What do you think?
Rate this book
Immortal Gifts
He lied about his identity. Two hundred years later, he’s still paying the price…
Prussia, 1841. Abraham only ever wanted to play violin. Hiding his Jewish status so he can study at the prestigious Berlin Academy of Music, the eager young man is delighted to find a patron who believes in him. But he’s mortified when his new friend turns him into a vampire… and Abraham earns the fury of an ancient antisemite who vows to see him permanently dead.
Fleeing the hate-mongering fiend across the decades, the sensitive violinist at last settles in twenty-first-century New Jersey with a mortal woman. But when he discovers his relentless tormentor has tracked him down yet again, Abraham despairs he’ll never find true happiness.
With everyone he’s ever loved at risk, can he escape the rage of a ruthless bigot?
In a complex tale woven through history, Katherine Villyard delivers a fresh and insightful twist on the vampire novel. Infusing the narrative with profound themes of love, betrayal, and the nature of monsters, she crafts an unforgettable saga of surviving prejudice that will keep readers turning pages deep into the night.
Immortal Gifts is the thoughtful first book in the Immortal Vampires contemporary fantasy series. If you like well-drawn characters, dual-timeline storytelling, and pulse-pounding suspense, then you’ll adore Katherine Villyard’s compelling read.
Prussia, 1841. Abraham only ever wanted to play violin. Hiding his Jewish status so he can study at the prestigious Berlin Academy of Music, the eager young man is delighted to find a patron who believes in him. But he’s mortified when his new friend turns him into a vampire… and Abraham earns the fury of an ancient antisemite who vows to see him permanently dead.
Fleeing the hate-mongering fiend across the decades, the sensitive violinist at last settles in twenty-first-century New Jersey with a mortal woman. But when he discovers his relentless tormentor has tracked him down yet again, Abraham despairs he’ll never find true happiness.
With everyone he’s ever loved at risk, can he escape the rage of a ruthless bigot?
In a complex tale woven through history, Katherine Villyard delivers a fresh and insightful twist on the vampire novel. Infusing the narrative with profound themes of love, betrayal, and the nature of monsters, she crafts an unforgettable saga of surviving prejudice that will keep readers turning pages deep into the night.
Immortal Gifts is the thoughtful first book in the Immortal Vampires contemporary fantasy series. If you like well-drawn characters, dual-timeline storytelling, and pulse-pounding suspense, then you’ll adore Katherine Villyard’s compelling read.
412 pages, Paperback
Published February 1, 2025
30 people are currently reading
8265 people want to read
About the author
Katherine Villyard
12 books72 followersKatherine Villyard is an award-winning author of speculative fiction and the President of Broad Universe, an organization promoting women and other traditionally marginalized genders in science fiction, fantasy, and horror. She lives in Atlanta, Georgia, with her cats. When she’s not writing, she’s probably working at her day job in IT, spoiling cats, or playing The Sims. Her greatest ambition is to rule the world.
And check out the Immortal Gifts Podcast!
And check out the Immortal Gifts Podcast!
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 129 reviews
June 2, 2025
I received this this Title in a Goodreads Giveaway for my honest opinion. I give this review voluntarily.
This vampire book was like nothing I read before. Forget what you know about vampires. This book contains a story plot about Abraham who is a Vampire, a Violinist, and a Jew. When Abraham is changed against his will, it tells his story over the next 200 years. It's also about a bigot vampire who continues to chase Abraham over that 200 year span. A bigot who followed orders under Hitler!
This book tells a story about betrayal, love and sacrifice to protect the ones you love. The book itself is well written. The book at times moved on with a good pace, other times it crawled like a snail. The book is good enough that you overlook the slow parts. It's a page turner so you can see what happens next.
This vampire book was like nothing I read before. Forget what you know about vampires. This book contains a story plot about Abraham who is a Vampire, a Violinist, and a Jew. When Abraham is changed against his will, it tells his story over the next 200 years. It's also about a bigot vampire who continues to chase Abraham over that 200 year span. A bigot who followed orders under Hitler!
This book tells a story about betrayal, love and sacrifice to protect the ones you love. The book itself is well written. The book at times moved on with a good pace, other times it crawled like a snail. The book is good enough that you overlook the slow parts. It's a page turner so you can see what happens next.
March 7, 2026
How surprisingly sweet this was. And queer. A compliment, of course. Absolutely delightful. From the blurb you could almost think this is a straight vampire book. Which already sounds like an oxymoron. Yeah, the main couple is straight presenting, but everything is infused in queerness. Destiny, the MC’s wife, has two mothers and has had partners who were women. And Abraham, the main character, is bisexual as well. Like every other vampire ever. And Ludwig is supposed to be gay, I’m pretty sure. And Thomas is a horrible person so he doesn’t matter.
Abraham is telling his life story, in typical vampire fashion, with the timeline going back and forth and we get POVs of him and the other characters. Abraham is your regular vampire, honestly. Nails don’t break off, your hair stays the same as when you were alive, he can’t go out in the sun. There is something he can do that any other vampire I’ve read about can’t, which is to have children. At a point he was watching the movie version of Interview with the Vampire AND What We Do in the Shadows. That’s hysterical in and of itself. He’s a cat person which is endearing, but it is sad to read about him losing his pets one after the other throughout his long life, especially the one we lose with him, Victoria. Speaking of cats, one other thing I never read about before was an animal being turned into a vampire pet. It reads half silly half terrifying.
Destiny and Abraham were so sweet together, not really anything exceptional but cute. Something I found funny was how every now and then he would tell his wife if she wanted to be turned, and she just would answer, “Nah, still vegetarian.” Honestly Abraham should just stop turning people period. And animals for that matter.
Side note, Ludwig was an interesting character to follow. He was definitely in love with Abraham in his own way. I feel like Abraham knows, especially after that one scene at the end, and Destiny likewise knows. He’s so fascinated with Abraham’s gift with the violin, too. He spent his life kind of protecting him. He did react negatively to Abraham being Jewish (to say the least), but amends were made, and they’re best friends now. If this were a different book, Ludwig and Abraham would’ve been the couple, but you didn’t hear this from me. There has to be a reason as to why everybody kept asking if he’s sure they’d never been an item. It’s the way he talks about him. “Did a life without him have meaning?” But I digress.
The writing is simple and not at all hard to follow. There are social issues discussed, and representation of Jewish customs and culture, something I’ve never read about in a vampire book. There’s a Jewish wedding right at the beginning between Destiny and Abraham, and that’s just the beginning of it. There are scenes set during the years WW2 took place, Abraham is Jewish, I’ll let you draw your conclusions.
I couldn’t be more surprised with how much I enjoyed this book, it’s a new favorite of mine. And the ending threw me completely off, it was crazy! It’s a 5/5⭐️ for me.
Audiobook notes: I liked the narrator for Abraham, a little less the one for Ludwig though I don’t really know why. And I didn’t quite form an opinion on the female narrator simply because she was part of it for only so long.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing an ALC in exchange for an honest review.
Abraham is telling his life story, in typical vampire fashion, with the timeline going back and forth and we get POVs of him and the other characters. Abraham is your regular vampire, honestly. Nails don’t break off, your hair stays the same as when you were alive, he can’t go out in the sun. There is something he can do that any other vampire I’ve read about can’t, which is to have children. At a point he was watching the movie version of Interview with the Vampire AND What We Do in the Shadows. That’s hysterical in and of itself. He’s a cat person which is endearing, but it is sad to read about him losing his pets one after the other throughout his long life, especially the one we lose with him, Victoria. Speaking of cats, one other thing I never read about before was an animal being turned into a vampire pet. It reads half silly half terrifying.
