Award finalist in the romance category. Her books have appeared on numerous bestseller lists, including USA Today and The New York Times. She and her husband, David, live in Colorado."

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
1,218 (51%)
4 stars
705 (29%)
3 stars
360 (15%)
2 stars
79 (3%)
1 star
19 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 250 reviews
Profile Image for Dale Harcombe.
Author 14 books428 followers
June 9, 2025

Marlena Wenger’s life undergoes a radical change. She is called to leave her home town and her loved ones, including her beau, Nat, and go and help her Mennonite grandmother care for niece Angela Rose after her estranged sister Luella is seriously hurt in an accident. Luella had years before given up on the Amish faith. Marlena plans to spend that summer in Brownstown, Pennsylvania with her grandmother who is grieving her husband’s death. But plans have a way of changing and so does Marlena, as she seeks to reconcile her grandmother’s beliefs, faith and relationship with God with the Old Order Amish teaching. The Old Order Amish teaching is something her beau is very strong on maintaining. Marlena is anxious to get back to Nat and the familiar as soon as possible, but then eventstake a drastic turn.
Along with this story is the story of neighbours Ellie and Roman, their three daughters and their son Small Jay who has a few challenges. Small Jay is used to feeling like an outsider, especially since his father seems to view him as a liability and not the type of son he wanted. But it is Small Jay who steps up and helps, Boston, a confused, homeless man.
This is a beautiful story about family, choices, faith, change and friendship as well as valuing others. It is peopled with characters who touched my heart. Little Jay in particular stole my heart. When I wasn’t reading, which is all I kept wanting to do, I was thinking about all the characters. So much of it really spoke to me. I loved this quote which appears in the book. ‘Wise folk never reject the possibility of a miracle.’ Indeed. Wise words to hold onto.
Interesting to see the differences in beliefs between different Amish and Mennonite groups but it was the bible teaching that often spoke to me. I adored everything about this story. Definitely a recommended thought provoking read.. For me a case of the right book at the right time.
Profile Image for Angie.
1,233 reviews90 followers
June 22, 2015
3.5 stars...

An enjoyable offering from Beverly Lewis, the master of Amish fiction. I have had a longtime fascination with the Amish, starting in grade school when I read Lois Lenski's "Shoo-fly Girl." I've read several of BL's series, but not all. I have to spread my Amish reading out, so I don't I get bored of it. Anyway, this summer my family took a road trip and I was fortunate to get to pass through Amish country. It inspired me to want to read a few new Amish stories. I found this on the "new" shelf at the library, and was intrigued.

As far as Amish fiction goes, I'd rate this up there with the more "religious" ones. That sounds strange, but often times the religion isn't really the focus. In this one, it was part of the main storyline. Our leading lady, Marlena, is a young woman in the mid 1960's during a time of change in the Amish. There are many break offs with varying degrees of strictness on technology, automobiles, clothing, prayer, etc. She is smack in the middle with family members attending different churches and her beau in still another one. This leads her on a spiritual journey. In spite of its religiousness, I liked this book and found it easy to read. It was about her journey to God without being overtly religious. There is also a couple of other interesting side stories that keep you entertained. Fans of BL will want to read it for sure. For those new to her writing, I'd suggest starting with the Abram's Daughters series, my personal favorite of hers, or the Courtship of Nellie Fisher, another series of hers I really liked.
Profile Image for Diane U.
119 reviews18 followers
April 13, 2015
When her sister falls gravely ill, twenty-year-old Marlena Wenger takes on the responsibility of caring for her infant niece, Angel Rose. Worried that this turn of events portends a more complicated future than he is prepared for, her beau ends their relationship. Marlena is devastated, but is determined to give Angel Rose the best care possible.

Though from the Beachy Amish herself, Marlena meets Ellie Bitner, an Old Order Amish mother who offers quilting and needlepoint classes. They soon form a bond, and Marlena is drawn into the circle of Ellie's family. Ellie's handsome cousin seems rather taken with Marlena, but after her recent breakup, she is cautious where her feelings are concerned.

