What do you think?
Rate this book
The Cut of the Moon
A startling mystery and a longing for love link two women, a century apart, in a haunting novel about family secrets by the Amazon Charts bestselling author of The Lost Letters of Aisling.
Jewelry designer Lindsey McKenna is thrilled to be working at an antique exhibit at a local landmark that has been her the Wind Thorne estate. During the 1920s, it roared. Until an unsolved murder shadowed its legacy. Today, restored as a museum, Wind Thorne draws crowds of visitors to upstate New York. When one of them approaches Lindsey with an old diary, Lindsey is drawn deeper into Wind Thorne’s storied past.
It’s 1925 when young Ruby Thornhill steals her beloved sister’s engagement ring—a naive but heartfelt attempt to stall her upcoming wedding, which Ruby fears will tear the siblings apart. What the theft triggers thrusts Ruby into danger, and with it comes the realization that Wind Thorne is home to potentially inescapable secrets.
Aided by a charming gemologist, Lindsey gradually uncovers Wind Thorne’s history—and to her surprise, her own history as well. Now two young women, nearly a century apart, are righting the wrongs of their family and putting the past, and all its heartbreaking mysteries, to rest.
Jewelry designer Lindsey McKenna is thrilled to be working at an antique exhibit at a local landmark that has been her the Wind Thorne estate. During the 1920s, it roared. Until an unsolved murder shadowed its legacy. Today, restored as a museum, Wind Thorne draws crowds of visitors to upstate New York. When one of them approaches Lindsey with an old diary, Lindsey is drawn deeper into Wind Thorne’s storied past.
It’s 1925 when young Ruby Thornhill steals her beloved sister’s engagement ring—a naive but heartfelt attempt to stall her upcoming wedding, which Ruby fears will tear the siblings apart. What the theft triggers thrusts Ruby into danger, and with it comes the realization that Wind Thorne is home to potentially inescapable secrets.
Aided by a charming gemologist, Lindsey gradually uncovers Wind Thorne’s history—and to her surprise, her own history as well. Now two young women, nearly a century apart, are righting the wrongs of their family and putting the past, and all its heartbreaking mysteries, to rest.
374 pages, Kindle Edition
Published September 16, 2025
427 people are currently reading
3608 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 56 reviews
September 14, 2025
Lindsey McKenna is happy to be helping her Aunt Petra with an opening of the newly restored local landmark Wind Thorne in upstate New York and it’s now a museum. Crowds of people line up to look and explore the estate, Petra has various tables set up and Lindsey is in charge of antique jewellery and next to a gemmologist Otis Allen.
A lady approaches Lindsey, she claims her mother worked as a maid at Wind Thorne and she feels uneasy about her reasons for coming forward.
The dual timeline story is set in present time and starts in the 1920’s and is easy to follow and a century apart.
Wind Thorne was once a thriving cattle ranch, they grew barley and corn and made whisky, until three things happened, an expensive diamond ring went missing, the Great Depression and tragedy struck.
Ruby with her neighbour Chester Mensley start snooping around the property, and they uncover an illegal and dangerous side to her family and this is when things start to spiral out of control.
I received a copy of The Cut of the Moon by Cynthia Ellingsen from NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing in exchange for an unbiased review. I was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed this narrative, at first I dismissed Ruby’s character as immature, especially when she moved to Manhattan, but the more I read and it drew me in and I was hooked.
A mystery about a family’s history, stolen jewellery, greed and lies, bootlegging and prohibition, murder and violation of human rights; with other aspects such as Lindsey’s mothers death and how she wanted to preserve her legacy, her distant relationship with her father and she felt he pushed her away when she needed him the most and favoured her brother and this causes her to have issues with trusting people.
Five stars from me, the perfect read for fans of dual timeline historical fiction with emphasis on old houses and estates and diary’s and paperwork and uncovering hidden secrets and how they unexpectedly link the past to the present.
A lady approaches Lindsey, she claims her mother worked as a maid at Wind Thorne and she feels uneasy about her reasons for coming forward.
The dual timeline story is set in present time and starts in the 1920’s and is easy to follow and a century apart.
Wind Thorne was once a thriving cattle ranch, they grew barley and corn and made whisky, until three things happened, an expensive diamond ring went missing, the Great Depression and tragedy struck.
Ruby with her neighbour Chester Mensley start snooping around the property, and they uncover an illegal and dangerous side to her family and this is when things start to spiral out of control.
I received a copy of The Cut of the Moon by Cynthia Ellingsen from NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing in exchange for an unbiased review. I was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed this narrative, at first I dismissed Ruby’s character as immature, especially when she moved to Manhattan, but the more I read and it drew me in and I was hooked.
A mystery about a family’s history, stolen jewellery, greed and lies, bootlegging and prohibition, murder and violation of human rights; with other aspects such as Lindsey’s mothers death and how she wanted to preserve her legacy, her distant relationship with her father and she felt he pushed her away when she needed him the most and favoured her brother and this causes her to have issues with trusting people.
Five stars from me, the perfect read for fans of dual timeline historical fiction with emphasis on old houses and estates and diary’s and paperwork and uncovering hidden secrets and how they unexpectedly link the past to the present.
September 21, 2025
3.5 Stars
One Liner: Starts with a bang but drags halfway through
1925
Young Ruby Thornhill’s life changes forever after her elder sister’s pre-wedding party. When she steals the diamond engagement ring, she doesn’t realize it will lead to so many consequences.
Present Day
Data analyst (and jewelry designer) Lindsey McKenna is in two minds about the antique exhibition at Wind Throne. The estate has a dark history – someone murdered the family living there in the 1920s. Today, it has become a museum, but the mysteries remain: who killed them, and where is the missing diamond ring?
The story comes in Ruby and Lindsey’s third-person POVs.
My Thoughts:
Though I don’t remember, I read one of the author’s books, The Choice I Made, and rated it well. Since I liked the premise of the current book, I decided to grab a copy.
The dual timeline comes in alternate chapters, and I was initially intrigued by both. The beginning is slow, but the story gradually picks up pace. It is by no means fast-paced, but it does gain momentum after a point.
However, the story began to drag in the second half. Though a lot was happening in the past timeline, it didn’t seem like there was enough progress. In fact, both main characters tended to go around in circles for different reasons.
The book deals with a range of themes – privilege, life from the mid-1920s and early 1930s in the US (bootleggers as well as the stock market crash, etc.), loss of a parent, dysfunctional families, father-daughter relationship, love, and more.
There are some parallels in both main characters and their journeys. This was interesting to an extent. However, some sudden developments (in the present timeline) didn’t feel seamless. They appeared more like a way to give the track a hopeful ending and diluted the impact. Also, certain actions by the characters were mostly for the plot to move forward in a specific manner (which affects character development).
In the past timeline, it was rather a surprise to learn that Ruby was fifteen when we first met her. I thought she was nine or eleven at the most! The extent of naivety is then and later often made me wonder how she managed to survive the way she did. No doubt, it was because of others who stepped in when she was so clueless!
The writing is enjoyable, though there were moments in the second half when I lost interest and just wanted the book to end. I feel the book would have been more entertaining if it were at least 30 pages shorter. Also, there is no epilogue!