Destiny and Abraham were so sweet together, not really anything exceptional but cute. Something I found funny was how every now and then he would tell his wife if she wanted to be turned, and she just would answer, “Nah, still vegetarian.” Honestly Abraham should just stop turning people period. And animals for that matter.
Side note, Ludwig was an interesting character to follow. He was definitely in love with Abraham in his own way. I feel like Abraham knows, especially after that one scene at the end, and Destiny likewise knows. He’s so fascinated with Abraham’s gift with the violin, too. He spent his life kind of protecting him. He did react negatively to Abraham being Jewish (to say the least), but amends were made, and they’re best friends now. If this were a different book, Ludwig and Abraham would’ve been the couple, but you didn’t hear this from me. There has to be a reason as to why everybody kept asking if he’s sure they’d never been an item. It’s the way he talks about him. “Did a life without him have meaning?” But I digress.
The writing is simple and not at all hard to follow. There are social issues discussed, and representation of Jewish customs and culture, something I’ve never read about in a vampire book. There’s a Jewish wedding right at the beginning between Destiny and Abraham, and that’s just the beginning of it. There are scenes set during the years WW2 took place, Abraham is Jewish, I’ll let you draw your conclusions.
I couldn’t be more surprised with how much I enjoyed this book, it’s a new favorite of mine. And the ending threw me completely off, it was crazy! It’s a 5/5⭐️ for me.
Audiobook notes: I liked the narrator for Abraham, a little less the one for Ludwig though I don’t really know why. And I didn’t quite form an opinion on the female narrator simply because she was part of it for only so long.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing an ALC in exchange for an honest review.
February 25, 2026
This was an interesting vampire story. Abraham was a likeable character. Some parts dragged a little but as things were wrapping up in the novel, it became more intense and I became a lot more invested. I liked how it covered many eras as well. If you like historical fiction with a twist, I think you will like it. You learn about Jewish culture as well which was an added bonus.
I want to thank NetGalley, Flower Feather Press and IBPA for a free copy of the audiobook. The narrators did a good job. My review is voluntary.
I want to thank NetGalley, Flower Feather Press and IBPA for a free copy of the audiobook. The narrators did a good job. My review is voluntary.
December 20, 2024
Thank you to BookSirens and author, Katherine Villyard, for this ARC. I do not typically read vampire or fantasy books but I LOVED this book! The main character, Abraham, is a talented violinist, vampire, and Jew. From this book I learned a lot about Jewish traditions, something I did not expect from a vampire book! The story is told from the point of view of several different characters. Personal relationships and love are highlighted throughout the story. This book far exceeded my expectations and was a joy to read! I received this advanced readers copy for free and am voluntarily leaving this review.
February 28, 2026
This books concept was interesting, but the pacing was not for me. Beware when picking this book up. There is animal death and animal cruelty triggers.
April 25, 2026
I adored this story, which I both listened to and read, about sensitive and music-loving vampire Abraham Levy, born in 1841 Prussia. Voice actors Dave Robison, Veronica Giguere, and J. Daniel Sawyer bring the characters to life. I loved their takes on Abraham and Destiny, bringing Abraham's kindness and grief and Destiny's strength and humour beautifully to life.
Desperate to study at the Berlin Academy of Music, he hides that he is Jewish, and secures a patron, Ludwig. He's is much less happy when this patron, entranced by Abraham's virtuosity, turns him into a vampire. And when another vampire, a raging antisemite named Thomas learns of this, Thomas is convinced that Abraham must be killed permanently.
This sets Abraham running, changing towns and countries, periodically, all to stay ahead of Thomas, who is happy to kill jews whenever he can, and who remains incensed that Ludwig made a Jew into a vampire, a gift he is convinced no Jew should ever receive.
Abraham, with help from Ludwig, manages to always stay ahead of Thomas, and eventually, after many years in New York City, with some years spent raising the children of a descendant, whom he helped escape Nazi Germany, he relocates to New Jersey.
Abraham eventually meets and marries a cheerful and loving veterinarian named Destiny, who is fully aware of his undead status, and is happy to remain human no matter how many times Abraham begs her to let him turn her. She says no, but that doesn't stop Abraham from turning a cat of theirs (and accidentally a dog) when he cannot bare to say goodbye to the near death cat.
Of course Thomas eventually finds him, and bad things happen.
But this novel, which felt cozy despite the terrible things that happen throughout it, also has a slightly different take on the vampire myth. Author Katherine Villyard deals with bigotry, trust, consent, loneliness, and religious prohibitions through the lens of a Jewish vampire who must stay ahead of violent reprisals just for being Jewish.
Then, there's the way Villyard shows how Abraham's inability to deal with grief causes him to make several mistakes, and to persistently not ask for consent, until he finally understands what it means for others when he makes unilateral decisions for them.
I really enjoyed the prose and the audio, and would love to find out what happens next with Abraham and Destiny, and their circle of family, friends and pets.
Thank you to Netgalley and to Flower Feather Press for these ARCs in exchange for my review.
Desperate to study at the Berlin Academy of Music, he hides that he is Jewish, and secures a patron, Ludwig. He's is much less happy when this patron, entranced by Abraham's virtuosity, turns him into a vampire. And when another vampire, a raging antisemite named Thomas learns of this, Thomas is convinced that Abraham must be killed permanently.
This sets Abraham running, changing towns and countries, periodically, all to stay ahead of Thomas, who is happy to kill jews whenever he can, and who remains incensed that Ludwig made a Jew into a vampire, a gift he is convinced no Jew should ever receive.
Abraham, with help from Ludwig, manages to always stay ahead of Thomas, and eventually, after many years in New York City, with some years spent raising the children of a descendant, whom he helped escape Nazi Germany, he relocates to New Jersey.
Abraham eventually meets and marries a cheerful and loving veterinarian named Destiny, who is fully aware of his undead status, and is happy to remain human no matter how many times Abraham begs her to let him turn her. She says no, but that doesn't stop Abraham from turning a cat of theirs (and accidentally a dog) when he cannot bare to say goodbye to the near death cat.
Of course Thomas eventually finds him, and bad things happen.
But this novel, which felt cozy despite the terrible things that happen throughout it, also has a slightly different take on the vampire myth. Author Katherine Villyard deals with bigotry, trust, consent, loneliness, and religious prohibitions through the lens of a Jewish vampire who must stay ahead of violent reprisals just for being Jewish.
Then, there's the way Villyard shows how Abraham's inability to deal with grief causes him to make several mistakes, and to persistently not ask for consent, until he finally understands what it means for others when he makes unilateral decisions for them.
I really enjoyed the prose and the audio, and would love to find out what happens next with Abraham and Destiny, and their circle of family, friends and pets.
Thank you to Netgalley and to Flower Feather Press for these ARCs in exchange for my review.
January 2, 2025
Disclaimer: I received this ARC for free from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. Check the author’s website for a list of content warnings.
I really enjoyed this story. The concept of a man who is both Jewish and a vampire making both work together despite his beliefs and needs conflicting was interesting to read, and very informative of traditions and rituals I had only ever heard of. The story also focuses a lot on death and grief, and how we cope with death, making this an emotional ride.
I enjoyed the three POV characters and I hope we get to learn more about them in future books. I will say though, that with three POVs, the writing sometimes was a little repetitive, especially when they talk about the same event.
The pacing had a few issues at times, but for the most part this book was engaging and quick to read.
I really enjoyed this story. The concept of a man who is both Jewish and a vampire making both work together despite his beliefs and needs conflicting was interesting to read, and very informative of traditions and rituals I had only ever heard of. The story also focuses a lot on death and grief, and how we cope with death, making this an emotional ride.
