A Perfect Arrangement

by Suzanne Berne

Handsome and ambitious, Mirella and Howard Cook-Goldman have it all-two precious children, dual careers, a great old colonial house on Massachusetts's North Shore, a golden retriever. The only thing they lack is reliable child care.

Enter Randi Gill, sent by Family Options, Ltd., an agency specializing in Midwestern girls with teaching aspirations ("Could you be Comfortable with Anything but the Best for Your Family?. . . Guaranteed Nationwide FBI Criminal Fingerprinting and Background Checks."). Randi's references are perfect. She's perfect. She cleans, cooks, sews, and makes her own Play-Doh. The children love her . . . almost too much.

Though it's hard for Mirella to watch Randi succeed with the children where she has failed, she can't deny the peace and order Randi has brought to the household. But perfection is a tough act to maintain, and soon enough, there are ruptures. When events force Mirella and Howard to reveal the secrets they've been hiding from each other, the family cataclysm catapults the nanny (who has secrets of her own) into a position of unnatural control.

Genres: Fiction, Literary Fiction, Literature, Book Club, Adult Fiction, Contemporary, Thriller

301 pages, Paperback

First published May 1, 2001

Reviews

[Katie Kenig · Rating 4 out of 5]

The last approximately ten percent of this book left me stunned and feeling more than a little unsettled.

It may have been my own history working as a nanny in my early twenties that made the character of Randi, the nanny in this novel, more compelling to me than the driven career-woman mother. Perhaps it was that I feel more of a connection to stay-at-home mothers and the mother in this novel treated them a little bit disdainfully that made me more on the nanny's "side". Whatever it was, I wasn't expecting my feelings to be so upended.

Primarily, this is a story about possessiveness and emotion. Who has the "right" to love who, or what, in our world? Who really "owns" children, land, clean air, free time, affection? Where do the boundaries lie between who is allowed to be family and who is not?

Touching. I'm glad this one made it to my bookshelf.

[Jenny Karraker · Rating 1 out of 5]

I saw this on someone's list and decided to read it. I found it very slow and not very interesting. Author explores the life of a wealthy Bostonian couple who struggle with the challenges of juggling 2 careers with raising children plus trying to keep their marriage intact. The nanny seems like a God send, but you know something isn't quite right about the while thing. Wanting closure, I skimmed through the book to found out what happens at the end. I don't think I'll read anything else by this author.

[L.N. Cronk · Rating 2 out of 5]

The description labels this book as "suspenseful", which is why I gave it such a low rating. The only suspense was waiting for something exciting to happen. It was more of a character study and the "events" at the end were anti-climatic, in my opinion. Nothing shocking, nothing surprising, nothing really original. If the book's description had not led me to believe the book was going to be exciting, I would have given it a higher rating.

[Frances · Rating 2 out of 5]

This book seemed to have great promise, but ran out of steam towards the end. The nanny, Randi, was built up to be a potential psychopath, but eventually appeared to be much more of a victim. The stresses of working parents coping with a child with severe autism were explored, but could have been much more fully developed by the author.

[Joe · Rating 2 out of 5]

Not sure why this book was written

[Beth Farnsworth · Rating 1 out of 5]

What was the purpose of this book? Waste of my time.

[Jarrod Li · Rating 2 out of 5]

For a book that is 300 pages, not much happens. In fact, one could argue that the author has run out of words at the end of the story, hamfistedly tacking together an ending that ties off the loose ends (of sorts).

I'm unsure if the novel was mysterious because it was supposed to be, or if it was a reflection of the writing. I truly thought the story would end with the parents discovering Randis kleptomaniacy, and that Randi would take Jacob with her to California, her largest heist of all.

All in all, I think that perhaps there were too many loose ends for my liking. So many avenues of discussion, thought and potential progression were opened only for them to be closed abruptly at the end.

There were some rather poignant turns of phrase though, and I've picked some of my favourites below. (also, lots of new, unfamiliar words!)

all of her worries and failures and abilities and cares, all of it mattered so dearly, but so briefly, and that it was all in a way nearly over, even the parts of her life that were still to come

it was true that simple exigency had united many families...who had manipulated, ignored, and transgressed against each other as married people inevitably must, if they are to accommodate a houseful of children and survive their life together

She began to feel the mild hopefulness that accompanies almost any excursion in fine weather, no matter how brief or circumscribed, or what the forecast ahead

Craving it all with a hunger that gradually lost the piquancy of desire and took on the suffocating absorption of lust

[Chris · Rating 4 out of 5]

Randi, is hired as a nanny to a double income couple (Howard and Mirabella) with two children, Pearl and Jacob. It comes as no surprise that the household and the marriage continue to deteriorate from the get go. These kids, this house, this life, they think, it all demands so much of them. The sacrifices they make. The morning chaos of getting everyone fed and dressed and cleaned up and out the door in time. Making sure everyone has their stuff and going over last minute updates for the day - plumber coming so be sure you’re home, dinner meeting next week can you cover for me... sort of thing.

