This is the story mainly of two people, which also includes the pov of other people in their lives. It is the story of how grief and loss has controlled much of their lives:
“Juliette’s grief is fresh, still warm like blood just out of the body, whereas Noah’s is old, childhood grief, ossified into the bone around which all new emotional tissue has grown. But they recognize something in each other, she thinks—the existential wound of motherless kids, maybe.”
It is the story of “How more than one thing can be true in the same breath." Ch 48, as both Juliette and Noah each have painful stories, and both want to have a better, or a different future, at times. They can see the same event in a different way, that alters both of their lives. This main event doesn’t happen until about 60% into the book, so there is a lot of world building and backstory before you get there, specifically with those other people in their lives - esp Noah’s girlfriend Jesse, Juliette’s best friend / lover Annie, Juliette’s other romances. This leads the reader to question if there is someone who is 100% right ? Or can both people have some version of the truth that is true to them? In any case, you read how their pain caused so much pain to others.
“Living someone else's life gives her the fire she needs to fight for her own, the fire she to burn through the grief and become the woman her father raised.” Ch 8
“It is not until now that Jesse can fully taste her own hunger. Like many women, she had learned to dampen her ambition, even in the privacy of her own room.” Ch 10
“Why don't they understand: anger has to go somewhere. Rage can't be swallowed forever.” Ch 21
“Jesse is cast as a character, and the life she made, the man she married, all of it is food now for the starved people sitting in front of their computer screens at desks in corporate offices, in coffee shops, in bed with the light of their phones.” Ch 38
“She wants to hold on to her anger. For her, for Juliette, for her mother. What does she have without it? A bottomless sadness.” Ch 48
Thank you to Libro.fm and Zibby books for providing copies to librarians!