What do you think?
Rate this book
Bumps in the Road #2
Down to a Science
A humorous and passionate journey to the person who defines “home” in Kat Paige's sophomore romcom, Down to a Science.
Rachel Moreau is Edinburgh’s newest resident. She has moved to Scotland with one specific goal: her Ph.D. in Marine Biodiversity. However, she instantly feels out of place and wonders if moving to a new country was a mistake. She doesn’t know a single soul in the city—until she meets Isla.
Isla Pyeon, tour guide, shop attendant, pub singer, and occasional dog walker, is the perfect person to introduce Rachel to her new home. She loves her city and knows it like the back of her hand, as well as many of the people in it. A sucker for a pretty face and always eager to lend a helping hand, Isla takes Rachel under her wing.
Following several accidental run-ins, the two spend an entire day exploring the city and getting to know one another. However, after this romantic day ends in disaster, Rachel and Isla have to reconstruct their short-lived entanglement as Rachel searches for grounding in her new home and Isla does everything she can to build a foundation for her aspirations. As they each find big and small ways to help the other, they discover that their friendship is meant to be much, much more.
Rachel Moreau is Edinburgh’s newest resident. She has moved to Scotland with one specific goal: her Ph.D. in Marine Biodiversity. However, she instantly feels out of place and wonders if moving to a new country was a mistake. She doesn’t know a single soul in the city—until she meets Isla.
Isla Pyeon, tour guide, shop attendant, pub singer, and occasional dog walker, is the perfect person to introduce Rachel to her new home. She loves her city and knows it like the back of her hand, as well as many of the people in it. A sucker for a pretty face and always eager to lend a helping hand, Isla takes Rachel under her wing.
Following several accidental run-ins, the two spend an entire day exploring the city and getting to know one another. However, after this romantic day ends in disaster, Rachel and Isla have to reconstruct their short-lived entanglement as Rachel searches for grounding in her new home and Isla does everything she can to build a foundation for her aspirations. As they each find big and small ways to help the other, they discover that their friendship is meant to be much, much more.
334 pages, Paperback
Published February 25, 2025
60 people are currently reading
992 people want to read
About the author
Kat Paige
4 books37 followersKat Paige is a writer of romance books with humor, heart, and a touch of spice. Originally a native of St. Louis, MO, she now lives in New York with one roommate who is more like family and an abundance of personified succulents. When not writing, she’s probably reading, baking, going to Broadway musicals, or watching TV shows she will inevitably get too emotionally invested in.
You can find Kat on Instagram, Threads, and TikTok under @katpaigeauthor
You can find Kat on Instagram, Threads, and TikTok under @katpaigeauthor
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 65 reviews
Read
January 24, 2025Hi readers, I'm writing this the day before ARCs go out just to say I hope you all enjoy this book as much as I enjoyed writing it. It's been a bit of a rough year, so writing this book really helped me get through it. I hope it gives you even a fraction of the joy it gave to me.
May 22, 2025
“Down to a Science" was an incredibly sweet read. The story about Rachel, who has just moved to Edinburgh to do her PhD, and Isla, an all-rounder, was very captivating. I was blown away by the first day they spend together. This lightness, tenderness, the pleasant tingling in my stomach. The ups and downs of the story really drove me crazy at times but at the same time the build-up of tension was soooo good. Both women were so authentic; they had scars and rough edges that made them so endearing. This extreme longing for each other was so delicious. Even though I'm not the most patient person, I enjoyed it so much. Rachel was definitely very special and it was so lovely to read how Isla managed to make Rachel feel safe and comfortable with her in such a short space of time.
I've always wanted to visit Scotland and after this book I want it even more! Edinburgh sounds so great; the places Rachel and Isla had visited sound incredible. I also loved it so much that the story was actually very focused on the two of them. Yes, there were friends, like Piper, David or Isla's brother Ben. But it was just so nice to read so much about Rachel and Isla and not have the side characters take up too much space.
Oh and can someone please sing Isla's song??? I would love to hear it!!!
A great, heartwarming and cozy book that really touched me. Paired with some spice a nice mix for this romance.
I've always wanted to visit Scotland and after this book I want it even more! Edinburgh sounds so great; the places Rachel and Isla had visited sound incredible. I also loved it so much that the story was actually very focused on the two of them. Yes, there were friends, like Piper, David or Isla's brother Ben. But it was just so nice to read so much about Rachel and Isla and not have the side characters take up too much space.
Oh and can someone please sing Isla's song??? I would love to hear it!!!
A great, heartwarming and cozy book that really touched me. Paired with some spice a nice mix for this romance.
November 20, 2025
Down to a Science by Kat Paige is what I would call romcom adjacent. It has the vibes and the references but not enough laughs to call the comedy part quite accurate. It started off slow for me, a bit awkward even, but around 25%, I feel like it got in a good rhythm, and I became more invested. The dual perspective was nice, and I liked the insight into Isla's trauma. I have more patience for miscommunications based on trauma response rather than a clear lack of communication.
I think Rachel is neurodiverse, and I liked how she communicated her needs and set boundaries. Isla has anxiety and panic attacks and that is addressed with healthy coping mechanisms. I think her mother is a narcissist.
The job/career experiences/paths add another layer of interest to their story. I was fascinated with the science talk about microplastics, and I melted for Isla as the musician. I love how they both had big goals and did not get derailed.
I also enjoyed the complex supporting cast who made a great found family unit.
There were tender moments and spicy scenes. The friendship was lovely, but it was always a bit more.
One of my very favorite things about the writing style was the setting descriptions. They were just beautiful! I also appreciated the romcom gestures.
The thing I found most unbelievable about the story was that a couple of lesbians wait two years to move in together. Haha.