But things begin to change when Ellie's young son Jacob discovers an older homeless man camped out in the nearby abandoned mill. Suffering from some cognitive disorder, the man has few prospects and fewer possessions--among them a small clutch of letters apparently from his own courting days. Could these letters be the key to the old man's identity? And can they bring healing and hope to Marlena and Ellie as well?

The first part of this story was about Marlena Wenger. She moves in with her Mammi to help her deal with household responsibilities after the passing of her Dawdi Tim. While she is there, her sister Luella, who left the Amish community, died in a car accident and Marlena has been asked to care for her young niece, Angel Rose, until Luella's husband and in-laws are contacted. It was a transition period for her but things worked out.

Marlena also has a beau, Nat, back home who she is staying the contact with but there are several things in her life with Mammi that Nat does not approve of, including her raising her niece. What will become of their relationship?

The second part of this story is about the Bitner family who are neighbors of Mammi. Small Jay meets a stranger in an abandoned mill named Boston who does not remember much about his past. Small Jay becomes a dear friend of Boston's and works with him to regain his memory of his past.

This was a story about love, dedication, family and responsibility. I really enjoyed reading it and how everything worked out in the end.

A special thank you to Bethany House for allowing me to read this book in advance in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Rhonda.
516 reviews20 followers
March 1, 2015
Death, dementia, special needs' children, faith and differences in religious practices and expression....these are all some weighty issues and Beverly Lewis tackles all of them in this book. Marlena and her family and friends stole my heart as I read this book. I could relate to Marlena's falling in love with her sister's precious baby, Angela. Marlena sacrifices for many people in her life and never complains or argues. She willingly goes along with ministering to others as she feels God's direction. I definitely could take some lessons from this loyal and dutiful young woman. She stirred my heart and gave me many things to consider and ponder.
I honestly felt that this book was one of Beverly's best ever. I appreciated the tender and sensitive way that she dealt with some very touchy issues. I taught special needs' preschoolers for many years and learned so many things from the precious children just as Jake taught so much to those around him as he helped the elderly homeless man. I wished that I could attend the quilting and embroidery classes along with Ellie and her students. It sounded like such fun and I would love to have someone show me how to quilt as I am learning but have to teach myself.
I rate this exceptional book 5 stars and would love to hear readers' thoughts after they have read it.
I received a pdf version of this book from netgalley in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for June Jacobs.
Author 51 books152 followers
April 16, 2015
This was an awesome book! The story is set in Pennsylvania Amish Country in 1966. The two main stories are very touching and involve the themes of love, healing, personal growth, and faith. The cover has a sweet photo of a young Amish woman cradling a baby on the porch of a farmhouse. It's beautiful and does a good job of introducing the tone of the book to readers.

I have enjoyed Beverly Lewis's books for several years, but the most recent three I've read ('The River', 'Child of Mine', and this one) have excelled in the storytelling and character development arenas. I highly recommend 'The Love Letters' for fans of Amish fiction, religious fiction, and historical fiction. I can't wait to read Mrs. Lewis's next release coming this fall, 'The Photograph'.

I borrowed a copy of this book from our local public library.