I enjoyed the three POV characters and I hope we get to learn more about them in future books. I will say though, that with three POVs, the writing sometimes was a little repetitive, especially when they talk about the same event.
The pacing had a few issues at times, but for the most part this book was engaging and quick to read.
December 17, 2024
Huge thanks to Katherine Villyard for this gifted ARC
📚 ARC Review 📚
Abraham has a gift for music.
Born in the 1800s, he lied about being Jewish to attend the Berlin Academy of Music and secure a patron. But, it also gets him turned into a vampire. When his lie is found out, it puts him in the crosshairs of zealous bigot. His tale spans centuries of him trying to be true to himself, his religion, and coming to terms with death.
At the heart of all of this, the story is one about death and grief. And while these are not unusual themes to be found in a story with vampires in it, I thought it was handled beautifully. Each character handled their grief and pain differently and each had their own thoughts on what it meant to be immortal.
That being said, at times I felt that there was a lot of information that was thrown at me that could have been cut out or at least summarized. There were moments where I felt like I was reading a diary rather than a story.
Because of this, I feel that the story is part fictional memoir and part historical fiction than any other genre.
The story was interesting and I liked the use of different timelines and different POVs to create a whole story. I also liked the blend of different religions. I would have liked to read more about Abraham’s time at the Academy, of his struggles and triumphs there. There were parts that dragged, but the pacing really picked up towards the end. I would also have liked to learn more about what happened to a few other characters, but since this is the first in a series, perhaps they will get their chance in later stories.
📚 ARC Review 📚
Abraham has a gift for music.
Born in the 1800s, he lied about being Jewish to attend the Berlin Academy of Music and secure a patron. But, it also gets him turned into a vampire. When his lie is found out, it puts him in the crosshairs of zealous bigot. His tale spans centuries of him trying to be true to himself, his religion, and coming to terms with death.
At the heart of all of this, the story is one about death and grief. And while these are not unusual themes to be found in a story with vampires in it, I thought it was handled beautifully. Each character handled their grief and pain differently and each had their own thoughts on what it meant to be immortal.
That being said, at times I felt that there was a lot of information that was thrown at me that could have been cut out or at least summarized. There were moments where I felt like I was reading a diary rather than a story.
Because of this, I feel that the story is part fictional memoir and part historical fiction than any other genre.
The story was interesting and I liked the use of different timelines and different POVs to create a whole story. I also liked the blend of different religions. I would have liked to read more about Abraham’s time at the Academy, of his struggles and triumphs there. There were parts that dragged, but the pacing really picked up towards the end. I would also have liked to learn more about what happened to a few other characters, but since this is the first in a series, perhaps they will get their chance in later stories.
March 10, 2026
Thank you NetGalley for the audiobook ARC!
I think this book was a nice read however it was not for me. I enjoyed all the information about Jewish religion/culture, in that regard the book was splendid. I also enjoyed the different voices of the narrators. For me, it fell flat in the juvenile feeling main characters. Abraham is supposed to be 200 or so years old and spent numerous chapters lamenting about a lost pet. His actions continue to reflect a level of childishness that not even his arrest age could explain. The internal monologue of our narrators and the shift chapters often lead to the same events being shared with no new information coming to light so it just became repetitive. Lastly, it’s not until the last 1/4 of the book that anything truly substantial happens. I wish I liked it more.
I think this book was a nice read however it was not for me. I enjoyed all the information about Jewish religion/culture, in that regard the book was splendid. I also enjoyed the different voices of the narrators. For me, it fell flat in the juvenile feeling main characters. Abraham is supposed to be 200 or so years old and spent numerous chapters lamenting about a lost pet. His actions continue to reflect a level of childishness that not even his arrest age could explain. The internal monologue of our narrators and the shift chapters often lead to the same events being shared with no new information coming to light so it just became repetitive. Lastly, it’s not until the last 1/4 of the book that anything truly substantial happens. I wish I liked it more.
November 24, 2024
Published on Goodreads 11/24/2024
Rating: 🤗/4
Review: This was such a unique book and genre mash up. Part romance, part horror, part historical fiction, part mystery. A literary vampire story with multiple times lines and POVs that tackle romance, grief, sadness/depression, love, acceptance, religion and even vampire pets. Pacing was a little off but the parts that dragged didn’t last long. This book made me chuckle out loud a few times but is also so much about grief and losing those you love deeply. Such an interesting way of looking at relationships when people are in different religions and how love and respect within those relationships can make it work. Probably one of the weirdest books I’ve read this year but also one I’ll think about for a while.
Format: 👩🏻💻
Source: #netgalley
Rating: 🤗/4
Review: This was such a unique book and genre mash up. Part romance, part horror, part historical fiction, part mystery. A literary vampire story with multiple times lines and POVs that tackle romance, grief, sadness/depression, love, acceptance, religion and even vampire pets. Pacing was a little off but the parts that dragged didn’t last long. This book made me chuckle out loud a few times but is also so much about grief and losing those you love deeply. Such an interesting way of looking at relationships when people are in different religions and how love and respect within those relationships can make it work. Probably one of the weirdest books I’ve read this year but also one I’ll think about for a while.
Format: 👩🏻💻
Source: #netgalley
April 24, 2026
I got a free copy from NetGalley in return for an honest review.
I found this book to be a very fun vampire slice of life novel.. It takes place over multiple centuries which some may not like but I felt they were well connected and easy to understand, every time perspective changes you get told the date. This novel is mainly character driven but I found that the main character Abraham was very likable and it left me wanting to know more about him and his life.
I deeply enjoyed all the character dynamics and how vampirism affected the relationships, my favorite was between Ludwig and Abraham.
I found this book to be a very fun vampire slice of life novel.. It takes place over multiple centuries which some may not like but I felt they were well connected and easy to understand, every time perspective changes you get told the date. This novel is mainly character driven but I found that the main character Abraham was very likable and it left me wanting to know more about him and his life.
I deeply enjoyed all the character dynamics and how vampirism affected the relationships, my favorite was between Ludwig and Abraham.
November 24, 2024
I didn't think Abraham was lucky to have immortality. It seemed more a painful and cruel curse. He outlived all those he loved- wives, children, and pets. At first I liked Destiny, but when she chose to leave Abraham it infuriated me. Selfish! If not for her, Abraham wouldn't have to suffer what Thomas had planned for him! I couldn't find redemption in my heart for Destiny because of her selfish actions. I voluntarily read a free copy of this book provided by book sirens and am giving an honest opinion.
November 21, 2024
Omg this is the best book ever epic , you get three main characters telling you what was happening from their point of view, I shed a few tears along the the way and laughed too this has a cast of great animals that could have a book of their own , I couldn’t recommend this book more highly it will stay with you forever I think 5 stars is a paltry amount but that’s all I can give it but a bright shiny 5 stars it’s got from me
February 25, 2026
I have to say that I was all over the place with this one!
I loved it. I hated it. I was going to stop! I couldn't put it down! Yes... to all of the above...
Abraham was a cherished, phenomenal violinist of the uppermost echelon back in the 1800's. When he studied at the acclaimed School of Music in Berlin... When his life was suddenly and irrevocably turned around... and he became a vampire... through no fault of his own...
And, he acquired an enemy who promised to track him down and kill him... once and for all.
Since then he's been on the move... for centuries.
But, whenever he lays down roots, he is afraid. He knows what this vampire can do... to other vampires... and what he can also do to mere mortals... like those Abraham has loved, will love... and has lost.
So when he once again, finds himself in a relationship with a wonderful woman in the 21st century, in New Jersey... well, he also fears being found... again. And... what might happen to all of them.
Needless to say... his worst fears do come true...
This one has just been released (2/24/26) so look for it on shelves now!!