To summarize, The Cut of the Moon is an intriguing drama in a dual time, dealing with some serious themes. While it has many good moments, I can’t say I liked it a lot. However, I do recommend the book if you are into this genre and don’t mind the slow pace.
Thank you, NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing, for the eARC. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book.
#NetGalley
***
In the process of shifting from my blog to Medium for book review posting.
Check out the review here: https://medium.com/@rekha.srivalli/du...
One Liner: Starts with a bang but drags halfway through
1925
Young Ruby Thornhill’s life changes forever after her elder sister’s pre-wedding party. When she steals the diamond engagement ring, she doesn’t realize it will lead to so many consequences.
Present Day
Data analyst (and jewelry designer) Lindsey McKenna is in two minds about the antique exhibition at Wind Throne. The estate has a dark history – someone murdered the family living there in the 1920s. Today, it has become a museum, but the mysteries remain: who killed them, and where is the missing diamond ring?
The story comes in Ruby and Lindsey’s third-person POVs.
My Thoughts:
Though I don’t remember, I read one of the author’s books, The Choice I Made, and rated it well. Since I liked the premise of the current book, I decided to grab a copy.
The dual timeline comes in alternate chapters, and I was initially intrigued by both. The beginning is slow, but the story gradually picks up pace. It is by no means fast-paced, but it does gain momentum after a point.
However, the story began to drag in the second half. Though a lot was happening in the past timeline, it didn’t seem like there was enough progress. In fact, both main characters tended to go around in circles for different reasons.
The book deals with a range of themes – privilege, life from the mid-1920s and early 1930s in the US (bootleggers as well as the stock market crash, etc.), loss of a parent, dysfunctional families, father-daughter relationship, love, and more.
There are some parallels in both main characters and their journeys. This was interesting to an extent. However, some sudden developments (in the present timeline) didn’t feel seamless. They appeared more like a way to give the track a hopeful ending and diluted the impact. Also, certain actions by the characters were mostly for the plot to move forward in a specific manner (which affects character development).
In the past timeline, it was rather a surprise to learn that Ruby was fifteen when we first met her. I thought she was nine or eleven at the most! The extent of naivety is then and later often made me wonder how she managed to survive the way she did. No doubt, it was because of others who stepped in when she was so clueless!
The writing is enjoyable, though there were moments in the second half when I lost interest and just wanted the book to end. I feel the book would have been more entertaining if it were at least 30 pages shorter. Also, there is no epilogue!
To summarize, The Cut of the Moon is an intriguing drama in a dual time, dealing with some serious themes. While it has many good moments, I can’t say I liked it a lot. However, I do recommend the book if you are into this genre and don’t mind the slow pace.
Thank you, NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing, for the eARC. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book.
#NetGalley
***
In the process of shifting from my blog to Medium for book review posting.
Check out the review here: https://medium.com/@rekha.srivalli/du...
August 17, 2025
On a dual timeline we meet Ruby and Chester in the 1920's and Lindsey and Otis in present day. The story is set around the Wind Thorne estate, once Ruby's parental home, now a museum run by Lindsey's aunt. When Lindsey gets hold of an ancestral diary, she decides to put her current job on low and concentrate on the family history, soon turning into family mystery.
Both women choose to step out of their comfort zone and into a life filled with obstacles, which adds serious flavor to the story.
The Cut of the Moon deals with forced marriage, human trafficking, bootlegging and the Great Depression, as well as friendship, care and kindness.
There is a good balance between both time periods. The characters are well developed, the writing is attractive and moves at a pleasant pace, the surroundings are fitting. A subtle twist leads to a satisfying conclusion.
Thank you Netgalley and Lake Union Publishing for the ARC.
Both women choose to step out of their comfort zone and into a life filled with obstacles, which adds serious flavor to the story.
The Cut of the Moon deals with forced marriage, human trafficking, bootlegging and the Great Depression, as well as friendship, care and kindness.
There is a good balance between both time periods. The characters are well developed, the writing is attractive and moves at a pleasant pace, the surroundings are fitting. A subtle twist leads to a satisfying conclusion.
Thank you Netgalley and Lake Union Publishing for the ARC.
September 11, 2025
So.... what are the chances of me reading two books in a row where one of the main characters is named "Otis" ??? Very slim to none, I'd guess... but, here we are! Two books. Two Otis' !!
Let me also start by saying that I LOVE Dual Timeline books, and this one did NOT disappoint in the least!!!
We start out in 1925 (I think) and go all the way through to 1933 or so...
And the other timeline is listed as 'present day'.
Ruby is living with her family on a farm. She is a very curious young girl who tries to 'record' everything that happens by writing it down in a journal. And now, her older sister is getting married. BUT, she's not sure that she likes the boy as he argued with her sister AND made her cry. In Ruby's young eyes... he must be made to pay for this.
And so, she doles out a retribution of sorts to hurt him... but what she doesn't realize is that she has actually changed quite a bit with the one small move that she made... and most probably has changed the course of history in this house... at least for her family.
They are a well-known, well-off, Well-feared farming family that has many in their employ.
And young Ruby is just BEGINNING to see the ways of her family.
Chester is a young boy living in a neighboring farm house. He and his older brother are thick as thieves... and get themselves into trouble quite often... as young boys often do.
And when he plans to 'escape' the life he lives, well, Ruby is thinking this might just be something she wants as well.
Fast forward about a hundred years and we have Lindsey, who is trying to uncover some secrets from The Wind Thorne Mansion that happened over a hundred years ago. She is a jewelry designer, kind of following in her later mother's footsteps, and is so happy to be working at the exhibit at the Wind Thorne Estate!! When an old diary is discovered, she is hoping to find some news from the past... as well as maybe, uncovering some old secrets too!!
Otis is a gemologist. He is also working at the exhibit at Wind Thorne, and he and Lindsey immediately hit it off! So they begin to 'kind-of' work together...
But, the more they uncover, the more they seem to need-to-know, as they are lost as to what the heck happened in this house all those years ago!!!
Family. Friendships. Neighbors. Love. War. Longing for Peace. and... Back-ways and old-time-thoughts accompany them on their journey too....
What an amazing book that incorporates two centuries, many generations, and a few families into one story!!!
#TheCutOfTheMoon by @CynthiaEllingsen and narrated beautifully by @AlexandraRyan! And yes, I am shocked to see that this was only ONE NARRATOR!!!! WOW!! Wonderful performance!! I had NO idea!!!!
All the stars for me, and then some!!!! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟✨✨✨✨✨💫💫💫💫💫
*** THIS HAS NOT BEEN RELEASED YET!!! LOOK 👀 FOR IT SOON!! RELEASE DATE IS 9/16/25!! ***
Thanks so much to #NetGalley, #BrillianceAudio and #BrilliancePublishing for an ARC of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review.
You can find my reviews on: Goodreads,
Insta @BookReviews_with_emsr and/or
My Facebook Book Club: Book Reviews With Elaine
Thanks so much for reading! And if you ‘liked’ my review, please share with your friends, & click ‘LIKE’ below… And, let me know YOUR thoughts if you read it!! 📚⭐️
Let me also start by saying that I LOVE Dual Timeline books, and this one did NOT disappoint in the least!!!
We start out in 1925 (I think) and go all the way through to 1933 or so...
And the other timeline is listed as 'present day'.
