What do you think?
Rate this book
Boys of Lake Chapel #3.5
Too Sweet
A brand new steamy, swoony, why choose novella from bestselling author Abby Millsaps
Life has been nonstop since the day I became Mrs. Crusade. Not that I have any interest in slowing down now that I’ve found my rhythm in Lake Chapel.
I love my life, my boys, and the future we’re creating together.
This semester, I even get to live with my best friend and her cohort of men.
There’s more than enough room at the Crusade Mansion for the ten of us, but between conflicting schedules, increased security measures, and Kendrick’s NFL draft intentions, it’s rare that I get time with all four of my guys.
That’s why I’m thrilled about our plans for Valentine’s Day.
Spending an entire weekend off the grid with the men I love is my personal version of heaven. I’m craving quality time with each of them (and hoping for some quality group fun, too).
All I want for Valentine’s Day is to be snuggled up at the cabin with Kylian, Locke, Kendrick, and Decker.
But apparently, my guys have other plans.
When it becomes clear they’ve uncovered a secret I intended to keep to myself, I’m forced to face the reality of what it means to be loved by four possessive, overbearing men.
Too Sweet is a 27,000 word spicy novella featuring the characters from the completed Boys of Lake Chapel series. This cohort has already found their happily ever after together, so expect low angst, swoony moments, the spiciest spice, and hilarious banter from Joey, Kylian, Locke, Kendrick, and Decker.
Life has been nonstop since the day I became Mrs. Crusade. Not that I have any interest in slowing down now that I’ve found my rhythm in Lake Chapel.
I love my life, my boys, and the future we’re creating together.
This semester, I even get to live with my best friend and her cohort of men.
There’s more than enough room at the Crusade Mansion for the ten of us, but between conflicting schedules, increased security measures, and Kendrick’s NFL draft intentions, it’s rare that I get time with all four of my guys.
That’s why I’m thrilled about our plans for Valentine’s Day.
Spending an entire weekend off the grid with the men I love is my personal version of heaven. I’m craving quality time with each of them (and hoping for some quality group fun, too).
All I want for Valentine’s Day is to be snuggled up at the cabin with Kylian, Locke, Kendrick, and Decker.
But apparently, my guys have other plans.
When it becomes clear they’ve uncovered a secret I intended to keep to myself, I’m forced to face the reality of what it means to be loved by four possessive, overbearing men.
Too Sweet is a 27,000 word spicy novella featuring the characters from the completed Boys of Lake Chapel series. This cohort has already found their happily ever after together, so expect low angst, swoony moments, the spiciest spice, and hilarious banter from Joey, Kylian, Locke, Kendrick, and Decker.
120 pages, Kindle Edition
Published February 14, 2025
About the author
Abby Millsaps
27 books1,189 followersAbby Millsaps is an author and storyteller who's been obsessed with romance since middle school. She's best known for writing unapologetically angsty romance, and prides herself in crafting authentic characters while weaving mental health, chronic illness, and neurodiverse representation into the fabric of her stories.
When Abby isn't writing she can be found reading, watching Formula 1, attending a Broadway show, riding rollercoasters with her kids, whipping up a batch of buttercream, or cheering for the Cleveland Browns with her dad. She lives in Northeast Ohio with Mr. Abby, their three kids, and a wiggly dachshund pup named Frankie.
Connect with Abby
Website: www.authorabbymillsaps.com
Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/AbbyMillsaps
Instagram: @abbymillsaps
TikTok: @authorabbymillsaps
Newsletter: https://geni.us/AuthorAbbyNewsletter
Facebook Reader Group: https://www.facebook.com/authorabbymi...
When Abby isn't writing she can be found reading, watching Formula 1, attending a Broadway show, riding rollercoasters with her kids, whipping up a batch of buttercream, or cheering for the Cleveland Browns with her dad. She lives in Northeast Ohio with Mr. Abby, their three kids, and a wiggly dachshund pup named Frankie.
Connect with Abby
Website: www.authorabbymillsaps.com
Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/AbbyMillsaps
Instagram: @abbymillsaps
TikTok: @authorabbymillsaps
Newsletter: https://geni.us/AuthorAbbyNewsletter
Facebook Reader Group: https://www.facebook.com/authorabbymi...
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 120 reviews
April 18, 2026
“You deserve every happiness, Josephine. My life’s purpose is to figure out new ways to make you smile.”
omg, Decker was eating in this novella & so was Nicky 😮💨 i love this group so much, even during their domestic moments im just smiling like a lunatic. i am so happy for every single character and how effortlessly they all work together to make the life they want possible. Kendrick, Nicky, Decker, Kylian & Joey have become everything to me.. sad that it’s over 😭🩷
omg, Decker was eating in this novella & so was Nicky 😮💨 i love this group so much, even during their domestic moments im just smiling like a lunatic. i am so happy for every single character and how effortlessly they all work together to make the life they want possible. Kendrick, Nicky, Decker, Kylian & Joey have become everything to me.. sad that it’s over 😭🩷
February 20, 2025
The things that I would do for Kylian Walsh are as vulgar as the mouth on that man. This surprise release was one that I didn’t know was missing in my life.
The queen of writing such original spice scenes remains on her throne.
This short novella was *chefs kiss* and left me sated.
The characters in this series are absolutely some of the favorite characters in any book series I have ever read.
I am absolutely obsessed with
emo boy-Nicky,
the feral fierce man that is K,
Cap- the sweetest tender soul & protector,
and the depths of GENIUS STATS DADDY.
And of course, the FMC, Josephine is arguably the luckiest lady in the entire fictional world finally in her life and deserves everything her cohort offers her.
📑🚙🏔️🪞⛸️🧁🫦🛋️🕯️🍹🚤🥞
🎵: Boat Ride by Brian Kelley
The queen of writing such original spice scenes remains on her throne.
This short novella was *chefs kiss* and left me sated.
The characters in this series are absolutely some of the favorite characters in any book series I have ever read.
I am absolutely obsessed with
emo boy-Nicky,
the feral fierce man that is K,
Cap- the sweetest tender soul & protector,
and the depths of GENIUS STATS DADDY.
