Book Boyfriend Boxed Set

by Erin Noelle

Follow Scarlett MacGregor's transformation from a young, naïve girl to a strong, mature young woman and her search for self-discovery and true love in three full length novels and one closing novella.

Intended for mature audiences.

Genres: Romance, New Adult, Contemporary, Erotica

589 pages, Kindle Edition

First published June 28, 2014

About the author

Erin Noelle is a Texas native, where she lives with her husband, two daughters, and three fur babies. When she's not reading or writing romance novels, she enjoys winning at cards and board games, awkward people-watching in public places, and doing cartwheels at the most random times. She's usually barefoot, is never without a song in her head, and currently holds the title of World's Best Procrastinator.
Her titles published include the Book Boyfriend Series, Dusk 'Til Dawn Series, Luminous Duet, Fire on the Mountain series, and numerous standalone books that range from New Adult to Contemporary romance. Her books have been a part of the USA Today Bestselling list as well as the Amazon and Barnes & Noble overall Top 100. You can follow her on Facebook @ www.facebook.com/erin.noelle.98, her blog @ www.erinnoelleauthor.com, on Twitter @authorenoelle, and on Instagram @erinnoelleauthor.

Reviews

[Sara · Rating 3 out of 5]

WARNING!! SPOILERS!! WARNING!!

This book is a perfect example of why I don't like "romance" novels.

In all honesty I'm not good with romance, it doesn't draw me in and hold on to my attention the way a good book should. So I usually stay away from these type of books. Can't remember why I started this series to begin with, it was a long time ago.

I do remember I had just gotten into reading, this series was like one of the first 5 books I read. It's also the reason I took a break from reading, after finishing it.

This is where the spoiler come in, so stop reading if you haven't read it yet.

Killing of characters. I understand that death is part of life and therefor is almost always featured in all books and movies, in some way. After all everyone has lost someone. The reason the death in this book bothered me so much is because I feel it's part of a larger, problem in books, movies and even tv show. The shock factor. The angst factor. The wanting to break the reader/viewers heart just because they can.

To me though, killing off a character has to be done a certain way. While other ways just simply pisses me off. Killing a character just to kill them off, without it improving the plot. I think everyone has read or watched something where you just knew someone was gonna die, and it's okay because it's necessary to further the plot or to evolve another character.

I'm fine with those kind of deaths. Like I said they're necessary.

The death in this book was completely unnecessary. I honestly feel like it was done simply to justify who the main character ended up with. And that just screams lazy. In a book which plot revolves around who the girl ends up with, it's the authors job to justify and make me see why the boy she chooses is the right decision even if it's not the boy I wanted her to choose. If an author can't justify a characters decision, then they've failed at the very point of storytelling. Living vicariously through a character. And a reader/viewer can't do that if they relate to the characters way of thinking.

Killing off one of the boys is just stupid. It actually made me so angry I quit books for a couple months. I don't appreciate having my heart toyed with just because the author can.

Every author has the right to break my heart, to a certain extend it's part of their job. Doesn't mean they should.

I might be the only one feeling this way, or maybe I'm to protective of my heart. All I know is this series was ruined for me because of this. And I now try and stay away college romance, angsty just for the angst kinda books.

If an author wants to break my heart they have to earn the right to hold my heart in the palm of their hand before they squeeze it. And this book did not manage to do that.

End of rant!!

[Samantha · Rating 5 out of 5]

Best. Ever.

I adore this series. there are a few grammar and spelling errors, but the story completely takes those downsides away. I fell in love with Ash & Mason instantly!! where is my Mason!? ;) love this! get it quick!

[Eileen · Rating 5 out of 5]

Absolutely wonderful roller coaster: go for a ride

Just like they say, just read it! Don't read any synopsis just dive in and enjoy, thank you to my book buddy Melissa for the recommendation. Wish I could give this series 10 stars!

[Kristin Reads · Rating 4 out of 5]

I honestly don't know if this series could have ripped my heart out any more that it did.. This was an up and down ride of emotions from book one... This book was definitely a page turner, and I could not put this down.I loved the way the author wrote in multiple POV.