Overall, I am glad I read through to the end because it was rewarding. It is a very layered story, and I recommend it.
#HEA #oppositesattract #PhD #tourguide #musician #cafe #businessowner #student #foundfamily #birep #neurodivergent #trauma #anxiety #mentalhealthrep #panicattacks #friendstolovers #Edinbugh #Scotland #romcomvibes #sweetandspicy #marinebiodiversity
I received this ARC from the author. This is my honest opinion.
I think Rachel is neurodiverse, and I liked how she communicated her needs and set boundaries. Isla has anxiety and panic attacks and that is addressed with healthy coping mechanisms. I think her mother is a narcissist.
The job/career experiences/paths add another layer of interest to their story. I was fascinated with the science talk about microplastics, and I melted for Isla as the musician. I love how they both had big goals and did not get derailed.
I also enjoyed the complex supporting cast who made a great found family unit.
There were tender moments and spicy scenes. The friendship was lovely, but it was always a bit more.
One of my very favorite things about the writing style was the setting descriptions. They were just beautiful! I also appreciated the romcom gestures.
The thing I found most unbelievable about the story was that a couple of lesbians wait two years to move in together. Haha.
Overall, I am glad I read through to the end because it was rewarding. It is a very layered story, and I recommend it.
#HEA #oppositesattract #PhD #tourguide #musician #cafe #businessowner #student #foundfamily #birep #neurodivergent #trauma #anxiety #mentalhealthrep #panicattacks #friendstolovers #Edinbugh #Scotland #romcomvibes #sweetandspicy #marinebiodiversity
I received this ARC from the author. This is my honest opinion.
April 22, 2025
This was SO PRECIOUS I LOVED IT AHHH!! Rachel and Isla are so sickeningly sweet together. And where can I find my own Isla? 😤
Also, that’s two for two for sapphic romances entitled “Down to a Science.” 🧪 This title must bring good energy.
Also, that’s two for two for sapphic romances entitled “Down to a Science.” 🧪 This title must bring good energy.
March 17, 2025
Rachel has just moved to Edinburgh from the US for her three years of doctorate study in Marine Biodiversity, where she is specifically studying microplastics in the environment and their effects on wildlife. Her brother Nick and her best friend Piper helped her move, but she hopes to make friends in Edinburgh soon. Rachel is a person who doesn’t make friends easily, finding it hard to talk to people.
Isla moved to Edinburgh for university from rural Scotland and never moved back home, loving the vibrancy of the historical city. She is a lively and outgoing person, and spends her time making money in a variety of ways; as an official tour guide, working in a local music shop, playing gigs in local pubs, and even painting and decorating when necessary. After past traumas she finds it difficult to believe people really want to be her friend or more, and when in a serious situation she sometimes runs away.
This story is really great, it grew on me the more I read. I found the beginning was a bit weak with no hook to keep me interested, but getting much better throughout, and the attention to detail about Edinburgh and its history is fantastic. I really liked the way the fears and insecurities of both women were shown; from Isla’s panics to Rachel’s tendency to overthink her feelings.
And now a comment on the author’s acknowledgements section as she seems to have impostors’ syndrome 😀: I really enjoyed this sweet story. Some of the Americanness came through in the writing, but most was put very well; where we were in an Isla chapter, for example, her voice was in Scottish English (or general British English) and then the reply from Rachel was in American English, such as in the names of clothing. And the song that the author wasn’t sure about that Isla wrote, I think this came across perfectly as a gentle and sweet love song.
Isla moved to Edinburgh for university from rural Scotland and never moved back home, loving the vibrancy of the historical city. She is a lively and outgoing person, and spends her time making money in a variety of ways; as an official tour guide, working in a local music shop, playing gigs in local pubs, and even painting and decorating when necessary. After past traumas she finds it difficult to believe people really want to be her friend or more, and when in a serious situation she sometimes runs away.
This story is really great, it grew on me the more I read. I found the beginning was a bit weak with no hook to keep me interested, but getting much better throughout, and the attention to detail about Edinburgh and its history is fantastic. I really liked the way the fears and insecurities of both women were shown; from Isla’s panics to Rachel’s tendency to overthink her feelings.
And now a comment on the author’s acknowledgements section as she seems to have impostors’ syndrome 😀: I really enjoyed this sweet story. Some of the Americanness came through in the writing, but most was put very well; where we were in an Isla chapter, for example, her voice was in Scottish English (or general British English) and then the reply from Rachel was in American English, such as in the names of clothing. And the song that the author wasn’t sure about that Isla wrote, I think this came across perfectly as a gentle and sweet love song.
January 28, 2025
ARC Review - Release Date: 25th February 2025!
You’ll enjoy this if you like:
- Friends to Lovers
- Found Family
- Bi x Lesbian
- RomCom Vibes
- Mental Health Rep
- Dual POV
- Opposites Attract
- 🌶️🌶️🌶️
📚
Rachel is a PhD student in Marine Biodiversity who has moved from the US to study in Edinburgh, Scotland. There, she meets Isla, an eccentric and professional “odd-jobber.” After a series of accidental run-ins, Isla offers Rachel a private tour of the city. They share an incredibly romantic day and evening together, but a disastrous misunderstanding threatens to extinguish the sparks.
Eventually, the two smooth things over and agree to proceed as “just friends”… 👀
💭
First and foremost—Isla, I love you. 🫶
Now that that’s out of the way…
This book is such a fun and heartwarming journey. I loved the witty banter, the charming Scottish setting, and all the fluffy romance. While I’m not usually a fan of the miscommunication trope, I think it was handled so well here. It wasn’t drawn out, and it added genuine value to the story.
I also really appreciated how the characters set clear boundaries and stuck to them, which felt especially important in a story with strong mental health representation. There’s some great personal growth woven in as well—ya girl loves character development.
