What do you think?
Rate this book
The Girl Who Fell Through Time
Selene Duskbriar is like any other young noblewoman—elegant, pampered, and wholly unprepared for betrayal. But when her ambitious husband steals her birthright, sparks a war, and ultimately causes her death, Selene’s life takes an unexpected turn. Sent back in time to the day of her engagement, she seizes her second chance to rewrite her fate.
In a desperate move, Selene marries Lord Dorian Nightbloom, a kind but unassuming lord, and flees to his quiet country estate, determined to hide from the schemes of her former husband, Duke Drakefell. Surrounded by Dorian’s gentle nature and the loyal warmth of his household, Selene’s heart begins to open in ways she never expected, drawing her toward a new life—and love—that she never knew she could want.
However, Duke Drakefell hasn’t forgotten his plans, and with her unique knowledge of the future, Selene may be the only one who can thwart his deadly ambitions. But will love and courage be enough to stop a war—and can she finally become the heroine of her own story?
In a desperate move, Selene marries Lord Dorian Nightbloom, a kind but unassuming lord, and flees to his quiet country estate, determined to hide from the schemes of her former husband, Duke Drakefell. Surrounded by Dorian’s gentle nature and the loyal warmth of his household, Selene’s heart begins to open in ways she never expected, drawing her toward a new life—and love—that she never knew she could want.
However, Duke Drakefell hasn’t forgotten his plans, and with her unique knowledge of the future, Selene may be the only one who can thwart his deadly ambitions. But will love and courage be enough to stop a war—and can she finally become the heroine of her own story?
377 pages, Kindle Edition
Published May 31, 2025
About the author
Katherine Macdonald
37 books468 followersKatherine "Kate" Macdonald writes the books she wishes she could have read more of as a teen—stories of fierce girls and gentle boys, of romance and adventure, and where the "three Cs" (chemistry, communication and consent) reign supreme. There may still be a little bit of miscommunication along the way as the characters grow as people, but she tries not to rely on that trope too much!
She loves books packed with witty banter, stories where you can feel the love growing between a pair, that include excellent, well-developed side-characters and a few subtly-foreshadowed twists and turns. She despises toxic relationships and tales that rely on old-fashioned notions of male and female stereotypes. She enjoys bending expectations and crafting worlds where sexism is a thing of the past. She considers herself an LGBTQIA+ friendly author, and her stories include a range of characters from within the community and absolutely no discrimination in sight.
She holds a BA in English and Creative Writing from Lancaster University, and a PGCE in teaching English and Drama from the University of Exeter. She's been a writer since she was old enough to hold a crayon, but it was only after surviving a year of parenthood and a full-time job on less than six hours of sleep a night that she finally gained the courage to publish her debut novel, "The Rose and the Thorn." It's a retelling of Beauty and the Beast inspired by a dream of a girl surrounded by snow in a field of flowers.
At her heart, Macdonald is storyteller, and it is her dream to inspire others in the way that she has been inspired.
She lives in Devon with her manic child and well-behaved cats.
She loves books packed with witty banter, stories where you can feel the love growing between a pair, that include excellent, well-developed side-characters and a few subtly-foreshadowed twists and turns. She despises toxic relationships and tales that rely on old-fashioned notions of male and female stereotypes. She enjoys bending expectations and crafting worlds where sexism is a thing of the past. She considers herself an LGBTQIA+ friendly author, and her stories include a range of characters from within the community and absolutely no discrimination in sight.
She holds a BA in English and Creative Writing from Lancaster University, and a PGCE in teaching English and Drama from the University of Exeter. She's been a writer since she was old enough to hold a crayon, but it was only after surviving a year of parenthood and a full-time job on less than six hours of sleep a night that she finally gained the courage to publish her debut novel, "The Rose and the Thorn." It's a retelling of Beauty and the Beast inspired by a dream of a girl surrounded by snow in a field of flowers.
At her heart, Macdonald is storyteller, and it is her dream to inspire others in the way that she has been inspired.
She lives in Devon with her manic child and well-behaved cats.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 88 reviews
July 15, 2025
“𝙎𝙚𝙡𝙚𝙣𝙚 𝙧𝙚𝙢𝙚𝙢𝙗𝙚𝙧𝙨 𝙩𝙝𝙞𝙨 𝙘𝙤𝙣𝙫𝙚𝙧𝙨𝙖𝙩𝙞𝙤𝙣, 𝙖𝙡𝙢𝙤𝙨𝙩 𝙬𝙤𝙧𝙙-𝙛𝙤𝙧-𝙬𝙤𝙧𝙙, 𝙡𝙞𝙠𝙚 𝙩𝙧𝙖𝙘𝙞𝙣𝙜 𝙥𝙖𝙥𝙚𝙧 𝙤𝙫𝙚𝙧 𝙖 𝙨𝙩𝙤𝙧𝙮. 𝙄𝙩'𝙨 𝙡𝙞𝙠𝙚 𝙨𝙝𝙚'𝙨 𝙩𝙪𝙧𝙣𝙚𝙙 𝙩𝙝𝙚 𝙥𝙖𝙜𝙚 𝙤𝙛 𝙖 𝙗𝙤𝙤𝙠 𝙩𝙤 𝙛𝙞𝙣𝙙 𝙞𝙩 𝙥𝙧𝙞𝙣𝙩𝙚𝙙 𝙟𝙪𝙨𝙩 𝙡𝙞𝙠𝙚 𝙩𝙝𝙚 𝙡𝙖𝙨𝙩 𝙤𝙣𝙚.
