What do you think?
Rate this book
Things We Keep Hidden
A threatening note.
Long-buried secrets.
Their friendship tested.
The last time lifelong friends Payton, Isley and Clara were together, Clara broke their unwritten rule and brought up the one thing they never talk about. And now, more than twenty years after their friend Cece took her life, they must confront that night as the three women and their husbands—plus one unexpected guest—gather at Isley’s Breckenridge vacation home. With tension already simmering just below the surface of their relationship, they’re each left shaken when a cryptic note Tell the truth or I will.
Who is the message for and what does it refer to? The women fear it could be linked to the truth they’ve kept hidden since the night Cece died…or maybe it has something to do with one of the problems they’ve each brought with them.
Isley’s son is in rehab after narrowly avoiding jail time, spurring her to a reckless act of her own. Clara, usually so careful to follow rules, is haunted by the one night that she didn’t. And Payton has been in denial regarding her husband’s so-called plan for their marriage.
As the weekend unfolds, all three will revisit the bonds they share and the challenges that have shaped their lives. And by the trip’s end, a truth that shocks them all will be revealed.
Long-buried secrets.
Their friendship tested.
The last time lifelong friends Payton, Isley and Clara were together, Clara broke their unwritten rule and brought up the one thing they never talk about. And now, more than twenty years after their friend Cece took her life, they must confront that night as the three women and their husbands—plus one unexpected guest—gather at Isley’s Breckenridge vacation home. With tension already simmering just below the surface of their relationship, they’re each left shaken when a cryptic note Tell the truth or I will.
Who is the message for and what does it refer to? The women fear it could be linked to the truth they’ve kept hidden since the night Cece died…or maybe it has something to do with one of the problems they’ve each brought with them.
Isley’s son is in rehab after narrowly avoiding jail time, spurring her to a reckless act of her own. Clara, usually so careful to follow rules, is haunted by the one night that she didn’t. And Payton has been in denial regarding her husband’s so-called plan for their marriage.
As the weekend unfolds, all three will revisit the bonds they share and the challenges that have shaped their lives. And by the trip’s end, a truth that shocks them all will be revealed.
Audible Audio
Published August 26, 2025
6 people are currently reading
4785 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 122 reviews
August 8, 2025
Book Review: Things We Keep Hidden by Jill Lynn
4 Stars
Blog Post: https://bookloveramanda.blogspot.com/...
Jill sure does know how to tell contemporary women's fiction stories with real life struggles, issues and characters with depth. This book follows 3 friends - they have swore not to talk about the night their friend CeCe took her life, but with them and their husbands back together at Isley's vacation home, there is a note left by a stranger that says "Tell The Truth or I Will." and they all think it has something to do with the circumstances surrounding their friend CeCe's death many years ago when they were young. Who is the message referring to?
We see this friend group, Isley, Payton and Clara being together again and working through real life problems with their marriages and children, as well as revisiting memories of the past together.
I really enjoyed the story and how Jill brought these real life struggles to the forefront - we see some hard topics discussed such as suicide, grief, drug addiction, rehab, marriage issues, domestic violence etc. and Jill really reminds us all that we all go through hard things and we all make mistakes or do things we wish we hadn't but at the end of the day, those things do not define us.
The end with the twists and explanations made me cry and while I wasn't as emotionally attached for all of the sisters collectively, the story is one that provides growth, emotions and relatability for readers.
Thank you to the publisher and author for providing a copy to honestly read and review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Content warning: suicide, grief, domestic violence, drug addiction, rehab, marriage issues, infidelity mentioned.
4 Stars
Blog Post: https://bookloveramanda.blogspot.com/...
Jill sure does know how to tell contemporary women's fiction stories with real life struggles, issues and characters with depth. This book follows 3 friends - they have swore not to talk about the night their friend CeCe took her life, but with them and their husbands back together at Isley's vacation home, there is a note left by a stranger that says "Tell The Truth or I Will." and they all think it has something to do with the circumstances surrounding their friend CeCe's death many years ago when they were young. Who is the message referring to?
We see this friend group, Isley, Payton and Clara being together again and working through real life problems with their marriages and children, as well as revisiting memories of the past together.
I really enjoyed the story and how Jill brought these real life struggles to the forefront - we see some hard topics discussed such as suicide, grief, drug addiction, rehab, marriage issues, domestic violence etc. and Jill really reminds us all that we all go through hard things and we all make mistakes or do things we wish we hadn't but at the end of the day, those things do not define us.
The end with the twists and explanations made me cry and while I wasn't as emotionally attached for all of the sisters collectively, the story is one that provides growth, emotions and relatability for readers.
Thank you to the publisher and author for providing a copy to honestly read and review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Content warning: suicide, grief, domestic violence, drug addiction, rehab, marriage issues, infidelity mentioned.
August 19, 2025
This was a very interesting book!
We have a group of friends who’ve been friends since HS… and every year they get together for a friends vacation and to catch up! This year, however, they each seem to be hiding something or another from the others…
A child in trouble. A husband who’s not happy in the marriage… and so on.
And as they spend time together, they begin to open up about their lives…again.
And then, there’s a break in. Nothing seems to be missing, but there’s an ominous note! Who is it for? What is it about? Do they need to be worried?
All this while little pieces of their lives seem to be disintegrating right before their eyes. 👀
Then, we add in a mouthy teenager who always seems to be in the wrong place… all the time. And guess what? She has secrets of her own! 😮
It’s a crazy story, yet one that we can all imagine, and even more so… RELATE TO!!
And when we finally get to the end, well, for me, I was just as surprised with the ending…as well as a little awestruck…
This one will give you pause. Make you think. Make you happy for the life you have… because even when things are not perfect, they’re probably a lot better than the lives of some of the people in this book! It will give you the chills. Make you laugh. And, even might make you cry…
But, for me, when I get ‘all the feels’… well, I am then a very happy camper!
4 big, bight shining 🌟🌟🌟🌟 for me!
#ThingsWeKeepHidden by @JillLynn and narrated beautifully by @TanyaEby.
**** THIS HAS NOT BEEN RELEASED YET!!! LOOK 👀 FOR IT ON SHELVES STARTING 8/26/25!!! *****
Thanks so much to #NetGalley and #HarlequinAudio for an ARC of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review.
You can find my reviews on: Goodreads,
Insta @BookReviews_with_emsr and/or
My Facebook Book Club: Book Reviews With Elaine
Thanks so much for reading! And if you ‘liked’ my review, please share with your friends, & click ‘LIKE’ below… And, let me know YOUR thoughts if you read it!! 📚⭐️
We have a group of friends who’ve been friends since HS… and every year they get together for a friends vacation and to catch up! This year, however, they each seem to be hiding something or another from the others…
A child in trouble. A husband who’s not happy in the marriage… and so on.
