Very nice to listen to Alan Watts, not just for his iconic voice and cadence but he takes you on a journey and makes good use of examples to see things differently (often a more eastern perspective).
Here, he unpacks the concept of ‘Maya’, an idea commonly associated with the world being an illusion. He shows goes through all its meanings from measurement, play, magic, art etc.
He shows through common thread of philosophical thought how there are illusions of division, where we divide the world so we can measure it, but those separations are arbitrary. Or how we group things together in abstractions which are equally arbitrary, like water running through a whirlpool, is in constant motion but staying in one place. He separates these ideas and shows can either extreme can lead to error. The answer is a balance.
“You cannot use the language of illusion. That is to say, the language of accurate separative description too far without getting into confusion. Push your nominalism and it becomes realism. Push your scientific materialism and it becomes mysticism.”
His conclusion is a Buddhist one. That all is one. Maya suggests two conclusions:
1) life is not ultimately serious.
2) you in your heart of hearts are god.
I think this is an example of how you can get overexcited from analysing the limits of philosophy. I do enjoy how he balances both extremes and shows the problem in each view but it’s is almost like his philosophy is to do away with the tension by delving into mysticism. It is a psychological resolution but not a complete one. Removing responsibility can be liberating but will also leave us ‘unmoored’ in the sense of Nietzsche’s madman.