############
Profile Image for Christina DeVane.
432 reviews53 followers
April 8, 2020
I needed a light, fluffy read for this time of craziness everywhere and I can’t seem to handle too heavy or deep topics right now in my pregnancy (6 months). 😆
This wasn’t a typical romance book which I greatly appreciated. The Love Letters belong to an older man who has been befriended by a young, simple-minded Amish boy. The man is lost and confused, living in barns, but carries a satchel filled with love letters from a woman he doesn’t remember. Marlena taking care of her niece is a side story really although the initial write up makes it sound all about her.
As always the ending is tied up nicely with everything being resolved.
Profile Image for Megan.
197 reviews35 followers
September 12, 2018
Whenever I pick up a book by Beverly Lewis, I get this extra happy, excited feeling because I know it is going to be a good book that will transport me to Amish country and introduce me to endearing characters. This book is no exception! I was transported away with the first page and immediately fell in love with the characters. I loved Small Jay! He was such a sweetheart! Marlena was also very sweet. I admire her a lot because of her willingness to take care of her sister's baby even despite criticism from others (shame on them!). She held her ground and didn't complain at all. I also appreciated her battle with where she fit in the Amish religiously. There were a lot of people breaking off from the Old Order at this time including Marlena's own family and she had to discover and grow her own faith. I enjoyed the love letter storyline with Boston and his love, but I do wish the love letters would have been shown more. Another gripe is there were times when the reader was told the characters talked about things without us actually "seeing" them talking. That pulled me out of the story and also, because that happened with the main couple, made the romance seem a bit rushed. That would be my final complaint. There didn't seem to be a lot of interaction between the main couple so the romance felt rushed and not very deep. I will say that romance is not really the focus of this story so that is probably why it was more in the background. Other than those small issues, I loved this sweet story!
Profile Image for Karyn Niedert.
379 reviews24 followers
March 28, 2015
Beverly Lewis managed to touch on a number of issues in her book, "The Love Letters". Marlena is struggling with identifying how she wants to honor her faith, balancing her upcoming betrothal to Nat while at the same time becoming responsible for her older sister's orphaned daughter Angela. The corollary story of Small Jay and how his friendship with a confused "homeless" man forges a new and strong relationship with his father. was wonderful.

Beverly Lewis has long been a favorite author of mine, and this is one of her best yet. She wrote of Small Jay's challenges with such heart and care it broke my heart. She also did a wonderful job explaining to readers throughout the story how Marlena's journey to decide whether to embrace Nat and the Old Amish order or to learn more about the more technologically accepting Beachy Amish order.

I truly loved the characters in "The Love Letters" and would love to read a follow up book sharing them again.

Thank you to Netgalley and Bethany House Publishing for providing me with an ARC.
Profile Image for Alicia Ruggieri.
Author 12 books126 followers
March 6, 2019
A lovely story of forgiveness and sacrifice, of finding out what real love - both romantic and platonic - is, of choosing God's path rather than your own, The Love Letters is one of those quiet novels that took me by surprise and left me thinking about its characters and their choices for a while... In fact, I'm still thinking about them. :-)

One thing I love about a lot of Beverly Lewis' novels, especially her last few like The Ebb Tide, is that they are not "Amish" novels but more novels that have characters who happen to Amish. The themes are ones that pervade all of our lives, Amish or not.

A really lovely book. Well recommended.
Profile Image for Angela (Kentuckybooklover) Brocato-Skaggs.
1,970 reviews37 followers
March 31, 2015
Beverly Lewis does it again! She tackles a little of everything that makes a family tick. I could not turn the pages fast enough to see what was going to transpire next. Lewis writes with such feeling you feel like you are the character you are reading.

The Love Letters is one of my favorite Beverly Lewis novels yet.
Profile Image for Abby.
130 reviews12 followers
May 21, 2015
A long book, with a slapped together "perfect" ending. Not my favorite by Beverly Lewis. I mean it was alright but not what I was expecting!
Profile Image for Paula-O.
558 reviews
April 16, 2015
The Love Letters written by Beverly Lewis

Marlena Wenger's life has changed drasticaly when she leaves a beau behind and goes to stay the summer with her Mothers Mother in Brownstown, PA.
Grandmother is a Mennonite and she came from old order amish, this makes for some changes that she never thought she would see in her life.
Love letters are written back and forth to her beau and she soon knows he is not happy with her going to a Mennonite church.
A sister that had left the amish community dies is an accident and her husband is in army faraway along with his parents out of the country. Marlena is asked to care for the child until others can be found and told.
Marlena soon loves this little one and will be sad when the father comes to get her. This is another thing that her beau is unhappy with as he ask in his letter often, "When will someone come for the child"?
Marlena tries to be a helper to all, grandmother-baby and to neighbors-meeting others in the community and seeing how Memmonite study their Bible and talk and pray to Jesus has her thoughts confused.