One thing that hooked me early on was how immersive the story felt. I’ve never been to Scotland, but this book gave me a taste of it. I don’t know much about marine biodiversity, but I came away feeling like I’d learned something. It’s clear the author put a lot of research into this, and it paid off!
The writing flows beautifully, keeping you captivated and engaged. Honestly, I already want more from this world!
Also, the spice is spicing. 🤭
You’ll enjoy this if you like:
- Friends to Lovers
- Found Family
- Bi x Lesbian
- RomCom Vibes
- Mental Health Rep
- Dual POV
- Opposites Attract
- 🌶️🌶️🌶️
📚
Rachel is a PhD student in Marine Biodiversity who has moved from the US to study in Edinburgh, Scotland. There, she meets Isla, an eccentric and professional “odd-jobber.” After a series of accidental run-ins, Isla offers Rachel a private tour of the city. They share an incredibly romantic day and evening together, but a disastrous misunderstanding threatens to extinguish the sparks.
Eventually, the two smooth things over and agree to proceed as “just friends”… 👀
💭
First and foremost—Isla, I love you. 🫶
Now that that’s out of the way…
This book is such a fun and heartwarming journey. I loved the witty banter, the charming Scottish setting, and all the fluffy romance. While I’m not usually a fan of the miscommunication trope, I think it was handled so well here. It wasn’t drawn out, and it added genuine value to the story.
I also really appreciated how the characters set clear boundaries and stuck to them, which felt especially important in a story with strong mental health representation. There’s some great personal growth woven in as well—ya girl loves character development.
One thing that hooked me early on was how immersive the story felt. I’ve never been to Scotland, but this book gave me a taste of it. I don’t know much about marine biodiversity, but I came away feeling like I’d learned something. It’s clear the author put a lot of research into this, and it paid off!
The writing flows beautifully, keeping you captivated and engaged. Honestly, I already want more from this world!
Also, the spice is spicing. 🤭
February 20, 2025
I… finished Down to a Science so fast. I loved that Rachel and Isla kept running into each other at first. It felt very much like ✨fate✨. And then to go on basically a day long not-a-date-but-definitely-a-date?
How sapphic of them! And getting tattoos on the non-a-date?? Felt like a whole stereotype in the best way possible.
But alas, there must be conflict. I love how the story pivoted to a friendship… of course that doesn’t mean the veryyy obvious chemistry doesn’t go away. I loved how much effort Isla put in to being there for Rachel though. There were so many sweet, meaningful moments between them leading up to well… this is a spicy romance after all.
I think the relationship and character development worked really well together. I was really rooting for Rachel and Isla! They each have their own issues that, to some extent, need to get sorted out for their relationship to work. I think it worked out wonderfully.
Another aspect I really enjoyed was the nonbinary side character rep. I loved that they just… were. Their identity and pronouns were not a big deal. They were just a part of the story like anyone else. I loved when books do this as it feels so natural and how society should.
I have no major complaints about the book. I think the only thing keeping it from 5 stars was I didn’t get that wow factor. Seeing as this is only Kat Paige’s second book, I suspect that may come with time, and I’m going to keep a look out for more book by her in the future.
I’d like to thank the author, Kat Paige, for providing me with an ARC. All opinions are my own, and I’ve left this review of my own volition (yay! sapphics in stem!)
I’ll have to edit the additional book details in at a later date as I don’t have my reading journal with me currently~
How sapphic of them! And getting tattoos on the non-a-date?? Felt like a whole stereotype in the best way possible.
But alas, there must be conflict. I love how the story pivoted to a friendship… of course that doesn’t mean the veryyy obvious chemistry doesn’t go away. I loved how much effort Isla put in to being there for Rachel though. There were so many sweet, meaningful moments between them leading up to well… this is a spicy romance after all.
I think the relationship and character development worked really well together. I was really rooting for Rachel and Isla! They each have their own issues that, to some extent, need to get sorted out for their relationship to work. I think it worked out wonderfully.
Another aspect I really enjoyed was the nonbinary side character rep. I loved that they just… were. Their identity and pronouns were not a big deal. They were just a part of the story like anyone else. I loved when books do this as it feels so natural and how society should.
I have no major complaints about the book. I think the only thing keeping it from 5 stars was I didn’t get that wow factor. Seeing as this is only Kat Paige’s second book, I suspect that may come with time, and I’m going to keep a look out for more book by her in the future.
I’d like to thank the author, Kat Paige, for providing me with an ARC. All opinions are my own, and I’ve left this review of my own volition (yay! sapphics in stem!)
I’ll have to edit the additional book details in at a later date as I don’t have my reading journal with me currently~
February 25, 2025
Actual rating 4.5 stars
There is a second book but worked great as a standalone and touched on the story of the MCs in book one so you don't miss out.
Such a wholesome read with a beautiful setting in Scotland! Loved watching Isla and Rachel's connection blossom, enjoyed the secondary characters and was hooked from the first page so read this super quickly!
My favourite part was Isla's song 😭❤️ I also enjoyed the exploration of past hurt, anxiety and complicated family relationships. My neurodivergent ass related to Rachel though this wasn't touched on explicitly I found she was my favourite character.
Really recommend this sweet Scottish romance and would love to read more sapphic stories by this author in the future 😁
ARC copy received in exchange for an honest review
There is a second book but worked great as a standalone and touched on the story of the MCs in book one so you don't miss out.
Such a wholesome read with a beautiful setting in Scotland! Loved watching Isla and Rachel's connection blossom, enjoyed the secondary characters and was hooked from the first page so read this super quickly!
