What do you think?
Rate this book
Brothers of the Gun: Wyatt Earp, Doc Holliday, and a Reckoning in Tombstone
An illuminating account of the most storied friendship of the American West: the bond between Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday.
A True West magazine BEST BOOK and BEST AUTHOR of the year.
In 1878, Wyatt Earp, town marshall of Dodge City, was attempting to arrest some drunken, armed men who’d cornered him in a saloon. John Henry “Doc” Holliday, who'd been gambling nearby, stepped in with a revolver and quieted the drunks, allowing Earp to make his arrests. This was the start to the most legendary friendship and partnership of the American West.
Through action-packed adventures, Gardner shows us how, over the years, Holliday became like a brother to Wyatt, riding from town to town, throughout the west. This thrilling narrative builds up to the moment when they'd hunt down the very men who murdered Wyatt's brother, Morgan, a legendary search that enthusiasts of the Wild West are eager to learn more about.
Gardner shows that there is far more to unearth about this famous friendship. Researched through firsthand observations at historic sites and countless contemporary letters and newspaper reports, this is the definitive book on Wyatt Earp, Doc Holliday, and their fascinating bond.
A True West magazine BEST BOOK and BEST AUTHOR of the year.
In 1878, Wyatt Earp, town marshall of Dodge City, was attempting to arrest some drunken, armed men who’d cornered him in a saloon. John Henry “Doc” Holliday, who'd been gambling nearby, stepped in with a revolver and quieted the drunks, allowing Earp to make his arrests. This was the start to the most legendary friendship and partnership of the American West.
Through action-packed adventures, Gardner shows us how, over the years, Holliday became like a brother to Wyatt, riding from town to town, throughout the west. This thrilling narrative builds up to the moment when they'd hunt down the very men who murdered Wyatt's brother, Morgan, a legendary search that enthusiasts of the Wild West are eager to learn more about.
Gardner shows that there is far more to unearth about this famous friendship. Researched through firsthand observations at historic sites and countless contemporary letters and newspaper reports, this is the definitive book on Wyatt Earp, Doc Holliday, and their fascinating bond.
336 pages, Hardcover
Published November 11, 2025
About the author
Mark Lee Gardner
24 books162 followersMark Lee Gardner grew up in rural Missouri in the small town of Breckenridge (pop. 500), in the heart of historic Jesse James country. He's written extensively about the American West, on subjects such as the Santa Fe Trail, George Armstrong Custer, Bent's Old Fort, Geronimo, Billy the Kid, and Crazy Horse. His book on the 1876 Northfield raid by the notorious James-Younger gang, Shot All To Hell, received the Western Writers of America Spur Award for best western nonfiction historical book, the Best Book Award from the Wild West History Association, and the Milton F. Perry Award for Best Nonfiction Book. His Rough Riders, published in 2016, received the Army Historical Foundation Distinguished Writing Award, the Father Thomas J. Steele Award for History, and the Colorado Book Award for Biography.
Mark's most recent book is The Earth Is All That Lasts: Crazy Horse, Sitting Bull, and the Last Stand of the Great Sioux Nation (Mariner Books). Mark spent five years researching and writing this dual biography, examining rare documents and artifacts in archives and museums across the country, from Chicago's Newberry Library to Cody's Buffalo Bill Center of the West. And he visited numerous historic sites all over the northern plains, even crossing the "holy line" into Canada, where Sitting Bull and his followers spent four years in exile.
True West magazine proclaimed The Earth Is All That Lasts the "Best Historical Nonfiction Book" of 2022. The book also won the 2023 Colorado Book Award for best history/biography and the 2023 John M. Carroll Literary Award from the Little Big Horn Associates.
In addition to his historical research and writing, Mark is also a performer of the historic music of the American West. His most recent CD is Outlaws: Songs of Robbers, Rustlers, and Rogues.
Mark's passions include rare books and ephemera; historic photography; old-time, bluegrass, and classic country music; and hunting, mainly calling up gobblers in the spring.
Mark is the 2024 recipient of the Frank Waters Award for Literary Excellence. He holds a master's degree in American Studies from the University of Wyoming and a bachelor's degree in history and journalism (double major) from Northwest Missouri State University. He's married with two children and lives with his family at the foot of majestic Pikes Peak.
Follow Mark on Instagram: mark_lee_gardner
Mark's most recent book is The Earth Is All That Lasts: Crazy Horse, Sitting Bull, and the Last Stand of the Great Sioux Nation (Mariner Books). Mark spent five years researching and writing this dual biography, examining rare documents and artifacts in archives and museums across the country, from Chicago's Newberry Library to Cody's Buffalo Bill Center of the West. And he visited numerous historic sites all over the northern plains, even crossing the "holy line" into Canada, where Sitting Bull and his followers spent four years in exile.
True West magazine proclaimed The Earth Is All That Lasts the "Best Historical Nonfiction Book" of 2022. The book also won the 2023 Colorado Book Award for best history/biography and the 2023 John M. Carroll Literary Award from the Little Big Horn Associates.
In addition to his historical research and writing, Mark is also a performer of the historic music of the American West. His most recent CD is Outlaws: Songs of Robbers, Rustlers, and Rogues.
Mark's passions include rare books and ephemera; historic photography; old-time, bluegrass, and classic country music; and hunting, mainly calling up gobblers in the spring.
Mark is the 2024 recipient of the Frank Waters Award for Literary Excellence. He holds a master's degree in American Studies from the University of Wyoming and a bachelor's degree in history and journalism (double major) from Northwest Missouri State University. He's married with two children and lives with his family at the foot of majestic Pikes Peak.
Follow Mark on Instagram: mark_lee_gardner
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 69 reviews
April 16, 2026
"'Fight' - that word kept coming up. It seemed inevitable now. Wyatt Earp explained years later that 'It was our intention to disarm [the 'Cowboys'] this time, and put them in jail or else make a fight if they wanted it, and we well knew they would fight.' The time was approximately 2:45 p.m., and the afternoon had turned cold and gusty. A storm was coming to Tombstone." -- on page 163
One of those periodic retellings or re-examinations (although I suppose those less enthralled would remark it was a rehashing) of the frontier incident known as the 'Gunfight at the O.K. Corral,' author Gardner's Brothers of the Gun also works as a biographical work of central players Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday. Again, this shootout on 26 October 1881 has been covered / dramatized numerous times in film (the excellent Tombstone and the very good Wyatt Earp, both from 1994, being just two of the most recent examples) and in countless books - such as author Tom Clavin's finely detailed Tombstone: The Earp Brothers, Doc Holliday, and the Vendetta Ride from Hell, which I coincidentally read exactly three years ago - but, to mangle a metaphor, if someone can breathe new life into an old song I say 'play on.' What Gardner helps bring alive this time around (without being trashy) is just how soap opera-ish the western territory towns like Tombstone used to be 150 years ago, with said communities being dens of iniquity - murder, gambling, prostitution, drunkenness, livestock thievery, as well as various sinful romantic entanglements and a virtually non-existent line between good guys and outlaws were often as common as the region's blue sky. (I may have missed a mention or two of jaywalking 😉.) So, yes, it's an already heavily-covered sort of history, but it was done in an engaging style, and also used the unshakable friendship between Wyatt and Doc as a sort of bedrock. Take cover, fair citizens - the deputy marshals and the cowboys are shooting it out once again. 💥
One of those periodic retellings or re-examinations (although I suppose those less enthralled would remark it was a rehashing) of the frontier incident known as the 'Gunfight at the O.K. Corral,' author Gardner's Brothers of the Gun also works as a biographical work of central players Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday. Again, this shootout on 26 October 1881 has been covered / dramatized numerous times in film (the excellent Tombstone and the very good Wyatt Earp, both from 1994, being just two of the most recent examples) and in countless books - such as author Tom Clavin's finely detailed Tombstone: The Earp Brothers, Doc Holliday, and the Vendetta Ride from Hell, which I coincidentally read exactly three years ago - but, to mangle a metaphor, if someone can breathe new life into an old song I say 'play on.' What Gardner helps bring alive this time around (without being trashy) is just how soap opera-ish the western territory towns like Tombstone used to be 150 years ago, with said communities being dens of iniquity - murder, gambling, prostitution, drunkenness, livestock thievery, as well as various sinful romantic entanglements and a virtually non-existent line between good guys and outlaws were often as common as the region's blue sky. (I may have missed a mention or two of jaywalking 😉.) So, yes, it's an already heavily-covered sort of history, but it was done in an engaging style, and also used the unshakable friendship between Wyatt and Doc as a sort of bedrock. Take cover, fair citizens - the deputy marshals and the cowboys are shooting it out once again. 💥
August 21, 2025
There are very few times I will say this as a history nerd. I was very afraid of the truth when I started Mark Lee Gardner's Brothers of the Gun. Quite simply, I love the movie Tombstone too much. I already knew it played fast and loose with the facts, but dang it, it plays well with those fictions. I know precisely what Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday actually looked like, but I can only picture Kurt and Val. The bad news is, yes, Tombstone is as fictional as you would expect. The good news is that this book is a hell of a lot of fun anyway.