I was given this book by Bethany House publishing to read and review, thanks for the opportunity to read this author again.
Profile Image for Kimberly.
167 reviews
February 3, 2015
I enjoyed reading The Love Letters by Beverly Lewis. Marlena Wenger is staying with her grandmother to help her out after the passing of her grandfather, when her sister is hospitalized and her niece Angel Rose also comes to stay. Marlena quickly becomes connected to the baby, which her beau Nat is not happy about.
The neighbor boy Jacob finds a homeless man, who is having problems with his memory, living in the old mill.

I found myself quickly involved in their stories, disliking Nat and his parents for there judgemental ways, and absolutely loving 'Small Jay'. I love reading books about the Amish and Beverly Lewis has created another wonderful story with characters to love and dislike.

I received an ARC (advanced readers copy) from Bethany House and NetGallery in exchange for my honest review rather it be good or bad. Thank you
Profile Image for Lyssa.
859 reviews25 followers
April 6, 2015
This was a very sweet, quiet kind of story. It was a little too quiet for my taste (you spend a lot of time in the character's thoughts, just pondering things, or remarking about the state of things), but was still a nice book to read before bed and here and there.

This is the first Amish book I've read that involved the "Beachy Amish" and there was little explanation about the different sects, so I didn't fully understand what the big deal was about some things.

I really enjoyed the unique characters and their resolutions. I loved the Christian themes of sacrifice and submission within a marriage and really waiting patiently on God and His plan.
3,939 reviews1,764 followers
August 11, 2015
I love the way this author's writing voice immediately coaxes me into another world. I feel like she's sitting next to me, relating the tale in the age old oral tradition of a classic storyteller. And, of course, I'm hanging onto her every word.

Lewis weaves seemingly diverse story threads together to create an unforgettable celebration of the power that comes from the many facets of love. Young Jake and a collection of love letters are the catalysts that stir things ups for a number of characters -- each on a journey of discovery; finding strength and courage in unforeseen places. A breathtaking read.
Profile Image for Katie.
508 reviews
May 2, 2015
The synopsis sounded interesting but the story didn't go anywhere. I got bored and started skimming. :/
Profile Image for Deanne Patterson.
2,414 reviews119 followers
February 25, 2016
This author is the first one I read the Amish genre from. She writes a great solid faith filled story . Each story teaches a subtle lesson of faith and compassion. I enjoyed this story immensely.
Profile Image for Andrea Cox.
Author 4 books1,744 followers
August 4, 2020
This book was all about the characters and their journeys for me.

Boston was my favorite character. He was a bit of a vagrant, dealt with amnesia, and had the most amazing love letters in his pack. I especially loved how he brought a community and a family closer together.

Small Jay was so much fun! He was adorable and had a cute pet cat. I liked that he yearned for affection, attention, and acceptance. It was also neat that he had a huge heart and wanted to lend a helping hand to his fellow man.

Marlena was amazing as well. That she learned to adapt well to forced changes in her life was inspiring to watch unfold. I liked that she was a caretaker for the young and old. Oh the heart she had! Her sensitivity, compassion, and sweetness made her a joy to read about.
Profile Image for Barbara.
1,983 reviews
May 25, 2019
Beverly Lewis is a good writer, and her books always hold my interest. The only negative is that many times I have a good idea what will happen about halfway through. I loved the way Jake changed during the course of the book, and his friendship with Boston was inspirational.
44 reviews1 follower
July 9, 2019
This was such a sweet book and beautifully written. I love reading about Amish families and this book was a delight, capturing my heart from the first chapter. An author I will definitely read again
Profile Image for Kristen.
154 reviews
September 16, 2023
This book didn’t really have my attention. It wasn’t my favorite book that I have read. I have read others by this author though and I have liked them so I plan to read more by this author. It was kinda blah to me.
Profile Image for Linda Munro.
1,939 reviews27 followers
February 22, 2019

This was one of the books used in my library’s Date with a book Contest. The book was wrapped in heart paper with a heart declaring “Could these letters be the key to the old man’s identity?” That intrigued me so I selected the book. Once I returned home, I unwrapped the book and was immediately disappointed that I had unknowingly selected an Amish based book. However, the caption on the package continued to intrigue me so I read the book.

