I have to be honest and admit that I struggled quite a bit with this duet—not in the sense that I couldn’t get through it, but in the sense that I found myself feeling frustrated with certain aspects of the story. I’ve tried to sit with my thoughts on this for a while to really digest all of my emotions, and still find myself disappointed. Let’s talk about it.
1. The Initial Setup
I found it immediately off-putting that this story starts with our FMC being, essentially, forced by her parents to move into a house of her own almost forty minutes away from them. Perhaps it’s the immigrant in me that finds it appalling and confusing that loving parents would do this to their daughter (who is not even of legal drinking age in the U.S.)—their daughter that was kidnapped and missing for years, brutally traumatized during that time, who had to spend over a year in a psychiatric facility because of how suicidal the experience made her.
It just seemed wildly counterintuitive that this would be beneficial to her at all given that it’s happening against her will, is forcing her to once again feel isolated (in the same ways she did when she was kidnapped), and doesn’t seem like something a parent in this situation would willing to do, let alone actively want to do.
This also is hand-in-hand with my issue of therapy in this duet—or the lack thereof. I immediately clocked, early on in the first book, that our FMC was not actively going to therapy—at least not in any meaningful way in the story. Quite frankly, I could not get past the mere idea that a young woman who went through as brutal a trauma as our FMC did would not actively be going to therapy to help work through her issues, especially if she had spent such a long time in treatment prior to being with her parents again. Which makes my original point even more glaring; you’d think her parents would be prioritizing therapy over forcing her to move out on her own.
I’m well aware that our FMC living on her own is the catalyst for the guys returning into her life and for the romance that ensues, but I don’t think it’s good enough.
2. Adam & Our Kidnapper
I think the majority of readers went into book two with the assumption that Adam was probably the kidnapper—I mean, why else would the author suddenly introduce a man that was best friends with the FMC’s father back in the day as a part of the story? More specifically to introduce him right after the FMC is hurt seeing ‘Mr. M’ again for the first time, with him miraculously finding her, and then suddenly remaining in her life?
So, you continue to read and narrow your eyes every time Adam makes another appearance in the second book, gears churning in your mind and disgust brewing in your gut. Because you’re convinced he’s got something to do with this. Why else would this RANDOM man keep appearing, even when he has no real depth to add to the story?
I’m genuinely not sure if this was meant to be a red herring and ‘trick’ the reader, or if the author just genuinely didn’t realize what she was doing with him while she wrote her book. But in the end, Adam is literally just a dude who was friends with her parents, and our real kidnapper was just a dude that goes completely unexplained.
3. The Kidnapping
We don’t really get a lot of details. Now, I want to be very clear that I’m not looking for graphic or highly triggering descriptions of what our FMC went through. I think that it can be difficult to stomach that kind of content sometimes and, quite frankly, there is enough violence against women in all sorts of media that we don’t need to weigh this story down with trauma p*rn.
However, we don’t really get any sort of insight into what happened. Our kidnapper is literally a nobody—I don’t think we even get a real name for him. We don’t know who he is or what his motivations are. We don’t know if he was watching our FMC for a while before he first kidnapped her, or if it was a crime of opportunity. We don’t know what he really wanted from her… A slave? From the details we do get, it seems like he wanted her to cook, clean, and stay quiet in the basement otherwise. We also get that this man is somehow incredible at changing his appearance and disguising himself.
These are all random facts that are thrown into the story, but when combined, don’t really paint a clear picture of who this man is. And I get it—he’s not the story, our FMC is. Fuck this dude. But I still find it to be a necessary part of the story that we should get some clear idea of, given that this is part of the FMC’s past and present. To me, it just feels like it wasn’t properly planned out or given enough detail in the author’s outlines and mind map, and therefore it makes the story weaker.
As an afterthought to this point, the author tries to make it explicitly clear that the FMC did NOT face any sort of sexual abuse while kidnapped. There’s not enough empirical, peer-reviewed data to suggest actual statistics on this, but it does feel a little unbelievable. More specifically, I kept catching on to this because it seemed like the author kept this component out of her trauma to aid in the romantic aspect of the story.