Gardner is telling the story of Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday. I assure I need not explain any further than that. I'll get to my critique first. Gardner's story is not as comprehensive as others on the subject. Doc feels very much like the second fiddle which makes sense since he basically disappears from the historical record a few times. That said, by far, Gardner's explanations of what happened, who do it, and why are the best I have read. This book is the first where the analysis lines up with what we know about all these characters (good guys and bad guys and well, let's be honest they are all gray at best) and what their motivations might be. While I mentioned the book is not as comprehensive as others, this is not to suggest Gardner skipped his own research. I think he just decided to streamline in a lot of places. Gardner clearly did his research and presented us with what we need to know.
Ultimately, this is a must read for Wild West fans. Non-fans may feel it is a little rushed or high-level, but I don't think anyone will complain much when they finish. It's a great (vendetta) ride.
(This book was provided as a review copy by NetGalley and Dutton Books.)
Gardner is telling the story of Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday. I assure I need not explain any further than that. I'll get to my critique first. Gardner's story is not as comprehensive as others on the subject. Doc feels very much like the second fiddle which makes sense since he basically disappears from the historical record a few times. That said, by far, Gardner's explanations of what happened, who do it, and why are the best I have read. This book is the first where the analysis lines up with what we know about all these characters (good guys and bad guys and well, let's be honest they are all gray at best) and what their motivations might be. While I mentioned the book is not as comprehensive as others, this is not to suggest Gardner skipped his own research. I think he just decided to streamline in a lot of places. Gardner clearly did his research and presented us with what we need to know.
Ultimately, this is a must read for Wild West fans. Non-fans may feel it is a little rushed or high-level, but I don't think anyone will complain much when they finish. It's a great (vendetta) ride.
(This book was provided as a review copy by NetGalley and Dutton Books.)
March 2, 2026
Before opening up this book on my Kindle, I assumed that it was going to be a “tell all”…detailing the many shortcomings of Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday. While the both of them certainly had a wagon full of flaws and character defects, the author provided a pretty well-rounded picture of these two notable characters of the 19th century. Even though Wyatt didn’t live the untarnished life of a choirboy, there’s no question that he was an amazing lawman for his time. In this regard, for anyone living in a small and rowdy wild west town in the 1870’s, it’s likely that they would have appreciated having a courageous and principled town marshal like Wyatt to keep things in order.
As for Doc Holiday…the man’s many contradictions and imperfections would undoubtedly be a point of interest to any aspiring novelist, actor, or psychologist. In this regard, despite his losing battle with tuberculosis, there was nothing “pitying” about this man who always dressed immaculately, drank heavily, and found his fun over endless hands of poker and games of faro. More impressively, on top of everything else, the well-armed dentist stayed by Wyatt’s side during the darkest and most dangerous times of the marshal’s life.
While the shootout at the OK Corral was fully covered in the book, it was interesting to read how this 30-second event followed Wyatt throughout his long life. Indeed, despite living in different places across the country and holding a myriad of jobs (e.g., boxing referee, mining investor, Hollywood consultant), the incident in Tombstone tended to overshadow everything else that he did during his 80-years.
All in all, this a finely researched and well written book, which will definitely be of interest to those readers interested in the late 19th century.
As for Doc Holiday…the man’s many contradictions and imperfections would undoubtedly be a point of interest to any aspiring novelist, actor, or psychologist. In this regard, despite his losing battle with tuberculosis, there was nothing “pitying” about this man who always dressed immaculately, drank heavily, and found his fun over endless hands of poker and games of faro. More impressively, on top of everything else, the well-armed dentist stayed by Wyatt’s side during the darkest and most dangerous times of the marshal’s life.
While the shootout at the OK Corral was fully covered in the book, it was interesting to read how this 30-second event followed Wyatt throughout his long life. Indeed, despite living in different places across the country and holding a myriad of jobs (e.g., boxing referee, mining investor, Hollywood consultant), the incident in Tombstone tended to overshadow everything else that he did during his 80-years.
All in all, this a finely researched and well written book, which will definitely be of interest to those readers interested in the late 19th century.
August 4, 2025
An ARC from NetGalley.com
A well research book about the real legend of Wyatt Earp, Wyatt Earp's brothers, Bat Masterson, and Doc Holiday. We are treated to what happen at the OK Coral, what lead up to it and what happen afterwards. Very well written with lots of cite to old newspapers, diarys, and eye witnesses. I am not into westerns but I enjoyed reading this old west history. The resources cited were 40% of the book, along with pictures of Wyatt, his brothers, common-law wives,Bat, Doc, Doc's common-law wives and Bat Masterson and some of 'The Cowboys' outfit. I highly recommend this book.
A well research book about the real legend of Wyatt Earp, Wyatt Earp's brothers, Bat Masterson, and Doc Holiday. We are treated to what happen at the OK Coral, what lead up to it and what happen afterwards. Very well written with lots of cite to old newspapers, diarys, and eye witnesses. I am not into westerns but I enjoyed reading this old west history. The resources cited were 40% of the book, along with pictures of Wyatt, his brothers, common-law wives,Bat, Doc, Doc's common-law wives and Bat Masterson and some of 'The Cowboys' outfit. I highly recommend this book.
May 1, 2026
I only knew peripheral things about Wyatt Earp [and his brothers], Doc Holliday, and Tombstone; I have never seen any of the movies [though I own Tombstone and this now gives me a reason to dive into that movie], and this was the first full book I have read about all of them.
This was a really good read for me; I have become really interested in the Old West a of late [and it has been SUCH a surprise to me as I never ever thought this would be a topic I'd grow to love], and it was good to finally get the full picture/story of the Earp Brothers and Doc Holliday - their story was way more complex than I expected [and the whole Tombstone thing makes me wonder just how things get so out of control in regards to the actual truth], and I am really glad that I was able to read this book.
Expertly researched and very well-written, this should be a must-read for anyone who loves the "wild west/Old West", the stories that have come out of that time, and of course the Earps and Doc Holliday. I think there will be some serious surprises for you within these pages.
Thank you to NetGalley, Mark Lee Gardner, and Dutton for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This was a really good read for me; I have become really interested in the Old West a of late [and it has been SUCH a surprise to me as I never ever thought this would be a topic I'd grow to love], and it was good to finally get the full picture/story of the Earp Brothers and Doc Holliday - their story was way more complex than I expected [and the whole Tombstone thing makes me wonder just how things get so out of control in regards to the actual truth], and I am really glad that I was able to read this book.
Expertly researched and very well-written, this should be a must-read for anyone who loves the "wild west/Old West", the stories that have come out of that time, and of course the Earps and Doc Holliday. I think there will be some serious surprises for you within these pages.
Thank you to NetGalley, Mark Lee Gardner, and Dutton for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
January 4, 2026
Not my kind of history book, but I've been spoiled by reading some great, academic history books over the past few years. It's more like story telling, not in the sense of making stuff up, but in its prose style, which is just not to my taste. For instance, I prefer the terms "jail" or "prison" to the antiquated vernacular "calaboose". The author is not of the same mind, and it makes the prose breezy and unserious.
In the preface, the author insists that everything in the book is backed up by references. He then goes on to consistently speculate, using "possibly", "likely", "perhaps", "maybe or maybe not" and the like. As he says in the preface, he does include a really massive set of endnotes, divided by chapter and carefully numbered. However, there are no matching numbers in the text itself, making finding specific references for specific quoted dialog more trouble than it's worth. Possibly the target audience would have been distracted by numbers in the text, but I really appreciate them.