And as they spend time together, they begin to open up about their lives…again.
And then, there’s a break in. Nothing seems to be missing, but there’s an ominous note! Who is it for? What is it about? Do they need to be worried?
All this while little pieces of their lives seem to be disintegrating right before their eyes. 👀
Then, we add in a mouthy teenager who always seems to be in the wrong place… all the time. And guess what? She has secrets of her own! 😮
It’s a crazy story, yet one that we can all imagine, and even more so… RELATE TO!!
And when we finally get to the end, well, for me, I was just as surprised with the ending…as well as a little awestruck…
This one will give you pause. Make you think. Make you happy for the life you have… because even when things are not perfect, they’re probably a lot better than the lives of some of the people in this book! It will give you the chills. Make you laugh. And, even might make you cry…
But, for me, when I get ‘all the feels’… well, I am then a very happy camper!
4 big, bight shining 🌟🌟🌟🌟 for me!
#ThingsWeKeepHidden by @JillLynn and narrated beautifully by @TanyaEby.
**** THIS HAS NOT BEEN RELEASED YET!!! LOOK 👀 FOR IT ON SHELVES STARTING 8/26/25!!! *****
Thanks so much to #NetGalley and #HarlequinAudio for an ARC of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review.
You can find my reviews on: Goodreads,
Insta @BookReviews_with_emsr and/or
My Facebook Book Club: Book Reviews With Elaine
Thanks so much for reading! And if you ‘liked’ my review, please share with your friends, & click ‘LIKE’ below… And, let me know YOUR thoughts if you read it!! 📚⭐️
August 15, 2025
This is my second women's fiction novel by Jill Lynn. In Things We Keep Hidden, three middle aged women who've been friends since high school and their spouses meet at one of their homes in Breckenridge, Colorado. Their fourth friend committed suicide their senior year of high school. The remaining three friends are working on a fundraiser for a suicide awareness non-profit named after their friend Cece. Each of the friends has their own issues they are working through. I loved seeing how their friendship continued to be important to each of them.
There's a bit of mystery as some odd things happen during their weekend together that no one can initially explain. Details unfold as the pages turn.
The cover is perfect for the novel.
My gratitude to publisher Harlequin-Romance for a complimentary NetGalley copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and all opinions expressed are my own.
There's a bit of mystery as some odd things happen during their weekend together that no one can initially explain. Details unfold as the pages turn.
The cover is perfect for the novel.
My gratitude to publisher Harlequin-Romance for a complimentary NetGalley copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and all opinions expressed are my own.
August 16, 2025
First of all thank you to Netgalley and the publishers for allowing me to have an audio copy of this book.
I did like a narration of this book a lot, it was clear and easy to follow.
But I didn't much care for the story, didn't connect to or like the characters much.
I feel like some of the book was quite forgettable, slow and repetitive. A bit hard to follow near the middle as well.
I feel like the book had a lot of potential, though I feel like it fell flat. It unfortunately didn't keep me interested or caring much about the secrets and everything that was happening to the characters.
I did like a narration of this book a lot, it was clear and easy to follow.
But I didn't much care for the story, didn't connect to or like the characters much.
I feel like some of the book was quite forgettable, slow and repetitive. A bit hard to follow near the middle as well.
I feel like the book had a lot of potential, though I feel like it fell flat. It unfortunately didn't keep me interested or caring much about the secrets and everything that was happening to the characters.
August 4, 2025
A cryptic, unsigned note is left at the vacation home of long-time friends, warning that the secret must be told. But what secret? This "friendcation" brings three couples together. The women share a secret from their past, and each of the couples has one or more secrets they are keeping. Plus there is a teenager along for the eye-rolls.
It's not bad, but it could have been funnier or cuter or more mysterious. The characters could have been better developed or more complex. In this tale, complexity was mostly hinted. The narration is good on the audiobook. We do switch POVs and there are three epilogues, so everything is wrapped up neatly at the end. 3.5 rounded down.
My thanks to the author, publisher, @HarlequinAudio, and #NetGalley for early access to the audiobook of #ThingsWeKeepHidden for review purposes. Publication date: 26 August 2025.
It's not bad, but it could have been funnier or cuter or more mysterious. The characters could have been better developed or more complex. In this tale, complexity was mostly hinted. The narration is good on the audiobook. We do switch POVs and there are three epilogues, so everything is wrapped up neatly at the end. 3.5 rounded down.
My thanks to the author, publisher, @HarlequinAudio, and #NetGalley for early access to the audiobook of #ThingsWeKeepHidden for review purposes. Publication date: 26 August 2025.
August 26, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and the publishing team for the opportunity to read/listen to as an ARC a bit early.
From the very beginning, the characters and storyline grabbed my attention and never let go! This is the first Jill Lynn story that I’ve had the pleasure of reading and/or listening to and it has definitely spurred me forward to read more from this author.
Despite their flaws and secrets, the characters really stick with you. Some thriller/suspense novels lack depth, but not in this case. The characters really do grow within a very short time.
The narration was delightful and pleasant to listen to. Tanya Eby did an incredible job. Her narration was clear, well read, and well animated without being over the top.
As for the story/plot, there were many twists and turns and unfortunately the story didn’t end the way I thought it would, haha! I think that calls for a point in the author’s favor though, so no complaints on that front.
I will say, some of the side stories seemed to purposefully throw the reader off the trail and it kept me guessing. I would have loved some more developed side paths, but overall, it was a great story.
Make sure you stay for the epilogue for a fun treat!
Definitely looking forward to telling my friends about this one and finding more books by this author! Great read!
From the very beginning, the characters and storyline grabbed my attention and never let go! This is the first Jill Lynn story that I’ve had the pleasure of reading and/or listening to and it has definitely spurred me forward to read more from this author.
Despite their flaws and secrets, the characters really stick with you. Some thriller/suspense novels lack depth, but not in this case. The characters really do grow within a very short time.
The narration was delightful and pleasant to listen to. Tanya Eby did an incredible job. Her narration was clear, well read, and well animated without being over the top.
As for the story/plot, there were many twists and turns and unfortunately the story didn’t end the way I thought it would, haha! I think that calls for a point in the author’s favor though, so no complaints on that front.
I will say, some of the side stories seemed to purposefully throw the reader off the trail and it kept me guessing. I would have loved some more developed side paths, but overall, it was a great story.
Make sure you stay for the epilogue for a fun treat!