My favourite part was Isla's song 😭❤️ I also enjoyed the exploration of past hurt, anxiety and complicated family relationships. My neurodivergent ass related to Rachel though this wasn't touched on explicitly I found she was my favourite character.
Really recommend this sweet Scottish romance and would love to read more sapphic stories by this author in the future 😁
ARC copy received in exchange for an honest review
February 27, 2025
"Down to a Science" is a heartwarming romance set in the beautiful city of Edinburgh.
Rachel, a PhD student, has moved across the world to pursue her studies there. She keeps running into Isla, who begins showing her around the city. While the story starts off a bit rocky with immediate miscommunication between the characters, the author provides excellent insight into how and why this conflict develops—and though miscommunication isn't most peoples favorite trope, I think it works well here.
The setting was incredibly beautiful and charming—having visited Edinburgh only a handful of times myself, I could still recognize many of the places mentioned throughout the book. The mental health representation was thoughtfully done, and I particularly appreciated how Rachel and Isla openly discussed their needs and boundaries in various situations.
I'm slowly warming up to the friends-to-lovers trope, and despite Rachel and Isla starting as strangers, their developing friendship felt wonderfully authentic. I loved watching them get to know each other. For me the pacing dipped slightly in the middle but this was an engaging read overall. The romantic scenes were well-crafted, and though they came later in the story, this timing felt natural given how their relationship developed. And Isla's song—what a magical moment!
Thank you so much to the author for an eARC of this book.
Rachel, a PhD student, has moved across the world to pursue her studies there. She keeps running into Isla, who begins showing her around the city. While the story starts off a bit rocky with immediate miscommunication between the characters, the author provides excellent insight into how and why this conflict develops—and though miscommunication isn't most peoples favorite trope, I think it works well here.
The setting was incredibly beautiful and charming—having visited Edinburgh only a handful of times myself, I could still recognize many of the places mentioned throughout the book. The mental health representation was thoughtfully done, and I particularly appreciated how Rachel and Isla openly discussed their needs and boundaries in various situations.
I'm slowly warming up to the friends-to-lovers trope, and despite Rachel and Isla starting as strangers, their developing friendship felt wonderfully authentic. I loved watching them get to know each other. For me the pacing dipped slightly in the middle but this was an engaging read overall. The romantic scenes were well-crafted, and though they came later in the story, this timing felt natural given how their relationship developed. And Isla's song—what a magical moment!
Thank you so much to the author for an eARC of this book.
June 21, 2025
3/5 - sapphic, contemporary
Spoiler-free:
Cute premise, and I’m a sucker for science-y romances, but I didn’t love one of the MCs (Rachel). I really liked the parts focusing on her research, but actually wish we got to see more of her in the academia setting and in the meat of her program. That aside, I found Rachel’s personality a bit frustrating at times, especially as the book progressed. Isla was great though, as well as some of our side characters (David and Ben in particular).
Spoilers:
I’m generally not a fan of third act conflicts, especially when they pop up 86% through the story, but ofc many books are still able to pull off a satisfying conclusion. In the case here, the conflict seemed unnecessary, especially seeing how it was already resolved 2% later and suddenly the couple is better off than ever before! Just felt like there were other ways to do this, and it soured me further on Rachel.
My other nitpick is that I hate the ending between Isla and her mother—I’m sick of toxic family members suddenly doing 180s and realizing their faults out of the blue, especially after years and years of toxicity. I just don’t buy it and it feels way too convenient.
Overall: sweet, but fell flat for me.
Spoiler-free:
Cute premise, and I’m a sucker for science-y romances, but I didn’t love one of the MCs (Rachel). I really liked the parts focusing on her research, but actually wish we got to see more of her in the academia setting and in the meat of her program. That aside, I found Rachel’s personality a bit frustrating at times, especially as the book progressed. Isla was great though, as well as some of our side characters (David and Ben in particular).
Spoilers:
I’m generally not a fan of third act conflicts, especially when they pop up 86% through the story, but ofc many books are still able to pull off a satisfying conclusion. In the case here, the conflict seemed unnecessary, especially seeing how it was already resolved 2% later and suddenly the couple is better off than ever before! Just felt like there were other ways to do this, and it soured me further on Rachel.
My other nitpick is that I hate the ending between Isla and her mother—I’m sick of toxic family members suddenly doing 180s and realizing their faults out of the blue, especially after years and years of toxicity. I just don’t buy it and it feels way too convenient.
Overall: sweet, but fell flat for me.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 9, 2025
How could I resist reading this book when the main character is marine biologist studying microplastics?!? This book originally caught my eye solely because of the field the main character was in. The main character, Rachel, is a phd student in marine biodiversity studying microplastics in microorganisms at a school in Edinburgh. This school was Rachel second choice school because she didn’t get into her top choice. Her top choice school just so happens to be a school in New Zealand that I have been doing a ton of research into applying to myself. The other main character is actually a local and has made it her mission to be Rachel’s personal tour guide. This was a cute, easy read. I am pretty invested in all the side characters as well now and will definitely have to read the next book which will inevitably be about Ben.
June 8, 2025
Wahhhhhh I loved this book! I got this book as an eARC, but then school became intense so I didn’t get to finish before the release. As a sapphic marine biology person who falls in love with anyone I see sing on a stage, I immediately knew I had to read this book. I got 60% of the way through before I had to focus on school, and recently I finished the remaining 40%. The book was very cute and made me happy to read, and once I got to the last 20% I couldn’t put it down if I tried!!! All of the characters were lovable, and I loved the representation in rachel for people who aren’t big on physical touch.
Anyway, if there was one thing that bothered me enough to mention, it would be that they did NOT follow lab safety protocols lol.
Anyway, if there was one thing that bothered me enough to mention, it would be that they did NOT follow lab safety protocols lol.