Consequently, I came away unconvinced that it was any more accurate than anything else about Earp & Holliday that I've read or seen.
In the preface, the author insists that everything in the book is backed up by references. He then goes on to consistently speculate, using "possibly", "likely", "perhaps", "maybe or maybe not" and the like. As he says in the preface, he does include a really massive set of endnotes, divided by chapter and carefully numbered. However, there are no matching numbers in the text itself, making finding specific references for specific quoted dialog more trouble than it's worth. Possibly the target audience would have been distracted by numbers in the text, but I really appreciate them.
Consequently, I came away unconvinced that it was any more accurate than anything else about Earp & Holliday that I've read or seen.
November 8, 2025
ARC
I'd like to thank Dutton and NetGalley for the chance to give "Brothers of the Gun" an early read in return for an honest review.
To keep things short, "Brothers of the Gun" presents an interesting portrait about two of Tombstone's best-known shooters, with their lives together as they head toward the infamous shootout in Tombstone, AZ. It's an intriguing topic, but felt a bit dry for my liking, not feeling like there was any kind of personality that made it stand out amongst other books about the west. I wasn't fairly knowledgeable about these two, so I personally learned a lot, but it isn't a comprehensive look at these two, so anyone with a basic understanding may find this a bit of a redundant read. I enjoyed getting to learn about these two men and the events that unfolded in Tombstone, but I wish it would have been done in a more interesting way to keep me wanting to continue reading.
Be sure to check "Brothers of the Gun" out when it is published on November 11, 2025!
I'd like to thank Dutton and NetGalley for the chance to give "Brothers of the Gun" an early read in return for an honest review.
To keep things short, "Brothers of the Gun" presents an interesting portrait about two of Tombstone's best-known shooters, with their lives together as they head toward the infamous shootout in Tombstone, AZ. It's an intriguing topic, but felt a bit dry for my liking, not feeling like there was any kind of personality that made it stand out amongst other books about the west. I wasn't fairly knowledgeable about these two, so I personally learned a lot, but it isn't a comprehensive look at these two, so anyone with a basic understanding may find this a bit of a redundant read. I enjoyed getting to learn about these two men and the events that unfolded in Tombstone, but I wish it would have been done in a more interesting way to keep me wanting to continue reading.
Be sure to check "Brothers of the Gun" out when it is published on November 11, 2025!
December 27, 2025
Much has been written and put on film about Wyatt Earp. Along with his brothers and infamous friend Doc Holliday, Earp moved from town to town during the heart of the Old West expansion in the late 1800’s. His legacy is that of a lawman but he had some vices as well. This book focuses on his friendship with Doc Holiday and numerous run ins with bad guys who were called cowboys. Unlike many depictions, this book does not make the famous Gunfight at the OK Corral in 1881 the centerpiece of the narrative. It is treated as one of many dangerous incidents in the life of Wyatt Earp.
June 3, 2026
wow!!!!!!! made even better after watching the movie :D
June 24, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and Dutton for providing me with man advanced reading copy.
For someone who loves the movie Tombstone I found this book to be both informative and entertaining. The author has a knack for providing a feeling of what the Old West was like and there were points that I felt like I was reading a novel. While Gardner has nothing less than an engaging style he also doesn’t sugarcoat the actions of both Earp and Holliday, and puts their stories within the contexts of their place and time. Highly recommend to people who love Western history or movies!
For someone who loves the movie Tombstone I found this book to be both informative and entertaining. The author has a knack for providing a feeling of what the Old West was like and there were points that I felt like I was reading a novel. While Gardner has nothing less than an engaging style he also doesn’t sugarcoat the actions of both Earp and Holliday, and puts their stories within the contexts of their place and time. Highly recommend to people who love Western history or movies!
February 18, 2026
Full review at: https://readingourshelves.wordpress.c...
The author first lays out the details of the Earp family, and Wyatt’s childhood. There were a lot of kids, and they moved around a lot, albeit mostly in the West. Wyatt tried to join the army when he was not yet old enough to do so, but his dad caught him. The boys and girls alike were used to picking up and moving on whenever opportunity beckoned.
John Henry Holliday, meanwhile, was born in Georgia. He studied in Philadelphia to become a dentist, then moved to Atlanta to practice. Within a few years, while still in his early twenties, Holliday began to show signs of “consumption” – tuberculosis. He moved West initially because he thought it would benefit his health. (While living in Texas, he was even active in his church’s temperance movement!) He did work as a dentist in several towns, so we presume that’s where his nickname “Doc” came from. His poor health – and the tonics and other drugs he took to ease his symptoms – eventually led him to rely primarily on gambling for his income.
Wyatt bounced around to several boomtowns, always following the crowds because that’s where the good money was. He often found employment as a lawman, or a security guard of some sort, and was considered level-headed. He was especially liked in Dodge City, where he first met Doc Holliday on the street.
Eventually, several Earps made their way to Tombstone, Arizona, to grab a stake in the new silver strike happening there. They swung through Las Vegas, where Doc was living, to see if he wanted in on their move. Doc’s girlfriend, Kate, did not like the Earps, so Doc did not join them in Tombstone until a little later.
A side note here about the women: Doc and Kate remained on and off for years, but she did not actually ever live in Tombstone – she only visited him there. Wyatt had several wives over the years, but they were all “common law” marriages. As the Earps moved often, they could just set themselves up in a new town with whatever names the ladies wanted. (As in, the women would just adopt their mens’ last names without ever getting married officially.)
There were, at various times, as many as five of the Earp brothers in Tombstone. Wyatt and Virgil took on some law enforcement positions while in town, and even Morgan worked security for a coach for a time. While they’re in town, we learn of their interactions with various other characters – the mayor, Wyatt’s political rival Johnny Behan, and the eventual appearance of the “Cowboys” – a traveling band of cattle thieves who sometimes blew into town to spend their earnings on women, booze, or gambling.
The author does a great and engaging job of detailing the various interactions that eventually lead to beef between some local thugs (with ties to the Cowboys) and Doc Holliday. They considered Virgil and Wyatt targets, as well, both for their ties to Holliday and their capacity as lawmen. One of the men, Ike Clanton, and Doc Holliday were separated in a bar fight one night, and told to go home and sleep it off. Rather than sleeping, Ike stayed up until the next day, and got a brother and a friend to join forces with him.
They were seen going into a gun store, and then through the alley behind it, where there was a corral for people to tie up their horses. Everyone in town was watching, as they knew trouble was brewing. Johnny Behan, the ranking lawman at the moment, went in first. When the Earps and Holliday arrived, Behan told them he had disarmed the men already. And yet, they pulled out guns. The ensuing and infamous shootout lasted all of 30 seconds.
Wyatt and Doc were actually arrested, but claimed they acted in self defense. Wyatt had glowing character witnesses from law enforcement in other cities. The initial court hearings, to see if there was enough evidence to charge them, lasted a full month. They were eventually let go.
The Cowboys swore revenge, and eventually maimed Virgil. Then the Earps swore revenge. Most of the Earp clan, including Virgil and all the women, moved to California to get out of the heat. Wyatt kept at hunting down some of the men involved for a while, and he and Doc did get into legal troubles again down the line… even separately.
Of course, Doc died fairly young. Some people thought he was reckless because he always figured he’d die soon, anyway. When he passed, in Colorado, he was 36. Wyatt lived a long life, going on to become a boxing referee and trying several times to get his life story published. He passed on in L.A. at age 80.
The author first lays out the details of the Earp family, and Wyatt’s childhood. There were a lot of kids, and they moved around a lot, albeit mostly in the West. Wyatt tried to join the army when he was not yet old enough to do so, but his dad caught him. The boys and girls alike were used to picking up and moving on whenever opportunity beckoned.
John Henry Holliday, meanwhile, was born in Georgia. He studied in Philadelphia to become a dentist, then moved to Atlanta to practice. Within a few years, while still in his early twenties, Holliday began to show signs of “consumption” – tuberculosis. He moved West initially because he thought it would benefit his health. (While living in Texas, he was even active in his church’s temperance movement!) He did work as a dentist in several towns, so we presume that’s where his nickname “Doc” came from. His poor health – and the tonics and other drugs he took to ease his symptoms – eventually led him to rely primarily on gambling for his income.