Definitely looking forward to telling my friends about this one and finding more books by this author! Great read!
July 28, 2025
Rating: 3.5 stars
E-ARC review for Things We Keep Hidden by Jill Lynn
The concept behind Things We Keep Hidden immediately caught my attention; a friend group bound by secrets, a shared past they can’t outrun, and a mystery that slowly unravels. It had serious Pretty Little Liars but for adults vibes, which I loved. The layers of suspense, emotional tension, and complicated relationships made the story engaging.
That said, I did struggle with the writing at times. Certain parts felt choppy or repetitive, which occasionally pulled me out of the narrative. Still, the plot itself was intriguing enough to keep me turning the pages, and I appreciated the deeper themes of forgiveness, truth, and the long-lasting impact of our choices.
A solid read for fans of suspense and small-town secrets.
Thank you to NetGalley and the author for the opportunity to read an advance copy!
E-ARC review for Things We Keep Hidden by Jill Lynn
The concept behind Things We Keep Hidden immediately caught my attention; a friend group bound by secrets, a shared past they can’t outrun, and a mystery that slowly unravels. It had serious Pretty Little Liars but for adults vibes, which I loved. The layers of suspense, emotional tension, and complicated relationships made the story engaging.
That said, I did struggle with the writing at times. Certain parts felt choppy or repetitive, which occasionally pulled me out of the narrative. Still, the plot itself was intriguing enough to keep me turning the pages, and I appreciated the deeper themes of forgiveness, truth, and the long-lasting impact of our choices.
A solid read for fans of suspense and small-town secrets.
Thank you to NetGalley and the author for the opportunity to read an advance copy!
October 31, 2025
Beautifully Blended Friendships with Some Surprising Twists
Things We Keep Hidden is such a perfect title for this layered novel. Against the backdrop of longstanding friendships that have been tainted by grief, author Jill Lynn shows how secrets mar relationships. I appreciated how distinct the three main characters were — Payton, Clara, and Isley — and yes, even CeCe.
Things We Keep Hidden is such a perfect title for this layered novel. Against the backdrop of longstanding friendships that have been tainted by grief, author Jill Lynn shows how secrets mar relationships. I appreciated how distinct the three main characters were — Payton, Clara, and Isley — and yes, even CeCe.
September 17, 2025
This was my first novel by Jill Lynn and I think it will likely be my last. It just missed the mark for me. Unfortunately this one was pretty underwhelming and just meh. When I read the description for the story, I had thought there’d be some kind of mystery and deep dark secrets being uncovered. In reality, the deep dark secrets were not really very big, deep or dark. The big reveals were all excruciatingly underwhelming, and the overall storyline just fell flat for me.
The main characters were all a bit forgettable and boring. The dialogue felt stilted and kind of weird, awkward and unrealistic (especially anything concerning the teenagers), and the resolutions also felt very contrived and lifeless. The entire character development and portrayal felt a little convoluted and like someone was trying to aim at a target in the dark while widely missing the mark.
I’m a mom to two older teenage boys, live in the areas described in the book and am supposed to be around the same age as these women and the story just felt kind of weird and a bit disingenuous to reality. The things being said and life perspectives being held were things more congruous with my parent’s generation and as a result, it made the story feel off. Additionally, the conversations, perspectives, and behaviors of the teens to the world around them, and the interactions between the teens with the parents, felt so strange to me. It was almost like they were written by someone who was imagining what it would be like to have teens, but they were using the perspectives and sayings of an older generation and as a result widely missed the mark.
I received this as an ALC and honestly, I don’t think the narrator helped the situation. She came across very AI sounding, emotionless and flat. I really wanted to like this story, but ultimately it just fell flat.
Thanks to NetGalley and Harlequin Audio for giving me an Advanced Listening Copy in exchange for my honest review.
The main characters were all a bit forgettable and boring. The dialogue felt stilted and kind of weird, awkward and unrealistic (especially anything concerning the teenagers), and the resolutions also felt very contrived and lifeless. The entire character development and portrayal felt a little convoluted and like someone was trying to aim at a target in the dark while widely missing the mark.
I’m a mom to two older teenage boys, live in the areas described in the book and am supposed to be around the same age as these women and the story just felt kind of weird and a bit disingenuous to reality. The things being said and life perspectives being held were things more congruous with my parent’s generation and as a result, it made the story feel off. Additionally, the conversations, perspectives, and behaviors of the teens to the world around them, and the interactions between the teens with the parents, felt so strange to me. It was almost like they were written by someone who was imagining what it would be like to have teens, but they were using the perspectives and sayings of an older generation and as a result widely missed the mark.
I received this as an ALC and honestly, I don’t think the narrator helped the situation. She came across very AI sounding, emotionless and flat. I really wanted to like this story, but ultimately it just fell flat.
Thanks to NetGalley and Harlequin Audio for giving me an Advanced Listening Copy in exchange for my honest review.
August 13, 2025
Thank you to Netgalley, Harlequin Audio and Harlequin Trade Publishing for a free copy of this ALC. All thoughts are my own.
Narrator:
Firstly, the narration of this book was amazing. The Narrator really took care of the sensitive subjects within these pages and did an amazing job at embodying each of the characters.
Plot:
This is my first book by this author but she does an amazing job at writing Women's fiction, which isn't usually my preferred genre. However, I devoured this book and based off this one, would love to read more of her catalog.
Payton, Isley and Clara have a friendship for the ages. Even after school ended, with marriages and relocating around the country, they still manage to keep their friendship strong. This trio wasn't always three however, they used to have a friend named Cece who's life came to an unfortunate end. A charity was set up in her honor to help others who are struggling, and it has had success. Our friends meet up once a year, but this time the husbands are involved and it's for a charity function.
While this meetup does involve the fundraiser, it is also still a girls trip filled with much needed R&R. Each of the marriages/family lives have struggles brewing and while each relationship has issues that come to a head during this trip, a threatening note shows up that shakes the group to their cores. "Tell the truth or I will." Suddenly, Payton, Isley and Clara must confront the truth of the night Cece's candle went out.
I love that this book gives us dual timelines. Not only do we confront the problems within each couple's relationships in the present, along with a few family mysteries and tensions, but we get a flashback from Cece's point of view leading up to the dark night. I was sure I knew what had happened twenty years ago, but as Cece's story starts to get told, doubts start to arise.
I really loved the HEA that each of the couple got, even if it was a bit unconventional for some of them. We get a resolution to the mystery of twenty years ago, but I do wish that there were a bit more signs that point to that resolution sprinkled throughout.