March 1, 2025
3.75 ⭐
Before I begin I want to thank the author, Kat Paige, for giving me this ARC.
I really liked reading this. It was a cute, Scottish, sapphic, and fast read. I could not put it down. I liked the characters and the way they were written. I did have a feeling of repetitiveness sometimes. The plot was a bit too yes no yes no, if you know what I mean.
Before I begin I want to thank the author, Kat Paige, for giving me this ARC.
I really liked reading this. It was a cute, Scottish, sapphic, and fast read. I could not put it down. I liked the characters and the way they were written. I did have a feeling of repetitiveness sometimes. The plot was a bit too yes no yes no, if you know what I mean.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
April 15, 2025
This was so so good 😭
March 6, 2025
ARC review
I absolutely loved this book. It was slow burn, had pretty accurate mental health rep, classic lesbian stereotypes like going on a day long first date. It was a slow burn romance but not in an annoying way, in a hopeful way. I usually hate slow burn because it feels like it’s dragging on but this book was not like that at all.
The spice was written well and it wasn’t too overly spicy, this book had an actual plot.
I absolutely loved this book. It was slow burn, had pretty accurate mental health rep, classic lesbian stereotypes like going on a day long first date. It was a slow burn romance but not in an annoying way, in a hopeful way. I usually hate slow burn because it feels like it’s dragging on but this book was not like that at all.
The spice was written well and it wasn’t too overly spicy, this book had an actual plot.
March 24, 2025
I think I’m in love with both main characters
June 20, 2025
Down to a Science was honestly such a sweet and heartwarming read. It struck a nice balance between humor and emotional depth, and I flew through it because it was just so relaxing and enjoyable.
Both Rachel and Isla had real depth and personality, and their choices felt grounded in their individual experiences and past traumas. Their emotional journeys made sense and added weight to the story. Their decisions and action felt like it was aligned with their personality.
That said, while the spotlight was mostly on the main characters, can we talk about Ben? What’s up with that dude? Did anyone actually understand him? I couldn’t make sense of his actions…especially that one scene on the side road. I just didn’t think there was any closer around the argument with his friend either.
But anyways.. hello Edinburgh! The way it was described made it sound absolutely magical. It was never really on my radar, but after reading this and then looking up some photos, it’s officially on my bucket list. Scotland, here I come!
As someone who reads a fair bit of smut—admittedly—I’d say this one is a 2/5 on the steam scale. It leans more into emotional connection and slow-burn love than spice. So if you’re into rom-coms that focus on heartfelt romance, this one might just hit the spot.
Both Rachel and Isla had real depth and personality, and their choices felt grounded in their individual experiences and past traumas. Their emotional journeys made sense and added weight to the story. Their decisions and action felt like it was aligned with their personality.
That said, while the spotlight was mostly on the main characters, can we talk about Ben? What’s up with that dude? Did anyone actually understand him? I couldn’t make sense of his actions…especially that one scene on the side road. I just didn’t think there was any closer around the argument with his friend either.
But anyways.. hello Edinburgh! The way it was described made it sound absolutely magical. It was never really on my radar, but after reading this and then looking up some photos, it’s officially on my bucket list. Scotland, here I come!
As someone who reads a fair bit of smut—admittedly—I’d say this one is a 2/5 on the steam scale. It leans more into emotional connection and slow-burn love than spice. So if you’re into rom-coms that focus on heartfelt romance, this one might just hit the spot.
February 6, 2025
🌟Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫
💧Drip-o-Meter: 💦💦💧
💗Something I Loved: Isla and Rachel had great chemistry but what I really loved was how much work Isla in particular I put into being friends with Rachel. After a perfect meeting that ended with hurt feelings, Rachel had no interest whatsoever in forgiving Isla. Still Isla recognized the unique connection they had and persisted, while always respecting Rachel’s boundaries, until they truly developed a beautiful friendship and learned to trust each other (and their own feelings). Basically, the grovel was real and I loved how she put in the work.
🫤Something I Would Have Changed: Nothing with the book and everything with my brain. Ok, so maybe not everything but I do wish I was able to see images in my brain in order to be able to fully appreciate the descriptive imagery Kat is clearly so good at. I know without a doubt that some of those scenes were utterly gorgeous (I mean a fairy bridge in Scotland… hello) so my only complaint is that I personally can’t envision it. 😞
🥰Favorite Moment: Rachel’s grand gesture. Isla put in so much work to be Rachel’s “friend” and make up for those initial mishaps that it was nice to see Rachel step up and make such a gesture when she realizes she too had something to make up for.
🌶️Spiciest Scene: There’s spice in chapters 6, 16, 17, 22, and 26 but my personal fave was chapter 17… when Isla, the “Scottish Goddess”, teaches Rachel how to be “good” at orgasms. Close second is chapter 22 when they break in Rachel’s new table. None of the spice was overly graphic but was definitely open-door.
📚Standalone vs. Series: The second book in Kat’s #BumpsintheRoad series. You could absolutely read them as standalones but I personally found it more enjoyable when read back to back (especially since there are several callbacks to BITR and multiple appearances by Piper and Nick in DTAS).
📖Would I Recommend: I would. It was an easy read (in a positive way… I got sucked in fast) and the characters are completely lovable, flaws and all. I really hope to see more from this group of friends (manifesting a David/Ben romance) and more from Kat in general in the future.
💬Tropes: Sapphic (Lesbian x Bisexual), Friends (in Denial) to Lovers, Opposites Attract, Found Family, Dual POV
💧Drip-o-Meter: 💦💦💧
💗Something I Loved: Isla and Rachel had great chemistry but what I really loved was how much work Isla in particular I put into being friends with Rachel. After a perfect meeting that ended with hurt feelings, Rachel had no interest whatsoever in forgiving Isla. Still Isla recognized the unique connection they had and persisted, while always respecting Rachel’s boundaries, until they truly developed a beautiful friendship and learned to trust each other (and their own feelings). Basically, the grovel was real and I loved how she put in the work.