Ruby is living with her family on a farm. She is a very curious young girl who tries to 'record' everything that happens by writing it down in a journal. And now, her older sister is getting married. BUT, she's not sure that she likes the boy as he argued with her sister AND made her cry. In Ruby's young eyes... he must be made to pay for this.
And so, she doles out a retribution of sorts to hurt him... but what she doesn't realize is that she has actually changed quite a bit with the one small move that she made... and most probably has changed the course of history in this house... at least for her family.
They are a well-known, well-off, Well-feared farming family that has many in their employ.
And young Ruby is just BEGINNING to see the ways of her family.
Chester is a young boy living in a neighboring farm house. He and his older brother are thick as thieves... and get themselves into trouble quite often... as young boys often do.
And when he plans to 'escape' the life he lives, well, Ruby is thinking this might just be something she wants as well.
Fast forward about a hundred years and we have Lindsey, who is trying to uncover some secrets from The Wind Thorne Mansion that happened over a hundred years ago. She is a jewelry designer, kind of following in her later mother's footsteps, and is so happy to be working at the exhibit at the Wind Thorne Estate!! When an old diary is discovered, she is hoping to find some news from the past... as well as maybe, uncovering some old secrets too!!
Otis is a gemologist. He is also working at the exhibit at Wind Thorne, and he and Lindsey immediately hit it off! So they begin to 'kind-of' work together...
But, the more they uncover, the more they seem to need-to-know, as they are lost as to what the heck happened in this house all those years ago!!!
Family. Friendships. Neighbors. Love. War. Longing for Peace. and... Back-ways and old-time-thoughts accompany them on their journey too....
What an amazing book that incorporates two centuries, many generations, and a few families into one story!!!
#TheCutOfTheMoon by @CynthiaEllingsen and narrated beautifully by @AlexandraRyan! And yes, I am shocked to see that this was only ONE NARRATOR!!!! WOW!! Wonderful performance!! I had NO idea!!!!
All the stars for me, and then some!!!! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟✨✨✨✨✨💫💫💫💫💫
*** THIS HAS NOT BEEN RELEASED YET!!! LOOK 👀 FOR IT SOON!! RELEASE DATE IS 9/16/25!! ***
Thanks so much to #NetGalley, #BrillianceAudio and #BrilliancePublishing for an ARC of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review.
You can find my reviews on: Goodreads,
Insta @BookReviews_with_emsr and/or
My Facebook Book Club: Book Reviews With Elaine
Thanks so much for reading! And if you ‘liked’ my review, please share with your friends, & click ‘LIKE’ below… And, let me know YOUR thoughts if you read it!! 📚⭐️
September 14, 2025
An engaging story that takes place in two time periods. The contemporary story is of a niece who is helping her aunt with the family estate. The earlier timeline is of what happened in that house, the secrets that were hidden for years, and eventually how the house came to be in the aunt’s possession. It’s also a story of romantic love and family love: expectations, belonging, being valued (or not), and what we leave behind.
The audiobook narration is good and the pacing between the timelines worked for me. It read like a mystery puzzle from the past that the contemporary characters worked to figure out from letters, diary entries, and etched and carved marks.
My thanks to the author, publisher, @BrillianceAudio, and #NetGalley for early access to the audiobook of #TheCutoftheMoon for review purposes. Publication date: 16 September 2025.
The audiobook narration is good and the pacing between the timelines worked for me. It read like a mystery puzzle from the past that the contemporary characters worked to figure out from letters, diary entries, and etched and carved marks.
My thanks to the author, publisher, @BrillianceAudio, and #NetGalley for early access to the audiobook of #TheCutoftheMoon for review purposes. Publication date: 16 September 2025.
September 16, 2025
Vivid, enchanting, and immersive!
𝐓𝐇𝐄 𝐂𝐔𝐓 𝐎𝐅 𝐓𝐇𝐄 𝐌𝐎𝐎𝐍 is a spellbinding, mysterious tale set in both 1920s New York and the present day, which takes you into the lives of two unforgettable women. Lindsey, a young jewelry designer who, after discovering the existence of an old diary, endeavours to delve deep into the shadows of her family’s complicated history, and Ruby, a spirited young woman who, after stealing her sister’s engagement ring and fleeing her ancestral home, sets off an unfortunate chain of events that ultimately leads to tragedy.
The prose is rich and smooth. The characters are layered, daring, and unyielding. And the plot is a captivating tale full of suspicious figures, perilous pursuits, hidden truths, deception, murder, and the glittering allure of gemology.
Overall, 𝐓𝐇𝐄 𝐂𝐔𝐓 𝐎𝐅 𝐓𝐇𝐄 𝐌𝐎𝐎𝐍 is another mesmerizing, atmospheric, beautifully crafted novel by Ellingsen that is entertaining, nostalgic, and deeply intriguing.
𝐓𝐇𝐄 𝐂𝐔𝐓 𝐎𝐅 𝐓𝐇𝐄 𝐌𝐎𝐎𝐍 is a spellbinding, mysterious tale set in both 1920s New York and the present day, which takes you into the lives of two unforgettable women. Lindsey, a young jewelry designer who, after discovering the existence of an old diary, endeavours to delve deep into the shadows of her family’s complicated history, and Ruby, a spirited young woman who, after stealing her sister’s engagement ring and fleeing her ancestral home, sets off an unfortunate chain of events that ultimately leads to tragedy.
The prose is rich and smooth. The characters are layered, daring, and unyielding. And the plot is a captivating tale full of suspicious figures, perilous pursuits, hidden truths, deception, murder, and the glittering allure of gemology.
Overall, 𝐓𝐇𝐄 𝐂𝐔𝐓 𝐎𝐅 𝐓𝐇𝐄 𝐌𝐎𝐎𝐍 is another mesmerizing, atmospheric, beautifully crafted novel by Ellingsen that is entertaining, nostalgic, and deeply intriguing.
September 26, 2025
I have been on a tear lately, this being my thirteen book read in the last month and a half. I enjoyed the back and forth between the past and present day. The author successfully built suspense in the latter half of the book, where I couldn’t predict what would happen next. This book reminded me of Sea of Tranquility (without the time travel), as I operated under limited context clues and missing history keeping my guessing and interested throughout the book. Recommend.
May 13, 2025
Book Review: The Cut of the Moon by Cynthia Ellingsen
The Cut of the Moon is a lyrical and emotionally resonant novel that deftly explores themes of generational trauma, feminine resilience, and the cyclical nature of history. Cynthia Ellingsen crafts a dual-timeline narrative that weaves together the lives of two women—a contemporary anthropologist grappling with personal loss and her enigmatic ancestor who survived the brutal witch trials of early America. The novel stands out for its meticulous historical research, psychological depth, and evocative prose that blurs the boundaries between past and present.
Ellingsen demonstrates particular skill in her structural execution. The parallel narratives mirror each other with precision, creating a haunting echo effect that reinforces the novel’s central thesis about inherited pain. The historical sections are rendered with vivid sensory detail, immersing readers in the claustrophobic atmosphere of 17th-century Puritan society without resorting to anachronistic moralizing. Meanwhile, the modern storyline offers a thoughtful meditation on how academic women navigate institutional skepticism toward “women’s histories.”
