I received this book free from Houghton Mifflin Harcourt publishing company in exchange for a review.
Overall, I felt like this was an informative book that does a good job of pointing out the dangers of what Michelangelo Signorile refers to as “victory blindness.” He explains something that I have been trying to tell my friends in the community and my friends and family who are our allies from some time now, and he explains it well. The fight for equality for the LGBT community is long from over and if we back off now and continue to settle for small victories and treat them as if they are huge victories and let “victory blindness” take hold of us then we will start to find ourselves taking steps backward instead of continuing to take steps forward, and Signorile makes that clear.
However, I did have a few issues with the book. One of the issues I had is when Signorile discusses the infamous “don’t say gay bill” in Tennessee. He says, “the bill would have forced kids out of the closet to families who might be conservative and anti-gay and might put them into harmful conversion therapy programs or, perhaps, even throw them out on the street.” This statement is true… mostly. My issue with it is that… whether this is what Signorile intended or not, to me the statement comes across sounding like the only families that could possibly be anti-gay, the only parents that would want to put their kids through conversion therapy or kick their kids out are conservative parents. Perhaps that often is the case, but it is not ALWAYS the case and simply because somebody is liberal does not automatically mean that they will be accepting and won’t kick their gay child out of the house or force them into conversion therapy. Such was the case for me when I came out. Much of my family is largely conservative and yet they all accepted me with arms wide open and many of them have been and are very vocal in their support for the LGBT community. The only person who did not accept me was my mother, who is very liberal in every other sense of the word and yet she still insisted that I had to move back in with her so that she could get me into one of those harmful conversion therapy programs. I have said to people in the past and I will say it again now: whether a person accepts us or not is NOT a matter of political orientation but in most cases more a matter of their religion. My mother is very religious, always has been… often times to extremes. Both my Dad and I on the other hand are Pagan… a religion that in any of its forms pretty much demands that we are loving and accepting of all regardless of their differences, and while the rest of my family is Catholic, they are not so religious to the point where they let it control their lives and let the hatred that is often preached from Catholicism take hold of them and lead them down a path of hate and bigotry as it has so many others like my mother. While politics and politicians (on BOTH sides… or all sides I should say) are guilty of leading people down a path of hate (sometimes intentionally)… when it comes to the LGBT community and the hatred we face, I think it’s safe to say that it is without a doubt religion and NOT political orientation that leads people to direct so much hatred and bigotry toward us.
The only other thing that really bothered me in the book was that Signorile seems to condemn the act of outing in one breath and condone it in the next. He discusses the dangers of the “don’t say gay” bill in Tennessee would have, encouraging teachers, counselors, etc. to out students to their parents. But in the next chapter he says, “it is increasingly not legally considered harmful to even falsely say that a public figure is gay.” Through much of the chapter he goes on encouraging the media to step up and out celebrities and public figures as if such an act would have no negative effect on them at all (and again, that may not be how he intended for his words to come across, but that is how they came across to me)… and that simply is not true. Don’t get me wrong, it is important for celebrities and public figures to come out. They are role models for many people young and old and if those people see their role models come out then it may encourage them to be more accepting of LGBT people as well as help young people in their own process of coming out. However, coming out can be a very emotional process and that doesn’t change simply because somebody is in the public eye and it should be up to those public figures to come out on THEIR time when THEY are ready… not when the media is ready to out them. I will admit, however, that I agree when Signorile goes on later in the chapter to point out the issue with and hypocrisy of anti-gay politicians who are themselves gay or bisexual. I think the case is different with such individuals. When celebrities decide to stay in the closet… or what Signorile refers to as the “glass closet,” it is typically for personal emotional reasons or for career reasons. And yes, perhaps they are slowing down our ability to move forward faster by making the choice to stay in the closet longer… but they aren’t actually really hurting anybody. It’s different with closeted gay and bisexual politicians. They are hurting the rest of us by using their power to stop or reverse our progress or pushing and passing bills that give religious individuals the right to deny us service or bills that would kick open out bedroom doors calling for the criminalization of gay sex… all while participating in gay sex behind closed doors… or even in public in some cases. Those individuals ARE hurting us and their actions do need to be exposed.
I found myself nodding my head with much of the rest of the book, particularly with the chapter on self-defense. Two often it seems that we simply lay down and take the constant bullying and bashing instead of fighting back and saying enough is enough and putting the bullies in their place. I think too often we rely too heavily on others to jump in and save the day and fight back for us. But it doesn’t always work that way. While teachers and administrators do (or should) have an obligation to ensure that schools are safe environments and parents have (or should have) an obligation to raise their kids not to be bullies, they don’t always follow through on those obligations even when they are pressured to follow through on them. It should have to be this way, but sometimes it’s up to us to stand up for ourselves… which isn’t really anything new. I grew up hearing stories from family members who now shake their heads in disappointment at the amount of bullying we all hear about… not because there is more of it, but rather because when they were my age or when they were in high school they didn’t put up with the bullying. There was a time when if somebody was getting bullied, regardless of the reason, the victim didn’t hesitate to fight back and neither did other students who witnessed it. But things have changed. We aren’t willing to stand up for ourselves the way people once were and I think part of what has made us less willing to fight back is not only a sense of weakness but also the fact that going back a few years, victims of bullying didn’t get in trouble for defending themselves… but now it seems, at least in my experience and hearing stories from others, that when the victim of bullying finally does say enough is enough and slugs the bullying or gets in the bully’s face even just verbally, either both the bully and the victim get in trouble or the victim gets in trouble and the bully walks away with little more than a slap on the wrist. This does nothing to encourage people to stand up for themselves, instead it encourages victims to feel weak and helpless and encourages them simply keep their mouth shut and their hands at their side and take the bullying until they simply can’t take it anymore and are driven to take their own life instead. Not only do we need to fight to put an end to bullying, but we need to fight for the victims of bullying to have their right to defend themselves without being punished for it returned to them.
All that said, this is a book that I would absolutely recommend that everybody in the LGBT community and our allies read, especially those who find themselves giving in to “victory blindness.” And hopefully those that do read will have their eyes opened to the dangerous of giving in or backing off rather than continuing to fight hard for the equality that we all deserve.