What do you think?
Rate this book
Roaring Twenties Magic #3
Viscounts & Villainy
Viscounts & Villainy has descriptive copy which is not yet available from the Publisher.
Audible Audio
First published July 1, 2025
32 people are currently reading
531 people want to read
About the author
Allie Therin
12 books887 followersAllie Therin is a bicultural author of award-winning romance and urban fantasy. She also is, or has been, a bookseller, an attorney, a Parks & Rec assistant, a boom operator, and a barista for one (embarrassing) day.
A longtime fan of romance, mystery and speculative fiction, she now strives to bring that same delight to her readers. Allie grew up in a tiny Pacific Northwest town with more bears than people, although the bears sadly would not practice Spanish with her.
A longtime fan of romance, mystery and speculative fiction, she now strives to bring that same delight to her readers. Allie grew up in a tiny Pacific Northwest town with more bears than people, although the bears sadly would not practice Spanish with her.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 141 reviews
July 1, 2025
Lord Fine, aka Wesley, aka the sarcastic posh one, aka the man who's getting feelings he's not quite sure what to do with, is one of my favourite book characters of all time.
Here things pick up immediately after the conclusion of Once a Rogue with Sebastian still having no magic, two relics yet to be found and the people responsible for the attack on the magic world still on the loose.
I've been so hyped for this final book in the Roaring Twenties series and it did not disappoint one bit! There's so much going on but throughout it all, the main thing which kept me reading was seeing Wesley come to terms with his feelings.
The uptight aristocratic former villain has been fighting the collapse of his whole stiff upper lip attitude for a while now, but coming to terms with Sebastian giving up his magic to save his life has got him all of a wobble.
Watching the two of them navigate falling in love is pure delight. Sebastian's got his heart on his sleeve, he's coming to terms with being non-magical and no longer having the protection of his enervation, when the trail sends them back to England and the upper class world Wesley inhabits.
While Arthur & Rory, Jade & Zhang, do make appearances, they're only in the periphery for this book, which really drives home the connection growing between Wesley and Sebastian and - perhaps - not all is lost with the magic.
I loved how Allie left hints throughout the narrative as to what was happening not only with the missing relics and who might be behind the events of the previous two books, but also as to whether or not Sebastian's magic had gone forever.
The de Leon family's connection to the relics and to magic in general really comes into play here with a deep dive back into the days of the Spanish Inquisition and distantly related Dukes hiding secrets.
There's red herrings aplenty but I was secretly pleased I'd worked out what had happened with Sebastian's magic before the big reveal and I loved how that part of the storyline was slowly developed and revealed through a number of incidents while in England.
Wesley though, his journey to acceptance that he is worthy of love and that he can give it in return, not only to Sebastian as his heart's connected soul, but also to the group of people that has gathered around him in friendship, really is beautiful.
That was probably my most favourite thing about this whole series. Seeing these two men, who appeared to be the bad guys in the Magic in Manhattan trilogy, really cement not only their relationship but their important part in the group of paranormals, was wonderful.
While this is the last book in this series, I really hope Allie hasn't finished with her urban historical paranormal world. I would read about this group over and over again!
#ARC kindly received from Harlequin via NetGalley, I am voluntarily leaving a review
Here things pick up immediately after the conclusion of Once a Rogue with Sebastian still having no magic, two relics yet to be found and the people responsible for the attack on the magic world still on the loose.
I've been so hyped for this final book in the Roaring Twenties series and it did not disappoint one bit! There's so much going on but throughout it all, the main thing which kept me reading was seeing Wesley come to terms with his feelings.
The uptight aristocratic former villain has been fighting the collapse of his whole stiff upper lip attitude for a while now, but coming to terms with Sebastian giving up his magic to save his life has got him all of a wobble.
Watching the two of them navigate falling in love is pure delight. Sebastian's got his heart on his sleeve, he's coming to terms with being non-magical and no longer having the protection of his enervation, when the trail sends them back to England and the upper class world Wesley inhabits.
While Arthur & Rory, Jade & Zhang, do make appearances, they're only in the periphery for this book, which really drives home the connection growing between Wesley and Sebastian and - perhaps - not all is lost with the magic.
I loved how Allie left hints throughout the narrative as to what was happening not only with the missing relics and who might be behind the events of the previous two books, but also as to whether or not Sebastian's magic had gone forever.
The de Leon family's connection to the relics and to magic in general really comes into play here with a deep dive back into the days of the Spanish Inquisition and distantly related Dukes hiding secrets.
There's red herrings aplenty but I was secretly pleased I'd worked out what had happened with Sebastian's magic before the big reveal and I loved how that part of the storyline was slowly developed and revealed through a number of incidents while in England.
Wesley though, his journey to acceptance that he is worthy of love and that he can give it in return, not only to Sebastian as his heart's connected soul, but also to the group of people that has gathered around him in friendship, really is beautiful.
That was probably my most favourite thing about this whole series. Seeing these two men, who appeared to be the bad guys in the Magic in Manhattan trilogy, really cement not only their relationship but their important part in the group of paranormals, was wonderful.
While this is the last book in this series, I really hope Allie hasn't finished with her urban historical paranormal world. I would read about this group over and over again!
#ARC kindly received from Harlequin via NetGalley, I am voluntarily leaving a review
June 14, 2025
What an absolutely gorgeous conclusion to Wesley and Sebastian's story.
I loved "Viscounts & Villainy" SO much. I managed to devour it in two days, and I still couldn't get enough of it by the end of it.
It's packed with magic and amazing world-building, action and secret plots, humour and so much romance and feels. Allie Therin is such a talented author, and I seriously cannot get enough of her books. Reading this has made me want to start a re-read of all her previous books (starting with Arthur and Rory's romance of course!).
I loved how well all the different plot threads tied up here; I loved the action and the non-stop clues leading to the explosive finale. I was on the edge of my seat the whole time!
Most of all, I loved the two protagonists, and their wonderful romance, SO MUCH.
Sebastian's truly a sweetheart, and seeing him put through the emotional wringer in this one wasn't pleasant, but I adored seeing him finally accept himself (and his past) and learn to forgive himself too.
AND WESLEY. God, that man. I love him half to death. He's grumpy and slightly mean, a snarky asshole who's convinced himself he's the worst, not worth loving at all, and seeing him finally accept the love Sebastian's trying to shower him in was WONDERFUL. Ugh, truly, one of my fav characters from Allie to date.
Wesley was used to the man in the mirror looking cold and severe. Untouchable and undesirable. But this man in the reflection was none of those things. He looked like someone’s lover.
Their romance stole my heart, and ALTHOUGH , I adored watching them finally REALIZE they can have the HEA both of them so desperately crave. My sweet babies <3
Having the gang back together was priceless, and I adored reading about Wesley and Arthur being overprotective mother hens, and I loved the banter between Rory and Wesley SO MUCH. All the other side characters were as priceless as always, and I might have found a new favourite.
“Look at you, out of Arthur’s sight,” Wesley said. “How is he coping? Should we telegram and assure him that you haven’t been mugged or, I don’t know, unacceptably jostled by passersby?”
That epilogue stole my heart <3 truly the best way to say goodbye to this series, although I'll probably beg Allie Therin for more in this universe until I'm dead and buried. I NEED IT!
Wholly recommended.
Many thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC. This is my honest opinion.
