A sweeping, gorgeously written debut: a novel of duty to family and country, the dictates of passion, and blood ties unraveling in the charged political climate of Berlin between the world wars.
Lev Perlmutter, an assimilated, cultured German Jew, enlists to fight in World War I, leaving behind his gentile wife, Josephine, and their children, Franz and Vicki. Moving between Lev's and Josephine's points of view, the first part of the novel focuses on Lev's experiences on the Eastern Front — both in war and in love — which render his life at home a pale aftermath by comparison. The second part of the novel takes us to Berlin, 1927–28. Now young adults, the Perlmutter children grapple with their own questions: Franz, drawn into the Nazi brown shirt movement, struggles with his unexpressed homosexuality; Vicki, seduced by the Jazz Age and everything new, bobs her hair and falls in love with a young man who wants to take her to Palestine.
Unlike many historical novels of its kind, The Empire of the Senses is not about the Holocaust but about the juxtaposition of events that led to it, and about why it was unimaginable to ordinary people like Lev and his wife. Plotted with meticulous precision and populated with characters who feel and dream to the fullest, it holds us rapt as the tides of cultural loss and ethnic hatred come to coexist with those of love, passion, and the power of the human spirit.
I’m going to share one of my reading secrets with you: I have an obsession with World War II and the Holocaust. Fiction or nonfiction, if a book is set between 1933-1945 I am easily inspired to pick it up. So, I am well versed in the literary world of this time period. I was starting to feel a bit burned out on the subject but suddenly in the last several years authors are starting to tackle lesser explored parts of this history and my reading on the subject has been reinvigorated. The Empire of the Senses is just such a book. It takes the unusual track of providing us with German narrators and exploring the lead up to WWII and the human atrocities that occurred in Germany during that time from the inside of a successful if dysfunctional middle class German family. Yes one of our narrators is Jewish, but he has spent his entire life trying to put his German nationality before his upbringing. The first half of this novel takes place during the Great War and interweaves whispers of the anti-Semitism and political extremism that will create the history we know today. The second half takes place between the two World Wars and provides us with multiple viewpoints through the four Perlmutter family members who have radically different political beliefs. I very much enjoyed the new viewpoints into a well explored bit of history. However, I felt that the author distanced the reader from the narrators somehow so that I was not fully engaged in their fates. It is also a very long and sometimes dense story and I considered giving up a few times but am glad in the long run that I didn’t.
My review appears in New York Journal of Books. Read that review first. Additional remarks that appeared in a different and now defunct publication begin with the next paragraph.
Jewish books: The Empire of the Senses probes Jewish identity in Weimar Germany
Where does acculturation end and assimilation begin? How do overlapping ethnic/religious and national identities on the one hand, and majority and minority cultures on the other, shape our individual identities? These are some of the issues Alexis Landau explores in the setting of an intermarried family in Germany in the second and third decades of the Twentieth Century (before the Nazis took power) in her debut novel The Empire of the Senses, which was published earlier this month by New York based publisher Pantheon, an imprint of Random House/Bertelsmann.
In my New York Journal of Books review I praise the book as “handsomely written” as well as a “powerful and compelling novel.” I also point out a few historical errors which can be viewed as rookie mistakes. The wealth of detail with which Landau describes Berlin in this period is impressive, but her knowledge of eastern Europe’s political geography between the wars is less reliable.
The family whose story the novel relates is the Perlmutters: Lev, the Jewish German husband and father whose family immigrated to Germany from southern Poland (then part of Austria-Hungary) when he was two; Josephine, the aristocratic Christian German wife and mother; and their children Franz and Vicki. The first third of the novel takes place during the First World War and describes Lev’s army service in Latvia with the occasional scene of Josephine and the kids back home in Berlin. The final two thirds takes place in Berlin in 1927-28 when Lev and Josephine’s marriage is in trouble and the young adult children each identify with his/her opposite gender parent.
Although the temporal setting predates Hitler’s appointment as chancellor in 1933 and the Holocaust in the early 1940s, Landau foreshadows these with place names. When in 1914 Lev asks a fellow soldier where he’s from the man replies Dachau, the suburb of Munich where the famous concentration camp would be built 19 years later. When Vicki enjoys walks along the Wannsee lakefront in the 1920s knowledgable readers will associate the spot with the January 1942 Wannsee Conference where Nazi officials planned the Holocaust.