While the book did offer hints towards an old man’s identity and where he was from; a man found by an outcast within his own family due to his size and stature, a man who wrote notes to himself when his memory fog cleared; it stuck to the Amish lifestyle, trials and tribulations, making it a slow read.

I think the book would have been a much better read if the soul focuse was on the old man with memory problems and the determination of anoter society to help him find his way home!

3 Stars
Profile Image for Carrie Tripp.
28 reviews1 follower
March 28, 2015
So we don't look at the troubles we can see now; rather, we fix our gaze on things that cannot be seen. For the things we see now will soon be gone, but the things we cannot see will last forever. 2 Corinthians 4:18 NLT

The Love Letters by Beverly Lewis focuses on Marlena Wenger, a young woman struggling to hold on to Old Order Amish ways amidst a family open to new ways, who is sent away from her beau to help her Mennonite grandmother who has recently become a widow. Soon after, she finds herself as surrogate mother to her newborn niece, and facing the unbelievable decision of letting go of flesh and blood or letting go of her future husband. Is it possible that Small Jay and the homeless man he has become attached to can find a way to fix everything in the Brownstown Plain community?

It seems that The Love Letters is a book in a series. While I love series, I agreed to review this book without realizing I was picking up a book in the middle of a series. The first few chapters of this book were very slow and confusing for me. I really struggled with the fact that based on what I know about romance formula, Marlena and Small Jay were going to fall in love.

Despite the beliefs of the religion, I just couldn't find myself ok with the age difference and difference in mental capacity. I kept finding myself arguing that while all people deserved love and to be loved, this wasn't the way this should happen.

The majority of this novel deals with the internal conflict Marlena faces time and time again as she searches for her place in God's kingdom. She desperately tries to cling to the way things have always been, while questioning and attempting to shun the idea of having a personal relationship with God.

While I don't feel anyone should make hasty decisions when evaluating their relationship with God, there were many times throughout this novel I wanted to yell at Marlena. Not only was she clinging to a religion instead of God Himself, she was holding tight to a man who didn't seem entirely faithful to his faith. Amish have always been known for taking care of their families and yet he seemed to be pushing Marlena to push hers away.

The main character in this novel in Marlena. However, a parallel plot line is Small Jay and Boston, his homeless friend with the mysterious sack of love letters. Each of the men, young and old, are searching for their place and acceptance. They help each other to discover exactly what they are looking for.

Once I figured out how each family was involved in the plot, the novel became not only easier to read but also an enjoyment! The character development of Young Jay's father became just as important to me as Marlena's. I would very much like to go back and read the prior books in this series. However, once you get past the first few chapters, this is very much a stand-alone book. You do NOT have to read the books before it to understand everything that happens within this one. I simply wonder if the beginning would have been a bit faster paced if I had some background knowledge coming in.

FINAL RATING

My typical way of rating 5 star books is by their ability to make me cry literal tears or laugh out loud. There was quite a bit of loss in this book. Loss as in life and loss of respect, loss of love, loss of impressions, just loss. That loss leapt off the pages into this reader's heart and escaped through my tears. Not much laughing to speak of, but the pain was palpable.

So, if you’re still reading this book review, consider me giving you a high five right now! I am giving The Love Letters by Beverly Lewis 5 out of 5 stars.

**I have been provided with a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for this review. Please be aware that I was afraid of doing this review because as a Christian first and an English teacher second, I don’t lie about what I read. This review is my honest opinion. Had I disliked the book, you would see a rating that reflected that.**
Profile Image for Sally.
344 reviews
April 16, 2015
Beverly Lewis writes another sweet Amish story.

The Bible says sometimes we entertain angels unaware. In “The Love Letters” that is exactly what happens as Marlena Wenger tries to deal with the loss of her sister, caring for her infant niece and struggling to find her place in God’s plan. In one moment in time, her life is forever changed.

Small Jay Bitner, son of Ellie and Roman Bitner, is an underdeveloped fourteen year old, who struggles with trying to get his father to accept him the way he is, and let me work side by side with him the way Amish sons are supposed to.

Boston Calvert, a vagrant, suddenly appears at the old mill with his dog Allegro. He has no memory of how he got there or where he came from. He only had a pack of love letters in his back pack.