Wyatt bounced around to several boomtowns, always following the crowds because that’s where the good money was. He often found employment as a lawman, or a security guard of some sort, and was considered level-headed. He was especially liked in Dodge City, where he first met Doc Holliday on the street.
Eventually, several Earps made their way to Tombstone, Arizona, to grab a stake in the new silver strike happening there. They swung through Las Vegas, where Doc was living, to see if he wanted in on their move. Doc’s girlfriend, Kate, did not like the Earps, so Doc did not join them in Tombstone until a little later.
A side note here about the women: Doc and Kate remained on and off for years, but she did not actually ever live in Tombstone – she only visited him there. Wyatt had several wives over the years, but they were all “common law” marriages. As the Earps moved often, they could just set themselves up in a new town with whatever names the ladies wanted. (As in, the women would just adopt their mens’ last names without ever getting married officially.)
There were, at various times, as many as five of the Earp brothers in Tombstone. Wyatt and Virgil took on some law enforcement positions while in town, and even Morgan worked security for a coach for a time. While they’re in town, we learn of their interactions with various other characters – the mayor, Wyatt’s political rival Johnny Behan, and the eventual appearance of the “Cowboys” – a traveling band of cattle thieves who sometimes blew into town to spend their earnings on women, booze, or gambling.
The author does a great and engaging job of detailing the various interactions that eventually lead to beef between some local thugs (with ties to the Cowboys) and Doc Holliday. They considered Virgil and Wyatt targets, as well, both for their ties to Holliday and their capacity as lawmen. One of the men, Ike Clanton, and Doc Holliday were separated in a bar fight one night, and told to go home and sleep it off. Rather than sleeping, Ike stayed up until the next day, and got a brother and a friend to join forces with him.
They were seen going into a gun store, and then through the alley behind it, where there was a corral for people to tie up their horses. Everyone in town was watching, as they knew trouble was brewing. Johnny Behan, the ranking lawman at the moment, went in first. When the Earps and Holliday arrived, Behan told them he had disarmed the men already. And yet, they pulled out guns. The ensuing and infamous shootout lasted all of 30 seconds.
Wyatt and Doc were actually arrested, but claimed they acted in self defense. Wyatt had glowing character witnesses from law enforcement in other cities. The initial court hearings, to see if there was enough evidence to charge them, lasted a full month. They were eventually let go.
The Cowboys swore revenge, and eventually maimed Virgil. Then the Earps swore revenge. Most of the Earp clan, including Virgil and all the women, moved to California to get out of the heat. Wyatt kept at hunting down some of the men involved for a while, and he and Doc did get into legal troubles again down the line… even separately.
Of course, Doc died fairly young. Some people thought he was reckless because he always figured he’d die soon, anyway. When he passed, in Colorado, he was 36. Wyatt lived a long life, going on to become a boxing referee and trying several times to get his life story published. He passed on in L.A. at age 80.
October 18, 2025
My thanks to NetGalley and Dutton for an advance copy of this history of the old West about two of the most famous names, lawmen, dentist, gambler, thief depending on is telling their tale, a retelling that tries to get past the myths and get to the truth of about these men, their lives, and their actions.
The American West continues to inspire and entertain people filling them with ideas of what was and what should be in the modern world. A man with a gun standing for what is right, and defending and revenging the put-upon. A cursory look at the west shows a world that is much like ours. Corrupt politicians being paid by the rich to enforce their idea of laws, with enforcement from men who made money by being lawmen. A dentist could be a gambler, a lawman could be a pimp. Accusations of vengeance and enforcing the laws could be made by different people. Stand your ground is close to what many of these men did, shot first, keep shooting and hope the other person doesn't shoot back. Dealing with the Old West, the Wild West the West of the Imagination is hard. Most like to print the legend, and many people believe it, as it is easy. I enjoy the fact that author admits that he hates this quote about printing legends. Reading this well-researched history and biography, about two men and one famous incident, one knows one is in good hands. Especially when the book is both informative and fun. Brothers of the Gun: Wyatt Earp, Doc Holliday, and a Reckoning in Tombstone by writer and historian Mark Lee Gardner is a dual biography of both men, and a tale of vengence, gun fights, extraordinary amounts of money, and how difficult it is to separate the truth from myths, when even the people involved prefer the mythology.
The book begins with the birth of both men, Wyatt Earp and Joe Henry "Doc" Holliday in different parts of the country. The Earps were a wondering family, their father always looking for the next big thing, followed by the big thing after that. Wyatt's father was also a lawman, a very lucrative trade back then. Wyatt left the area after being in law enforcement under a cloud with some missing tax money, that might have staked him as he went west. Holliday grew up in good family, though he was diagnosed with tuberculosis at a young age. Holliday had an uncle who was a dentist, which gave him a trade, but a knowledge of his illness, and a possible racial incident sent him West, where he found gambling, women and alcohol much to his liking. Wyatt and Doc as Holliday was known, met as Wyatt was working as a bounty hunter, starting an acquaintance that blossomed into a real friendship when Holliday came to Wyatt's aid during a difficult arrest in Dodge City, starting a friendship that would last, with a minor spat, through gun battles, ambushes, and numerous court cases, untill Holliday died.
This is a very well-researched book that is not romantic or with a rose colored glasses. Gardner is a very good writer, able to capture the feel of gun battles, of ambushes leaving Wyatt alone against cowboys, saving people in fires, being on the range. And even gambling with a sideline of being a pimp for both men. Gardner looks to find the truth, and presents it as it comes, not protected stories or probable lies from wifes in name only, fellow lawmen with a block on their shoulders, nor fawning writers and supporters. What one gets from this book, is that these men were complicated, who lived in violent occupations, lawman, gambler, dentist and drunk. What surprised me most was the money that lawman could make, one was making $40,000 dollars collecting taxes in Tombstone. No wonder law enforcement was so popular.
The book is very well written, with action, and lots of thoughtful moments, and questions asked about events. The truth will never really be known about most of the events these men were involved in. Both sides have good cases for and against what happened. Though I think this book comes the closest of all to separating the truth and the truth that many would prefer to believe. I have read quite a few book by Mark Lee Gardner and have enjoyed them. This might be my favorite and his best. A really good history, and even better a really good book, perfect for the holidays.
The American West continues to inspire and entertain people filling them with ideas of what was and what should be in the modern world. A man with a gun standing for what is right, and defending and revenging the put-upon. A cursory look at the west shows a world that is much like ours. Corrupt politicians being paid by the rich to enforce their idea of laws, with enforcement from men who made money by being lawmen. A dentist could be a gambler, a lawman could be a pimp. Accusations of vengeance and enforcing the laws could be made by different people. Stand your ground is close to what many of these men did, shot first, keep shooting and hope the other person doesn't shoot back. Dealing with the Old West, the Wild West the West of the Imagination is hard. Most like to print the legend, and many people believe it, as it is easy. I enjoy the fact that author admits that he hates this quote about printing legends. Reading this well-researched history and biography, about two men and one famous incident, one knows one is in good hands. Especially when the book is both informative and fun. Brothers of the Gun: Wyatt Earp, Doc Holliday, and a Reckoning in Tombstone by writer and historian Mark Lee Gardner is a dual biography of both men, and a tale of vengence, gun fights, extraordinary amounts of money, and how difficult it is to separate the truth from myths, when even the people involved prefer the mythology.
The book begins with the birth of both men, Wyatt Earp and Joe Henry "Doc" Holliday in different parts of the country. The Earps were a wondering family, their father always looking for the next big thing, followed by the big thing after that. Wyatt's father was also a lawman, a very lucrative trade back then. Wyatt left the area after being in law enforcement under a cloud with some missing tax money, that might have staked him as he went west. Holliday grew up in good family, though he was diagnosed with tuberculosis at a young age. Holliday had an uncle who was a dentist, which gave him a trade, but a knowledge of his illness, and a possible racial incident sent him West, where he found gambling, women and alcohol much to his liking. Wyatt and Doc as Holliday was known, met as Wyatt was working as a bounty hunter, starting an acquaintance that blossomed into a real friendship when Holliday came to Wyatt's aid during a difficult arrest in Dodge City, starting a friendship that would last, with a minor spat, through gun battles, ambushes, and numerous court cases, untill Holliday died.
