Of Wolves and Stags is the kind of book I would have absolutely adored as a young teenager. Fast-paced, full of action, and with twists that feel fully emotionally wrought and resonant, I found this book quite enjoyable. I would say, without a doubt, that this book is best enjoyed by younger YA readers (at the time of posting, this is tagged as YA in NetGalley but Adult in Goodreads); the language used is simple, the plot relatively uncomplicated, the twists spelled out, and the romantic subplots most similar to middle-grade books that I have read. It’s the sort of book I wish I had read when I was in my early teens: body-positive, inclusive, and deeply humanizing.
This book follows Dalia, an older teenage orphan residing in a small northern fishing village. Much of her past is lost to her, blocked in her memories, but she knows a few things: she is a Crystalline, a magic user, made through abuse by the ruling Elven government for the purpose of powering weapons. She knows she escaped from the Elven camp 10 years ago and has been in hiding since. She knows her older sister, a fire user who helped her flee the camp, told her 10 years ago to wait for her on the northernmost tip of the land. She knows her sister has not appeared since. Dalia’s life changes when she finds a young man on the beach, burned and dying, and uses her magic to heal him. Thus, kicks off her adventure: of rebel camps and Elven hunts, of mysteries solved and secrets revealed.
In a lot of ways, this book feels right in line with the YA books I remember reading when I was younger. The heroine with special powers approaches a new side of the world she has never seen before and, in doing so, uncovers secrets and plot twists and the mysteries of her own past. This being a lot of the book, it’s often a pretty typical read, though a good example of these kinds of plots.
Where this book really shines is in the secrets it reveals. I can’t get into too much detail here as much of this is revealed late in the book, but I’ll do my best to explain. As Dalia gets to know the people of the Stag’s camp, she uncovers plot twists about characters’ pasts and motivations. Rather than being merely shock value, I found these plot twists to be really effective examinations of guilt, complicity, greed, and power. For example, when Dalia meets someone who sees her, a magic user, only for their utility in a greater fight, she rightfully recognizes the dehumanization at play. However, rather than stopping there, she also begins to see the way an ally is similarly objectifying her: in the way that ally will not stand up for her, in the ally’s possessiveness and overall psyche. Though things like this could read as a plot twist for the sake of a plot twist, I found it to be a really strong exploration of how marginalization can be expressed even by those who legitimately care about you. The book is full of ideas like this that I think are especially effective for a YA audience.
Where this book fell short is in the ending, as well as some of the implications of the ending. First of all, while I don’t see any evidence that this book has definite plans for a sequel, the ending needs one. So much happens at the end with a good number of threads hanging loose, but, the way the ending is written, it is unclear if the loose threads are the sign of a sequel or ideas that will never be resolved. I hope the book will get a sequel to feel fully resolved. My second issue is with the way an enemy group is handled. I don’t want to get too deep into this as I don’t want to spoil anything, but a theme of this book is understanding what makes a person deserving of forgiveness. Towards the end of the book, there is a lot of trust placed in a person or group who, as written, does not deserve even a hint of trust or mercy. This is one of the plot threads that feels loose at the end, as I wanted to see why certain choices were made in regard to this person or group. As written, it feels strange and somewhat undercuts the stronger parts of the book.
In the end, I am giving this book 4 stars. I appreciated it for what it was as an adult reader, and really see the strengths this book has to offer the right audience. I recommend this book for YA audiences as it is the kind of book I would have really enjoyed at that age.
Thank you to the publisher for providing a free eARC through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.