3 1/2
First, let's get rid of the unpleasant. I can't believe Ms Saintcrow -who has been in the business more than 10 years - could not publish something better edited. Starting from the cover where you find a different name and ending with many missing words in the text.
Nothing troubling, mind you, but she is still a very well published author. You really don't expect such mistakes, however minor.
The really good: plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose. If you have loved her stronger, most difficult heroines, Smoke let you see the beginning of her mould.
It had for me that reckless feeling that causes me palpitations and a twin rage that I so loved in Dante.
It's not an easy book, nor an easy heroine. The first is at times bogged down by endless descriptions, the second is on a self destructive bend that is difficult to watch. I prefer that destruction going forward, I fear.
For her fan, a must read, even if you might end hating it.