What do you think?
Rate this book
The Best Advice: A Novel
Rosalind is an advice columnist who is far more comfortable fixing other people’s problems than dealing with her own.Meddling in other people’s business is kind of her thing. Rosalind writes a popular advice column in a magazine. When she butts heads with her editor over a controversial letter response, she loses her job and byline. To keep writing, Rosalind establishes a fake identity with a male pen name at the dubious suggestion of her friends.
Retreating to a small town on the water, she starts a new column for a local newspaper. The unexpected online success of her advice writing only serves to exacerbate her bad habit of meddling in real life. This threatens to damage her relationships with family and friends.
It also complicates her budding romance with ruggedly handsome travel television star Andy Arden. He’s gorgeous, he’s outdoorsy, and he writes her (terrible) poetry. But he also thinks “Gavin,” the guy giving him relationship advice via text, and his new love interest are two different people…
Rosalind juggles it all because her advice is ALWAYS right. Usually right. Would you settle for sometimes right? Can she outgrow her game-playing and confront her grief in time to untangle the mess she’s made of her personal and professional life?
⭐"A charming, fun read.” - Reader Review
⭐“I loved the variety of characters and the community that supports them.” - Reader Review
⭐”This book was brilliant…” - Reader Review
A finalist in the Pacific Northwest Writer’s Association literary contest.
Retreating to a small town on the water, she starts a new column for a local newspaper. The unexpected online success of her advice writing only serves to exacerbate her bad habit of meddling in real life. This threatens to damage her relationships with family and friends.
It also complicates her budding romance with ruggedly handsome travel television star Andy Arden. He’s gorgeous, he’s outdoorsy, and he writes her (terrible) poetry. But he also thinks “Gavin,” the guy giving him relationship advice via text, and his new love interest are two different people…
Rosalind juggles it all because her advice is ALWAYS right. Usually right. Would you settle for sometimes right? Can she outgrow her game-playing and confront her grief in time to untangle the mess she’s made of her personal and professional life?
⭐"A charming, fun read.” - Reader Review
⭐“I loved the variety of characters and the community that supports them.” - Reader Review
⭐”This book was brilliant…” - Reader Review
A finalist in the Pacific Northwest Writer’s Association literary contest.
309 pages, Kindle Edition
Published July 8, 2025
About the author
Amy Dressler
2 books21 followersAmy Dressler writes contemporary fiction featuring heroines who wrestle their emotional baggage while maintaining a sense of humor.
She is an active member of the Author's Guild, Women's Fiction Writers Association, and the Pacific Northwest Author's Association, where her books have twice been recognized as contest finalists. She holds a certificate in Popular Fiction from the University of Washington, as well as a BA in English from Whitman College and a Master's in Library and Information Science, also from the University of Washington. She spends her days shepherding government documents but has also worked as an academic librarian and freelance pop culture writer.
Amy’s hobbies include barely running (she’s completed ten half marathons, slowly), cooking and baking, hiking, tending her neighborhood Little Free Library, relaxed traveling, and attending live theater. When she’s not writing, Amy can often be found cozied up reading, eating fancy cheese, shopping for fancy cheese, or cooking with fancy cheese. She lives in the Seattle suburbs with her spouse and ridiculous cats.
She is an active member of the Author's Guild, Women's Fiction Writers Association, and the Pacific Northwest Author's Association, where her books have twice been recognized as contest finalists. She holds a certificate in Popular Fiction from the University of Washington, as well as a BA in English from Whitman College and a Master's in Library and Information Science, also from the University of Washington. She spends her days shepherding government documents but has also worked as an academic librarian and freelance pop culture writer.
Amy’s hobbies include barely running (she’s completed ten half marathons, slowly), cooking and baking, hiking, tending her neighborhood Little Free Library, relaxed traveling, and attending live theater. When she’s not writing, Amy can often be found cozied up reading, eating fancy cheese, shopping for fancy cheese, or cooking with fancy cheese. She lives in the Seattle suburbs with her spouse and ridiculous cats.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews
July 8, 2025
This story starts off with a bang of fiery tempers, and you quickly get thrown into a well-established friend group where you can feel the history between them. Rosalind, or Roz for short, along with Celeste, and Barry, hit up this little Seattle dinner and it all feels so authentic. From there Roz hatches a plan that kept me hooked, waiting to see what hijinks would happen next and where this secret identity would get her. (Side note: I love that Roz loves the ferry ride over to the islands. I feel that is such a true PNW vibe)
This is a modern retelling of the Shakespearean classic As You Like It, which I will admit I’m not familiar with. I felt all the characters were well-rounded and stood on their own. Each had their own strengths and weaknesses, and I felt they all had their own goals and desires. No one felt phoned in or flat. I enjoyed the dialogue and banter, and how many different perspectives we got as it added the perfect amount of details and information.
I’m not going to lie, the last third of the book I could not put it down. I stayed up way too late having to read “just one more page!” I think Amy Dressler really hit her stride on pacing and balancing all the action and feelings going on in this book. I was thrilled with how things played out and would highly recommend this book to anyone who enjoys a fun summer read, romcoms, and cozy feel-good stories.
I do need to note, this book deals with the themes of the death of a parent (in the past) and the grief Roz is going through. I feel it is written so thoughtfully and from the heart. I teared up at times.