This is a very well-researched book that is not romantic or with a rose colored glasses. Gardner is a very good writer, able to capture the feel of gun battles, of ambushes leaving Wyatt alone against cowboys, saving people in fires, being on the range. And even gambling with a sideline of being a pimp for both men. Gardner looks to find the truth, and presents it as it comes, not protected stories or probable lies from wifes in name only, fellow lawmen with a block on their shoulders, nor fawning writers and supporters. What one gets from this book, is that these men were complicated, who lived in violent occupations, lawman, gambler, dentist and drunk. What surprised me most was the money that lawman could make, one was making $40,000 dollars collecting taxes in Tombstone. No wonder law enforcement was so popular.
The book is very well written, with action, and lots of thoughtful moments, and questions asked about events. The truth will never really be known about most of the events these men were involved in. Both sides have good cases for and against what happened. Though I think this book comes the closest of all to separating the truth and the truth that many would prefer to believe. I have read quite a few book by Mark Lee Gardner and have enjoyed them. This might be my favorite and his best. A really good history, and even better a really good book, perfect for the holidays.
January 5, 2026
Icons never die.
Because of my lifelong love of westerns and—specifically—Tombstone, I've been a huge fan of Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday for a good majority of my life. Even more so, I've been fascinated by Doc Holliday and the devotion he seemed to show Wyatt at every turn of their storied friendship, despite their contrasting dispositions. Most of what I've learned over the years—that wasn't exaggerated through the filter of Hollywood—tended to be vague; third, fourth or fifth-hand accounts, contradictory historical writings and the like.
So, to be able to dive into a history dedicated to them both—their lives, their friendship, the historic 30-seconds and its aftermath that made them immortal—that is as thoroughly researched and well-told as Mark Lee Gardner's Brothers of the Gun: Wyatt Earp, Doc Holliday, and a Reckoning in Tombstone , was really something special.
Trouble seemed to follow Wyatt. Doc made his own.
I'm generally not the biggest fan of nonfiction, but the way Gardner tells Wyatt & Doc's stories is as entertaining as it is informative. Through his research, he uncovers who these men really were: the good, the bad, and the ugly. The way he handles the timelines and Wyatt & Doc's questionable dealings throughout their lives never waters them down. Instead, his honest handling of the negative only ever makes the positives all the more impressive/iconic.
"Yes, we are friends."
I may have been left wanting more in terms of their actual time spent together, especially after they leave Tombstone, but I completely understand an account like that is impossible without some serious poetic license being taken, as apparently neither left behind much official detail about their peculiar connection. Understanding that, Brothers of the Gun isn't only the definitive historical retelling of the 1881 events in Tombstone, or the ultimate account of Wyatt & Doc's friendship, it very well may be the best, most well-researched and accurate exploration of who these men were and what they did in their many lives, both together and apart.
"This is funny."
8/10
Because of my lifelong love of westerns and—specifically—Tombstone, I've been a huge fan of Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday for a good majority of my life. Even more so, I've been fascinated by Doc Holliday and the devotion he seemed to show Wyatt at every turn of their storied friendship, despite their contrasting dispositions. Most of what I've learned over the years—that wasn't exaggerated through the filter of Hollywood—tended to be vague; third, fourth or fifth-hand accounts, contradictory historical writings and the like.
So, to be able to dive into a history dedicated to them both—their lives, their friendship, the historic 30-seconds and its aftermath that made them immortal—that is as thoroughly researched and well-told as Mark Lee Gardner's Brothers of the Gun: Wyatt Earp, Doc Holliday, and a Reckoning in Tombstone , was really something special.
Trouble seemed to follow Wyatt. Doc made his own.
I'm generally not the biggest fan of nonfiction, but the way Gardner tells Wyatt & Doc's stories is as entertaining as it is informative. Through his research, he uncovers who these men really were: the good, the bad, and the ugly. The way he handles the timelines and Wyatt & Doc's questionable dealings throughout their lives never waters them down. Instead, his honest handling of the negative only ever makes the positives all the more impressive/iconic.
"Yes, we are friends."
I may have been left wanting more in terms of their actual time spent together, especially after they leave Tombstone, but I completely understand an account like that is impossible without some serious poetic license being taken, as apparently neither left behind much official detail about their peculiar connection. Understanding that, Brothers of the Gun isn't only the definitive historical retelling of the 1881 events in Tombstone, or the ultimate account of Wyatt & Doc's friendship, it very well may be the best, most well-researched and accurate exploration of who these men were and what they did in their many lives, both together and apart.
"This is funny."
8/10
June 7, 2026
I saw this book at the library and grabbed it primarily because Gardner promised fresh information about Earp's "vendetta ride." Well, whatever fresh he had is trivial, and his overall coverage of that ride is in less depth than what I've read elsewhere. I was afraid this would be on the level of a Tom Clavin, and? It was.
In addition? No maps. Neither for the ride (totally not acceptable) nor for greater Tombstone, ie the western portion of today's Cochise County. The only map is a city map of the OK Corral area as it's believed to have looked like in 1881. Boessenecker's Ride the Devil's Herd has the same problem, and many others.
Then, there's the writing. Beyond another two-starrer calling some of it and terms "antiquated," it's more like "hackneyed," "overwrought" or "purplish."
How many times does Gardner use "sporting man" for "gambler"? Three dozen? Four dozen?
Then there's the purplish prose, like “knights of the green table” on 27. Gack!
Oh, and while he doesn't repeat Clavin's error in that person's Dodge City book of reprinting legend about Big Nosed Kate, Gardner does have one almost certain factual error.
Per Clay Allison’s Wiki page, Bat Masterson likely wasn’t in Dodge at the time Wyatt and Bat Masterson allegedly confronted him, and Earp didn’t make the claim until after Allison was dead. Charlie Siringo, the later Pinkerton agent, says two other people confronted Allison and had that in a written statement backed by other witnesses.
Shock me that Brendan the History Nerd Toddler, while rightly dismissing Tombstone the movie, doesn't pick up on this boo-boo, nor on the purplish prose, in his review.
That said, Brendan tells on himself with the first paragraph:
Yes, it's always story with him, and rarely worry about the facts.
That said, the groupies know, per the second comment on the review:
There you are.
Finally, contra the last sentence of Soy Boy's review, this is NOT a "must" for Wild West lovers.
As far as Earp's time in Tombstone, at least, with his brothers? That book would be Philip Fradkin's "Stagecoach."
In addition? No maps. Neither for the ride (totally not acceptable) nor for greater Tombstone, ie the western portion of today's Cochise County. The only map is a city map of the OK Corral area as it's believed to have looked like in 1881. Boessenecker's Ride the Devil's Herd has the same problem, and many others.
Then, there's the writing. Beyond another two-starrer calling some of it and terms "antiquated," it's more like "hackneyed," "overwrought" or "purplish."
How many times does Gardner use "sporting man" for "gambler"? Three dozen? Four dozen?
Then there's the purplish prose, like “knights of the green table” on 27. Gack!
Oh, and while he doesn't repeat Clavin's error in that person's Dodge City book of reprinting legend about Big Nosed Kate, Gardner does have one almost certain factual error.
Per Clay Allison’s Wiki page, Bat Masterson likely wasn’t in Dodge at the time Wyatt and Bat Masterson allegedly confronted him, and Earp didn’t make the claim until after Allison was dead. Charlie Siringo, the later Pinkerton agent, says two other people confronted Allison and had that in a written statement backed by other witnesses.
Shock me that Brendan the History Nerd Toddler, while rightly dismissing Tombstone the movie, doesn't pick up on this boo-boo, nor on the purplish prose, in his review.
That said, Brendan tells on himself with the first paragraph:
There are very few times I will say this as a history nerd. I was very afraid of the truth when I started Mark Lee Gardner's Brothers of the Gun. Quite simply, I love the movie Tombstone too much. I already knew it played fast and loose with the facts, but dang it, it plays well with those fictions.
Yes, it's always story with him, and rarely worry about the facts.
That said, the groupies know, per the second comment on the review:
So which do you think made for a better story - the truth or the movie?
There you are.
Finally, contra the last sentence of Soy Boy's review, this is NOT a "must" for Wild West lovers.
As far as Earp's time in Tombstone, at least, with his brothers? That book would be Philip Fradkin's "Stagecoach."
November 11, 2025
Many thanks to Netgalley and Dutton publishing for the advanced reader copy.
