This is my sixth Alan Gratz book, and, although it uses the same basic formula that has made his prior books enjoyable to one degree or another, I have to say this was my least favorite.
The premise was effective enough: The life of seventeen-year-old Kamran is turned upside down when his older brother is accused of being a terrorist. The early parts of the book are very suspenseful and moving as we watch the struggles Kamran and his family go through with the negative media attention and the resulting loss of their community ties. The action and stakes are amped up even further when the CIA grabs them in the middle of the night and locks them up in separate cells for agonizing weeks.
After that, the story gets more and more far-fetched, one crazy, unlikely Mission Impossible episode after another. Sure, there’s a lot of excitement, it’s just accompanied by a lot of eye rolling, and, in my case, mutterings of things like, “There is no way that would happen”. Also, I have to wonder why Gratz felt the need of including the low-blow comparison of Lindsay Lohan to a cockroach? Seems unnecessary and mean spirited.
Middle school and early high school readers will probably enjoy it more than I did as they see a protagonist about their age struggle against impossible odds. And it has some useful life lessons along the way that will be good for all readers to encounter and consider.
When I was still teaching, I frequently recommended Gratz’s books to students. Once a student even gave me a gift of one of Gratz’s autographed books, something I treasure. So overall I’m a Gratz fan, just not so much of this one that stretched the bounds of believability too many times.