𝙊𝙙𝙙. 𝙎𝙩𝙧𝙖𝙣𝙜𝙚. 𝙐𝙣𝙨𝙚𝙩𝙩𝙡𝙞𝙣𝙜.”
My rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5/5
If you were anything like me, then you probably read otome isekai manga and manhwas during covid. Obsessively. Well, if it wasn't you, it was definitely me, and even to this day I hold the otome isekai/villainess genre close to my heart.
The Girl Who Fell Through Time is similar in that regard, in that it is a historical romance with a hint of fantasy elements. Selene Duskbriar, after her year of marriage to the duke and finding out that he was treasonous to the kingdom, was shot at. Thus, ending her life. Except, not, when she woke up one year ago, on the day where the duke was planning to propose to her at her parent's party. Terrified of living that reality all over again, she asks Lord Dorian Nightbloom, an unassuming noble with nothing striking in particular, to marry her, which he agreed.
This story was such a delight to read from start to end, with an ending that frankly should be illegal. But thank goodness this is a duology! The plot was intriguing, as we navigate through Selene's second life and second marriage, and while her relationship with him deepens, we learn more about Dorian as well, and we find out he's not much of the wallflower as he makes himself seen. The first half explores their relationship together, while the second half highlights more on the drama and mystery involving the Duke, because even in this timeline he has his eyes set on Selene. It had me glued to the page, unwilling to part. The writing was also such a delight to read, the way the author mixes the prose with beautiful imagery and detail but in such a way that it doesn’t feel heavy or bogged down. It was just so easy to imagine the scenes in my head. Ugh. Love.
The romance. The romance??? THE ROMANCE. All that time developing their relationship, so when they finally realised their feelings for each other?? Had me giggling, had me gagging, had me yearning like crazy. It was addictive. The way these two characters fit so nicely 😭💖 Scarred from her previous life with the duke, she was apprehensive with Dorian, but he was so patient and gave her the space she needed to process everything, and was always an attentive listener to her. What more could I ask for??? Bro idkwhat else to write ah but if you love historical romance and OI mangas/manhwas this is right up your alley! This will be available at the end of this month 💖
Thank you to Booksprout and the author for providing an e-arc in exchange for an honest review hehe
𝙊𝙙𝙙. 𝙎𝙩𝙧𝙖𝙣𝙜𝙚. 𝙐𝙣𝙨𝙚𝙩𝙩𝙡𝙞𝙣𝙜.”
My rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5/5
If you were anything like me, then you probably read otome isekai manga and manhwas during covid. Obsessively. Well, if it wasn't you, it was definitely me, and even to this day I hold the otome isekai/villainess genre close to my heart.
The Girl Who Fell Through Time is similar in that regard, in that it is a historical romance with a hint of fantasy elements. Selene Duskbriar, after her year of marriage to the duke and finding out that he was treasonous to the kingdom, was shot at. Thus, ending her life. Except, not, when she woke up one year ago, on the day where the duke was planning to propose to her at her parent's party. Terrified of living that reality all over again, she asks Lord Dorian Nightbloom, an unassuming noble with nothing striking in particular, to marry her, which he agreed.
This story was such a delight to read from start to end, with an ending that frankly should be illegal. But thank goodness this is a duology! The plot was intriguing, as we navigate through Selene's second life and second marriage, and while her relationship with him deepens, we learn more about Dorian as well, and we find out he's not much of the wallflower as he makes himself seen. The first half explores their relationship together, while the second half highlights more on the drama and mystery involving the Duke, because even in this timeline he has his eyes set on Selene. It had me glued to the page, unwilling to part. The writing was also such a delight to read, the way the author mixes the prose with beautiful imagery and detail but in such a way that it doesn’t feel heavy or bogged down. It was just so easy to imagine the scenes in my head. Ugh. Love.
The romance. The romance??? THE ROMANCE. All that time developing their relationship, so when they finally realised their feelings for each other?? Had me giggling, had me gagging, had me yearning like crazy. It was addictive. The way these two characters fit so nicely 😭💖 Scarred from her previous life with the duke, she was apprehensive with Dorian, but he was so patient and gave her the space she needed to process everything, and was always an attentive listener to her. What more could I ask for??? Bro idkwhat else to write ah but if you love historical romance and OI mangas/manhwas this is right up your alley! This will be available at the end of this month 💖
Thank you to Booksprout and the author for providing an e-arc in exchange for an honest review hehe
August 5, 2025
I feel lucky to have found this book
July 31, 2025
Well, I read this in about 24 hours. THAT LAST LINE!? Excuse me. Thankfully this is now a completed duology and I can dive right in.
July 24, 2025
“Does it hurt when I touch you?” she asks.
He shakes his head. “It only hurts when you don’t.”
I started this at 10pm, stayed up till 2am, and finished before noon the next day. As such, I think it's safe to say that I absolutely adored this book. A new Katherine Macdonald favorite and sure to be one of my top reads of the year. I can't wait for book two!
He shakes his head. “It only hurts when you don’t.”
I started this at 10pm, stayed up till 2am, and finished before noon the next day. As such, I think it's safe to say that I absolutely adored this book. A new Katherine Macdonald favorite and sure to be one of my top reads of the year. I can't wait for book two!
Read
July 25, 2025Another duology now completed!
The Girl Who Fell Through Time fulfils my long awaited desire of writing a book about a marriage of convenience. It also scratches my time-travel itch, although I will admit it's not as much a part of the book as I would like. (Guess I'll have to write another one)
It was inspired by reading far too much manhwa and also because I binge watched Spy Family and wanted a marriage of convenience and also a found family dynamic (but also with a LOT more romance). It's set in a regency inspired society that worships four gods, but otherwise operates a lot like early 1800s England... though there are references to indoor plumbing because I don't want my poor characters to suffer THAT much. Abusive marriages, wounds, death, illness? Sure. No running water? Abhorrent.
When I first starting writing, Selene was initially meant to be much more vain and spoiled, but I quickly realised that her awful first marriage would have rubbed a lot of this away from her, and she was a lot softer--and meeker--as a result. I wanted a heroine who didn't have to ride into battle to be strong, whose strength lay in other areas, who was no less of a badass because she didn't pick up a sword. I have written many of those. I'll write many more. But there are different kinds of strength.
Dorian, meanwhile, might be a bit of a swash-buckler, but like Selene, his real strength lies in his heart. He's more reserved and bookish than any of my other heroes, but I think I love him all the more for it.
I hope that you do, too.
The Girl Who Fell Through Time fulfils my long awaited desire of writing a book about a marriage of convenience. It also scratches my time-travel itch, although I will admit it's not as much a part of the book as I would like. (Guess I'll have to write another one)
It was inspired by reading far too much manhwa and also because I binge watched Spy Family and wanted a marriage of convenience and also a found family dynamic (but also with a LOT more romance). It's set in a regency inspired society that worships four gods, but otherwise operates a lot like early 1800s England... though there are references to indoor plumbing because I don't want my poor characters to suffer THAT much. Abusive marriages, wounds, death, illness? Sure. No running water? Abhorrent.
When I first starting writing, Selene was initially meant to be much more vain and spoiled, but I quickly realised that her awful first marriage would have rubbed a lot of this away from her, and she was a lot softer--and meeker--as a result. I wanted a heroine who didn't have to ride into battle to be strong, whose strength lay in other areas, who was no less of a badass because she didn't pick up a sword. I have written many of those. I'll write many more. But there are different kinds of strength.
Dorian, meanwhile, might be a bit of a swash-buckler, but like Selene, his real strength lies in his heart. He's more reserved and bookish than any of my other heroes, but I think I love him all the more for it.
I hope that you do, too.
June 13, 2025
I’m gonna throw up. This was so good oh MY GOD. It needed a little more editing cus there was some grammar and spelling mix ups but I can’t even be the slightest bit peeved about that because this story was INCREDIBLE.
In a sea of broody shadow daddies, I have found sweet, sweet Dorian Nightbloom! He’s such a beautiful breath of fresh air!! And I even really liked Selene as a FMC, her troubles were relatable and she wasn’t a snarky badass like so many other FMCs are nowadays. And I mean no offense or insult to authors who have written shadow daddies and overpowered FMCs, or the ones who enjoy reading those books, but I am so incredibly tired of both. But that is a me problem.
It has been so long since a book has pulled me in from just the first few pages. The romance had me giggling and kicking my feet (internally). The found family was wonderfully done. I only was a little annoyed at Selene at first because I thought maybe she felt herself too good to downgrade her lifestyle, but I quickly realized that she had been so ingrained in her former lifestyle that it was simply a shock to her moving into Dorian’s house and not necessarily her turning her nose up at the way he “ran” his household. Watching her come to be comfortable with herself and start to feel empowered was heartwarming.
Katherine Macdonald thank you so much for this wonderful experience and I will be buying both this book and the 2nd one in paperback when the 2nd book releases, since I read this on KU. And if you’re seeing this I would love to be an ARC reader for any of your future books 😭
This is a, dare I say, 6 star read ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
In a sea of broody shadow daddies, I have found sweet, sweet Dorian Nightbloom! He’s such a beautiful breath of fresh air!! And I even really liked Selene as a FMC, her troubles were relatable and she wasn’t a snarky badass like so many other FMCs are nowadays. And I mean no offense or insult to authors who have written shadow daddies and overpowered FMCs, or the ones who enjoy reading those books, but I am so incredibly tired of both. But that is a me problem.
It has been so long since a book has pulled me in from just the first few pages. The romance had me giggling and kicking my feet (internally). The found family was wonderfully done. I only was a little annoyed at Selene at first because I thought maybe she felt herself too good to downgrade her lifestyle, but I quickly realized that she had been so ingrained in her former lifestyle that it was simply a shock to her moving into Dorian’s house and not necessarily her turning her nose up at the way he “ran” his household. Watching her come to be comfortable with herself and start to feel empowered was heartwarming.
Katherine Macdonald thank you so much for this wonderful experience and I will be buying both this book and the 2nd one in paperback when the 2nd book releases, since I read this on KU. And if you’re seeing this I would love to be an ARC reader for any of your future books 😭
This is a, dare I say, 6 star read ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
June 1, 2025
“The problem with holding you, Selene,” he says quietly, “is that every time I do, it gets a little harder to let go.”
No notes. I absolutely devoured this. I love Dorian and Selene. 🩷 Five stars.
Website | Bookstagram | BookTok
No notes. I absolutely devoured this. I love Dorian and Selene. 🩷 Five stars.
Website | Bookstagram | BookTok
August 22, 2025
“So if your heart is too weak to bear this all alone, take mine. It’s only ever been yours”
I loved this book with all my heart.
I loved this book with all my heart.
June 3, 2025
I believe this story consumed me just as much as I did it.
There were so many elements here that I absolutely adore. Selene is not your typical “ bad ass “ mfc, but she is strong in her own ways and soft in others that matter just as much.
There is mystery, regency vibes, a sweet slow burn romance, and so much more.
I did not want to put this book down -
& those last lines had me gasping!
Can not wait for the second book.
There were so many elements here that I absolutely adore. Selene is not your typical “ bad ass “ mfc, but she is strong in her own ways and soft in others that matter just as much.