All because Sassy, Small Jay’s cat and Allegro met, healing began to happen in the lives of Small Jay, Boston, Marlena and Ellie and Roman.

All I can say is have the tissues ready because you will need them as this book will pull at your heart-strings more than once. I found myself moved to tears as Marlena struggled with the loss of her sister and the uncertainty of her sister’s salvation. Her sister had left the Amish Order and there had been little contact with her since she left. I found myself again in tears as she struggled with wanting to know God personally which was against the Old Order Amish. However she knew if she was going to marry her intended, Nat Zimmerman she had to stay in the Old Order faith.

The next tears came as Small Jay struggled for acceptance from his father. He felt the only one in the world who understood him was his cat Sassy and he told her everything. Through his friendship with Boston, against his father’s wishes, he began to feel that he was more than just a small handicapped boy because Boston talked to him as a person and encouraged him to follow his heart. Under Boston’s encouragement he began to grow as a responsible young man.

More tears arrived as I read Boston’s part in the story. A man, who was obviously not Amish, yet accepted their simple way of life without question. Even though Boston had little memory, his dog, Allegro, a package of love letter, a harmonica and his love for music, he was able to convey love and acceptance to all of those who met him.

Again the tears came when the healing process in the lives of those around Boston began to take place. This is an exciting story that will keep you turning the pages and holding your breath while praying for a miraculous outcome. Although there were many tears of sorrow, there were also tears of joy and lots of laughter, especially with the antics of Slasher. As I read the finishing pages, I was reminded of the scripture in Psalms 30:5 …weeping may endure for the night, but joy cometh in the morning. If you are a fan of Beverly Lewis you won’t want to miss this book. It is the best I have read to date, her insight of the Amish people is superior to any other author’s work I have read concerning the Amish. She has a distinct way of bringing a story together without being “preachy” and she often, as in the book, brings triumph through tragedy. Although her books are Amish, the events can easily be applied to any person’s life and she reveals that the Amish in many ways have the same issues as the English.

Disclosure: I was given a copy of this Book by the publisher, Bethany House, through Bethany House blogger program for review. I was not required to write a favorable review nor was I compensated for my review. The opinions in this review are my own.
Profile Image for B.J. Burgess.
790 reviews24 followers
November 17, 2015
I had never even knew there was such a thing as Amish fiction until I read The Covenant (book one in the Abram's Daughter series) by Beverly Lewis, which was either in 2001 or 2002. I had joined one of the those book clubs where you get five or six books for $.99 and you have to buy three or four books during the next two years at full price. The Covenant was one of the books I got for joining the club. I recall I was short one book, so I just picked The Covenant as it looked an interesting read. Let's just say that I became a fan of Beverly Lewis's writings very quickly. I ended up purchasing her previous novels and I have continued to read each and every new release of hers.

While many of the author's novels are part of a series featuring three to five books, she does occasionally write a stand alone novel, which just happens to be the case for The Love Letters. (No, this isn't the made-for-Hallmark movie from the late 90s.) This story is set in 1966 and centers on Marlena Wenger, a young woman with a lot on her young shoulders. She was set to marry Nathaniel Zimmerman shortly after she finishes her classes prior to being baptized into the Old Amish Order, well, that is until she learns that her grandfather has passed away and someone needs to go to Brownstown, Pennsylvania and assist her grandmother, Mammi Janice, for the summer. Guess whose going?

Yep, you guessed it - Marlena must put her life on hold to help out her grandmother. Not too long after arriving in Brownstown, Marlena learns that her estranged sister Luella has died in a car crash. Luell had left the Amish lifestyle to marry her sweetheart Gordon Munroe, who is currently serving his country in Vietnam. This leaves Marlena the guardian of her baby niece, Angela Rose.

Her grandmother's neighbors are Ellie and Roman Bitner, who have a mentally-challenged son, Jake (known as Small Jay). Due to the Jake's problems, Roman has emotionally distant himself from the boy. All the boy wants is father figure, and eventually he finds one - Boston, a homeless man with signs of Alzheimer’s. Jake talks his parents into letting Boston stay in the small house on their land that once belonged to their late Dawdi, where Jake reads Boston's old letters to him.

