My congratulations to Roy Lotz for having the courage (and the inventiveness) to transport Cervantes' immortal character to a modern-day setting, and for having achieved this very difficult feat so very successfully.
Roy first came to my attention shortly after Ybernia had published my novel 'The Way'. Roy,too, is one of Ybernia's authors, and he also regularly writes reviews of other writers' works on this website. Roy kindly posted a very favourable review of 'The Way', and I am now pleased to be able to return the compliment by providing some thoughts on 'Don Bigote'.
My first impressions on reading it were very positive, not because of any obligation to return a favour, but simply beacuse the book is original, thought provoking, and also very entertaining. The bumbling Don Bigote, with his wacky obsessions and weird conspiracy theories, is a very believable character, not least because such extravagant ideas have now become standard fare on all the social media. We only need to think back to the Pandemic to recall certain insane affirmations that the vaccines contained secret ingredients that would convert us into zombies, more easily controlled by the (unspecified) forces that created them. There were many Don Bigotes on the loose during those days! And what about Mr. Trump's extraordinary contribution to medicinal resources -that intravenous shots of bleach would cure Covid?
The fact that Bigote's list of apparently unrelated conspirators is so comprehensive does not make it any more or less plausible. Mexicans, Muslims, Homosexuals, Femeinists - they were all involved in the plot!
As I progressed through the story, I came to realise that here was a very incisive satire on variuos aspects of modern life, which reflected many ideas already expressed in other enouned sources. For example, the social and political structure enforced in the Sub-World was strongly reminiscent of parts of Swift's 'Gulliver's Travels'. Elsewhere I could identify ideas about the prohibition of private property and its replacement with communal ownership, which were perhaps first outlined in Thomas More's 'Utopia' - a predecessor, some might say, of Marx and Engels in that respect? And not forgetting the debate opened up in Chapter 7 about the quest for happiness, and the role of religion, which immediately reminded me of Voltaire's 'Candide'. Perhaps Roy will say that I am reading too much into things, but I would hope that he might agree to some extent with these similarities.
Howver, there were other espects of 'Don Bigote' which I must comment on. The character of Dan Champan (although seemingly harmless and perfectly amiable) was instantly recognisable. It is my hope that Roy deliberately created a satirical stereotype in order to expose a trend which, if generally true, would be a truly painful portrait of youth in modern-day America. Too often in films and T.V. series, young Americans are portrayed as empty-headed bozos whose only concern is how to acquire unlimited access to sex, drugs and alcohol. I do hope that this image does not reflect the majority of the younger population.
In a similar vein, the four tales recounted in Chapter 9, which offer us personal views of life-experiences, all combine ro reveal the frighteneing and damning picture of a society without scruples or moral values. Writing now, after 100 days of Donald Trump`s disastrous second administration, I find it dificult to hope that the United States will one day really be a country where the labels of 'freedom', 'justice', and ´'liberty' might be applied without being negated and stifled by an overwhelming blanket of cynicism.