Gunfighters of the Old West have become legendary for their exploits, whether they actually happened or not. Like so many other legends and outlaws, when it comes to Wyatt Earp and his tubercular sidekick, Doc Holliday, it’s difficult, if not impossible, to know what is truth, what is legend, and what is the product of false accusations, prejudiced journalism, and dime store novel lore.
I’ve read several books written on the subject, only to later learn that most were not authentic, so I was quite intrigued by Gardner's take on Saintly Wyatt and Hardened Killer Holiday as they are often portrayed. I was also intrigued by the book’s premise of looking into the friendship that is often referred to as unlikely between the lawman and the gambler. What Gardner finds is that the friendship isn’t that unlikely because the two actually had quite a lot in common. They both took common law wives whose backgrounds were less than innocent. Both had incidents in their pasts that led them to seek new pastures.
While Earp is often portrayed as a lawman, he was, in fact a gambler just like Holliday. While the former dentist chased the next wild town and its many barrooms and gambling houses, Wyatt chased the next big rush, always looking to make that big fortune that seemed always one step ahead of him. Both were unfailingly loyal and seemingly without fear when it came to standing their ground in the face of threats and violence.
I've always found Gardner's books to be well researched and fact-based, and Brothers of the Gun was no different. I appreciate that Gardner admits when information isn't available to verify speculation. In this book, he brings forth a lot of information that I'd never read before, especially about the less than saintly incidents in Wyatt’s past and events in Tombstone that led up to and followed after the infamous shoot-out. Gardner keeps the pace moving and the details engaging. I found the book an enjoyable, fast read that made me thankful for what Gardner’s research uncovered, but also left me wondering about all those things we’ll never know about the famous friends: Where and how did Wyatt find out about Doc’s passing? What happened to all of Doc’s letters to his dear cousin Mattie? Can you imagine what could be learned about the dentist-turned-gambler if they were ever discovered? Gardner would have to write another book about it all, and I’d be just as eager to read that one as I was to read Brothers of the Gun.
Gunfighters of the Old West have become legendary for their exploits, whether they actually happened or not. Like so many other legends and outlaws, when it comes to Wyatt Earp and his tubercular sidekick, Doc Holliday, it’s difficult, if not impossible, to know what is truth, what is legend, and what is the product of false accusations, prejudiced journalism, and dime store novel lore.
I’ve read several books written on the subject, only to later learn that most were not authentic, so I was quite intrigued by Gardner's take on Saintly Wyatt and Hardened Killer Holiday as they are often portrayed. I was also intrigued by the book’s premise of looking into the friendship that is often referred to as unlikely between the lawman and the gambler. What Gardner finds is that the friendship isn’t that unlikely because the two actually had quite a lot in common. They both took common law wives whose backgrounds were less than innocent. Both had incidents in their pasts that led them to seek new pastures.
While Earp is often portrayed as a lawman, he was, in fact a gambler just like Holliday. While the former dentist chased the next wild town and its many barrooms and gambling houses, Wyatt chased the next big rush, always looking to make that big fortune that seemed always one step ahead of him. Both were unfailingly loyal and seemingly without fear when it came to standing their ground in the face of threats and violence.
I've always found Gardner's books to be well researched and fact-based, and Brothers of the Gun was no different. I appreciate that Gardner admits when information isn't available to verify speculation. In this book, he brings forth a lot of information that I'd never read before, especially about the less than saintly incidents in Wyatt’s past and events in Tombstone that led up to and followed after the infamous shoot-out. Gardner keeps the pace moving and the details engaging. I found the book an enjoyable, fast read that made me thankful for what Gardner’s research uncovered, but also left me wondering about all those things we’ll never know about the famous friends: Where and how did Wyatt find out about Doc’s passing? What happened to all of Doc’s letters to his dear cousin Mattie? Can you imagine what could be learned about the dentist-turned-gambler if they were ever discovered? Gardner would have to write another book about it all, and I’d be just as eager to read that one as I was to read Brothers of the Gun.
February 24, 2026
Brothers of the Gun takes on familiar Western ground but approaches it from a slightly different angle. While much of the broad history surrounding Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday is well known, Gardner reframes their story by closely examining how their lives developed alongside one another. That parallel structure gives the narrative a fresh rhythm.
One of the strengths of the book is its attention to detail. Gardner surfaces lesser-known facts that help explain how two very different men ended up bound by circumstance, loyalty, and violence. The reader gains a clearer sense of how chance meetings and shared enemies shaped their relationship over time.
The author’s research is solid and evident throughout. Gardner does not rush the story, instead grounding each phase of their lives in social context and personal motivation. At one point he notes that the West was a place where “reputation traveled faster than truth,” a line that neatly captures the environment both men navigated.
For readers like myself who have visited Tombstone, Arizona, the book has added resonance. Familiar locations such as Allen Street and the O.K. Corral take on new meaning when paired with Gardner’s descriptions. Seeing the town firsthand provides a strong sense of scale and geography that complements the narrative and makes the events feel more immediate.
Gardner also succeeds in portraying Earp and Holliday as complex figures rather than simple legends. Their flaws, tempers, and contradictions are presented alongside their loyalty and resolve. This balance helps strip away some of the myth while still respecting why their story endures.
Overall, this is a well-researched and thoughtfully constructed account that rewards readers who think they already know the story. It does not reinvent the history, but it deepens it, offering nuance and perspective that feel earned. For anyone interested in the American West and its enduring figures, the book provides a worthwhile and engaging read.
One of the strengths of the book is its attention to detail. Gardner surfaces lesser-known facts that help explain how two very different men ended up bound by circumstance, loyalty, and violence. The reader gains a clearer sense of how chance meetings and shared enemies shaped their relationship over time.
The author’s research is solid and evident throughout. Gardner does not rush the story, instead grounding each phase of their lives in social context and personal motivation. At one point he notes that the West was a place where “reputation traveled faster than truth,” a line that neatly captures the environment both men navigated.
For readers like myself who have visited Tombstone, Arizona, the book has added resonance. Familiar locations such as Allen Street and the O.K. Corral take on new meaning when paired with Gardner’s descriptions. Seeing the town firsthand provides a strong sense of scale and geography that complements the narrative and makes the events feel more immediate.
Gardner also succeeds in portraying Earp and Holliday as complex figures rather than simple legends. Their flaws, tempers, and contradictions are presented alongside their loyalty and resolve. This balance helps strip away some of the myth while still respecting why their story endures.
Overall, this is a well-researched and thoughtfully constructed account that rewards readers who think they already know the story. It does not reinvent the history, but it deepens it, offering nuance and perspective that feel earned. For anyone interested in the American West and its enduring figures, the book provides a worthwhile and engaging read.
November 9, 2025
*Disclosure: I received a free advance review copy of this book from NetGalley.
Mark Lee Gardner clearly poured extensive research into Brothers of the Gun. His narrative, however, has a streamlined quality—especially when it comes to portraying Doc Holliday, who often feels more like a sidekick in Wyatt’s saga rather than a fully fleshed-out historical figure. It's not as detailed or comprehensive as some other biographies swirling around, yet it is packed with facts that challenge the romanticized imagery often surrounding the duo. Gardner doesn't shy from exposing the less-than-glamorous aspects of Earp and Holliday, some of which I was already familiar with, and others that caught me off guard. Perhaps this was Gardner’s intention, a clever tactic to carve out a distinctive space in the crowded field of Wild West literature. There were occasional moments when I felt I was immersed in a fictional tale rather than a historical account—and maybe that was all by design.
But what do I know? I'm just a guy sharing thoughts from the dusty corners of my blog. Despite my moments of nitpicking, I enjoyed reading Brothers of the Gun. Gardner has a knack for weaving words; his prose dances off the page, and I found myself learning a few intriguing nuggets about Wyatt and Doc that I hadn’t encountered before. So, tip your hat and open your mind—this journey through the storied lives of two of the West’s most infamous characters is one worth taking. ╌★★★★✰
Find my full review at https://www.coffeeaddictedwriter.com/....
