What do you think?
Rate this book
Women of Midtown #2
When Stars Light the Sky
In a world on the brink of war, two hearts must navigate shadows of uncertainty.
Inga Klein's carefree life in New York takes a dramatic turn when she sails for Berlin, Germany, to serve as the secretary for America's ambassador. Amid the glamour of life at the embassy, she continually finds herself at odds with the straitlaced and imposing Benedict Kincaid, the diplomatic chief of staff who harbors deep misgivings toward the German-born Inga.
As Europe hurtles toward World War I, Benedict's determination to keep America out of the conflict adds to the already tense atmosphere. Despite their relentless sparring, Inga and Benedict succeed in keeping the embassy afloat through one crisis after another. But when they run out of diplomatic options, a marriage of convenience may be Inga's only hope of escape from the impending war.
Inga Klein's carefree life in New York takes a dramatic turn when she sails for Berlin, Germany, to serve as the secretary for America's ambassador. Amid the glamour of life at the embassy, she continually finds herself at odds with the straitlaced and imposing Benedict Kincaid, the diplomatic chief of staff who harbors deep misgivings toward the German-born Inga.
As Europe hurtles toward World War I, Benedict's determination to keep America out of the conflict adds to the already tense atmosphere. Despite their relentless sparring, Inga and Benedict succeed in keeping the embassy afloat through one crisis after another. But when they run out of diplomatic options, a marriage of convenience may be Inga's only hope of escape from the impending war.
Audible Audio
First published January 21, 2025
61 people are currently reading
4824 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 200 reviews
January 16, 2025
Author Elizabeth Camden introduces readers to Inga Klein and shows us how adapting and evolving is just as valuable in 1914 America as it is in our present day. Inga embraced the possibilities and opportunities for growth and ended up reinventing herself and building up resilience, two things she needed to survive as her country teetered on the brink of war.
Camden reminds us of the push and pull of divided loyalties as well as the importance of bridling fear of failure. Her compelling and fascinating opposites attract and marriage of convenience story is steeped in emotion and true to its historical setting.
I loved the moment the connection between Claude Debussy playing ‘Clair de lune’ and the book’s title manifested itself, and appreciated the opportunity to do further investigation on the Ruhleben prisoner exchange and the history of The Martha Washington building.
My two takeaways:
1) “The best opportunities in life are usually the scariest.” - shared by Midge Lightner, an elderly nurse in The Martha Washington Building.
2) The importance of reaching out to those in need.
This Gilded Age romance set in Europe on the brink of war and featuring two lonely souls who must embrace uncertainty and do what it takes to keep afloat during multiple crises is one you’ll want on your reading list ASAP.
I was gifted this copy by Bethany House and NetGalley and was under no obligation to provide a review.
Camden reminds us of the push and pull of divided loyalties as well as the importance of bridling fear of failure. Her compelling and fascinating opposites attract and marriage of convenience story is steeped in emotion and true to its historical setting.
I loved the moment the connection between Claude Debussy playing ‘Clair de lune’ and the book’s title manifested itself, and appreciated the opportunity to do further investigation on the Ruhleben prisoner exchange and the history of The Martha Washington building.
My two takeaways:
1) “The best opportunities in life are usually the scariest.” - shared by Midge Lightner, an elderly nurse in The Martha Washington Building.
2) The importance of reaching out to those in need.
This Gilded Age romance set in Europe on the brink of war and featuring two lonely souls who must embrace uncertainty and do what it takes to keep afloat during multiple crises is one you’ll want on your reading list ASAP.
I was gifted this copy by Bethany House and NetGalley and was under no obligation to provide a review.
December 18, 2024
Wow! This was a great story! If you love WWI era and marriage of convenience, then trust me, you will want to read this book! I don’t think I’ve ever read a WWI book set in Germany and it was very interesting. Inga goes to Germany as the secretary for America’s ambassador. Benedict is also at the US embassy in Germany, as the diplomatic chief of staff. They don’t get along that well. But they work hard to try to keep America out of the war and help people. Situations arise where they must marry and I really loved how this was handled. I loved watching them work together and also their relationship grow. Just a fantastic book and I definitely recommend!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from netgalley. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from netgalley. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
September 8, 2025
Sweet story with a great marriage of convenience! Their opposites attract storyline was the cutest.
I really enjoyed the history too!
I really enjoyed the history too!
January 29, 2025
This was quite possibly one of my favorite marriage of convenience stories I've ever read. The heroine, Inga, ends up as secretary to the American ambassador to Germany just before WWI starts. Inga emigrated to New York City with her parents when she was a young girl, so she is more American than German, but her German fluency makes her an ideal fit for the post. At the American embassy is Benedict Kincaid, the straight-laced second in command who eats cold oats for breakfast and loves to scold and criticize. As war is declared and the American embassy staff is put to the test in countless ways as a neutral nation, Inga's position as German-born and not yet an American citizen puts in her in a vulnerable position... (So like my other favorite MOC story, The Morning Gift, by Eva Ibbotson.)
This was a completely new aspect of WWI to me. I never thought about what it would be like to be a neutral nation's embassy in a country at war. Their duties were fascinating to read about and the embassy staff was so much fun. They weren't hugely distinct characters (except for Larry, Nellie, and Mrs. Barnes), but there is a real sense of camaraderie amongst the staff as we get to know them over several years of war-time living in Berlin. I thought Benedict's character was particularly well drawn. He's definitely a Darcy type to Inga's Elizabeth, so of course I loved that dynamic. I was in suspense about some things to the very end of the novel.
