The author has compiled this brilliant, educative work after referring, studying and doing his thorough research about the origin of the Aryans, their arrival to India and the legacy they have supposedly left behind in the form of literature. But unlike most of the theories, the author asserts that the Aryans came into the nation on trade ships and it was the people of the Indus Valley Civilization who even let them to live amongst them. There are many references to Vedas and Zoroastrian epics and scriptures. A source also claims that the Zoroastrianism also belonged to the same ethnic stock as the Aryans. A must have history aficionados.
Great attempt to identify the journey of "Aryans" and the history behind them. Book tries to understand the common ancestry between us and Zoroastrians (Persians). The most interesting thing is that it delves into a topic which had personally interested me a lot. That the Devas and Asuras of Hindu religion were polar opposites of Ahuras(Asuras) and Daevas (Devas)of Zoroastrian religion. The book hypothesis what many speculated that we shared a common ancestry and during the course of which tribal rivalry resulted in the creation of two separate religions. The book does a fantastic job of finding out the journey of Aryans and how the rivalry on method of worship resulted in the creation of so much history not only in the sub-continent but influencing movements across central Asia, Persia, Levant and Greece.
This book is one of rare books that tries to delve into the period of Indian history where we have so little information. Separating Mythology to extract historical information from them is difficult task and the author has done a fantastic job of the same.
it is very nice book, which empowered me with some new fact about an aryan journey. This book is also successful to show the common past of Zoroastrian and an aryan. But the author of book has willfully concealed some fact about aryan entry/invasion in India. He said the aryan came in India on the invitation of indus valley civilization, on the other point he says that there is no knowledge how the indus valley civilization was destroyed. He has not also elaborated,why the molnivasi pepole become so poorer and how the aryan people become so powerful and controlled all resources in India. The aryan can be even seen today .They are so strong , powerful and controlling all resources.
My IAS batch-mate and friend Harsh Mahaan Cairae has published a scholarly work, 'An Aryan Journey' published by Rupa Publications. Cairae, who had scored heavily in Sanskrit in the IAS Exam has translated many Richas from Veds and many hymns from Avesta to conclude that the Aryan jouney started from the Arctic Circle, a conclusion also arrived at by Lokmanya Tilak, born exactly hundred years before Cairae. He observes that the Vedic Aryans and the Zoroastrians were one people till they were near Balkash lake (Arjia, an area they refer to as heaven later); the dispute between Vedic people and Zoroastrians arose on whether there should be fire sacrifices or only fire worship; the asuras referred to by Vedic people were worshippers of Ahura-Mazda and Angra-Manyu, the villain of Parsees was Manu of the Aryans. Cairae has put in a lot of effort in studying various religious scriptures and also Manichean ethics. He concludes that Aryans came to India not as invaders but as refugees. The Indus Valley Civilization died out not because of an invasion but because of change in course of the Saraswati river whose water started flowing into Yamuna after the change in course. Cairae has studied many details of the social life of different people, from Persia to Indus Valley showing a very deep understanding of intricate matters such as even ship design. Indeed a scholarly work by our batch-mate who had represented his university in boxing, which is actually a greatly intellectual sport :).
This is a most interesting book and one that I will probably have to read again.
Harsh Mahaan does indeed interpret the Vedas in an interesting manner and does provide us with some alternate histories of the Aryans.
He postulates that their story started from the Arctic Circle. While I do not claim to be an expert, I wonder if this interpretation is correct. He postulates that Indra, Manu, Yam(a) etc were kings and warriors of old, who gradually were deified. I do think that this is a possibility. I also think that there is a possibility that they were blonde, as he has suggested.
Since the journeys were, as seen from our times, obscure and sometimes difficult to understand, I would have liked that the chapters were to be broken down into sections. A 'family tree', even as a postulate, and maps, would have helped to make the narrative clear.
It is indeed a book well worth reading. It is a book that needs a second, clearer, edition.
An Aryan Journey by Harsh Mahaan Cairae is a deeply researched and thought-provoking book that presents a bold alternative view of Aryan origins using the Rigveda, Avesta, Shahnama, archaeology, and historical analysis to explore maritime migration, the Indus Valley Civilization, Sapta Sindhu, Somras, Tilak's Arctic theory, and the shared roots of Indian and Iranian Aryans; while it challenges mainstream views and requires careful reading, the author's remarkable dedication, extensive research, and original perspective make this a fascinating and rewarding read for anyone interested in ancient Indian history.
What a beautiful book. It brings out evidence from scriptures to create a very convincing sequence of events that occurred in such remote antiquity. It is highly recommended for general readers as well as students of history.