ISBN 006147357X - Any parent or player who's given up summer after summer for baseball, in any youth baseball program, not just Little League, is bound to recognize something of themselves and the players they've known in this book. That, alone, makes it an interesting read for that audience. The author's style of storytelling, unfortunately, doesn't seem likely to attract a wider readership.
Toms River's All Stars, having made their way to the Show in 1995, 1998 and 1999 with Mike Gaynor, have set a precedent for all the teams to come and the 2007 team, coached by John Puleo, is fired up and ready to follow in their footsteps - and return the title of Little League World Champs to their town. The book attempts to document all four teams' roads to Williamsport and fails to do any of the stories real justice.
Kreidler begins with a cliffhanger glimpse at the end of the story, such an over-used technique that it deserves an eyeroll. Had he then told a story in chronological order, the book would easily have overcome that, but he didn't. The story skips around from 2006 to 1995 to 1998 to 2007... over and over. It's disconcerting but perhaps intentional, to bolster the idea that Toms River is just cranking out the ballplayers.
While there's something to that, no fan of the game can fail to recognize that the successes of the town's Little League All-Star programs only happen under the guidance of specific coaches. This is no magical little town that's been sprinkled with MLB dust: it is clearly the hands of Gaynor and Puleo, two coaches almost a decade apart, that guide the boys to victory. Even that story would have made an interesting tale. As it is, Kreidler seems to buy into the improbable idea that Toms River itself is the single common denominator, seemingly determined to overlook the fact that, in hands other than Gaynor's or Puleo's, Toms River's All Star teams seem to be fairly average.
A surprising inability to give any of the players individual personalities, coupled with Kreidler's habit of starting a portion of the story in one decade and suddenly talking about another, has all the players periodically blending into a sort of generic "baseball kid" through much of the book. Another hundred pages and a little more detail would, perhaps, have turned out a more read-able, in depth, tale.
In all, an average book for the writing, a just-above average book for the story, Six Good Innings will appeal to fans and survivors of youth baseball, specifically, and less so to baseball fans in general.
- AnnaLovesBooks