Later historic events are also called to mind by the activities of Nazi thugs in the 1920s, as when Lev, Josephine, and Vicki witness a young gentile woman having her head shaved for associating with a Jewish man.
“Lev glanced over at Josephine, standing on the other side of Vicki. She held her head high, staring impassively ahead, as if surmising the sunset or some other benign natural phenomenon. How did she not feel shattered by this? She, who had also committed the sin of loving a Jewish man, now gazed stonily at the poor girl. Perhaps she’s afraid too, Lev thought, and she’s trying to put on a strong front for Vicki, as I am. Or perhaps she’s oblivious to the implications of this, thinking it unfortunate but impersonal, as if witnessing a half-dead bird twitching on the side of the road before speeding by, already on to the next thought.”
Landau’s command of figurative language is also evident in this description of Josephine walking home from a bakery:
“Holding the bread to her chest, she made her way home, thinking of those dreamy winter afternoons, when the light looked as it did now, the crystalline blue of the sky slipping into a faded purple, as faint as a bruise.”
Sensory language such as this in part explains the novel’s title, which unfortunately is similar to and reminiscent of the titles of Japanese director Nagisa Oshima's art house erotic movies In The Realm of the Senses (1976) and The Empire of Passion (1978). I conclude my NYJB review by recommending The Empire of the Senses to readers of literary historical fiction. See that review for a fuller discussion of the novel.
In an interview Landau said that one of this novel’s minor characters will be the protagonist of her next novel, which will be set in Los Angeles in the 1940s and 50s. I look forward to reading it and this talented author's other future books.
Great idea for an interesting plot. The marriage of a German Jew to a Christian German aristocrat before WW1 and his life though the first war and all the way to the 50’s. Great descriptive prose of cities and the experience of the war but his life during WW2 was sketchy and Compressed. in general, this was a dull read and Disappointing.
This book is about a family...that somehow manages to survive WWI and the years after WWI...just before Hitler manages to come into power. Lev and Josephine...married...parents to Franz and Vicki. Lev is Jewish...Josephine is not. Franz is a closeted homosexual involved in Hitler youth groups...Brown Shirts...even though his father is Jewish. Lev and Josephine do not love each other...they have each found others whom they yearn for.
My thoughts after reading this book...
This book was a more personal look at what happens to people during the horrors of war. Lev was a soldier for three years until he decided that he was finished with soldiering. This book was most interesting to me because there were so many characters missing key opportunities in their lives. Lev wants to go to America to find his long lost love Leah...but things keep happening to prevent his departure. Josephine withdraws...Franz becomes more German and tries to keep his hands off of his best friend...Vicki chops off her hair and dances. And all the while there is this build up to the nightmare that will become WWII and Hitler.
What I loved best...
This book was not at all what I expected. It was more than a book about the events that led up to WWII. It was really about the lives of reluctant soldiers and families and all of the good and bad things they endured during this time.
What potential readers might want to know...
This is a huge book...the story of what happens to this family is gripping. Readers who love historical fiction with a focus on the people involved in these events...should really enjoy this book.
After reading so many books about war, I was hesitant to read this book. To my delight this book was more about the characters and the turns their lives took than about the two world wars. I really enjoyed the twists and turns in the plot. Ultimately, this book could have been set in any time period because, at it's core, it is about the highs and lows of life--love and loss. When I finished the book, I was pleasantly satisfied that I had had an honest and beautifully detailed experience of the characters' lives during such a tumultuous time in history. A little too long for my taste, but definitely worth the read.
I was very excited about this novel but even though I was on a World War II reading binge, I was unable to form enough of a connection with the characters to finish it.
It was as though the characters were floating through their lives connected only by the slightest of strings. There are enough developments in the story for some real emotional grip, but it does not happen.
It's a quality book and I'm glad others are enjoying it. For me, however, it was a no go.
I read this on my phone, so when I started I didn't have a sense of how long it was, and I'm a fast reader; so when it still felt like I was at the beginning of the story after a few hours of reading, I was a little surprised, until I checked and saw that it was 1200 pages. Oh. I found the second part more engaging than the first, although both halves could have used more editing. Several of the references to Jewish practices or ideas were just "off" enough (misspellings, incorrect timing, anachronistic or otherwise inappropriate) that it was distracting, but not enough that I wouldn't recommend it. Otherwise, it was a compelling portrait of the social and ideological cauldron of interwar Germany.