4 1/2 stars for me, rounded up to 5!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫
#ImmortalGifts by @KatherineVillyard and narrated beautifully by @DaveRobison, @VeronicaGiguere and @JDanielSawyer.
Of Note: This is book #1 in the series!
Thanks so much to #NetGalley, @FlowerFeatherPress, @IndependentBookPublishersAssociation (IBPA) and @MembersAudiobooks for an ALC of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review!!
You can also find my reviews on: Goodreads,
Instagram: @BookReviews_with_emsr and/or
My Facebook Book Club: Book Reviews With Elaine
Thanks so much for reading! And if you ‘liked’ my review, please share with your friends, & click ‘LIKE’ below… And, let me know YOUR thoughts if you read it!! 📚⭐️
I loved it. I hated it. I was going to stop! I couldn't put it down! Yes... to all of the above...
Abraham was a cherished, phenomenal violinist of the uppermost echelon back in the 1800's. When he studied at the acclaimed School of Music in Berlin... When his life was suddenly and irrevocably turned around... and he became a vampire... through no fault of his own...
And, he acquired an enemy who promised to track him down and kill him... once and for all.
Since then he's been on the move... for centuries.
But, whenever he lays down roots, he is afraid. He knows what this vampire can do... to other vampires... and what he can also do to mere mortals... like those Abraham has loved, will love... and has lost.
So when he once again, finds himself in a relationship with a wonderful woman in the 21st century, in New Jersey... well, he also fears being found... again. And... what might happen to all of them.
Needless to say... his worst fears do come true...
This one has just been released (2/24/26) so look for it on shelves now!!
4 1/2 stars for me, rounded up to 5!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫
#ImmortalGifts by @KatherineVillyard and narrated beautifully by @DaveRobison, @VeronicaGiguere and @JDanielSawyer.
Of Note: This is book #1 in the series!
Thanks so much to #NetGalley, @FlowerFeatherPress, @IndependentBookPublishersAssociation (IBPA) and @MembersAudiobooks for an ALC of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review!!
You can also find my reviews on: Goodreads,
Instagram: @BookReviews_with_emsr and/or
My Facebook Book Club: Book Reviews With Elaine
Thanks so much for reading! And if you ‘liked’ my review, please share with your friends, & click ‘LIKE’ below… And, let me know YOUR thoughts if you read it!! 📚⭐️
February 28, 2025
I love vampire books (as seen by past reviews), and this one had its own spin on the trop, but instead of turning me away, I LOVED IT!!
The whole concept is a Jewish man who is a vampire and trying to hide that from the rest of the world. He's also a superbly talented violinist, but he hasn't been able to play for fear of other vampires taking notice of him (specifically one) and hunting him down.
I loved the way the story weaved Jewish culture into his vampirishness. There was so much information, but it was placed right where my interest would be piqued, and just enough was left out that I kept reading to find out more.
I loved Destiny and Abraham's relationship. The way they interact with each other, and with their pets!, is so adorable.
I will admit that at first I was confused about Ludwig's POV; I didn't realize he was separate from Abraham, but when I looked back, I realized what was going on.
This book was super fun and sweet. Definitely will read things by this author in the future!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The whole concept is a Jewish man who is a vampire and trying to hide that from the rest of the world. He's also a superbly talented violinist, but he hasn't been able to play for fear of other vampires taking notice of him (specifically one) and hunting him down.
I loved the way the story weaved Jewish culture into his vampirishness. There was so much information, but it was placed right where my interest would be piqued, and just enough was left out that I kept reading to find out more.
I loved Destiny and Abraham's relationship. The way they interact with each other, and with their pets!, is so adorable.
I will admit that at first I was confused about Ludwig's POV; I didn't realize he was separate from Abraham, but when I looked back, I realized what was going on.
This book was super fun and sweet. Definitely will read things by this author in the future!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
May 2, 2026
Immortal Gifts is such a unique take on vampire lore. I loved how Abraham’s story weaves through history, blending music, identity, and immortality in a way that feels both emotional and fresh. The dual timeline kept things interesting, and the themes of love, prejudice, and survival added real depth to the story. Katherine Villyard did a great job making the characters feel human—even when they’re not.
The audiobook narration (with Dave Robison, Veronica Giguerre, and J. Daniel Sawyer) brought the story to life, especially in the emotional moments, though some voices took a little getting used to.
Overall, it’s a thoughtful, character-driven vampire story with a lot of heart and just enough suspense to keep you hooked.
The audiobook narration (with Dave Robison, Veronica Giguerre, and J. Daniel Sawyer) brought the story to life, especially in the emotional moments, though some voices took a little getting used to.
Overall, it’s a thoughtful, character-driven vampire story with a lot of heart and just enough suspense to keep you hooked.
April 23, 2026
The gift of immortality to a non-Christian? Absolutely formidable!
The story has a great plotline, with vampire hide-and-chase stretching from the 1840s into contemporary timelines. The emotions really hook you in, and the pain of having to start over again and again is something I could deeply correlate with.
It was great to read a vampire story after such a long time, especially one that takes on modern concepts like consent, while also adding those special heart-to-heart connections with pets, which lead to another layer of bloody creations.
There are some repetitions around Chapter 6, which made certain parts feel slightly stretched. It is also a little difficult to tell when the narrative shifts from one vampire to another, despite the audiobook having multiple narrators. Because of that, I feel this story might be better suited to reading rather than listening.
The story has a great plotline, with vampire hide-and-chase stretching from the 1840s into contemporary timelines. The emotions really hook you in, and the pain of having to start over again and again is something I could deeply correlate with.
It was great to read a vampire story after such a long time, especially one that takes on modern concepts like consent, while also adding those special heart-to-heart connections with pets, which lead to another layer of bloody creations.
There are some repetitions around Chapter 6, which made certain parts feel slightly stretched. It is also a little difficult to tell when the narrative shifts from one vampire to another, despite the audiobook having multiple narrators. Because of that, I feel this story might be better suited to reading rather than listening.
February 19, 2026
This story follows Abraham a vampire who loves playing the violin and cats! Sounds joyful right?
But dont be fooled this is a powerful story of love, religion, destiny and grief.
Abraham is a jew and he struggles to come to terms with being a vampire. He also lives in Germany and his experiences as a jew are devastating. His maker Ludwig is a delightful character!
Overall this is a vampire story, but a like non you will have read before!
4⭐️
But dont be fooled this is a powerful story of love, religion, destiny and grief.
Abraham is a jew and he struggles to come to terms with being a vampire. He also lives in Germany and his experiences as a jew are devastating. His maker Ludwig is a delightful character!
Overall this is a vampire story, but a like non you will have read before!
4⭐️
February 20, 2026
a vampire book different to what you've ever heard. a nice breath of fresh air
January 30, 2025
I received this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
This was a very readable book. I enjoyed spending time with the characters, and learning about their backgrounds. Recommended.
This was a very readable book. I enjoyed spending time with the characters, and learning about their backgrounds. Recommended.
Read
March 3, 2025Oops. :D I was trying to update my progress...
Edited: I have a link to content warnings here, if that’s your thing: https://www.katherinevillyard.com/202...
So, this book. It’s kind of what would happen if you took Interview with the Vampire and crossed it with When the Angels Left the Old Country, perhaps with a dash of The Time Traveler's Wife. Other people mentioned A Discovery of Witches, for the female witch/wiccan character with two moms who is married to a vampire.
Instead of poor depressed Louis, I have an undercover Jewish violinist with a wry sense of humor. His patron, a Bavarian noble second son originally destined for the church, embodies “Immortality is awesome!” Who wants to live forever? The patron, that’s who! The violinist’s mortal wife, that’s who doesn’t!