Such an enjoyable read! I honestly can't think of a thing I disliked. I know I'll return to this in the future, and now I'm off to read the first book in the series.
This was a completely new aspect of WWI to me. I never thought about what it would be like to be a neutral nation's embassy in a country at war. Their duties were fascinating to read about and the embassy staff was so much fun. They weren't hugely distinct characters (except for Larry, Nellie, and Mrs. Barnes), but there is a real sense of camaraderie amongst the staff as we get to know them over several years of war-time living in Berlin. I thought Benedict's character was particularly well drawn. He's definitely a Darcy type to Inga's Elizabeth, so of course I loved that dynamic. I was in suspense about some things to the very end of the novel.
Such an enjoyable read! I honestly can't think of a thing I disliked. I know I'll return to this in the future, and now I'm off to read the first book in the series.
February 17, 2025
This series is fast becoming one of my favorites! I love the time period as well as the characters and romance. I thoroughly enjoy the mystery and suspense as well in these books.
This second book is set in the beginnings of WW2. I loved seeing the point of view from an american embassy. I've never read a story like it and I just wanted more and more. I can't wait for the third book!
*Thank you to Bethany House for a complimentary copy of this book. All thoughts are my own.
6⭐
This second book is set in the beginnings of WW2. I loved seeing the point of view from an american embassy. I've never read a story like it and I just wanted more and more. I can't wait for the third book!
*Thank you to Bethany House for a complimentary copy of this book. All thoughts are my own.
6⭐
January 28, 2025
When Stars Light the Sky by Elizabeth Camden transported me back to Germany at the start of World War I. This well-written novel held lots of historical details and provided a unique perspective of that time. The serious subject matter anchored the plot, but the story was not overly dark due to the characters being mostly safe as workers at the US Embassy. I appreciated how the novel brought this difficult period to life without drowning me in sadness.
Although I enjoyed the setting, plot events, and historical details, the romance elevated When Stars Light the Sky to a five star read for me. Camden deftly weaved together at least three romantic tropes (grumpy/sunshine personalities, enemies-to-lovers, and marriage of convenience). These elements provided rich soil for character growth and for the romantic tension between Inga and Benedict. Their initial difficulties made the development and fruition of their relationship especially satisfying. Plus, I adored the ending.
When Stars Light the Sky lands as book two in the Women of Midtown series by Elizabeth Camden, but the novel works well as a standalone. Characters from book one feature briefly, but the setting and atmosphere of the two stories are very different. There is a light faith element that will appeal to Christian readers. Five stars for this all-around lovely novel!
Disclosure of Material Connection: I was provided a copy of this book by the author or publisher. All opinions in this review are my own.
Although I enjoyed the setting, plot events, and historical details, the romance elevated When Stars Light the Sky to a five star read for me. Camden deftly weaved together at least three romantic tropes (grumpy/sunshine personalities, enemies-to-lovers, and marriage of convenience). These elements provided rich soil for character growth and for the romantic tension between Inga and Benedict. Their initial difficulties made the development and fruition of their relationship especially satisfying. Plus, I adored the ending.
When Stars Light the Sky lands as book two in the Women of Midtown series by Elizabeth Camden, but the novel works well as a standalone. Characters from book one feature briefly, but the setting and atmosphere of the two stories are very different. There is a light faith element that will appeal to Christian readers. Five stars for this all-around lovely novel!
Disclosure of Material Connection: I was provided a copy of this book by the author or publisher. All opinions in this review are my own.
December 20, 2025
3.7 stars (4/10 hearts). I'm not exactly sure how to review this. I enjoyed the first half so much—and then it all came crashing down, and I'm not sure how I feel about it.
First off... I did really like the characters. Especially Benedict. He was such an upright, peace-seeking man, and I appreciated and admired him so much. But Inga was also very loveable and admirable in her own way. I loved her strength, and her optimism, and her tender heart. And the whole crew at the House with them—I enjoyed them all, especially Larry (as a fellow allergy sufferer, he has all my sympathies).
Secondly, I loved the setting!!! WW1 Germany, not from the POV of the trenches but the diplomatic city world, is so unusual and I enjoyed every bit of it. I mean, I enjoyed getting to see the ambassador/diplomatist side of things anyways, but the WW1 aspect added an extra layer of interest and I was fascinated watching these men work behind the scenes to protect the world and their specific countries. The book spanned several years of the war, and watching it progress from America's neutrality to the infamous telegram to Mexico was super cool. I couldn't put the book down during most of the plot-driven parts.
Now for the parts I didn't love. I didn't have a problem with the marriage of convenience—but the romance got a lot more detailed than I expected, and fast. It got to where I was frankly uncomfortable. I don't think it ever crossed into fully inappropriate territory, based on the reviews of women I know who have read this book; it's just that as an unmarried woman, I personally was not comfortable and ended up skimming quite a few parts of the last 40% (also, I'm not sure if "sexy" wasn't a word in 1915—the dictionary says it first appears in the 1890s—but it seemed jarringly unfit to the era). But really it was just unexpected. I also felt like the spiritual aspect of things was very neglected... mentioned occasionally in a few convos, but never a part of daily life. And finally, the ending disappointed me.
In short, I would definitely continue to read this author and I'm eager to read the next book in this series. I just think next time I read this book I may skip a few chapters and stop before the ending. ;P
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*
First off... I did really like the characters. Especially Benedict. He was such an upright, peace-seeking man, and I appreciated and admired him so much. But Inga was also very loveable and admirable in her own way. I loved her strength, and her optimism, and her tender heart. And the whole crew at the House with them—I enjoyed them all, especially Larry (as a fellow allergy sufferer, he has all my sympathies).
Secondly, I loved the setting!!! WW1 Germany, not from the POV of the trenches but the diplomatic city world, is so unusual and I enjoyed every bit of it. I mean, I enjoyed getting to see the ambassador/diplomatist side of things anyways, but the WW1 aspect added an extra layer of interest and I was fascinated watching these men work behind the scenes to protect the world and their specific countries. The book spanned several years of the war, and watching it progress from America's neutrality to the infamous telegram to Mexico was super cool. I couldn't put the book down during most of the plot-driven parts.
Now for the parts I didn't love. I didn't have a problem with the marriage of convenience—but the romance got a lot more detailed than I expected, and fast. It got to where I was frankly uncomfortable. I don't think it ever crossed into fully inappropriate territory, based on the reviews of women I know who have read this book; it's just that as an unmarried woman, I personally was not comfortable and ended up skimming quite a few parts of the last 40% (also, I'm not sure if "sexy" wasn't a word in 1915—the dictionary says it first appears in the 1890s—but it seemed jarringly unfit to the era). But really it was just unexpected. I also felt like the spiritual aspect of things was very neglected... mentioned occasionally in a few convos, but never a part of daily life. And finally, the ending disappointed me.
In short, I would definitely continue to read this author and I'm eager to read the next book in this series. I just think next time I read this book I may skip a few chapters and stop before the ending. ;P
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*
March 24, 2025
Pleasant. Sweet. Interesting.
Inga is a bright, fun character and seeing the friction, and later romance, between Inga and Benedict is amusing and heartwarming.
Both the city of Berlin and the German countryside make an appearance almost as background characters themselves, which adds nice layering.
OF NOTE
Clean fiction, with no vulgarity or sex scenes. There are a few mentions of faith or prayer later in the book, but nothing more than what would have been typical for the time and place of these characters and story. Mote a falling-in-love story than Christian fiction.
CONCLUSION:
Recommended. Great for historical fiction buffs, those who appreciate clean fiction, and book club fans.
- Desiree Reads
The Bookish Birder
March 24, 2024
Find more good book recs @ https://bookshop.org/shop/TheBookishB...
Inga is a bright, fun character and seeing the friction, and later romance, between Inga and Benedict is amusing and heartwarming.
Both the city of Berlin and the German countryside make an appearance almost as background characters themselves, which adds nice layering.
OF NOTE
Clean fiction, with no vulgarity or sex scenes. There are a few mentions of faith or prayer later in the book, but nothing more than what would have been typical for the time and place of these characters and story. Mote a falling-in-love story than Christian fiction.
CONCLUSION:
Recommended. Great for historical fiction buffs, those who appreciate clean fiction, and book club fans.
- Desiree Reads
The Bookish Birder
March 24, 2024
Find more good book recs @ https://bookshop.org/shop/TheBookishB...
July 15, 2025
1914-1917 New York City and Berlin
Loved all the history in this novel including a secondary character based upon the life of Ambassador James Gerard. The details about the strains between the US and Germany before the US entered the war were fascinating. I look forward to the next in the series.
Loved all the history in this novel including a secondary character based upon the life of Ambassador James Gerard. The details about the strains between the US and Germany before the US entered the war were fascinating. I look forward to the next in the series.
December 17, 2024
I loved getting to be immersed in the world of diplomacy and enjoyed every moment of being at the American Embassy in Berlin with Inga and Benedict. The impact of diplomatic relations and its role in staving off conflict and brokering between nations at odds with one another was utterly fascinating. I couldn't have asked for a more engaging story that balanced the western world at the brink of war and the turmoil of opposite personalities clearly being attracted to one another. This was probably one of the more memorable marriages of convenience I've read where the relationship was just as much a meeting of the minds along with physical attraction.
Benedict and Inga are characters who leap off the pages, and their conversations are intellectually fulfilling as they reference the Bible and the church. I appreciate that both of them do their best to protect the other person, which points to their loving selflessness in their actions. Overall, the book focuses heavily on the rapidly progressing movements toward war, providing a glimpse into life before the Great War. Readers who enjoy Camden's rich historical details will find themselves engrossed by life in the embassy and in Inga and Benedict's unconventional yet charming relationship where navigating the nuanced layers of cleverness and discretion in negotiations took on multiple meanings.
Review link: https://christianshelves.blogspot.com...
Benedict and Inga are characters who leap off the pages, and their conversations are intellectually fulfilling as they reference the Bible and the church. I appreciate that both of them do their best to protect the other person, which points to their loving selflessness in their actions. Overall, the book focuses heavily on the rapidly progressing movements toward war, providing a glimpse into life before the Great War. Readers who enjoy Camden's rich historical details will find themselves engrossed by life in the embassy and in Inga and Benedict's unconventional yet charming relationship where navigating the nuanced layers of cleverness and discretion in negotiations took on multiple meanings.
Review link: https://christianshelves.blogspot.com...
February 20, 2025
Elizabeth Camden is probably the queen of making a historical setting live and breathe. I had a hard time putting this one down.
Set in the years before the U.S. entered the first world war, this story follows the household of the American ambassador to Germany, including his secretary Inga and his chief of staff Benedict. Marriage-of-convenience comes into play in the middle of the story. It's all quite compellingly written with EXCELLENT attention to historical events, and I finished the last half of the book in a day.
The book actually varied between 4 and 5 stars for me; I did have an occasional quibble, including Inga's wearying indecisiveness towards the end. But it was definitely one of the best examples of historical fiction I've read in a long time.