4. Is she unknown?
This maybe goes along a bit with the previous point, but I want to give it it’s own section. I found myself genuinely confused in this duet about how much of our FMC is publicly known. The information within the duet is contradictory.
-In book one, when the guys find out she’s alive, they’re relieved and adamant about seeing her immediately. When her parents come clean that she’s been back for over two years, the guys are mad. This sets up canonical information that when our FMC escaped, her identity was kept hidden—hidden to the point that her four best friends, who have been hopeful for her return all this time, had no clue that she was already back home with her parents.
-Later in book one, she goes out with the guys, and some random teenage boy immediately recognizes her as the kidnapping victim of this killer who escaped. This sets up new, canonical information that our FMC’s identity is known enough that a true crime fan could immediately clock her identity.
-In book two, the guys find news articles about her rescue and state that there’s some information about her but that it was very hard to find without looking for it.
As a reader, you’re left with a host of questions and concerns.
-What information of hers was actually released to the public, especially given the perpetrator is still actively at large?
-Given that he’s still out there, there is no reasonable explanation for her not being in some sort of WISTEC program to protect her, especially now that his victims are being killed.
-If some random teenage boy in Provo could recognize her, did NO ONE in Heber know she was back? This duet confirms that her parents still live in her childhood home, and so the assumption is that the neighbors would probably know she was back. Which begs the question, how did the guys not know? The excuse that her parents didn’t call isn’t good enough, when anyone else could have. Anyone could have posted about it online, too—which goes back to a concern for her safety given that this man is still out there.
I’m not looking for a perfect book with not a single flaw to be found or question to be had. But I should NOT have this many questions and concerns, which feel glaringly obvious as unanswered and potentially just plot holes.
5. The Relationship…
The relationship between our FMC and her guys really hinges on the fact that they were best friends before she was kidnapped, and that there was already a potential relationship blooming between the five of them. This is meant to explain why our FMC is so quick to trust the guys and let them into her life and why their relationships progress so quickly (both emotionally and physically).
Except, we don’t see their relationship before. We only see it now. So you don’t really get good relationship growth because the relationships are sort of predetermined by their past, and we’re not privvy to that.
And while I appreciate when an author doesn’t try to write perfect and unrealistic characters, there were multiple instances where the guys’ behavior towards Nina and her trauma and trauma responses felt a little to hot-headed and not understanding enough. I wasn’t a huge fan of this.
6. Unnecessary Duet
Both books are less than 250 pages, I believe, so I think two books is a bit unnecessary when it could have just been one book with the content we do have. That being said, to have this be a more successful story, I think the author *should* have kept this a duet, but should have made the story more robust.
I think it would have been more powerful for us, as readers, to have gotten:
-More of the FMC and the guys before the kidnapping. We’re told multiple times that they were very close and that there was a blossoming relationship happening between them already. It would have been more emotional for us to have seen some of this, to help us understand just why the guys care so much, why our FMC is struggling to believe they’ll still want her, etc.
-As previously mentioned, more about the actual kidnapping would have been great. Even more about our FMC after being found, while being in the psychiatric hospital, etc. We’re sort of thrown from her escaping to her years later in the present, and I think it makes the story not as powerful.
-In the same vein, I would have loved more build up into her growing fear of being watched and feeling unsafe. It would have been interesting to see her start to open up and live life more, and then retreat in a way that worries those around her and has them question her. I think the author tried to do this, but with so few words in the entire duet, this doesn’t get explored well.
-More therapy. Our FMC’s internal monologues about how she’s struggling are great. They feel raw and real. But I would have loved to see her working through this more with a professional and even her parents, as opposed to it literally just being that the guys come back into her life and fix her, which is more or less what happens.
7. The Epilogue
I’ll keep this part short because it’s personal preference more than anything, but I’m not a fan of the happy ending just suddenly appearing this way and being years in the future and she has KIDS. I think it’s a bit off kilter from the rest of the story, honestly, not to mention that I don’t think kids need to be part of HEAs