I really have so many emotions this book brought out. Frustration, Love, heartache, doubt, and sometime it was painful for me to continue. I feel in love with many characters in this book. But with all good books there is always an element of surprises and situations that cause you to hold your breath and think to our self.. Did that really just happen?

This book is about watching a girl go through trails and tribulations, while learning how to love herself first. I really wanted for her to stand on her own and not depend on others to give her happiness... I loved both Rat and Ash...

The only reason this book did not get a full 5 stars, is because it did not end how I wanted it to end..Even though it was still a great ending. Great Series. Really enjoyed this book.. But holy moly heartbreak city.

[Marta · Rating 4 out of 5]

Liked the book, it was sweet (sometimes to sweet), funny, sexy an sad. BUT the editing really sucked, thats why I'll give it 3,5⭐️

[Michelle · Rating 1 out of 5]

I should've quit after book one.
Metamorphosis: Scarlett was an immature, indecisive, manipulative brat. She used everyone. Dylan dropped off without another word. The situation with Evie was obvious from her first ailment. I lied Ash instantly. I knew he was deep and loving and smart and amazing. He deserves his own book. Not to be caught up in the Venus fly trap that was Scarlett. And Mason, I did like him but not for Scarlett. He was obsessed and caught up in her web of crazy selfishness. I hated the way this book ended.
The side characters were all good and I added just enough to the book.

Ambrosia: all I can say in poor Ash he is so amazing. I love this guy. He is true and genuine. Mason was just never right in my eyes. That relationship was just off. I was so happy his band moved giving Scarlett space. I was elated with her finding her way to happiness she was running from since day 1. I liked where this was going. And then she runs off AGAIN. Ugh. This girl is so full of conflicting emotions it is obnoxious. Take a break and spend sometime alone and figure yourself out instead of using and abusing those around you. She contradicted herself Everytime she opened her mouth or had any thoughts at all. She was so weak.

Euphoria: nothing about this book was Euphoric. Masons behavior was down right pathetic and juvenile, you can't always get what you want. But this selfish garbage bag will take whatever he can get. It made me sick to think there was a beautiful ending ripped away. I cried when loss happened again. Not for Scar but for the beautiful life lost and how that beautiful spirit would be disregarded and disrespected an forgotten before long. I was hoping it was a dream sequence but no such luck Knowing who she would eventually turn to. Made me angry I was disgusted and completely let down. And we never got closure, the book skips large spans of time and totally ignores that entire life altering event. What a bite off "when it rains" by lisa De Jong with the soulmate vs true love. However that was written so beautifully that it worked. It was sweet and kind. Not the debacle that this was. I absolutely loathed Euphoria. What guy takes second best after being demolished twice already. And what ever happen to the engagement ring That was purchased after she skipped town? I was never mentioned.

Timeless. I wish I got the time back I used to read this series. It was pointless. I didn't care how They got to their HEA. Scarlett still whined and seemed unsure of her HEA even after all the years had passed. All their friends were completely forgotten, even her BFF and one true love who she couldn't breathe without were mentioned once. I know she named her kids after them but come on. It was just crap.

The writing was not detailed, except for the sex scenes and Scarlett's indecision. Other than that it felt very brief. I'm sorry but it was just all a big no for me.

[Bozica · Rating 5 out of 5]

This series had ALL the feels and if you love a good love triangle, angst, swoony hero’s and a heroine who you see mature and grow with each book then this series is for you.

It ripped my heart out more than once and I loved it!

[Kari · Rating 4 out of 5]

This one was a tough read for me emotionally. Believe it or not, I'm still reeling from it and i finished it last night. Each book had me pulled in different directions when it came to Mason and Ash. And in the end while her choice was perfect for her in everyway, the way it happened made me feel so much pain for everyone. Sure happily ever after but I'm left feeling so depressed after reading it. Scarlet had to grow on me because for a while I didn't care for her very much.

Great series but a little too much typos whuch ended up being a bit distracting.

3.5-4 stars

[Ashley · Rating 2 out of 5]

I too bought this on sale because I had been wanting to read it for awhile.