🫤Something I Would Have Changed: Nothing with the book and everything with my brain. Ok, so maybe not everything but I do wish I was able to see images in my brain in order to be able to fully appreciate the descriptive imagery Kat is clearly so good at. I know without a doubt that some of those scenes were utterly gorgeous (I mean a fairy bridge in Scotland… hello) so my only complaint is that I personally can’t envision it. 😞
🥰Favorite Moment: Rachel’s grand gesture. Isla put in so much work to be Rachel’s “friend” and make up for those initial mishaps that it was nice to see Rachel step up and make such a gesture when she realizes she too had something to make up for.
🌶️Spiciest Scene: There’s spice in chapters 6, 16, 17, 22, and 26 but my personal fave was chapter 17… when Isla, the “Scottish Goddess”, teaches Rachel how to be “good” at orgasms. Close second is chapter 22 when they break in Rachel’s new table. None of the spice was overly graphic but was definitely open-door.
📚Standalone vs. Series: The second book in Kat’s #BumpsintheRoad series. You could absolutely read them as standalones but I personally found it more enjoyable when read back to back (especially since there are several callbacks to BITR and multiple appearances by Piper and Nick in DTAS).
📖Would I Recommend: I would. It was an easy read (in a positive way… I got sucked in fast) and the characters are completely lovable, flaws and all. I really hope to see more from this group of friends (manifesting a David/Ben romance) and more from Kat in general in the future.
💬Tropes: Sapphic (Lesbian x Bisexual), Friends (in Denial) to Lovers, Opposites Attract, Found Family, Dual POV
February 17, 2025
'Down to a Science' is a sapphic romance whose main characters are Rachel, a PhD student from the US, and Isla, a Scot who has various jobs including tour guide whilst dreaming of setting up her own cafe, with the story taking place in and around Edinburgh where Isla lives and Rachel has started studying.
The book is brilliant! The characters of Rachel and Isla are beautifully written and their different facets and motivations - the anxiety and lack of confidence that afflicts Rachel, the past emotional scarring that continues to impact Isla - are drawn with an authenticity that totally immerses you in the story.
Kat Paige has done an incredible job in bringing these two to life as well as crafting the supporting characters and the world in which they live! The story is enthralling, drawing you in and immersing you in the thoughts and actions of the two principals, to the point where the pain and hurt they both felt when they fought was so believably described I did fear they wouldn't be able to come back from it! I want to gushingly enthuse about all the details, twists and turns in the book but equally don't want to reveal all the plot instead of letting you enjoy reading it yourself
Down to a Science is a wonderfully enjoyable, and gripping read, incredibly well written and with great characters and a lovely storyline; I read it twice, back to back, and can thoroughly recommend it - its brilliant and well worth a read of it yourself!
(This review is based on an ARC copy of the book)
The book is brilliant! The characters of Rachel and Isla are beautifully written and their different facets and motivations - the anxiety and lack of confidence that afflicts Rachel, the past emotional scarring that continues to impact Isla - are drawn with an authenticity that totally immerses you in the story.
Kat Paige has done an incredible job in bringing these two to life as well as crafting the supporting characters and the world in which they live! The story is enthralling, drawing you in and immersing you in the thoughts and actions of the two principals, to the point where the pain and hurt they both felt when they fought was so believably described I did fear they wouldn't be able to come back from it! I want to gushingly enthuse about all the details, twists and turns in the book but equally don't want to reveal all the plot instead of letting you enjoy reading it yourself
Down to a Science is a wonderfully enjoyable, and gripping read, incredibly well written and with great characters and a lovely storyline; I read it twice, back to back, and can thoroughly recommend it - its brilliant and well worth a read of it yourself!
(This review is based on an ARC copy of the book)
February 11, 2025
Disclaimer: I was very kindly given this eARC by the author in exchange for my honest review.
First of all, I’d just like to state that I am now a HUGE Kat Paige fan. From the storytelling, to the Scottish setting and incredible worldbuilding, to the mental health representation (which so many other authors get wrong).
While this can definitely be read as a standalone, there are so many spiderweb links back to Bumps In The Road that I 100% recommend reading that one first, so that you fully immerse yourself in this story.
The setting: perfection
The characters: LOVE THEM (everyone needs a David in their lives)
The writing: I really appreciate Kat Paige for how she deals with mental health (specifically anxiety and touch-sensitivity, which you don’t often see being explored), boundaries and miscommunication between our main characters. Some of my favourite quotes (SPOILER ALERT):
First of all, I’d just like to state that I am now a HUGE Kat Paige fan. From the storytelling, to the Scottish setting and incredible worldbuilding, to the mental health representation (which so many other authors get wrong).
While this can definitely be read as a standalone, there are so many spiderweb links back to Bumps In The Road that I 100% recommend reading that one first, so that you fully immerse yourself in this story.
The setting: perfection
The characters: LOVE THEM (everyone needs a David in their lives)
The writing: I really appreciate Kat Paige for how she deals with mental health (specifically anxiety and touch-sensitivity, which you don’t often see being explored), boundaries and miscommunication between our main characters. Some of my favourite quotes (SPOILER ALERT):
February 20, 2025
Thank you Kat Paige for this ARC. I ABSOLUTELY loved this book. I could not put it down and had it finished in a day. The writing was executed so well. All you could do was root for Isla and Rachel. This was the classic friends to lovers but a little more almost lovers to friends to lovers. We have one MFC Isla who is outgoing, a social butterfly but scared to commit when things are serious. Then we have our other MFC Rachel who is more reserved, an academic and tries to take every possible opportunity. They are different in so many ways but bring out the best in each other, all you can do throughout the book is root for them. It is a back and forth battle of will they be together or not. You get sucked right in by the writing and will fall in love with the characters as well as the supporting characters (Piper, Nick, David Josie and Ben). This is definitely in my top 5 favourite Sapphic books. You will laugh, you will be surprised, you will feel the heart break and the joy. 10/10 must read. Plus props to the mention of an under rated movie, that happens to be one of my favourites "Imagine me and you".
February 22, 2025
ARC Review:
This was a sweet Sapphic love story that explored the themes of finding home in unexpected places, mental health, and biphobia. Rachel moves to Scotland to get her PhD and meets Isla, a local who she is immediately attracted to. Unfortunately, each of them has some baggage to work through before they can actually be together.
The first 20% or so of this book was a bit slow, but once we got into the full cast of Rachel, Isla, and the people around them, I was hooked. There's plenty of Scottish tourism, which I was hoping for from a book about moving there for the first time, and the relationship took its time in developing from friends to lovers. I would have liked the physical relationship to move a little slower, personally, but it didn't ruin the book for me. Overall, had a really nice time with this one!
On a personal note, I found it hilarious how Rachel was frustrated she hadn't found her footing in Edinburgh after a week or so. Whenever I've moved to a new city, it's often taken me at least a few months to feel comfortable there, and often more to feel truly at home.
This was a sweet Sapphic love story that explored the themes of finding home in unexpected places, mental health, and biphobia. Rachel moves to Scotland to get her PhD and meets Isla, a local who she is immediately attracted to. Unfortunately, each of them has some baggage to work through before they can actually be together.
The first 20% or so of this book was a bit slow, but once we got into the full cast of Rachel, Isla, and the people around them, I was hooked. There's plenty of Scottish tourism, which I was hoping for from a book about moving there for the first time, and the relationship took its time in developing from friends to lovers. I would have liked the physical relationship to move a little slower, personally, but it didn't ruin the book for me. Overall, had a really nice time with this one!
On a personal note, I found it hilarious how Rachel was frustrated she hadn't found her footing in Edinburgh after a week or so. Whenever I've moved to a new city, it's often taken me at least a few months to feel comfortable there, and often more to feel truly at home.
February 28, 2025
“Don’t be afraid to ask what you want. I will always give it to you.”
I had such a great time with Rachel and Isla from Down to a Science that I’ve almost inhaled the book. The author made me bounce from one emotion to another.
The beginning is super hot before a glacial tidal wave that made me doubt, but helped to redefine how the character would interact during the rest of the book. Isla is (among other things) a tourist guide in Edinburgh and I loved to discover the city –and some other places in Scotland– thanks to her and through Rachel’s eyes. I also loved to see Rachel exploring what a relationship can be.
The characters have a great chemistry even though they decide to be friends, which inevitably ends in very steamy scenes, but they are before all very human and greatly written. I loved how they support each other, but also the relationship they have with the other important persons in their life, creating a great found family around them.
I’ll definitely read the other books in this series.
Thank you to the author for the eARC. My opinions are my own.
Rate 4.5/5
I had such a great time with Rachel and Isla from Down to a Science that I’ve almost inhaled the book. The author made me bounce from one emotion to another.
The beginning is super hot before a glacial tidal wave that made me doubt, but helped to redefine how the character would interact during the rest of the book. Isla is (among other things) a tourist guide in Edinburgh and I loved to discover the city –and some other places in Scotland– thanks to her and through Rachel’s eyes. I also loved to see Rachel exploring what a relationship can be.
The characters have a great chemistry even though they decide to be friends, which inevitably ends in very steamy scenes, but they are before all very human and greatly written. I loved how they support each other, but also the relationship they have with the other important persons in their life, creating a great found family around them.
I’ll definitely read the other books in this series.
Thank you to the author for the eARC. My opinions are my own.
Rate 4.5/5
February 11, 2025
ARC review - release date Feb 25, 2025
Great read if you enjoy:
- Opposites attract
- LGBTIQ+ representation
- Scotland 😇
- 🌶️
I fell in love instantly with the setting of this book. And the fact that the characters are very relatable and engaging makes for a perfect read for romance lovers.
Queer romance stories are generally not on my radar, so I didn’t know what to expect but it surely did not disappoint!
To be fair, the 🌶️ scenes were actually serving the story and I thoroughly enjoyed exploring that side of queer romance. I didn’t know that’s was what I would enjoy, let alone enjoy it as much as I did.
The academic setting also worked for me and I liked that it wasn’t as prominent as it could’ve been.
Moreover, we have to talk about the additional characters! We definitely have a good serving of strong additional characters with their own identity and motivations. There has to be something brewing there. Perhaps for another story?
So, in short, if you enjoy romance of any kind: pick up a copy of this book! I promise it will not disappoint! 🥰
Great read if you enjoy:
- Opposites attract
- LGBTIQ+ representation
- Scotland 😇
- 🌶️
I fell in love instantly with the setting of this book. And the fact that the characters are very relatable and engaging makes for a perfect read for romance lovers.
Queer romance stories are generally not on my radar, so I didn’t know what to expect but it surely did not disappoint!
To be fair, the 🌶️ scenes were actually serving the story and I thoroughly enjoyed exploring that side of queer romance. I didn’t know that’s was what I would enjoy, let alone enjoy it as much as I did.
The academic setting also worked for me and I liked that it wasn’t as prominent as it could’ve been.
Moreover, we have to talk about the additional characters! We definitely have a good serving of strong additional characters with their own identity and motivations. There has to be something brewing there. Perhaps for another story?