Characterization proves to be the novel’s greatest strength. Both protagonists are rendered with remarkable psychological complexity, their inner lives revealed through subtle gestures and carefully chosen dialogue rather than exposition. Secondary characters—particularly the network of women who form a quiet resistance in both timelines—are equally well-drawn, serving as more than mere foils to the central figures. The novel’s treatment of magic and folklore is especially compelling, presented not as supernatural embellishment but as a tangible expression of female knowledge systems under threat.
If the novel has a weakness, it lies in its occasional over-reliance on familiar tropes of historical fiction. Certain plot developments in the contemporary narrative feel predictable, and the romantic subplot, while sensitively handled, follows a somewhat conventional arc. However, these are minor flaws in what is otherwise an exceptionally crafted work. The climax delivers both emotional catharsis and intellectual satisfaction, tying together the novel’s themes with elegant symmetry.
Overall Rating: 4.6/5
Analytical Scoring Breakdown:
-Historical Authenticity: 5/5 - Impeccable research integrated organically into narrative
-Character Complexity: 4.8/5 - Nuanced protagonists with authentic growth trajectories
-Structural Innovation: 4.5/5 - Effective dual timeline with occasional pacing imbalances
-Thematic Cohesion: 5/5 - Powerful exploration of feminine legacy and resistance
-Prose Quality: 4.7/5 - Evocative language with occasional overwrought passages
Thank you to NetGalley and author Cynthia Ellingsen for providing an advance copy of this compelling novel in exchange for an honest review.
The Cut of the Moon is a lyrical and emotionally resonant novel that deftly explores themes of generational trauma, feminine resilience, and the cyclical nature of history. Cynthia Ellingsen crafts a dual-timeline narrative that weaves together the lives of two women—a contemporary anthropologist grappling with personal loss and her enigmatic ancestor who survived the brutal witch trials of early America. The novel stands out for its meticulous historical research, psychological depth, and evocative prose that blurs the boundaries between past and present.
Ellingsen demonstrates particular skill in her structural execution. The parallel narratives mirror each other with precision, creating a haunting echo effect that reinforces the novel’s central thesis about inherited pain. The historical sections are rendered with vivid sensory detail, immersing readers in the claustrophobic atmosphere of 17th-century Puritan society without resorting to anachronistic moralizing. Meanwhile, the modern storyline offers a thoughtful meditation on how academic women navigate institutional skepticism toward “women’s histories.”
Characterization proves to be the novel’s greatest strength. Both protagonists are rendered with remarkable psychological complexity, their inner lives revealed through subtle gestures and carefully chosen dialogue rather than exposition. Secondary characters—particularly the network of women who form a quiet resistance in both timelines—are equally well-drawn, serving as more than mere foils to the central figures. The novel’s treatment of magic and folklore is especially compelling, presented not as supernatural embellishment but as a tangible expression of female knowledge systems under threat.
If the novel has a weakness, it lies in its occasional over-reliance on familiar tropes of historical fiction. Certain plot developments in the contemporary narrative feel predictable, and the romantic subplot, while sensitively handled, follows a somewhat conventional arc. However, these are minor flaws in what is otherwise an exceptionally crafted work. The climax delivers both emotional catharsis and intellectual satisfaction, tying together the novel’s themes with elegant symmetry.
Overall Rating: 4.6/5
Analytical Scoring Breakdown:
-Historical Authenticity: 5/5 - Impeccable research integrated organically into narrative
-Character Complexity: 4.8/5 - Nuanced protagonists with authentic growth trajectories
-Structural Innovation: 4.5/5 - Effective dual timeline with occasional pacing imbalances
-Thematic Cohesion: 5/5 - Powerful exploration of feminine legacy and resistance
-Prose Quality: 4.7/5 - Evocative language with occasional overwrought passages
Thank you to NetGalley and author Cynthia Ellingsen for providing an advance copy of this compelling novel in exchange for an honest review.
May 9, 2025
The Wind Thorne Estate was up to all sorts of nefarious deeds during the Great Depression - and we get to see them through the eyes of Ruby, the youngest jewel of the glittering Thornhill family. She steals her sister's engagement ring, witnesses the violent death of a servant, and flees to New York... only to have the Depression chase her back home, to the trouble she left behind.
This was so fun to write - I hope you all enjoy it!
This was so fun to write - I hope you all enjoy it!
June 24, 2025
Lindsay McKenna was happy to accept Aunt Petra's invitation to use her jewelry design and metalworking skills at an antique show fundraiser at Wind Thorne. Happy to help her aunt, Lindsay was eager to tour the estate to view the completed renovations. Although it took Aunt Petra some time to accept her inheritance of the estate, she transformed it into a well-regarded museum with care and diligence after it had been abandoned for years due to an unsolved murder. After an unexpected encounter at the antique show, Lindsay couldn't have imagined everything that would happen in the following weeks.
I enjoy novels that intertwine two timelines, linking the contemporary narrative with events from the past. In this novel, the dual narratives are presented in alternating chapters, showcasing unique perspectives from two distinct characters: Ruby, the youngest daughter at Wind Thorne in the 1920s, and Lindsay, who navigates her life in the present day. This book stands out because, unlike many novels with dual timelines where one storyline tends to overshadow the other, both narratives are equally captivating. I found it difficult to put down either one, as each character's journey was compelling and deeply engaging.
The strong characterizations effectively showcase the societal norms of their times, family dynamics, and the various influences of human emotions—from fear and love to betrayal, disappointment, and loss—that shape life's connections and experiences. The depth of intrigue in Present Day is suspenseful, and I never imagined how the twists and turns would culminate, revealing even more about the generational history of Wind Thorne.
I enjoy novels that intertwine two timelines, linking the contemporary narrative with events from the past. In this novel, the dual narratives are presented in alternating chapters, showcasing unique perspectives from two distinct characters: Ruby, the youngest daughter at Wind Thorne in the 1920s, and Lindsay, who navigates her life in the present day. This book stands out because, unlike many novels with dual timelines where one storyline tends to overshadow the other, both narratives are equally captivating. I found it difficult to put down either one, as each character's journey was compelling and deeply engaging.
The strong characterizations effectively showcase the societal norms of their times, family dynamics, and the various influences of human emotions—from fear and love to betrayal, disappointment, and loss—that shape life's connections and experiences. The depth of intrigue in Present Day is suspenseful, and I never imagined how the twists and turns would culminate, revealing even more about the generational history of Wind Thorne.
May 30, 2025
Thanks to Net Galley for the ARC! Cynthia Ellingsen’s The Cut of the Moon is a beautifully woven tale that masterfully combines historical intrigue with modern-day romance. Lindsey McKenna’s passion for jewelry and her work at the Wind Thorne estate immediately drew me in, and I appreciated how the story seamlessly shifts between the 1920s and the present day. The dual timelines are handled with care, revealing layers of family secrets, love, and betrayal that keep you hooked from start to finish. The mystery surrounding Ruby Thornhill’s theft and the subsequent dangers she faces adds a compelling tension that persists throughout Lindsey’s journey of discovery. I especially enjoyed the charm of her relationship with the gemologist—adding both warmth and depth to the story. The Cut of the Moon is a delightful blend of mystery, history, and heartfelt storytelling—well worth the read!
September 15, 2025
Atmospheric, emotional, and twisty with a few pacing issues
Really enjoyed this one! The Cut of the Moon blends mystery, grief, and family drama in a beautifully written, emotionally layered story. Greer is a strong and relatable lead, and the setting Mackinac Island adds a dreamy, almost gothic tone to the story. Loved the slow unraveling of family secrets and the haunting feel throughout.