Disappointing. I expected to like this much more. I know some readers have enjoyed this book, but I found it an exhausting slog. I felt cheated by the resolution, which was much too neat. I didn't find the characters or their stories emotionally compelling. Instead, I felt deluged by every possible detail the author discovered in her research, which, sadly, does not make for an enjoyable read.
Saga that follows a German Jew as he enlists and serves in World War I, becomes disillusioned, falls in love, returns to his wife and family, watches his children make choices that bring him pain, and grows old in a foreign land. The plot moves so well that, despite 470+ pages, I wished the story were prolonged. The characters are well drawn and believable, and the writing is sensual.
I really liked this book and it is probably one of my favourite reads this year. It covers a long period of time and suffers the same problem as many similar books in that this time is not spread out in a balanced manner. However, it was a new and interesting take on WWI, Weimar Germany and its aftermath.
i have always felt fascinated by the jewish history of mitteleurope; by all the art, language, food, and cultural richness that europe lost after the holocaust. i find myself wondering about the ever-shifting nature of borders, and how the very fluidity of central and eastern european countries also helped shape jewish identity, with some people choosing to assimilate and follow the bourgeois fantasy of contemporary nationalism, and others remaining enclosed in the relative safety of the shtetl — until it, too, was ravaged by external forces.
this novel explores what it meant to be jewish during the first third of the twentieth century in a manner that was, quite frankly, astounding to me. i think i had never read a novel in which the sense of place and time was this well-crafted; in a way, it felt like gazing at the ruins of a greek temple, observing a cultural and political reality that was brutally extermined only a handful of years after the main events of the novel. mitau, the small village where lev was deployed during the first part of the novel, came alive in such beautiful and evocative ways; i almost felt as though i had been transported there as i pored through its pages.
the characters, on the other hand, were richly layered and beautifully crafted — i found most of them grating at one point or another, but i think that was precisely the point. lev is a complex man, grappling with his jewish identity after having spent most of his youth trying his hardest to assimilate into german culture; franz, his eldest son, was devastatingly nuanced and always kept me on the edge of my seat. perhaps josephine and vicki were a little less well-rounded as characters, but i still liked them nevertheless — vicki, particularly, was a delicious character, and i adored her youthful sense of rebellion and her sudden romance with geza, who was also really beautifully written.
that being said, my only major qualm with this book is that i felt as though the various family dynamics were a little underdeveloped, as i found myself wishing landau had explored vicki and franz’s relationship a little more, as well as franz and lev’s. on that topic, i also wish the ending had felt a little less rushed, because it felt a little cheap to have most of the plot neatly tied up with a ribbon in an immense epilogue. the zionist-y overtones were also a little jarring at times, which i think is what ultimately prevented me from completely loving this as a whole.
At the beginning of WWI Lev Perlmutter, an assimilated German Jew married to a non-Jewish woman enlists in the German army. Assigned to be a medic, he ends up in the Pale of Settlement, where he falls in love with Leah, a widow. As the war winds down, he deserts before the Russians occupy the area. Part 2 takes place in 1927. His son Franz, a closeted homosexual joins the SA. His daughter, Vicki falls in love with Geza, a young Jew who Lev knew as a teenager during WWI. Geza is a Zionist who convinces Vicki to go to Palestine with him. Circling around the Holocaust, his book does a wonderful job of presenting how Germany gradually slid into anti-Semitism. Fascinaitng and well written
Alexis Landau use of language is too striking and beautiful to rush...
(side note: the book received mixed reviews but who can bypass a book with such a title)
Lines that touch: "the redness of the sun sadly vibrating through the fir trees struck him as beautiful."
"Teacups placed down on saucers, glasses clinking with glasses, spoons knocking against porcelain, and knives scraping the last bits of cake off plates filtered through the long drafty hall, creating a music of its own."
What is love?
"He asked again, raising his voice, "What is love?" and not waiting for a reply, he answered, "It is a candle flickering on the mantel. Briefly, it leaves its mark. Then once again fades into the dark."