Regardless, this was an amazing story and I can't wait to read what else the author has written,
Narrator:
Firstly, the narration of this book was amazing. The Narrator really took care of the sensitive subjects within these pages and did an amazing job at embodying each of the characters.
Plot:
This is my first book by this author but she does an amazing job at writing Women's fiction, which isn't usually my preferred genre. However, I devoured this book and based off this one, would love to read more of her catalog.
Payton, Isley and Clara have a friendship for the ages. Even after school ended, with marriages and relocating around the country, they still manage to keep their friendship strong. This trio wasn't always three however, they used to have a friend named Cece who's life came to an unfortunate end. A charity was set up in her honor to help others who are struggling, and it has had success. Our friends meet up once a year, but this time the husbands are involved and it's for a charity function.
While this meetup does involve the fundraiser, it is also still a girls trip filled with much needed R&R. Each of the marriages/family lives have struggles brewing and while each relationship has issues that come to a head during this trip, a threatening note shows up that shakes the group to their cores. "Tell the truth or I will." Suddenly, Payton, Isley and Clara must confront the truth of the night Cece's candle went out.
I love that this book gives us dual timelines. Not only do we confront the problems within each couple's relationships in the present, along with a few family mysteries and tensions, but we get a flashback from Cece's point of view leading up to the dark night. I was sure I knew what had happened twenty years ago, but as Cece's story starts to get told, doubts start to arise.
I really loved the HEA that each of the couple got, even if it was a bit unconventional for some of them. We get a resolution to the mystery of twenty years ago, but I do wish that there were a bit more signs that point to that resolution sprinkled throughout.
Regardless, this was an amazing story and I can't wait to read what else the author has written,
September 9, 2025
This was such a compelling story! I really enjoyed how the author dug deep into the bonds of lifelong friendship—messy, complicated, but also full of love and hope. The reunion between Payton, Isley, and Clara felt authentic, and I loved watching their past and present weave together.
There’s a slight thread of mystery running throughout, starting with the chilling note, “Tell the truth or I will.” That undercurrent kept me turning the pages, wondering what secrets would surface. But at its heart, this isn’t just about suspense—it’s about grief, forgiveness, and the ties that can both strain and sustain us through life’s hardest moments.
I received the audiobook for review, and the narrator was wonderful—she really brought the emotions and tension of the story to life. This was my first book by Jill Lynn, and I thoroughly enjoyed it. I’d absolutely recommend it and will be picking up more of her work in the future.
Thank you to NetGalley, Love Inspired Trade, and the publisher for my advanced reader copy (and audiobook!) in exchange for my honest review.
There’s a slight thread of mystery running throughout, starting with the chilling note, “Tell the truth or I will.” That undercurrent kept me turning the pages, wondering what secrets would surface. But at its heart, this isn’t just about suspense—it’s about grief, forgiveness, and the ties that can both strain and sustain us through life’s hardest moments.
I received the audiobook for review, and the narrator was wonderful—she really brought the emotions and tension of the story to life. This was my first book by Jill Lynn, and I thoroughly enjoyed it. I’d absolutely recommend it and will be picking up more of her work in the future.
Thank you to NetGalley, Love Inspired Trade, and the publisher for my advanced reader copy (and audiobook!) in exchange for my honest review.
September 16, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and Harlequin Audio for this advanced listener copy.
I recently watched the new TV adaptation of The Four Seasons, and this book gave me a very similar vibe. Isley, Clara, and Payton head to Isley’s Breckenridge vacation home, but each woman arrives with her own secrets, baggage, and husband in tow. On the very first day, a threatening note is left on the counter, and the three friends fear it might be tied to a secret from their past.
As the story unfolds, more layers of deception come to light, not just among the women but also within their marriages. While this story doesn’t have a lot of twists, it is heavier on drama than suspense, making it a lighter, character-driven read filled with tension and interpersonal intrigue.
I recently watched the new TV adaptation of The Four Seasons, and this book gave me a very similar vibe. Isley, Clara, and Payton head to Isley’s Breckenridge vacation home, but each woman arrives with her own secrets, baggage, and husband in tow. On the very first day, a threatening note is left on the counter, and the three friends fear it might be tied to a secret from their past.
As the story unfolds, more layers of deception come to light, not just among the women but also within their marriages. While this story doesn’t have a lot of twists, it is heavier on drama than suspense, making it a lighter, character-driven read filled with tension and interpersonal intrigue.
August 1, 2025
From the very first page, Things We Keep Hidden by Jill Lynn is an absolute triumph, a riveting and emotionally charged read that left me completely captivated. Having had the chance to listen to the ARC audiobook from NETGALLEY, I can confidently say this is one of those rare stories that stays with you long after the final chapter. I loved every minute and was genuinely sad to see it end.
The novel centers on three lifelong friends—Payton, Isley, and Clara—who find their bond tested by a tragic event from their past: the suicide of their friend Cece over twenty years ago. The secret of that night has been carefully buried, a fragile peace maintained by an unspoken pact never to discuss it. When the women and their husbands gather for a weekend getaway, the tension is already palpable. But everything comes to a head with the arrival of a cryptic, threatening note: "Tell the truth or I will."
This simple message acts as a masterfully executed catalyst, shattering the group's fragile calm and forcing them to confront not only the night Cece died but also the individual secrets they've been harboring. Isley is grappling with the consequences of her son's reckless behavior, which has led to a reckless act of her own. Clara, known for being the rule-follower, is haunted by a single night of rebellion. Meanwhile, Payton is in denial about the true nature of her husband's plans for their marriage.
Jill Lynn weaves these multiple threads together with incredible skill. The plot is a perfect blend of pulse-pounding mystery and deeply emotional character drama. I was on the edge of my seat, constantly trying to piece together the truth about what happened all those years ago, while also becoming deeply invested in each woman's personal journey. The author's exploration of friendship, loyalty, guilt, and forgiveness is both raw and authentic.
The narration of the audiobook was superb, adding another layer of depth to the story and making the characters feel incredibly real and relatable. This is more than just a suspense novel; it's a powerful story about the things we keep hidden, the burdens we carry, and the unbreakable bonds of friendship. The final reveal is genuinely shocking and provides a deeply satisfying conclusion to the mystery.
For anyone who loves a character-driven story with a compelling mystery at its heart, Things We Keep Hidden is an absolute must-read. Jill Lynn has crafted a truly unforgettable novel, and I cannot recommend it highly enough.
The novel centers on three lifelong friends—Payton, Isley, and Clara—who find their bond tested by a tragic event from their past: the suicide of their friend Cece over twenty years ago. The secret of that night has been carefully buried, a fragile peace maintained by an unspoken pact never to discuss it. When the women and their husbands gather for a weekend getaway, the tension is already palpable. But everything comes to a head with the arrival of a cryptic, threatening note: "Tell the truth or I will."