That said, the middle lagged a bit for me. Some scenes felt repetitive, and a few side characters could’ve used more development. But overall, the story kept me hooked, and the payoff was satisfying.
If you're into moody mysteries with emotional depth (think Tana French lite or Megan Miranda), this one’s worth picking up.
Really enjoyed this one! The Cut of the Moon blends mystery, grief, and family drama in a beautifully written, emotionally layered story. Greer is a strong and relatable lead, and the setting Mackinac Island adds a dreamy, almost gothic tone to the story. Loved the slow unraveling of family secrets and the haunting feel throughout.
That said, the middle lagged a bit for me. Some scenes felt repetitive, and a few side characters could’ve used more development. But overall, the story kept me hooked, and the payoff was satisfying.
If you're into moody mysteries with emotional depth (think Tana French lite or Megan Miranda), this one’s worth picking up.
December 28, 2025
I really loved the past timeline. I did enjoy some of the present timeline as well but I did feel like moments were dragged on, and not fully necessary to the story. I didn’t like the way the present day characters were trying to guess what had happened in the past, when we had just found out what really happened. Overall though I absolutely loved Ruby and Chester, and I feel like the past timeline was written really well!
October 20, 2025
Down, down, down. . . this book started out somewhat interesting then derailed, big-time
I cannot recommend this book. If you must embrace it, read it; do not (I repeat,) do not listen to it. The narration makes a bad book unbearable. I only have myself to blame in that I cannot seem to DNF but must complete a book despite its unworthiness.
I cannot recommend this book. If you must embrace it, read it; do not (I repeat,) do not listen to it. The narration makes a bad book unbearable. I only have myself to blame in that I cannot seem to DNF but must complete a book despite its unworthiness.
October 8, 2025
Thank you Goodreads Giveaways for giving me the opportunity to read this absolutely beautiful story. I was hooked from chapter one and I loved going back and forth between the time periods. I can’t wait to read more of this author!
June 11, 2025
𝒜𝑅𝒞 ℝ𝕖𝕧𝕚𝕖𝕨- 𝕋𝕙𝕖 𝕔𝕦𝕥 𝕠𝕗 𝕥𝕙𝕖 𝕞𝕠𝕠𝕟 💎
Spoilers incoming!
"saying they would be better off in captivity is not true, and it's not right. Slavery has been abolished, and that’s what this is, no matter how you want to frame it."
Hello, my sweet, awful creatures! 🦇
From time to time, I find myself unsure about what to say regarding the book I've read, and once again, I'm at that point. I can truthfully say, however, that I really enjoyed it and would gladly read it again! Let’s dive into this review, shall we?
The story is narrated by two characters across different timelines that are somehow connected. It begins with Ruby, the youngest daughter of the Windthorne family, who finds herself in the middle of a crime scene when a chilling scream echoes through the mansion in 1925, upstate New York.
After Ruby's story, we shift to Lindsey, who is visiting her aunt, the current owner of the Windthorne mansion. During her visit, she encounters a young woman claiming to possess a secret diary that belonged to her mother, who once worked at Windthorne. This unexpected interaction leaves Lindsey intrigued: wouldn't it be fantastic to learn more about the place and uncover her connections to Windthorne?
This book was nothing like I expected—it was so much better! What starts off as a feminist narrative evolves into a deeper exploration of feminism, slavery, romance, and heartbreak.
I was a sucker for Ruby's story!! I could have read the entire book just for her story alone. It was fascinating to witness her transformation and growth as she became more independent during her time in New York, working as the help in one of the wealthier areas. Her connection with Chester developed into something beautiful over time, making me feel all giddy and excited. I'm a slow-burn romance girly so two people falling in love, over time as they help each other out, looking out for each other while slowly realizing that they might be more than friends is so up my alley.
The depiction of slavery was revealed so subtly that when I finally encountered that part, I was shocked to my core! As the story unfolds through Ruby's perspective, we don’t see the darker side of the Windthorne family until Ruby grows into a young woman and realizes how hard the enslaved individuals in their home work. She could have chosen to look away, pretending not to know about their plight, but instead, she decided to fight for their lives and pursue true justice alongside Chester. Is it obvious that they're my favorite characters in this book?
To keep you on your toes, I'll leave you in the dark about Lindsey's story... or should I say her legacy?
Watch out for the release on December 16th this year, and allow yourself to be pulled into this mysterious tale!
Until next time!
Mira 💗
Spoilers incoming!
"saying they would be better off in captivity is not true, and it's not right. Slavery has been abolished, and that’s what this is, no matter how you want to frame it."
Hello, my sweet, awful creatures! 🦇
From time to time, I find myself unsure about what to say regarding the book I've read, and once again, I'm at that point. I can truthfully say, however, that I really enjoyed it and would gladly read it again! Let’s dive into this review, shall we?
The story is narrated by two characters across different timelines that are somehow connected. It begins with Ruby, the youngest daughter of the Windthorne family, who finds herself in the middle of a crime scene when a chilling scream echoes through the mansion in 1925, upstate New York.
After Ruby's story, we shift to Lindsey, who is visiting her aunt, the current owner of the Windthorne mansion. During her visit, she encounters a young woman claiming to possess a secret diary that belonged to her mother, who once worked at Windthorne. This unexpected interaction leaves Lindsey intrigued: wouldn't it be fantastic to learn more about the place and uncover her connections to Windthorne?
This book was nothing like I expected—it was so much better! What starts off as a feminist narrative evolves into a deeper exploration of feminism, slavery, romance, and heartbreak.
I was a sucker for Ruby's story!! I could have read the entire book just for her story alone. It was fascinating to witness her transformation and growth as she became more independent during her time in New York, working as the help in one of the wealthier areas. Her connection with Chester developed into something beautiful over time, making me feel all giddy and excited. I'm a slow-burn romance girly so two people falling in love, over time as they help each other out, looking out for each other while slowly realizing that they might be more than friends is so up my alley.
The depiction of slavery was revealed so subtly that when I finally encountered that part, I was shocked to my core! As the story unfolds through Ruby's perspective, we don’t see the darker side of the Windthorne family until Ruby grows into a young woman and realizes how hard the enslaved individuals in their home work. She could have chosen to look away, pretending not to know about their plight, but instead, she decided to fight for their lives and pursue true justice alongside Chester. Is it obvious that they're my favorite characters in this book?
To keep you on your toes, I'll leave you in the dark about Lindsey's story... or should I say her legacy?
Watch out for the release on December 16th this year, and allow yourself to be pulled into this mysterious tale!
Until next time!
Mira 💗
July 19, 2025
4.5
This was so good. It did take me a little bit to get into it but then I was hooked.