The author must be commended for developing characters (that are in some cases weak and despicable) and integrating these individuals into the lesser known historical arenas like the eastern front of the First World War and Germany during the post-First World War era. It did take me sometime to read this novel because of the character development and plodding (at times) storyline. But after completing the book, I do believe that this was the aim of the author, develop some characters, leave other character's faith open to interpretation, while all the while highlighting how fallible, indecisive and gullible humans can be.
Sweeping saga spans the first and second world wars, complex romantic relationships and sexual awakenings intimately examined. For all of its potential: difficult to invest in self-absorbed characters prone to spare displays of love and warmth; author's agenda transparent (e.g., anti-Semitism, homophobia, Zionism, sexual liberation); hard to sympathize with upper middle class of late 1920s Berlin given Germany at large in crisis; tragedy of Lev and Leah never reuniting in America undercut by Lev's lack of urgency while languishing in Argentina.
A beautiful, complicated love story spanning the pre-WWI-post-WWII years, this novel follows the various stories of the members of a "mixed-race" family and those with whom they fall in love, taking the reader through the social strata of Berlin to the Eastern Front of WWI, to post-WWI Germany and the rise of Nazi racism, and the quest of some for a true Jewish homeland and for others the freedom they imagine in the New Worlds of the Americas.
I find that overall i did enjoy this book. I did get lost in the timing - i couldn't tell if it was a month or a year that had gone by only to find out that it was just a week.
I did find that I was talking back to narrator - agreeing or disagreeing with a move a character made (sure sign that the book was stuck in me :) )
It was a interesting read. I almost wished there were pictures to go along with it.
This is Landau's 1st novel. I read and loved her 2nd book "Those Who Are Saved" and I connected with the characters, so checked out this book to see how Lev and his family fared after the war. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and hated for it to end. Important to read the Epilogue as well. I'd recommend this book.
The Empire of the Senses is historical fiction about a German family in the first decades of the 20th century. Unfortunately, it is written using 21st century attitudes and sensibilities, and just becomes unbelievable very quickly. Also, the pace is irregular, and the characters a bit stiff.
Overall, I found this book to be interesting and, for the most part, it kept my attention. There were a lot of characters and at times I found it difficult to remember who was who.
Definitely my favorite literary fiction novel as of yet this year. Granted, I was drawn to it in part because of the subject matter. I've longed for a novel that described the fallen world of European Jewry, particularly the largely assimilated one of German Jewry, before WWII. But much like the Fatherland itself, the current Jewish narrative seems to focus most concretely on the present. The Shoah was the maw from which we were all birthed--and in the near decimation of the European community, the Jewish reality was changed forever.
But before Hitler's rise to power, German Jews had another story. We see it manifested through the Perlmutter family--interfaith, largely assimilated, complex. We start in the Great War, which 30-year-old patriarch and son of Galician immigrants, Lev, has signed up for to prove his national pride, largely to his antisemitic in-laws. I love the way that his young son, Franz, buys into the propaganda and imagines him blowing up English soldiers, while in reality he's laying roads and bumping shoulders with peasants in the Baltic states, a territory that changes hands between Russia and Germany. Stationed in the town of Mitau for years, he has a long love affair with a Jewish woman, Leah, which among other things brings up the differences and similarities between their Judaisms and the response from their home countries. Of course we also dip into the Russian civil war with the deaths of the Romanovs and the rise of the Bolsheviks, German arrogance about their technical and psychological superiority, etc.
After the end of the war, when Lev is forced to leave Leah, we skip ten years into the future, where Landau deftly and unobtrusively explores the rising militant nationalism, the clash of cultures as Germany struggles after the Great War yet more eastern refugees flood in, etc. Through fiction, I think we can also see how these fears and resentments, populist xenophobia and slow shift towards violence, reverberates throughout history.
But I wouldn't be so entranced if I didn't feel anything for the characters. It's a fractured family from the start, with "Aryan" Josephine (Lev's wife) and Franz on one side, and Lev and his daughter, Vicki, on the other. That's not to say that the story devolves into polarizing battles, although it's perhaps intriguing that both Josephine and Franz suffered from suppressing their sexualities. But Franz's growing nationalist militarism, although in hindsight rapidly leading to Nazism, couldn't be understood, piecemeal, by his parents attempting to live with and understand their emotionally claustrophobic, angry young son. Josephine, for her part, longed for the antiquated days of the faded Austro-Hungarian Empire; I was perhaps most in love with Landau's detailed writing as she talked about Strauss and the operas and the opulent summer homes in the Bavarian woods (Josephine also comes from old money, of course).