And of course, the FMC, Josephine is arguably the luckiest lady in the entire fictional world finally in her life and deserves everything her cohort offers her.
📑🚙🏔️🪞⛸️🧁🫦🛋️🕯️🍹🚤🥞
🎵: Boat Ride by Brian Kelley
August 5, 2026
Cute little Novella on Joey and her men
This follows Valentines Day and Joey's Birthday and how the men surprise her
Spicy as always and love reading more about Joey and her men, they all sound so delicious <3
Spice - 4/5
Story - 5/5
This follows Valentines Day and Joey's Birthday and how the men surprise her
Spicy as always and love reading more about Joey and her men, they all sound so delicious <3
Spice - 4/5
Story - 5/5
Read
February 18, 2025Available now!
Download today or read for FREE with #kindleunlimited
https://geni.us/toosweet
Goodreads: https://bit.ly/4gDOEvP
Spotify Playlist: https://bit.ly/3QikL9I
💖 Valentine’s Day at the Cabin
📈 834.6 Pounds of Sprinkles
🤳 Toys as Teammates
🤭 He Gets a Tattoo for Her
👅 Sunday Morning Traditions
🛥️ Decker Breaks his Boat Rule
Download today or read for FREE with #kindleunlimited
https://geni.us/toosweet
Goodreads: https://bit.ly/4gDOEvP
Spotify Playlist: https://bit.ly/3QikL9I
💖 Valentine’s Day at the Cabin
📈 834.6 Pounds of Sprinkles
🤳 Toys as Teammates
🤭 He Gets a Tattoo for Her
👅 Sunday Morning Traditions
🛥️ Decker Breaks his Boat Rule
March 4, 2025
This was DELICIOUS! I will never get enough of the lake chapel boys I don’t think. Hope to revisit with them in the future, bc this absolutely just made me want even more of them!
January 13, 2026
3.75⭐️
February 15, 2025
5/5⭐️
4/5🌶️
What are we here for? A spicy novella. AND WE GOT IT! This was delicious, nutritious, and everything I wanted. I was so glad to be back with our girl and her guys! Super spicy, fun scenes, a little angst to get us through it… this was a real treat! And what a fun surprise for my Saturday! Yay!
4/5🌶️
What are we here for? A spicy novella. AND WE GOT IT! This was delicious, nutritious, and everything I wanted. I was so glad to be back with our girl and her guys! Super spicy, fun scenes, a little angst to get us through it… this was a real treat! And what a fun surprise for my Saturday! Yay!
April 21, 2025
Joey and the guys get away for Valentines which is also her birthday but she freaks out when she realises they know!
Just wasn’t needed IMO
Xx
Just wasn’t needed IMO
Xx
March 16, 2025
3.5 stars ★ ★ ★ ☆ ☆
･ ｡ﾟ☆:Too Sweet *.☽ .*:☆ﾟ
⁺₊★·.´🎧✩°｡ 0:56 ──♡───── 3:32 ⁺₊🎧★·.·´
🎶 Don't be scared to come put your trust in me. Can't you see all I really want to be. Is your boyfriend (yeah) 🎶
Despite the size of the mansion, the demanding schedules of her four men—Kylian, Locke, Kendrick, and Decker (H)—along with increased security and Kendrick's NFL draft ambitions, make it difficult to find quality time with all of them. So when Valentine’s Day approaches, she eagerly anticipates a weekend getaway to a secluded cabin, away from distractions, where she can reconnect with each of them, and maybe even indulge in some group fun.
─── ･ ｡ﾟ☆: THOUGHTS*.☽ .*:☆ﾟ. ───
[Kylian]
MY BABY. He knows Jo so well that he totally understood she wouldn’t want to make a big deal out of her birthday. So, he told everyone to hold off on the celebrations—but of course, they didn’t listen. It just shows how in tune he is with her needs, always paying attention to what she wants and what makes her comfortable. I love how he’s so structured and has his routines, and the fact that she gets him and understands that side of him just makes them even more amazing together. I’ve missed him so much, and he’s just so special to me.
[Decker]
One thing about Decker is that he’s really good at carving out those special moments just for him and Jo. He doesn’t mind sharing her with others, but there’s something about those quiet, intimate times just between the two of them that he treasures. It’s like he knows how important those moments are for their connection. He loves her so deeply and is always willing to give her whatever she needs, as long as it makes her happy. And yeah, he can be a little bossy, but in the best way possible—he’s got this incredible ability to understand exactly what Jo needs and how to give it to her in a way that feels natural and right.
[Locke - Nicky]
STOP. He just wanted to show Jo how much she’s loved on her birthday, to appreciate her in the sweetest way possible. But in trying to do that, he accidentally triggered a bad memory, and I honestly felt so terrible for him. He’s such a good guy, and he was just trying to do something nice for her. But at the same time, this moment is such a learning experience for their relationship. They’re still figuring each other out, and they’re so different, yet they balance each other so well. It’s all a part of their growth, and even though it was tough, it just makes me love them even more. I love my babies so much.
[Kendrick]
MAMA. I love Kendrick. That’s husband material right there. He gets it so perfectly, especially when it comes to Jo. He understands that it’s all about the small moments, the little things that show her how much she means to him. Kendrick truly thrives on taking care of her—he gets a sense of fulfillment from making sure she feels reassured, loved, and supported. One thing’s for sure, he will ALWAYS take care of her. He just knows how to show up for her in ways that matter, and it’s everything. What a man.
─── ･ ｡ﾟ☆: OVERALL*.☽ .*:☆ﾟ. ───
This is exactly what I needed too—a novella that shows they’re all happy, close, and still learning about each other. It’s like watching my precious babies grow together, and it just fills my heart. They’re so perfect for each other, and even with all their differences, they’re finding their way through it, one step at a time. I can never get enough of them, honestly.