Death and grief aren’t unusual topics for a vampire book, but if you’ve lost someone it feels like you’re a member of a super sucky club, doing your secret handshakes with your fellow sufferers. It’s a thing I felt keenly while writing. Both of my parents are dead, and my pandemic experience was being alone and isolated with cats… two of whom died suddenly during the pandemic. One of my critique partners died during the writing of this book, too. The opposite of death is immortality, but that won’t save you from the heartache of others’ mortality. The mortal wife being a veterinarian… ties in, thematically.
Don’t be afraid of the vampires. Vampires are our friends! What’s really scary is hate, isolation, and the pain of grief.
Spice level: unsalted mashed potatoes/closed door/fade to black.
Edited: I have a link to content warnings here, if that’s your thing: https://www.katherinevillyard.com/202...
So, this book. It’s kind of what would happen if you took Interview with the Vampire and crossed it with When the Angels Left the Old Country, perhaps with a dash of The Time Traveler's Wife. Other people mentioned A Discovery of Witches, for the female witch/wiccan character with two moms who is married to a vampire.
Instead of poor depressed Louis, I have an undercover Jewish violinist with a wry sense of humor. His patron, a Bavarian noble second son originally destined for the church, embodies “Immortality is awesome!” Who wants to live forever? The patron, that’s who! The violinist’s mortal wife, that’s who doesn’t!
Death and grief aren’t unusual topics for a vampire book, but if you’ve lost someone it feels like you’re a member of a super sucky club, doing your secret handshakes with your fellow sufferers. It’s a thing I felt keenly while writing. Both of my parents are dead, and my pandemic experience was being alone and isolated with cats… two of whom died suddenly during the pandemic. One of my critique partners died during the writing of this book, too. The opposite of death is immortality, but that won’t save you from the heartache of others’ mortality. The mortal wife being a veterinarian… ties in, thematically.
Don’t be afraid of the vampires. Vampires are our friends! What’s really scary is hate, isolation, and the pain of grief.
Spice level: unsalted mashed potatoes/closed door/fade to black.
December 14, 2024
Who doesn’t enjoy a good time travel vampire story. This was a lot of fun to read. The periods of time that it takes place in keeps it interesting. The characters are at times complicated. Good backstory which is nice to have.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
December 3, 2024
I must admit, at first, each short chapter starting at a different date and in the words of a different character was a little jarring. However I’m glad I persevered because I loved this book and know that you will as well. In fact, I am about to start the next novel in this series!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this honest review voluntarily
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this honest review voluntarily
July 28, 2025
I really wish the author had done this in third person instead of first person.
The tale itself is original, well-researched, and beautifully complex. There is a glimpse into history, and the emotions are conveyed well. The time jumps don't bother me.
But the first third of the book really read like a love affair between a vampire and his cats. It wasn't believable and it got rather absurd.
The switching between narrators did not result in any change of tone and sometimes only served to echo what was happening earlier. These parts made it a slow read.
For a debut book, I do think this was good, and vampire lovers will find a good tale. The author clearly has a lot of potential and needs time to figure out how to round out the story. For those looking for a quick read, this book might not serve them.
The tale itself is original, well-researched, and beautifully complex. There is a glimpse into history, and the emotions are conveyed well. The time jumps don't bother me.
But the first third of the book really read like a love affair between a vampire and his cats. It wasn't believable and it got rather absurd.
The switching between narrators did not result in any change of tone and sometimes only served to echo what was happening earlier. These parts made it a slow read.
For a debut book, I do think this was good, and vampire lovers will find a good tale. The author clearly has a lot of potential and needs time to figure out how to round out the story. For those looking for a quick read, this book might not serve them.
April 9, 2025
I am a sucker for a vampire story. This one was good but was a slow burn to the finale.
I love also pov's from different time periods which this one had. Not gory or scary, just a good story. Almost like a soap opera. Good guys, bad buys, innocents. The makings of a great arc for characters. Kept my interest but it did just that. It didn't make me want to hurry back when I had to close the book.
I love also pov's from different time periods which this one had. Not gory or scary, just a good story. Almost like a soap opera. Good guys, bad buys, innocents. The makings of a great arc for characters. Kept my interest but it did just that. It didn't make me want to hurry back when I had to close the book.
March 8, 2026
Set against the backdrop of nineteenth-century Prussia and spanning into present-day New Jersey, Immortal Gifts follows Abraham, a gifted violinist whose desire to study at the prestigious Berlin Academy of Music leads him to conceal his Jewish identity. When an unexpected act transforms him into a vampire, Abraham becomes the target of an ancient antisemite determined to see him destroyed. Across centuries, he grapples with faith, prejudice, love, and the burden of immortality in a world that refuses to forget hatred.
**What This Book Does Well**
Katerine Villyard demonstrates clear mastery of vampire lore and historical research. The nineteenth-century sections feel grounded as fully realized environments that shape Abraham's internal and external conflicts. The story smoothly transitions through the centuries without losing cohesion. Additionally, I loved the musical references woven throughout the story!
Most notably, the novel offers something genuinely new within vampire fiction. Abraham's Jewish identity is not an aesthetic detail - it is central to his psychological and moral framework. The integration of vampirism and Jewish customs, theology, and personal faith feels organic and deeply considered. Rather than relying on familiar tropes, the novel interrogates what it means to be "monstrous" in a world already shaped by bigotry.
The antagonist is compelling and persistent, embodying hatred that stretches across generations. The thematic exploration of prejudice and survival adds emotional gravity beyond standard supernatural conflict.
**Where It Fell Short For Me**
Personally, the multi-POV structure did not feel necessary. Abraham's perspective is so strong that the additional viewpoints occasionally diluted rather than deepened the narrative. In my opinion, much of what is conveyed in secondary perspectives could plausibly have been understood through Abraham's lens without losing essential context.
The romantic arc between Abraham and Destiny also feels more secondary than central. While their relationship supports key themes - particularly the tension between mortal and immortal life - their conversations sometimes read as though they are navigating issues that should have been addressed earlier in their relationship. As a result, I did not feel as emotionally invested in their relationship.
The novel's most overtly suspenseful moments arrive toward the end, and while effective, they felt slightly rushed compared to the pacing earlier in the book.
**Craft & Writing Quality**
From a craft perspective, Villyard shines with psychological nuance and thematic ambition. Abraham's internal evolution across centuries is convincing and meaningful. His struggle with his self-perception as a Jewish vampire adds a philosophical dimension to the story that elevates it beyond genre expectations.
The prose supports the contemplative tone of the narrative. There are a few points in the novel that I felt were a bit repetitive, but considering the century-spanning scope, it could be understood as reflective of how memory and identity resurface across time.
For me, this is a character-driven vampire novel first, and a suspense-driven fantasy second. Reading expecting relentless action may find the pacing measured, but those drawn to moral and psychological exploration will find much to enjoy!
**Narration & Audio Quality**
The performance of Abraham is exceptional! The narration enhances the emotional resonance of his arc and brings warmth, vulnerability, and depth to his centuries-long journey.
However, there was a noticeable inconsistency in audio production quality between the narrators. Certain sections have lower audio clarity, occasional static, and moments of dead air that interrupted immersion for me. Additionally, while multiple narrators align logically with the multi-POV structure, the tonal disparity between performances created enough of an imbalance that I questioned if the multi-POV structure was necessary at all.
Listeners should be aware that the storytelling itself remains strong, but the technical execution and narration performance are uneven.
**Who I Would Recommend This To**
I would recommend Immortal Gifts to readers who enjoy historically grounded, well researched vampire fiction, character-driven fantasy, and stories that thoughtfully explore faith, identity, and generational prejudice. If you enjoy psychological depth with some action, this will likely be a compelling read for you!