So, in short, if you enjoy romance of any kind: pick up a copy of this book! I promise it will not disappoint! 🥰
July 13, 2025
This was a fun read, and I enjoyed that it didn’t feel formulaic. The characters were both a little quirky but not in an over-the-top LOOK AT ME kind of way. They have past hurts and they react to those past hurts but the way they work through those wasn’t annoying.
I didn’t always look at the title tags and you need to because I lost track of POV a couple times with she/her. They both have mom issues, I think? And they both have brothers. And they’re both friends with David. I’ve been reading a lot of MM and it happens to me there too with the he/him. That’s not a fault of the book - just if you haven’t started yet, be smarter about it than I was. I don’t learn, obviously.
I read the blurb for the next book. I’m glad it’s Ben. I’m not going to put a spoiler here but I really hoped the other person was going to be someone specific and it’s not so I don’t know how I feel about reading it. I feel like this whole book was setting that up and then it didn’t happen so that’s something.
I didn’t always look at the title tags and you need to because I lost track of POV a couple times with she/her. They both have mom issues, I think? And they both have brothers. And they’re both friends with David. I’ve been reading a lot of MM and it happens to me there too with the he/him. That’s not a fault of the book - just if you haven’t started yet, be smarter about it than I was. I don’t learn, obviously.
I read the blurb for the next book. I’m glad it’s Ben. I’m not going to put a spoiler here but I really hoped the other person was going to be someone specific and it’s not so I don’t know how I feel about reading it. I feel like this whole book was setting that up and then it didn’t happen so that’s something.
October 30, 2025
The author took great care in portraying the differences in culture and language between an American and a British person. The story itself envelops you in a comfortable bubble of Edinburgh, even providing history/tourist spots along the way, which, for me, adds to the atmosphere. It's not a drama-filled plot, which I found to be a big plus—more of an inviting and warm feeling between the two characters as they navigate their struggles.
Although there is a sort of third-act breakup that feels somewhat forced, like an unnecessary final obstacle was added between them, I believe it wasn't needed beyond what was already snowballing towards the end. A big conversation between the characters would have been enough and could have led to a more satisfying ending. I think that's what made it four stars rather than five.
++Additionally, since this is a series, as someone who had not read the previous book, I appreciated the good details that helped me stay on the same wavelength with the characters and still understand relationships well
Although there is a sort of third-act breakup that feels somewhat forced, like an unnecessary final obstacle was added between them, I believe it wasn't needed beyond what was already snowballing towards the end. A big conversation between the characters would have been enough and could have led to a more satisfying ending. I think that's what made it four stars rather than five.
++Additionally, since this is a series, as someone who had not read the previous book, I appreciated the good details that helped me stay on the same wavelength with the characters and still understand relationships well
November 25, 2025
STEM FMC: PhD student in marine biodiversity
I do love a good friends to lovers situation, and it was fun watching them blur the line. Both of their parents kind of suck, and that was some of the most relatable parts of this book. Isla's mom in particular was difficult to read for me, but I did love watching Isla set a boundary and maintain it, which I struggle with in real life. I also think that Rachel is likely autistic, although that is never explicitly stated, but she's definitely neurodivergent. Without her autism being stated, everyone still learns her touch boundaries and preferences and respects them without question or guilt.
I do struggle to connect with sapphic romances and seeing their connection as romantic, but I still enjoyed the friendship they built together. This book has a moderate amount of spice.
I didn't realize that this book was the second in a series until I was about halfway through, so I can say with certainty that you can definitely read this book as a standalone.
3.5 stars!
I do love a good friends to lovers situation, and it was fun watching them blur the line. Both of their parents kind of suck, and that was some of the most relatable parts of this book. Isla's mom in particular was difficult to read for me, but I did love watching Isla set a boundary and maintain it, which I struggle with in real life. I also think that Rachel is likely autistic, although that is never explicitly stated, but she's definitely neurodivergent. Without her autism being stated, everyone still learns her touch boundaries and preferences and respects them without question or guilt.
I do struggle to connect with sapphic romances and seeing their connection as romantic, but I still enjoyed the friendship they built together. This book has a moderate amount of spice.
I didn't realize that this book was the second in a series until I was about halfway through, so I can say with certainty that you can definitely read this book as a standalone.
3.5 stars!
January 30, 2025
ARC REVIEW!
Rating: 4/5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶️ 1/2
I absolutely adored this book. Rachel and Isla were such an amazing couple with sizzling chemistry. It tells a story of Rachel moving to Scotland to complete her PhD and stumbling across the lovely Isla.
The reason I rated it four stars is because I wish that they could’ve been together for longer. I think they spent too much time in their heads knowing their feelings but refusing to communicate them. Which of course is normal in a book but I feel like it was probably around 85 to 90% of the book. I also wish we could’ve seen more development in Isla and her mom‘s relationship versus them just getting into an argument and then making up at the last minute. But, besides that I devoured this book. Perhaps Ben and David will be getting a book????
I will be recommending to my friends.
Rating: 4/5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶️ 1/2
I absolutely adored this book. Rachel and Isla were such an amazing couple with sizzling chemistry. It tells a story of Rachel moving to Scotland to complete her PhD and stumbling across the lovely Isla.
The reason I rated it four stars is because I wish that they could’ve been together for longer. I think they spent too much time in their heads knowing their feelings but refusing to communicate them. Which of course is normal in a book but I feel like it was probably around 85 to 90% of the book. I also wish we could’ve seen more development in Isla and her mom‘s relationship versus them just getting into an argument and then making up at the last minute. But, besides that I devoured this book. Perhaps Ben and David will be getting a book????
I will be recommending to my friends.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 65 reviews