Mark Lee Gardner clearly poured extensive research into Brothers of the Gun. His narrative, however, has a streamlined quality—especially when it comes to portraying Doc Holliday, who often feels more like a sidekick in Wyatt’s saga rather than a fully fleshed-out historical figure. It's not as detailed or comprehensive as some other biographies swirling around, yet it is packed with facts that challenge the romanticized imagery often surrounding the duo. Gardner doesn't shy from exposing the less-than-glamorous aspects of Earp and Holliday, some of which I was already familiar with, and others that caught me off guard. Perhaps this was Gardner’s intention, a clever tactic to carve out a distinctive space in the crowded field of Wild West literature. There were occasional moments when I felt I was immersed in a fictional tale rather than a historical account—and maybe that was all by design.
But what do I know? I'm just a guy sharing thoughts from the dusty corners of my blog. Despite my moments of nitpicking, I enjoyed reading Brothers of the Gun. Gardner has a knack for weaving words; his prose dances off the page, and I found myself learning a few intriguing nuggets about Wyatt and Doc that I hadn’t encountered before. So, tip your hat and open your mind—this journey through the storied lives of two of the West’s most infamous characters is one worth taking. ╌★★★★✰
Find my full review at https://www.coffeeaddictedwriter.com/....
March 13, 2026
An excellent duel biography of Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday, making use of original sources (newspapers, letters, diaries, etc) to reconstruct their intertwined lives. The author is also very reliable in pointing out when any particular recorded event in their lives isn't 100% confirmed or is simply unlikely. There are extensive endnotes to back up the sources used. The author's conversational prose carries the story along effectively and keeps the reader engaged.
Both men were very flawed human beings, but Wyatt was brave, loyal to his brothers and his friends, and could be an excellent lawman when he stayed within the bounds of the law. Which he didn't always do, most notably during the Vendetta Ride after his brother Morgan was murdered. In that instance, though, it's difficult not to sympathize with him.
Doc was pretty much a drunken mess during his entire adult life, but he also had physical courage. He saved Wyatt's life in Dodge City and the two men became lifelong friends. Whatever other faults they unquestionably had, the two unlikely companions always had each other's back.
The book's last two paragraphs sum up its theme quite nicely: "When Sadie (Wyatt's wife) was working on her life's story, she [claims] that she and Wyatt had visited Doc one last time when he was dying in Glenwood Springs. There's no evidence of such a visit, no reports in the local newspapers of the famed Wyatt Earp in town. It may never have happened.
Even so, it's the ending we want."
Both men were very flawed human beings, but Wyatt was brave, loyal to his brothers and his friends, and could be an excellent lawman when he stayed within the bounds of the law. Which he didn't always do, most notably during the Vendetta Ride after his brother Morgan was murdered. In that instance, though, it's difficult not to sympathize with him.
Doc was pretty much a drunken mess during his entire adult life, but he also had physical courage. He saved Wyatt's life in Dodge City and the two men became lifelong friends. Whatever other faults they unquestionably had, the two unlikely companions always had each other's back.
The book's last two paragraphs sum up its theme quite nicely: "When Sadie (Wyatt's wife) was working on her life's story, she [claims] that she and Wyatt had visited Doc one last time when he was dying in Glenwood Springs. There's no evidence of such a visit, no reports in the local newspapers of the famed Wyatt Earp in town. It may never have happened.
Even so, it's the ending we want."
September 14, 2025
Thanks to NetGalley and Dutton for allowing me to read this ARC in exchange for an honest review. This book was well researched, well written and a pleasure to read. I've read a lot about Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday, but still learned a lot that I had not heard before. The author does an excellent job of telling the full histories of both Wyatt and Doc, warts and all, while examining their friendship through the years. He does a very thorough job of detailing Wyatt's days in Wichita and Dodge City, and does one of the best jobs I've yet read of explaining the events leading up to and describing the famous shootout at the OK Corral, as well as the aftermath. He also does an excellent job of detailing Wyatt's vendetta ride, probably the most clearly written description I've found. I would have liked a bit more information on their lives after Tombstone, but I understand that the main subject here was the friendship of Wyatt and Doc. The author brought out a lot of details I had not read before about their Tombstone days, and his analysis was top notch. You also meet, in less detail, all the other players like Virgil and Morgan Earp, Mattie, Sadie, Big Nosed Kate, Bat Masterson and the Cowboys. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and highly recommend it to anyone interested in the Old West, especially the real story of the shootout at the OK Corral. Also to anyone looking for a concise, yet thorough biography of Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday.
December 1, 2025
How well do you know the tale of the Shoot-out at the OK Corral? How many versions of this tale have you read? Well, get ready for another ride in the Earp vs Cowboys saga with Mark Gardner's Brothers of the Gun! But do not let the subtitle fool you, this books is about so much more than the shootout in Tombstone!
Mark Gardner lays the groundwork for the tale by digging up all the background on Wyatt Earp and his family along with similar attention to detail on Doc Holliday. The reader travels with the pair as they move west from Illinois and Georgia to Kansas and then on to New Mexico, Arizona, and California with stints in Colorado. And the reader learns about their employment or lack thereof along with their myriad family relationships. But Gardner's major focus is on the friendship between Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday and the impact that friendship had on those around the pair whether that be Big Nose Kate, the other Earp brothers, or the Cowboys gang of thieves.
Mark Gardner's Brothers of the Gun provides a look into the Old West through the lens of the Earp - Holiday partnership. The reader gets to time travel to the past and find not a black and white world of heroes and villains, but rather a world of gray where actions and men could be good or bad depending on one's point of view. If you are interested in visiting, do pick up a copy of Brothers of the Gun and enjoy!
Thanks Netgalley and Dutton for the chance to read this title!
Mark Gardner lays the groundwork for the tale by digging up all the background on Wyatt Earp and his family along with similar attention to detail on Doc Holliday. The reader travels with the pair as they move west from Illinois and Georgia to Kansas and then on to New Mexico, Arizona, and California with stints in Colorado. And the reader learns about their employment or lack thereof along with their myriad family relationships. But Gardner's major focus is on the friendship between Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday and the impact that friendship had on those around the pair whether that be Big Nose Kate, the other Earp brothers, or the Cowboys gang of thieves.
Mark Gardner's Brothers of the Gun provides a look into the Old West through the lens of the Earp - Holiday partnership. The reader gets to time travel to the past and find not a black and white world of heroes and villains, but rather a world of gray where actions and men could be good or bad depending on one's point of view. If you are interested in visiting, do pick up a copy of Brothers of the Gun and enjoy!
Thanks Netgalley and Dutton for the chance to read this title!
May 16, 2026
I normally dance between about 3-4 different books that I’m reading at a time; but I literally couldn’t put this story down wanting to know the conclusion and how things unfolded. The best stories are real life, and this book is a great illustration of that.
I’ve never watched the famous “tombstone” movie, so I went into this book incredibly ignorant as to the events of Tombstone Arizona, or who individuals such as doc holiday were. I had heard of the famous Earp brothers before, and knew that they were famous lawmen, but I knew next to nothing about who was who and what they accomplished.
This book attempts to tell the story of Doc Holiday and Wyatt Earp in a chronological telling of their lives, and to do so without the blemish of bias or sensational media attachment. Rather, it sets out to give a realistic historical narrative of what actually occurred in the unlawful boomtowns of 19th century America.
It’s rare than such an authentic, primary source focused, secondary source can be written in narrative format and work, but this book is exactly that. The author wrote in such a way that you’re learning history in a story narrative format, making it not only educational but entertaining as well. I really enjoyed this book a lot, and it’s sparked a much further interest into the lives and stories of some other famous old west individuals that I seek to soon explore. Great book.
I’ve never watched the famous “tombstone” movie, so I went into this book incredibly ignorant as to the events of Tombstone Arizona, or who individuals such as doc holiday were. I had heard of the famous Earp brothers before, and knew that they were famous lawmen, but I knew next to nothing about who was who and what they accomplished.
This book attempts to tell the story of Doc Holiday and Wyatt Earp in a chronological telling of their lives, and to do so without the blemish of bias or sensational media attachment. Rather, it sets out to give a realistic historical narrative of what actually occurred in the unlawful boomtowns of 19th century America.
It’s rare than such an authentic, primary source focused, secondary source can be written in narrative format and work, but this book is exactly that. The author wrote in such a way that you’re learning history in a story narrative format, making it not only educational but entertaining as well. I really enjoyed this book a lot, and it’s sparked a much further interest into the lives and stories of some other famous old west individuals that I seek to soon explore. Great book.