I loved "Viscounts & Villainy" SO much. I managed to devour it in two days, and I still couldn't get enough of it by the end of it.
It's packed with magic and amazing world-building, action and secret plots, humour and so much romance and feels. Allie Therin is such a talented author, and I seriously cannot get enough of her books. Reading this has made me want to start a re-read of all her previous books (starting with Arthur and Rory's romance of course!).
I loved how well all the different plot threads tied up here; I loved the action and the non-stop clues leading to the explosive finale. I was on the edge of my seat the whole time!
Most of all, I loved the two protagonists, and their wonderful romance, SO MUCH.
Sebastian's truly a sweetheart, and seeing him put through the emotional wringer in this one wasn't pleasant, but I adored seeing him finally accept himself (and his past) and learn to forgive himself too.
AND WESLEY. God, that man. I love him half to death. He's grumpy and slightly mean, a snarky asshole who's convinced himself he's the worst, not worth loving at all, and seeing him finally accept the love Sebastian's trying to shower him in was WONDERFUL. Ugh, truly, one of my fav characters from Allie to date.
Wesley was used to the man in the mirror looking cold and severe. Untouchable and undesirable. But this man in the reflection was none of those things. He looked like someone’s lover.
Their romance stole my heart, and ALTHOUGH , I adored watching them finally REALIZE they can have the HEA both of them so desperately crave. My sweet babies <3
Having the gang back together was priceless, and I adored reading about Wesley and Arthur being overprotective mother hens, and I loved the banter between Rory and Wesley SO MUCH. All the other side characters were as priceless as always, and I might have found a new favourite.
“Look at you, out of Arthur’s sight,” Wesley said. “How is he coping? Should we telegram and assure him that you haven’t been mugged or, I don’t know, unacceptably jostled by passersby?”
That epilogue stole my heart <3 truly the best way to say goodbye to this series, although I'll probably beg Allie Therin for more in this universe until I'm dead and buried. I NEED IT!
Wholly recommended.
Many thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC. This is my honest opinion.
August 30, 2025
”Angels were far more aggravating than devils”.
These books!!!! I am not ready for them to be over. Allie Therin must be a paranormal because seriously, the talent you must have to write this series that not only has a fantastic and captivating plot, but also has character growth, compelling side characters and an absolutely adorable and sweet romance.
I spent the whole book giggling like crazy because Wesley was completely smitten with Sebastian and trying very hard to act tough while at the same time doing absolutely everything in his power to make him happy and see him smile. And the dangerous marshmallow himself, Sebastian, who never tried to pretend he wasn't 100% in love with Wesley ❤️.
All their moments together were extremely sweet. I also loved Ace and Rory's involvement in the book; they were responsible for helping move the plot along without stealing the focus from Wesley and Seb.
“I was actually just thinking that there’s so much I still don’t know about you. You must be the most fascinating man I’ve ever met.” “Oh.” Sebastian ducked his head. “I am not so fascinating, though— very simple, really. I like the ocean, and cats, and you.
These books!!!! I am not ready for them to be over. Allie Therin must be a paranormal because seriously, the talent you must have to write this series that not only has a fantastic and captivating plot, but also has character growth, compelling side characters and an absolutely adorable and sweet romance.
I spent the whole book giggling like crazy because Wesley was completely smitten with Sebastian and trying very hard to act tough while at the same time doing absolutely everything in his power to make him happy and see him smile. And the dangerous marshmallow himself, Sebastian, who never tried to pretend he wasn't 100% in love with Wesley ❤️.
All their moments together were extremely sweet. I also loved Ace and Rory's involvement in the book; they were responsible for helping move the plot along without stealing the focus from Wesley and Seb.
“I was actually just thinking that there’s so much I still don’t know about you. You must be the most fascinating man I’ve ever met.” “Oh.” Sebastian ducked his head. “I am not so fascinating, though— very simple, really. I like the ocean, and cats, and you.
July 29, 2025
A- / 4.5 stars rounded up.
Allie Therin’s inventive and entertaining Roaring Twenties Magic series comes to a rousing conclusion with Viscounts & Villainy, in which our heroes – upper-crust cynic and self-professed arsehole Wesley, Lord Fine, and “dangerous marshmallow” Sebastian de Leon - come face-to-face with probably their most dangerous (and unhinged) foe yet. This story links back to events in earlier books in both this series and the author’s Magic in Manhattan books, and although it’s probably possible to enjoy this story without having read the earlier series, it’s essential to have read Proper Scoundrels and Once a Rogue before Viscounts & Villainy as there’s an overarching plotline and reference to earlier events that will likely be confusing if you haven’t.
Please note that there are likely to be spoilers for those books in this review.
At the end of Once a Rogue, Wesley and Sebastian narrowly escaped death at the hands of the deranged paranormal who was part of a plot to control and destroy magic through unlocking the evil magic held within the pomander relic, a magical artefact dating from the fifteenth century. Alasdair Findlay now lies unconscious in a mental hospital and the pomander is no more, but victory came at great cost to Sebastian, who sacrificed his magic in order to destroy the relic and save Wesley’s life. He doesn’t regret it and he’d do it again in a heartbeat to save the man he loves – but it’s going to take a huge adjustment to learn to live without magic.
In the weeks since those events, it’s become clear that Findlay and his cronies weren’t working alone and that someone else has been pulling the strings all along, someone withdeep knowledge of paranormal lore and magical history. Wesley, Sebastian and their friends are sure that they – whoever they are - isn’t going to just give up, and that they need to act quickly if they’re going to find them and prevent more death and destruction. With little to go on, they decide to follow the trail of the relics themselves; seven were created to hide the magic of seven powerful paranormals during the Spanish Inquisition, and they know the location – or fates – of five of them. So tracking down the missing two – a medallion that can track magic, and a cuff that can cast curses – would be a good starting point. Sebastian, a direct descendant of the witch hunter who tracked down the seven relic-makers, knows that the cuff once belonged to a Spanish countess whose English husband, the Duke of Valemount, created the medallion – and Wesley, given the aristocratic circles in which he generally moves, knows the current Duke of Valemount.
Wesley, Sebastian, Arthur and Rory prepare to return to England, where Wesley plans to put in an appearance at a number of social events at which the Duke of Valemount is sure to be in attendance, and to which he will be accompanied by his friend, Don Sebastian, the eldest son of a Spanish count. Sebastian isn’t overly enthused by the idea of infiltrating English society as a Spanish aristocrat, but it makes sense for him to tag along with Wesley because he can act as a second pair of eyes – and because he’s the most likely to recognise any reference to the relics Valemount might make. It also turns out that Sebastian and Valemount are probably very distantly related (through that fifteenth century Spanish countess), and given the duke himself is descended from two powerful paranormals, they can’t discount the possibility that he might have magic himself.
Viscounts & Villainy is another fabulous, well-paced, and gripping read in which the high-stakes plot and delightful, opposites-attract romance are skilfully balanced so that it never feels as though one takes precedence over the other. Wesley and Sebastian’s romance has developed over three books and I’ve loved every minute I’ve spent watching them falling for each other and coming to accept that they’re worthy of love and deserving of happiness. It’s been a hard road though; Sebastian had to come to terms with the fact that he wasn’t responsible for the bad things he did while he was magically enslaved, and Wesley continues to struggle with the fact that Sebastian adamantly refuses to believe he’s the cold-hearted bastard everyone else thinks him to be. But it’s been his reality for so many years that he’s bought the lie, too, believing that if everyone he knows thinks he’s a cynical, sarcastic and intolerable arsehole with no feelings, they must be right.
From the moment they met, Sebastian has thrown Wesley off balance – figuratively as well as (sometimes) literally – making it clear that he doesn’t believe Wesley to be hard-hearted or intolerable; that he sees through the act to the kind and decent man underneath. Wesley tries to laugh it off as Sebastian’s soft heart and desire to see good in everyone, insists that he’s seeing him through rose-tinted glasses; but after Sebastian gave up his magic to save Wesley’s life, he’s finding it harder and harder to cling to his entrenched beliefs about himself. If Sebastian – probably the only truly good person Wesley has ever known and who knows Wesley better than anyone else by now – thought he was worth such a huge sacrifice, then… might Wesley not be such an irredemable arsehole after all? And on top of all this, Wesley is horrified at the thought that he might actually be having some of those pesky feelings he’s avoided for so long.
As Wesley struggles to come to terms with this reassessment of himself, so is Sebastian struggling to deal with the loss of his magic and to adapt to living without it. In an odd reversal of their usual positions, Sebastian is certain it’s gone forever while Wesley simply can’t shake the feeling that it’s still with them, somehow – but Sebastian is determined to force himself to move on and into a non-magical life without looking back. The love and trust they have for and in one another is displayed beautifully when Wesley tells Sebastian to slow down and take a breath, reminding him that he’s allowed to rely on other people as he adjusts, and when Sebastian says he feels safe enough with Wesley to admit how bereft he feels. Knowing of his lover’s new vulnerability redoubles Wesley’s already fierce protective streak when it comes to Sebastian, but he tries hard not to be overprotective, knowing Sebastian’s innate kindness and sweet disposition don’t make him weak and that he’s stronger than most people give him credit for.
The dynamic between these two has always been a highlight of the stories; the teasing and flirty banter is funny, their growing love for each other has been a delight to watch and the way they are so utterly supportive and intuitive to the other’s wants and needs is wonderful to see. I liked seeing Wesley’s gradual acceptance that he might have actual friends for possibly the first time in his life – and enjoyed seeing those friends again, although they are, rightly, supporting characters, and allow Wesley and Sebastian to take centre stage.
I’m rather sad this series has come to an end – I’ll miss Wesley’s snark and Sebastian’s sweetness - but I’m happy it’s gone out on such a high note. Viscounts & Villainy is imaginative, funny, clever, and romantic, and I’m more than happy to recommend both it and the entire Roaring Twenties Magic series.
Allie Therin’s inventive and entertaining Roaring Twenties Magic series comes to a rousing conclusion with Viscounts & Villainy, in which our heroes – upper-crust cynic and self-professed arsehole Wesley, Lord Fine, and “dangerous marshmallow” Sebastian de Leon - come face-to-face with probably their most dangerous (and unhinged) foe yet. This story links back to events in earlier books in both this series and the author’s Magic in Manhattan books, and although it’s probably possible to enjoy this story without having read the earlier series, it’s essential to have read Proper Scoundrels and Once a Rogue before Viscounts & Villainy as there’s an overarching plotline and reference to earlier events that will likely be confusing if you haven’t.
Please note that there are likely to be spoilers for those books in this review.
At the end of Once a Rogue, Wesley and Sebastian narrowly escaped death at the hands of the deranged paranormal who was part of a plot to control and destroy magic through unlocking the evil magic held within the pomander relic, a magical artefact dating from the fifteenth century. Alasdair Findlay now lies unconscious in a mental hospital and the pomander is no more, but victory came at great cost to Sebastian, who sacrificed his magic in order to destroy the relic and save Wesley’s life. He doesn’t regret it and he’d do it again in a heartbeat to save the man he loves – but it’s going to take a huge adjustment to learn to live without magic.
In the weeks since those events, it’s become clear that Findlay and his cronies weren’t working alone and that someone else has been pulling the strings all along, someone withdeep knowledge of paranormal lore and magical history. Wesley, Sebastian and their friends are sure that they – whoever they are - isn’t going to just give up, and that they need to act quickly if they’re going to find them and prevent more death and destruction. With little to go on, they decide to follow the trail of the relics themselves; seven were created to hide the magic of seven powerful paranormals during the Spanish Inquisition, and they know the location – or fates – of five of them. So tracking down the missing two – a medallion that can track magic, and a cuff that can cast curses – would be a good starting point. Sebastian, a direct descendant of the witch hunter who tracked down the seven relic-makers, knows that the cuff once belonged to a Spanish countess whose English husband, the Duke of Valemount, created the medallion – and Wesley, given the aristocratic circles in which he generally moves, knows the current Duke of Valemount.
Wesley, Sebastian, Arthur and Rory prepare to return to England, where Wesley plans to put in an appearance at a number of social events at which the Duke of Valemount is sure to be in attendance, and to which he will be accompanied by his friend, Don Sebastian, the eldest son of a Spanish count. Sebastian isn’t overly enthused by the idea of infiltrating English society as a Spanish aristocrat, but it makes sense for him to tag along with Wesley because he can act as a second pair of eyes – and because he’s the most likely to recognise any reference to the relics Valemount might make. It also turns out that Sebastian and Valemount are probably very distantly related (through that fifteenth century Spanish countess), and given the duke himself is descended from two powerful paranormals, they can’t discount the possibility that he might have magic himself.
Viscounts & Villainy is another fabulous, well-paced, and gripping read in which the high-stakes plot and delightful, opposites-attract romance are skilfully balanced so that it never feels as though one takes precedence over the other. Wesley and Sebastian’s romance has developed over three books and I’ve loved every minute I’ve spent watching them falling for each other and coming to accept that they’re worthy of love and deserving of happiness. It’s been a hard road though; Sebastian had to come to terms with the fact that he wasn’t responsible for the bad things he did while he was magically enslaved, and Wesley continues to struggle with the fact that Sebastian adamantly refuses to believe he’s the cold-hearted bastard everyone else thinks him to be. But it’s been his reality for so many years that he’s bought the lie, too, believing that if everyone he knows thinks he’s a cynical, sarcastic and intolerable arsehole with no feelings, they must be right.
From the moment they met, Sebastian has thrown Wesley off balance – figuratively as well as (sometimes) literally – making it clear that he doesn’t believe Wesley to be hard-hearted or intolerable; that he sees through the act to the kind and decent man underneath. Wesley tries to laugh it off as Sebastian’s soft heart and desire to see good in everyone, insists that he’s seeing him through rose-tinted glasses; but after Sebastian gave up his magic to save Wesley’s life, he’s finding it harder and harder to cling to his entrenched beliefs about himself. If Sebastian – probably the only truly good person Wesley has ever known and who knows Wesley better than anyone else by now – thought he was worth such a huge sacrifice, then… might Wesley not be such an irredemable arsehole after all? And on top of all this, Wesley is horrified at the thought that he might actually be having some of those pesky feelings he’s avoided for so long.
As Wesley struggles to come to terms with this reassessment of himself, so is Sebastian struggling to deal with the loss of his magic and to adapt to living without it. In an odd reversal of their usual positions, Sebastian is certain it’s gone forever while Wesley simply can’t shake the feeling that it’s still with them, somehow – but Sebastian is determined to force himself to move on and into a non-magical life without looking back. The love and trust they have for and in one another is displayed beautifully when Wesley tells Sebastian to slow down and take a breath, reminding him that he’s allowed to rely on other people as he adjusts, and when Sebastian says he feels safe enough with Wesley to admit how bereft he feels. Knowing of his lover’s new vulnerability redoubles Wesley’s already fierce protective streak when it comes to Sebastian, but he tries hard not to be overprotective, knowing Sebastian’s innate kindness and sweet disposition don’t make him weak and that he’s stronger than most people give him credit for.
The dynamic between these two has always been a highlight of the stories; the teasing and flirty banter is funny, their growing love for each other has been a delight to watch and the way they are so utterly supportive and intuitive to the other’s wants and needs is wonderful to see. I liked seeing Wesley’s gradual acceptance that he might have actual friends for possibly the first time in his life – and enjoyed seeing those friends again, although they are, rightly, supporting characters, and allow Wesley and Sebastian to take centre stage.
I’m rather sad this series has come to an end – I’ll miss Wesley’s snark and Sebastian’s sweetness - but I’m happy it’s gone out on such a high note. Viscounts & Villainy is imaginative, funny, clever, and romantic, and I’m more than happy to recommend both it and the entire Roaring Twenties Magic series.
January 2, 2026
I really, really love this couple! The banters, the incongruity between Wesley’s mind and what he says, and how Sebastian still understands Wesley’s heart despite of that. The plot is also much better this time.
And the confession!! It's so funny and adorable, and so typical Wesley.
“The only thing I want is you,” Sebastian said, as he let Wesley tug him exactly where he wanted him, which was right into Wesley’s arms.
You already have that, and embarrassingly completely. Wesley didn’t say it, instead sliding his hands lower on Sebastian’s back. “Listen to you, trying to charm me. You know I’m not that easy.”
“Are you sure?” Sebastian twined his own arms around Wesley’s neck. “Because you just offered to buy me a zoo.”
And the confession!! It's so funny and adorable, and so typical Wesley.
“Oh.” Sebastian’s cheeks colored. “You mean the thing I said after I found out you sabotaged the fox hunt? That thing?”
“Yes,” Wesley said. “When you said…the thing.”
Sebastian’s cheeks were still flushed, but he raised his chin and met Wesley’s eyes. “I remember.” He swallowed. “You don’t have to say it back, not tonight, not ever,” he said quickly. “But I meant it.”
“Oh.” It was Wesley’s turn to feel his face heat. “Well. I mean. I, um. I just—that thing you said. Well. Yes. Likewise.”
Likewise? Really? That was Wesley’s big romantic declaration?
But Sebastian had broken into the sweetest smile Wesley might have ever seen. “Okay,” he said happily, and then he was kissing Wesley.
June 24, 2025
I received an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Viscounts & Villainy wraps up Allie Therin's spin-off trilogy set in her historical New York/London universe. True to form, we follow Lord Fine and Sebastian on a quest to save magic and have a lot of sex. Except this time, they’re joined by a cast of familiar faces...
First, let me tell you the story of my getting this ARC: I’ve seen both the Roaring Twenties trilogy and its original instalment, the Magic in Manhattan trilogy, recommended everywhere for years. I even bought all the previous books, saving them for a rainy day. So when this popped up on NetGalley, I thought, “Hell yeah! Now’s the time!” I planned to read just this trilogy, keeping the first one for later. Imagine my surprise when, halfway through the first chapter of Proper Scoundrels , I realized this spin-off series is absolutely not a standalone. Suddenly, I had a month to read all six books in this universe. “Fine!” I grumbled to myself. “I'm a fast reader, I can do it!”
So then I read Spellbound , the first book in the original trilogy, and I... hated it. I hated it so much.
Thankfully, none of the others were quite as revolting to me, and a few moments did shine. Still, this is the last time I’ll request an ARC in a series I haven’t read before. I have learned. I have grown. ✨ And I’m never trusting y'all book reviews again.
On to the review: If you’ve enjoyed the previous entries, you’ll likely love this one too. The opening chapters strike a better balance between recapping earlier books and moving the story forward. The writing is competent, and the sense of setting is as present as ever.
Unfortunately, that’s where my compliments end. The book seems almost allergic to advancing the plot, preferring endless character banter and fanservice. The main couple from the earlier trilogy is very present, and since I didn’t like them, their constant presence was a real pain in my side. The first 25% feels more like a reunion novella than the set-up to a murder-mystery.
The story relies heavily on lore dumps in dialogue, rather than letting the characters discover things for themselves (as did the previous books). The character dynamics, which many readers adore, grated on me: Wesley’s constant angst about his (not-)feelings and Sebastian’s relentless “cinnamon roll” innocence felt shallow and repetitive. I get why people love this archetype, but here it lacks any real depth.
Repetition is a serious issue. Whole sentences and emotional beats are recycled within pages of each other-is it padding? Editing oversight? As for the mystery, it follows Therin’s usual pattern: convoluted, vague, and fading into the background whenever ✨ romance ✨ happens. The villain’s motives are unclear, and the stakes never feel urgent.
That said, credit where it’s due: the writing is technically solid, and Therin’s flair for period detail and atmosphere is still strong. If you’re here for the vibes and the sexy Kindle Unlimited-type romance, you’ll get exactly what you want.
Ultimately, this book was made with love for established fans who want more of the same. The last plot threads are tied up, but I wouldn’t be surprised if there ends up being another spin-off in the future. I’m disappointed I didn’t enjoy it more actually, but I’m really glad others will find what they’re looking for.
Viscounts & Villainy wraps up Allie Therin's spin-off trilogy set in her historical New York/London universe. True to form, we follow Lord Fine and Sebastian on a quest to save magic and have a lot of sex. Except this time, they’re joined by a cast of familiar faces...
First, let me tell you the story of my getting this ARC: I’ve seen both the Roaring Twenties trilogy and its original instalment, the Magic in Manhattan trilogy, recommended everywhere for years. I even bought all the previous books, saving them for a rainy day. So when this popped up on NetGalley, I thought, “Hell yeah! Now’s the time!” I planned to read just this trilogy, keeping the first one for later. Imagine my surprise when, halfway through the first chapter of Proper Scoundrels , I realized this spin-off series is absolutely not a standalone. Suddenly, I had a month to read all six books in this universe. “Fine!” I grumbled to myself. “I'm a fast reader, I can do it!”
So then I read Spellbound , the first book in the original trilogy, and I... hated it. I hated it so much.
Thankfully, none of the others were quite as revolting to me, and a few moments did shine. Still, this is the last time I’ll request an ARC in a series I haven’t read before. I have learned. I have grown. ✨ And I’m never trusting y'all book reviews again.
On to the review: If you’ve enjoyed the previous entries, you’ll likely love this one too. The opening chapters strike a better balance between recapping earlier books and moving the story forward. The writing is competent, and the sense of setting is as present as ever.
Unfortunately, that’s where my compliments end. The book seems almost allergic to advancing the plot, preferring endless character banter and fanservice. The main couple from the earlier trilogy is very present, and since I didn’t like them, their constant presence was a real pain in my side. The first 25% feels more like a reunion novella than the set-up to a murder-mystery.
The story relies heavily on lore dumps in dialogue, rather than letting the characters discover things for themselves (as did the previous books). The character dynamics, which many readers adore, grated on me: Wesley’s constant angst about his (not-)feelings and Sebastian’s relentless “cinnamon roll” innocence felt shallow and repetitive. I get why people love this archetype, but here it lacks any real depth.
Repetition is a serious issue. Whole sentences and emotional beats are recycled within pages of each other-is it padding? Editing oversight? As for the mystery, it follows Therin’s usual pattern: convoluted, vague, and fading into the background whenever ✨ romance ✨ happens. The villain’s motives are unclear, and the stakes never feel urgent.
That said, credit where it’s due: the writing is technically solid, and Therin’s flair for period detail and atmosphere is still strong. If you’re here for the vibes and the sexy Kindle Unlimited-type romance, you’ll get exactly what you want.
Ultimately, this book was made with love for established fans who want more of the same. The last plot threads are tied up, but I wouldn’t be surprised if there ends up being another spin-off in the future. I’m disappointed I didn’t enjoy it more actually, but I’m really glad others will find what they’re looking for.
July 28, 2025
So I reread book 1 and 2 in anticipation of this one, and I'm glad I did. The trilogy takes place over the span of only a few months, so it helped to be really on top of things, but it makes finishing all the more bittersweet because I was so immersed in it.
We get more high-stakes magical shenanigans as the gang tries to save magic, following the trail from New York back to England. The plot was fine, but honestly I was there for the romance. Sebastian and Wesley may well be one of my favourite pairings ever. Watching notorious jackass Wesley Collins go absolutely gooey over Sebastian has honestly been a joy to read about. Devastated to be done with this world. What I really want now is a full-length novel about Wesley turning his Yorkshire estate into a fox sanctuary for Sebastian. No plot necessary.
We get more high-stakes magical shenanigans as the gang tries to save magic, following the trail from New York back to England. The plot was fine, but honestly I was there for the romance. Sebastian and Wesley may well be one of my favourite pairings ever. Watching notorious jackass Wesley Collins go absolutely gooey over Sebastian has honestly been a joy to read about. Devastated to be done with this world. What I really want now is a full-length novel about Wesley turning his Yorkshire estate into a fox sanctuary for Sebastian. No plot necessary.
January 21, 2026
I really enjoyed this trilogy. Mostly because of the romance.
The relationship development is top-notch and I love how they learned to trust each other and share with each other and be vulnerable. They are a little shaky in their relationship until pretty close to the end but you can see them continuing to be more open. It's lovely!
The plotting and the mysteries are a little bit flat for me. At the end of each book, the main characters make stupid mistakes and trust people they shouldn't. It's very annoying but all prevail in the end. The world building is also kind of weak
But, the romance is fabulous and I enjoyed listening to the audiobook narrator. It was a good time!
The relationship development is top-notch and I love how they learned to trust each other and share with each other and be vulnerable. They are a little shaky in their relationship until pretty close to the end but you can see them continuing to be more open. It's lovely!
The plotting and the mysteries are a little bit flat for me. At the end of each book, the main characters make stupid mistakes and trust people they shouldn't. It's very annoying but all prevail in the end. The world building is also kind of weak
But, the romance is fabulous and I enjoyed listening to the audiobook narrator. It was a good time!
July 29, 2025
My review of the ebook edition is HERE
I enjoyed revisiting this one in audio - Joel Leslie can be a bit hit-and-miss for me (I've realised his American-accented narrations don't work as well for me as his English-accented ones!) but he's fabulous as cynical, snarky Wesley, who is gradually discovering that perhaps he's not quite the arrogant arsehole everyone thinks he is and that maybe he does have a heart after all - and that it's been stolen by a gorgeous, cheeky Spaniard who likes to see the best in everyone.
Viscounts and Villainy is a terrific wrap-up to an enjoyable series.
I enjoyed revisiting this one in audio - Joel Leslie can be a bit hit-and-miss for me (I've realised his American-accented narrations don't work as well for me as his English-accented ones!) but he's fabulous as cynical, snarky Wesley, who is gradually discovering that perhaps he's not quite the arrogant arsehole everyone thinks he is and that maybe he does have a heart after all - and that it's been stolen by a gorgeous, cheeky Spaniard who likes to see the best in everyone.
Viscounts and Villainy is a terrific wrap-up to an enjoyable series.
July 15, 2025
Such a great ending to a great series. We get to see different parts of them, feelings growing, their partnership stronger than ever, facing danger with far more to lose than when everything started.
Sebastian is without magic after sacrificing it to save Wesley, and he's coping. While Wesley feels guilty and very protective, maybe a bit too protective, treating Seb like he could break. But Seb is much stronger than everyone could imagine, his sweet disposition doesn't make him weak, and Wesley sees that clearly when they embark in this last mission to uncover who has plans to destroy all magic. Infiltrating Wesley's world posing like aristocracy is hard on Wesley because Seb has to wear fancy clothes that make him look even more delicious than before. The self restraint on Wes should earn him a prize or something. He wanted to devour Sebastian, to keep him from anyone else. That man afraid of feelings has so many of them he blushes, blushes ffs! Adorable and so in love.
Theories I thought improbable were confirmed true, mysteries were not solved by my poor detective skills, but I nevertheless enjoyed every second of it. I flew through the pages so fast I thought the book was super short because why is it already 80%, I just started?? It was a page-turner delight!
I am sad this is goodbye; the epilogue made me so happy and when it was over I suddenly realised that was it, that was the last words I'd read about Seb, Wesley, Arthur, Rory, Jade, Zhang, Mateo and everyone else who accompanied the MCs on this dangerous journey where luckily for them, it brought them the loves of their lives!
Sebastian is without magic after sacrificing it to save Wesley, and he's coping. While Wesley feels guilty and very protective, maybe a bit too protective, treating Seb like he could break. But Seb is much stronger than everyone could imagine, his sweet disposition doesn't make him weak, and Wesley sees that clearly when they embark in this last mission to uncover who has plans to destroy all magic. Infiltrating Wesley's world posing like aristocracy is hard on Wesley because Seb has to wear fancy clothes that make him look even more delicious than before. The self restraint on Wes should earn him a prize or something. He wanted to devour Sebastian, to keep him from anyone else. That man afraid of feelings has so many of them he blushes, blushes ffs! Adorable and so in love.
Theories I thought improbable were confirmed true, mysteries were not solved by my poor detective skills, but I nevertheless enjoyed every second of it. I flew through the pages so fast I thought the book was super short because why is it already 80%, I just started?? It was a page-turner delight!
I am sad this is goodbye; the epilogue made me so happy and when it was over I suddenly realised that was it, that was the last words I'd read about Seb, Wesley, Arthur, Rory, Jade, Zhang, Mateo and everyone else who accompanied the MCs on this dangerous journey where luckily for them, it brought them the loves of their lives!
July 3, 2025
It hurts me to rate this at three stars. 😩 I LOVE Allie Therin. I love Wes and Sebastian and Arthur and Rory and Jade and Zhang! And this book was SO sweet— but it had no plot.
If you are here for the romance, Viscounts and Villainy has it in spades. Wesley is so head over heels for Sebastian, so changed by his love. They are adorable and sexy together in the most satisfying way. But there is a plot afoot!
Or is there? 🤔 supposedly, someone was pulling Alistair’s strings. Someone was after Hyde. Someone had a nefarious plot to unlock the last two relics and destroy magic once and for all. That’s what we’re told— but the details are so vague and distant, they may as well have been happening in a different book. THIS book was about a lonely viscount who finally found his soulmate after years of malcontent. It was about affection and emotion and the sacrifices you make for the people you love… which is all well and good, except NOTHING happened.
After 300 pages of kisses and affirmations, Wesley went on a hunt, and Seb got his magic back and— TA-DA! Problem solved. 🤷🏻♀️ The fate of the magical world was restored with relative ease, and everyone lived happily ever after!
The best part of this book was a gold band on Rory’s finger. I LOVE this series, and this book was the warm and fuzzy end poor, sweet, emotionally starved Wes deserved, but I was expecting so much more from the mystery/adventure. Oh, well! If you’ll excuse me, I’ll just be sitting here, impatiently waiting for Edge of Mercy.
If you are here for the romance, Viscounts and Villainy has it in spades. Wesley is so head over heels for Sebastian, so changed by his love. They are adorable and sexy together in the most satisfying way. But there is a plot afoot!
Or is there? 🤔 supposedly, someone was pulling Alistair’s strings. Someone was after Hyde. Someone had a nefarious plot to unlock the last two relics and destroy magic once and for all. That’s what we’re told— but the details are so vague and distant, they may as well have been happening in a different book. THIS book was about a lonely viscount who finally found his soulmate after years of malcontent. It was about affection and emotion and the sacrifices you make for the people you love… which is all well and good, except NOTHING happened.
After 300 pages of kisses and affirmations, Wesley went on a hunt, and Seb got his magic back and— TA-DA! Problem solved. 🤷🏻♀️ The fate of the magical world was restored with relative ease, and everyone lived happily ever after!
The best part of this book was a gold band on Rory’s finger. I LOVE this series, and this book was the warm and fuzzy end poor, sweet, emotionally starved Wes deserved, but I was expecting so much more from the mystery/adventure. Oh, well! If you’ll excuse me, I’ll just be sitting here, impatiently waiting for Edge of Mercy.
April 18, 2025
I read the NetGalley eARC, and this is my honest review:
What a great end to the second trilogy of this series! I'm so very glad that I "met" the author via Twitter and gave her work a try. *happy sigh*
What a great end to the second trilogy of this series! I'm so very glad that I "met" the author via Twitter and gave her work a try. *happy sigh*
July 2, 2025
This isn't my favorite Allie Therin book. Honestly, there is almost nothing happening the majority of this book. But let's be real I'm here for Wesley 🤷♀️ The sexy bastard. So four stars for Wesley. I'm going to miss him.
April 21, 2025
This last book of the trilogy has confirmed what I already knew: Wesley and Sebastian are my favorite couple of all this author´s have written.
It is always a delight to come back to this world of magic. And, in this particular case, we begin where we left in the last book: Sebastian has lost his powers and there is a mysterious someone who wants to use a relic to try and get rid of the paranormals. Now, first things first, this book is more mystery than action. Which I personally enjoyed very much.
Most of the plot happens during the trip through the Atlantic and at a Hunting retreat later in England. There are suspitions of paranormals missing (or possibly killed) and maybe one clue or two that Sebastian´s magic might not be lost forever in the unknown (I loved how this particular plot was solved, by the way, very satisfying).
We get the usual grumpy x sunshine dynamic here as well, and I have to praise how, even after all these books, the dynamic and the pinning between Sebastian and Wesley remains fresh and funny.
Overall, it was the perfect ending for this trilogy. Perhaps, if I were to complain about anything, I felt the ending a bit rushed. But just a tiny bit: At the same time, it doesn´t ocurr to me how could it have been done better, so there´s that. I also enjoyed seeing other characters from other Allie Therin´s stories and I hope there can ever be a spin off of the spin off (wait, is this a new concept?)
Anyway, very recommended.
It is always a delight to come back to this world of magic. And, in this particular case, we begin where we left in the last book: Sebastian has lost his powers and there is a mysterious someone who wants to use a relic to try and get rid of the paranormals. Now, first things first, this book is more mystery than action. Which I personally enjoyed very much.
Most of the plot happens during the trip through the Atlantic and at a Hunting retreat later in England. There are suspitions of paranormals missing (or possibly killed) and maybe one clue or two that Sebastian´s magic might not be lost forever in the unknown (I loved how this particular plot was solved, by the way, very satisfying).
We get the usual grumpy x sunshine dynamic here as well, and I have to praise how, even after all these books, the dynamic and the pinning between Sebastian and Wesley remains fresh and funny.
Overall, it was the perfect ending for this trilogy. Perhaps, if I were to complain about anything, I felt the ending a bit rushed. But just a tiny bit: At the same time, it doesn´t ocurr to me how could it have been done better, so there´s that. I also enjoyed seeing other characters from other Allie Therin´s stories and I hope there can ever be a spin off of the spin off (wait, is this a new concept?)
Anyway, very recommended.
July 6, 2025
4.25 stars from me. Loved Wesley's character growth, and the fact that Sebastian's magic reappeared just at the tight time 😉. Quite a lot of sexy times for an Allie Therin read too...
July 15, 2025
The book opens with Wesley, Sebastian, and Rory doing some bootlegging for Jade. Sebastian is still figuring out what it means to no longer have magic. This shifts quickly to the gang trying to figure out who is really behind the plot to rid the world of magic, and their conclusion sends them back to Europe and into Wesley’s world.
Viscounts and Villainy is the third book in the Roaring Twenties Magic series, and the sixth book in a set of connected series. These books are best when read in order, and I don’t recommend starting with this one since it’s the conclusion of a major story arc that spanned both series.
Viscounts and Villainy is filled with action, adventure, and romance. All the key players from both series are either mentioned or make an appearance. Therin wraps up the over-arching series plots and gives our characters their well-deserved happy endings. I absolutely adored seeing the hardened Lord Wesley Fine learn to love and be loved. He and Sebastian are both adorable and sexy together.
So here’s the thing… There are two years between the release dates for each of these books. The plots are complex, and I struggled to recall what happened previously. Even though the author does a good job including reminders from the earlier books, I still felt lost and that the story lacked continuity. And if one reads it as a standalone, it’s lacking the character and romance development because it has been occurring over the course of the series. I don’t want this to discourage anyone from reading the series, because I find the mythology fascinating and the romance sweet. However, I think these books would be best read within a few months of one another rather than over the course of four years.
In the end, I have mixed feelings about Viscounts and Villainy. As the concluding story for the series, the book brings it all together and gives readers the HEA. However, it was hard for me to fully immerse myself and enjoy the story since I felt disconnected, probably due to the long time since I read the previous book.
My Rating: C+
Review copy provided by the publisher
Originally posted at That's What I'm Talking About
Viscounts and Villainy is the third book in the Roaring Twenties Magic series, and the sixth book in a set of connected series. These books are best when read in order, and I don’t recommend starting with this one since it’s the conclusion of a major story arc that spanned both series.
Viscounts and Villainy is filled with action, adventure, and romance. All the key players from both series are either mentioned or make an appearance. Therin wraps up the over-arching series plots and gives our characters their well-deserved happy endings. I absolutely adored seeing the hardened Lord Wesley Fine learn to love and be loved. He and Sebastian are both adorable and sexy together.
So here’s the thing… There are two years between the release dates for each of these books. The plots are complex, and I struggled to recall what happened previously. Even though the author does a good job including reminders from the earlier books, I still felt lost and that the story lacked continuity. And if one reads it as a standalone, it’s lacking the character and romance development because it has been occurring over the course of the series. I don’t want this to discourage anyone from reading the series, because I find the mythology fascinating and the romance sweet. However, I think these books would be best read within a few months of one another rather than over the course of four years.
In the end, I have mixed feelings about Viscounts and Villainy. As the concluding story for the series, the book brings it all together and gives readers the HEA. However, it was hard for me to fully immerse myself and enjoy the story since I felt disconnected, probably due to the long time since I read the previous book.
My Rating: C+
Review copy provided by the publisher
Originally posted at That's What I'm Talking About
July 11, 2025
4.25 stars
I feel sad that this is the final book of this universe and I had to say goodbye to the whole gang. What I loved the most from this one was Wesley's character's growth.
Yes, Wesley Collins, Viscount Fine, stayed true to himself being curmudgeon lord, but he finally admitted (albeit not using literal ones, because he's BAD WITH actual WORDS 😆) his feelings towards Sebastian. I loved how Wesley was trying to keep his Sebastian happy - that part with the fox hunt was ADORABLE!
Sebastian was still the wonderful marshmallow that he was. If in the second book he questioned a lot on why Wesley would like to be with the likes of him, I am happy to report that it wasn't the case here. I also loved that Sebastian did accept the lost of his magic, because he did it for Wes, and he didn't have any regrets.
On that note, I also loved that Wesley wasn't written into one being so full of guilt - and instead he supported Sebastian in the way that he could (that part when Sebastian got drunk was also cute!).
Allie Therin definitely threw crumbs about what really happened with Sebastian's magic () - and I was so satisfied with that.
Again, so sad that this is the end of this universe. I wish them all the finest of life!
I feel sad that this is the final book of this universe and I had to say goodbye to the whole gang. What I loved the most from this one was Wesley's character's growth.
Yes, Wesley Collins, Viscount Fine, stayed true to himself being curmudgeon lord, but he finally admitted (albeit not using literal ones, because he's BAD WITH actual WORDS 😆) his feelings towards Sebastian. I loved how Wesley was trying to keep his Sebastian happy - that part with the fox hunt was ADORABLE!
Sebastian was still the wonderful marshmallow that he was. If in the second book he questioned a lot on why Wesley would like to be with the likes of him, I am happy to report that it wasn't the case here. I also loved that Sebastian did accept the lost of his magic, because he did it for Wes, and he didn't have any regrets.
On that note, I also loved that Wesley wasn't written into one being so full of guilt - and instead he supported Sebastian in the way that he could (that part when Sebastian got drunk was also cute!).
Allie Therin definitely threw crumbs about what really happened with Sebastian's magic () - and I was so satisfied with that.
Again, so sad that this is the end of this universe. I wish them all the finest of life!
August 25, 2025
A fun end to this series. The overarching plot wraps up nicely, if a little abruptly, but let's be real, this series is about the ultimate grumpy/sunshine pairing and Wesley falling in love despite his best intentions. I feel like this series is more than a little slept on, but if you like KJ Charles (especially the Magpies series) or Freya Marske, pick up the first one - there are two trilogies, but they definitely need to be read in order. Start with Spellbound and you will not be sorry. I just wish there were more in this world!
(SBTB Summer Bingo: character living abroad. Would work for immigrant MC, magic, yellow/orange cover, or paranormal.)
(SBTB Summer Bingo: character living abroad. Would work for immigrant MC, magic, yellow/orange cover, or paranormal.)
August 13, 2025
Had such a good time I considered a 5 star but I remain annoying.
I will need to reread all these eventually but thanks for the ARC and the absolutely obscene amount of squealing and feet kicking I did reading about these doorknobs one last time.
I will need to reread all these eventually but thanks for the ARC and the absolutely obscene amount of squealing and feet kicking I did reading about these doorknobs one last time.
April 17, 2025
Thank yout to Netgalley and Carina Press for the eARC
This is the conclusion of a trilogy, itself being the spinn off of another trilogy. Both of which I LOVED. Somehow, I was less hooked with 'Viscounts and Villainy'. I felt like thing were repeated a little too much for my liking, with a very straighforward plot. Which, let me be clear, was already present in the previous book, I was simply less bothered by it, being in a better mood. I suspect that when I reread this last book of Wesley and Sebastian's adventures, I might have a different opinion, and so I will try to write the rest of this review with that in mind.
In this tome, Wesley learns to be more vulnerable while still being his viscounty self, especially since their chase for the artefacts lead them back to England, among Wesley's peers. Sebastian, for his part, also need to compose with his own new vulnerabily after the events of book 2, even though it is quite clear since the beginning that things will get better. They both struggle, and yet never their relationship is questionned, only strengthened. It is nice to read, in a hopeful cosy way.
Jade and Zhang, as well as Arthur and Rory really play a sidekick role, either going on their own chase in another part of Europe or staying back in a village. Fair enough, it is Wesley and Sebastian's story after all.
The mystery/paranormal plot is all right. By that I mean that it works for its purpose of adding something to the romantic tension and moving the story forward by giving the characters something to do. Nothing too complicated, still enternaining.
Overall, a nice read and fair conclusion to the trilogy. I hope I will enjoy more once I reread it in a better headspace.
This is the conclusion of a trilogy, itself being the spinn off of another trilogy. Both of which I LOVED. Somehow, I was less hooked with 'Viscounts and Villainy'. I felt like thing were repeated a little too much for my liking, with a very straighforward plot. Which, let me be clear, was already present in the previous book, I was simply less bothered by it, being in a better mood. I suspect that when I reread this last book of Wesley and Sebastian's adventures, I might have a different opinion, and so I will try to write the rest of this review with that in mind.
In this tome, Wesley learns to be more vulnerable while still being his viscounty self, especially since their chase for the artefacts lead them back to England, among Wesley's peers. Sebastian, for his part, also need to compose with his own new vulnerabily after the events of book 2, even though it is quite clear since the beginning that things will get better. They both struggle, and yet never their relationship is questionned, only strengthened. It is nice to read, in a hopeful cosy way.
Jade and Zhang, as well as Arthur and Rory really play a sidekick role, either going on their own chase in another part of Europe or staying back in a village. Fair enough, it is Wesley and Sebastian's story after all.
The mystery/paranormal plot is all right. By that I mean that it works for its purpose of adding something to the romantic tension and moving the story forward by giving the characters something to do. Nothing too complicated, still enternaining.
Overall, a nice read and fair conclusion to the trilogy. I hope I will enjoy more once I reread it in a better headspace.
June 8, 2025
Wesley is up there as one of my favorite characters! My partner likes to say it's because I'm also allergic to feelings but I like to think it's more about his arc, his growth throughout the three books (and sure, that part of him resonate with me). There's a subtlety and nuance to how his character grows, almost as if it sneaks up on him. It's both hilarious and heartwarming.
I don't think I've talked about Allie's talent for blending comedic moments and funny quips with tender, heartfelt actions. I laughed out loud several times while reading this and it made it all the more enjoyable.
Sebastian is possibly the kindest, sweetest person. I understand where Wesley is coming from: what do you do with someone who is so selfless, someone who loves deeply and gives that love so freely?! It's magical. And I also loved seeing moments between Arthur and Rory. Rory is another character I can't get enough of so the vulnerable moments he shares with Wesley and Sebastian were favorites of mine.
Plot-wise, I was once again so invested in the story and the characters that I didn't try very hard to figure things out. Sure, one aspect wasn't a surprise but plenty of others were. Just like in Wonderstruck, Wesley and Sebastian's story ends perfectly. It'd be easy to keep the story going, to give us more of their adventures and their love, but we don't need it for everything to feel complete.
I will never shut up about these books. I will recommend them to EVERYONE and cheer loudly when new people fall in love with them!
Many thanks to NetGalley, Carina Press, and the author for providing a copy in exchange for an honest review.
I don't think I've talked about Allie's talent for blending comedic moments and funny quips with tender, heartfelt actions. I laughed out loud several times while reading this and it made it all the more enjoyable.
Sebastian is possibly the kindest, sweetest person. I understand where Wesley is coming from: what do you do with someone who is so selfless, someone who loves deeply and gives that love so freely?! It's magical. And I also loved seeing moments between Arthur and Rory. Rory is another character I can't get enough of so the vulnerable moments he shares with Wesley and Sebastian were favorites of mine.
Plot-wise, I was once again so invested in the story and the characters that I didn't try very hard to figure things out. Sure, one aspect wasn't a surprise but plenty of others were. Just like in Wonderstruck, Wesley and Sebastian's story ends perfectly. It'd be easy to keep the story going, to give us more of their adventures and their love, but we don't need it for everything to feel complete.
I will never shut up about these books. I will recommend them to EVERYONE and cheer loudly when new people fall in love with them!
Many thanks to NetGalley, Carina Press, and the author for providing a copy in exchange for an honest review.
January 3, 2026
I wish I could give it a higher rating! I love the characters, but find the plot complicated/convoluted unless you read them back to back.
I found it hard to remember some of the details from the previous books, especially all of the villains we’ve met along the way. The book would benefit from stronger callbacks to the previous plot lines (which are needed to understand how things are connected in this book).
I love that the author includes characters from previous books, but it feels like we barely see them! Most are on their own side quests that we never see and get little payout for it. I wish there were novellas or periodic chapters from the POV of some of the side characters and their missions.
I also wish there was more world-building related to the magic itself. I just go along with it and suspend my belief, but I wish it actually spelled out more of how the magic works in this world.
I still love the characters themselves and their growth! I could read this as just a romance novel between Wes and Sebastian and be happy. But I do wish the plot of saving magic was easier to follow, or at least as strong as the romance.
I found it hard to remember some of the details from the previous books, especially all of the villains we’ve met along the way. The book would benefit from stronger callbacks to the previous plot lines (which are needed to understand how things are connected in this book).
I love that the author includes characters from previous books, but it feels like we barely see them! Most are on their own side quests that we never see and get little payout for it. I wish there were novellas or periodic chapters from the POV of some of the side characters and their missions.
I also wish there was more world-building related to the magic itself. I just go along with it and suspend my belief, but I wish it actually spelled out more of how the magic works in this world.
I still love the characters themselves and their growth! I could read this as just a romance novel between Wes and Sebastian and be happy. But I do wish the plot of saving magic was easier to follow, or at least as strong as the romance.
July 1, 2025
A Joyfully Jay review.
4.5 stars
Viscounts & Villainy is the third book in Allie Therin’s Roaring Twenties Magic trilogy, a spin-off on the author’s fabulous Magic in Manhattan series. You are definitely going to want to read this series in order, as the plot builds across the books. And honestly, to get the most enjoyment from these books, I suggest starting with the first series. All these books are amazing and I can’t recommend them highly enough, so do yourself a favor and start from the beginning.
I am so glad that Therin decided to give these two Magic in Manhattan side characters their own trilogy, because I have found these books just fabulous. The stories are exciting and the characters are wonderful and this trilogy has been so much fun. If you haven’t checked these books out, I highly recommend them.
Read Jay’s review in its entirety here.
4.5 stars
Viscounts & Villainy is the third book in Allie Therin’s Roaring Twenties Magic trilogy, a spin-off on the author’s fabulous Magic in Manhattan series. You are definitely going to want to read this series in order, as the plot builds across the books. And honestly, to get the most enjoyment from these books, I suggest starting with the first series. All these books are amazing and I can’t recommend them highly enough, so do yourself a favor and start from the beginning.
I am so glad that Therin decided to give these two Magic in Manhattan side characters their own trilogy, because I have found these books just fabulous. The stories are exciting and the characters are wonderful and this trilogy has been so much fun. If you haven’t checked these books out, I highly recommend them.
Read Jay’s review in its entirety here.
July 5, 2025
OMG ... I so loved this one. I fell in love with Arthur and Brody in their book series and thought they were perfect but Wesley trumped them both
this is the perfect last book in this series and Wesley and Sebastian are just perfect. PERFECT!!!!
I think Wesley is my favorite character in all 6 books. I loved seeing the different sides of him
I won't say anything about the plot, because it would spoiler the fun. I just say - it is so well done!!!
this series must be read in order - to really enjoy it, you should start with Arthur and Brody
definetely one of my favorites in this year
this is the perfect last book in this series and Wesley and Sebastian are just perfect. PERFECT!!!!
I think Wesley is my favorite character in all 6 books. I loved seeing the different sides of him
I won't say anything about the plot, because it would spoiler the fun. I just say - it is so well done!!!
this series must be read in order - to really enjoy it, you should start with Arthur and Brody
definetely one of my favorites in this year
July 20, 2025
I. Love. This. Series. So. Much.
Wesley and Sebastian are the perfect example of the grumpy/sunshine trope, and I’ve loved every minute of their journey. This has been such a a fun magical setting (and to be honest I would happily read 20 more books set in this world).
I especially appreciated the way everything wrapped up in this final installment. It was the perfect ending to a perfect series! 10 out of 10. Absolutely recommend!
Wesley and Sebastian are the perfect example of the grumpy/sunshine trope, and I’ve loved every minute of their journey. This has been such a a fun magical setting (and to be honest I would happily read 20 more books set in this world).
I especially appreciated the way everything wrapped up in this final installment. It was the perfect ending to a perfect series! 10 out of 10. Absolutely recommend!
July 21, 2025
nooooo I'm so sad this trilogy is over 😭😭 I need a hundred more books just like this
I love Wesley and Sebastian so damn much and the ending to this magic plot was really good too, I love a historical fantasy romance
I love Wesley and Sebastian so damn much and the ending to this magic plot was really good too, I love a historical fantasy romance
Read
July 1, 2025Me before reading: I hope this book ends with [redacted]
Allie Therin: ends book with [redacted]
Truly, the people's champion 🫡
Allie Therin: ends book with [redacted]
Truly, the people's champion 🫡
July 5, 2025
I love these characters so much and i got to love the world and setting a lot as well. This was such a perfect finale to the trilogy and I can't wait to read more from Allie Therin
July 28, 2025
3.75 stars
December 8, 2025
4,5 stars
Displaying 1 - 30 of 141 reviews