Overall, a wonderful book that I would be excited to read again to visit the characters and pick up some threads earlier. I also greatly enjoyed the Book Club questions at the end for some added discussion prompts.
This is a modern retelling of the Shakespearean classic As You Like It, which I will admit I’m not familiar with. I felt all the characters were well-rounded and stood on their own. Each had their own strengths and weaknesses, and I felt they all had their own goals and desires. No one felt phoned in or flat. I enjoyed the dialogue and banter, and how many different perspectives we got as it added the perfect amount of details and information.
I’m not going to lie, the last third of the book I could not put it down. I stayed up way too late having to read “just one more page!” I think Amy Dressler really hit her stride on pacing and balancing all the action and feelings going on in this book. I was thrilled with how things played out and would highly recommend this book to anyone who enjoys a fun summer read, romcoms, and cozy feel-good stories.
I do need to note, this book deals with the themes of the death of a parent (in the past) and the grief Roz is going through. I feel it is written so thoughtfully and from the heart. I teared up at times.
Overall, a wonderful book that I would be excited to read again to visit the characters and pick up some threads earlier. I also greatly enjoyed the Book Club questions at the end for some added discussion prompts.
May 30, 2025
I know that as a literature graduate I should probably read Shakespeare works at least once in my life, but I haven't, ok? And I probably never will (don't tell anyone). I've read a few sonnets, and I've heard of Hamlet, duh, but if asked, I could never tell you any of the plots of the plays. It was therefore very interesting to read another book by Amy Dressler. I love modern retellings, they bring classic works closer to our times and lives. And I can confidently say that Amy Dressler doesn't disappoint. I've been curious to read more of her books since reading How to Align the Stars: A Sweet Romantic Comedy (Shakespeare Retelling), her first book, and I am really glad I got a chance to read "The Best Advice".
This book is a retelling of of Shakespeare’s "As You Like It". Now, to those of you who are better read than me in Shakespeare, this will probably already tell you some things about the book. We meet Rosalind, who really loves inserting herself into everyone's business. This promises awkward encounters, drama and just all around fun times. But wait, there's also Andy - the love interest. Lighthearted, whimsical, funny - this is the mood of both Shakespeare and Dressler's work. Amy Dressler weaves a fast-paced plot full of unexpected events (my gosh, these characters do and experience more in a week than I in half a year), deep friendship, self-discovery and, of course, sweet budding romance. I thoroughly enjoyed it!
Thank you to the author, publishers, and Booksprout for the ARC of this book. My review is based solely on my honest opinion, and is written with the utmost respect.
This book is a retelling of of Shakespeare’s "As You Like It". Now, to those of you who are better read than me in Shakespeare, this will probably already tell you some things about the book. We meet Rosalind, who really loves inserting herself into everyone's business. This promises awkward encounters, drama and just all around fun times. But wait, there's also Andy - the love interest. Lighthearted, whimsical, funny - this is the mood of both Shakespeare and Dressler's work. Amy Dressler weaves a fast-paced plot full of unexpected events (my gosh, these characters do and experience more in a week than I in half a year), deep friendship, self-discovery and, of course, sweet budding romance. I thoroughly enjoyed it!
Thank you to the author, publishers, and Booksprout for the ARC of this book. My review is based solely on my honest opinion, and is written with the utmost respect.
July 7, 2025
The Best Advice by Amy Dressler is a contemporary romance and modern-day retelling of Shakespeare’s As You Like It. The book follows a fervent advice columnist, Rosalind (Roz), as she navigates life, her career, and eventually love after the loss of her mother.
I love retellings, and Amy Dressler does such a good job of modernizing Shakespeare’s comedies. You don’t have to read or know As You Like It to enjoy The Best Advice; however, if you have the background of knowing the play, you will have an engaging reading experience when comparing the similarities and differences between the original and this version.
Although the main focus of the story is Roz’s journey, the supporting players and their storylines are equally as important and interesting. The author really replicates the Shakespearean feel of a robust, interconnected cast of characters moving the story forward together.
The plot unfolds over a short amount of time, so there is an aspect of instalove to all of the romantic relationships that form in this novel. Dressler uses multiple POVs and a balance of sweet romance and witty banter that contributes to the quick pacing of the book. The dynamics between characters are very sentimental, but they also possess a comedic element that will make readers laugh.
Dressler excels at writing about heavy themes in a light way without lessening the gravity of the topic at hand. This book tackles subject matter related to the grief of losing a parent and LGBTQIA+ acceptance and inclusivity. It also touches upon the nuances of divorce, harassment in the workplace, and personal boundaries within relationships. More than anything, the way that The Best Advice approaches how one may deal with grief is quite moving.
Just like How to Align the Stars (Book #1 in Amy Dressler’s Shakespeare Project), The Best Advice is another heart-warming book in this series to give you all the feels. I recommend this to anyone looking for a romantic comedy that includes the substance of essential and culturally relevant topics and themes.
Thank you to Amy Dressler and Egret Lake Books for allowing me to read this copy in advance.
I love retellings, and Amy Dressler does such a good job of modernizing Shakespeare’s comedies. You don’t have to read or know As You Like It to enjoy The Best Advice; however, if you have the background of knowing the play, you will have an engaging reading experience when comparing the similarities and differences between the original and this version.