**Final Thoughts & Opinions**
Overall, I genuinely enjoyed *Immortal Gifts*. Abraham is a compelling protagonist, and the novel's exploration of faith, identity, and prejudice distinguishes it within vampire fiction. While I am not entirely certain where the series will head next, I would be open to continuing depending on future installments, and I would certainly be interested in reading more from this author. The lore is thoughtful. The themes are intentional. And the psychological dimension lingers.
Since this is an audiobook and the experience is notably shaped by its narrators and audio quality, I did lower my overall rating for this book strictly due to those issues (see scoring breakdown below).
My thanks to Netgalley, Flower Feather Press, and Katherine Villyard for complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
**Scoring Breakdown**
Personal Enjoyment: 4/5
Execution (Did the book do what it set out to do?): 4.5/5
Writing & Craft Quality: 4.25/5
Narration performance & Audio Quality: 3/5
Characters: 3.75/5
Plot: 4/5
**What This Book Does Well**
Katerine Villyard demonstrates clear mastery of vampire lore and historical research. The nineteenth-century sections feel grounded as fully realized environments that shape Abraham's internal and external conflicts. The story smoothly transitions through the centuries without losing cohesion. Additionally, I loved the musical references woven throughout the story!
Most notably, the novel offers something genuinely new within vampire fiction. Abraham's Jewish identity is not an aesthetic detail - it is central to his psychological and moral framework. The integration of vampirism and Jewish customs, theology, and personal faith feels organic and deeply considered. Rather than relying on familiar tropes, the novel interrogates what it means to be "monstrous" in a world already shaped by bigotry.
The antagonist is compelling and persistent, embodying hatred that stretches across generations. The thematic exploration of prejudice and survival adds emotional gravity beyond standard supernatural conflict.
**Where It Fell Short For Me**
Personally, the multi-POV structure did not feel necessary. Abraham's perspective is so strong that the additional viewpoints occasionally diluted rather than deepened the narrative. In my opinion, much of what is conveyed in secondary perspectives could plausibly have been understood through Abraham's lens without losing essential context.
The romantic arc between Abraham and Destiny also feels more secondary than central. While their relationship supports key themes - particularly the tension between mortal and immortal life - their conversations sometimes read as though they are navigating issues that should have been addressed earlier in their relationship. As a result, I did not feel as emotionally invested in their relationship.
The novel's most overtly suspenseful moments arrive toward the end, and while effective, they felt slightly rushed compared to the pacing earlier in the book.
**Craft & Writing Quality**
From a craft perspective, Villyard shines with psychological nuance and thematic ambition. Abraham's internal evolution across centuries is convincing and meaningful. His struggle with his self-perception as a Jewish vampire adds a philosophical dimension to the story that elevates it beyond genre expectations.
The prose supports the contemplative tone of the narrative. There are a few points in the novel that I felt were a bit repetitive, but considering the century-spanning scope, it could be understood as reflective of how memory and identity resurface across time.
For me, this is a character-driven vampire novel first, and a suspense-driven fantasy second. Reading expecting relentless action may find the pacing measured, but those drawn to moral and psychological exploration will find much to enjoy!
**Narration & Audio Quality**
The performance of Abraham is exceptional! The narration enhances the emotional resonance of his arc and brings warmth, vulnerability, and depth to his centuries-long journey.
However, there was a noticeable inconsistency in audio production quality between the narrators. Certain sections have lower audio clarity, occasional static, and moments of dead air that interrupted immersion for me. Additionally, while multiple narrators align logically with the multi-POV structure, the tonal disparity between performances created enough of an imbalance that I questioned if the multi-POV structure was necessary at all.
Listeners should be aware that the storytelling itself remains strong, but the technical execution and narration performance are uneven.
**Who I Would Recommend This To**
I would recommend Immortal Gifts to readers who enjoy historically grounded, well researched vampire fiction, character-driven fantasy, and stories that thoughtfully explore faith, identity, and generational prejudice. If you enjoy psychological depth with some action, this will likely be a compelling read for you!
**Final Thoughts & Opinions**
Overall, I genuinely enjoyed *Immortal Gifts*. Abraham is a compelling protagonist, and the novel's exploration of faith, identity, and prejudice distinguishes it within vampire fiction. While I am not entirely certain where the series will head next, I would be open to continuing depending on future installments, and I would certainly be interested in reading more from this author. The lore is thoughtful. The themes are intentional. And the psychological dimension lingers.
Since this is an audiobook and the experience is notably shaped by its narrators and audio quality, I did lower my overall rating for this book strictly due to those issues (see scoring breakdown below).
My thanks to Netgalley, Flower Feather Press, and Katherine Villyard for complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
**Scoring Breakdown**
Personal Enjoyment: 4/5
Execution (Did the book do what it set out to do?): 4.5/5
Writing & Craft Quality: 4.25/5
Narration performance & Audio Quality: 3/5
Characters: 3.75/5
Plot: 4/5
February 18, 2026
Faith, immortality, and prejudice collide in Immortal Gifts, creating a fresh vampire narrative rooted in identity and moral complexity as it explores prejudice, survival, and what it means to be monstrous in a world already shaped by hate.
What This Book Does Well
Katherine Villyard demonstrates a strong command of vampire lore and historical detail. The 19th century sections feel grounded, shaping Abraham's internal and external conflicts in meaningful ways. The timeline shifts smoothly across centuries, and the musical references add texture and personality to the narrative.
Most notably, the novel offers something genuinely fresh within vampire fiction. Abraham's Jewish identity is central to the story's psychological and moral framework. The integration of vampirism with Jewish faith, theology, and lived identity feels organic. Instead of relying on familiar tropes, the novel interrogates what it means to be "monstrous" in a world already shaped by bigotry.
The antagonist is compelling and persistent, embodying generational hatred that adds emotional weight beyond standard supernatural conflict.
Where It Fell Short For Me
The multi-POV structure felt somewhat unnecessary. Abraham's perspective is so strong that the additional viewpoints occasionally diluted the narrative rather than deepening it.
Similarly, the romantic arc between Abraham and Destiny supports the novel's themes around immortality, but I didn't feel fully invested. Some of their conversations read more like early-relationship conflicts than those of an established marriage.
Most of the action-heavy moments arrive near the end and feel slightly rushed compared to the novel's otherwise measured pacing. This really wasn't an issue for me personally, but since the book blurb describes this a "pulse-pounding" I wanted to note it.
Craft & Writing Quality
Villyard's greatest strength lies in psychological nuance and thematic ambition. Abraham's evolution across centuries feels earned, and his struggle with self-perception as a Jewish vampire adds philosophical depth that elevates the novel beyond genre expectations.
The prose supports the contemplative tone of the story, and while there are moments of repetition, it felt understandable to me within a narrative spanning centuries.
To me, this is a character-driven vampire novel first, and a suspense-driven fantasy second. Readers drawn to moral complexity and thematic exploration will likely find more satisfaction than those expecting nonstop action.
Narration & Audio Quality
Abraham's narrator delivers a PHENOMENAL performance in particular! However, the audio production and performances are uneven, with some sections having lower clarity, occasional static, and moments of dead air that interrupted the story for me. The storytelling itself is strong, but the audio execution in it's current state could be improved.
Who I Would Recommend This To
Readers who enjoy character-driven vampire fiction that leans into history, faith, and psychological complexity. Those looking for psychological exploration and cultural nuance within vampire lore will likely find a lot to love here!
Final Thoughts & Opinions
Overall, I genuinely enjoyed Immortal Gifts. Abraham is a compelling protagonist, and the novel's exploration of faith, identity, and prejudice sets it apart within vampire fiction.
