In the second instalment of The Inside Story of the British Bureau for the Arcane, Phil Parker seems to have found his target genre: James Bond, but make it urban fantasy and with parental issues. Tayn, Arlo’s son, who made his first gentle appearance in the first book, has taken over half of The Carolean Codex. His perspective is welcome and very different from Arlo’s sometimes irritating stoicism.
The worldbuilding I so enjoyed in The Dark Elf Dynasty File is sadly missing from The Carolean Codex. This book reads more like a thriller – but with fae and dark elves. Honestly, there should be fewer Tom Clancy and whossit that has all those ghostwriters, Patterson? – and more of this.
Apart from triggering some of my minor personal pet peeves related to commas ;) the only criticism I really have is the handling of the relationship between Tayn and Eldrick. The author works so hard on reminding us that they are nothing but friendly friends (this comes as certain surprise to Eldrick) that it feels like heavy and unnecessary foreshadowing of something that ultimately plays a very minor role in the book. Oddly, so does the actual Carolean Codex – we never get to see it before [spoiler removed]. What I really enjoyed was the mix between the modern and the fantasy – there are guns and flaming swords, Sylvia Kent and Gwyn, and the trusty tomb vacuum! (I still need one.)
I am not necessarily the right audience for this book, nevertheless I appreciated the steady pacing, quick action, and the fact that once again Parker proves that it’s possible to fit what other authors would need 600 pages for into only 166 (!) – this is not a book that overstays its welcome! I’ll be looking forward to the third book in the series and I expect to enjoy it.
(7/10, rounded up to 4/5 for Goodreads)
My ratings:
5* = this book changed my life
4* = very good
3* = good
2* = I should have DNFed
1* = actively hostile towards the reader*