3.5
“Still waters, by and large, do not last. But rivers—rivers flow forever.”
now i didn’t HAVE to read this book to grade my students’ essays (in fact everyone, even the dean! told me that i should just skim it) but for the suffering i went through last year, i thought i would STOP 🙅🏽♀️🙅🏽♀️🙅🏽♀️ the cycle of violence and be the bestest TA i could be, which involves reading their three hundred page assigned summer book. pursuing altruism is such an exhausting experience LMAO.
anyway when i was a chapter in, my only thought was MAN! this woman can WRITE! and that thought remained throughout the entire read. this was really engaging and the paperback had a hefty weight in my hands as i made my way though highlighting so many lines that i enjoyed. and truly i highlighted SOOO many lines like my god! this woman can write!!! i have read an overload of hard scientific articles these past few months, this past year even, that it feels so beautiful to be surprised with this after expecting more of a scientific heavy read. the literary devices, the figurative language, the descriptions? ohh so good. the second person pov switch to open chap 8???? okay. i did NOT know bruno’s game like that!!!! i’m honestly jealous that my required summer reading for seminar was nowhere near this fun (obligatory mention that my summer reading pick WAS good. and i got to talk to the author about his work too but that was still homework to me, THIS? this is like enjoyable! i never highlighted shit in my copy of nature’s best hope!)
now, as a non new jersey native, figuring out where the hell we were talking about was a constant battle (shoutout to that map in the beginning she was carrying my understanding on her BACK) but it didn’t necessarily take away from the enjoyment. this read is part memoir, part historical account, and part scientific writing, and while it may sound like a mess, the straddling of various topics actually strengthens the novel and engages the reader more. the third chapter on dioxin genuinely had me 😨😨😨. in bringing her experiences in, centering the novel on her tumultuous journey of reacquainting herself with the passaic of her childhood and in turn dissecting the highs and lows of her life, mary bruno ensures that this book feels less academic and more personal—emphasizing a call to action more effective than your typical environmental read.
chapters 3 and 8, to me were the STRONGEST parts of this book in regards scientific discussion, historical account, and personal memoir (they’re also some of the longest!) but overall, it’s really such a good read. i will say this book would have benefitted from some pictures which sounds ridiculous and anti intellectual but some of the imagery in this novel painted such a beautiful scene, some of these descriptions are so visceral and SINCE they’re talking about real life events, i feel like a visual representation of some of the events she’s talking about would have been AMAZINGG. pictures of the river interspersed alongside her journey would have killed! but i have the documentary for that so it’s fine i guess ive heard it’s just as beautiful as these descriptions..
thankfully i’m not the one who had to write an essay based on a prompt for this novel (i did my time!) so i have no further thoughts…besides the prevailing how the fuck am i going to grade twenty something essays about this book..well! that’s a problem for later.
“If I listen carefully I can almost hear the river breathing. It is alive. Still. Always.”
“Behold the mighty Passaic, I thought as I clicked the shutter. Remember it.”