While I'm not entirely certain where the series will head next, I would be open to continuing the series depending on future installments and I would absolutely read more from Katherine Villyard!
Because this was an audiobook, my overall rating reflects the narration and audio quality issues as well as the story itself (see scoring breakdown below for details).
My thanks to Netgalley, Flower Feather Press, and Katherine Villyard for the ALC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Scoring Breakdown
Personal Enjoyment: 4/5
Execution (Did the book do what it set out to do?): 4.5/5
Writing & Craft Quality: 4.25/5
Narration & Audio Quality: 3/5
Characters: 3.75/5
Plot: 4/5
What This Book Does Well
Katherine Villyard demonstrates a strong command of vampire lore and historical detail. The 19th century sections feel grounded, shaping Abraham's internal and external conflicts in meaningful ways. The timeline shifts smoothly across centuries, and the musical references add texture and personality to the narrative.
Most notably, the novel offers something genuinely fresh within vampire fiction. Abraham's Jewish identity is central to the story's psychological and moral framework. The integration of vampirism with Jewish faith, theology, and lived identity feels organic. Instead of relying on familiar tropes, the novel interrogates what it means to be "monstrous" in a world already shaped by bigotry.
The antagonist is compelling and persistent, embodying generational hatred that adds emotional weight beyond standard supernatural conflict.
Where It Fell Short For Me
The multi-POV structure felt somewhat unnecessary. Abraham's perspective is so strong that the additional viewpoints occasionally diluted the narrative rather than deepening it.
Similarly, the romantic arc between Abraham and Destiny supports the novel's themes around immortality, but I didn't feel fully invested. Some of their conversations read more like early-relationship conflicts than those of an established marriage.
Most of the action-heavy moments arrive near the end and feel slightly rushed compared to the novel's otherwise measured pacing. This really wasn't an issue for me personally, but since the book blurb describes this a "pulse-pounding" I wanted to note it.
Craft & Writing Quality
Villyard's greatest strength lies in psychological nuance and thematic ambition. Abraham's evolution across centuries feels earned, and his struggle with self-perception as a Jewish vampire adds philosophical depth that elevates the novel beyond genre expectations.
The prose supports the contemplative tone of the story, and while there are moments of repetition, it felt understandable to me within a narrative spanning centuries.
To me, this is a character-driven vampire novel first, and a suspense-driven fantasy second. Readers drawn to moral complexity and thematic exploration will likely find more satisfaction than those expecting nonstop action.
Narration & Audio Quality
Abraham's narrator delivers a PHENOMENAL performance in particular! However, the audio production and performances are uneven, with some sections having lower clarity, occasional static, and moments of dead air that interrupted the story for me. The storytelling itself is strong, but the audio execution in it's current state could be improved.
Who I Would Recommend This To
Readers who enjoy character-driven vampire fiction that leans into history, faith, and psychological complexity. Those looking for psychological exploration and cultural nuance within vampire lore will likely find a lot to love here!
Final Thoughts & Opinions
Overall, I genuinely enjoyed Immortal Gifts. Abraham is a compelling protagonist, and the novel's exploration of faith, identity, and prejudice sets it apart within vampire fiction.
While I'm not entirely certain where the series will head next, I would be open to continuing the series depending on future installments and I would absolutely read more from Katherine Villyard!
Because this was an audiobook, my overall rating reflects the narration and audio quality issues as well as the story itself (see scoring breakdown below for details).
My thanks to Netgalley, Flower Feather Press, and Katherine Villyard for the ALC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Scoring Breakdown
Personal Enjoyment: 4/5
Execution (Did the book do what it set out to do?): 4.5/5
Writing & Craft Quality: 4.25/5
Narration & Audio Quality: 3/5
Characters: 3.75/5
Plot: 4/5
February 10, 2025
Liturgies of the Undying: A Nocturne of Persecution
Katherine Villyard’s Immortal Gifts reimagines the vampire narrative by intertwining supernatural lore with Jewish history, theology, and the enduring spectre and very topical of antisemitism. Through the fragmented, dual-timeline journey of Abraham Levy, a Jewish violin prodigy-turned-reluctant vampire, the novel traverses centuries—from 19th-century Prussia to contemporary New Jersey—while exploring themes of persecution, survival, and the cost of immortality. Abraham’s transformation, an act forced upon him by his well-intentioned but misguided patron Ludwig, not only severs him from his mortal aspirations but also places him in the crosshairs of Thomas, an ancient, unrelenting antisemitic vampire whose hatred spans historical epochs. Villyard deftly uses vampirism as a metaphor for exclusion, particularly highlighting Abraham’s struggle to reconcile his condition with Jewish law, which expressly forbids the consumption of blood. This theological dilemma adds complexity to the character’s arc, framing his existence as one of perpetual displacement—not just as a vampire, but as a Jew navigating centuries of evolving hostility.
The novel’s structure, shifting between past and present, enhances its thematic depth while reinforcing the inescapable nature of Abraham’s persecution. His present-day life with Destiny, his mortal wife, offers him a fragile semblance of peace—one inevitably shattered by Thomas’s reappearance. Villyard’s characterization is both rich and layered, with Abraham’s deep moral introspection and unexpected humour providing levity amid the novel’s darker undercurrents. The infusion of contemporary cultural references grounds the historical narrative in present-day anxieties, further drawing connections between past and ongoing antisemitic ideologies. In addition to its thematic weight, the novel introduces inventive elements to the vampire mythos, including the integration of scientific advancements such as IVF in the realm of the undead. These imaginative flourishes, coupled with the novel’s philosophical inquiries into faith, identity, and the nature of monstrosity, distinguish Immortal Gifts from conventional urban fantasy.
While the novel ambitiously navigates multiple periods and perspectives, its pacing occasionally fluctuates, reflecting the tension between its historical and contemporary narratives. However, this nonlinear storytelling choice effectively underscores the cyclical nature of prejudice and survival. The interplay between faith and fangs, tradition and transformation, makes Immortal Gifts a compelling, thought-provoking addition to vampire fiction. Villyard crafts a story that, while steeped in the supernatural, resonates with deeply human struggles, making it an essential read for those interested in Gothic fantasy.
Katherine Villyard’s Immortal Gifts reimagines the vampire narrative by intertwining supernatural lore with Jewish history, theology, and the enduring spectre and very topical of antisemitism. Through the fragmented, dual-timeline journey of Abraham Levy, a Jewish violin prodigy-turned-reluctant vampire, the novel traverses centuries—from 19th-century Prussia to contemporary New Jersey—while exploring themes of persecution, survival, and the cost of immortality. Abraham’s transformation, an act forced upon him by his well-intentioned but misguided patron Ludwig, not only severs him from his mortal aspirations but also places him in the crosshairs of Thomas, an ancient, unrelenting antisemitic vampire whose hatred spans historical epochs. Villyard deftly uses vampirism as a metaphor for exclusion, particularly highlighting Abraham’s struggle to reconcile his condition with Jewish law, which expressly forbids the consumption of blood. This theological dilemma adds complexity to the character’s arc, framing his existence as one of perpetual displacement—not just as a vampire, but as a Jew navigating centuries of evolving hostility.
The novel’s structure, shifting between past and present, enhances its thematic depth while reinforcing the inescapable nature of Abraham’s persecution. His present-day life with Destiny, his mortal wife, offers him a fragile semblance of peace—one inevitably shattered by Thomas’s reappearance. Villyard’s characterization is both rich and layered, with Abraham’s deep moral introspection and unexpected humour providing levity amid the novel’s darker undercurrents. The infusion of contemporary cultural references grounds the historical narrative in present-day anxieties, further drawing connections between past and ongoing antisemitic ideologies. In addition to its thematic weight, the novel introduces inventive elements to the vampire mythos, including the integration of scientific advancements such as IVF in the realm of the undead. These imaginative flourishes, coupled with the novel’s philosophical inquiries into faith, identity, and the nature of monstrosity, distinguish Immortal Gifts from conventional urban fantasy.