I'll admit, I didn't get even halfway through the first book. Insta-love, ugh. The over the top ness of everything including Scarlett's parents and the way she and Evie talked about everything drove me crazy. Add in three guys who all fall madly in love (instantly!) with shy, sheltered Scarlett, and I was done.

DNF.

[Melanie Holtz · Rating 5 out of 5]

It was always Scarlet and Mason....

From the very beginning of their relationship, for me...there was no one else for Scarlet but Mason...I loved this book from beginning to end. Death is a part of life and moving forward is difficult for anyone to do, but it’s also a part of life that is expected because we are all just on this earth to live for a reason, when that reason is done....

[Beach Bums Romance · Rating 5 out of 5]

I’ve never been on such an emotional roller coaster with a book in m life! I’ve never ugly cried with one either until this one! This is my first time to read anything by this author & it was absolutely wonderful! Can’t wait to read another by her!

[DCT · Rating 4 out of 5]

This series has been on my Kindle for a while now, and I'm not sure why I haven't started it sooner, but for some reason, the time is now. I so enjoyed MILF by this author, so I am aquatinted with her talent, so I just tried to emerse myself into the story. First I have to say that I typically can't stomach love triangles, and I usually am light on the angst; so of course, this series is going to stretch me past my limits. Okay, so for my impressions, I can definitely see why both men are so appealing; they both have a certain charm and charisma that make them both lovable, sexy and unique, so I can relate to Scarlett's dilemma. However, what I couldn't relate to was the woman in question, Sam aka Angel, aka Butterfly/Psyche. Her behavior often frustrated me. I was glad to see that at least she could acknowledge that her behavior towards Mason near the end was somewhat similar to what she perceived as Ash's behavior/actions towards her. I have no idea where this is headed, but my gut tells me that it going to be a long, angsty, frustrating ride. I actually got the boxed set with all the series together, so I'm on to Ambroisa, which I understand is the nectar of the gods, so I'm not sure if I will sip it slowly, or if I should be prepared for a big gulp!

OK, I had a feeling this was going to be a wide ride, and I was absolutely, positively correct! First, I am thoroughly enjoying this series, there are so many highs and lows, back and forths that I can barely keep up. But I must say that I have experienced a first with this read; this is the first time that I have so enjoyed a series, yet not care for the heroine, at all. Now I understand that she is extremely young, and had had a sheltered existence prior to leaving for college; but even with all of the mistakes and indecision, and I'm in love with 2 great guys, along with her good friend Max, I'm not seeing many redeeming qualities, so I not feeling that heartfelt connection to Scarlett that makes me want to root for her to find her Prince Charming and live HEA. However, I can understand why she is attracted to our guys, I mean they are perfection. I can hardly wait to see how this is going to play out and see if our girl can settle for just ONE guy; so I'm going to dive right into Euphoria, and I hope that I experience some once I'm done, lol!

WOW, That was not the ending that I had expected!!!! I mean WOW. As I have completed this series (all except for the novella, which I will start next) I felt that Scarlett would finally make a decision, I just didn't think that it would come to pass in the way that it did. I'm still not sure how I feel about the outcome though; I'm still trying to process it. I mentioned after book 2, that I found myself not liking Scarlett very much. I'm not sure if my feelings really changed, but she just became more benign to me, like she was on the periphery of the story, not the main character. But that did not take away from my complete enjoyment of this story, and how it all played out. I am hoping that the sweet little novella will redeem Scarlett for me, and help me have a new appreciation for her. Thank you Erin for this wonderful series.

What a sweet way to wrap up this series! My emotions were on a crazy ride for the very beginning, and I have to admit that my feelings for Scarlett have not been in the affirmative; but it was nice to see this precious little family find joy and happiness in the end. I did love how the author took us through the journey of where this couple had been since Euphoria ended. Overall, this was an enjoyable series.

[Ashley Jasper · Rating 4 out of 5]

I had heard amazing things about this series so when the box set came out I jumped right on it.

Right away I was drawn into the story. I had a bit of trouble connecting with Scarlett but was rooting for her to breakout on her own and learn who she really was. I adored the friendship between Scarlett & Evie. They reminded me a lot of myself & my best friend in the way they interacted with each other.