March 27, 2026
There’s something to be said for nonfiction books that read like novels, despite half of the book spent on notes and a bibliography (Do you read these parts? Or just finish the meaty bits and call it a day?). That word to be said? Satisfactory, in the most complimentary sense of the word.
Brothers of the Gun: Wyatt Earp, Doc Holliday, and a Reckoning in Tombstone, by Mark Lee Gardner, is a vivid, accessible account of the lives of two Western icons and the climax of their lives, which was the shootout at the O.K. Corral in Tombstone, Arizona. Gardner has indeed done his homework—although I admittedly skipped right through the notes—referencing interviews, newspaper accounts, and other primary source documents to tell the legendary tale authentically.
What I appreciated most about this book is that both Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday were portrayed not as legendary saints (I learned a new word, hagiographic), but as fallible humans—their faults as well as their strengths, their curses as well as their blessings, their failures as well as their triumphs, were all even-handedly and deftly illustrated. I wish more nonfiction books were written with the right combination of flair and down-to-earth elements.
I recommend this book to those who admire Westerns and those who love to read well-written biographies/nonfiction accounts of true events.
Brothers of the Gun: Wyatt Earp, Doc Holliday, and a Reckoning in Tombstone, by Mark Lee Gardner, is a vivid, accessible account of the lives of two Western icons and the climax of their lives, which was the shootout at the O.K. Corral in Tombstone, Arizona. Gardner has indeed done his homework—although I admittedly skipped right through the notes—referencing interviews, newspaper accounts, and other primary source documents to tell the legendary tale authentically.
What I appreciated most about this book is that both Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday were portrayed not as legendary saints (I learned a new word, hagiographic), but as fallible humans—their faults as well as their strengths, their curses as well as their blessings, their failures as well as their triumphs, were all even-handedly and deftly illustrated. I wish more nonfiction books were written with the right combination of flair and down-to-earth elements.
I recommend this book to those who admire Westerns and those who love to read well-written biographies/nonfiction accounts of true events.
November 19, 2025
This was a well researched and entertaining biography of Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday. Gardner does a good job of presenting a balanced view of these men. There was a lot of care given to showing the limitations and biases present in the limited primary source data.
There were no major revelations, but I think that I would be much more skeptical of any book claiming to have a major revelation about Tombstone. I did learn a few new things and overall enjoyed my reading experience.
My one quibble was that there were quite a few abrupt transitions. For example, in the section about Doc's time in Las Vegas when he entered and lost a lottery pool for a violin, Gardner says that it is a good thing that he lost, because the last thing that Doc needs is a violin. To me this reads like the beginning of a longer anecdote; why is a violin, specifically, the last thing that Doc needs? However, the book immediately moved on to the next scene.
Thank you to NetGalley and Dutton for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
There were no major revelations, but I think that I would be much more skeptical of any book claiming to have a major revelation about Tombstone. I did learn a few new things and overall enjoyed my reading experience.
My one quibble was that there were quite a few abrupt transitions. For example, in the section about Doc's time in Las Vegas when he entered and lost a lottery pool for a violin, Gardner says that it is a good thing that he lost, because the last thing that Doc needs is a violin. To me this reads like the beginning of a longer anecdote; why is a violin, specifically, the last thing that Doc needs? However, the book immediately moved on to the next scene.
Thank you to NetGalley and Dutton for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
June 8, 2026
I feel in a previous life that I had a strong presence in the wild west. I have always been enamored with and drawn to cowboys and gunslingers. I've been a big time fan of the movie Tombstone, and yes I know, it's a movie but the characters have always played into my soul. I happened to come across this book while getting ready to leave Barnes and Noble, and I was immediately drawn to it.
I've never known where to start for some western, gunslinger, cowboy material but this was going to be it.
Mark Lee Gardner does a good job of story telling through historical research. He doesn't bore you with the mundane but gives you the facts that seem important to establishing the relationship these two had with one another and society they lived in. Doc seems like a side character but I blame that more on he wasn't as prominent in his exploits when compared to Wyatt.
This book works as a way to give you a solid idea of how the Earps and Doc, moved around, what their motivations were, and what it was like to see how news was spread when major events occured in one town or another. They were muddled with bias accounts and reporting, and it was fascinating to read. It was a fun ride and trip into the west.
I've never known where to start for some western, gunslinger, cowboy material but this was going to be it.
Mark Lee Gardner does a good job of story telling through historical research. He doesn't bore you with the mundane but gives you the facts that seem important to establishing the relationship these two had with one another and society they lived in. Doc seems like a side character but I blame that more on he wasn't as prominent in his exploits when compared to Wyatt.
This book works as a way to give you a solid idea of how the Earps and Doc, moved around, what their motivations were, and what it was like to see how news was spread when major events occured in one town or another. They were muddled with bias accounts and reporting, and it was fascinating to read. It was a fun ride and trip into the west.
February 20, 2026
I picked this up for a UMW Great Lives lecture and found a gripping, well-researched narrative that goes far beyond the legends we think we know. While history often reduces the Earps and Doc Holliday to a single afternoon in Tombstone, this book reminds us that they lived colorful, complex lives long before that fateful day.
It offers a much better perspective on who these men were as individuals before the world defined them by a few minutes of violence, but it also serves as a powerful reminder of how easy it is to let one moment overshadow a person's full history.
This is a must-read for anyone who thinks they know the story of the O.K. Corral. It is a sobering look at how single events can define a lifetime, for better or worse.
It offers a much better perspective on who these men were as individuals before the world defined them by a few minutes of violence, but it also serves as a powerful reminder of how easy it is to let one moment overshadow a person's full history.
This is a must-read for anyone who thinks they know the story of the O.K. Corral. It is a sobering look at how single events can define a lifetime, for better or worse.
December 13, 2025
Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday are two of the most legendary figures from the American West. Books, movies, and television have popularized their friendship, but what is the true story? Author Mark Lee Gardner separates the truth from the lore in this fascinating look at these men. Gardner writes in such a powerful way that I feel like I had a front-row seat to the entire story. I know some people feel like it is a challenge to make history entertaining, but this book did that beautifully. Gardner did a phenomenal amount of research, finding many firsthand accounts, allowing him to deliver a nuanced look at these two men and the world they found themselves in.
January 12, 2026
Over 4 stars. Last year I was on a kick of reading histories of the Old West and happened up several by Tom Clavin and associates that were excellent. I have to say that Brothers of the Gun ranks up there with those at the very least. It has to be the most extensive history of Wyatt Earp and his association with Doc Holiday that I have read. A fascinating read although at times a little too extensive in terms of all the smaller events in their lives. I kept comparing it to the movie Tombstone with Val Kilmer and Kurt Russell which was very well done but not strictly historical. If you like these types of histories would be hard pressed to find a better way to spend your time.
February 18, 2026
I'd certainly heard of the Earp brothers and their friend, Doc Holliday prior to reading this book. I really enjoyed it. I also appreciated that author's candid way of admitting where history is silent regarding certain details of the lives of the characters described in the book. All in all, I highly encourage any student of history - particularly of the Old West - to read this book. I really enjoyed it! I also watched the movie "Earp" starring Kevin Costner after reading this book. The book, as do all books, provides some details about the story of the Earps and Holliday that the movie cannot include. Check them both out!!!
March 9, 2026
Well written, engaging, and an honest, objective depiction of complex people in complex situations, in a world and a social system that is difficult for the modern mind to understand. Gardner takes you back to the times and immerses you in the culture, familiarizing you with the culture and the men and women populating it. The Earps, Doc Holliday, Bat Masterson, the men and women good and bad with whom they interacted, and how those interactions created the many myths and storylines about them. What is real, what isn't - what wasn't! ... Gardner has written a wonderful history that will lay it out for you.
May 10, 2026
Revisiting the well-worn story of Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday that is grounded, and a lot messier than the legend. Instead of clear heroes and villains, everyone lives in shades of gray, which makes the story far more interesting. The pacing is tight, the research is solid, and the buildup to the O.K. Corral (and its aftermath) is especially compelling. It reads more like a gritty narrative than a dry history. My only knock: the book leans more toward Wyatt than Doc, and I wanted a bit more balance. Still, it’s a great ride through the Old West. If you loved Tombstone, just be ready, this is the version where history quietly walks in and says, “I’ll be your huckleberry…”!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 69 reviews