There is mystery, regency vibes, a sweet slow burn romance, and so much more.
I did not want to put this book down -
& those last lines had me gasping!
Can not wait for the second book.
August 2, 2025
I thoroughly enjoyed this book - I usually go for a morally grey, shadow daddy, enemies to lovers storyline, so imagine my surprise when I picked up this book and absolutely loved it!
The main character was sweet but strong, determined to make a difference in her life and station. The MMC also allowed her to be herself in a time when that wasn't allowed. I loved them together.
A Refreshing Change of Pace
The pacing was good, the characters and their relationships evolved naturally, and the romance was slow but came to fruition nicely. I usually don't like time travel, but this was done in such a way that it was not intrusive and was seamlessly put into the story line. I am now a fan!
The twist at the end I had vague inklings about, but I was still surprised when I came about. I like that it ended with the main characters in a good place, not a crazy cliffhanger.
All in all, this was an excellent read. I can't wait to read book 2!!!!
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
The main character was sweet but strong, determined to make a difference in her life and station. The MMC also allowed her to be herself in a time when that wasn't allowed. I loved them together.
A Refreshing Change of Pace
The pacing was good, the characters and their relationships evolved naturally, and the romance was slow but came to fruition nicely. I usually don't like time travel, but this was done in such a way that it was not intrusive and was seamlessly put into the story line. I am now a fan!
The twist at the end I had vague inklings about, but I was still surprised when I came about. I like that it ended with the main characters in a good place, not a crazy cliffhanger.
All in all, this was an excellent read. I can't wait to read book 2!!!!
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
September 20, 2025
Absolutely delightful! My favorite of Macdonald’s books since A Curse of Hope and Shadows—and very much a similar vibe. There is just enough mystery and intrigue to make you wonder how it will all come together, while in the meantime you can luxuriate in an expertly written slow burn. Highly recommend, and will definitely read part 2.
August 2, 2025
Honestly closer to 4.5 - was very pleasantly surprised by this one! On to the second in the duo logy!
August 2, 2025
6 star read I think - read this within 24 hours (almost one sitting) and picking up the second one immediately
April 26, 2025
While this was a slower paced story than others by this author, it was just as engaging. I loved watching the sweet, gentle romance unfold between Selene and Dorian—much needed after what Selene has gone through! Seeing Selene start to heal and grow made the journey that much more satisfying. It was fun to see how clever she can be with the resources at hand.
As always, I swooned for the LI—Dorian is reserved and kindhearted, but on multiple occasions reminded me of Westley from The Princess Bride. I found myself grinning and squealing in delight as he and Selene bonded over a number of things. They are too cute!
I’m very much looking forward to what’s in store for the next book!
Contains:
-Violence
-Sexual Content
-Language
-Verbal Abuse
As always, I swooned for the LI—Dorian is reserved and kindhearted, but on multiple occasions reminded me of Westley from The Princess Bride. I found myself grinning and squealing in delight as he and Selene bonded over a number of things. They are too cute!
I’m very much looking forward to what’s in store for the next book!
Contains:
-Violence
-Sexual Content
-Language
-Verbal Abuse
Read
July 6, 2025This book gripped me from the start, and I just couldn't stop reading. In fact, I finished it in less than a day.
Intrigue, atmosphere, and intriguing characters and relationships. These were the three main points that made the book for me.
I feel that most of the reviews on Katherine Macdonalds' book focus mostly on the romantic relationship. For me, the relationship was ok (I think I'll be more into it after finishing the duology) but the plot and simply the "vibes" she can evoke so easily are what worked so well for me, and one of the main reasons I keep returning to her books.
The pace felt both slow and fast at the same time, like nothing much was happening, but the everyday bits felt important.
I just wasn't a fan of the present tense. But that's on me, and most of the time I was able to overlook it.
All in all, a very intriguing read that completely grabbed me and made me glad I had the ARC of the second book to start right after finishing.
Beware:
1. It ends with most of the questions unanswered. I'm hoping the second book will have those answers;
2. There is a sex scene.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Intrigue, atmosphere, and intriguing characters and relationships. These were the three main points that made the book for me.
I feel that most of the reviews on Katherine Macdonalds' book focus mostly on the romantic relationship. For me, the relationship was ok (I think I'll be more into it after finishing the duology) but the plot and simply the "vibes" she can evoke so easily are what worked so well for me, and one of the main reasons I keep returning to her books.
The pace felt both slow and fast at the same time, like nothing much was happening, but the everyday bits felt important.
I just wasn't a fan of the present tense. But that's on me, and most of the time I was able to overlook it.
All in all, a very intriguing read that completely grabbed me and made me glad I had the ARC of the second book to start right after finishing.
Beware:
1. It ends with most of the questions unanswered. I'm hoping the second book will have those answers;
2. There is a sex scene.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
May 26, 2025
I received an ARC of this book and am leaving a review voluntarily.
What a fun story and a little but different than the author’s usual fare while still containing my absolute favorite techniques of hers.
The story starts off with a bang both getting us thoroughly on our MC Selene’s side, introducing us to the conflict at hand and making us hate an antagonist rather thoroughly. And all in one chapter!
I love how contrast is used here. The brief bit we saw before the time travel carries so much weight and truly lets us appreciate what can be different and HOW different it can be!
Our LI Dorian is a regular sweetheart and more soft spoken than some of MacDonald’s other couples but that just makes me live for his words all the more. The gentle way he interacts with Selene is reminiscent of all the fairy tale princes I loved as a child but he has realistic layers to him that make him so much more intriguing.
I adore this couple in a complete different way than I have adored MacDonald’s other works but I am happy to add them to the collection in my heart.