･ ｡ﾟ☆:Too Sweet *.☽ .*:☆ﾟ
⁺₊★·.´🎧✩°｡ 0:56 ──♡───── 3:32 ⁺₊🎧★·.·´
🎶 Don't be scared to come put your trust in me. Can't you see all I really want to be. Is your boyfriend (yeah) 🎶
Despite the size of the mansion, the demanding schedules of her four men—Kylian, Locke, Kendrick, and Decker (H)—along with increased security and Kendrick's NFL draft ambitions, make it difficult to find quality time with all of them. So when Valentine’s Day approaches, she eagerly anticipates a weekend getaway to a secluded cabin, away from distractions, where she can reconnect with each of them, and maybe even indulge in some group fun.
─── ･ ｡ﾟ☆: THOUGHTS*.☽ .*:☆ﾟ. ───
[Kylian]
“I did not get Jo anything,” Kylian replies. “I curated an experience she will find equal parts amusing and sexually satisfying.”
MY BABY. He knows Jo so well that he totally understood she wouldn’t want to make a big deal out of her birthday. So, he told everyone to hold off on the celebrations—but of course, they didn’t listen. It just shows how in tune he is with her needs, always paying attention to what she wants and what makes her comfortable. I love how he’s so structured and has his routines, and the fact that she gets him and understands that side of him just makes them even more amazing together. I’ve missed him so much, and he’s just so special to me.
[Decker]
“Sit and let me take care of you, woman.”
After the full minute passes, I murmur, “Thank you for loving me so well.
One thing about Decker is that he’s really good at carving out those special moments just for him and Jo. He doesn’t mind sharing her with others, but there’s something about those quiet, intimate times just between the two of them that he treasures. It’s like he knows how important those moments are for their connection. He loves her so deeply and is always willing to give her whatever she needs, as long as it makes her happy. And yeah, he can be a little bossy, but in the best way possible—he’s got this incredible ability to understand exactly what Jo needs and how to give it to her in a way that feels natural and right.
[Locke - Nicky]
“That’s not an accurate portrayal of what occurred. Nicky alerted you to the significance of the date, yes. But you don’t see a massive pile of presents from him anywhere, do you? This”—he makes a sweeping gesture around the kitchen, ending at the present-covered table—“was all your idea.”
STOP. He just wanted to show Jo how much she’s loved on her birthday, to appreciate her in the sweetest way possible. But in trying to do that, he accidentally triggered a bad memory, and I honestly felt so terrible for him. He’s such a good guy, and he was just trying to do something nice for her. But at the same time, this moment is such a learning experience for their relationship. They’re still figuring each other out, and they’re so different, yet they balance each other so well. It’s all a part of their growth, and even though it was tough, it just makes me love them even more. I love my babies so much.
[Kendrick]
Kendrick lightly shoves him in the chest. “You just don’t know when to quit, do you, Cap?”
MAMA. I love Kendrick. That’s husband material right there. He gets it so perfectly, especially when it comes to Jo. He understands that it’s all about the small moments, the little things that show her how much she means to him. Kendrick truly thrives on taking care of her—he gets a sense of fulfillment from making sure she feels reassured, loved, and supported. One thing’s for sure, he will ALWAYS take care of her. He just knows how to show up for her in ways that matter, and it’s everything. What a man.
─── ･ ｡ﾟ☆: OVERALL*.☽ .*:☆ﾟ. ───
This is exactly what I needed too—a novella that shows they’re all happy, close, and still learning about each other. It’s like watching my precious babies grow together, and it just fills my heart. They’re so perfect for each other, and even with all their differences, they’re finding their way through it, one step at a time. I can never get enough of them, honestly.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 23, 2026
4 ⭐️ | Too Sweet by Abby Millsaps | Audiobook
Too Sweet is the perfect little return to the Boys of Lake Chapel crew, giving us more of Josephine, Kylian, Locke, Kendrick, and Decker after they’ve already found their happily ever after. This time, the group is heading off to a secluded cabin for Valentine’s Day, where Joey is expecting some much-needed alone time with all four of her possessive men. Instead, the guys have uncovered a secret she was hoping to keep hidden, forcing Joey to confront just how far these four will go when it comes to loving, protecting, and claiming their girl.
This novella feels like a delicious bonus episode for fans who aren’t ready to say goodbye to the series. There’s plenty of domestic sweetness, ridiculous banter, playful chaos, and that familiar found-family dynamic that makes the Boys of Lake Chapel crew so addictive. But don’t let the title fool you. The romance may be sweet, but the spice is anything but. The scenes are unapologetically steamy, with possessive energy, toys joining the party, Daddy kink, breath play, and plenty of the group chemistry that fans of this why-choose romance have come to expect.
The audiobook was a fun, quick listen that brought these characters back to life for one more round. My only complaint is that I wanted more. As a short novella, it doesn’t have the emotional depth or plot development of the earlier books, but that’s not really what it’s trying to be. Too Sweet is a spicy, low-angst Valentine’s Day getaway that lets us peek into the happily-ever-after we’ve been waiting for.
4 stars because I loved spending more time with this chaotic, possessive, ridiculously lovable group. If you’ve finished the Boys of Lake Chapel series and aren’t emotionally prepared to let these characters go, Too Sweet is exactly the little extra treat you need.
Too Sweet is the perfect little return to the Boys of Lake Chapel crew, giving us more of Josephine, Kylian, Locke, Kendrick, and Decker after they’ve already found their happily ever after. This time, the group is heading off to a secluded cabin for Valentine’s Day, where Joey is expecting some much-needed alone time with all four of her possessive men. Instead, the guys have uncovered a secret she was hoping to keep hidden, forcing Joey to confront just how far these four will go when it comes to loving, protecting, and claiming their girl.
This novella feels like a delicious bonus episode for fans who aren’t ready to say goodbye to the series. There’s plenty of domestic sweetness, ridiculous banter, playful chaos, and that familiar found-family dynamic that makes the Boys of Lake Chapel crew so addictive. But don’t let the title fool you. The romance may be sweet, but the spice is anything but. The scenes are unapologetically steamy, with possessive energy, toys joining the party, Daddy kink, breath play, and plenty of the group chemistry that fans of this why-choose romance have come to expect.
The audiobook was a fun, quick listen that brought these characters back to life for one more round. My only complaint is that I wanted more. As a short novella, it doesn’t have the emotional depth or plot development of the earlier books, but that’s not really what it’s trying to be. Too Sweet is a spicy, low-angst Valentine’s Day getaway that lets us peek into the happily-ever-after we’ve been waiting for.
