I did not enjoy this book mainly due to the advice that leaned toward gentle parenting. I agree with most of the basic principles about not speaking harshly to your children. However, I raised my three children with an authoritative style (to be clear, not authoritarian) and all three of them now agree this was the best style. It set them apart from their peers who are generally more irresponsible, self-focused, and unmotivated, according to my young adult children’s descriptions.
One example from the book. She tells a story of her daughter throwing a fit because she wanted to swing while the author was speaking to adult friends. The author indulged her daughter’s request, then afterward, explained how she really shouldn’t whine to get what she wants.
By contrast, before these type of events, I would review with my young children the ground rules I expected them to follow outside the home. A couple repeated phrases I used with them were, “I don’t reward bad behavior” and “I can’t hear your requests when you speak in a whiny voice.” They now praise me for setting clear boundaries and expectations, and I have close, loving relationships with all of them.
Authoritative parenting is the style most supported by biblical principles, and that is why I used it. This is why I do not endorse the ideas in this book.