What a fun story and a little but different than the author’s usual fare while still containing my absolute favorite techniques of hers.
The story starts off with a bang both getting us thoroughly on our MC Selene’s side, introducing us to the conflict at hand and making us hate an antagonist rather thoroughly. And all in one chapter!
I love how contrast is used here. The brief bit we saw before the time travel carries so much weight and truly lets us appreciate what can be different and HOW different it can be!
Our LI Dorian is a regular sweetheart and more soft spoken than some of MacDonald’s other couples but that just makes me live for his words all the more. The gentle way he interacts with Selene is reminiscent of all the fairy tale princes I loved as a child but he has realistic layers to him that make him so much more intriguing.
I adore this couple in a complete different way than I have adored MacDonald’s other works but I am happy to add them to the collection in my heart.
May 29, 2025
I received this as an ARC because this is the absolute truth: I'm a sucker for time travel stories slow burns and regency vibes and I NEEDED to read this book immediately. The Girl Who Fell Through Time checked all of those boxes and more! From the first delightful chapter heading illustration to the sweet fantasy romance and amazing ending (ahem, cliffhanger) I was completely immersed in the story of Selene and Dorian. I was in love with Dorian within pages of meeting him! The story is engaging and feels like you're really IN it – the best kind of story. I absolutely wanted more and at the same time knew that this was the PERFECT way to tell part one of this story. I immediately ordered a physical copy of this book and pre-ordered the sequel coming in July (which can't get here fast enough!)
May 30, 2025
“The Girl Who Fell Through Time” is a beautifully written fantasy novel. While it’s a little bit of a departure from Macdonald’s typical writing, most of the elements readers come to expect from her are present: rich world building, fully developed characters, and romance that tugs at your heartstrings.
Despite a prologue that is very intense, the story unfolds at a slightly slower pace, but not too slow that it drags. We find the FMC Selene being horribly betrayed by her husband and subsequently finding herself back in time to before she married him. Will she marry him again or forge a different path for her future?
As per usual, Macdonald writes a beautiful romance that feels genuine and natural; no forced insta-love here. We also get hit with a cliffhanger that leaves you with all the feels while you impatiently await book 2.
If you like tender regency era romance with beautifully written characters and found family, then chances are you will love “The Girl Who Fell Through Time”.
I received an ARC of this book via Booksprout, however this review is my own unbiased personal opinion, left of my own volition.
Despite a prologue that is very intense, the story unfolds at a slightly slower pace, but not too slow that it drags. We find the FMC Selene being horribly betrayed by her husband and subsequently finding herself back in time to before she married him. Will she marry him again or forge a different path for her future?
As per usual, Macdonald writes a beautiful romance that feels genuine and natural; no forced insta-love here. We also get hit with a cliffhanger that leaves you with all the feels while you impatiently await book 2.
If you like tender regency era romance with beautifully written characters and found family, then chances are you will love “The Girl Who Fell Through Time”.
I received an ARC of this book via Booksprout, however this review is my own unbiased personal opinion, left of my own volition.
April 16, 2026
Wow!!! I expected to like this book as I've enjoyed this author's other books but it exceeded my expectations by far. This is definitely going on my list of favorite books. The story itself was so unique and I absolutely fell in love with all of the characters, especially, of course, Dorian. The slow burn romance, the twists, the setting, all incredible. It read like a period drama you'd watch on PBS but with the tense plot of a fantasy. I highly recommend!
August 20, 2025
Actual Rating: 3.5
I am such a sucker for the specific trope(s) in this book so I was happy to overlook the occasional editing issue (missing words here and there, clunky re-use of something already stated almost word for word) and absolutely devoured this in one night. Also features a delightful change of pace from the popular "grrr I'm a villain" MMC characterization.
A lovely read that demands you pick up Book 2 immediately.
I am such a sucker for the specific trope(s) in this book so I was happy to overlook the occasional editing issue (missing words here and there, clunky re-use of something already stated almost word for word) and absolutely devoured this in one night. Also features a delightful change of pace from the popular "grrr I'm a villain" MMC characterization.
A lovely read that demands you pick up Book 2 immediately.
June 2, 2025
I loved this! I cannot wait for the next book 😁😁!! This book had me sussed up until the end.. I will not be revealing why spoilers.
If you know me then you understand this isn’t a book I would normally pick up but 100% glad I did.
If you know me then you understand this isn’t a book I would normally pick up but 100% glad I did.
August 29, 2025
It’s nearly 1 AM, and I was supposed to go to bed at 8:00 PM. I couldn’t put this book down. I LOVED Selene and Dorian. Dorian may be in my top five male main characters of all time. The romance in this book is true romance, not insta-love or lust, and the story is very well-written. Ugh- just one of those stories that will never leave my head
April 5, 2026
Couldn’t Put It Down
I picked up this book randomly for a reading challenge (the word “time” had to be in the title) and I am so glad I did.
From the very first few pages, I was hooked. I pulled an all-nighter to finish it. Every time I thought I could predict how the story would go, I was delightfully wrong.
Selene is the perfect heroine. She starts off reserved and reflective but she also has this fierce determination to change the past and her bold yet quick-witted decisions ultimately moved the story forward in the best of ways. She was relatable and her “flaws” actually weren’t flawed at all. At the most basic level, it’s a story of second chances and female empowerment. At the deepest, it’s the story of a young woman who is willing to face death itself to change the past and save others around her from a terrible fate.
Dorian was swoon-worthy 😍 and his character growth was also so good. While both he and Selene had their own insecurities, it was refreshing to read about a man struggle with his own. Like Selene, he grew into his confidence and the twist towards the end of the book (Dorian… omg) makes me want to immediately jump into the next one.
Five stars!
I picked up this book randomly for a reading challenge (the word “time” had to be in the title) and I am so glad I did.
From the very first few pages, I was hooked. I pulled an all-nighter to finish it. Every time I thought I could predict how the story would go, I was delightfully wrong.
Selene is the perfect heroine. She starts off reserved and reflective but she also has this fierce determination to change the past and her bold yet quick-witted decisions ultimately moved the story forward in the best of ways. She was relatable and her “flaws” actually weren’t flawed at all. At the most basic level, it’s a story of second chances and female empowerment. At the deepest, it’s the story of a young woman who is willing to face death itself to change the past and save others around her from a terrible fate.
Dorian was swoon-worthy 😍 and his character growth was also so good. While both he and Selene had their own insecurities, it was refreshing to read about a man struggle with his own. Like Selene, he grew into his confidence and the twist towards the end of the book (Dorian… omg) makes me want to immediately jump into the next one.
Five stars!
August 3, 2025
'The problem with holding you, Selene. Is that every time I do, it gets a little harder to let go.'
FINALLY! A six star read!! It was cosy and romantic, I binged this so fast. O.B.S.E.S.S.E.D!!!
Dorian is my new favourite book boyfriend; he is genuinely the sweetest golden retriever.
"You're very pretty and it makes me nervous sometimes." LIKE ARE YOU KIDDING???
With the romantasy genre recently, I have grown used to MMCs being broody and lowkey mean. Yes Dorian had some brooding moments (which I did love), but overall he is so soft and sweet and it was such a breath of fresh air. He has created a new type for me <3
Now, the actual book was great. The writing immersed me in the story and I was really sad when it was over... GOOD THING I HAVE THE SEQUEL ON ITS WAYY MWAHAHHA
'"You look like the night sky," he murmurs
"Then try not to get lost in me."
"That's a dangerous thing to ask."'
FINALLY! A six star read!! It was cosy and romantic, I binged this so fast. O.B.S.E.S.S.E.D!!!
Dorian is my new favourite book boyfriend; he is genuinely the sweetest golden retriever.
"You're very pretty and it makes me nervous sometimes." LIKE ARE YOU KIDDING???
With the romantasy genre recently, I have grown used to MMCs being broody and lowkey mean. Yes Dorian had some brooding moments (which I did love), but overall he is so soft and sweet and it was such a breath of fresh air. He has created a new type for me <3
Now, the actual book was great. The writing immersed me in the story and I was really sad when it was over... GOOD THING I HAVE THE SEQUEL ON ITS WAYY MWAHAHHA
'"You look like the night sky," he murmurs
"Then try not to get lost in me."
"That's a dangerous thing to ask."'
January 27, 2026
That final line is just…
January 26, 2026
5 ⭐️ I accidentally stumbled upon this wonderful gaslamp fantasy with a time loop component and I am not mad about it
March 21, 2026
This duology (The Girl Who Fell Through Time & The Ones Who Undid Tomorrow) is just wonderful! FMC and MMC are so easy to root for and the plot is exceptional with some unexpected twists along the way! But the romance! He falls first, yearning, and an “I’d love you in any lifetime” feel, the romance is spectacular! Love love loved these books!!
March 21, 2026
*4.9/5 Stars
SELENE WAS LUNA THIS ENTIRE TIME I’M GOING TO THROW MYSELF OUT THE WINDOW.
I HAD THE SUSPICION THAT HE TRAVELLED BACK TOO BUT I DISMISSED IT, I FREAKING KNEWWWW ITTTT.
SELENE WAS LUNA THIS ENTIRE TIME I’M GOING TO THROW MYSELF OUT THE WINDOW.
I HAD THE SUSPICION THAT HE TRAVELLED BACK TOO BUT I DISMISSED IT, I FREAKING KNEWWWW ITTTT.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 5, 2025
I was honored to be an ARC reader for this story.
Oddly Specific Reader Recommendation
Are you the type of person who loves those mobile games where you gradually renovate an old mansion while discovering love and solving mysteries? Like "Merge Mansion," "Merge Gardens," those kinds of games? You'll also love this book! There's no mini games to read the chapters, I promise, but the same "bringing an old estate to new glory one room at a time while uncovering deep betrayal and falling in love" vibe happens. Except even better because no ads or microtransactions.
That said, here's my more detailed review.
The Writing
Fantastic. Delightful. Delectable, even. There was not a single time where I wished for more edits or got taken out of the story. Not a single time I was compelled to put the story down. Ms. Macdonald's ability to paint a setting in technicolor is remarkable. But it's not just that the author gives you all the factual details of a setting - it's all told through the main character's perspective, and the author understands that means we're going to perceive things differently depending on when Selene is reserved, sociable, anxious, or relaxed. I was always attuned to Selene's emotions, always vividly living the scene, always turning pages for the next event. I love Ms. Macdonald's writing voice and I was left craving more.
The Plot
I'm not the biggest romance reader - something I'm actively trying to change - and one of the things I tend to get stuck on is what I call the plot "balance." The important story in romance is the relationship, yes. But when you also introduce as high of stakes as "the safety of the whole kingdom" and "a mysterious goddess of unknown origin" and "literal time travel," I want to be engaged in those plot points. It can get frustrating when "saving the world" seems to have patience to wait while the leads are figuring out how they feel about each other.
If your opinions are similar to mine, I'm happy to say this book gets that balance perfectly for a simple but genius reason - the relationship and the high-stakes mystery of the plot are connected. The lead characters are only able to accomplish their goals by building their trust and affection for each other. So when I see them communicating through their feelings, building alliances through genuine trust and respect, facing their own attachment fears together, it also advances our understanding of those mysterious forces threatening their land. This is the perfect balance I've needed and didn't realize I was searching for.