Set in the years before the U.S. entered the first world war, this story follows the household of the American ambassador to Germany, including his secretary Inga and his chief of staff Benedict. Marriage-of-convenience comes into play in the middle of the story. It's all quite compellingly written with EXCELLENT attention to historical events, and I finished the last half of the book in a day.
The book actually varied between 4 and 5 stars for me; I did have an occasional quibble, including Inga's wearying indecisiveness towards the end. But it was definitely one of the best examples of historical fiction I've read in a long time.
January 21, 2025
Elizabeth Camden never fails to wow me. She has the ability to incorporate mundane, everyday careers (dentist, police officer, spice manufacturer, translator, botanist, lawyer, etc) into fascinating and captivating stories based on little known historical facts and events. This story was slightly different because the main characters had somewhat glamourous careers in US Embassy in WWI Germany. But the author's eye for detail and her ability to completely engage the reader remained true. I learned so much about US-Germany relations during this time period and loved having a backstage view of the political dealings.
Benedict and Inga were opposites - he a sorrow-embattled, stickler for rules and decorum and she a bright bubble of joy and enthusiasm, driven by compassion. He was the upper class, highly educated intellectual who craved knowledge and she was the lower class who used grit, heart, and determination to make something of herself. Despite their differences and constant bickering, they worked so well together and their disdain turned into respectful friendship then to love. Their romance was sweet and tender. I love marriage of convenience trope and the author did a fantastic job bringing them together in a realistic manner.
If you enjoy historical romance, this book is a must-read. I received a complimentary copy courtesy of Bethany House via NetGalley and was under no obligation to post a positive comment. All opinions are my own.
Benedict and Inga were opposites - he a sorrow-embattled, stickler for rules and decorum and she a bright bubble of joy and enthusiasm, driven by compassion. He was the upper class, highly educated intellectual who craved knowledge and she was the lower class who used grit, heart, and determination to make something of herself. Despite their differences and constant bickering, they worked so well together and their disdain turned into respectful friendship then to love. Their romance was sweet and tender. I love marriage of convenience trope and the author did a fantastic job bringing them together in a realistic manner.
If you enjoy historical romance, this book is a must-read. I received a complimentary copy courtesy of Bethany House via NetGalley and was under no obligation to post a positive comment. All opinions are my own.
January 3, 2025
A grumpy/sunshine marriage of convenience set mostly in Germany at the beginning of WWI, before America takes part. Inga, a German immigrant who has lived in America for most of her life, travels from NY to Berlin to be an assistant to the US Ambassador. Benedict is the grumpy Chief of Staff who keeps everything running as smoothly as possible when the new Ambassador missteps. It’s a fascinating glimpse of the wartime diplomatic roles as Benedict and the Ambassador try to keep the US out of the Great War. It’s combined with a slow burn romance that starts as a marriage of convenience because Inga does not have US citizenship papers. I expected more drama solely because of all the action in the first book, but I really enjoyed this story. It’s book two, but is a complete standalone novel.
I received an advanced copy from the publisher via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
I received an advanced copy from the publisher via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
July 1, 2025
Set in both New York and Berlin during WWI. A captivating story that I really enjoyed.
December 23, 2024
I loved this story by master storyteller Elizabeth Camden! I spent all day reading and loved every minute of this excellent, captivating story!
Inga Klein enjoys her job, dating, and living with girlfriends at the Martha Washington, and loves her life in New York. She came to America as a child with her parents from Germany. Her life changes drastically when Ambassador James Gerards asks her to accompany him and his wife, Mrs Mary Gerards to the American Embassy in Berlin to act as his secretary. He needs someone he can trust to help him, and she excels at typing, shorthand, how to use a wireless, and she knows German.
I loved the inside look at American Embassy life in Berlin just before WWI and how hard Benedict Kincaid, chief diplomatic counselor, and Ambassador Gerards worked to help President Wilson keep the USA out of the war.
Benedict Kincaid is considered a strict, straight-laced, wet blanket, but very good at his job. He is reading through the entire set of the Encyclopedia Britannica for fun. I thoroughly enjoyed the sparring between Inga and Benedict. "She remained aggressively cheerful whenever he entered a room, which seemed to irritate him because Benedict couldn't help being a wet blanket."
"When Stars Light the Sky" is an absolutely sweet romance, opposites attract, marriage of convenience, interesting, bittersweet, historical tale that kept me turning pages. I highly recommend it for lovers of historical fiction and historical romance.
The author writes "When Stars Light the Sky is one of the most powerful and charming love stories I’ve ever written." I wholeheartedly agree!
Thank you to the author, publisher, and Net Galley for allowing me to read an early copy. All opinions are my own.
Inga Klein enjoys her job, dating, and living with girlfriends at the Martha Washington, and loves her life in New York. She came to America as a child with her parents from Germany. Her life changes drastically when Ambassador James Gerards asks her to accompany him and his wife, Mrs Mary Gerards to the American Embassy in Berlin to act as his secretary. He needs someone he can trust to help him, and she excels at typing, shorthand, how to use a wireless, and she knows German.
I loved the inside look at American Embassy life in Berlin just before WWI and how hard Benedict Kincaid, chief diplomatic counselor, and Ambassador Gerards worked to help President Wilson keep the USA out of the war.
Benedict Kincaid is considered a strict, straight-laced, wet blanket, but very good at his job. He is reading through the entire set of the Encyclopedia Britannica for fun. I thoroughly enjoyed the sparring between Inga and Benedict. "She remained aggressively cheerful whenever he entered a room, which seemed to irritate him because Benedict couldn't help being a wet blanket."