Although the main focus of the story is Roz’s journey, the supporting players and their storylines are equally as important and interesting. The author really replicates the Shakespearean feel of a robust, interconnected cast of characters moving the story forward together.
The plot unfolds over a short amount of time, so there is an aspect of instalove to all of the romantic relationships that form in this novel. Dressler uses multiple POVs and a balance of sweet romance and witty banter that contributes to the quick pacing of the book. The dynamics between characters are very sentimental, but they also possess a comedic element that will make readers laugh.
Dressler excels at writing about heavy themes in a light way without lessening the gravity of the topic at hand. This book tackles subject matter related to the grief of losing a parent and LGBTQIA+ acceptance and inclusivity. It also touches upon the nuances of divorce, harassment in the workplace, and personal boundaries within relationships. More than anything, the way that The Best Advice approaches how one may deal with grief is quite moving.
“This is how you say goodbye: squeezing a hand that still feels alive, kissing the warm cheek, whispering into the ear you know can’t hear to say you love her and you wish you’d told her more often, that you’re not ready, but you promise you’ll be okay.”
-Amy Dressler, The Best Advice
Just like How to Align the Stars (Book #1 in Amy Dressler’s Shakespeare Project), The Best Advice is another heart-warming book in this series to give you all the feels. I recommend this to anyone looking for a romantic comedy that includes the substance of essential and culturally relevant topics and themes.
Thank you to Amy Dressler and Egret Lake Books for allowing me to read this copy in advance.
July 8, 2025
Reading, The Best Advice, by Amy Dressler was the perfect book during this transition of seasons. With the pouring spring rain easing into Seattle's promise of summer, this modern-day retelling of Shakespeare’s, As You Like It, really put me in the mood for summer and fresh starts.
The main character, Rosalind, an advice columnist, winds up in more trouble than she’s bargained for. When the possibility of something new arises in the turmoil of her life-altering chaos, along with a hunky television star, Andy, she may or may not need her own advice to save the day.
Let’s dive in! First, the characters. There are four POV's, vastly different from each other, so the reader is never lost. But the feelings and concerns they each go through---oh my goodness! It felt like I could have called any of them up and met them for a drink in Seattle (where the story begins).
Rosalind is perfectly imperfect, and so the hole she digs herself is enormous, thus allowing her journey out to become the real victory in the end. And truly, the sense of advice goes deeper and broader than a reader can possibly imagine! I honestly did not know how Dressler was going to tie up all the side drama happening along the way, but she did so brilliantly.
The setting of the story, Port Poulsen (a fictional town, just a ferry ride from Seattle) is more than a backdrop for the story, it's a character itself! With hints and flavors of Poulsbo, WA, the reader is constantly grounded in the setting. From the boats at the pier to the Scandinavian-themed charm sprinkled all around town, I literally googled Port Poulsen more than once just to be sure it wasn't real.
Finally, I liked that Dressler wasn't afraid to include current day content and debatable issues into this story. With a title like, The Best Advice, it makes perfect sense. Her other book in this series, How to Align the Stars, is another Shakespearean retelling that’s also worth the read!
This book is for readers who want to escape into a new world that still feels somewhat similar to the one we currently live in, yet seen through new eyes with various viewpoints, deep inside a charming setting, while rooting for each character to find their way. It's a feel-good read and perfect for anytime!
The main character, Rosalind, an advice columnist, winds up in more trouble than she’s bargained for. When the possibility of something new arises in the turmoil of her life-altering chaos, along with a hunky television star, Andy, she may or may not need her own advice to save the day.
Let’s dive in! First, the characters. There are four POV's, vastly different from each other, so the reader is never lost. But the feelings and concerns they each go through---oh my goodness! It felt like I could have called any of them up and met them for a drink in Seattle (where the story begins).
Rosalind is perfectly imperfect, and so the hole she digs herself is enormous, thus allowing her journey out to become the real victory in the end. And truly, the sense of advice goes deeper and broader than a reader can possibly imagine! I honestly did not know how Dressler was going to tie up all the side drama happening along the way, but she did so brilliantly.
The setting of the story, Port Poulsen (a fictional town, just a ferry ride from Seattle) is more than a backdrop for the story, it's a character itself! With hints and flavors of Poulsbo, WA, the reader is constantly grounded in the setting. From the boats at the pier to the Scandinavian-themed charm sprinkled all around town, I literally googled Port Poulsen more than once just to be sure it wasn't real.
Finally, I liked that Dressler wasn't afraid to include current day content and debatable issues into this story. With a title like, The Best Advice, it makes perfect sense. Her other book in this series, How to Align the Stars, is another Shakespearean retelling that’s also worth the read!
This book is for readers who want to escape into a new world that still feels somewhat similar to the one we currently live in, yet seen through new eyes with various viewpoints, deep inside a charming setting, while rooting for each character to find their way. It's a feel-good read and perfect for anytime!
July 15, 2025
Amy Dressler’s The Best Advice is a fun, modern take on As You Like It, with a fresh twist set in the world of advice columns. It follows Roz, a quick-witted columnist whose career has been shaped by the legacy of her late mom, a well-known writer herself. When Roz loses her job after a controversial post, she decides to start over—using a male pen name—and moves to a cute little coastal town to write a new column. But things get complicated fast, with mixed-up identities, some sneaky mischief, and an unexpected spark with a charming travel TV host named Andy Arden.
Fun concept with a modern spin: The Shakespeare inspiration gives the story a cool backbone, but it’s Dressler’s sharp humor and advice-column angle that really bring it to life.
Here are some highlights:
Great characters and real feelings: Roz is smart, funny, and totally relatable - figuring out how to deal with loss, guilt, and trying to stay in control. Her chemistry with Andy adds a sweet and emotional layer.
Cozy small-town vibes: The little coastal town feels like its own character - welcoming but also a bit challenging for Roz. Being from Seattle it was especially fun to immerse myself into the setting!
Some familiar plot points: The whole mistaken identity and romance storyline isn’t exactly new, but it’s done with enough style and personality to still feel fresh.
The Best Advice is a smart, funny, and feel-good rom-com with a fun Shakespeare twist. It’s got sharp dialogue, a playful plot, and characters you actually care about. This is a great read for fans of Jennifer Weiner or anyone who loves a light, modern romance. It might not go super deep, but it totally works as a cozy, satisfying read that’s perfect for the beach or a chill weekend.
Fun concept with a modern spin: The Shakespeare inspiration gives the story a cool backbone, but it’s Dressler’s sharp humor and advice-column angle that really bring it to life.
Here are some highlights:
Great characters and real feelings: Roz is smart, funny, and totally relatable - figuring out how to deal with loss, guilt, and trying to stay in control. Her chemistry with Andy adds a sweet and emotional layer.
Cozy small-town vibes: The little coastal town feels like its own character - welcoming but also a bit challenging for Roz. Being from Seattle it was especially fun to immerse myself into the setting!
Some familiar plot points: The whole mistaken identity and romance storyline isn’t exactly new, but it’s done with enough style and personality to still feel fresh.
The Best Advice is a smart, funny, and feel-good rom-com with a fun Shakespeare twist. It’s got sharp dialogue, a playful plot, and characters you actually care about. This is a great read for fans of Jennifer Weiner or anyone who loves a light, modern romance. It might not go super deep, but it totally works as a cozy, satisfying read that’s perfect for the beach or a chill weekend.
July 10, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and @EgretLakeBooks for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This book was such a fun read! The Best Advice is a modern retelling of As You Like It, but even if you’re not into Shakespeare, don’t worry you’ll still enjoy this one. It’s got all the charm and chaos of a good rom-com with a smart, slightly messy FMC right at the center.
Rosalind writes a popular advice column and has strong opinions (sometimes too strong), which gets her into trouble early on. After a very public fallout with her editor, she ends up starting over in a small coastal town, writing under a fake male pen name. What could go wrong, right?
Turns out, a lot. Especially when her advice ends up helping the charming (and very attractive) Andy Arden who has no idea she’s both his love interest and the guy texting him advice. The whole identity mix-up is handled in a fun, believable way, and their chemistry was great. Plus, Andy writes bad poetry, which honestly made me love him more.
What I really liked, though, is that this isn’t just about the romance. There’s a lot about grief, friendship, and learning when to stop hiding behind a persona (even one with great advice). Rosalind’s voice felt real, funny, sharp, but vulnerable underneath it all.
The pacing slowed a bit in the middle, but overall, this was smart, warm, and just really enjoyable. If you like rom-coms with a little emotional depth, fake identities, and some Shakespeare style twists, I definitely recommend picking this up.
4.45 Stars!
#NetGalley, #TheBestAdvice:ANovel, #AmyDressler, #RomCom, #ShakespeareRetelling
This book was such a fun read! The Best Advice is a modern retelling of As You Like It, but even if you’re not into Shakespeare, don’t worry you’ll still enjoy this one. It’s got all the charm and chaos of a good rom-com with a smart, slightly messy FMC right at the center.
Rosalind writes a popular advice column and has strong opinions (sometimes too strong), which gets her into trouble early on. After a very public fallout with her editor, she ends up starting over in a small coastal town, writing under a fake male pen name. What could go wrong, right?
Turns out, a lot. Especially when her advice ends up helping the charming (and very attractive) Andy Arden who has no idea she’s both his love interest and the guy texting him advice. The whole identity mix-up is handled in a fun, believable way, and their chemistry was great. Plus, Andy writes bad poetry, which honestly made me love him more.
What I really liked, though, is that this isn’t just about the romance. There’s a lot about grief, friendship, and learning when to stop hiding behind a persona (even one with great advice). Rosalind’s voice felt real, funny, sharp, but vulnerable underneath it all.
The pacing slowed a bit in the middle, but overall, this was smart, warm, and just really enjoyable. If you like rom-coms with a little emotional depth, fake identities, and some Shakespeare style twists, I definitely recommend picking this up.
4.45 Stars!
#NetGalley, #TheBestAdvice:ANovel, #AmyDressler, #RomCom, #ShakespeareRetelling
July 9, 2025
Rosalind writes a popular advice column for a magazine, when her career takes an unexpected turn. A disagreement with her editor over a controversial letter response, costs Rosalind her job and byline. Determined to keep writing, Rosalind reinvents herself as ‘Gavin’ and starts a new advice column for a small-town newspaper in Port Poulsen. What begins as a temporary escape quickly becomes more complicated when her alter ego's popularity soars and her meddling starts to affect her personal life, particularly her budding relationship with charming travel TV star, Andy Arden. To complicate matters, Andy doesn’t realise that his girlfriend and the guy giving him relationship advice are the same people.
Inspired by Shakespeare’s classic ‘As you like it’, Rosalind (Roz) has to navigate the complexities of relationships for her column whilst trying to keep her relationship with Any alive. Rosalind’s witty voice, the sharp banter, and the romantic entanglements make for a thoroughly entertaining and fast-paced read. While the multiple points of view were a bit overwhelming at first, once each character was introduced, it became easier to follow and added depth to the story.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book from NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Inspired by Shakespeare’s classic ‘As you like it’, Rosalind (Roz) has to navigate the complexities of relationships for her column whilst trying to keep her relationship with Any alive. Rosalind’s witty voice, the sharp banter, and the romantic entanglements make for a thoroughly entertaining and fast-paced read. While the multiple points of view were a bit overwhelming at first, once each character was introduced, it became easier to follow and added depth to the story.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book from NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
June 3, 2025
Roz is a Seattle-based magazine advice columnist who finds that dishing out advice is way easier than focusing on successful solutions to her own problems. When she loses her job and byline, she creates a male alter-ego, "Gavin," and starts a new column in a small-town newspaper. She can’t seem to stop meddling in other people’s relationships, despite it causing hurt and frustration, to the point that she might lose those closest to her. Would being deceptive really be the advice Roz would give a reader? Yet she follows her own “best advice” and finds herself at risk of missing out on a true connection and romance.
The Best Advice author, Amy Dressler, does it again – she instantly makes you feel a connection to the main character that makes you want to keep turning the page. Those familiar with (and even those not) the Seattle/Puget Sound area can easily visualize the quaint Norwegian seaside town of Port Poulsen. It is the main setting of this fun, adventurous, easy-to-read story of Roz and friends that we meet along the way. No Shakespeare knowledge required to read. Take my advice – add The Best Advice to your must-read list!
The Best Advice author, Amy Dressler, does it again – she instantly makes you feel a connection to the main character that makes you want to keep turning the page. Those familiar with (and even those not) the Seattle/Puget Sound area can easily visualize the quaint Norwegian seaside town of Port Poulsen. It is the main setting of this fun, adventurous, easy-to-read story of Roz and friends that we meet along the way. No Shakespeare knowledge required to read. Take my advice – add The Best Advice to your must-read list!
July 20, 2025
This was sweet, detail-rich (clothing, food, settings), busy, tender, and powerful in spots. I cried, laughed, cared and hoped, and was both gently led on and surprised each in turn. This book moved right along, with depthful and believable characters despite there being so many from a short play into a short-ish book (can’t wait for the sequel, prequel and/or screenplay exploring everyone’s backstories), with impactful flashbacks, lots of personal growth and/or resignation, and pertinent, affirming and modern touching upon themes and sensibilities old and current. As with Dressler’s first also excellent book, How to Align the Stars, you don’t have to be at all familiar with the play it’s based on to enjoy it, but I like delicious easter egg facet to these ‘cover stories’ as I call them (based on a story by a man named ‘Speare, to lift a line from the Beatles), where she works really well with the apples-enough-to-apples (both obvious and not) and their updatings and twists vs. the original work. Everything in the plot(s) here was well wrapped up neatly and positively in ways I think different kinds and levels of reader will appreciate, and the ending was nice.
July 10, 2025
Amy Dressler has done it again with another Shakespeare retelling. "The Best Advice" is a delightfully charming contemporary take on "As You Like It" that will have you laughing out loud while your heart melts in equal measure. Meet Rosalind, an advice columnist who's brilliant at solving everyone else's problems but spectacularly messy when it comes to her own life. When she loses her job and creates a fake male identity to keep writing advice in a quaint waterside town, the hijinks that ensue are both hilarious and heartwarming. The romantic tension with gorgeous outdoorsman Andy Arden (a pretty terrible poet) is absolutely swoon-worthy, especially as Rosalind juggles her double life while he unknowingly texts "Gavin" for relationship advice about... well, her. Dressler has crafted a story that perfectly balances humor, heart, and that satisfying feeling of watching someone finally get out of their own way, all while delivering a fresh take on Shakespeare that feels completely modern and utterly addictive.
May 31, 2025
This book is a clever, emotional romantic comedy that re imagines Shakespeare’s As You Like It for a modern audience. It’s the second installment in The Shakespeare Project series, but it stands well on its own.
It is multi-viewpointed - you don't just get the voices of Roz and Andy, but the supporting characters which is unusual but adds to the plot. The author uses wit, banter between characters and humour to engage the reader. She also has subthemes such as the way in which the characters respond to grief and how the main character reinvents herself to respond to the loss of her journalistic outlet. It offers a thoughtful take on identity, love, and the advice we give others - it leads to her understanding that there is a fine line between meddling and helping and also helps some of the characters find the relationships they need and deserve. Well written and enjoyable.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
It is multi-viewpointed - you don't just get the voices of Roz and Andy, but the supporting characters which is unusual but adds to the plot. The author uses wit, banter between characters and humour to engage the reader. She also has subthemes such as the way in which the characters respond to grief and how the main character reinvents herself to respond to the loss of her journalistic outlet. It offers a thoughtful take on identity, love, and the advice we give others - it leads to her understanding that there is a fine line between meddling and helping and also helps some of the characters find the relationships they need and deserve. Well written and enjoyable.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
November 2, 2025
This was a fun rom-com /romance novel. I couldn't put it down. It's set in my home town, Seattle, which also made it more fun to read because I could clearly picture where the characters were and understood the vibe. This is a LGBTQ+ positive read (which I wasn't expecting when I picked it up so that is only why I mention it). The characters are charming and all you want is for them to find happiness. That lovely elusive HEA. I like how this book had each character questioning their decisions, and growing. They face fears, challenge each other, and help one another and the community. Who doesn't want a feel good outcome, especially now a days? I also laughed a lot while reading this book. The writing is quick and witty. Although the author mentions this is influenced by a Shakespeare play, don't have to like or even read Shakespeare to fully enjoy this book! I am telling all my friends this is my favorite latest read. Enjoy!
May 7, 2025
Reading The Best Advice by Amy Dressler is like having brunch with your smartest, sassiest friend who somehow knows exactly what you need to hear—right when you need to hear it. This book doesn’t just dish out advice; it serves it up with wit, warmth, and the occasional side-eye you didn’t know you needed.
Dressler’s writing is equal parts heartfelt and hilarious, packed with insights that make you go, “Oof, that’s me,” followed immediately by, “Okay, now I know what to do about it.” Whether she’s talking relationships, self-worth, career chaos, or those inexplicable life spirals we all pretend aren’t happening—she gets it.
It’s part pep talk, part therapy session, part permission slip to live your dang life unapologetically.
Highly recommended for anyone who’s ever needed a nudge, a laugh, or a reminder that their mess isn’t just normal—it’s magnificent.
Dressler’s writing is equal parts heartfelt and hilarious, packed with insights that make you go, “Oof, that’s me,” followed immediately by, “Okay, now I know what to do about it.” Whether she’s talking relationships, self-worth, career chaos, or those inexplicable life spirals we all pretend aren’t happening—she gets it.
It’s part pep talk, part therapy session, part permission slip to live your dang life unapologetically.
Highly recommended for anyone who’s ever needed a nudge, a laugh, or a reminder that their mess isn’t just normal—it’s magnificent.
June 19, 2025
Just finished The Best Advice by Amy Dressler, and this one stuck with me. She's a Seattle author, and it shows. The city felt real, not like someone just pulled details off Google. As a local, it felt like slipping into something familiar and comfortable.
It’s her second in a series of modern Shakespeare retellings, this one’s a rom-com, and it’s genuinely sweet without being fluffy. Roz, the main character, was so relatable. That whole thing where it’s easier to deal with everyone else’s problems than your own? Nailed it. And when she does face her stuff? It’s messy in all the right ways.
The story handles LGBTQ+ themes, grief, boundaries, and found family with heart. I cried twice. No regrets. Definitely worth picking up, especially if you need something that hits both emotionally and hopefully.
It’s her second in a series of modern Shakespeare retellings, this one’s a rom-com, and it’s genuinely sweet without being fluffy. Roz, the main character, was so relatable. That whole thing where it’s easier to deal with everyone else’s problems than your own? Nailed it. And when she does face her stuff? It’s messy in all the right ways.
The story handles LGBTQ+ themes, grief, boundaries, and found family with heart. I cried twice. No regrets. Definitely worth picking up, especially if you need something that hits both emotionally and hopefully.
July 30, 2025
I'm not a big Shakespeare person so sometimes when I see that something is done based on his works, my eyes glaze over and my mind does a time jump back to my least favorite part of high school theatre. That being said, this book experience was not that.
Ms Dressler's writing is sharp and witty, descriptive and well researched. I appreciated the modern spin on a familiar tale. Not being from the Pacific Northwest, I enjoyed the descriptiveness and found myself researching to see if events and places from her story truly exist because I'd love to visit them. (I'll let you figure it out for yourself so as not to spoil the mystery.)
There's an underlying theme of unprocessed grief throughout the book that I found to be profound and insightful.
Plus there's a cute dog. I'm a sucker for cute dogs.
Ms Dressler's writing is sharp and witty, descriptive and well researched. I appreciated the modern spin on a familiar tale. Not being from the Pacific Northwest, I enjoyed the descriptiveness and found myself researching to see if events and places from her story truly exist because I'd love to visit them. (I'll let you figure it out for yourself so as not to spoil the mystery.)
There's an underlying theme of unprocessed grief throughout the book that I found to be profound and insightful.
Plus there's a cute dog. I'm a sucker for cute dogs.
June 24, 2025
When Roz's advice-column job goes sour and her besties walk out with her, the gang relocates to a quaint Washington island to reexamine their priorities, find community, and make connections of all kinds. Roz and her sister Celeste are forced to determine where their parents' plans and hopes for their lives diverge from their own and figure out how to shape their own identities.
As with Dressler's debut novel, The Best Advice is a charming, fun read. I appreciated that all of the characters have depth and motivation, and that the main character has flaws that make her not entirely likable sometimes but lovable in the end. The town and its denizens reminded me of Stars Hollow, and a loyal dog will always have my heart.