The story goes back and forth between late 1920s and present day. The 1920 storyline follows Ruby. She is a young girl living with her family at Wind Thorne estate. Rubi steaks her sister’s engagement ring to try and stop her sister’s wedding. A few days before the wedding, she sees the dead body of a servant. Ruby is afraid of what happened to the servant. She is also afraid to be left alone with her uncle Peter. Her sister was her only protection from him and she is leaving. She decides to run off with a neighbor boy, Chester. They run off after Chester’s brother Elliot. They run to New York. They stay on New York and work as servants. After the Great Depression hits she goes back home. The present day story follows Lindsey. She is the great granddaughter of the former owners of Wind Thorne. She has returned to help her aunt. Her aunt has been restoring Wind Thorne and is turning it into a museum. They are holding an antiques event and Lindsey, as a former jewelry designer, is going to help. While there she is approached by a woman who says she has a diary written by Ruby. Lindsey is excited and wants to aquire it for the estate. She is also looking for clues. The entire family was murdered shortly after Ruby returns home and the killers were never apprehended.
Ok I loved this one. I loved how the stories went back and forth. Each time line was really interesting. I was rushing to see what happened next. I loved that the first timeline is set in 1920s and the Great Depression. I really love seeing everything thru Ruby’s eyes. I love her descriptions of New York and everything that’s going on. I think the book so really well researched. I loved the relationship between Ruby and Chester. I wish I would have gotten even more detail of their relationship but that’s just me being greedy. Haha
I loved all of the descriptions of the jewelry. I could picture it. It all sounded so beautiful.
I loved how the mystery of what happened to Ruby and her family unravels. I enjoyed the relationship between Lindsey and her aunt.
Overall this was a fun and exciting book. I’m so glad I got to read it and can’t wait til share it with others
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me a digital ARC in exchange for my honest review.
This was so good. It did take me a little bit to get into it but then I was hooked.
The story goes back and forth between late 1920s and present day. The 1920 storyline follows Ruby. She is a young girl living with her family at Wind Thorne estate. Rubi steaks her sister’s engagement ring to try and stop her sister’s wedding. A few days before the wedding, she sees the dead body of a servant. Ruby is afraid of what happened to the servant. She is also afraid to be left alone with her uncle Peter. Her sister was her only protection from him and she is leaving. She decides to run off with a neighbor boy, Chester. They run off after Chester’s brother Elliot. They run to New York. They stay on New York and work as servants. After the Great Depression hits she goes back home. The present day story follows Lindsey. She is the great granddaughter of the former owners of Wind Thorne. She has returned to help her aunt. Her aunt has been restoring Wind Thorne and is turning it into a museum. They are holding an antiques event and Lindsey, as a former jewelry designer, is going to help. While there she is approached by a woman who says she has a diary written by Ruby. Lindsey is excited and wants to aquire it for the estate. She is also looking for clues. The entire family was murdered shortly after Ruby returns home and the killers were never apprehended.
Ok I loved this one. I loved how the stories went back and forth. Each time line was really interesting. I was rushing to see what happened next. I loved that the first timeline is set in 1920s and the Great Depression. I really love seeing everything thru Ruby’s eyes. I love her descriptions of New York and everything that’s going on. I think the book so really well researched. I loved the relationship between Ruby and Chester. I wish I would have gotten even more detail of their relationship but that’s just me being greedy. Haha
I loved all of the descriptions of the jewelry. I could picture it. It all sounded so beautiful.
I loved how the mystery of what happened to Ruby and her family unravels. I enjoyed the relationship between Lindsey and her aunt.
Overall this was a fun and exciting book. I’m so glad I got to read it and can’t wait til share it with others
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me a digital ARC in exchange for my honest review.
September 18, 2025
This is a captivating dual-timeline mystery that keeps readers hooked as it unravels secrets spanning more than a century. At the heart of the story is Lindsey, who becomes determined to uncover the truth behind a missing ring, a quest that pulls her deep into the past while unraveling connections to the present.
Ellingsen crafts the narrative with an engaging back-and-forth between timelines, seamlessly transporting readers from the present day to events that unfolded generations earlier. This structure not only builds suspense but also layers the story with richness and intrigue, allowing readers to piece together the puzzle right alongside Lindsey.
What makes the novel so enjoyable is the balance of mystery, history, and unexpected twists. Just when you think you’ve discovered the truth behind the ring’s disappearance, another secret surfaces, shifting everything you thought you knew. The slow unveiling of hidden motives and buried truths adds depth and complexity, making the mystery more than just about a lost piece of jewelry—it becomes a story about family, legacy, and the echoes of the past.
The twist at the end is both surprising and satisfying, tying together the dual narratives in a way that feels earned and rewarding. It’s the kind of ending that makes you want to revisit earlier chapters to see all the breadcrumbs Ellingsen carefully laid out along the way.
With its elegant prose, strong sense of history, and clever construction, The Cut of the Moon is the perfect read for fans of mysteries with a historical edge. It’s atmospheric, suspenseful, and full of secrets waiting to be uncovered—a story that proves the past is never truly gone, and its mysteries are often closer than they appear.
Ellingsen crafts the narrative with an engaging back-and-forth between timelines, seamlessly transporting readers from the present day to events that unfolded generations earlier. This structure not only builds suspense but also layers the story with richness and intrigue, allowing readers to piece together the puzzle right alongside Lindsey.
What makes the novel so enjoyable is the balance of mystery, history, and unexpected twists. Just when you think you’ve discovered the truth behind the ring’s disappearance, another secret surfaces, shifting everything you thought you knew. The slow unveiling of hidden motives and buried truths adds depth and complexity, making the mystery more than just about a lost piece of jewelry—it becomes a story about family, legacy, and the echoes of the past.
The twist at the end is both surprising and satisfying, tying together the dual narratives in a way that feels earned and rewarding. It’s the kind of ending that makes you want to revisit earlier chapters to see all the breadcrumbs Ellingsen carefully laid out along the way.
With its elegant prose, strong sense of history, and clever construction, The Cut of the Moon is the perfect read for fans of mysteries with a historical edge. It’s atmospheric, suspenseful, and full of secrets waiting to be uncovered—a story that proves the past is never truly gone, and its mysteries are often closer than they appear.
September 25, 2025
This is among one of my favourite types of stories - a dual time line! Not to mention the gorgeous cover that first attracted me!
The first timeline is set in the 1920's. Ruby Thornhill lives with her well-to-do farming family on an estate called Wind Thorne in up-state New York. The family also dabbles in bootlegging. A young Ruby steals her sister's engagement ring in hopes that she won't marry and leave her. On that same night a servant falls to her death down the stairs and Ruby sees the dead body. She runs away from her family with her neighbour Chester who is looking for his older brother in New York City. They both begin to work as servants for a wealthy family but the stock market crashes in 1929 and they are forced to return home to their families. Shortly upon Ruby's return the whole family is killed.
In the present day Lindsey McKenna is a jewellery designer and the Great-Grandaughter of the former owners of Wind Thorne. Her Aunt is now the sole-owner and is restoring the estate with Lindsey's help. While hosting a special event there Lindsey is approached by a lady who says her mother used to work at the mansion. She has an old diary that once belonged to Ruby. Lindsey is intrigued to read it and piece together what happened so long ago. Could the diary hold answers to the still missing ring? Will she discover some old family secrets in the process?
This is a slow-building story that is told very well. The timelines blend seamlessly. If you enjoy a mystery, with a touch of romance and family drama you will enjoy it. Good twist at the end!
Published on September 16, 2025
I'd like to kindly thank NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing for granting me access to this Advance Reader's Copy.
