What do you think?
Rate this book
The Emmett Till Case
Summer 1955. The murder of a young Black teenager becomes a pivotal moment in American history.
At the end of August 1955, the lifeless and disfigured body of a teenager was fished out of the Tallahatchie River in Mississippi. The body was that of Emmett Till, a fourteen-year-old Black boy from Chicago who had come to spend the vacations with his mother's family. A few days earlier, he had been seen in conversation with Carolyn Bryant, a young white shopkeeper, to whom, according to some witnesses, he had made advances. Roy Bryant, her husband, and J.W. Milam, her brother-in-law, picked up Till in the middle of the night at his uncle's house. He was never seen alive again.
The two men were quickly arrested and brought to trial. A month later, a jury of twelve white men acquitted them after an hour-long deliberation. Seventy years later, the Till case has become a milestone in American civil rights history. But the criminal case is still not entirely solved as new elements continue to emerge. The Till case will weigh heavily on American history for many years to come.
50 States of France’s leading true crime journalists investigate America’s most notorious cases, one for every state in the Union, offering up fresh perspectives on famously storied crimes and reflecting, in the process, a dark national legacy that leads from coast to coast.
At the end of August 1955, the lifeless and disfigured body of a teenager was fished out of the Tallahatchie River in Mississippi. The body was that of Emmett Till, a fourteen-year-old Black boy from Chicago who had come to spend the vacations with his mother's family. A few days earlier, he had been seen in conversation with Carolyn Bryant, a young white shopkeeper, to whom, according to some witnesses, he had made advances. Roy Bryant, her husband, and J.W. Milam, her brother-in-law, picked up Till in the middle of the night at his uncle's house. He was never seen alive again.
The two men were quickly arrested and brought to trial. A month later, a jury of twelve white men acquitted them after an hour-long deliberation. Seventy years later, the Till case has become a milestone in American civil rights history. But the criminal case is still not entirely solved as new elements continue to emerge. The Till case will weigh heavily on American history for many years to come.
50 States of France’s leading true crime journalists investigate America’s most notorious cases, one for every state in the Union, offering up fresh perspectives on famously storied crimes and reflecting, in the process, a dark national legacy that leads from coast to coast.
- GenresNonfiction
240 pages, Paperback
Published September 2, 2025
1 person is currently reading
13 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 of 1 review
July 4, 2025
Book Review: The Emmett Till Case by Jean-Marie Pottier & Lynn E. Palermo
Rating: 4.5/5
A searing and meticulously researched examination of one of America’s most harrowing crimes, The Emmett Till Case transcends true crime tropes to deliver a profound meditation on racial violence, historical memory, and the unfinished work of justice. Pottier and Palermo, with their outsider perspective as French journalists, offer a fresh yet unflinching lens on the 1955 lynching that galvanized the Civil Rights Movement—a narrative that feels both historically grounded and painfully urgent today.
What struck me most was the book’s balance: it neither sensationalizes Till’s murder nor reduces it to a mere footnote in history. Instead, the authors weave together courtroom transcripts, archival press coverage, and contemporary reflections to expose how systemic racism orchestrated both the crime and its aftermath. Their prose is taut yet evocative, particularly in passages reconstructing the terror of Till’s abduction and the grotesque theater of the trial. I found myself alternating between rage (at the jury’s obscene acquittal) and awe (at Mamie Till-Mobley’s defiant decision to display her son’s mutilated body, forcing the world to witness the truth).
The book’s greatest strength lies in its refusal to treat the case as a closed chapter. By highlighting recent developments—like the 2017 revelation that Carolyn Bryant recanted her testimony—the authors underscore how historical injustices continue to reverberate. That said, I occasionally wished for deeper analysis of Till’s cultural legacy in art and activism (e.g., parallels to modern movements like Black Lives Matter). The translation, while fluid, occasionally flattens the emotional weight of key moments—a minor critique for an otherwise masterful work.
The Emmett Till Case is essential reading, not just for true crime enthusiasts but for anyone grappling with America’s legacy of racial violence. It’s a book that lingers, demanding reflection on how far we’ve come—and how far we haven’t.
Thank you to the publisher W. W. Norton and Edelweiss for the advance copy. This is history written with the precision of journalism and the moral clarity of a manifesto.
Rating: 4.5/5
A searing and meticulously researched examination of one of America’s most harrowing crimes, The Emmett Till Case transcends true crime tropes to deliver a profound meditation on racial violence, historical memory, and the unfinished work of justice. Pottier and Palermo, with their outsider perspective as French journalists, offer a fresh yet unflinching lens on the 1955 lynching that galvanized the Civil Rights Movement—a narrative that feels both historically grounded and painfully urgent today.
What struck me most was the book’s balance: it neither sensationalizes Till’s murder nor reduces it to a mere footnote in history. Instead, the authors weave together courtroom transcripts, archival press coverage, and contemporary reflections to expose how systemic racism orchestrated both the crime and its aftermath. Their prose is taut yet evocative, particularly in passages reconstructing the terror of Till’s abduction and the grotesque theater of the trial. I found myself alternating between rage (at the jury’s obscene acquittal) and awe (at Mamie Till-Mobley’s defiant decision to display her son’s mutilated body, forcing the world to witness the truth).
The book’s greatest strength lies in its refusal to treat the case as a closed chapter. By highlighting recent developments—like the 2017 revelation that Carolyn Bryant recanted her testimony—the authors underscore how historical injustices continue to reverberate. That said, I occasionally wished for deeper analysis of Till’s cultural legacy in art and activism (e.g., parallels to modern movements like Black Lives Matter). The translation, while fluid, occasionally flattens the emotional weight of key moments—a minor critique for an otherwise masterful work.
The Emmett Till Case is essential reading, not just for true crime enthusiasts but for anyone grappling with America’s legacy of racial violence. It’s a book that lingers, demanding reflection on how far we’ve come—and how far we haven’t.
Thank you to the publisher W. W. Norton and Edelweiss for the advance copy. This is history written with the precision of journalism and the moral clarity of a manifesto.
Displaying 1 of 1 review