Right away Scarlett meets Ash and they are drawn to one another in a way neither can describe. He does the right thing, which is let her go and be her own person. Enter Mason. He is the bad boy rocker, tattooed and pierced and he wants Scarlett. They meet one night at a bar where his band is preforming and they also have an instant connection.

Mason & Scarlett build a relationship and all is going well until tragedy strikes and Scarlett's world is torn apart. She doesn't know what to do or where to go. She makes a rash decision that leaves both of the men in her life shaking their head and asking what happened.

Flash forward eight months and Scarlett is back and she wants Mason. Things continue to be fast & furious with these two. All is going well until his band gets a big break. A HUGE misunderstanding leads to the demise of Scarlett & Mason. She goes off the rails again but this time so does Mason. Ash is there to help her pick up the pieces and their relationship is back on again.

Just as Ash & Scarlett are finding their stride, Mason is back and he needs help, badly. Scarlett goes racing to help and leaves Ash wondering if he is going to lose her again. But she knows that Ash is who she should be with and works to make that clear to both guys. As Mason gets his life back on track, his band gets another break and he invites Scarlett to the opening night of the show.

Tragedy strikes Scarlett again and this time she is more lost than ever. She spends quite some time in rehab. This is after her friends force her hand to make sure she gets the help she needs. After her release, she works on herself and finally finds who she is! Along the way, her and Mason reconnect, again, and this time it is the staying kind. Mason and Scarlett, finally and I mean finally find their happily ever after. It took years for them to get to a place where they could be and give the best versions of themselves to the other.

I also enjoyed how much music and literature played a part in the plot. The characters bonded, grew, broke and healed all through music. The book blog devoted to Evie was a great way to keep her character alive. AND let us not forget the amazing scene at the very end at a book signing. It included some of my favorite writers and Erin depicted them perfectly. Scarlett had gained three new "sisters" for the birth of her twins. The name dedication was also very touching. Overall, it was a good series. There was enough drama and angst to keep me reading. However, there were times when I wanted to jump into my kindle and shake some sense into Scarlett.Although it was the first, it will not be the last title I read from this author.

[Ebony · Rating 5 out of 5]

So, I'm reading The Book Boyfriend Series by Erin Noelle and its nothing like I expected. First, let me say that I stayed up until 5:00 in the morning because I couldn't put the book down. I finished the first book in a couple of hours and Evie's death threw me off. Sorry but I don't think I can handle not telling the goods about this book. So, if you haven't read the book or are in the midst of reading and don't want to know what happens.... STOP READING NOW. LIKE RIGHT NOW. DON'T GO PAST THIS WORD.... Ok, so now that I've warned you that this is indeed a SPOILER ALERT, I'm going to continue. (I'm still giving you time to back out!!!! That was your cue!) Anyway, at first I wanted Scarlet to be with Ash, then I fell for Mason and I felt like he truly loved her. Then the little slut slept with Max, God help her, she's so confused. But now she has this little fling going on with Ash again and it just seems so perfect, you know? She's spending time with his family and everything. I just wonder when is he going to tell her about the engagement ring he bought her. I completely forgot about Dylan, poor Dylan, I never wanted them to be together anyway. He was such a bore! Well I'm only halfway through the second book. So I'm sure you will hear from me again soon. I pray to the good man above that Scarlet gets her act together quick and doesn't get involved with any other men,

Laters-

book boyfriend series by erin noelle

So I finished the book, and I'm hurt. I'm happy but the book definitely didn't end the way i wanted it to end. Like i warned you above (^^^^^^) this is indeed a spoiler alert. I couldn't keep this book to myself. I'm sorry. Anyway, I have to send my condolences to Ash's family. I was crushed when he died. At first, I did blame Scarlet for his death. Maybe if she didn't leave for Vegas, he wouldn't have went to the beach and drowned. But if she never went to Vegas, then she would have never ended up with Mason. I knew from the start that he loved that girl but I really wanted to see Ash and Scarlet. I'm happy that he turned his life around and Scarlet was right there with him. I also had a feeling that Mason would start falling for Heather but I'm beyond happy that they didn't. That would have crushed Scarlet and I don't think that I could handle that heartache. Well, in the end, Scarlet and Mason got married, Had twins and now live happily ever after. Although I would like to see where Andi and Max end up. Maybe there's a book for that. Who knows?!