4 stars because I loved spending more time with this chaotic, possessive, ridiculously lovable group. If you’ve finished the Boys of Lake Chapel series and aren’t emotionally prepared to let these characters go, Too Sweet is exactly the little extra treat you need.
February 16, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
Okay this little Valentine’s Day novella had me freaking tearing up, gasping, and SWEATING with how hot it was. I have been DYING to get back with my favourite cohort and this was DELICIOUS. As a Decker Crusade girlie, this made my heart so happy. This man, and all of these men knew how to take care of Jo so well for the entire weekend, and I freakin LOVED EVERY MINUTE OF IT!
You get an individual scene with all of them, as well as MULTIPLE group scenes in this book. My heart is so happy. YUM. The best surprise!
🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
Okay this little Valentine’s Day novella had me freaking tearing up, gasping, and SWEATING with how hot it was. I have been DYING to get back with my favourite cohort and this was DELICIOUS. As a Decker Crusade girlie, this made my heart so happy. This man, and all of these men knew how to take care of Jo so well for the entire weekend, and I freakin LOVED EVERY MINUTE OF IT!
You get an individual scene with all of them, as well as MULTIPLE group scenes in this book. My heart is so happy. YUM. The best surprise!
July 12, 2026
The way I devoured this series. I had read that you should read the other series besides Lake Chapel before reading this, but of course I did not listen. And I wish I had because there were many references to it. My fault!!!
I loved that Decker really tried so hard in this, we really saw him putting effort into the family dynamic and showing that he could adapt.
I can’t wait to dive into the next series!
I loved that Decker really tried so hard in this, we really saw him putting effort into the family dynamic and showing that he could adapt.
I can’t wait to dive into the next series!
September 9, 2025
I will always want to go back to Joey and her guys! This quick novella gives us some more stories of what they’re all up to now! It’s Valentine’s Day at the cabin and what a great holiday it turns out to be.
April 27, 2025
Quick, dirty and exactly what you think you need from a novella featuring our favourite gang from lake chapel. Thank you for this unexpected treat
October 28, 2025
*3.75 Stars
February 17, 2025
A quick and spicy novella. I love being back with these characters. It’s hard to choose a favorite but I think Decker might just take it ❤️
February 18, 2025
Valentine novella back at Lake Chapel with characters i love. Perfect easy read. 💘❤️🔥💝
February 24, 2025
Five stars!!
This was just as good as the rest of the series. I loved seeing the guys making Josephine happy again. The hot sex scenes were great!
This was just as good as the rest of the series. I loved seeing the guys making Josephine happy again. The hot sex scenes were great!
February 18, 2025
This was such a fun read, and it made my heart happy to see Joey and her cohort thriving! There is so much love between Joey, Kylian, Locke, Kendrick, and Decker. 𝑻𝒐𝒐 𝑺𝒘𝒆𝒆𝒕 was truly the perfect addition to the 𝘉𝘰𝘺𝘴 𝘰𝘧 𝘓𝘢𝘬𝘦 𝘊𝘩𝘢𝘱𝘦𝘭 series.
ᴛʀᴏᴘᴇꜱ:
💘 Valentine’s Day at the cabin
📈 834.6 pounds of sprinkles
💙 Toys as teammates
🖊️ He gets a tattoo for her
☀️ Sunday morning traditions
🚤 Decker breaks his boat rule
ᴛʀᴏᴘᴇꜱ:
💘 Valentine’s Day at the cabin
📈 834.6 pounds of sprinkles
💙 Toys as teammates
🖊️ He gets a tattoo for her
☀️ Sunday morning traditions
🚤 Decker breaks his boat rule
March 28, 2025
It’s me, hi! I am still a Decker girl. It’s me.
February 17, 2025
“You have me, Decker. I belong to you.” Then, with an uncharacteristic softness I never get from this woman, she whispers, “Please keep me. And never let me go.”
✔️MFMMM why choose romance (established relationships)
✔️HEA novella
✔️valentines novella
✔️low angst
The Boys of Lake Chapel is one of my favorite series, and this happily ever after novella just made me so happy. It was so nice to jump back into this world and see this group happy and settled in their lives together. Yes, this is a spicy novella, and there is definitely more spice than plot but that is exactly what this story needed to be. Josephine and her guys (Decker, Locke, Kylian and Kendrick) get away to the cabin for valentines weekend so they can have quality time alone together. What starts as a fun weekend becomes awkward when the guys find out something that Josephine was trying to keep under wraps, and they need to figure out how to get through it together. Their relationships are all solid so they are able to work through it easily, and it was nice to see their communication improve even more after the events of Too Far.
Also, Decker breaks one of his biggest rules (iykyk), and it was an excellent group scene. I love that we got scenes with each of them individually, as well as group scenes. I also loved seeing Decker’s and Josephine’s character growth continue, after the trauma that was the third act of Too Far, it seems that both of them have come a long way individually and together and it was so nice to see (yes, we also see it in the epilogues, but timeline wise this is closer to the events of that book).
✔️MFMMM why choose romance (established relationships)
✔️HEA novella
✔️valentines novella
✔️low angst
The Boys of Lake Chapel is one of my favorite series, and this happily ever after novella just made me so happy. It was so nice to jump back into this world and see this group happy and settled in their lives together. Yes, this is a spicy novella, and there is definitely more spice than plot but that is exactly what this story needed to be. Josephine and her guys (Decker, Locke, Kylian and Kendrick) get away to the cabin for valentines weekend so they can have quality time alone together. What starts as a fun weekend becomes awkward when the guys find out something that Josephine was trying to keep under wraps, and they need to figure out how to get through it together. Their relationships are all solid so they are able to work through it easily, and it was nice to see their communication improve even more after the events of Too Far.
Also, Decker breaks one of his biggest rules (iykyk), and it was an excellent group scene. I love that we got scenes with each of them individually, as well as group scenes. I also loved seeing Decker’s and Josephine’s character growth continue, after the trauma that was the third act of Too Far, it seems that both of them have come a long way individually and together and it was so nice to see (yes, we also see it in the epilogues, but timeline wise this is closer to the events of that book).