As with Dressler's debut novel, The Best Advice is a charming, fun read. I appreciated that all of the characters have depth and motivation, and that the main character has flaws that make her not entirely likable sometimes but lovable in the end. The town and its denizens reminded me of Stars Hollow, and a loyal dog will always have my heart.
June 27, 2025
A fun, lighthearted romance with a beautiful, small town setting.
This was such a fun take on Shakespeare’s As You Like It! While you don’t have to know that play to enjoy this light hearted romance, I enjoyed seeing how the author wove that storyline into her contemporary characters. I really liked the main character, Roz, the quaint small town (adding this area to my travel list), her best friends, and the love interest(s). I also really loved and appreciated the modern awareness of gender swapping, and the author’s additional material at the end of the book. That sort of attention to detail can make or break my overall enjoyment of an escapism novel, and in this instance it made it. Definitely recommend this book, Shakespeare fan or not.
This was such a fun take on Shakespeare’s As You Like It! While you don’t have to know that play to enjoy this light hearted romance, I enjoyed seeing how the author wove that storyline into her contemporary characters. I really liked the main character, Roz, the quaint small town (adding this area to my travel list), her best friends, and the love interest(s). I also really loved and appreciated the modern awareness of gender swapping, and the author’s additional material at the end of the book. That sort of attention to detail can make or break my overall enjoyment of an escapism novel, and in this instance it made it. Definitely recommend this book, Shakespeare fan or not.
April 16, 2025
A Clever, Modern Spin with Heart and Humor
The Best Advice is a charming, smart retelling of As You Like It that mixes mistaken identity, heartfelt drama, and a whole lot of witty advice-column chaos. Rosalind’s journey from confident columnist to small-town anonymous fixer was full of messy situations and real emotions, and I liked watching her slowly peel back the layers of her own grief and bad habits. The mix of modern romance and Shakespearean undertones really worked for me, especially the way it balanced humor with vulnerability. I stayed up way too late reading this because I just had to see how she’d untangle it all.
The Best Advice is a charming, smart retelling of As You Like It that mixes mistaken identity, heartfelt drama, and a whole lot of witty advice-column chaos. Rosalind’s journey from confident columnist to small-town anonymous fixer was full of messy situations and real emotions, and I liked watching her slowly peel back the layers of her own grief and bad habits. The mix of modern romance and Shakespearean undertones really worked for me, especially the way it balanced humor with vulnerability. I stayed up way too late reading this because I just had to see how she’d untangle it all.
April 26, 2025
Another really fun adaptation of Shakespeare by Amy Dressler.
Everyone around Roz loves her, but wouldn't mind giving her a little slap upside the head every now and then.
Fortunately for her, they are kind and let her find her way through steamrolling tunnel vision she developed as a coping mechanism after the loss of her mother.
I usually like a story that's a little more complicated than this, but as it is an adaptation of a Shakespeare play, there's not a lot of wiggle room for that. This is an engaging adaptation of a classic story with some great characters and modernized plot lines. I'd certainly recommend it to my friends.
Everyone around Roz loves her, but wouldn't mind giving her a little slap upside the head every now and then.
Fortunately for her, they are kind and let her find her way through steamrolling tunnel vision she developed as a coping mechanism after the loss of her mother.
I usually like a story that's a little more complicated than this, but as it is an adaptation of a Shakespeare play, there's not a lot of wiggle room for that. This is an engaging adaptation of a classic story with some great characters and modernized plot lines. I'd certainly recommend it to my friends.
June 3, 2025
Advice vs Meddling . . .
Rosalind (“Roz”) seems to have trouble simply giving advice in her advice column. She takes it further by involving herself in other people’s real-life business. Arguing with her editor over one of her answers, she gets fired. So this time, she writes for a small-town newspaper under a male pen name of "Gavin," continuing to stick her nose into other people’s relationships with humor and sincerity. When it starts to damage her own relationships, will she recognize the advice coming from her own pen? Will she maybe learn to listen to the advice of those who care about her when they can offer another perspective that may make more sense?
Rosalind (“Roz”) seems to have trouble simply giving advice in her advice column. She takes it further by involving herself in other people’s real-life business. Arguing with her editor over one of her answers, she gets fired. So this time, she writes for a small-town newspaper under a male pen name of "Gavin," continuing to stick her nose into other people’s relationships with humor and sincerity. When it starts to damage her own relationships, will she recognize the advice coming from her own pen? Will she maybe learn to listen to the advice of those who care about her when they can offer another perspective that may make more sense?
July 11, 2025
I have forgotten most of the plot of "As You Like It" before reading this creative retelling. This novel is such a fun approach to the Shakespeare play, with plenty of current-day social issues. A big emphasis is placed on LGBTQ+ issues and rights, and I thought the author handled those aspects with sensitivity. While Roz feels like the main character, several other POVs are included in the novel and each one truly enhances the reader's understanding of events. I enjoyed the sweet romance plotlines and the fact that no one is presented as perfect (especially not meddling Roz, ha!) but that the characters grow in meaningful ways throughout the story.
April 14, 2025
Dear Gavin: You had me fooled—and I LOVED it!