[vhaneza · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is ONE HELL of an emotional ride and I LOVE IT!!!

Finding herself lost between LIKE , LOVE AND LUST and moving on to whatever fate gave her in such a young age I truly give her my
100% support and standing ovation.

Though I would prefer milder instances believing an escape for a happy ending for fictional characters, the author just snatches my heart and make it more vulnerable to
a more deeper but loving reality.

Not a fan of "WHY" but "HOW", it further convince me that everything has its own pace and place in time. We meet a special someone for a purpose and that we should
always TREASURE them and enjoy every moment we spent together cause we don't really know when they gonna leave us.

What matter is, we should be always be THANKFUL that they came our way and for giving us a PART of THEM that make us a WHOLE.

Again, my views and perception for a deeper LOVE had gone 2 notches above my expectation hoping that in reality this kind of LOVE exist.

ONE with a wings of a BUTTERFLY... always there to understand... see beyond expectation... accepting without questioning... letting you fly for you to see your own happiness...

The other ONE is with an ANGEL wings... always there to keep you safe and comfort you on your sadness... a strong rock that will shelter and block you to all the harsh winds
that crashes your way... clipped your wings so you can STAY and realized that you will always be LOVE and here you will find HAPPINESS...

In the end, I'm not qualified to judge how any person responses toward LOVE challenges... I just hope that in the end there would never be any "REGRETS" and "IF's" on the choices
that they will be making.

And if ever faced with such DECISIONS in the future, all I will do is to close my eyes and listened to my HEART while whispering a little prayer ... that I will TRUST what HE will be GIVING ME instead of what i'm asking for And WHOEVER it may be...

I WILL BE FOREVER BE THANKFUL AND LOVE HIM WITH ALL OF MY HEART... for he is not a CHOICE but an ANSWERED PRAYED...

[Emily Goodman · Rating 5 out of 5]

There should be an option to purchase more stars in order to review this book. Wow oh Wow. What a great read by Erin Noelle. I actually got Metamorphosis as a freebie. It sat on my TBR list for months... What an idiot I was not to pick up this book sooner. What a great story! This book ranked up there with some of my all time favorites. While I did ugly cry with some unexpected events, there was a lot of great moments within these books that made it all better. I can tell that Erin Noelle at some point had to be a book reviewer (note- I've not researched it) because the best way I can describe the way she writes is to say she if Molly McAdams, Kelly Elliott, Colleen Hoover and Jamie Mcguire all had a book baby they'd have to name her Erin Noelle and the book would be this series. I was immediately sucked into the premise of Scarlett and Evie using their book boyfriends to search for a real guy. Noted, I am very upset they didn't explore this a little further just because it's a great idea. This book had just enough emotional ups and downs, steamy love scenes, and love triangles that make it awesome. I loved her humor, the banter between characters and how the story was absoslutely believable. I loved how she talked about the other books that Scarlett was reading and the music that went along with the books. Having read most of the books that were mentioned it helped me identify more with Scarlett, having know how I felt reading those exact same books. With that being said, it was hard not to compare one book in particular because it was a little similar to this series. I felt like one of the biggest moments of the series was a little less anticlimatic in comparison to the other book. If you want a story about a girl who is honestly in love with two men at once, each good for her for all the right reasons, this book is for you. Overall, this series is a great read. One I will definately read again! Hope you enjoy the Book Boyfriends as much as I did!

[Tiffany · Rating 4 out of 5]

**I was gifted a copy of this book**

"I also realize that there's a difference between soul mates and true love. Looking at the surface, they are similar but when I dug deep down inside, I found they were different."

This series absolutely wrecked me!!! Lots of angst, heartbreak and loss, even after reading spoilers and knowing how the series would end (I had to after Scarlett met Mason), I still struggled to get through it. Scarlett had been sheltered her entire life until going off to college with her best friend where she finally gets a taste of freedom. She meets three awesome guys and not knowing how to act with her raging hormones, she seemed to be ready to lose her virginity to either one of them. After one guy leaves this weird equation and the Scarlett, Mason and Ash love triangle gets more dramatic, I found myself bouncing back and forth between the two men because I loved them both. Even though I knew who Scarlett would end up with, I couldn't help but feel the connection between her and both men. Ash was clearly her soul mate but she was also in love with Mason. Many decisions that Scarlett made throughout the series left me heartbroken but as she traveled the road to self discovery, Mason and Ash stuck by her and both continued to love her. By book three, I was an emotional mess and cried throughout most of the story thinking that soon, one of these awesome guys was going to be heartbroken and wondering how and why. Then the unthinkable happened and even though it was devastating, I realized that that was the only ending that made sense.

Overall, this was a great story that left me an absolute mess by the end. Sometimes the road to true love and self love is long and difficult and we all make mistakes. I'm extremely happy with book 4 and the HEA...I fell in love with Mason all over again!! Absolutely perfect names for the children!!!

[Mary Jo · Rating 4 out of 5]

Metamorphosis: Scarlett is spreading her wings and breaking free from her controlling parents. She has rebelled and left home for college much to her parents dismay. Evie is Scarlett's best friend, really her only friend, who has been there during the trials and tribulations of living in her parents' house. She becomes the co-hort in crime to help Scarlett find her way. Enter Asher, drop-dead bad boy that sets off all of Scarlett's bells and whistles but he pushes her away. Then Mason crosses Scarlett's path and a relationship is born. Then the unthinkable happens and the one person she had leaned on let's her down. How will Scarlett recover from this blow?
Ambrosia: Scarlett returns to Houston and works to make amends with her friends. She and Mason rekindle their relationship but Ash has realized he can't live without her so he decides that he won't give up. Communication issues always cause the most drama which pushes Scarlett to make a bad decision and sends Mason off the deep end. Who will survive this latest battle?
Euphoria: Ash and Scarlett are building a strong relationship but Mason needs her help. Can Ash accept Mason as her friend? Will Mason be able to recover from his latest setbacks? Ok, just when I thought Scarlett had found her path to happiness her world is flipped again. How will she survive this latest blow?
Timeless: I don't want to give anything away. Just know that Timeless provides a wonderful wrap-up, letting you into the future lives so that you know just how things end up. It's that cherry on top of the sundae and will make you smile.

[Becky · Rating 3 out of 5]

3.5 + stars. Wow first this box set is an amazing price, second these stories are truly a rollercoaster ride of emotions. These books are definitely about young love, growing and maturing into the mature adults we all become,. It's a story of love and loss, soul mates and true loves, heartbreak and joy, best friends forever, a story of first experiences we all can relate to. I felt like the story could have left out some of the angst between the main characters and it still would have had the same effect on the readers but unfortunately that's what alot of growing up comes with. I laughed, I cried (boy did I ugly cry), I was happy, hot, and cried again.. I can't say to much without giving spoilers away, but oh how I LOVED Ash, he was frustrating in the beginning but his maturity showed thru, he was sexy and smart and just everything and when he told the story of Psyche and Eros I'm pretty sure I fell more in love with him, he can call me butterfly any time sigh... Mason was the hot rocker boyfriend we all have fantasies about dream about and wish we could meet. He's sexy funny and from the start dependable until pushed. Evie and Savannah'S friendship is awesome, sweet and makes you want to call your own BFF and thank her for being in your life!These stories will remind you of your own youth and of growing up even though it's told more dramatically. Read these books and be ready to go through every one of your emotions!!!

[Missy G. · Rating 5 out of 5]

What a roller coaster I have been on with this book! I have been consumed by this story for the last couple of days. I actually went into this book without reading the summary or knowing what it was about. I’m actually really glad I did that. At first I thought the beginning of the book was kind of too good to be true. Basically the coincidences were a bit too frequent and a little unbelievable. That said, it really didn’t bother me because sometimes you just enjoy a story that isn’t too complicated. I was really getting into the book when BAM, all of the sudden the emotions hit me from left field! This book was so unexpectedly good. From start to the very last page I enjoyed the entire store. So without giving too much away the story is about a girl who finally breaks away from her parents clutches to go to collage with her best friend. She has been sheltered from everything, so every experience is a new one. She takes us on her journey of discovering herself, Love, and loss, and every other emotion under the sun. There is a battle for her affection by two guys. But be warned, it will be almost impossible to pick a favorite.