February 27, 2025
Omg did you see? This is a brand new novella from Abby featuring Josephine and her boys. I’ve missed these characters since finishing Boys of the Lake Chapel and seeing their brief appearances in Boys of South Chapel. It felt like catching up with old friends and I was thrilled to see they’re happy and thriving after everything they went through.
The magic of this novella lies in the reunion with Joey’s dream team: Decker, Kylian, Locke and Kendrick. As always, each of them shines, bringing their unique charm and dynamic to the story. The banter and camaraderie between them are as electric as ever, and seeing them support Joey as she navigates her past is truly heartwarming. Abby masterfully balances the familiar warmth of these characters with their continued growth.
Too Sweet is brimming with swoony moments that will leave you breathless, and the spicy scenes are absolutely fire! But it’s not just about the romance; Abby delves deeper into Joey’s emotional journey, allowing her to heal further from past traumas. The way she weaves Joey’s struggles into the narrative, while still maintaining the lighthearted and fun atmosphere, is truly impressive.
The novella is also packed with Easter eggs and inside jokes that fans of the series will adore, creating a sense of connection and belonging. The over-the-top grand gestures from each of the boys just hit different, adding a layer of sweet, heartfelt intensity.
Too Sweet is an absolute must-read. Everything came together seamlessly, with a perfect blend of romance, humor, and emotional depth. It’s a wonderful reminder of why we fell in love with Joey and her boys in the first place. I can’t recommend it enough!
The magic of this novella lies in the reunion with Joey’s dream team: Decker, Kylian, Locke and Kendrick. As always, each of them shines, bringing their unique charm and dynamic to the story. The banter and camaraderie between them are as electric as ever, and seeing them support Joey as she navigates her past is truly heartwarming. Abby masterfully balances the familiar warmth of these characters with their continued growth.
Too Sweet is brimming with swoony moments that will leave you breathless, and the spicy scenes are absolutely fire! But it’s not just about the romance; Abby delves deeper into Joey’s emotional journey, allowing her to heal further from past traumas. The way she weaves Joey’s struggles into the narrative, while still maintaining the lighthearted and fun atmosphere, is truly impressive.
The novella is also packed with Easter eggs and inside jokes that fans of the series will adore, creating a sense of connection and belonging. The over-the-top grand gestures from each of the boys just hit different, adding a layer of sweet, heartfelt intensity.
Too Sweet is an absolute must-read. Everything came together seamlessly, with a perfect blend of romance, humor, and emotional depth. It’s a wonderful reminder of why we fell in love with Joey and her boys in the first place. I can’t recommend it enough!
June 5, 2025
┈ Read this if you like ┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈
✦ Sports Romance
✦ College Football
✦ Reverse Harem/Why Choose?
✦ Millionaire Romance
✦ Forced Proximity
✦ Slow Burn
✦ MFMMM Romance (No ⚔️)
✦ Chronic Illness Representation
✦ Novella / Short Story
┈ MY THOUGHTS ┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈
- This is a short novella about their trip to the cabin to celebrate Valentine's and escape from the house and Hunter's cohort. It's a short, fast read and provides an interesting plot that isn't all bedroom scenes.
- Overall: This was short and sweet, with a little bit of new content to keep the plot interesting.
┈ OVERVIEW ┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈
⛔️ Warning - possible spoilers below ⛔️
Pacing: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
Characters: ⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️/5
Overall:⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
Cover Art: ⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
Format: eBook
POV: Multi 👨👨👧
Would I Recommend? 👍
Read Again? 👎
Setting / Location: Lake Capel, North Carolina
TW:
Heroine/FMC: Josephine Meyer
〰️Characteristics: tan skin, dark cinnamon-brown/auburn hair, freckles, sharp blue eyes
〰️Occupation: College Student
〰️Age: 21
〰️Nickname(s): Joey, Joe, hot girl, Ohio, baby, siren, Jojo, mama, pretty girl
——————————————————
Hero/MMC: Decker Crusade
〰️Characteristics: hard set jaw, perfect lips, high cheekbones, tall, onyx black eyes
〰️Occupation: Student Athlete: Football - quarterback
〰️Age: ~21
〰️Nickname(s): Cap
First kiss💋: 62% (Book 2)
First time they have sex: 48% (Book 3)
First time they say "I Love You": h: 45%, H: 48% (Book 3)
——————————————————
Hero/MMC: Kylian Walsh
〰️Characteristics: glasses, lean/slim, sapphire colored eyes, hard muscles, abs, angular
〰️Occupation: College Student
〰️Age: ~21
〰️Nickname(s): Kyl
First kiss💋: 45% (Book 1)
First time they have sex: 70% (Book 2)
First time they say "I Love You": H: 79% (Book 2)
——————————————————
Hero/MMC: Nicholas “Locke” Lockwood
〰️Characteristics: huge, bulky tatted arms, brown hair, gauges in his ears, face piercings, emo appearance, brown eyes
〰️Occupation: Student Athlete: Football - Guard
〰️Age: ~21
〰️Nickname(s): Good boy, Nicky, emo boy
First kiss💋: 13% (Book 1)
First time they have sex: 90% (Book 1)
First time they say "I Love You": 88% (Book 2)
——————————————————
Hero/MMC: Kendrick Taylor
〰️Characteristics: huge, gorgeous, 230 lbs, massive arms, a tightly cropped fade, brown eyes
〰️Occupation: Student Athlete: Football - Running Back
〰️Age: ~21
〰️Nickname(s): K, sir
First kiss💋: 51% (Book 2)
First time they have sex: 52% (Book 2)
First time they say "I Love You": 7% (Book 3)
——————————————————
H/h virgin? No
Noteworthy Chapters🔥: N/A
Kinks: Praise, dirty talk, toys, SPRINKLES, edging/orgasm denial, no condom, 🍑 play, voyeurism, biting/marking, cum jammer, sub/Dom, pierced 🍆, spit, domination, hand necklace, hair-pulling
OW/OM Drama? No
H/h cheat? No
Time apart? No
Did I cry? No
Ending: HEA 🥰
Standalone/Series? Series
Epilogue? Yes
✦ Sports Romance
✦ College Football
✦ Reverse Harem/Why Choose?