Mirabella does not handle this family chaos well; she can be short tempered and as obstinate as her daughter Pearl. Mirabella is an attorney and her mind is always racing with thoughts of work, thoughts of what she would like to take care of at home (but can’t) or promising her involvement for school/community and ends up forgetting things and coming up short. Her appearance is important as well as necessary focus in her job. Howard is more the patient laid back parent but this is all starting to get on his nerves more and more as he’s been relegated to step in and his work more often than hers takes a back seat (he is an architect). Thus, this is yet another attempt (after failed others) at securing a nanny.

It is apparent their lifestyle requires two incomes and it is apparent they both do like their work - perhaps more than taking care of their children? It’s all just so exhausting trying to balance everything. Mirabella, as an attorney, is constantly strapped for time and attention and her long commute just adds to the problem.

So Randi is interviewed and hired through an agency and in no time is running spectacular interference for the family. She manages to not only take care of the house, but the adults and the two children which I’m presuming Jacob has autistic tendencies though that diagnosis was never indicated. Pearl is a difficult child in and of herself with tendencies to worry herself sick about the weather which they lie to her about so she does not work herself up every day. I learned this is a very real psychological illness called astraphobia.

Randi has developed a close connection with Jacob, and the mother begins to get jealous. Especially as the children start to prefer being with Randi over Mirabella.

Randi employs the children to do crafts, she reads them books, they bake cookies, they play games, go for a walk, etc. she is not only the nanny but becomes much more, cook, cleaner, organizer, shopper, party planner, good neighbor, caregiver, etc. Not a bad deal and...she’s good at it! Everyone loves her. The kids really connect with her. So does Howard. She is the epitome of what they have all been missing. The calm in the chaos. The nurturer.

The reader is given some clues at the start that something is amiss with Randi, so we wait to see what is going to be so horrible. Randi has not had a happy childhood and is happy to get away from her former life and land this job in a beautiful home with her own room with a lovely family. What I see (as no harm) is Randi wanting to recreate a happy loving home she never had, with things she never had or could afford, treating and working with the children as if they were her own. She enjoys doing these things, is very creative with good intentions. I’m still waiting for what’s so horrible...and guess what? I expected the absolute worst so was disappointed with what was so bad because it really wasn’t.

There are some unexpected events during the story which are good, but when it came to the ending I was disappointed with that. It was rather innocuous in that “life goes on as before” especially after everything that occurred. Not sure that Howard and Mirabella actually learned life lessons from their own despicable behaviors. Sad to say, Randi was the victim in this story, if you ask my opinion.

[Alexandra · Rating 5 out of 5]

I’m really surprised at the low ranking this novel gets - for me it was a really well-handled portrait of a professional couple and their marriage and family in crisis. The novel explores in detail the forces that drew the couple together and that now threaten to disconnect them completely, alongside the main narrative of a stranger who offers love and attention to two children that seem to need it. And how that intervention is viewed as unwelcome and potentially possessive despite the fact that it’s necessary and not coming from a more appropriate source. Thought-provoking, well-written and full of human and emotional truth.

[Tiffany Garcia · Rating 1 out of 5]

This sounded like a really good book and how the nanny was going to be so bad, it was nothing like that. She just got attached to the autistic son and the mother couldn't handle it. Could have been great.

[Aimee · Rating 2 out of 5]

O.K. A little creepy and the family dynamic frusterated me.

[Alan · Rating 4 out of 5]

2006 notebook: controlled, polished writing. An unqualified nanny is appointed to a middle class American home (lawyer/designer). Deft account of their roles and affairs.

[Carol Randall · Rating 4 out of 5]

A compelling read with interesting, although not always likeable, characters.

[Kelly Petruno · Rating 2 out of 5]

Slow moving book. I’m usually a “one book at a time” reader and actually picked up another book in the middle of this one, and finished that one first! I could have easily left this one unfinished. It does pick up a little bit in the second half, however I still felt like it fell a bit flat, lacking necessary character development to make the ending more suspenseful or shocking than it actually was.

[Mandy · Rating 1 out of 5]

This book was almost like the movie the hand that rocks the craddle. It was full of detail that went on and on. I wanted to read about what happen to Randi when she left besides the postcard. I wanted to find out what happen to Howard after the town meeting. How did he walk out of there. The writer seemed to try to create suspens but all that I felt was created was annoying.

[Lori · Rating 1 out of 5]

Not suspenseful. The characters were bland and unlikeable. I think the author tried to eek out reader empathy but it fails. I skimmed the entire novel because I wanted to discover the disturbing event touted on the jacket. There was nothing disturbing or thrilling at all about this pedestrian tale of middle-class people who live a life of ingratitude and then screwing up what they have.

[Saya · Rating 4 out of 5]

Shades of A.M Homes, always a good thing.

[Judith · Rating 4 out of 5]

This was an intriguing book. I had no idea where it was going to go, except that it would involve the nanny.

