I was so excited for this book, especially for the opportunity to support Becca Erin Title, the owner of Meet Cute (my favorite romance book store!). Throughout this book, it is evident that Title has all the prerequisites for an amazing romance novel - a cute storyline, popular tropes, and creative characters. Specifically, I loved the grumpy sunshine trope, especially with the girl being grumpy and the guy being sunshine. I LOVED Daniel. His character was so likable and while I like a morally gray mmc as much as the next girl, it can be refreshing to see a pure sunshine mmc as well. She also did a really good job writing the lead up to the steamy scenes. I would definitely argue that it is one of the author's strengths and I enjoyed reading these scenes.
Now, for the 2-star rating. While all the elements were there, the execution was just... underwhelming. Overall, the characters were extremely underdeveloped. I wasn't allowed to infer anything about the characters without Title hitting me over the head telling me who they were and about their traits. The plot felt very forced - people just decided things out of the blue without giving any insight to their thought processes or how their feelings changed. And then, in the middle of the book, is a whole chapter devoted towards the fmc's abortion. Now, I am very pro-choice, and don't have a problem with abortions being mentioned, even in romance novels. I have appreciated Title's outspoken stance and advocacy for reproductive rights. But a full chapter that feels like a step-by-step guide on how to get an abortion in North Carolina felt very out of place, especially when the fmc makes a string of life-changing decisions in like 5 pages at the end of the book with no insight into her decision making process. Finally, the writing just felt... immature. I don't need everything I read to be a literary work of art, but I felt that, for this story, it actually took away from my enjoyment of it. I would definitely read more for Title, especially as her writing style continues to evolve. I know writing a book is EXTREMELY difficult! If anything, I think this book demonstrates the potential this author has to be a top tier romance author!