✦ Millionaire Romance
✦ Forced Proximity
✦ Slow Burn
✦ MFMMM Romance (No ⚔️)
✦ Chronic Illness Representation
✦ Novella / Short Story
┈ MY THOUGHTS ┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈
- This is a short novella about their trip to the cabin to celebrate Valentine's and escape from the house and Hunter's cohort. It's a short, fast read and provides an interesting plot that isn't all bedroom scenes.
- Overall: This was short and sweet, with a little bit of new content to keep the plot interesting.
┈ OVERVIEW ┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈
⛔️ Warning - possible spoilers below ⛔️
Pacing: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
Characters: ⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️/5
Overall:⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
Cover Art: ⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
Format: eBook
POV: Multi 👨👨👧
Would I Recommend? 👍
Read Again? 👎
Setting / Location: Lake Capel, North Carolina
TW:
Heroine/FMC: Josephine Meyer
〰️Characteristics: tan skin, dark cinnamon-brown/auburn hair, freckles, sharp blue eyes
〰️Occupation: College Student
〰️Age: 21
〰️Nickname(s): Joey, Joe, hot girl, Ohio, baby, siren, Jojo, mama, pretty girl
——————————————————
Hero/MMC: Decker Crusade
〰️Characteristics: hard set jaw, perfect lips, high cheekbones, tall, onyx black eyes
〰️Occupation: Student Athlete: Football - quarterback
〰️Age: ~21
〰️Nickname(s): Cap
First kiss💋: 62% (Book 2)
First time they have sex: 48% (Book 3)
First time they say "I Love You": h: 45%, H: 48% (Book 3)
——————————————————
Hero/MMC: Kylian Walsh
〰️Characteristics: glasses, lean/slim, sapphire colored eyes, hard muscles, abs, angular
〰️Occupation: College Student
〰️Age: ~21
〰️Nickname(s): Kyl
First kiss💋: 45% (Book 1)
First time they have sex: 70% (Book 2)
First time they say "I Love You": H: 79% (Book 2)
——————————————————
Hero/MMC: Nicholas “Locke” Lockwood
〰️Characteristics: huge, bulky tatted arms, brown hair, gauges in his ears, face piercings, emo appearance, brown eyes
〰️Occupation: Student Athlete: Football - Guard
〰️Age: ~21
〰️Nickname(s): Good boy, Nicky, emo boy
First kiss💋: 13% (Book 1)
First time they have sex: 90% (Book 1)
First time they say "I Love You": 88% (Book 2)
——————————————————
Hero/MMC: Kendrick Taylor
〰️Characteristics: huge, gorgeous, 230 lbs, massive arms, a tightly cropped fade, brown eyes
〰️Occupation: Student Athlete: Football - Running Back
〰️Age: ~21
〰️Nickname(s): K, sir
First kiss💋: 51% (Book 2)
First time they have sex: 52% (Book 2)
First time they say "I Love You": 7% (Book 3)
——————————————————
H/h virgin? No
Noteworthy Chapters🔥: N/A
Kinks: Praise, dirty talk, toys, SPRINKLES, edging/orgasm denial, no condom, 🍑 play, voyeurism, biting/marking, cum jammer, sub/Dom, pierced 🍆, spit, domination, hand necklace, hair-pulling
OW/OM Drama? No
H/h cheat? No
Time apart? No
Did I cry? No
Ending: HEA 🥰
Standalone/Series? Series
Epilogue? Yes
May 31, 2025
📚Boys of Lake Chapel Series by Abby Millsaps📚
•Rate:⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
First of all, I just want to say sorry for being a bit late with this review—migraine days are no joke, and sometimes reading has to take a back seat. But now that I’ve finally finished the series, I have to talk about it because… wow. I’m officially hooked.
I’m genuinely so grateful I got the chance to read Boys of Lake Chapel. This series completely drew me. Every single character was written with such care and depth—they each brought something unique to the story. I loved seeing how they handled their own personal struggles, how they grew over time, and how their paths intertwined in ways that felt natural and meaningful.
Josephine, our main character, absolutely stole my heart. The chemistry between her and her love interests was perfection—intense, passionate, and full of tension I love. What really stood out to me was how each character had their own way of expressing love, pain, and loyalty. Their interactions with Josephine felt so authentic and layered, making the relationships in the story feel incredibly real.
The plot kept me invested from start to finish. It was the perfect mix of emotional depth, unexpected twists, and yes… the spice. The spicy scenes definitely delivered without overpowering the emotional journey of the characters. I laughed and teared up a few times.
I would definitely recommend this series.
•Rate:⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
First of all, I just want to say sorry for being a bit late with this review—migraine days are no joke, and sometimes reading has to take a back seat. But now that I’ve finally finished the series, I have to talk about it because… wow. I’m officially hooked.
I’m genuinely so grateful I got the chance to read Boys of Lake Chapel. This series completely drew me. Every single character was written with such care and depth—they each brought something unique to the story. I loved seeing how they handled their own personal struggles, how they grew over time, and how their paths intertwined in ways that felt natural and meaningful.
Josephine, our main character, absolutely stole my heart. The chemistry between her and her love interests was perfection—intense, passionate, and full of tension I love. What really stood out to me was how each character had their own way of expressing love, pain, and loyalty. Their interactions with Josephine felt so authentic and layered, making the relationships in the story feel incredibly real.
The plot kept me invested from start to finish. It was the perfect mix of emotional depth, unexpected twists, and yes… the spice. The spicy scenes definitely delivered without overpowering the emotional journey of the characters. I laughed and teared up a few times.
I would definitely recommend this series.
July 21, 2026
Unfortunately, this novella didn't change my feelings about the series. It's a quick, spicy read, but it mostly highlighted the same issues I had with the previous books. Joey's behavior surrounding her birthday really frustrated me. She repeatedly says she's worked through her trauma, but her actions tell a completely different story. Character growth is important to me, and I just didn't feel like I saw enough of it here.