Randi Gill lands a nanny job with Mirella and Howard Goldman by faking her credentials. As it turns out, though, she is very skilled at the job. She leans on women's magazines and newspapers for recipes and household hints, and throws herself into each task with dedication. She seems to have an instinct for relating to children, which serves her well when she encounters Jacob, a little boy, nearly three, who has yet to talk. She finds activities to do with both children and yet finds time to clean and cook and help the parents as needed, too.

Mirella, struggling as an attorney in a newish partnership, worries about her role at home. Is she letting Randi take on too much of what really should be Mirella's duties? Meanwhile, Howard sees how well Randi does with the children and the house and mainly feels relief.

Mirella and Howard have a strained relationship, in part because Howard had an affair with a coworker a few years back. Perhaps having the weight of running a household lessened gives them more time to dwell on what's wrong between them.

Meanwhile, Randi has also given a false name and has made up her past. When she learns that someone from her past is trying to find her, she tries to keep that from happening.

The big mystery of who Randi is does come to the front. I found the resulting changes abrupt and confusing. I wanted a better understanding. Perhaps I am just dense, not seeing what is there.

[Kelly · Rating 2 out of 5]

This book plodded along following each of the very flawed and not very like-able family and their nanny. Everything in their lives was designed to go wrong, from Mirella not telling her husband about the pregnancy and oops, she is having twins to Henry having an affair with a vengeful woman with problems. Don't forget their inability to vet a nanny appropriately for their kids, or their lack of joy with their children. There was no levity for the reader and any character for the reader to bond with and root for.

Once the climax occurred, I was flummoxed about a number of things but the top two were:

1. When Randi's mom first arrived, why did she think it was so important for Randi to go home immediately? Randi was holding a job and outwardly seemed to be doing well - other than previous bad acts at home of stealing and lying, what did the mom know about Randi that we the reader never learned? Had Randi been diagnosed with a mental condition previously?

2. After Henry realizes Martha has been run over by the Jeep - where was Randi's mom, Delores? Wouldn't she be keeping an eye on Randi if it was so important for her to go home that day? Wouldn't she have been concerned when Randi and Jacob disappear together - especially when Randi is being forced to leave? The Delores character just disappears in the middle of the climax.

It just felt like the plot was wrapped up haphazardly and was wanting.

[Jayne Charles · Rating 3 out of 5]

The word that comes to mind in connection with this book is "muted". Given the set-up (stressed-out professional couple hire nanny with faked references who seems brilliant) most people would expect the story to go a particular - quite dramatic - way. It doesn't. It's rather more concerned with examining the relationship of the couple, and the relationship of the nanny with her estranged family. I realised close to the end that there wasn't going to be any drama and settled down to enjoy the descriptive stuff - and really this author is excellent at describing people (I loved the smug earth-mother neighbour for example). I shouldn't feel disappointed, but somehow I do.

[Carolyn Drake · Rating 4 out of 5]

A skilled dissection of a middle-class family struggling to connect and communicate with eachother. Mirella and Howard have an outwardly enviable life, with well-paying, professional jobs. Randi, their new nanny, although 'a little earnest', is proving a godsend with their children, particularly the uncommunicative/autistic toddler. But everyone is weighed down with secrets and guilt. Sharply observational, the different characters' perspectives and inner voices are well-handled and convincing. A slow-burner.

[Trudy · Rating 3 out of 5]

Good book. Mystery with an edge to it. The suspense was built up gradually, but unfortunately the climax never happened. There weren't really any twists and turns.....just basically dark edgy character build up. It was however a good mystery in the sense that in the end there was a revelation of a sort and an unexpected ending. I enjoyed reading it because I love reading - but I won't be bragging about this book or insisting anyone read it.

[Goldie · Rating 1 out of 5]

Absolutely Terrible.
Probably one of the worst books I've read in years. So upset with myself for wasting my time with it.
Totally boring, no plot whatsoever.
I don't understand why this book was written...
Please... Don't waste your time! These are hours of your life that you will never get back...

[Lesley · Rating 2 out of 5]

I actually liked the character Randi and wanted more in her past! Otherwise I would have easily disliked this book but then Randi did something that kept me reading to see where the book goes.
I will say that I automatically drop a point foe a dog dies in the book (uhmm NO NO NO)

[Tessa · Rating 2 out of 5]

Couldn't finish this book. Got up to around half way and gave up. The writing was great, but the plot seemed very ... jumbled and not very interesting.

[Jude Hayland · Rating 5 out of 5]

I loved this novel - entirely engaging and real characters, wonderful easy yet poignant, elegant writing. The last page I shall read and re-read constantly as it says so much so effortlessly.

[Barbara Matteau · Rating 4 out of 5]

Very interesting character developments. Competent story that was well written & detailed. The touch of local details was enriching & helped give a sense of place & feeling.

[Jill Walerius · Rating 1 out of 5]

I just can't figure out why this book was written.

[Liz Owen · Rating 3 out of 5]

3.5 I enjoyed this, a sort of family story with a twist. Quite well done.

[Mary Jo Jo · Rating 1 out of 5]

This book was very hard to get into and all over the place! I did not enjoy this one at all, almost dnf but pushed through it!