The Characters
I'm a sucker for a cast of colorful characters who build a found family through hard work and respect, and you'll definitely find that here. You'll only love them more as they grow in their bonds through well-deserved camaraderie.
Selene - our leading lady - what a lady. In a world that so often treats the idea of a "strong female protagonist" as a woman who's "not like other girls," Ms. Macdonald has given us a protagonist who is strong because of her tenacity in the face of the horrors she's survived. Selene is privileged, vulnerable, and domestic - a true court lady. And at no point does the story make her apologize for that or forsake that in order to succeed. Instead we confront how that privileged life also came with layers of emotional abuse meant to keep her small and meek. We watch her nurture her talents (and herself) to surpass her abusers' expectations and learn how everything she looked down on in herself is actually an asset. Her healing journey from the abuse she had normalized in her past life (both spousal and parental) is raw and powerful.
Dorian - the love interest - was the reason I requested the ARC in the first place. Great example of my fictional crush archetype, and OH BOY did he surpass my expectations. The perfect blend of emotionally intelligent adoring lover and his own unique attachment trauma that actually is helped by Selene growing to return his affections. He has his own secrets that only grow in interest and intensity as the story progresses. And at every turn we see him striving as hard as Selene does to do what he knows is right.
The Romance
As I mentioned above, I'm not a huge romance reader (yet). I have my own attachment anxieties that make a lot of common romance tropes uncomfortable for me to read. And I'm happy to announce that I was not made uncomfortable a single time, while still having plenty of reader angst. I think Ms. Macdonald's secret to this is that we are reading two people working through their own healing journeys, actively wanting to do so together but also needing to face parts of it distinctly alone. These are two emotionally mature and intelligent characters that are working through difficult, painful things. So when it's hard for them to say something - when it feels like they're passing each other or missing a moment - it makes perfect sense for where they are in their healing, and it never feels like the door is slamming shut forever. Even in their darkest moments of doubt, there's a thread of attachment and love between these two that only gets stronger as time goes on. This is the love story I needed when I was younger and yet the story I wasn't ready to read until now. I saw some of my own needs and emotional learning in Selene and Dorian at different times.
In Summary
I literally requested the ARC because of the cover and the description of Dorian, and I couldn't be happier for that impulsive decision. This story more than delivers on what it promises. It's a love story, it's a suspenseful thriller, it's a cozy story about building home and connection, and it's a story about healing what you didn't even know was wounded. I can't recommend this highly enough and I am on the edge of my seat for the sequel.
Oddly Specific Reader Recommendation
Are you the type of person who loves those mobile games where you gradually renovate an old mansion while discovering love and solving mysteries? Like "Merge Mansion," "Merge Gardens," those kinds of games? You'll also love this book! There's no mini games to read the chapters, I promise, but the same "bringing an old estate to new glory one room at a time while uncovering deep betrayal and falling in love" vibe happens. Except even better because no ads or microtransactions.
That said, here's my more detailed review.
The Writing
Fantastic. Delightful. Delectable, even. There was not a single time where I wished for more edits or got taken out of the story. Not a single time I was compelled to put the story down. Ms. Macdonald's ability to paint a setting in technicolor is remarkable. But it's not just that the author gives you all the factual details of a setting - it's all told through the main character's perspective, and the author understands that means we're going to perceive things differently depending on when Selene is reserved, sociable, anxious, or relaxed. I was always attuned to Selene's emotions, always vividly living the scene, always turning pages for the next event. I love Ms. Macdonald's writing voice and I was left craving more.
The Plot
I'm not the biggest romance reader - something I'm actively trying to change - and one of the things I tend to get stuck on is what I call the plot "balance." The important story in romance is the relationship, yes. But when you also introduce as high of stakes as "the safety of the whole kingdom" and "a mysterious goddess of unknown origin" and "literal time travel," I want to be engaged in those plot points. It can get frustrating when "saving the world" seems to have patience to wait while the leads are figuring out how they feel about each other.
If your opinions are similar to mine, I'm happy to say this book gets that balance perfectly for a simple but genius reason - the relationship and the high-stakes mystery of the plot are connected. The lead characters are only able to accomplish their goals by building their trust and affection for each other. So when I see them communicating through their feelings, building alliances through genuine trust and respect, facing their own attachment fears together, it also advances our understanding of those mysterious forces threatening their land. This is the perfect balance I've needed and didn't realize I was searching for.
The Characters
I'm a sucker for a cast of colorful characters who build a found family through hard work and respect, and you'll definitely find that here. You'll only love them more as they grow in their bonds through well-deserved camaraderie.
Selene - our leading lady - what a lady. In a world that so often treats the idea of a "strong female protagonist" as a woman who's "not like other girls," Ms. Macdonald has given us a protagonist who is strong because of her tenacity in the face of the horrors she's survived. Selene is privileged, vulnerable, and domestic - a true court lady. And at no point does the story make her apologize for that or forsake that in order to succeed. Instead we confront how that privileged life also came with layers of emotional abuse meant to keep her small and meek. We watch her nurture her talents (and herself) to surpass her abusers' expectations and learn how everything she looked down on in herself is actually an asset. Her healing journey from the abuse she had normalized in her past life (both spousal and parental) is raw and powerful.
Dorian - the love interest - was the reason I requested the ARC in the first place. Great example of my fictional crush archetype, and OH BOY did he surpass my expectations. The perfect blend of emotionally intelligent adoring lover and his own unique attachment trauma that actually is helped by Selene growing to return his affections. He has his own secrets that only grow in interest and intensity as the story progresses. And at every turn we see him striving as hard as Selene does to do what he knows is right.