I also continued to struggle with the relationship dynamics. Joey still very clearly favors Kylian, and that has bothered me throughout the entire series. I love why choose romances because I want to believe each relationship is equally meaningful, and I just never got that feeling here.
Another thing that really stood out to me was that Joey still doesn't say I love you back to some of the MMCs. That honestly made me sad for them and made the relationships feel even more unbalanced.
I also think this novella may fit better somewhere in the middle of the next connected series rather than being read as book four. There were several storylines that seemed to tie into those books, so the placement felt a little confusing.
Overall, this was a short, spicy novella, but it didn't add much for me. I was hoping it would strengthen the relationships and wrap up some lingering feelings I had after the trilogy, but instead it left me with many of the same frustrations.
I also continued to struggle with the relationship dynamics. Joey still very clearly favors Kylian, and that has bothered me throughout the entire series. I love why choose romances because I want to believe each relationship is equally meaningful, and I just never got that feeling here.
Another thing that really stood out to me was that Joey still doesn't say I love you back to some of the MMCs. That honestly made me sad for them and made the relationships feel even more unbalanced.
I also think this novella may fit better somewhere in the middle of the next connected series rather than being read as book four. There were several storylines that seemed to tie into those books, so the placement felt a little confusing.
Overall, this was a short, spicy novella, but it didn't add much for me. I was hoping it would strengthen the relationships and wrap up some lingering feelings I had after the trilogy, but instead it left me with many of the same frustrations.
February 15, 2025
I have been missing these boys something fierce and am thrilled to have more of them in my life!
Stats Daddy continues to be the daddiest and I love the depth and intensity of his love for Joey, and particularly the way that Joey recognizes and cherishes the gestures and intentional acts Kylian shows her that push his boundaries.
Nicky!! The big, softie Emo Boy continues to go full out for our girl and those moments where he shows the vulnerable broken boy are all the more intimate.
Kendrick, the man obsessed, is feral and possessive while simultaneously being a fantastic team player. What a dream to be showered in his affection.
And the final man of Joey’s cohort has had the hardest time adjusting to their arrangement and letting go of his control, but there is not an ounce of doubt that he loves this family with his whole chest and nothing is out of the question when it comes to protecting his people. I loved getting to see his tender moments and the safe haven for him and Joey to lean into their connection even more.
You’ll Find —
💖 Valentine’s Day at the Cabin
📈 834.6 Pounds of Sprinkles
🤳 Toys as Teammates
🤭 He Gets a Tattoo for Her
👅 Sunday Morning Traditions
🛥️ Decker Breaks his Boat Rule
Thankful as always for the opportunity to read more Boys of Lake Chapel!
Stats Daddy continues to be the daddiest and I love the depth and intensity of his love for Joey, and particularly the way that Joey recognizes and cherishes the gestures and intentional acts Kylian shows her that push his boundaries.
Nicky!! The big, softie Emo Boy continues to go full out for our girl and those moments where he shows the vulnerable broken boy are all the more intimate.
Kendrick, the man obsessed, is feral and possessive while simultaneously being a fantastic team player. What a dream to be showered in his affection.
And the final man of Joey’s cohort has had the hardest time adjusting to their arrangement and letting go of his control, but there is not an ounce of doubt that he loves this family with his whole chest and nothing is out of the question when it comes to protecting his people. I loved getting to see his tender moments and the safe haven for him and Joey to lean into their connection even more.
You’ll Find —
💖 Valentine’s Day at the Cabin
📈 834.6 Pounds of Sprinkles
🤳 Toys as Teammates
🤭 He Gets a Tattoo for Her
👅 Sunday Morning Traditions
🛥️ Decker Breaks his Boat Rule
Thankful as always for the opportunity to read more Boys of Lake Chapel!
March 9, 2025
Decker, Joey, Locke, Kylian & Kendrick
I just finished reading this adorable novella in the Boys Of Lake Chapel series, and I'm still grinning from ear to ear. This happy-ever-after story follows Josephine and her four guys - Decker, Locke, Kylian, and Kendrick - as they escape to a cabin for a Valentine's Day weekend getaway.
The novella starts off as a fun, relaxing weekend, but things take an awkward turn when the guys discover a secret Josephine's been keeping from them. However, since their relationships are solid, they're able to work through the issue together, and it's lovely to see their communication skills improve even more.
One of the highlights of this novella is the character growth, particularly with Decker and Josephine. After the traumatic events in the third book, it's wonderful to see how far they've come, both individually and together. Decker even gets to break one of his biggest rules, which leads to an excellent group scene!
I also appreciated the fact that we got to see scenes with each of the guys individually, as well as group scenes. It's clear that the author is dedicated to showcasing the unique bond between Josephine and each of her partners.
#BoysOfLakeChapel
#HappyEverAfter
#Novella
#Polyamory
#CharacterGrowth
#RelationshipGoals
#ValentinesDay
#BookLovers
#ReadingIsFun
#SeriesRecommendation
#MustRead
I just finished reading this adorable novella in the Boys Of Lake Chapel series, and I'm still grinning from ear to ear. This happy-ever-after story follows Josephine and her four guys - Decker, Locke, Kylian, and Kendrick - as they escape to a cabin for a Valentine's Day weekend getaway.
The novella starts off as a fun, relaxing weekend, but things take an awkward turn when the guys discover a secret Josephine's been keeping from them. However, since their relationships are solid, they're able to work through the issue together, and it's lovely to see their communication skills improve even more.
One of the highlights of this novella is the character growth, particularly with Decker and Josephine. After the traumatic events in the third book, it's wonderful to see how far they've come, both individually and together. Decker even gets to break one of his biggest rules, which leads to an excellent group scene!
I also appreciated the fact that we got to see scenes with each of the guys individually, as well as group scenes. It's clear that the author is dedicated to showcasing the unique bond between Josephine and each of her partners.