This book is like a rom-com had a fling with Shakespeare and gave birth to pure chaos. 💌🤣 I was totally obsessed with Rosalind’s double-life drama, the juicy texts, and Andy with his terrible poetry (hilariously terrible). I laughed, I cringed, I wanted to shake her and hug her. Honestly, the whole advice-column-gone-wrong thing was genius and had me rooting for Rosalind even when she was making a mess of everything. If you like witty banter, secret identities, and hot guys who hike, this book is for you. 📝💘🌲
This book is like a rom-com had a fling with Shakespeare and gave birth to pure chaos. 💌🤣 I was totally obsessed with Rosalind’s double-life drama, the juicy texts, and Andy with his terrible poetry (hilariously terrible). I laughed, I cringed, I wanted to shake her and hug her. Honestly, the whole advice-column-gone-wrong thing was genius and had me rooting for Rosalind even when she was making a mess of everything. If you like witty banter, secret identities, and hot guys who hike, this book is for you. 📝💘🌲
May 5, 2025
As an advice columnist Roz believes she should solve everyone’s problems even if they want to do so on their own. When she is fired from her job she goes to a small town and newspaper. She encounters a one-night stand, Andy, and their relationship is rocky. I loved how Roz’s friends convinced her to stay away from meddling and just be a listener. There are several couples with relationships that present a healthy idea of how that looks. I loved the variety of characters and the community that supports them Great book with good lessons in life.
May 13, 2025
The Best Advice
After losing her mother, Roz takes over the role of advice columnist at the magazine she worked for.
Her Stepfather and she had a poor relationship, and ultimately fell out.
Roz, her Stepsister Celeste, and Barry, a co-worker, all left their jobs on the same day.
I received an advance review copy for free, and am leaving this honest review voluntarily.
This story is compelling, and well written, with a cast of characters and situations, that kept me hooked until the end.
I really enjoyed it, and look forward to reading more from the author.
After losing her mother, Roz takes over the role of advice columnist at the magazine she worked for.
Her Stepfather and she had a poor relationship, and ultimately fell out.
Roz, her Stepsister Celeste, and Barry, a co-worker, all left their jobs on the same day.
I received an advance review copy for free, and am leaving this honest review voluntarily.
This story is compelling, and well written, with a cast of characters and situations, that kept me hooked until the end.
I really enjoyed it, and look forward to reading more from the author.
May 17, 2025
Here’s my best advice—buy the book! In this fresh retelling of As You Like It, Amy Dressler swept me into the antics of a cast of endearing characters on the first page. With her distinctive voice, she blends humor with the tumult of family, friendship, and love interests. Set in the Pacific Northwest, Dressler paints a picture so real you can smell the Puget Sound and taste the lefsa. She artfully weaves a plot that will keep you guessing. As dazzling as her debut, I cannot wait to read the next one.
May 29, 2025
I’m a fan of advice columns, especially the ones that invite input from their readers. Sometimes the readers point out where the advice oversteps boundaries or misses the mark and for me those are the most interesting columns. That’s probably why I enjoyed this so much.
In The Best Advice Roz has taken over her late mother’s advice column ‘Kate Knows Best’ and now she thinks she knows what’s best for her close friends and co-workers. Their gentle push back and Roz’s own growing awareness that what works for her doesn’t necessarily work for others makes this a very engaging story about personal growth that also mixes in a little romance for everyone. Since I’ve never seen or read Shakespeare’s play As You Like It that this is based on I can’t say how well it works as a retelling, but I never felt that I was missing out on anything. My thanks to Librarything Early Reviewers and the publisher for an ebook copy to review.
July 10, 2025
I loved this book, and found myself enjoying it like a great varied feast over a single looong evening! Dressler makes it such a pleasure to meet her cast of characters, major and minor both, and to enjoy the settings she's created for them to bounce along with and into each other. The writing is terrific: propulsive and deft with these jolts of absolute beauty that rob you of breath, reminding you that though it's terrific fun "The Best Advice" is serious in its regard for all of us as we work our way to ourselves and each other--with love.
February 10, 2026
The Best Advice, a fun, romantic book with engaging twists and turns, arrives with a unique, brilliant idea by author Amy Dressler. Why not weave Shakespearian sonnets into a modern day love story? As a lover of Shakespeare’s plays, seeing his sonnets pop up as a method to help Roz and Andy overcome new relationship struggles gave me joy. I can’t wait to see how Dressler layers other works of Shakespeare into novels set in the current era. I kept turning the pages, unable to put this book down!
September 3, 2025
Rosalind finds herself in a tricky situation after leaving her job. She hates the direction that her mother's spouse is taking the company she worked so hard to build. With limited opportunities, she devises a new identity to find employment. This leads to complications with family and a potential romantic interest. Will she be able to confront her grief and finally make a place for herself in the world that she belongs in?
November 19, 2025
Another 5 star book from Amy Dressler! She writes small town novels so well - the characters are relatable and likable people instead of super quirky (like I see in so many other small town settings). Port Poulson was a perfect setting and if you live in the PNW it’s so fun noticing aspects of different towns to create this fictions one.
I especially enjoyed Olivia’s character who progressed throughout the novel and found myself really rooting for her in the end.
I especially enjoyed Olivia’s character who progressed throughout the novel and found myself really rooting for her in the end.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews