2.5 stars. I realize this is a pretty low rating, but even though I enjoyed the sweet, cuddly, loving-on-the-baby moments, and even though there was one novella I REALLY enjoyed, some of the characters in these stories infuriated me. I was about to go INSANE from how ridiculously annoying they were, and that definitely took away from my enjoyment. O_o
In His Father's Arms by Beth Wiseman - Everyone was crying and wouldn't stop. The main conflict was born out of teary Levi's immaturity; he neglected his infant son, tossing burdens upon his hormone-ridden young wife (they're nineteen-year-old new parents) all because the baby had Down's Syndrome and Levi was seriously struggling to accept that. And I know it's his character arc, but like... it annoyed me a lot??? :/
A Son for Always by Amy Clipston - The main character Carolyn was the one who annoyed me in this one. Her husband Joshua was WONDERFUL, and so were a bunch of the other side characters! But Carolyn was just... kinda ignorant?? Like, HONEY, YOU SHOULD KNOW YOUR HUSBAND. You can see how much he loves your son Ben!
You see, Carolyn had a child with someone else when she was younger and unmarried, a mistake she'd repented of and the Amish community had forgiven her of. Now she's married and has a new baby daughter. Carolyn, however, spent the majority of the story worrying and worrying and worrying that Joshua wouldn't care for Ben as much as for his new biological daughter, when CLEARLY he had accepted the boy as his own. Anyone with two eyes could see it.
Like I said, the side characters were wonderful. <3 And Carolyn, though kinda annoying, wasn't that bad. Annoyance levels were high for a good portion of the story, though.
A Heart Full of Love by Kathleen Fuller - *deep breaths* Edna's behavior absolutely RUINED this novella for me. Rather than furthering my enjoyment, as conflict in a story should, the conflict with Edna only made me angry. Very, very angry.
This woman loves her new twin grandkids. But get this - she doesn't trust her daughter, the twins' blind mother, to take care of her own children! Poor Ellie, the twins' mother, barely had ANY time with her own precious children, whom - as their mother - she loved more than anyone!! She could barely TOUCH the babies, Edna was hogging them so much of the time. *growls* I mean... the woman has a reason for her extreme protectiveness, but STILL. I spent the majority of the novella literally taking deep breaths to contain how immensely upset I was. :P
An Unexpected Blessing by Vanetta Chapman - And this, my friends, was the one I very much enjoyed. <3 The characters (Etta, Mose, their daughters, etc.), the twists, the writing style - all of it was soooo good. For such a short story, it was REALLY well done, and my heart was full of warmth by the last page. <3
I felt like the first three novellas went overboard on the emotions and missed the mark with their conflicts, whereas the last story balanced the emotions well and crafted a conflict that was neither too intense nor too flimsy.
I'm not trying to bash the first three authors about their stories - those three novellas just... didn't cut it for me. You may enjoy them more than I did. :)
In summary, I didn't HATE these stories, but I didn't like them either (except the last one, which had to be one of the shorter ones. Of course. :P).