This simple message acts as a masterfully executed catalyst, shattering the group's fragile calm and forcing them to confront not only the night Cece died but also the individual secrets they've been harboring. Isley is grappling with the consequences of her son's reckless behavior, which has led to a reckless act of her own. Clara, known for being the rule-follower, is haunted by a single night of rebellion. Meanwhile, Payton is in denial about the true nature of her husband's plans for their marriage.
Jill Lynn weaves these multiple threads together with incredible skill. The plot is a perfect blend of pulse-pounding mystery and deeply emotional character drama. I was on the edge of my seat, constantly trying to piece together the truth about what happened all those years ago, while also becoming deeply invested in each woman's personal journey. The author's exploration of friendship, loyalty, guilt, and forgiveness is both raw and authentic.
The narration of the audiobook was superb, adding another layer of depth to the story and making the characters feel incredibly real and relatable. This is more than just a suspense novel; it's a powerful story about the things we keep hidden, the burdens we carry, and the unbreakable bonds of friendship. The final reveal is genuinely shocking and provides a deeply satisfying conclusion to the mystery.
For anyone who loves a character-driven story with a compelling mystery at its heart, Things We Keep Hidden is an absolute must-read. Jill Lynn has crafted a truly unforgettable novel, and I cannot recommend it highly enough.
September 11, 2025
Rating: 3/5 Stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️
Pub Date: 8/26
•
Three lifelong couples and one of their teenage children go away on a vacation. The group becomes upset when a cryptic note is left in their house stating “Tell the truth or I will”.
•
Within the first few chapters, as things started happening, I was totally getting some “I Know What You Did Last Summer” vibes. I was hype for some serious drama and let’s be honest - gore… Alas, this story is more of a deep dive into trauma-bonding, lifelong friendships and the secrets we keep from people we really care about. This story is pretty slow to steady paced and it bounces from friend to friend as you learn their secrets and just what happened years ago and in their current lives. I was very interested in the “what really happened” and of course I got caught up in their drama, but I felt like the overall ending was a bit of an underwhelming letdown. Overall, this is a decent read. I will look forward to reading more from this author.
•
I listened to this via audiobook. It was narrated by Tanya Eby and I thought she did a great job! I really enjoyed what she did throughout the story. If you are thinking of picking this one up be sure to check out the audio.
Pub Date: 8/26
•
Three lifelong couples and one of their teenage children go away on a vacation. The group becomes upset when a cryptic note is left in their house stating “Tell the truth or I will”.
•
Within the first few chapters, as things started happening, I was totally getting some “I Know What You Did Last Summer” vibes. I was hype for some serious drama and let’s be honest - gore… Alas, this story is more of a deep dive into trauma-bonding, lifelong friendships and the secrets we keep from people we really care about. This story is pretty slow to steady paced and it bounces from friend to friend as you learn their secrets and just what happened years ago and in their current lives. I was very interested in the “what really happened” and of course I got caught up in their drama, but I felt like the overall ending was a bit of an underwhelming letdown. Overall, this is a decent read. I will look forward to reading more from this author.
•
I listened to this via audiobook. It was narrated by Tanya Eby and I thought she did a great job! I really enjoyed what she did throughout the story. If you are thinking of picking this one up be sure to check out the audio.
August 1, 2025
Three lifelong friends and their husbands (and one of their daughters) come together at a cabin in Colorado for a mini vacation and to plan the charity event for their childhood friend Cece. "As the weekend unfolds, all three will revisit the bonds they share and the challenges that have shaped their lives. And by the trip’s end, a truth that shocks them all will be revealed."
This was an enjoyable medium paced low stakes dramatic mystery with themes of friendship, parenting, marriage/relationships and secrets. There was a lot of relationships dynamics at play: Pay, Isley and Clara's lifelong friendship and their trauma bond; each woman and their partner and each woman and their teenage/young adult kids. This made for a winding mystery and many questions about their pasts that were mostly answered by the end. I was curious to find out what happened with Cece but knew from the beginning it wasn't anything truly nefarious that the girls did. I also suspected the ending, which hurt, but didn't know how it would happen.
The audiobook narrator was excellent and brought the story to life. I could picture this as a made-for-tv movie with some popular mid-forties/early-50s actors. Personally, I had a bit of a hard time connecting with characters just because they are on different stages of their lives than I am as a mid-30s woman, but it was still an enjoyable story and something that I would recommend to my mom or any readers who like emotional and dramatic stories about relationships and secrets.
This was my first book by this author and I appreciated her writing style and the way she weaved together multiple storylines and relationships.
Thank you to NetGalley and Harlequin Audio for the opportunity to listen to and review this ARC!
3.75 stars rounded up.
This was an enjoyable medium paced low stakes dramatic mystery with themes of friendship, parenting, marriage/relationships and secrets. There was a lot of relationships dynamics at play: Pay, Isley and Clara's lifelong friendship and their trauma bond; each woman and their partner and each woman and their teenage/young adult kids. This made for a winding mystery and many questions about their pasts that were mostly answered by the end. I was curious to find out what happened with Cece but knew from the beginning it wasn't anything truly nefarious that the girls did. I also suspected the ending, which hurt, but didn't know how it would happen.
The audiobook narrator was excellent and brought the story to life. I could picture this as a made-for-tv movie with some popular mid-forties/early-50s actors. Personally, I had a bit of a hard time connecting with characters just because they are on different stages of their lives than I am as a mid-30s woman, but it was still an enjoyable story and something that I would recommend to my mom or any readers who like emotional and dramatic stories about relationships and secrets.
This was my first book by this author and I appreciated her writing style and the way she weaved together multiple storylines and relationships.
Thank you to NetGalley and Harlequin Audio for the opportunity to listen to and review this ARC!
3.75 stars rounded up.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Read
August 25, 2025Release Day/Book Review⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5’s
Thank you to the author @JillLynnAuthor, @htp_hive, @htpbooks_audio, @HarlequinBooks, and @NetGalley for the #gifted book.
A threatening note.
Long-buried secrets.
Their friendship tested.
I love Jill Lynn’s books—they’re always such a treat to read, and this one is no exception! The cover is gorgeous, and the story inside is just as absorbing. With a mix of friendships, family drama, and secrets revealed during a friendcation, this clean women’s fiction novel with a touch of romance hits all the right notes. Jill’s writing draws me in every single time, and I always enjoy the heartfelt stories she tells.