Lev's childhood seemed somewhat confusingly split between a religious and a cultured secular upbringing. As an adult, though still occasionally communing with his Communist mother and keeping a wary eye on the National Socialist movement, he mostly saw himself as German and disdained Vicki's ultimate Zionist leanings. He rightly assumed that she was simply agreeing to make Aliyah to Palestine because of her love for a Zionist boy, and I appreciate how Vicki struggled with her decision, both leading up to and after the move. And one could say that thanks to her Communist Jewish grandmother, or a very strained relationship with her own mother, the desire for rebellion and change was already planted. Still, for a girl who started out as a rather myopic jazz aficionado, her relationship with Geza and new leanings seemed a little fast. I'm just glad she got out of Germany before the Shoah, of course, but although some Jews were anxious, no one could quite see that future coming.
Landau certainly did her research into the culture and time period; I can't say that I knew a lot about all of it (relatedly, I'm unsure why Landau or her editor chose to provide translations for some words/phrases but not others), but the world was descriptive and engrossing. The characters and situations were layered, thought provoking, and of course, a little bittersweet. I was hoping that this book would suck me in, and I wasn't disappointed.
Alexis Landau's first novel, "The Empire of the Senses", is set in Berlin, with some side scenes in western Russia, Argentina, and Palestine. But it is a novel basically about Berliners, and about the Jewish/Christian family of Lev Pearlmutter and his wife, Josephine, and their two children, Franz and Vicki. It's a story about a "mixed marriage" and the illicit love for others outside of it.
The book begins in 1914 as Lev Pearlmutter leaves his family in Berlin to go off to war, joining millions of other men in France, Britain, Russia, and Austria-Hungary as they prepared for the war they thought would be over by Christmas. Of all the reasons soldiers enlisted, probably few did it for the same reason Lev Pearlmutter did; he wanted to prove to the Christian family he had married into that he was just as "good" a German as they were, despite his Jewish background. Lev was sent to the Russian front and spend four years as a medic. While there, he fell in love with Leah, a young Jewish woman, who he was loathe to leave at the war's end. But he does so and returns to his wife and family and assimilated place in Berlin society. As the 1920's proceed, the Pearlmutter family falls apart. Tolstoy was right about "unhappy families" and the Pearlmutters are a classic example of his dictum.
Alexis Landau does a good job at individualizing her characters. None are caricatures though the son, Franz, is both gay and self-hating of his Jewish side. Josephine is a self-absorbed narcissist and the love between Lev and her blossomed and then died. Vicki is a typical searching young woman. But the most interesting character in Landau's novel is Lev Pearlmutter, a thoughtful man who has to come to terms with the mistakes he's made in his life. It's around Lev that Landau has put most of the novel's action.
Landau's Berlin is a tightly drawn study of that ever-changing city and its society in the first half of the 1900's. (She refers to the daughter of the American ambassador to Germany and her flighty, flirty ways - Martha Dodd - but William Dodd didn't become ambassador until 1933. The time set was the late 1920's. A few "mistakes" like that shouldn't color the enjoyment of this novel; I'm mentioning it only if the author and editor might want to correct it before final publication.) But overall Alexis Landau has written a very good novel and I'm looking forward to her future work.
I’m going to share one of my reading secrets with you: I have an obsession with World War II and the Holocaust. Fiction or nonfiction, if a book is set between 1933-1945 I am easily inspired to pick it up. So, I am well versed in the literary world of this time period. I was starting to feel a bit burned out on the subject but suddenly in the last several years authors are starting to tackle lesser explored parts of this history. The Empire of the Senses is just such a book. It takes the very unusual track of providing us with German narrators and exploring the lead up to WWII and the human atrocities that occurred in Germany during that time from the inside of a successful if dysfunctional middle class German family. Yes one of our narrators is Jewish, but he has spent his entire life trying to put his German nationality before his upbringing. The first half of this novel takes place during the Great War and interweaves whispers of the anti-Semitism and political extremism that will create the history we know today. The second half takes place between the two World Wars and provides us with multiple viewpoints through the four Perlmutter family members who have radically different political beliefs. I very much enjoyed the new viewpoints into a well explored bit of history. However, I felt that the author distanced the reader from the narrators somehow so that I was not fully engaged in their fates. It is also very long and sometimes dense story and I considered giving up a few times but am glad in the long run that I didn’t.
