It’s refreshing to read a Christmas novel that is (1) not a romance and (2) about a woman in her late 70s who grows intellectually and emotionally as the story progresses. Sylvia has returned to her childhood home in Sewickley, PA, because she is the only surviving heir to the family’s stately manor. A young couple lives harmoniously with her in the manor, and they have helped Sylvia fashion their home into a quilters’ retreat center. Sylvia left this home 50 years earlier under circumstances that are revealed during the novel, with Christmas as the catalyst. Sylvia had not returned once between leaving home as a young adult and returning home after everyone was gone.
As the holidays approach, Sylvia is determined not to celebrate. She has many family traditions that she’d rather not revive because they’d bring up too many memories and emotions. Her young friend Sarah insists upon decorating, and as Sylvia begins to agree to allow more and more celebratory traditions to creep back in, so she experiences memories from many past Christmases. She remembers her parents, grandmother, favorite cousin, aunts and uncles, brother and sister, and family friends. She remembers happy times, sad times, rich times, poor times, and times when her stubbornness made some family members, including herself, less than happy. As past hardships are revealed, we see why Sylvia would not want to celebrate. And yet, as she recounts the past, she sees more reasons to preserve the family traditions and reach out to find the family that she thinks she has lost.
Regarding the title: while searching in the attic for the Christmas decorations, Sarah also finds the Christmas quilt, which has never been finished. Throughout generations, the women in Sylvia’s family have made squares for the quilt, yet no one has sewn them together. Sylvia cannot imagine how so many different parts could come together into an attractive whole, but it turns out that there’s a secret about the quilt squares that Sylvia doesn’t know.
The Christmas Quilt has the requisite touch of magical Christmas coincidences that make for happy seasonal storytelling. At the same time, the breadth of emotions that Sylvia experiences, from excruciating loss to pure joy, elevate this novel above the usual Christmas fluff. Readers looking for a Christmas novel with some depth and introspection as well as light heartedness, tradition, and fun will enjoy this book. Women intrigued by the women in their families throughout the generations might find it interesting. Quilters will also enjoy it, and appreciate the details about the different quilt patterns and how they reflect the personalities of the quilters.