I received an ARC from Edelweiss in exchange for an honest review.
I went into The Boyfriend Candidate knowing it would be political, so the politics isn't the reason behind my low rating; it's fairly easy for me to dissociate politics from romance. This book has such a delicious premise: after the paparazzi catches Alexis Stone outside a hotel with governor candidate Logan Arthur, she agrees to fake date him in public to save his campaign. I couldn't resist this storyline, especially since I've previously enjoyed Ashley Winstead's books. But my issue with this particular book is that the romance gets bogged down by the political storyline and the inconsistent characterization of the heroine Alexis. To me, it felt like the politics was the primary storyline and the romance was secondary, which is not what I was expecting.
Let's being with what I liked. Logan...I loved him as a hero. He's bold, brash, and blunt. He's Alexis's complete opposite and he perfectly complements her, personality-wise. He's also very grumpy, which is an added bonus. His overall vibe and energy is incongruent with his career. He's not going to appeal to everyone as a hero, but I loved him. His only flaw is that he's a Spurs fan 🤣 There were also a couple of things I liked about the romance, mostly thanks to Logan's contribution. The swoon-worthy kisses. This book has one of the best first kisses ever. The cuddling on the couch was very cute. Logan being vulnerable with Alexis. Logan and KITTENS!!!! 😍
My main problem is with Alexis; I had a hard time understanding her characterization. First of all, Alexis's political activism came out of nowhere. There was no basis supporting her sudden interest in political activism. She has never once fought for educators and librarians in the past. If Alexis had a history of fighting for educators on a local level, then her activism on a state level would have made more sense. It was also hard to believe that a shy introvert like Alexis kept nailing all of her public speeches.
Secondly, a huge part of Alexis's character is that she's always in the shadow of her older sister Lee, including the fact that she has no friends her own age. Alexis does have an important talk with her sister about this in the end, which I appreciated. But Alexis is also stuck becoming friends with her sister's friend Zoey, who only approached Alexis on behalf of Lee. Wouldn't it have made more sense for Alexis to strike out on her own and find her own circle of friends? That would have been an integral part of her journey. It would have added more depth to her journey and growth. It would have proven that she can make friends with people her own age, without the influence of her older sister. Alexis's friendship with Zoey came out of nowhere and contributed absolutely nothing to her growth as a character.
Lastly, instead of following the rules set out by Logan's staff, Alexis holds rallies on behalf of his campaign without checking with his team first. She constantly makes stupid decisions on her own and breaks the rules that she herself agreed to. She never tells the campaign before making stupid decisions that go completely against the rules, decisions that have massive repercussions on Logan and his campaign. She does this not once, but twice, completely negating any sort of character development. Alexis will tell you that she likes following rules, but her actions prove otherwise when she constantly breaks the rules to defy Logan. She expects Logan to drop everything for her, even when he is literally in the middle of a shitstorm, but it's okay for her to go behind his back to break their agreement multiple times. She keeps messing up, and get this...Logan is the one who keeps apologizing her, even though he has nothing to apologize for. Who's really the victim here? It is an affront to Leslie Knope that the characters in this book compared idiot Alexis to her. Homegirl should remain an assistant librarian. She's clearly too dumb to be a librarian.
I'm getting heated all over again because of dumbo Alexis. I wish Logan had dropped Alexis lol. I couldn't stand her.