In C.J. Box’s 25th and newest Joe Pickett novel - “Battle Mountain” – we pick up the pieces of destruction that took place in last year’s book “Three-Inch Teeth”. Dallas Cates and Axel Soledad wreaked havoc and death on Joe and Nate Romanowski’s families, leaving them in emotional tatters.
When “Battle Mountain” begins, Nate is off the grid again and hunting for Soledad, seeking revenge for the man who caused him so much personal pain and loss. Unfortunately, Nate is also realizing his time living on the grid in a civilized manner has made soft and vulnerable, and he needs to find and renew his killer instinct in order to accomplish what needs to be done. This time, Nate realizes that he will need help, and he knows exactly where to go for it…
As for Alex Soledad, he’s not sitting around waiting for Nate to attack. He’s busy on a mission of his own, gathering weapons, ex-military soldiers and anti-government protestors in preparation for an attack on the country’s most powerful military and defense contractors. If he succeeds, Soledad can strike at the heart of America’s highest military leadership.
At the same time the game warden in the county of Twelve Sleep, Wyoming, has been called to meet with Governor Rulon who has a personal favor to ask. Rulon’s got his nephew, Mark Eisele, a job working with an elk-hunting guide near Battle Mountain. The problem is that his nephew and the guide have gone missing. Rulon needs Joe to go find them before word gets out to the press and public that the Governor’s nephew can’t be found. More importantly, before Rulon’s wife and his daughter, Mark’s wife, find out and hold Rulon responsible.
Joe heads out to Warm Springs, where he and the local game warden, Susan Kany, begin their search for the two missing men. Joe is trying to keep things under the radar, but things are not going well for him. Local law enforcement is not believing anything he says, and Susan knows that he’s withholding key information.
What neither Joe nor Nate realize is that both of their paths are headed for an ultimate showdown with their biggest enemy, who will be executing his biggest act of retribution of his own, at Battle Mountain…
I have now finished all 25 of C.J. Box’s Joe Pickett novels (and related short story collection). Most of them binged over the last six months. And what a rewarding this reading experience has been for me. Many hours of fun, thrilling, and emotional connections have been made with Joe, Marybeth, their daughters, Nate, their friends, associates, and supporting characters.
On a personal note, Governor Rulon has been one of my absolute favorites. His fast thinking, always several steps ahead of everyone else, and charismatic no-nonsense attitude in dealing with others makes him so interesting to me. And he serves an important role in both putting Joe in dangerous situations yet also be his biggest political protector.
“Battle Mountain” also introduced two new characters that I hope we get to see again in future books. There’s FBI Special Agent Rick Orr, who’s been tracking Nate’s activities for a while. Usually, FBI agents have played the role of bad guys or spoilers in the series, but Orr seems to be different, a more rebel-type-of government agent that bucks the system and could play a potential role in Nate’s future activities. Who knows. We’ll see. The other one is lawyer, Cheryl Tuck-Smith, a seven-foot-tall lawyer. We don’t learn a lot about her, but her interactions with Nate was interesting. She could also play a role with Nate and Geronimo in future storylines.
Let me add a few comments about why I enjoyed this book and series, and then one constructive piece of feedback about how I felt on the ending of this one.
C.J., Box has done so many wonderful things with these Joe Pickett novels. The plotting, characters, and settings mix together in a masterful recipe in the mystery/thriller genre using a modern western style that delivers a winning formula. In my opinion, his plotting skills are excellent, especially as weaves storylines over multiple books, setting things up in one that will come back and pay off in later books. It made me glad that he had already published over 20 books when I started this series, so I could just pick up the next one after finishing the last one. Unfortunately, now that I’m all caught up, I have to wait a year between each book, and that really sucks. Oh well.
For me, C.J. Box’s strongest skill is his characters, built on the foundation of Joe Picket, his wife, Marybeth, and three daughters, and Joe’s brother from another mother, Nate, who serves as Joe’s physical protector much like Hawk does for Spenser in Robert B. Parker’s classic mystery series. Nate takes care of the things that Joe’s personal code won’t allow him to do. Nate and Hawk are two of my all-time favorite literary characters.
I also want to add that C.J. Box writes some of the strongest female characters. Marybeth is smart, analytical, mentally and emotionally strong. So are her daughters – Sheridan, April, and Lucy – each in their own ways. I am strongly endeared to Sheridan, watching her grow into an independent, headstrong woman and falconer. I love April’s robust spirit after all that she’s been through and suffered from. I would love to see her private investigator role be explored in future books. I also look forward to seeing Lucy’s future, which should be bright and full of potential success.
These characters, their relationships, strengths, weaknesses, challenges, conflicts, and growth, are what drives this series. Their love of family and each other, is the heart of this series. It is C.J. Box’s secret sauce that compels his readers to keep coming back over and over again to find out what happens next to them. Joe’s family is our family. Nate’s battles are our battles. Joe and Marybeth’s daughters are our daughters. What happens to them, happens to us. It is personal. And that is the magic C.J. Box delivers to us. It’s why I keep coming back.
My only complaint about “Battle Mountain” is that I feel like C.J. Box was short when it came to the book’s ending.
** WARNING – BRIEF SPOILERS FOLLOW ** ** WARNING – BRIEF SPOILERS FOLLOW **
There were several storylines that were missing their payoff moments. For example, I loved Sheridan’s moment of strength with Sherriff Bishop, but the outcome of their interaction is not shown, takes place offscreen, and is only referenced to briefly. I felt robbed of not experiencing that moment directly, as well feeling like that part of the storyline was set-up and then just dropped at its most crucial moment. Also, Nate’s reunion with his daughter is also offscreen and only referenced to briefly. I also felt robbed of not experiencing that moment directly. Missing the emotional payoffs left me feeling letdown and disappointed. Maybe that’s just me, but after such emotional set-up it feels wrong not to get the payoff side of it.
** END OF BRIEF SPOILERS ** ** END OF BRIEF SPOILERS **
Overall, this was a strong 5-star rating until the end. Per my comments on missing out on two of the emotional payoffs, I am knocking it down half-a-star to 4.5-stars. I realize that this rather immaterial and may come across as petty to some readers. If so, I understand. I am still loving “Battle Mountain” and the Joe Pickett series, which has easily become one of my favorites.
Now, I just have to sit back and wait a year until the next one comes out… That feels like a long time from now…