Meanwhile, Marlena must decide what is more important - marrying Nathaniel or taking care of her family.

The Love Letters is a completely different novel for Beverly Lewis. While the majority of her novels is about the romance between an Amish girl and her beau, the novel is about faith, family and trust. For me, it starts out a little a slow for the first several chapters, but I eventually got swept into the story. Overall, The Love Letters is an emotional tale from beginning to end.
Profile Image for Kristina Anderson.
4,062 reviews82 followers
March 20, 2015
The Love Letters by Beverly Lewis is a sweet Amish Fiction set in 1966. Dawdi Tim has pass away and his wife, Mammi Janice needs some assistance. Marlena Wenger is sent to help her out for the summer. This will mean that Marlena misses out on baptism instruction classes for the Old Order Amish and will have to wait another year to marry Nathaniel (Nat) Zimmerman.

Mammi Janice's neighbors are Ellie and Roman Bitner with their daughter's and son, Jake (aka Small Jay). Jake is mentally challenged but a very sweet boy. He has cat named Sassy that he walks around on a leash. Roman has never been close to his son. He will not let Jake help with any chores around the farm. Jake keeps trying with his father. Then one day Jake runs across a man named Boston.

Boston has memory troubles. He does not know who he is or how he ended up staying at the old mill. Boston has a dog named Allegro who liked Jake’s cat, Sassy. Boston befriends Jake. Boston provides the male figure that Jake has desperately wanted in his life. Jake brings Boston home to the farm and asks Roman to allow Boston to stay in the empty Dawdi house. Roman allows Boston to stay (in the barn) and Boston does chores in exchange. Jake reads letters to Boston that Boston had in his pack. Jake is hoping that there will be clues in the letters to Boston’s identity and family.

Shortly after Marlena arrives at her Mammi’s she receives word that her sister Luella has been in a car accident. Luella left the community several years ago and married Gordon Munroe, a soldier. Gordon is currently in Vietnam and his parents are on a cruise. Marlena is asked to look after Luella’s little girl, Angela Rose. Marlena is also attending Church with Mammi (Mennonite) as well as friends who are New Order Amish. Marlena is not sure on her decision to join the Old Order Amish which leads to conflict with her beau, Nat.

To find out what happens to Angela Rose, Boston, and Marlena, read The Love Letters. I give The Love Letters 4 out of 5 stars. The book is hard to get into at the beginning, but I enjoyed it once I got a quarter of a way into the story. A few times I found myself yelling at Ellie while reading the book. If she said she would check with her husband one more time (for permission), I think I would have screamed (of course, maybe I am a little bit too independent). I did enjoy the ending of this book. It is one of those endings where you close the book and sigh.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Laura.
Author 39 books654 followers
May 8, 2015
Title: THE LOVE LETTERS
Author: Beverly Lewis
Publisher: Bethany House
March 2015
ISBN 978-0764212468
Genre: Amish / Women’s fiction


Marlena needed time to let things sink in. It was beyond her how all this could possibly work out--adding the care of an infant to her daily routine. Fortunately, it would just be until Luella returned home from the hospital and was stronger.
No more than a couple weeks, surely.

Marlena Wenger's life takes an unexpected turn on the day she learns she must care for her estranged sister's baby. Spending the summer in Brownstown, Pennsylvania, to assist her Mennonite grandmother, and miles from Marlena's Old Order Amish beau, she feels out of her element in nearly every respect. Yet Marlena determines to do her best and stay focused on her future, even as those hopes become drastically altered.

THE LOVE LETTERS is Ms. Lewis’ newest Amish fiction release. I am a long time fan of Ms. Lewis’ books, having read everything she’s written thus far, but this book doesn’t have the same flow or feel as her previous books. Lately, she’s been more hit and miss with me instead of instant hits, though I’m not ready to give up reading her books yet.