The first timeline is set in the 1920's. Ruby Thornhill lives with her well-to-do farming family on an estate called Wind Thorne in up-state New York. The family also dabbles in bootlegging. A young Ruby steals her sister's engagement ring in hopes that she won't marry and leave her. On that same night a servant falls to her death down the stairs and Ruby sees the dead body. She runs away from her family with her neighbour Chester who is looking for his older brother in New York City. They both begin to work as servants for a wealthy family but the stock market crashes in 1929 and they are forced to return home to their families. Shortly upon Ruby's return the whole family is killed.
In the present day Lindsey McKenna is a jewellery designer and the Great-Grandaughter of the former owners of Wind Thorne. Her Aunt is now the sole-owner and is restoring the estate with Lindsey's help. While hosting a special event there Lindsey is approached by a lady who says her mother used to work at the mansion. She has an old diary that once belonged to Ruby. Lindsey is intrigued to read it and piece together what happened so long ago. Could the diary hold answers to the still missing ring? Will she discover some old family secrets in the process?
This is a slow-building story that is told very well. The timelines blend seamlessly. If you enjoy a mystery, with a touch of romance and family drama you will enjoy it. Good twist at the end!
Published on September 16, 2025
I'd like to kindly thank NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing for granting me access to this Advance Reader's Copy.
September 23, 2025
Thank you NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing for this eCopy to review.
I didn’t expect The Cut of the Moon to be so emotionally layered, but it completely swept me away. Cynthia Ellingsen has crafted a dual-timeline mystery that’s both haunting and heart warming, with themes of family, legacy, and the secrets we carry.
💍 Plot Summary
In the present day, jewellery designer Lindsey McKenna is working at an antique exhibit at the Wind Thorne estate, a place she’s long been obsessed with. When a visitor hands her an old diary, Lindsey is pulled into a century-old mystery that begins in 1925, when Ruby Thornhill steals her sister’s engagement ring in a desperate attempt to stop a wedding she fears will tear them apart.
What follows is a beautifully interwoven story of two women, separated by time but united by love, loss, and a shared determination to uncover the truth. As Lindsey teams up with a charming gemologist, she begins to unravel not only Wind Thorne’s dark history, but her own.
🕰️ What Stood Out
- Atmosphere: Wind Thorne estate is practically a character in itself, elegant, eerie, and full of secrets.
- Dual Timeline: The transitions between Ruby’s 1920s world and Lindsey’s modern-day investigation are seamless and compelling.
- Emotional Depth: The relationships, especially between Ruby and Chester, and Lindsey and Otis are believable, with real stakes and heartbreak.
📔 Final Thoughts
The Cut of the Moon is a rich, evocative mystery that blends historical fiction with emotional storytelling. It’s perfect for fans of Kate Morton or anyone who loves uncovering secrets in old houses.
I didn’t expect The Cut of the Moon to be so emotionally layered, but it completely swept me away. Cynthia Ellingsen has crafted a dual-timeline mystery that’s both haunting and heart warming, with themes of family, legacy, and the secrets we carry.
💍 Plot Summary
In the present day, jewellery designer Lindsey McKenna is working at an antique exhibit at the Wind Thorne estate, a place she’s long been obsessed with. When a visitor hands her an old diary, Lindsey is pulled into a century-old mystery that begins in 1925, when Ruby Thornhill steals her sister’s engagement ring in a desperate attempt to stop a wedding she fears will tear them apart.
What follows is a beautifully interwoven story of two women, separated by time but united by love, loss, and a shared determination to uncover the truth. As Lindsey teams up with a charming gemologist, she begins to unravel not only Wind Thorne’s dark history, but her own.
🕰️ What Stood Out
- Atmosphere: Wind Thorne estate is practically a character in itself, elegant, eerie, and full of secrets.
- Dual Timeline: The transitions between Ruby’s 1920s world and Lindsey’s modern-day investigation are seamless and compelling.
- Emotional Depth: The relationships, especially between Ruby and Chester, and Lindsey and Otis are believable, with real stakes and heartbreak.
📔 Final Thoughts
The Cut of the Moon is a rich, evocative mystery that blends historical fiction with emotional storytelling. It’s perfect for fans of Kate Morton or anyone who loves uncovering secrets in old houses.
September 25, 2025
The Cut of the Moon is a mesmerizing dual-timeline mystery that immediately drew me in. Ellingsen masterfully balances past and present, weaving together Lindsey’s search for truth with Ruby’s heartbreaking choices in 1925. The diary connection between the two women creates a seamless bridge between the timelines. Lindsey’s curiosity and determination made her a character I loved following. Ruby’s story was full of tension, sacrifice, and emotional depth that kept me turning the pages. The Wind Thorne estate was described with such vivid detail that it felt like a character itself, hiding secrets in every corner. Each twist and revelation landed with both suspense and heart. The emotional layers of family, loyalty, and love gave the story incredible richness. I also appreciated how the romance was subtle yet meaningful, adding warmth to the darker themes. This is a haunting, beautifully written novel that will stay with me long after reading.
- Vanesa Gjolaj, Author Of “The Enchanted Manuscript”
- Vanesa Gjolaj, Author Of “The Enchanted Manuscript”
September 9, 2025
This was a fun read with a mix of intense and slower moments. The story took a little while to really pull me in, but once it did, the pages flew by. While much of the plot is predictable, I didn’t mind—it still made for an enjoyable escape. I’d recommend this book as a great vacation read or something cozy for a rainy day.
I listened to the audiobook version, but I think I would have enjoyed the story more if I had read it instead. The narrator, Alexandra Ryan, didn’t quite bring the characters to life for me. The men’s voices, in particular, came across more geeky than charming, and the added crying noises felt distracting when the text only described the action.
Overall, the story itself was entertaining, but if you’re considering it, I’d suggest picking up the print or ebook rather than the audio.
I received a complimentary copy of this audiobook. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own. Thank you to Brilliance Publishing and NetGalley for the ARC.
I listened to the audiobook version, but I think I would have enjoyed the story more if I had read it instead. The narrator, Alexandra Ryan, didn’t quite bring the characters to life for me. The men’s voices, in particular, came across more geeky than charming, and the added crying noises felt distracting when the text only described the action.
Overall, the story itself was entertaining, but if you’re considering it, I’d suggest picking up the print or ebook rather than the audio.
I received a complimentary copy of this audiobook. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own. Thank you to Brilliance Publishing and NetGalley for the ARC.
September 16, 2025
The Cut of the Moon by Cynthia Ellingsen is a beautifully woven story that I thoroughly enjoyed. What stood out most to me was the way the author intertwined the lives of two women across time, connecting their journeys in a way that felt both seamless and meaningful. The dual perspectives added richness to the narrative and kept me fully engaged as each woman’s story unfolded.
The audiobook narration was strong and truly enhanced the listening experience. Each voice brought depth and distinction, making it easy to follow along and connect with both timelines. The pacing felt just right, allowing the suspense, emotions, and revelations to build naturally.
This was a heartfelt and well-crafted story that balanced history, mystery, and emotion. I loved how it all came together, and it left me eager to explore more of Ellingsen’s work.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
The audiobook narration was strong and truly enhanced the listening experience. Each voice brought depth and distinction, making it easy to follow along and connect with both timelines. The pacing felt just right, allowing the suspense, emotions, and revelations to build naturally.