The Romance
As I mentioned above, I'm not a huge romance reader (yet). I have my own attachment anxieties that make a lot of common romance tropes uncomfortable for me to read. And I'm happy to announce that I was not made uncomfortable a single time, while still having plenty of reader angst. I think Ms. Macdonald's secret to this is that we are reading two people working through their own healing journeys, actively wanting to do so together but also needing to face parts of it distinctly alone. These are two emotionally mature and intelligent characters that are working through difficult, painful things. So when it's hard for them to say something - when it feels like they're passing each other or missing a moment - it makes perfect sense for where they are in their healing, and it never feels like the door is slamming shut forever. Even in their darkest moments of doubt, there's a thread of attachment and love between these two that only gets stronger as time goes on. This is the love story I needed when I was younger and yet the story I wasn't ready to read until now. I saw some of my own needs and emotional learning in Selene and Dorian at different times.
In Summary
I literally requested the ARC because of the cover and the description of Dorian, and I couldn't be happier for that impulsive decision. This story more than delivers on what it promises. It's a love story, it's a suspenseful thriller, it's a cozy story about building home and connection, and it's a story about healing what you didn't even know was wounded. I can't recommend this highly enough and I am on the edge of my seat for the sequel.
April 26, 2025
“The problem with holding you, Selene,” he says quietly, “is that every time I do, it gets a little harder to let go.”
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 𝟱 𝓈𝓌𝑜𝑜𝓃𝒾𝓃𝑔 𝓈𝓉𝒶𝓇𝓈 🤍
A romantasy with time-travel and a marriage of convenience ? Sign me in !
After reading a really traumatizing and depressing dark romance trilogy, this book was everything I needed. It carries a certain softness and lightness that is hard to explain. Maybe it’s because humor and playful teasing are always cleverly present, or maybe it’s the undeniable chemistry between Selene and Dorian that made this book an absolute delight to read.
But, considering the traumas of the characters and how vicious and unpredictable the Duke Drakefell can be, you could expect it to be a heavy read. Don’t get me wrong, some moments were really intense and nerve-wracking, and I definitely had tears in my eyes during those because of the realness of the characters’ emotions, the attachment I had for them and because of how relatable they were.
But more than just another love story wrapped in action and twists, this is a story of survivors. People who have lived through deep trauma and are trying to heal. While Dorian is still very wounded by his own past, he never fails to be present for Selene. He walks beside her as she frees herself from her own pain, helping her learn who she is, reveal it, and stand proud in it.
Both of them slowly open up, little by little, and there’s something especially tender and moving about witnessing this healing process they go through together, seeing the gentleness of their bond and the beauty of the love that blooms from it.
« “You don’t have to hide yourself,” he reminds her. “You don’t have to cower or dim your light to make others feel better. You never have to be anything other than yourself. »
When I think about this book, what lingers is a sense of tenderness, hope, something comforting. I don’t see it through the lens of pain or difficulty, but through the healing that emerges from it and the love between the two characters that shines above everything else.
It was so easy to grow attached to Selene and Dorian, but also to the side characters. There’s definitely a found family vibe to this book.
I think Selene is a really intriguing FMC, which I don’t say as often as I'd like. I find it especially interesting that we’re introduced to her at her most vulnerable moment, when she’s being betrayed by her husband.
She’s a relatable character who is deeply wounded by her traumas, and it was beautiful, inspiring, and emotionally resonant to see her work through them, to try to overcome it all, to heal. There are so many lines in the book that felt incredibly real, things I’ve thought or heard myself.
It was beautiful to see her bloom into the strong, self-aware, and compassionate woman she was always meant to be.
It was also so easy to fall in love with Dorian. He’s gentle, pure, and kind. He’s reliable, resourceful, and I loved how present, attentive, patient, and understanding he was with Selene. But he also has this secret side to him, a wounded side that comes from believing he has to carry the weight of the world on his shoulders.
I was genuinely surprised to read about an MMC who lacks self-confidence, isn’t described as physically perfect, and blushes easily.
"Would you believe me if I told you that I think you’re pretty too?” Dorian tenses, just for a moment. “No,” he says. “But thank you for saying that.”
(This one hurts)
But that doesn’t make him weak in the slightest, or any less of a man, as we see time and time again throughout the book.
I also adored the fact that he can be incredibly charming and is more than capable of taking the lead with Selene when he wants to, his shyness vanishing in a heartbeat… I may or may not have been the one blushing multiple times ! 🙈
The pacing of their connection just felt right. It evolved in such a natural, organic way.
I’m not a fan of slow burns that drag on for too long, and this one didn’t feel like that at all. Every moment between them mattered. Each interaction felt meaningful and important to their growing relationship and was a delight to read.
The chemistry was there from the very start, and it played a huge role in how easy it was to get pulled into the story and to fall in love with both characters.
“Does it hurt when I touch you?” she asks.
He shakes his head. “It only hurts when you don’t.”
The prologue was certainly one of the best I’ve ever read. I was instantly captivated by the story. It was incredibly easy to dive into and get emotionally invested.
I was also very pleasantly surprised by one trope used in the book… which I won’t talk about further to not spoil anything. 🤫
The ending definitely left me wanting more, leaving us on a cliffhanger with a lot of secrets and answers about to be revealed, including about the time travel situation.
I’m so ready to devour the second book and see where Dorian and Selene’s story is headed (please don’t hurt them more 😭) !
Displaying 1 - 30 of 88 reviews