What do you think?
Rate this book
Constitutional Conflicts between Congresss and the President
Nearly three decades after its initial publication, Louis Fisher's durable classic remains at the head of its class-a book that Congressional Quarterly called "as close to being indispensable as anything published in this field." This newly revised and updated fifth edition emphatically reinforces that sterling reputation.
Fisher dissects the crucial constitutional disputes between the executive and legislative branches of government from the Constitutional Convention through President Clinton's impeachment battles to the recent controversies over President Bush's conduct as commander in chief. He ventures beyond traditional discussions of Supreme Court decisions to examine the day-to-day working relationships between the president and Congress.
By analyzing a mixture of judicial pronouncements, executive acts, and legislative debates, Fisher pinpoints the critical areas of legislative-executive appointment powers, investigatory powers, legislative and executive vetoes, the budgetary process, and war powers. He then examines these areas of tension within a concrete political and historical context.
To scholars, this book offers a comprehensive examination of the institutions and issues of public law. For practitioners, general readers, and students of American government, it demonstrates how constitutional issues shape and define current events.
"Presents a set of issues, themes, questions, and arguments that will continue to be of fundamental interest to constitutional scholars in particular and political scientists in general."-George C. Edwards III, author of Presidential Leadership
"An extremely worthwhile book, adaptable to a variety of courses."-Jeffrey K. Tulis, author of The Rhetorical Presidency
New material in this
* Post-9/11 wars in Afghanistan and Iraq
* Military tribunals and NSA eavesdropping
* Kosovo war in 1999
* Impeachment of President Clinton
* Termination of ABM treaty
* Controversies over appointments and removals
* Disputes over executive orders and proclamations
* Presidential signing statements
* Developments with item veto and pocket veto
* Public access to intelligence budgets
* FBI search warrant of congressman's office
* State secrets privilege
* Presidential and vice-presidential immunity
Fisher dissects the crucial constitutional disputes between the executive and legislative branches of government from the Constitutional Convention through President Clinton's impeachment battles to the recent controversies over President Bush's conduct as commander in chief. He ventures beyond traditional discussions of Supreme Court decisions to examine the day-to-day working relationships between the president and Congress.
By analyzing a mixture of judicial pronouncements, executive acts, and legislative debates, Fisher pinpoints the critical areas of legislative-executive appointment powers, investigatory powers, legislative and executive vetoes, the budgetary process, and war powers. He then examines these areas of tension within a concrete political and historical context.
To scholars, this book offers a comprehensive examination of the institutions and issues of public law. For practitioners, general readers, and students of American government, it demonstrates how constitutional issues shape and define current events.
"Presents a set of issues, themes, questions, and arguments that will continue to be of fundamental interest to constitutional scholars in particular and political scientists in general."-George C. Edwards III, author of Presidential Leadership
"An extremely worthwhile book, adaptable to a variety of courses."-Jeffrey K. Tulis, author of The Rhetorical Presidency
New material in this
* Post-9/11 wars in Afghanistan and Iraq
* Military tribunals and NSA eavesdropping
* Kosovo war in 1999
* Impeachment of President Clinton
* Termination of ABM treaty
* Controversies over appointments and removals
* Disputes over executive orders and proclamations
* Presidential signing statements
* Developments with item veto and pocket veto
* Public access to intelligence budgets
* FBI search warrant of congressman's office
* State secrets privilege
* Presidential and vice-presidential immunity
344 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 1985
1 person is currently reading
38 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews
June 6, 2015
This book is not exactly a joy to read, but it does a good job of hitting all the major areas of conflict between the executive branch and legislative branch. It's the kind of book that is extremely handy to have read if you suspect you may get a question about that sort thing on a comprehensive exam or similar test.
The opening of the book is a little intimidating, but once Fisher starts going through the paces, he clearly lays out the history of various sources of conflict. He suggests that the two branches work together best when individuals involved adopt a pragmatic view toward their relations and abandon rigid, prescriptive approaches toward their interaction.
Even though reading it is a bit like taking your medicine, it is good medicine in the end.
The opening of the book is a little intimidating, but once Fisher starts going through the paces, he clearly lays out the history of various sources of conflict. He suggests that the two branches work together best when individuals involved adopt a pragmatic view toward their relations and abandon rigid, prescriptive approaches toward their interaction.
Even though reading it is a bit like taking your medicine, it is good medicine in the end.
March 5, 2012
No one argues the Congressional side of the debate better than Fisher.
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews