Eleven tales explore the early history of Scotland’s constant struggle for freedom from the English
Scottish history is full of tales of blood and sacrifice, great heroes and fierce warriors, and above all, the constant battle between the Scots and the Brits for Scotland’s independence. For hundreds of years, Scotland and England teetered between war, peace, and unity, and being Scottish royalty could bring as much danger as it could power and riches.
The legendary stories included in Claymore and Kilt follow the rise and fall of the great Scottish kings of old. With tales including those of the sons of Cathmor, who vowed to avenge their father’s murder, the strange riddle that saved a lord’s life, and the king who loved only one thing more than his beautiful dog, this collection gives a voice to the complicated history of Scottish kings and castles.
Sorche Nic Leodhas (1898–1969) was born LeClaire Louise Gowans in Youngstown, Ohio. After the death of her first husband, she moved to New York and attended classes at Columbia University. Several years later, she met her second husband and became LeClaire Gowans Alger. She was a longtime librarian at the Carnegie Library in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, where she also wrote children’s books. Shortly before she retired in 1966, she began publishing Scottish folktales and other stories under the pseudonym Sorche Nic Leodhas, Gaelic for Claire, daughter of Louis. In 1963, she received a Newbery Honor for Thistle and Thyme: Tales and Legends from Scotland. Alger continued to write and publish books until her death 1969.
I actually purchased this book because I saw one of Leo & Diane Dillon's gorgeous illustrations from it and wanted to see more of the same, but I was rewarded with an unexpectedly fabulous collection of well-researched historical tales, to which the illustrations are just the icing on the cake. Not only does Sorche Nic Leodhas provide detailed historical background for each of the stories, making the book very informative, but her writing style is exceedingly charming and engaging. This is a book I would have LOVED if I'd had it when I was younger. I plan to purchase the rest of her books of Scottish tales, and keep them for my own future family.
If you have Scottish heritage or are just interested in Scottish history, the introduction portion of this book is one of the best and most concise summaries of the history of Scottish rulers that I have ever read! And the stories are tons of fun as well!
This is a compendium of folklore and folk history, stories about kings and castles. It begins with the druids, who called themselves Gaedil (stones people). Higher knowledge was their exclusive domain, and they considered it unlawful to write anything down of their history. Folk history consisted in oral form in verse and took a druid 20 years to learn. As the druids were later exterminated by the Romans, this cultural wealth was largely lost. The book treats early lords—beginning with Fingal (if indeed historical) who ruled Argyll as Ard-righ (high chief) of the clans between Wales and the West Coast—and early saints, including Ninian and Kentigern as well as Columba. The concept of the book is to tell us about the folktales without actually narrating the folktales. It assumes readers already know the story. We are informed about the various versions of the tales and informed of where they differ from historical fact, but some of the stories are referred to rather than told. For example, a chapter heading announces 'the riddle sent to Bruce', yet the chapter does not tell us what the riddle was. This is unsatisfactory. Though well-written, it is not narrative enough to be a book of folklore and not sociological enough to be a book about folklore. I checked out the tales on Google, so I did learn something, but I would've preferred a more narrative approach, which wouldn't have added too many pages to the not-too-long 157-page book. It is illustrated with beautiful curly Celtic art-nouveau line drawings. Other books by this author treat ghosts, legends and tales from the Highlands.
A really great book about legends of Scottish Kings. The forward is also fantastic in giving historical references to time each story occurs without giving away the plot of the story (which forwards often do).
A grand collection of folk tales with some history in their too, although the lines between fact and fantasy no doubt blurred over time. Very well told with fab illustrations.
Although it is written in a very romanticized language, I still enjoyed this book a lot. Good stories, enjoyable characters. One thing I could bring up against it is that some of the best stories never made it into the actual book; the extensive introduction mentions a whole bunch of things I would have loved to read more about. On the plus side, one tale does mention Saint Margaret of Scotland, but never tells us who she is, so I only caught the reference because I am familiar with her from other sources. Still, fun read, and a nice introduction to Scottish history, especially for children.
Though not quite as fun as the fairy and folk tales, these historically based tales are still very interesting and written in Ms. Leodhas's signature style.