"When Stars Light the Sky" is an absolutely sweet romance, opposites attract, marriage of convenience, interesting, bittersweet, historical tale that kept me turning pages. I highly recommend it for lovers of historical fiction and historical romance.
The author writes "When Stars Light the Sky is one of the most powerful and charming love stories I’ve ever written." I wholeheartedly agree!
Thank you to the author, publisher, and Net Galley for allowing me to read an early copy. All opinions are my own.
February 18, 2025
Wow! What an engrossing read! I didn’t want to put it down! This is a great story of life at the embassy in Germany just before the United States became involved in World War I.
I really enjoyed Inga’s delightfully pleasant and upbeat personality. She brought sunshine to every room. Conversely, Benedict was a cloud of gloom and doom. Two more opposite personalities would be hard to find. He’s so annoyed by her and her bright cheerful attitude. She doesn’t let him get her down.
It was heartwarming to see their feelings for each other develop from enemies, to coworkers, to friends to more. There were lots of twists and turns in this story that kept me turning pages. It was my first book by this author, but it certainly won’t be my last.
My thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review this book. All thoughts are my own.
I really enjoyed Inga’s delightfully pleasant and upbeat personality. She brought sunshine to every room. Conversely, Benedict was a cloud of gloom and doom. Two more opposite personalities would be hard to find. He’s so annoyed by her and her bright cheerful attitude. She doesn’t let him get her down.
It was heartwarming to see their feelings for each other develop from enemies, to coworkers, to friends to more. There were lots of twists and turns in this story that kept me turning pages. It was my first book by this author, but it certainly won’t be my last.
My thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review this book. All thoughts are my own.
January 21, 2025
Absolutely phenomenal.
Elizabeth’s books are always full of rich, historical detail and the most swoony of slow burn romances - with strong and intelligent FMCs and MMCs. This was no different. The scene setting as World War I is about to emerge is incredible.
Inga’s light-hearted and uplifting personality is a challenge and yet a complement to Benedict’s serious and “stick-to-business” attitude. Yet, the way their hearts are slowly woven together is so tender, and yet so heady. A couple of favorite things: the enyclopedias, the visit to family, and that final scene. *swoons*
Elizabeth’s books are always full of rich, historical detail and the most swoony of slow burn romances - with strong and intelligent FMCs and MMCs. This was no different. The scene setting as World War I is about to emerge is incredible.
Inga’s light-hearted and uplifting personality is a challenge and yet a complement to Benedict’s serious and “stick-to-business” attitude. Yet, the way their hearts are slowly woven together is so tender, and yet so heady. A couple of favorite things: the enyclopedias, the visit to family, and that final scene. *swoons*
January 23, 2025
In her novel, When Stars Light the Sky, Author Elizabeth Camden has written a delightful and charming historical romance that readers will absolutely love. With her attention to historical detail and the way she brings it to life from the pages, readers will be enraptured with this story that takes place right before WWI starts. A sweet grumpy/sunshine, opposites attract, marriage of convenience, and swoony Gilded Age romance that readers will absolutely not want to put down.
Series: Women in Midtown
Genre: historical, mystery, romance
Publisher: Bethany House
Publication date: January 21
Number of pages: 352
Books in the series:
1-While the City Sleeps
2-When Stars Light the Sky
Disclosure statement: A complimentary review copy of this book was provided from tour groups, publishers, publicists, authors, and others, including NetGalley, OR was borrowed from the library, including OverDrive, Or borrowed from Kindle Unlimited, OR borrowed from Deseret Bookshelf, OR pre-ordered/purchased for review, including Audible. A review was not required and all views and opinions expressed are my own.
Series: Women in Midtown
Genre: historical, mystery, romance
Publisher: Bethany House
Publication date: January 21
Number of pages: 352
Books in the series:
1-While the City Sleeps
2-When Stars Light the Sky
Disclosure statement: A complimentary review copy of this book was provided from tour groups, publishers, publicists, authors, and others, including NetGalley, OR was borrowed from the library, including OverDrive, Or borrowed from Kindle Unlimited, OR borrowed from Deseret Bookshelf, OR pre-ordered/purchased for review, including Audible. A review was not required and all views and opinions expressed are my own.
February 15, 2025
I don’t read as much WWI fiction as I’d like, so I really enjoyed When Stars Light the Sky. Elizabeth Camden offers readers a unique perspective of the war, with Americans working in diplomacy in Germany during tumultuous and, quite honestly, frightening years. I enjoyed Inga and Benedict’s story, and the sneak peek of the next book in this series has me counting the days to its 2026 release. If you enjoy historical fiction with light themes of romance, definitely add Camden’s books to your TBR. 4/5 stars
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
January 24, 2025
Elizabeth Camden’s When Stars Light the Sky is an absolute delight and a shining sequel in The Women of the Midtown Agency series. Following the success of While the City Sleeps, this story sweeps readers into the glittering world of Berlin’s American embassy on the brink of World War I—a setting that feels both luxurious and fraught with tension. Camden’s gift for blending meticulous historical detail with deeply human stories truly shines here.
At the heart of the story are Inga Klein and Benedict Kincaid, two opposites who clash in the best ways possible. Inga’s quick wit and fiery determination are a perfect foil to Benedict’s disciplined, buttoned-up demeanor, making their journey from sparring coworkers to a marriage of convenience irresistibly fun to watch unfold. Their relationship is a masterclass in slow-burn romance, full of chemistry, growth, and moments that will have you laughing one minute and swooning the next.
