What do you think?
Rate this book
Moonville #2
The Folklore of Forever
From the acclaimed author of
Old Flames and New Fortunes
comes a steamy enemies-to-lovers romantasy about a paranormal skeptic who is roped into a ghost hunting romp by the charming boy next door . . . who might just show her what real fantasies are made of.
Paranormal skeptic Zelda Tempest is hoping for a much-needed creativity boost for a new paranormal mystery novel. But despite the alleged magic of her hometown, Moonville, Ohio, she’s as stuck as ever.
With two witch sisters, not believing in magic is strange for a Tempest, but no one is more disappointed than Morgan Angelopoulos, the charming man next door. So, to cure her of her writer's block and her disbelief in magic, Morgan ropes her into a ghost-hunting romp, only for Zelda to discover something else bizarre, never-before-seen creatures that appear as ordinary pets to everyone else.
Curious about what else might be lurking in Moonville's woods, Zelda and Morgan embark on a quest to uncover the true magic that lies in their midsts . . . and perhaps, just maybe, they will find that the magic they're searching for has been with them all along.
Paranormal skeptic Zelda Tempest is hoping for a much-needed creativity boost for a new paranormal mystery novel. But despite the alleged magic of her hometown, Moonville, Ohio, she’s as stuck as ever.
With two witch sisters, not believing in magic is strange for a Tempest, but no one is more disappointed than Morgan Angelopoulos, the charming man next door. So, to cure her of her writer's block and her disbelief in magic, Morgan ropes her into a ghost-hunting romp, only for Zelda to discover something else bizarre, never-before-seen creatures that appear as ordinary pets to everyone else.
Curious about what else might be lurking in Moonville's woods, Zelda and Morgan embark on a quest to uncover the true magic that lies in their midsts . . . and perhaps, just maybe, they will find that the magic they're searching for has been with them all along.
Audible Audio
First published April 8, 2025
83 people are currently reading
5382 people want to read
About the author
Sarah Hogle
8 books4,101 followersSarah Hogle is a mom of three who enjoys trashy TV and provoking her husband for attention. Her dream is to live in a falling-apart castle in a forest that is probably cursed. Her novels are You Deserve Each Other, Twice Shy, Just Like Magic, and Old Flames and New Fortunes.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 573 reviews
November 19, 2025
i've been robbed.
i have been victim to a theft. i have been divested of my valuables. i am the pearl-laden old rich lady at the beginning of a boring mystery bemoaning the loss of her jewels.
i love sarah hogle books, and i love ghosts (which this book is, kinda, about), but in my rom-coms i love banter and yearning and drama.
instead of the goofy romantic romp i expected, these characters never seem to even like each other and things were paced oddly and i didn't have fun.
and unfortunately, while i love an unpopular opinion, i have to concede to the dominant reason this book's average rating is so low.
the guy in it really does suck.
but above all, the concept of this is just strange. in the first book in the trilogy, we meet a witchy girl who lives above her witchy store with her two witchy sisters and her witchy niece.
this book is about the sister who is witchy, and has the witchy sisters and the store and the niece and what have you, and also additionally a successful witchy romance series set in a fictionalized witchy version of her witchy town, and yet...
she doesn't believe any of it and thinks her dearest loved ones, from her grandma to the child she lives with, are lying.
this is annoying and mean! if my sisters told me with their heart in their eyes that i was built upside down and backwards i'd believe them. that's what sisterhood is.
so we spend 300 pages while this quirky mean girl falls in love with a sucky guy and also decides to believe everyone when it becomes convenient for her. there is not much to like about it.
our protagonist in this book is an author struggling to write her next book, and after reading this choppy, strange, un-sarah-hogle-y story, i can't help but wonder if that hits close to home for the author.
bottom line: my tbr review said sarah hogle!!!!!!!!! but now i'm more like ...sarah hogle?
(2.5 / thanks to the publisher for the e-arc)
i have been victim to a theft. i have been divested of my valuables. i am the pearl-laden old rich lady at the beginning of a boring mystery bemoaning the loss of her jewels.
i love sarah hogle books, and i love ghosts (which this book is, kinda, about), but in my rom-coms i love banter and yearning and drama.
instead of the goofy romantic romp i expected, these characters never seem to even like each other and things were paced oddly and i didn't have fun.
and unfortunately, while i love an unpopular opinion, i have to concede to the dominant reason this book's average rating is so low.
the guy in it really does suck.
but above all, the concept of this is just strange. in the first book in the trilogy, we meet a witchy girl who lives above her witchy store with her two witchy sisters and her witchy niece.
this book is about the sister who is witchy, and has the witchy sisters and the store and the niece and what have you, and also additionally a successful witchy romance series set in a fictionalized witchy version of her witchy town, and yet...
she doesn't believe any of it and thinks her dearest loved ones, from her grandma to the child she lives with, are lying.
this is annoying and mean! if my sisters told me with their heart in their eyes that i was built upside down and backwards i'd believe them. that's what sisterhood is.
so we spend 300 pages while this quirky mean girl falls in love with a sucky guy and also decides to believe everyone when it becomes convenient for her. there is not much to like about it.
our protagonist in this book is an author struggling to write her next book, and after reading this choppy, strange, un-sarah-hogle-y story, i can't help but wonder if that hits close to home for the author.
bottom line: my tbr review said sarah hogle!!!!!!!!! but now i'm more like ...sarah hogle?
(2.5 / thanks to the publisher for the e-arc)
May 4, 2025
3.5 STARS! 🌟 Huge thanks to PENGUIN GROUP Putnam | G.P. Putnam's Sons for the ARC via NetGalley! 💌
Okay, so let’s talk about Morgan… because what in the ADHD gremlin hell was that man doing for the first chunk of this book??? I was ready to throw hands. He had zero chill, maximum chaos and major red flag energy at times. The man was a MENACE—but the annoying, lovable, idiot kind. Did I want to strangle him? Yes. Did he grow on me anyway? ALSO YES. 😭
Zelda, our FMC, is the ultimate "I don't believe in magic" skeptic… despite literally living in Moonville, Ohio, the magical capital of weirdness. Girl, be so serious. But once she gets roped into ghost-hunting shenanigans with Morgan, things get WAY weirder than expected. There are mystical creatures, questionable potions, and enough hijinks to make you question reality.
Now, let’s address the elephant in the room—the first 20%? A STRUGGLE. I genuinely thought I was going to hate this. The tone was all over the place, and Morgan was giving "needs therapy and a nap" energy. But somehow this book reeled me back in! Once the story committed to its magical chaos, I was having so much fun.
By the end? I was charmed. The banter was hilarious, the magical elements were so creative, and despite all my early frustrations, I actually loved Zelda and Morgan together. Do I think this was a perfect romance? No. But do I think it was a ridiculously fun, messy, magical ride? Absolutely.
Would I let Morgan gaslight, gatekeep, and girlboss his way into my life? Probably not.
Would I read about him doing it to someone else? Oh, for sure.
Final thoughts: If you love Sarah Hogle’s brand of hilarious, unhinged romcom energy, this one will probably work for you! Just prepare to suffer a little first.
Now… Luna’s book when?! 👀✨
Okay, so let’s talk about Morgan… because what in the ADHD gremlin hell was that man doing for the first chunk of this book??? I was ready to throw hands. He had zero chill, maximum chaos and major red flag energy at times. The man was a MENACE—but the annoying, lovable, idiot kind. Did I want to strangle him? Yes. Did he grow on me anyway? ALSO YES. 😭
Zelda, our FMC, is the ultimate "I don't believe in magic" skeptic… despite literally living in Moonville, Ohio, the magical capital of weirdness. Girl, be so serious. But once she gets roped into ghost-hunting shenanigans with Morgan, things get WAY weirder than expected. There are mystical creatures, questionable potions, and enough hijinks to make you question reality.
Now, let’s address the elephant in the room—the first 20%? A STRUGGLE. I genuinely thought I was going to hate this. The tone was all over the place, and Morgan was giving "needs therapy and a nap" energy. But somehow this book reeled me back in! Once the story committed to its magical chaos, I was having so much fun.
By the end? I was charmed. The banter was hilarious, the magical elements were so creative, and despite all my early frustrations, I actually loved Zelda and Morgan together. Do I think this was a perfect romance? No. But do I think it was a ridiculously fun, messy, magical ride? Absolutely.
Would I let Morgan gaslight, gatekeep, and girlboss his way into my life? Probably not.
Would I read about him doing it to someone else? Oh, for sure.
Final thoughts: If you love Sarah Hogle’s brand of hilarious, unhinged romcom energy, this one will probably work for you! Just prepare to suffer a little first.
Now… Luna’s book when?! 👀✨
October 2, 2025
“The Folklore of Forever” takes readers back to Moonville, Ohio, a town steeped in mystery and magic, as we follow Zelda Tempest on a journey to rediscover the magic she’s spent her life denying. Sarah Hogle expertly blends humor, romance, and the supernatural in this quirky tale. While Zelda’s neurotic tendencies and skepticism make her an engaging and relatable protagonist, Morgan, the charming and mischievous neighbor, provides an eccentric contrast that, while occasionally grating, ultimately complements Zelda's transformation.
The story shines in its lighthearted moments, with laugh-out-loud banter and whimsical touches like unusual magical creatures and eccentric ghost-hunting adventures. Hogle’s vivid descriptions breathe life into Moonville, and the enchanting setting pulls readers into the mystery, even when the magic system and plot points can feel a bit muddled. Despite some confusing elements, such as the mechanics of magic and certain plot twists that come out of nowhere, The Folklore of Forever delivers a heartwarming narrative about self-discovery and unexpected love.
Though the romance itself is more of a slow burn than an intense passion, the witty dialogue and emotional depth keep the story moving at a good pace. Zelda’s gradual acceptance of both magic and love feels earned, and while Morgan’s motives may feel questionable at times, their dynamic eventually clicks in a satisfying, if not overly conventional, way. Fans of Hogle’s previous work will enjoy revisiting Moonville and its cast of characters, even if this book leans more into comedy than pure romantasy.
Overall, The Folklore of Forever may not be for everyone, especially those seeking a straightforward romance, but its charm, humor, and magical whimsy make it a delightful, if slightly flawed, read.
Many thanks to NetGalley and PENGUIN GROUP Putnam | G.P. Putnam's Sons for sharing this lovely romantasy's digital reviewer copy with me in exchange of my honest thoughts.
medium.com
instagram
facebook
twitter
The story shines in its lighthearted moments, with laugh-out-loud banter and whimsical touches like unusual magical creatures and eccentric ghost-hunting adventures. Hogle’s vivid descriptions breathe life into Moonville, and the enchanting setting pulls readers into the mystery, even when the magic system and plot points can feel a bit muddled. Despite some confusing elements, such as the mechanics of magic and certain plot twists that come out of nowhere, The Folklore of Forever delivers a heartwarming narrative about self-discovery and unexpected love.
Though the romance itself is more of a slow burn than an intense passion, the witty dialogue and emotional depth keep the story moving at a good pace. Zelda’s gradual acceptance of both magic and love feels earned, and while Morgan’s motives may feel questionable at times, their dynamic eventually clicks in a satisfying, if not overly conventional, way. Fans of Hogle’s previous work will enjoy revisiting Moonville and its cast of characters, even if this book leans more into comedy than pure romantasy.
Overall, The Folklore of Forever may not be for everyone, especially those seeking a straightforward romance, but its charm, humor, and magical whimsy make it a delightful, if slightly flawed, read.
Many thanks to NetGalley and PENGUIN GROUP Putnam | G.P. Putnam's Sons for sharing this lovely romantasy's digital reviewer copy with me in exchange of my honest thoughts.
medium.com
November 22, 2025
The Folklore of Forever is the 2nd-book in the Moonville series by Sarah Hogle. If I'm understanding it correctly, these are companion novels following various characters in the town of Moonville, Ohio.
The 1st-book, and this one, follow sisters, but I'm not sure if all the books are going to follow sisters in this family, who are maybe witches, or if other townsfolk will be included. Nevertheless, it includes many whimsical witchy vibes.
In this one, we're following Zelda Tempest, a paranormal skeptic, and Morgan Angelopoulos, a ghost-hunting podcast host with a deep desire for magic.
Zelda's family, the Tempests, include a history of alleged witches, including her two sisters, but Zelda doesn't get down with all of that. Even though she's made her living writing paranormal mystery books, she's not a believer.
She's recently returned to her hometown of Moonville with a case of writer's block, hoping it will inspire her creativity in some way. It's there she begins having run-ins with the handsome man next door, Morgan.
Morgan ends up convincing Zelda to go on one of his ghost-hunting romps with him, exploring a local haunted property, and it's during this night out that Zelda discovers something disturbing about herself. She can see whimsical creatures lurking in the Moonville woods that no one else can see.
Maybe her sisters aren't just faking it. Perhaps she has magical powers too? She and Morgan pair up and lean into Zelda's creature spotting abilities, delving deep into Moonville's woods to see what else could be hidden there.
This was such an oddly-composed book. I felt compelled to keep reading, but couldn't really understand why?
It's hard to explain. It's not bad by any stretch, but yeah, definitely just a head-scratching, middle of road experience for me. It's also a bit outside my comfort zone, as I don't tend to vibe well with light-whimsical stories. I prefer a lot of dark, danger and dread with my whimsy.
Additionally, the story itself was ALL over the place. It was enchanting, but in a Luna Lovegood-when you first meet her-kind of way.
You wonder, is she okay? And of course, she is, she's great, but at times hard to understand.
The writing style is eccentric, and both the character interactions and the plot felt chaotic. With this being said though, I did enjoy watching the relationship between Zelda and Morgan develop.
While it was certainly the oddest Romance book I've ever read, I think for people who enjoy this type of story, especially the Cottagecore vibes, this could work quite well.
It does get really wild towards the end. I was laughing out loud, like it really got that wild. It was fun though. I certainly never could have predicted all that happened.
I am interested, believe it or not, in picking up the other books in this series. As oddly compelling as it is, I want to get the other sister's stories as well.
Thank you to the publisher, G.P. Putnam's Sons, for providing me with a copy to read and review. Even though a little out of my element, I still enjoyed my time with this.
The 1st-book, and this one, follow sisters, but I'm not sure if all the books are going to follow sisters in this family, who are maybe witches, or if other townsfolk will be included. Nevertheless, it includes many whimsical witchy vibes.
In this one, we're following Zelda Tempest, a paranormal skeptic, and Morgan Angelopoulos, a ghost-hunting podcast host with a deep desire for magic.
Zelda's family, the Tempests, include a history of alleged witches, including her two sisters, but Zelda doesn't get down with all of that. Even though she's made her living writing paranormal mystery books, she's not a believer.
She's recently returned to her hometown of Moonville with a case of writer's block, hoping it will inspire her creativity in some way. It's there she begins having run-ins with the handsome man next door, Morgan.
Morgan ends up convincing Zelda to go on one of his ghost-hunting romps with him, exploring a local haunted property, and it's during this night out that Zelda discovers something disturbing about herself. She can see whimsical creatures lurking in the Moonville woods that no one else can see.
Maybe her sisters aren't just faking it. Perhaps she has magical powers too? She and Morgan pair up and lean into Zelda's creature spotting abilities, delving deep into Moonville's woods to see what else could be hidden there.
This was such an oddly-composed book. I felt compelled to keep reading, but couldn't really understand why?
It's hard to explain. It's not bad by any stretch, but yeah, definitely just a head-scratching, middle of road experience for me. It's also a bit outside my comfort zone, as I don't tend to vibe well with light-whimsical stories. I prefer a lot of dark, danger and dread with my whimsy.
Additionally, the story itself was ALL over the place. It was enchanting, but in a Luna Lovegood-when you first meet her-kind of way.
You wonder, is she okay? And of course, she is, she's great, but at times hard to understand.
The writing style is eccentric, and both the character interactions and the plot felt chaotic. With this being said though, I did enjoy watching the relationship between Zelda and Morgan develop.
While it was certainly the oddest Romance book I've ever read, I think for people who enjoy this type of story, especially the Cottagecore vibes, this could work quite well.
It does get really wild towards the end. I was laughing out loud, like it really got that wild. It was fun though. I certainly never could have predicted all that happened.
I am interested, believe it or not, in picking up the other books in this series. As oddly compelling as it is, I want to get the other sister's stories as well.
Thank you to the publisher, G.P. Putnam's Sons, for providing me with a copy to read and review. Even though a little out of my element, I still enjoyed my time with this.
April 10, 2025
2.5 Messy ✨'s
This was such a messy and convoluted read! From the characters to the plot and the abysmal romance, every minute of reading this was so lackluster. Our FMC and MMC are both supposed to be extremely quirky and different, but I just found them plain obnoxious. Their weird banter and offhanded dialogue was completely unnecessary and cringey. Not to mention, the random timeskips and in between where they wouldn't talk or see each other for weeks had me questioning whether this was even a romance. The only saving grace to the story was the whimsical nature and lore of the magical plot, I loved all the small town stories and how that tied in with the ghost hunting, magical investigations, and witch search throughout the book. Overall, I can't say that I would recommend this story, however, I do think the first book is worth a try, and I'm not quite ready to give up on the series. I seriously hope the next one is better!
~Many thanks to Putnam for and ARC of this book in return for an honest review.
This was such a messy and convoluted read! From the characters to the plot and the abysmal romance, every minute of reading this was so lackluster. Our FMC and MMC are both supposed to be extremely quirky and different, but I just found them plain obnoxious. Their weird banter and offhanded dialogue was completely unnecessary and cringey. Not to mention, the random timeskips and in between where they wouldn't talk or see each other for weeks had me questioning whether this was even a romance. The only saving grace to the story was the whimsical nature and lore of the magical plot, I loved all the small town stories and how that tied in with the ghost hunting, magical investigations, and witch search throughout the book. Overall, I can't say that I would recommend this story, however, I do think the first book is worth a try, and I'm not quite ready to give up on the series. I seriously hope the next one is better!
~Many thanks to Putnam for and ARC of this book in return for an honest review.
April 25, 2025
3 stars
I am such a Sarah Hogle fan, and I wanted to love this one, but unfortunately, it was just okay for me. I don’t love magical books, but I sometimes read them if there is an epic romance. I liked the first book in the series, but the romance in this just didn’t hit for me.
I am such a Sarah Hogle fan, and I wanted to love this one, but unfortunately, it was just okay for me. I don’t love magical books, but I sometimes read them if there is an epic romance. I liked the first book in the series, but the romance in this just didn’t hit for me.
Audio book source: Libby
Story Rating: 3 stars
Narrators: Mara Wilson
Narration Rating: 4 stars
Genre: Magical Realism/Romance
Length: 11h
April 20, 2025
This book seems like a collection of good plots, but struggles to fully deliver on them in a way that is just a bit unsatisfying. I think if it had focused more on one path, it would have been so much more enjoyable-a maybe witch struggling to come to terms with her powers in a family of believers, a mystical animal hunt/mystery, a redemption romance? I struggled to like either of the main characters-they’d go from being nearly endearing to insensibly off the wall with no lead up in a way that didn’t feel quirky or charming, and I didn’t root for them the way I wanted to. The third act was repeatedly nonsensical and I ended up skimming the last 20% to avoid DNF-ing. Overall I think this book had a few great concepts, but didn’t manage to nail any single concept down in a way that made me excited to read more and I wish it had been edited/condensed into a more cohesive story.
October 10, 2024
Wish I could give something half a star…. Chaos. It was absolute chaos.
I have read 2 of this author’s previous books. In my review of the second one, it literally says “Note for Future Jen when she sees the author’s new book recommended so she goes to check her reviews on the author’s previous books: you don’t like them. Don’t read it.”
Oops. I should also note that the review says “you probably won’t listen to Past Jen.” Damn, I’m smart. I didn’t listen! But it’s Spoozy Szn and this fit in the spooky rom com category, so I couldn’t resist! I ran out of spooky rom coms and I got it as an ARC from NetGalley! It couldn’t be helped! More exclamation points!!!
He’s a paranormal investigator (which means podcaster) and she’s a writer who also has witch sisters. I guess.
It ping-ponged all over the fucking place. He dresses in 1980’s clothes. He flirts with her out of nowhere, in an unearned-flirt kind of way. Like, who are you, dude? Then on a date he says he only asked her out because he thought she was a witch and needed a witch to fall in love with him to get powers. Then suddenly it turns into some weird banter-y energy, but not in a natural way. Then it was suddenly “I haven’t spoken to Morgan for a month.” Wait, what? It was just utterly bizarre in that I had no idea what was happening, why, or what the tone of this was meant to be. There. Was. No. Romance.
I don’t see the point. But I know one thing, Past Jen fucking tried. And Future Jen CANNOT do this shit again. You hear me, bitch?
I have read 2 of this author’s previous books. In my review of the second one, it literally says “Note for Future Jen when she sees the author’s new book recommended so she goes to check her reviews on the author’s previous books: you don’t like them. Don’t read it.”
Oops. I should also note that the review says “you probably won’t listen to Past Jen.” Damn, I’m smart. I didn’t listen! But it’s Spoozy Szn and this fit in the spooky rom com category, so I couldn’t resist! I ran out of spooky rom coms and I got it as an ARC from NetGalley! It couldn’t be helped! More exclamation points!!!
He’s a paranormal investigator (which means podcaster) and she’s a writer who also has witch sisters. I guess.
It ping-ponged all over the fucking place. He dresses in 1980’s clothes. He flirts with her out of nowhere, in an unearned-flirt kind of way. Like, who are you, dude? Then on a date he says he only asked her out because he thought she was a witch and needed a witch to fall in love with him to get powers. Then suddenly it turns into some weird banter-y energy, but not in a natural way. Then it was suddenly “I haven’t spoken to Morgan for a month.” Wait, what? It was just utterly bizarre in that I had no idea what was happening, why, or what the tone of this was meant to be. There. Was. No. Romance.
I don’t see the point. But I know one thing, Past Jen fucking tried. And Future Jen CANNOT do this shit again. You hear me, bitch?
March 28, 2025
this makes me so sad...
2.5 ★
simply put, the folklore of forever was a chaotic mess — too many ideas, too little romance, resulting in a struggle to keep up as the narration and focus shifted so suddenly. there would be full pages where my brain couldn't process the words on the page, a situation I don't encounter offer. that difficulty told me all I needed to know about my invested in this couple and their story.
after the first 25% failed to impress, I anticipated this read would be a DNF, but wished to stick it out since sarah has been a favorite author in the past. her signature brand of banter and quirk were present here but dialed up far too high and with no real direction. so much about this story needed to be edited or scaled back to make space for the important elements to shine. but because there was so much going on at all times, seeing through the muck to make sense of what actually mattered proved difficult.
having said this, I do credit sarah for her continued effort to craft unique tales for her readers, full of charm and wit. though the folklore of forever didn't work for me, I appreciate the risks she took here. this experience certainly won't deter me from picking up any of her future titles.
thanks to sarah hogle and g.p. putnam's sons for an eARC in exchange for an honest review.
2.5 ★
simply put, the folklore of forever was a chaotic mess — too many ideas, too little romance, resulting in a struggle to keep up as the narration and focus shifted so suddenly. there would be full pages where my brain couldn't process the words on the page, a situation I don't encounter offer. that difficulty told me all I needed to know about my invested in this couple and their story.
after the first 25% failed to impress, I anticipated this read would be a DNF, but wished to stick it out since sarah has been a favorite author in the past. her signature brand of banter and quirk were present here but dialed up far too high and with no real direction. so much about this story needed to be edited or scaled back to make space for the important elements to shine. but because there was so much going on at all times, seeing through the muck to make sense of what actually mattered proved difficult.
having said this, I do credit sarah for her continued effort to craft unique tales for her readers, full of charm and wit. though the folklore of forever didn't work for me, I appreciate the risks she took here. this experience certainly won't deter me from picking up any of her future titles.
thanks to sarah hogle and g.p. putnam's sons for an eARC in exchange for an honest review.
July 23, 2024
Seated. Sat. Reclined. Ready.
December 23, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️
🔥🔥
🍄🟫 magical realism
🔮 books about books
🍄🟫 enemies to lovers
🔮paranormal
As the second book in this series, The Folklore of Forever closely mirrors my experience with the first, I enjoyed it, but didn’t quite fall in love. While charming and heartfelt in moments, the pacing occasionally dragged and the emotional payoff felt muted, making this a just-okay read for me.
♥︎ Many thanks to Netgalley, Sarah Hogle and Penguin Group Putnam for the ARC of The Folklore of Forever.
🌶️🌶️ = open door, minimal detail
🔥🔥
🍄🟫 magical realism
🔮 books about books
🍄🟫 enemies to lovers
🔮paranormal
As the second book in this series, The Folklore of Forever closely mirrors my experience with the first, I enjoyed it, but didn’t quite fall in love. While charming and heartfelt in moments, the pacing occasionally dragged and the emotional payoff felt muted, making this a just-okay read for me.
♥︎ Many thanks to Netgalley, Sarah Hogle and Penguin Group Putnam for the ARC of The Folklore of Forever.
🌶️🌶️ = open door, minimal detail
October 13, 2024
One thing about our male lead Morgan is that he’s a genuine LOSER. He is a certified BUM. I’m talking nuclear levels of ick. I always thought I wanted to date Shawn Spencer from Psych but after reading this…..I still do. Because…guess what…he grew on me. Yes, he needs a Vyvanse prescription more than I need air… but god damn it if he’s not funny.
This was a tough rate because the first 20% is so genuinely a tonal nightmare. The male lead comes off genuinely unlikable like almost to an irredeemable degree. The female lead seems a bit like the boring manic pixie dream girl arches type. I thought this was going to be a two-star venture. BUT, it definitely got better. The story found its footing when it committed a bit more to the magical elements and bringing out Morgan’s (the male lead) charm and Zelda’s passion. By the end, I was really amused and… dare I say it? Charmed.
Thank you to Netgalley, the publisher, and the author for the ARC in exchange for my honest review. The publishing date is April 8, 2024.
This was a tough rate because the first 20% is so genuinely a tonal nightmare. The male lead comes off genuinely unlikable like almost to an irredeemable degree. The female lead seems a bit like the boring manic pixie dream girl arches type. I thought this was going to be a two-star venture. BUT, it definitely got better. The story found its footing when it committed a bit more to the magical elements and bringing out Morgan’s (the male lead) charm and Zelda’s passion. By the end, I was really amused and… dare I say it? Charmed.
Thank you to Netgalley, the publisher, and the author for the ARC in exchange for my honest review. The publishing date is April 8, 2024.
July 13, 2025
So disappointed ☹️😭
—————
My queen is giving us another enchanting Moonville tale. 💜🍄🍂
I love stalking author’s Goodreads accounts for these pleasant surprises… this has yet to be announced.
—————
My queen is giving us another enchanting Moonville tale. 💜🍄🍂
I love stalking author’s Goodreads accounts for these pleasant surprises… this has yet to be announced.
March 19, 2025
2.5 stars
I’ve read and enjoyed a few of the other books from Sarah and I’m wondering if maybe I would have liked this one more if I would have read the previous book in the series (which I didn’t realize this was part of a series.)
I think I liked Zelda and Morgan. They’re both chaotic and messy and their relationship started out cute then Morgan showed his ass a bunch and then maybe it was cute again? I did like Zelda’s sisters and how supportive they were, but the real star of the book was Zelda’s niece Aisling.
Plot wise, it’s all over the place. I spent a good part of the book wondering if magic is actually real in this world or if everyone was just delusional (again, something that might have been established for me if I read the first book.) I skimmed portions of the pages and pages of inner monologue to find what was likely supposed to be sassy banter disguised as flirting, but by then, I just wanted answers.
Overall, something kept me reading this story, yet I can’t tell you what it was.
**Huge thanks to the publisher for providing the arc free of charge**
I’ve read and enjoyed a few of the other books from Sarah and I’m wondering if maybe I would have liked this one more if I would have read the previous book in the series (which I didn’t realize this was part of a series.)
I think I liked Zelda and Morgan. They’re both chaotic and messy and their relationship started out cute then Morgan showed his ass a bunch and then maybe it was cute again? I did like Zelda’s sisters and how supportive they were, but the real star of the book was Zelda’s niece Aisling.
Plot wise, it’s all over the place. I spent a good part of the book wondering if magic is actually real in this world or if everyone was just delusional (again, something that might have been established for me if I read the first book.) I skimmed portions of the pages and pages of inner monologue to find what was likely supposed to be sassy banter disguised as flirting, but by then, I just wanted answers.
Overall, something kept me reading this story, yet I can’t tell you what it was.
**Huge thanks to the publisher for providing the arc free of charge**
March 1, 2025
very sad to report that i did not like this which is so UPSETTING bc i love sarah hogle :(
i honestly did not like either of the characters, & the plot was all over the place?? morgan (mmc) is SO immature & not one time did i ever stop and think “huh he sounds hot” .. like girl?? he literally admitted he only took her on a date to use her & he had ZERO DEPTH. did not find out one thing abt him until at least 70%
the fmc zelda was in denial abt quite a few things (and not even for a good reason??) & it made the book quite boring at times. she gave me whiplash honestly. overall this book wasn’t for me, i didn’t vibe with the characters at all, but i am looking forward to the third book!
thank you to the publisher for providing this book for review via netgalley. all opinions are my own <3
i honestly did not like either of the characters, & the plot was all over the place?? morgan (mmc) is SO immature & not one time did i ever stop and think “huh he sounds hot” .. like girl?? he literally admitted he only took her on a date to use her & he had ZERO DEPTH. did not find out one thing abt him until at least 70%
the fmc zelda was in denial abt quite a few things (and not even for a good reason??) & it made the book quite boring at times. she gave me whiplash honestly. overall this book wasn’t for me, i didn’t vibe with the characters at all, but i am looking forward to the third book!
thank you to the publisher for providing this book for review via netgalley. all opinions are my own <3
March 30, 2025
This was much more heavy on the magic and light on the romance than the first book. But hey, I'm not complaining, it was fun! Essentially we follow Zelda through a bout of writer's block and a heavy flirtation with Morgan, who we met in book 1. Morgan's heard rumors that if you fall in love with a witch, you basically gain some power of your own, so Zelda's initially very suspicious of his advances. The two team up to find the famed Black Bear Witch in the Moonville wilderness. There are some sections of this book that seem so convoluted that they actually work and oh yeah, there's a cat that turns into a piano. Looking for a new quirky, witchy romance? This is the one for you. Zelda and Morgan are just so soft and silly and I want to wrap them in a warm blanket and keep them forever.
September 22, 2024
I wanted to like this, but sadly, this one fell flat for me. I liked magical elements, but romance didn't deliver for me.
ARC kindly provided by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
ARC kindly provided by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
September 27, 2024
ahh i don’t know what to rate this. i don’t even know how to review this. if you know me, you know i love sarah hogle more than anything ever, and so i was so very excited for this book. and. then i read it. i don’t know what exactly the hiccup was here, because the book seems to employ all the same exact wonderful, magical ingredients most of her books do, the captivating main character, a beautifully written and planned out world, a story concept that’s as familiar as it is fascinating. and the sparks-fly love interest, and i’ll admit it took me a bit to get used to him, was fun in so many ways, edging me closer and closer into adoring him completely. the book between the 70-90% mark is magical, something straight out of wonder and whimsy, something that shot straight to my heart, as a person who loves books and the people who write them so very, very much.
but. there’s a problem here, and i think it’s that i could just not buy the narrative. i’m not sure why that’s the case, or what triggered it so repetitively, but something about morgan (his general immaturity?) and the entire romantic dynamic between him and zelda—never quite resonated with me. and i don’t know why! i genuinely cannot figure it out! because there’s no clear cut reason! and it’s sarah hogle! i’ve always loved sarah hogle! so maybe i’m just being silly, who knows. but for whatever reason, i didn’t love this as much as i had expected i would. and that makes me so sad, because again it’s literally sarah hogle?! i’m so excited for the (hopeful?) sequel nonetheless, because luna is easily one of my favorite characters in this trilogy, and i’ve loved her from the start and will continue to do so forevermore.
thank you to gp putnam for the arc. 3/5
but. there’s a problem here, and i think it’s that i could just not buy the narrative. i’m not sure why that’s the case, or what triggered it so repetitively, but something about morgan (his general immaturity?) and the entire romantic dynamic between him and zelda—never quite resonated with me. and i don’t know why! i genuinely cannot figure it out! because there’s no clear cut reason! and it’s sarah hogle! i’ve always loved sarah hogle! so maybe i’m just being silly, who knows. but for whatever reason, i didn’t love this as much as i had expected i would. and that makes me so sad, because again it’s literally sarah hogle?! i’m so excited for the (hopeful?) sequel nonetheless, because luna is easily one of my favorite characters in this trilogy, and i’ve loved her from the start and will continue to do so forevermore.
thank you to gp putnam for the arc. 3/5
May 18, 2025
My expectations were probably too high, so I feel a little disappointed, but that’s not really a reflection of this book. It just feels like an odd sequel to Old Flames, because it’s SO magic world building heavy and I wasn’t prepared for 80% magic adventure 20% lovely character study romance, when I would switch those ratios in Book 1.
Besides not meeting my expectations, my only really complaint is that Zelda’s journey back to magic felt a little perfunctory. She’s pretty much just falls back into being a witch the moment she gets concrete evidence of magical creatures around her again, which had practically nothing to do with her sisters or Morgan and so it just fell flat to me. The third part magic woods journey felt more chaotic than anything else that I’ve read in a while. But the parts that are good, are so so so good in a way that I only get from Sarah Hogle books.
Besides not meeting my expectations, my only really complaint is that Zelda’s journey back to magic felt a little perfunctory. She’s pretty much just falls back into being a witch the moment she gets concrete evidence of magical creatures around her again, which had practically nothing to do with her sisters or Morgan and so it just fell flat to me. The third part magic woods journey felt more chaotic than anything else that I’ve read in a while. But the parts that are good, are so so so good in a way that I only get from Sarah Hogle books.
October 8, 2024
This book doesn’t come out until April 2025 so there aren’t a ton of reviews yet, but it seems I am in the same boat with the other two star reviewers - I rated this lower because I didn’t like Morgan (the MMC) at all.
He was pushy, annoying, made dumb comments, and was basically just using the main character for a good chunk of the story, all of which made him completely unlikable for me. This made me also somewhat annoyed with the main character for liking him back (or tolerating him at all). I was honestly rooting for Zelda to end up with literally anyone else because Morgan was so awful.
I started off liking Zelda okay (especially her skepticism) but as the story progressed I liked her less and less given her weird hangup on Morgan.
Overall, while I love this author, it does not seem that this series is really for me since I didn’t like the first book either.
Thank you to NetGalley and G P Putnam’s Sons Press for the advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.
He was pushy, annoying, made dumb comments, and was basically just using the main character for a good chunk of the story, all of which made him completely unlikable for me. This made me also somewhat annoyed with the main character for liking him back (or tolerating him at all). I was honestly rooting for Zelda to end up with literally anyone else because Morgan was so awful.
I started off liking Zelda okay (especially her skepticism) but as the story progressed I liked her less and less given her weird hangup on Morgan.
Overall, while I love this author, it does not seem that this series is really for me since I didn’t like the first book either.
Thank you to NetGalley and G P Putnam’s Sons Press for the advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.
August 15, 2025
A low rating for a Sarah Hogle novel is a ONE-OFF situation.
The first novel in this series is a yearly reread. It ticks every box - witchy, whimsical, well-paced tension. A theme that spans many Hogle rom coms is transformation. Not in a typical character-arc way. Her MCs often altar themselves for the sake of their personal growth.
What I like about the Moonville series is it's refreshingly non-money driven. What's with all the billionaires in romance? Moonville's most magical trait is its anti-capitalist spirit. While the beginning of this series still felt steeped in reality with splashes of whimsy, The Folklore of Forever goes into an uncanny territory. We have an actual Fae land now? Time portals? Spiritual animals?
I'm also confused by our heroine, hero, and their oddly paced relationship? She's literally raised by witches, dresses like a witch, is surrounded by witchy accoutrements... but doesn't believe in actual witchcraft? Even if it means calling everyone she loves a liar. Morgan is introduced as a total non sexual entity in Moonville #1 in neon 80s wear, so it was a difficult to pivot my brain chemistry there.
I still can't wait for Luna's book though!
The first novel in this series is a yearly reread. It ticks every box - witchy, whimsical, well-paced tension. A theme that spans many Hogle rom coms is transformation. Not in a typical character-arc way. Her MCs often altar themselves for the sake of their personal growth.
What I like about the Moonville series is it's refreshingly non-money driven. What's with all the billionaires in romance? Moonville's most magical trait is its anti-capitalist spirit. While the beginning of this series still felt steeped in reality with splashes of whimsy, The Folklore of Forever goes into an uncanny territory. We have an actual Fae land now? Time portals? Spiritual animals?
I'm also confused by our heroine, hero, and their oddly paced relationship? She's literally raised by witches, dresses like a witch, is surrounded by witchy accoutrements... but doesn't believe in actual witchcraft? Even if it means calling everyone she loves a liar. Morgan is introduced as a total non sexual entity in Moonville #1 in neon 80s wear, so it was a difficult to pivot my brain chemistry there.
I still can't wait for Luna's book though!
November 14, 2024
*2.5 Stars*
This book was probably my biggest disappointment of the year. I loved Old Flames and New Fortunes and was so excited to read the next book in the Moonville series. Zelda is a great character, and I loved the magical elements to this book but the love interest, Morgan, completely ruined this book for me. Mogan is probably one of the worst male main characters I have read in a long time. Morgan seemed to be using Zelda for her powers through most of the book and there didn't seem to be a romantic element in this "romance" book until the very end. I am conflicted about continuing the series. I love Luna as a character and would love to read her story but am concerned that I will be reading about another unlikable love interest.
Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Group Putnam for the opportunity to review The Folklore of Forever. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
This book was probably my biggest disappointment of the year. I loved Old Flames and New Fortunes and was so excited to read the next book in the Moonville series. Zelda is a great character, and I loved the magical elements to this book but the love interest, Morgan, completely ruined this book for me. Mogan is probably one of the worst male main characters I have read in a long time. Morgan seemed to be using Zelda for her powers through most of the book and there didn't seem to be a romantic element in this "romance" book until the very end. I am conflicted about continuing the series. I love Luna as a character and would love to read her story but am concerned that I will be reading about another unlikable love interest.
Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Group Putnam for the opportunity to review The Folklore of Forever. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
April 24, 2025
2.5 stars for my queen feels blasphemous but i just couldn't get into it!! i still LOVE sarah hogle's writing style and voice but this one just felt a little too ... disconnected? and i could NOT get attached to the characters no matter how hard i tried. morgan was just weird for like 70% of the book (i came around on him in the end tbf but too little too late) and zelda was cool i guess but also meh?
i will ofc still read the next one and i have high hopes bc i LOVEEE a parentified eldest daughter so fingers crossed sarah hogle reels me back in with moonville #3
I LOVE YOU SARAH I'M SORRY
i will ofc still read the next one and i have high hopes bc i LOVEEE a parentified eldest daughter so fingers crossed sarah hogle reels me back in with moonville #3
I LOVE YOU SARAH I'M SORRY
April 3, 2025
Opting to DNF this one at 25ish%. Y'all, I love Sarah Hogle, and I powered through Old Flames and New Fortunes (which just had SOOOO much going on), but I think this universe is not for me.
I want to thank PRH Audio for the gifted audiobook and for G.P. Putnam's Sons for the eARC of this one. I was SO excited to find out Mara Wilson (you know, FREAKING MATILDA) was going to be narrating this one! But I just could not get into or care about either of the main characters. This world is whimsical and there's witchy vibes and haunted houses, and Morgan, who I really liked in book one, but I just kinda disliked him a lot in this one? He was pushy and he couldn't communicate with Zelda if their lives depended on it. There was no chemistry. There was no history. There was no understanding or connection between these two a quarter of the one into the story. It's just a no for me for now. And, I hate to say this, but if I don't love the audio, I don't think I'd be any more inclined to eyeball read it... it was keeping my attention when I could do 7 other things at the same time, lol.
I want to thank PRH Audio for the gifted audiobook and for G.P. Putnam's Sons for the eARC of this one. I was SO excited to find out Mara Wilson (you know, FREAKING MATILDA) was going to be narrating this one! But I just could not get into or care about either of the main characters. This world is whimsical and there's witchy vibes and haunted houses, and Morgan, who I really liked in book one, but I just kinda disliked him a lot in this one? He was pushy and he couldn't communicate with Zelda if their lives depended on it. There was no chemistry. There was no history. There was no understanding or connection between these two a quarter of the one into the story. It's just a no for me for now. And, I hate to say this, but if I don't love the audio, I don't think I'd be any more inclined to eyeball read it... it was keeping my attention when I could do 7 other things at the same time, lol.
March 9, 2025
I loved the first book of this series and Sarah Hogle's other books so I was really excited for The Folklore of Forever. Unfortunately, this book is a mess and was disappointing, especially because Zelda's story has the bones for a great, witchy romance. Thank you to NetGalley for the eARC.
Where to even begin with this book? Well, I guess I should start with the things I liked. I was happy to be back in Moonville and enjoyed the little bit of info we got to expand the magic system. Zelda started off as a character I could really love. She is quirky, has a diverse set of interests, is an author and is convinced she is not a witch. There was so much to work with when it came to her character.
Ok, let's dive into what didn't work. First of all, the MMC, Morgan, was an absurd character who did something nasty to Zelda at the beginning of the story but didn't really atone for his shitty behavior. He felt like a caricature until the end of the book; all flash, no substance. This left the romance plot feeling thin and like an afterthought for the story. The last 20% of this book was an absolute mess. The magic system got super weird without any preparation and I still don't understand most of what happened after reading it twice.
On a personal note, I have a HUGE bone to pick with the representation of premenstrual dysphoric disorder (PMDD) in this book. I happen to have PMDD. I was diagnosed with it as a teenager and have been treating it for 17 years at this point. PMDD causes severe mood swings, can cause clinical depression and anxiety in the days leading up to your period, and usually comes with severe physical symptoms. It does not cause you to uproot your life, never see your family and move every four weeks to a new city. I don't know where the hell Sarah Hogle came up with that bullshit, but it's representation like this that causes people to think that PMDD is a something much worse than what it really is: a mood disorder that impacts up to 10% of people who have periods. If you have 10 friends who have periods, odds are one of them has PMDD. I almost threw my kindle across the room when Zelda said her PMDD was the reason she ditched her family and wouldn't come home. That's not how it works.