Jan 2021:
Just reread this series and I fell in love with it all over again. I agree with my above review, but I think the second time around I had a favorite, lol. However, no matter who she ended up with would have been ok with me. I would totally recommend this book!

[Jan · Rating 4 out of 5]

Loved the drama in this series & it was hot!.

Two girls setting up on there own starting college Scarlett who is the main character has been pretty much cocooned by her parents, never had a boyfriend and never had a social life except spending time with her best friend Evie her neighbour.

Both the girls love to read romance so when Scarlett eager to date doesen't even know her type they set a little competition the book boyfriend challenge picking a rocker or another type of character from a book to hook up with.

This only lasts at least three parties because Scarlett who is like a moth to a flame ends up balancing three guys at one point and Evie finds her love too.

Scarlett has heartache and the love of two men in her life throughout this book which keeps you on your toes. I must admit I couldn't put it down and going to bed still thinking about it and wanting to continue as soon as I could the next day.

Only down side the ending dragged I had already read the perfect ending but it went on a little bit and thought it could of gone more in depth of the wedding and just left it at that and maybe a baby announcement just to finish nothing else.

Will look out for more from this author all the books mentioned during the story and other authors was a great touch.

[Sandra Curney · Rating 5 out of 5]

I don't know why I've haven't read this series before now, this was an incredible read. I was in such a book funk until I got thru this series. These books evoked so much emotion from the readers. Erin made me feel every emotion the characters felt.
Scarlett lived a very sheltered life. Never allowed to be a normal teenager. Scarlett and Evie head off to college together, Scarlett cutting the ties of her parents. At college they come up with book boyfriend challenge. Trying to meet every single type of bbf there is. As an avid reader it was fun to see Erin include all the hottest bbf. <3
Scarlett meets Ash, all American boy who has no intentions of settling down. However he feels something deep for his butterfly. Can she be the one to settle him down?
Scarlett than meets Mason, bad boy rocker. She has a strong physical attraction to Mase. She is his Angel. Is it possible to love two different men?
When tragedy strikes, who will help pick Scarlett up? Who will be her shoulder to lean on?
This series is one everyone must read!!!! Once I picked it up I just couldn't stop. Love, happiness, loss and forgiveness is something Erin made sure every reader could feel. Not your normal HEA!

[Sandi Ramirez · Rating 5 out of 5]

You know YOU love an author when you not only buy their boxed set but you also buy their books in singles LOL
Well what really went on was I picked up the box set when it originally came out because of the cover and it was a Texas Author. I got busy and did not read it then and with over 4K books in my library I forgot I had it. Then the first book was offered for free so I picked it up read one chapter was hooked and then quickly one clicked the rest of the books. Right after my laptop died and then in my part of TX Fios was sold to a rat company so I went 3 weeks with no internet but that was fine because it gave me *a super fast reader* time to catch up on all my ARCs and then more (70 books). I discovered this CUTE book cover and remembered OH YES she The author was going to be around the corner from me at a book show so I gotta finish this series fast.

Anyways I will be writing my reviews in a few for each book but long an short ...
OMG One Texas writer who can tell an amazing story that keeps you not only on your toes but squirming in your sheets AND grabbing for the Kleenex. This is the complete box set of all 4 books in one set. Erin Noelle is one of two great authors from Texas that I HIGHLY RECOMMEND!.
This is one set you will NOT be about to put down.

[Beth Slone · Rating 5 out of 5]

OMG What a series it will have crying,happy,mad and ready to throw your kindle and say kindle meet wall. If you haven't read this series you need to. I fell in love with it instantly and could not put it down. When I wasn't reading the series I was thinking about the characters and what was going to happen next. I loved Mason so much he was my favorite character in this series. Scarlett I loved her and was mad at her also.
Scarlett is 18 years old starting her first year of college and is finally out from her controlling parents grip. She can finally make her own choices and live her life. But she has to go through so many obstacles in life that she never expected to have to deal with it at such a young age.
This is the first series by Erin Noelle I have read and I will be reading plenty more by her after this series. Erin Noelle is an AMAZING author. I loved this series so much and can't wait to read more by this author.