What made this story truly special was its focus on resilience and finding strength in unexpected partnerships. The marriage of convenience trope can be tricky to nail, but Camden delivers it with all the charm and emotional depth you could hope for. This book is playful, poignant, and perfectly paced—a true page-turner.
I couldn’t put it down. Camden’s writing makes history come alive, her characters feel like old friends, and her stories leave you with a satisfying sense of warmth and hope. When Stars Light the Sky is a must-read for fans of clever historical romance and vibrant, character-driven stories. If you haven’t picked up While the City Sleeps yet, now is the perfect time to dive into this enchanting series!
At the heart of the story are Inga Klein and Benedict Kincaid, two opposites who clash in the best ways possible. Inga’s quick wit and fiery determination are a perfect foil to Benedict’s disciplined, buttoned-up demeanor, making their journey from sparring coworkers to a marriage of convenience irresistibly fun to watch unfold. Their relationship is a masterclass in slow-burn romance, full of chemistry, growth, and moments that will have you laughing one minute and swooning the next.
What made this story truly special was its focus on resilience and finding strength in unexpected partnerships. The marriage of convenience trope can be tricky to nail, but Camden delivers it with all the charm and emotional depth you could hope for. This book is playful, poignant, and perfectly paced—a true page-turner.
I couldn’t put it down. Camden’s writing makes history come alive, her characters feel like old friends, and her stories leave you with a satisfying sense of warmth and hope. When Stars Light the Sky is a must-read for fans of clever historical romance and vibrant, character-driven stories. If you haven’t picked up While the City Sleeps yet, now is the perfect time to dive into this enchanting series!
July 31, 2025
4 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I liked this one just a bit better than the first book. The story was good and I liked the characters. Inga did annoy me at times and the book drug a bit in the middle. Additionally, I was so sad that Benedict gave up his dream (and calling) just because Inga had insecurity issues. I almost gave it 3 stars because of that but I can appreciate the romantic gesture. It just seemed unnecessary. Overall, I did enjoy the book and the audio book narrator does a great job.
I liked this one just a bit better than the first book. The story was good and I liked the characters. Inga did annoy me at times and the book drug a bit in the middle. Additionally, I was so sad that Benedict gave up his dream (and calling) just because Inga had insecurity issues. I almost gave it 3 stars because of that but I can appreciate the romantic gesture. It just seemed unnecessary. Overall, I did enjoy the book and the audio book narrator does a great job.
May 30, 2025
An interesting story of a young woman who is a stenographer in New York who becomes the secretary for the head of the US Embassy in Germany just before World War I breaks out. But German born Inga finds sherself often at odds with the straitlacked and imposing Benedict Kincaid, the chief of Staff in the US Embassy. Will Inga and Benedict learn to work together as well as be friends or will Inga return to the US?
Well written and a totally different perspective as Camden covers the build up to World War I and how it affected all of the embassies as the war developed.
Well written and a totally different perspective as Camden covers the build up to World War I and how it affected all of the embassies as the war developed.
February 26, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️💫
Romance Level: 5
This is my personal opinion. I know many people loved this story, however it just wasn’t for me. Don’t let my review deter you from reading this book if you really want to. It’s an excellent story filled with loveable characters. I just have high expectations when it comes to an author that I’ve read for a long time and who I know has had books filled with rich faith content in the past.
This review is really hard to write, because I love Elizabeth’s books and writing style. This book cover is gorgeous and I was so excited to jump into this book. I love marriage of convenience tropes and WW1 storylines so I was sure this would be my best read of the month.
And at first, it was. The plot was well written and the historical elements were exactly what I’ve come to expect from this author, detailed and meticulously researched. The characters were fun and engaging and complete opposites, which was setting up for a great story.
And then I noticed a few things. The faith content I’ve come to expect from this author was strikingly absent. The characters were making decisions based solely on their surroundings and their own feelings. There was no prayer, no seeking of direction from God. I was a little bit thrown off by that but kept reading, thinking surely they would turn to prayer eventually. They didn’t.
A certain decision was made by the FMC that soured my opinion of her. The MMC was self sacrificing and loving, as you would expect. But it felt like she gave him nothing in return. She took advice from a woman who did not have wise council and made a selfish decision that affected the MMC in a very big way.
So as much as I loved the first three quarters of this book, the last chapters are why my rating is so much lower than usual. I still really liked some elements of the story and I’ll be reading the third book in the series when it comes out, but I am very saddened by the things I felt were lacking in this story.
Romance Level: 5
This is my personal opinion. I know many people loved this story, however it just wasn’t for me. Don’t let my review deter you from reading this book if you really want to. It’s an excellent story filled with loveable characters. I just have high expectations when it comes to an author that I’ve read for a long time and who I know has had books filled with rich faith content in the past.
This review is really hard to write, because I love Elizabeth’s books and writing style. This book cover is gorgeous and I was so excited to jump into this book. I love marriage of convenience tropes and WW1 storylines so I was sure this would be my best read of the month.
And at first, it was. The plot was well written and the historical elements were exactly what I’ve come to expect from this author, detailed and meticulously researched. The characters were fun and engaging and complete opposites, which was setting up for a great story.
And then I noticed a few things. The faith content I’ve come to expect from this author was strikingly absent. The characters were making decisions based solely on their surroundings and their own feelings. There was no prayer, no seeking of direction from God. I was a little bit thrown off by that but kept reading, thinking surely they would turn to prayer eventually. They didn’t.