🎧 I also listened to the audiobook, narrated by Tanya Eby, and she did such an incredible job bringing the characters and all their angst to life. She’s one of those narrators I could listen to forever!
⭐️ A wonderful read full of heart, depth, and secrets that will keep you hooked.
Thank you to the author @JillLynnAuthor, @htp_hive, @htpbooks_audio, @HarlequinBooks, and @NetGalley for the #gifted book.
A threatening note.
Long-buried secrets.
Their friendship tested.
I love Jill Lynn’s books—they’re always such a treat to read, and this one is no exception! The cover is gorgeous, and the story inside is just as absorbing. With a mix of friendships, family drama, and secrets revealed during a friendcation, this clean women’s fiction novel with a touch of romance hits all the right notes. Jill’s writing draws me in every single time, and I always enjoy the heartfelt stories she tells.
🎧 I also listened to the audiobook, narrated by Tanya Eby, and she did such an incredible job bringing the characters and all their angst to life. She’s one of those narrators I could listen to forever!
⭐️ A wonderful read full of heart, depth, and secrets that will keep you hooked.
August 10, 2025
I received an audiobook ARC from Net Galley in exchange for a review. This was a story ultimately about friendship and the secrets we keep, even from those we are closest to. Unfortunately, this one missed the mark for me.
Things I liked: The characters were different enough to avoid confusion, well developed, and complex. I enjoyed each of their individual storylines and their shared interactions. I liked the focus on lifelong friendship. The story dealt with a lot of heavy issues but did it in a way that wasn’t explicit or over the top.
Things I didn’t like: The narrator sounded like AI and the dialogue felt very stilted and unnatural. That may have been more of a narrator issue, I’m not sure. The whole “mystery/big secret” plot was entirely unnecessary and distracted from the rest of the book. It didn’t need to be as big of a thing as it was, especially since the “reveal” was extremely unsatisfying. I think the story would’ve been much stronger and felt more focused without that side plot.
Overall, this one just wasn’t it for me, but I seem to be in the minority!
Things I liked: The characters were different enough to avoid confusion, well developed, and complex. I enjoyed each of their individual storylines and their shared interactions. I liked the focus on lifelong friendship. The story dealt with a lot of heavy issues but did it in a way that wasn’t explicit or over the top.
Things I didn’t like: The narrator sounded like AI and the dialogue felt very stilted and unnatural. That may have been more of a narrator issue, I’m not sure. The whole “mystery/big secret” plot was entirely unnecessary and distracted from the rest of the book. It didn’t need to be as big of a thing as it was, especially since the “reveal” was extremely unsatisfying. I think the story would’ve been much stronger and felt more focused without that side plot.
Overall, this one just wasn’t it for me, but I seem to be in the minority!
August 30, 2025
This is the first book I read from the author and it definitely won’t be my last!
This Women’s Fiction book is engaging from the first page until the last. I had a hard time putting it down and I finished it at 2 am, because I needed to know how it was going to end. To say the ending surprised me is an understatement. This story has a lot of unexpected twists that make you want to read more and more.
Isley, Payton and Clara are three best friends that reunite every two years for what they call “friendcation”. Their husbands are included too, plus one of their teenage daughters who goes a bit unwillingly, but will have her own important part in the story. Other that enjoy the vacation, they are take part in the fundraiser event for Finch’s Hope, the NGO that was started in honor of Cece, their fourth best friend who committed suicide during their senior year of high school. The three friends carry deep personal secrets they haven’t disclosed between them and carry their own guilt. Even deeper than their personal secrets, they all carry a burden together that nobody knows. The night Cece died, they were with her hours before she took her life. They kept the secret at first because they were afraid that what they did that day could make the police think they had influenced her decision. More than 20 years have passed and they still hold their secret tight because they fear of hurting Cece’s mother -the founder of the organization that has saved many lives from committing suicide- loves each of them as if they were her own daughters. Add to everything, that while they stay at Isley’s vacation home, a mysterious person breaks in the house in the middle of the night and leaves a strange message that says “say the truth or I will!”. They all are afraid of what truth the person is talking about. Could it be that somebody knows what they did that fateful day? Or could it be directed to their personal secrets one of them carries?
The story touches tough issues like mental illness, suicide, divorce, drug abuse, but I think it was made in a very gentle and respectful -yet still realistic- way. I liked that the book has each of the three women POV, and even goes back in time and tells Cece’s version in first person. The way it changes from third person to first person flows and you barely notice the change.
The characters are complex, have gone and are going through some difficult personal issues in their marriage or family, and the bond they share and how they support each other was inspiring. A friendship that lasts through time and stays intact even if they all have different lives, live in different states, and only see each other every two years. The trust between them seems unwavering, until they each realize that they carry their own problems which they are trying to hide, and the only way to face them in the right way is to share them with your unconditional friends who will always have your back.
I have to admit I kind of expected some of the characters to reach to God, pray and ask for His guidance and provision, as I thought all the Love Inspired books had a faith inspired thread. This is not the case, but I’m not saying this in detriment of the book, because clearly that wasn’t the objective, and this probably makes the book more open to non-believers and it definitely is a wholesome and touching story. But even if there’s not a faith thread, this story is full of moral values told in a natural way: the importance of being truthful, about trust in marriage, about facing reality with humility even if it hurts to admit it to others or even yourself, the value of unconditional friendship and support during good and bad times. The difficulties of parenting are evident and realistic in this story, and I loved how the women tried their best to raise their children, trying not to fall in their dysfunctional parents pattern, yet realizing sooner or later that they too can fail, because nobody is perfect, but what is important is the love and care for their children must experience.
My favorite character was Clara. Her marriage seemed as the most perfect one, yet she also faced communication difficulties with her husband, the struggle with the strain that dire finances can cause in the relationship, etc., but what I loved the most was her caring personality, her empathy, compassion, and her sense of humor (and her husband’s too).
The ending was very good and satisfying, yet unexpected. The way things unraveled at the end felt a bit rushed, but I loved the epilogue!
All in all, a book I recommend. It made me want to read her previous Women’s Fiction book, The Summer of Keeping Secrets.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author and was under no obligation to post a positive review. This is my honest and unbiased opinion.
This Women’s Fiction book is engaging from the first page until the last. I had a hard time putting it down and I finished it at 2 am, because I needed to know how it was going to end. To say the ending surprised me is an understatement. This story has a lot of unexpected twists that make you want to read more and more.
Isley, Payton and Clara are three best friends that reunite every two years for what they call “friendcation”. Their husbands are included too, plus one of their teenage daughters who goes a bit unwillingly, but will have her own important part in the story. Other that enjoy the vacation, they are take part in the fundraiser event for Finch’s Hope, the NGO that was started in honor of Cece, their fourth best friend who committed suicide during their senior year of high school. The three friends carry deep personal secrets they haven’t disclosed between them and carry their own guilt. Even deeper than their personal secrets, they all carry a burden together that nobody knows. The night Cece died, they were with her hours before she took her life. They kept the secret at first because they were afraid that what they did that day could make the police think they had influenced her decision. More than 20 years have passed and they still hold their secret tight because they fear of hurting Cece’s mother -the founder of the organization that has saved many lives from committing suicide- loves each of them as if they were her own daughters. Add to everything, that while they stay at Isley’s vacation home, a mysterious person breaks in the house in the middle of the night and leaves a strange message that says “say the truth or I will!”. They all are afraid of what truth the person is talking about. Could it be that somebody knows what they did that fateful day? Or could it be directed to their personal secrets one of them carries?
The story touches tough issues like mental illness, suicide, divorce, drug abuse, but I think it was made in a very gentle and respectful -yet still realistic- way. I liked that the book has each of the three women POV, and even goes back in time and tells Cece’s version in first person. The way it changes from third person to first person flows and you barely notice the change.
The characters are complex, have gone and are going through some difficult personal issues in their marriage or family, and the bond they share and how they support each other was inspiring. A friendship that lasts through time and stays intact even if they all have different lives, live in different states, and only see each other every two years. The trust between them seems unwavering, until they each realize that they carry their own problems which they are trying to hide, and the only way to face them in the right way is to share them with your unconditional friends who will always have your back.
I have to admit I kind of expected some of the characters to reach to God, pray and ask for His guidance and provision, as I thought all the Love Inspired books had a faith inspired thread. This is not the case, but I’m not saying this in detriment of the book, because clearly that wasn’t the objective, and this probably makes the book more open to non-believers and it definitely is a wholesome and touching story. But even if there’s not a faith thread, this story is full of moral values told in a natural way: the importance of being truthful, about trust in marriage, about facing reality with humility even if it hurts to admit it to others or even yourself, the value of unconditional friendship and support during good and bad times. The difficulties of parenting are evident and realistic in this story, and I loved how the women tried their best to raise their children, trying not to fall in their dysfunctional parents pattern, yet realizing sooner or later that they too can fail, because nobody is perfect, but what is important is the love and care for their children must experience.
My favorite character was Clara. Her marriage seemed as the most perfect one, yet she also faced communication difficulties with her husband, the struggle with the strain that dire finances can cause in the relationship, etc., but what I loved the most was her caring personality, her empathy, compassion, and her sense of humor (and her husband’s too).
The ending was very good and satisfying, yet unexpected. The way things unraveled at the end felt a bit rushed, but I loved the epilogue!
All in all, a book I recommend. It made me want to read her previous Women’s Fiction book, The Summer of Keeping Secrets.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author and was under no obligation to post a positive review. This is my honest and unbiased opinion.
August 27, 2025
Things We Keep Hidden by Jill Lynn
A threatening note.
Long-buried secrets.
Their friendship tested.
The last time lifelong friends Payton, Isley and Clara were together, Clara broke their unwritten rule and brought up the one thing they never talk about. And now, more than twenty years after their friend Cece took her life, they must confront that night as the three women and their husbands—plus one unexpected guest—gather at The last time lifelong friends Payton, Isley and Clara were together, Clara broke their unwritten rule and brought up the one thing they never talk about. And now, more than twenty years after their friend Cece took her life, they must confront that night as the three women and their husbands—plus one unexpected guest—gather at Isley’s Breckenridge vacation home. With tension already simmering just below the surface of their relationship, they’re each left shaken when a cryptic note arrives: Tell the truth or I will.
vacation home. With tension already simmering just below the surface of their relationship, they’re each left shaken when a cryptic note arrives: Tell the truth or I will.
Who is the message for and what does it refer to? The women fear it could be linked to the truth they’ve kept hidden since the night Cece died…or maybe it has something to do with one of the problems they’ve each brought with them.
Isley’s son is in rehab after narrowly avoiding jail time, spurring her to a reckless act of her own. Clara, usually so careful to follow rules, is haunted by the one night that she didn’t. And Payton has been in denial regarding her husband’s so-called plan for their marriage.
As the weekend unfolds, all three will revisit the bonds they share and the challenges that have shaped their lives. And by the trip’s end, a truth that shocks them all will be revealed.
This is As the weekend unfolds, all three will revisit the bonds they share and the challenges that have shaped their lives. And by the trip’s end, a truth that shocks them all will be revealed.
This is Isley and family's story.
This is Payton and family's story.
This is Clara and family's story.
Isley, Payton, and Clara are lifelong friends who try to get together every year.
They’re each left shaken when a cryptic note arrives: Tell the truth or I will.
Things We Keep Hidden by Jill Lynn is a 3 star book.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced readers copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions shared here in this review are my own.
A threatening note.
Long-buried secrets.
Their friendship tested.
The last time lifelong friends Payton, Isley and Clara were together, Clara broke their unwritten rule and brought up the one thing they never talk about. And now, more than twenty years after their friend Cece took her life, they must confront that night as the three women and their husbands—plus one unexpected guest—gather at The last time lifelong friends Payton, Isley and Clara were together, Clara broke their unwritten rule and brought up the one thing they never talk about. And now, more than twenty years after their friend Cece took her life, they must confront that night as the three women and their husbands—plus one unexpected guest—gather at Isley’s Breckenridge vacation home. With tension already simmering just below the surface of their relationship, they’re each left shaken when a cryptic note arrives: Tell the truth or I will.
vacation home. With tension already simmering just below the surface of their relationship, they’re each left shaken when a cryptic note arrives: Tell the truth or I will.
Who is the message for and what does it refer to? The women fear it could be linked to the truth they’ve kept hidden since the night Cece died…or maybe it has something to do with one of the problems they’ve each brought with them.
Isley’s son is in rehab after narrowly avoiding jail time, spurring her to a reckless act of her own. Clara, usually so careful to follow rules, is haunted by the one night that she didn’t. And Payton has been in denial regarding her husband’s so-called plan for their marriage.
As the weekend unfolds, all three will revisit the bonds they share and the challenges that have shaped their lives. And by the trip’s end, a truth that shocks them all will be revealed.
This is As the weekend unfolds, all three will revisit the bonds they share and the challenges that have shaped their lives. And by the trip’s end, a truth that shocks them all will be revealed.
This is Isley and family's story.
This is Payton and family's story.
This is Clara and family's story.
Isley, Payton, and Clara are lifelong friends who try to get together every year.