Debut author Alexis Landau has created a dramatic historical novel spanning over twenty years of early 20th century Berlin. She centers her tale on the family of Lev Perlmutter, an assimilated Jewish German, married to an aristocratic and haughty Gentile wife, with two young children. In part 1, Lev is drafted into World War I, and finds himself internally conflicted between his familial duty back home and his Jewish mistress he meets during his military travels. In part 2, the timeline jumps to 1927, following the dramatic sagas of Lev’s young adult children, Franz and Vicki, as they move away from their Jewish heritage in a seductive jazz-age Berlin. Christopher Lane narrates with European flair, his bass tone rumbling pleasantly throughout the novel. His German-Yiddish accent for Lev feels authentic, contrasted with lighter accents for the female characters. Lane staccatos his voice to portray the thick German accents during World War I, which may make for occasionally difficult listening. Yet listeners will be captivated by the complex characters Landau has created, and Lane has interpreted with grace and authenticity.
3.5 stars for its ambition and its frequently engaging quality.
A family saga at heart and because of what we know about what is coming to Germany and to the Jews, everything seems especially poignant. A little detail like the rabbi not liking beets because they look like blood seems ominous. Another might be the Russian Jews rounded up for lice treatment in WWI, which foreshadows the much more deadly rounding up to come.
One often wonders how the German people allowed Nazism to rise in the first place and this book does a pretty good job showing us, although it hits in a hurry. One minute everything is relatively okay, then the next the family sees a rally in Nuremberg and it’s fascism in every direction.
And so what does the title mean? Geo-political empires come and go but the dominion of sex, the libido, the sexual drive in all of us, that is the empire that never falls. I guess.
The book was obviously auto-corrected in many places to its detriment. Waiting with "baited breath," wearing a beautiful "broach" and others too numerous to name show that no one bothered to proofread it a final time.
Lev Perlmutter is a Berliner married to a woman whose family, steeped in military tradition, hates him because he is a Jew. Lev hopes that his service in WWI will gain him honor in their eyes. He serves on the eastern front where he sees less combat than service, and he falls in love with a Jewish woman whose husband is in the Russian army and thought to be dead. By the late 1920s Lev is back at work at the family textile plant and successful. His wife Josephine is distant, her family still despises him and his two children are a problem. Franz is caught up in the brown shirt movement and Vicki is into the night life of the city.
Each character is drawn nicely and there is an inevitability to the story which creates a powerful tension. Hilter’s rise to power, the ugliness of anti-semitism. And yet the story veers from the predictable. Choices people make, decisions that shape the course of a life, these become central and what transpires is ... well, you’ll have to explore this.
This novel hooked me with a powerful story, strong writing and believable charaters. Enjoy the read!
I feel like I've read a lot of historical fiction lately that takes place during or around the World Wars, yet Empire of the Senses was unique in that the war wasn't really its focus. The first part of the novel takes place on the Eastern Front, but it focuses more on Lev's feelings about being separated from his family, and the relationship he develops with a local woman.
The second part picks up with Lev's family in Germany in the late 20's, and shows how each of them is choosing to cope with the changing world around them--psychoanalysis, jazz, the brown shirt movement. A few times, Landau examines the same day from each character's perspective, which was a conceit I really enjoyed. It was interesting to see the same interactions from different angles, knowing what each character was hiding from the others. It proved to be an interesting portrait of a family growing up and, in some cases, growing apart, in the shadow of a coming war.
In a light impressionistic style, the story of a melancholy, assimilated German Jew, slowly weaves it way between the two great wars. In a microcosm of Germany, the novel describes a love affair, marriage, and collapse and the impact on the lives of the family members. The protagonist, without much thought or self-knowledge, stumbles through a love affair with a German woman to begin a failing marriage, attempting to maintain a bourgeois existence for his family, only to have it all fall apart when he falls in love with a Jewish woman. In a well written story, without great drama or surprises, it tells its sad tale. I would not use this story as a metaphor, which I believe its style promotes, but more as a light portrait of an individual family's struggle against a harsh environment.