This was a heartfelt and well-crafted story that balanced history, mystery, and emotion. I loved how it all came together, and it left me eager to explore more of Ellingsen’s work.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
September 7, 2025
The Cut of the Moon by Cynthia Ellingsen is an engaging work of historical fiction that weaves together dual timelines—one set in the 1920s–1930s and the other in the present day. I especially loved the strong female leads: Ruby Thornhill in the past and Lindsay McKenna in the present. Watching their growth across time made the story all the more compelling.
Ellingsen captures both the resilience and heartbreak of life during the Great Depression, immersing the reader in a time of hardship and survival. At its core, this is a novel about forgiveness, the weight of consequences, and uncovering long-buried mysteries.
The audiobook narration by Alexandra Ryan was excellent—she truly brought the characters and atmosphere to life, enhancing the overall reading experience.
Thank you to NetGalley & Brilliance Publishing | Brilliance Audio for letting me read this ARC.
Ellingsen captures both the resilience and heartbreak of life during the Great Depression, immersing the reader in a time of hardship and survival. At its core, this is a novel about forgiveness, the weight of consequences, and uncovering long-buried mysteries.
The audiobook narration by Alexandra Ryan was excellent—she truly brought the characters and atmosphere to life, enhancing the overall reading experience.
Thank you to NetGalley & Brilliance Publishing | Brilliance Audio for letting me read this ARC.
September 12, 2025
A dual timeline look at the lives of two women as they deal with family and secrets. I went in expecting more focus on a mystery, but still found myself pulled in by the story. I was not expecting some of the reveals about Ruby’s family and enjoyed piecing it together with Lindsey (I also really liked that Lindsey and Otis made guesses that weren’t always correct. It felt true to life that they didn’t just automatically intuit what the reader knew).
That said, I think I may have enjoyed this more if I had read it rather than listening, as I struggled with the narration. Specifically, the narrator had a tendency to overact, and I found her voice for Otis to be flawed. The description of the character and how he was supposed to sound clashed with the voice he was given.
Thanks to NetGalley and Brilliance Publishing for this ALC!
2.75 ⭐️
That said, I think I may have enjoyed this more if I had read it rather than listening, as I struggled with the narration. Specifically, the narrator had a tendency to overact, and I found her voice for Otis to be flawed. The description of the character and how he was supposed to sound clashed with the voice he was given.
Thanks to NetGalley and Brilliance Publishing for this ALC!
2.75 ⭐️
September 17, 2025
I received an ARC copy from Netgalley and Lake Union Publishing as well as the audiobook from Brilliance Publishing.
I was pleasantly thrilled that an immersive reading technique (listening to the Audiobook and reading from my Kindle at the same time) worked for this book! It really helped to distinguish the tone between the two existing timelines happening in the book.
My first impression of this book is that it was page turning! I couldn’t put my headphones and kindle down. It felt a bit slow at first, but I was hooked! I’ve always loved family secrets as a huge theme for ANY mystery book.
The characters were impeccably created for the plot point and very well balanced. I enjoyed getting to know Ruby and Chester from the 1920s as well as Lindsay and Otis in present day.
This book is a solid 4/5 stars for me. Looking forward to the author’s next book!
I was pleasantly thrilled that an immersive reading technique (listening to the Audiobook and reading from my Kindle at the same time) worked for this book! It really helped to distinguish the tone between the two existing timelines happening in the book.
My first impression of this book is that it was page turning! I couldn’t put my headphones and kindle down. It felt a bit slow at first, but I was hooked! I’ve always loved family secrets as a huge theme for ANY mystery book.
The characters were impeccably created for the plot point and very well balanced. I enjoyed getting to know Ruby and Chester from the 1920s as well as Lindsay and Otis in present day.
This book is a solid 4/5 stars for me. Looking forward to the author’s next book!
June 7, 2025
This book drew me in from the first page. A dual storyline set between the 1920's and the present, the reader meets two strong women connected by a diamond engagement ring. We first meet Ruby in the earlier period. Upset by her sister's engagement and then the murder of a servant, she escapes to NYC with her neighbor where she starts life anew as a servant. in the present, we meet Lindsay who has come to the estate previously owned by Ruby's family to assist her aunt in the house's rennovation and documentation of its history. What follows is a page turning story of family secrets, fascinating characters and a brief section on human smuggling. Highly recommended, I can't wait to read more books from this author.
August 11, 2025
Thank you to Net Galley and Lake Union Publishing for the chance to read and review this book. All opinions are my own.
Wow! What a great story! This story is told using two storylines-one is current time, and one is the 1920's. A young woman from each time period is the main character in their story line. There is also a mystery involved. The author does an excellent job of bringing the characters together. It is the kind of book that you don't want to stop reading. You want to find the answers. Lots of times one of the storylines is stronger in a book, but it is not true in this story. I thought both of them were equally engaging. I know you will like this book. It is an intriguing tale with lots of twists and turns.
Wow! What a great story! This story is told using two storylines-one is current time, and one is the 1920's. A young woman from each time period is the main character in their story line. There is also a mystery involved. The author does an excellent job of bringing the characters together. It is the kind of book that you don't want to stop reading. You want to find the answers. Lots of times one of the storylines is stronger in a book, but it is not true in this story. I thought both of them were equally engaging. I know you will like this book. It is an intriguing tale with lots of twists and turns.
September 6, 2025
Jewelry designer Lindsey McKenna is thrilled to work at the Wind Thorne estate, a historic landmark turned museum. When a visitor gives her an old diary, Lindsey is drawn into the estate’s past, uncovering secrets alongside young Ruby Thornhill, whose attempt to stall her sister’s wedding puts her in danger.
I didn’t fully connect with this story in audiobook format, and I think the narration just wasn’t for me personally. I generally enjoy historical fiction, and the premise of this book is genuinely intriguing, so I’m planning to give it another try in ebook format once it’s released. Sometimes it’s just about the format, and I’m looking forward to giving it another shot then.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an ALC of this audiobook in exchange for an honest review.
I didn’t fully connect with this story in audiobook format, and I think the narration just wasn’t for me personally. I generally enjoy historical fiction, and the premise of this book is genuinely intriguing, so I’m planning to give it another try in ebook format once it’s released. Sometimes it’s just about the format, and I’m looking forward to giving it another shot then.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an ALC of this audiobook in exchange for an honest review.
October 3, 2025
I won this book through a Goodreads giveaway in exchange for an honest review. Thanks to Amazon Publishing for choosing me.
I don't read a lot of historical fiction, but I'm glad I entered this giveaway. I was captivated from beginning to end. The dual timeline worked perfectly, Cynthia Ellingsen does an incredible job of shifting from past to present without hurting the flow of the novel. No matter where she stops a chapter and shifts back between timelines, it always continues without a hitch.
Unraveling the mystery, figuring out the betrayal, and surviving the heartache kept me intrigued from beginning to end. I had a great time with these characters and will surely be thinking of them for a long time.
I don't read a lot of historical fiction, but I'm glad I entered this giveaway. I was captivated from beginning to end. The dual timeline worked perfectly, Cynthia Ellingsen does an incredible job of shifting from past to present without hurting the flow of the novel. No matter where she stops a chapter and shifts back between timelines, it always continues without a hitch.
Unraveling the mystery, figuring out the betrayal, and surviving the heartache kept me intrigued from beginning to end. I had a great time with these characters and will surely be thinking of them for a long time.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 56 reviews