[Ivi · Rating 4 out of 5]

All together I loved this series very much and it was fast and fun read.I did have some issues esp.in 2nd book when I want to slap Scarlett more than few times but..
I guess the reason I loved so much this book is also partly personal because some time ago I was in similar situation where I was on crossroads with my pick ; soul mate or true love.My soul mate was my best friend and I loved ( still do)him very much but my husband come along and he become my true love,so yes ,it was very personal for me to read this books.
The other part which I simply love about this book is authors play list. While I was being able to read a book I had my personal movie in my head with sound track and all and this help me a lot to get in the mood and feelings of characters in the book. Like I said it was fun read and I recommend this books to all who are wondering about soul mates and true love.

[Shermaine Dowling · Rating 5 out of 5]

Scarlot and Ash and Mason are some of my book characters. This was such a difficult one to get my head out of because of everything that Scarlet experienced. There were times that I became a little impatient with Scarlet because of some of her decisions with both men, but in the end felt that she made the right choices. I can't imagine having to experience these things she did and was so especially thrilled with the final outcome and the way Erin Noelle filled us in with events at the end in Timeless. Ms Noelle is one of my favorite romance authors, and she certainly fulfilled that role with this series! I had bought the first 3 individually, and then bought the boxed set when it came out, and would gladly share my individual ones with others who need to read the series because it is phenomenal!!!

[Nikki · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book brought you every emotion our little humanly bodies can create. Just when you think you are rooting for it to go one way you find yourself so twisted up and confused thinking you may want it the other way. Erin had a way to put you into each of these characters heads and feel the love and pain they went through. You can be feeling such heart break for one character and jump into the next ones head and be laughing with them. This is an emotional roller coaster and I'd be back in line right after for another ride. I am so happy with the way we ended although my heart still breaks thinking of how we had to get there.

Thank you Erin for a truly captivating story of life, loss and love.

[Raquel · Rating 3 out of 5]

*****Spoilers*****

I don't think i've come across a book that's frustrated me as much as this one not to mention its TOO DAMN PREDICTABLE! I absolutely HATED Scarlett. I wanted her to be with Mason all along ONLY to make him happy but to be honest he deserves much better. She doesn't know what she wants and it really pees me off! She deserves to be ALONE, don't get me wrong I feel bad she lost her best friend and boyfriend but come on!!!!!!! This was such a bad read i ended up skimming most of it just because i wanted it to end!

All in all it sounded a lot like previous reads just thrown together in this book and the author just didn't make it sound convincing at all!

3 Stars is actually quite generous!

[Regina Quinones · Rating 5 out of 5]

This was heart wreking my fav was the third one. When Ash died I started crying and stayed crying for like half hour. I loved the song list at the beginning of each chapter and listening to the playlist while reading gave me the perfect atmosphere! I liked the mention of other books and when they mentioned When it rains (which is my fav book) I went over the Cliff the way the author could adapt the mention of it to what was going on with the story made the waterworks start all over again!!!!
Excellent book excellent story.
The alternate ending I think was to make people happy but I prefer the original one better, it was the breaking point for me.
This book drains you, it's a roller coaster of emotions. Enjoy it!!

[Tammy · Rating 5 out of 5]

Book Boyfriend Series Box Set- Metamorphosis Ambrosia Euphoria Timeless- Erin Noelle-Amazing book series, I will say I was annoyed by Scarlett's immaturity in the beginning but I had to remember she was 18 and grew up in an over protective family she never dated, partied and attended an all girl school. Once at college she really decided to let loose with her best friend. The love triangle between Scarlett, Ashton and Mason is very intense. I cried my eyes out and absolutely loved the novella wrapping up the story Heartbreaking and beautiful.
And fantastic music to go along with each chapter- that was very cool