I am deeply disappointed with this book. I don't know if I will read book three. It's sad considering how much I loved book one.
Where to even begin with this book? Well, I guess I should start with the things I liked. I was happy to be back in Moonville and enjoyed the little bit of info we got to expand the magic system. Zelda started off as a character I could really love. She is quirky, has a diverse set of interests, is an author and is convinced she is not a witch. There was so much to work with when it came to her character.
Ok, let's dive into what didn't work. First of all, the MMC, Morgan, was an absurd character who did something nasty to Zelda at the beginning of the story but didn't really atone for his shitty behavior. He felt like a caricature until the end of the book; all flash, no substance. This left the romance plot feeling thin and like an afterthought for the story. The last 20% of this book was an absolute mess. The magic system got super weird without any preparation and I still don't understand most of what happened after reading it twice.
On a personal note, I have a HUGE bone to pick with the representation of premenstrual dysphoric disorder (PMDD) in this book. I happen to have PMDD. I was diagnosed with it as a teenager and have been treating it for 17 years at this point. PMDD causes severe mood swings, can cause clinical depression and anxiety in the days leading up to your period, and usually comes with severe physical symptoms. It does not cause you to uproot your life, never see your family and move every four weeks to a new city. I don't know where the hell Sarah Hogle came up with that bullshit, but it's representation like this that causes people to think that PMDD is a something much worse than what it really is: a mood disorder that impacts up to 10% of people who have periods. If you have 10 friends who have periods, odds are one of them has PMDD. I almost threw my kindle across the room when Zelda said her PMDD was the reason she ditched her family and wouldn't come home. That's not how it works.
I am deeply disappointed with this book. I don't know if I will read book three. It's sad considering how much I loved book one.
March 16, 2025
I would not consider this a romance. I have been duped. Enemies to lovers is a hard trope for me because if the guy is unlikable, which this guy is, then I do not want them to get together. Also, they do not get together until 85%, that is also a problem for me if the book is considered a romance. So ignoring the romance this could be a cute story with Zelda not believing in magic even though her sisters are witches. She does not believe in any of it. Morgan wants to get with her and he comes on way too strong. Another reviewer said he made her think of PePe Le Pew and I agree with that. He tells her he only wants to be with her so he can get some of her magic. That is just gross. I then thought that he must not be the romantic lead at that point but I was wrong. She does not believe she has any magic. They both go on a quest in the woods because she starts thinking maybe there is something to this magic that everyone else in town seems to believe in. The quest in the woods was all over the place. I just couldn't follow it. The book had funny moments and some redemptive qualities but there was also a lot of chaos.
-...I would've had to hear her complaints that I don't get out of my shell enough (which is preposterous. Would she say this to a turtle? Shells have a valuable function).
-Is there anything quite like a library? No, there is not. You're allowed to walk right in, open a book, any book. You can read whatever you like until closing time, and nobody will bother you. Interrupting the immersed reader with small talk is distasteful here. I thrive like a cockroach in this social system.
-Some stories you forget about as soon as you finish the last page, and some you carry in your soul forever.
-...I would've had to hear her complaints that I don't get out of my shell enough (which is preposterous. Would she say this to a turtle? Shells have a valuable function).
-Is there anything quite like a library? No, there is not. You're allowed to walk right in, open a book, any book. You can read whatever you like until closing time, and nobody will bother you. Interrupting the immersed reader with small talk is distasteful here. I thrive like a cockroach in this social system.
-Some stories you forget about as soon as you finish the last page, and some you carry in your soul forever.
November 15, 2024
Thank you Net Galley and publishers for letting me read an arc of this book in return for an honest review.
I was so excited to enter the town of Moonville again, but was unfortunately a little disappointed with this one. The first book of the series was a 5/5 for me, would read again, but this one just took forever to get into. The first 20% of the book was very cringey and kinda boring. It didn't pick up until maybe 60% of the way through. I found Morgan to be very immature and kind of a jerk. He only wanted to go out with Zelda to make her fall in love with him so he could get magical powers. And Zelda was closed off and annoying too. She denied being a witch almost the whole book, saying magic was all a lie. They both eventually got better, but still not my favorite couple of the series so far. I hope Luna's story will be like the first and not this one. It was entertaining but a bit all over the place.
I was so excited to enter the town of Moonville again, but was unfortunately a little disappointed with this one. The first book of the series was a 5/5 for me, would read again, but this one just took forever to get into. The first 20% of the book was very cringey and kinda boring. It didn't pick up until maybe 60% of the way through. I found Morgan to be very immature and kind of a jerk. He only wanted to go out with Zelda to make her fall in love with him so he could get magical powers. And Zelda was closed off and annoying too. She denied being a witch almost the whole book, saying magic was all a lie. They both eventually got better, but still not my favorite couple of the series so far. I hope Luna's story will be like the first and not this one. It was entertaining but a bit all over the place.
May 1, 2025
I am not sure how everyone isn't taken with the town of Moonville and all the witchy characters there! I loved the first book and I loved Zelda and Morgan's story just as much. The push and pull and the banter between them! It was top tier. There was so much of the fantastical in this book, and sometimes it went off in crazy directions, but it all came back at the end. It all made sense and came together because fate was at play. I can't wait for Luna's story! 4.5 stars.
September 23, 2024
I know Sarah Hogle can write an amazing love interest, so whatever possessed her to write the most creepy, godawful men in this series, I will never understand. Once is a fluke, but twice? I'm very confused and disappointed. It's safe to say I didn't enjoy this book, because Morgan was a major creep and I didn't trust him.
April 19, 2025
I have no idea what I just read. The first book in this series was a hilarious, magic-themed rom-com that I gave 5 stars. This book was a fever dream, and my 3 stars were generous. The plot got more and more bizarre as the story progressed, and the romance, when it finally did appear, felt forced.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 573 reviews