While the novel ambitiously navigates multiple periods and perspectives, its pacing occasionally fluctuates, reflecting the tension between its historical and contemporary narratives. However, this nonlinear storytelling choice effectively underscores the cyclical nature of prejudice and survival. The interplay between faith and fangs, tradition and transformation, makes Immortal Gifts a compelling, thought-provoking addition to vampire fiction. Villyard crafts a story that, while steeped in the supernatural, resonates with deeply human struggles, making it an essential read for those interested in Gothic fantasy.
February 21, 2025
'Eternity is boring without company, and yet the company is not, for the most part, immortal.'
We all might have heard about vampires and read a couple of books and watched series highlighting the different aspects of their life and their immortality. An unpopular choice may be but I don't prefer reading much about vampires. Immortal Gifts is the first book in the Immortal Vampire series and it did make me perceive a different side of vampires and kept me hooked. Surprisingly. The thin line between choice and being forced to be someone is what I could sense through Abraham, one of the protagonists, who happens to be a vampire - not by choice. While art keeps us going, for him it was the other way around. His grace with the violin became the very reason for his separation from humaneness. Yet, his kind heart, love towards animals, and the aching fear of losing his loved ones to death are portrayed with such depth that you feel like reaching out and offering a kind word. He seems to be one among us, stuck between the endless choices that lie within life and death. His wife, Destiny, and their not-so-normal companionship made me think of how love can't be put into boxes with labels. However, the best part is the way it's written with different perspectives and from different POVs. Each character shares a part of him - a part of what made him who he is through a history of pain and survival. I feel the author has done justice to each character and given a good understanding of their lives wherein we can connect and relate to them - regardless of them being fictitious.
Death, immortality, and the desire to save your loved ones from death is articulated so well. There was one particular scene where Abraham and Destiny had different ways of coping with the sickness of their cats. I was moved!
Dated back to the '90s and spanning across different eras, you get a taste of history as well. The transition from one era to another doesn't feel superficial - it seems the characters are molded by history. While there were many things that I didn't relate to, it was the storytelling and unfiltered portrayal of emotions that made it worth it!
We all might have heard about vampires and read a couple of books and watched series highlighting the different aspects of their life and their immortality. An unpopular choice may be but I don't prefer reading much about vampires. Immortal Gifts is the first book in the Immortal Vampire series and it did make me perceive a different side of vampires and kept me hooked. Surprisingly. The thin line between choice and being forced to be someone is what I could sense through Abraham, one of the protagonists, who happens to be a vampire - not by choice. While art keeps us going, for him it was the other way around. His grace with the violin became the very reason for his separation from humaneness. Yet, his kind heart, love towards animals, and the aching fear of losing his loved ones to death are portrayed with such depth that you feel like reaching out and offering a kind word. He seems to be one among us, stuck between the endless choices that lie within life and death. His wife, Destiny, and their not-so-normal companionship made me think of how love can't be put into boxes with labels. However, the best part is the way it's written with different perspectives and from different POVs. Each character shares a part of him - a part of what made him who he is through a history of pain and survival. I feel the author has done justice to each character and given a good understanding of their lives wherein we can connect and relate to them - regardless of them being fictitious.
Death, immortality, and the desire to save your loved ones from death is articulated so well. There was one particular scene where Abraham and Destiny had different ways of coping with the sickness of their cats. I was moved!
Dated back to the '90s and spanning across different eras, you get a taste of history as well. The transition from one era to another doesn't feel superficial - it seems the characters are molded by history. While there were many things that I didn't relate to, it was the storytelling and unfiltered portrayal of emotions that made it worth it!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
April 1, 2026
I read Immortal Gifts partly as an ebook and partly as an audiobook ARC. About halfway through, I randomly came across the audiobook while browsing NetGalley, and from then on I used both formats together, which made for an interesting reading experience.
What stood out to me most was the idea of a Jewish vampire. I basically grew up consuming all kinds of vampire stories, and this felt fresh and different. I really liked Abraham’s struggle with his faith, his deliberate isolation, and how his perspective changes over time. When his distant descendant turns into a vampire in the modern era, the said descendant introduces the idea that they are still alive, not dead, and can therefore continue to take part in Jewish traditions.
I also enjoyed learning about the Jewish customs included in the story. Some of it matched things I’ve come across before (mostly through Miriam Ezagui), though I’m not an expert. It did make me curious about how accurate everything is and how much research went into it. I also learned something new, like Wagner’s antisemitism and racist essays. The detail about Abraham not wanting Lohengrin played at his vow renewal was a great touch.
Not much happens plot-wise until the very end. The author focuses more on daily life, both in the present and in the vampires’ past. While I usually prefer plot-driven stories, I didn’t really mind it here. I actually enjoyed seeing history through the eyes of vampires.
However, I did have some issues with the writing. The dual (or triple?) POV didn’t always work for me. At times it felt unnatural, especially when one character shares their thoughts and the next POV directly reacts to them. It made some scenes feel forced and artificial. Another example is when one character wonders if another is gay, and the very next POV immediately confirms it.
The vampire transformation also felt too quick, and the characters accepted it with very little doubt, which made it less believable.
For the audiobook, I started listening around chapter 8. Abraham’s voice sounded much older than I expected for a 19-year-old, and also didn’t really match his description (small, thin, boyish). Ludwig’s voice worked better for me, and I especially enjoyed Destiny’s narrator. I also found myself wondering whether the Hebrew prayers were pronounced correctly, especially since the author discusses pronunciation choices (Ashkenazi vs. Sephardic) in the endnotes.
I would also suggest adding an LGBTQ+ content warning for readers.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
What stood out to me most was the idea of a Jewish vampire. I basically grew up consuming all kinds of vampire stories, and this felt fresh and different. I really liked Abraham’s struggle with his faith, his deliberate isolation, and how his perspective changes over time. When his distant descendant turns into a vampire in the modern era, the said descendant introduces the idea that they are still alive, not dead, and can therefore continue to take part in Jewish traditions.
I also enjoyed learning about the Jewish customs included in the story. Some of it matched things I’ve come across before (mostly through Miriam Ezagui), though I’m not an expert. It did make me curious about how accurate everything is and how much research went into it. I also learned something new, like Wagner’s antisemitism and racist essays. The detail about Abraham not wanting Lohengrin played at his vow renewal was a great touch.
Not much happens plot-wise until the very end. The author focuses more on daily life, both in the present and in the vampires’ past. While I usually prefer plot-driven stories, I didn’t really mind it here. I actually enjoyed seeing history through the eyes of vampires.
However, I did have some issues with the writing. The dual (or triple?) POV didn’t always work for me. At times it felt unnatural, especially when one character shares their thoughts and the next POV directly reacts to them. It made some scenes feel forced and artificial. Another example is when one character wonders if another is gay, and the very next POV immediately confirms it.
The vampire transformation also felt too quick, and the characters accepted it with very little doubt, which made it less believable.
For the audiobook, I started listening around chapter 8. Abraham’s voice sounded much older than I expected for a 19-year-old, and also didn’t really match his description (small, thin, boyish). Ludwig’s voice worked better for me, and I especially enjoyed Destiny’s narrator. I also found myself wondering whether the Hebrew prayers were pronounced correctly, especially since the author discusses pronunciation choices (Ashkenazi vs. Sephardic) in the endnotes.
I would also suggest adding an LGBTQ+ content warning for readers.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 129 reviews