For the sake of total transparency, I want to say, that I truly love Haiti and the Haitian people. I served two tours there in the US Embassy for a total of six years, ten years apart. The Haitian people are among the most noble, hard working and kind people in the world. That's why I wanted to read this book, and I really wanted to like the book. Isma's unique story has it all -- themes of resistance, resilience, class struggle, love, and the quest for justice, drawing readers into Haiti's rural countryside, the streets, the alleys of St. Louis du Nord and Port au Prince, all the struggles while highlighting its proud past and turbulent present (and undoubtedly its future.)
The descriptions of the rough life of rural Haiti was brilliantly portrayed, and the young man who is the main protagonist is really Haiti's everyman. His struggle for justice, and just to make a living and survive were poignantly described. The author is very passionate about the injustice and class struggles in Haiti and the blight of foreign influence. But the constant drone of Marxist dogma and doctrine as outlined by the heroic resistance fighters gets a bit overused.
Where I had an issue, and it was a big one, was suspending my sense of disbelief. Although, I found the military aspect quite fascinating, it was totally unbelievable. The Haitian Army/National Police do not have "divisions," do not have heavy artillery, rotary wing attack helicopters or scores of tanks. What the author was describing militarily was more akin to the scale of the war in Ukraine than in a potential revolution in Haiti.
Besides the struggle for survival and dignity, the best part of the book was the remarkable love story, touching and very well done. If you're looking for a singular, passionate, and unique piece of historical fiction set in the contemporary setting of strife torn Haiti, this is well worth your time.