A certain decision was made by the FMC that soured my opinion of her. The MMC was self sacrificing and loving, as you would expect. But it felt like she gave him nothing in return. She took advice from a woman who did not have wise council and made a selfish decision that affected the MMC in a very big way.
So as much as I loved the first three quarters of this book, the last chapters are why my rating is so much lower than usual. I still really liked some elements of the story and I’ll be reading the third book in the series when it comes out, but I am very saddened by the things I felt were lacking in this story.
January 17, 2025
This intriguing book showed what it was like to be in Berlin in the American Embassy just before WWI.
Inga was a German-born girl who settled in New York. She became the secretary to the Ambassador to Berlin. Diplomatic chief of staff to Ambassador Gerards, Benedict, is a very blunt, businesslike man. The diplomatic contingent is doing all it can to keep American neutral. But as war looms, Inga fears she will not be able to return to America, since she has not followed through with her citizenship status. A marriage in name only to Benedict seems the only solution.
It was very interesting to note that this book was partly based on the memoirs of the real Ambassador Gerards. The author did a great job of conveying the tension between the Embassy staff and the German rulers at the time that was critical in our nation’s history.
I loved the way the romance developed and how Inga struggled to feel smart enough and worthy enough to be the wife of a diplomat. And Benedict was an admirable hero who was patient even though he was struggling with a past that was affecting his present relationship with Inga.
This is another well written historical to add to my favorites list.
*A complimentary copy of this book was provided by Bethany House on behalf of the author and a NetGalley copy through Interviews and Reviews. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are mine alone.*
Inga was a German-born girl who settled in New York. She became the secretary to the Ambassador to Berlin. Diplomatic chief of staff to Ambassador Gerards, Benedict, is a very blunt, businesslike man. The diplomatic contingent is doing all it can to keep American neutral. But as war looms, Inga fears she will not be able to return to America, since she has not followed through with her citizenship status. A marriage in name only to Benedict seems the only solution.
It was very interesting to note that this book was partly based on the memoirs of the real Ambassador Gerards. The author did a great job of conveying the tension between the Embassy staff and the German rulers at the time that was critical in our nation’s history.
I loved the way the romance developed and how Inga struggled to feel smart enough and worthy enough to be the wife of a diplomat. And Benedict was an admirable hero who was patient even though he was struggling with a past that was affecting his present relationship with Inga.
This is another well written historical to add to my favorites list.
*A complimentary copy of this book was provided by Bethany House on behalf of the author and a NetGalley copy through Interviews and Reviews. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are mine alone.*
March 15, 2025
4.5 ⭐️! Camden’s historical novels are always interesting—but I particularly enjoyed that this one featured a refreshing take on a WWI story through the perspective of an American ambassador’s experience in Berlin. Plus a marriage of convenience and enemies to lovers?? Sign me up!
Audio: pretty good!
Content: kissing, occasional reference to consummation but no actual scene, lite faith content, recommended for married readers since it is a marriage of convenience and they end up sharing a bed at one point though only snuggling happens
Audio: pretty good!
Content: kissing, occasional reference to consummation but no actual scene, lite faith content, recommended for married readers since it is a marriage of convenience and they end up sharing a bed at one point though only snuggling happens
February 12, 2025
Marriage-of-convenience plus World War 1 plus Elizabeth Camden? I could not read When Stars Light the Sky fast enough, while at the same time wanting the story to go on forever. Benedict and Inga are like oil and water at first, which means sparks fly whenever they’re together. Whether it’s the sparks of annoyance or attraction makes no difference to me because any form of fireworks between them makes for some delicious romantic tension. By the time a marriage of convenience is necessary to allow Inga to leave Germany safely, I think they were already half in love (though I equally think they would both argue otherwise). Goodness knows I was completely enamored with the two of them together, especially as straitlaced Benedict’s softer side begins to show in the wake of his growing fascination with Inga. Let’s just say that I have never loved reading an encyclopedia more. Ok, I could gush about these two for days, but there’s so much more to this novel that deserves my attention as well.
I always love the unique historical elements that Camden incorporates into her stories, and in When Stars Light the Sky we are given a front row seat to diplomatic relations in Berlin from the first stirrings of the Great War to the sinking of the Lusitania and right up to the moment that America could no longer remain neutral. I was really intrigued by the tightrope that they had to walk and the constant potential for setting off an international incident even by accident, and I became so grateful for the real men & human who navigated it as long as they did to protect America. While Benedict and Inga are sadly fictional, the story does revolve around the real US Ambassador to Germany, James Gerard and his wife Mary. Their early gaffes provided the perfect reason for Camden to bring Inga’s character from New York to Germany, which put her right smack dab in Benedict’s path … and now we’re back to me gushing over how delightful the two of them were together.
Bottom Line: Fans of opposites attract, enemies to more, forced proximity, and marriage of convenience romances rejoice! When Stars Light the Sky by Elizabeth Camden sweeps readers up in a swoony love story set against a contrasting backdrop of glamour and gravitas. As America creeps ever closer to entering the first World War, compelling characters like Benedict and Inga take us into the heart of an American embassy and the tireless efforts to maintain diplomacy for as long as possible. I enjoyed getting a different, more personal, perspective on these international relationships and pivotal events than I was taught in my history textbooks, and I once again found things that I want to research more on my own. Most of all, though, I stayed completely besotted with the fan-worthy romantic tension between Benedict and Inga and I’m shallow enough to freely admit it. Elizabeth Camden always writes such exquisite stories, and When Stars Light the Sky is no exception!