#BoysOfLakeChapel
#HappyEverAfter
#Novella
#Polyamory
#CharacterGrowth
#RelationshipGoals
#ValentinesDay
#BookLovers
#ReadingIsFun
#SeriesRecommendation
#MustRead
June 10, 2025
🚤 𝘽𝙤𝙮𝙨 𝙤𝙛 𝙇𝙖𝙠𝙚 𝘾𝙝𝙖𝙥𝙚𝙡: 𝙏𝙝𝙚 𝘾𝙤𝙢𝙥𝙡𝙚𝙩𝙚 𝙎𝙚𝙧𝙞𝙚𝙨 𝙗𝙮 𝘼𝙗𝙗𝙮 𝙈𝙞𝙡𝙡𝙨𝙖𝙥𝙨 🚤
Thank you @abbymillsaps and @valentine_pr_ for the opportunity to read and review this series 🖤 It's been a MINUTE since I've read anything where a character gives their vehicle a name. Immediate nostalgia kicked in and I basically fell in love with these books from that moment. But also it was when we met Alice and how all of the story seemed to stem from the promise she talked Josephine into keeping.
I'm not sure if there was a best part per se, because so much is going on. There's soap op vibes, not gonna lie. But there are also raw and vulnerable connections, found family, a strong and wilful FMC, and 4 very different MCs. Here's where I want to branch out and share the personalities of each MC..
➕️Kyl- techy, neurodivergent, calm in the storm
➕️Locke- buoyant, lighthearted, goofy, flirt
➕️Kendrick- unwavering, steadfast, dedicated
➕️Decker- commanding presence, respectful, caring
I loved getting to know each one of them and their quirks. For my first impression of Abby's work, these books set the bar high and I can't wait to dive into Hunter's story next!
Thank you @abbymillsaps and @valentine_pr_ for the opportunity to read and review this series 🖤 It's been a MINUTE since I've read anything where a character gives their vehicle a name. Immediate nostalgia kicked in and I basically fell in love with these books from that moment. But also it was when we met Alice and how all of the story seemed to stem from the promise she talked Josephine into keeping.
I'm not sure if there was a best part per se, because so much is going on. There's soap op vibes, not gonna lie. But there are also raw and vulnerable connections, found family, a strong and wilful FMC, and 4 very different MCs. Here's where I want to branch out and share the personalities of each MC..
➕️Kyl- techy, neurodivergent, calm in the storm
➕️Locke- buoyant, lighthearted, goofy, flirt
➕️Kendrick- unwavering, steadfast, dedicated
➕️Decker- commanding presence, respectful, caring
I loved getting to know each one of them and their quirks. For my first impression of Abby's work, these books set the bar high and I can't wait to dive into Hunter's story next!
February 19, 2025
I love the Boys of Lake Chapel
🩷 Too Sweet🩷 (Novella in the Boys of Lake Chapel series) by Abby Millsaps
𝐑𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐞𝐰:
🩷 I truly love this world. Every character, every moment, every piece of them is just elite to me.
🩷 I have been a sucker for Joey and her cohort since Book 1 - I loved them during their story and I truly loved them after when they made an appearance in Hunters story.
This truly was a breath of 🌶️ fresh air. You truly got to see each side of these men together and apart - with Joey 1 v 1 and all as a group.
🩷 You will fall more in love with Joey each time the page turns. You get to see her vulnerable but strong and truly this was everything.
🩷 These men truly show up and show out. It’s a why choose so you ain’t gotta choose - but if you’re a sucker for KYLIAN “STATS DADDY” WALSH like I am - you’re gonna squee the entire time he makes an appearance in this book.
🩷 The others are amazing just as much - will always be a lover of the Boys of South Chapel!
📖
🩷 Too Sweet🩷 (Novella in the Boys of Lake Chapel series) by Abby Millsaps
𝐑𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐞𝐰:
🩷 I truly love this world. Every character, every moment, every piece of them is just elite to me.
🩷 I have been a sucker for Joey and her cohort since Book 1 - I loved them during their story and I truly loved them after when they made an appearance in Hunters story.
This truly was a breath of 🌶️ fresh air. You truly got to see each side of these men together and apart - with Joey 1 v 1 and all as a group.
🩷 You will fall more in love with Joey each time the page turns. You get to see her vulnerable but strong and truly this was everything.
🩷 These men truly show up and show out. It’s a why choose so you ain’t gotta choose - but if you’re a sucker for KYLIAN “STATS DADDY” WALSH like I am - you’re gonna squee the entire time he makes an appearance in this book.
🩷 The others are amazing just as much - will always be a lover of the Boys of South Chapel!
📖
May 16, 2025
Im gonna miss this universe so much. Hunter and Jo will always have a special place in my heart as FMC’s. Greedy, Levi, Spencer, Sione, Kylian, Locke, Kendrick, and Decker. You all are my dream guys. And I love the way they treat their women with such love and care.
Greedy I didn’t really care for u at first but once u and Levi started going at it, I was very intrigued and u became a dinamic character.
Levi ur my favorite guy from ur series, No explanation needed.
Spencer ur giving rich baby daddy and im so here for it, I love the way u take care of Levi.
Sione ur alright, ur just an extra add on that I began to love.
Kylian u have to be my favorite guy I love u soooo muchhh bro, u and Levi have my heart.
Locke u were ok I love the idea of ur piercing tho.
Kendrick ur black, 230 pounds,and u call Jo mama what more do u have to say.
Decker ur just so good with ur big decker energy and why are u always scowling😭
Anyways thank u for being my comfort for a month, I’ll be back for more🤍
Greedy I didn’t really care for u at first but once u and Levi started going at it, I was very intrigued and u became a dinamic character.
Levi ur my favorite guy from ur series, No explanation needed.
Spencer ur giving rich baby daddy and im so here for it, I love the way u take care of Levi.
Sione ur alright, ur just an extra add on that I began to love.
Kylian u have to be my favorite guy I love u soooo muchhh bro, u and Levi have my heart.
Locke u were ok I love the idea of ur piercing tho.
Kendrick ur black, 230 pounds,and u call Jo mama what more do u have to say.
Decker ur just so good with ur big decker energy and why are u always scowling😭
Anyways thank u for being my comfort for a month, I’ll be back for more🤍
Displaying 1 - 30 of 120 reviews