There are several different stories included in this book, with Little Jay (a special Amish boy) and Marlena being the main characters. Both of those characters have several different things going on they are balancing, with Little Jay befriending a “homeless” man who lost his identity, and dealing with his father who doesn’t try to understand him, and Marlena balancing caring for her grossmammi, being away from her beau, caring for her sister’s baby and so much more.

Unlike Ms. Lewis’ previous books, this one doesn’t seem to flow and is rather disjointed. I skimmed more than read as I couldn’t get pulled into the story, didn’t identify with the characters, and really didn’t care.

Amish women’s fiction fans or fans of Beverly Lewis might enjoy this book.

3 stars. Available in ebook, hardcover, audio, and paperback. 320 pages.

I received this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Kelly.
614 reviews2 followers
January 5, 2016
In the book The Love Letters by Beverly Lewis Marlena starts taking care of her infant niece while her sister falls very ill. Her beau is worried that this is going to affect his future and not one he is prepared for and breaks it off. Marlena is hurt but focuses on giving her niece Angel Rose the best care she can offer. A new bond is formed between Marlena and an older amish mother named Ellie. She slowly welcomed into Ellie’s family circle. Later Ellie’s son Jacob finds a older homeless man by a nearby mill. The homeless man seems to have lost his memory all he has are some old letters from his courting days. Could these letters help them figure out this mans identity? Could they bring healing to Marlena and Ellie as well?

I would recommend this book to teens and adults.

This was a nice easy read. There were some parts that I found dull and at times found myself scratching my head in confusion. There were two different stories going on and for me while reading books that do this the stories always end up connect on a deeper level at some point. So I found myself expecting that and it never happened in my opinon.

It wasn’t an awful book, it just wasn’t like other books I have read by Beverly Lewis. I usually love her writing but this one was just very different for me. I loved watching Jacob wanting to care for this homeless man. It’s something not many people would be willing to do. Myself included. I have had several situations come up in the last year where I could take in a 2 year old and her mother. That scared me, for our own protection we decided just to take in the 2 year old as our way of supporting the mother. Sometimes I see that a selfish decision but the most that I could do at the moment. Last night we found out a friend was going to be “homeless” starting today. He has a home he can go to but cannot stay there long. Before I knew it my husband and I had that look in our eyes and we invited him to live with us. I do not know if he will accept it and most people may think it seems weird but I feel this is how God calls us to love by sharing our home and our love with others.

I rate this book a 3 out of 4 stars.
136 reviews
April 8, 2015
The Love Letters by Beverly Lewis is a stand alone novel filled with much more than the typical love story. It had so much depth, and I took a lot away from this book. This is by far the best book I've read from Beverly Lewis. I loved that it was more than a love story. In fact, that played a very minor roll. This book is about loss, regrets, and sacrificing your desires to help someone else.

Marlena Wenger's parents asked her to go stay with her Mennonite grandmother for the summer since her grandpa just died. Going brings up lots of memories of her older sister, Luella who left the church to marry an Englishcer and of her beloved grandfather. Not long after arriving, Marlena hears some bad news. Luella was severely injured in a car wreck, and her 5 month old daughter, Angela, is being brought to Marlena. Shocked and overwhelmed, Marlena does her best to not only take care of the baby but also her grandmother. Wishing her beau was here, Marlena struggles to take everything in.
Will Luella be alright?

I loved this story! Marlena had to figure out what she believed. Should she go against the Ordnung and her beau, or should she embrace them both but not listen to the yearning of her heart to live for Jesus?

There were a couple quotes that I loved from this book, too. Here are my two favorites:

"...it's less important to seek after miracles than it is to hunger after the miracle-giver."
"Wise folk never reject the possibility of miracles."

The first one is so true! It can be busy to focus on the miracle and forget the One who did the miracle! Not be awed by the miracle itself, but awed by Jesus who performed it. It was explained and reiterated so well throughout the whole story even though there wasn't a miracle in the book. haha It was still a good reminder, though. :-)

I highly recommend this novel to anyone who loves fiction. If you aren't into Amish fiction, please try this book anyway. You won't regret it!

I was given this book free from Bethany House in exchange for an honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 250 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.