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
first reviewed at Reading Is My SuperPower
I always love the unique historical elements that Camden incorporates into her stories, and in When Stars Light the Sky we are given a front row seat to diplomatic relations in Berlin from the first stirrings of the Great War to the sinking of the Lusitania and right up to the moment that America could no longer remain neutral. I was really intrigued by the tightrope that they had to walk and the constant potential for setting off an international incident even by accident, and I became so grateful for the real men & human who navigated it as long as they did to protect America. While Benedict and Inga are sadly fictional, the story does revolve around the real US Ambassador to Germany, James Gerard and his wife Mary. Their early gaffes provided the perfect reason for Camden to bring Inga’s character from New York to Germany, which put her right smack dab in Benedict’s path … and now we’re back to me gushing over how delightful the two of them were together.
Bottom Line: Fans of opposites attract, enemies to more, forced proximity, and marriage of convenience romances rejoice! When Stars Light the Sky by Elizabeth Camden sweeps readers up in a swoony love story set against a contrasting backdrop of glamour and gravitas. As America creeps ever closer to entering the first World War, compelling characters like Benedict and Inga take us into the heart of an American embassy and the tireless efforts to maintain diplomacy for as long as possible. I enjoyed getting a different, more personal, perspective on these international relationships and pivotal events than I was taught in my history textbooks, and I once again found things that I want to research more on my own. Most of all, though, I stayed completely besotted with the fan-worthy romantic tension between Benedict and Inga and I’m shallow enough to freely admit it. Elizabeth Camden always writes such exquisite stories, and When Stars Light the Sky is no exception!
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
first reviewed at Reading Is My SuperPower
January 24, 2025
I'm going to say this right now: if you love Pride and Prejudice, Benedict is our Mr. Darcy!
I'm getting ahead of myself though. When Stars Lights the Sky begins shortly before WWI when Inga is offered a job as the ambassador to Germany's secretary. In fact, Inga is from neighboring Bavaria, so going to Berlin is very nostalgic.
There she encounters the broody Benedict, whom she affectionately calls Cold Oats. Though her sunshine demeanor is almost impenetrable to his cool exterior.
What would she say if she knew she was in fact melting him away?
It gets more complicated when WWI begins and the US is declared as neutral and they are in an Axis country. Together, Benedict and Inga try to essentially save the world by navigating the waters and offering assistance to war prisoners.
But what will happen when it's Inga who's in trouble and Benedict is her only solution?
I really feel like this is going to be one of my top for 2025, I couldn't get enough of Inga and Benedict. I need MORE!!!
I'm getting ahead of myself though. When Stars Lights the Sky begins shortly before WWI when Inga is offered a job as the ambassador to Germany's secretary. In fact, Inga is from neighboring Bavaria, so going to Berlin is very nostalgic.
There she encounters the broody Benedict, whom she affectionately calls Cold Oats. Though her sunshine demeanor is almost impenetrable to his cool exterior.
What would she say if she knew she was in fact melting him away?
It gets more complicated when WWI begins and the US is declared as neutral and they are in an Axis country. Together, Benedict and Inga try to essentially save the world by navigating the waters and offering assistance to war prisoners.
But what will happen when it's Inga who's in trouble and Benedict is her only solution?
I really feel like this is going to be one of my top for 2025, I couldn't get enough of Inga and Benedict. I need MORE!!!
February 5, 2025
Elizabeth Camden is one of my go to authors for great historical fiction. Her stories are always entertaining and interesting and I usually learn about historical events etc. “When Stars Light the Sky” was a fun read. I liked the character development and the story being mostly set in Germany in the days leading up to World War 1 made for a compelling story. A bit of a “look behind the curtain” for diplomatic events at the American embassy is definitely a storyline I haven’t read before and it was a fun read for me as stories around the World Wars always intrigue me. Can’t wait to see what Elizabeth weaves for book 3!
I received a copy of this book from the publisher and was not required to post a positive review. All thoughts are my own.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher and was not required to post a positive review. All thoughts are my own.
January 23, 2025
I absolutely adored this book! Camden does a great job of combining historical events with a wonderful romance to create a fantastic story.
Based on real events in the years prior to the U.S. entering World War I, the story was a riveting page turner. It was fascinating to learn more about the international diplomatic relationships between countries and how they affected history.
The character development was excellent. I loved Inga and Benedict! Their marriage of convenience, opposites attract relationship, and verbal sparring and witty banter, was an absolute delight. There’s a great cast of secondary characters that added a lot of interest to the story.
The author’s meticulous historical research and attention to details was obvious, and her writing is very engaging. This gem of a story reminded me why I love historical romance fiction. Highly recommended!
I received a gifted copy from Bethany House Fiction and Austenprose PR, but a positive review wasn’t required.
Based on real events in the years prior to the U.S. entering World War I, the story was a riveting page turner. It was fascinating to learn more about the international diplomatic relationships between countries and how they affected history.
The character development was excellent. I loved Inga and Benedict! Their marriage of convenience, opposites attract relationship, and verbal sparring and witty banter, was an absolute delight. There’s a great cast of secondary characters that added a lot of interest to the story.
The author’s meticulous historical research and attention to details was obvious, and her writing is very engaging. This gem of a story reminded me why I love historical romance fiction. Highly recommended!
I received a gifted copy from Bethany House Fiction and Austenprose PR, but a positive review wasn’t required.
April 1, 2025
I loved the first book in this series but felt like this one didn’t really correlate to the first book or characters until the end, unless I’m just forgetting the first book, but it seemed different in a way. I would still read #3 book when it comes out but I was really hoping for a grand slam series and this one wasn’t a top fav.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 200 reviews