They’re each left shaken when a cryptic note arrives: Tell the truth or I will.
Things We Keep Hidden by Jill Lynn is a 3 star book.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced readers copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions shared here in this review are my own.
August 24, 2025
Thanks to the Publisher and Netgalley for an opportunity to read this ARC in exchange for a honest review.
So I stepped out of .you comfort zone a little in choosing this book because it was romantic suspense and followed multiple characters rather then a single or dual pov. However Im not sorry for selecting this book as it was a great read for mt planeride back home and kept me in suspense and wanting to keep reading until the end.
This story follows three lifetime friend: Clara, Isles, Payton and also contains a pov of Cece, their fourth musketeer member who died their senior year of high school. The woman are now in their early 40s and all married with children. Payton child. Ends up joining them on their trip. They are in Colorodo to raise money for a charity run by Ceces mom . Their first night in the house, there is a break in and a mysterious note is left.
The note forces the couples to relive the past and present. The women try to piece together the night Cece died and try to figure out who among them has secrets that would lead to the note being left.
Whenever I read stories with third person povs that shift in multiple directions with multiple stories; I try to figure out who the main character is, the main thread that weaves through the story. The most sympathetic character. That for me was Payton.
At first it was Isley but then definitely Psyton. Payton 's daughter is keeping secrets and do is her husband. He's already made it clear to her that he wanted to seperate 6 months ago but live like friends. She doesn't understand why or what she did and feels unloved. The past stories. Especially from Ceces pov reveals that was never the case and that is where the second chance romance comes in.
Although I did enjoy this book, I just thought the first half of the story dragged somewhat and didnt puck up until the last half. The husbands characters weren't as strong as the wives or even as strong as Paytons daughter. I especially hated Liam as I felt he was swarmy and a liar but there wasnt any satisfying conclusion to this theory, just a draw your own conclusion.
So I stepped out of .you comfort zone a little in choosing this book because it was romantic suspense and followed multiple characters rather then a single or dual pov. However Im not sorry for selecting this book as it was a great read for mt planeride back home and kept me in suspense and wanting to keep reading until the end.
This story follows three lifetime friend: Clara, Isles, Payton and also contains a pov of Cece, their fourth musketeer member who died their senior year of high school. The woman are now in their early 40s and all married with children. Payton child. Ends up joining them on their trip. They are in Colorodo to raise money for a charity run by Ceces mom . Their first night in the house, there is a break in and a mysterious note is left.
The note forces the couples to relive the past and present. The women try to piece together the night Cece died and try to figure out who among them has secrets that would lead to the note being left.
Whenever I read stories with third person povs that shift in multiple directions with multiple stories; I try to figure out who the main character is, the main thread that weaves through the story. The most sympathetic character. That for me was Payton.
At first it was Isley but then definitely Psyton. Payton 's daughter is keeping secrets and do is her husband. He's already made it clear to her that he wanted to seperate 6 months ago but live like friends. She doesn't understand why or what she did and feels unloved. The past stories. Especially from Ceces pov reveals that was never the case and that is where the second chance romance comes in.
Although I did enjoy this book, I just thought the first half of the story dragged somewhat and didnt puck up until the last half. The husbands characters weren't as strong as the wives or even as strong as Paytons daughter. I especially hated Liam as I felt he was swarmy and a liar but there wasnt any satisfying conclusion to this theory, just a draw your own conclusion.
August 30, 2025
"Things We Keep Hidden" is general fiction. I had mistakenly thought it was a Christian book, but there's no mention of God (or Jesus) and the main characters strove to solve their problems in their own strength and wisdom. However, there was no sex or bad language. Even though we're introduced to 8+ main characters within the first chapter, the author did a good job of making them each distinct. I had no trouble remembering who everyone was, their problems, and their relationships. Perhaps to prevent slowing an already slow start, details about the characters came out over time.
However, the characters KNEW what problem they were thinking about (when you're supposedly in their head and know their thoughts) yet they only vaguely referred to various problems for over half the book. Even with all the hiding, the truth behind what happened with CeCe was predictable (yes, I guessed it before the reveal). And what the girls did that they hid It's a non-issue at this point yet these women couldn't see this and were burdened for a good chunk of their life over it.
The author kept me at a distance by hiding rather than inviting me into the main character's problems, so I never bonded with any of them. The author didn't seem to understand how farms work, so even that couple's very vague farm problems were hard to relate to because they didn't make sense to me. Despite two of the women being control freaks, they missed what was obviously happening under their noses. And the meaning behind the "Tell the truth or I will" was a bit of a letdown.
Also, these women were supposed to be best friends, yet they spent the first part of the book trying to hide their troubles from the others. Why? When they did, they all did act like good, supportive friends, so why try to pretend their lives were fine? It wasn't a bad story, but it just wasn't relatable to me. It felt like they self-inflicted a whole lot of stress over minor issues while the major ones were just glossed over.
I received a free ebook review copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.
However, the characters KNEW what problem they were thinking about (when you're supposedly in their head and know their thoughts) yet they only vaguely referred to various problems for over half the book. Even with all the hiding, the truth behind what happened with CeCe was predictable (yes, I guessed it before the reveal). And what the girls did that they hid It's a non-issue at this point yet these women couldn't see this and were burdened for a good chunk of their life over it.
The author kept me at a distance by hiding rather than inviting me into the main character's problems, so I never bonded with any of them. The author didn't seem to understand how farms work, so even that couple's very vague farm problems were hard to relate to because they didn't make sense to me. Despite two of the women being control freaks, they missed what was obviously happening under their noses. And the meaning behind the "Tell the truth or I will" was a bit of a letdown.
Also, these women were supposed to be best friends, yet they spent the first part of the book trying to hide their troubles from the others. Why? When they did, they all did act like good, supportive friends, so why try to pretend their lives were fine? It wasn't a bad story, but it just wasn't relatable to me. It felt like they self-inflicted a whole lot of stress over minor issues while the major ones were just glossed over.
I received a free ebook review copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.
October 20, 2025
Objectively, this book is heartfelt, emotional, and easy to read — but it just wasn’t quite for me.
Clara, Isley, and Peyton are lifelong best friends who reunite to honor their close friend who passed away when they were younger. Despite the years that have passed, they still carry the guilt of a secret surrounding their friend’s death. When they receive an ominous note threatening to expose the truth, old wounds reopen. As the women navigate this reunion, they’re each facing their own personal challenges with relationships, family, and identity, all while trying to decide how to confront their past.
The story alternates between the present-day reunion and the past point of view of their late friend, gradually revealing what really happened. The premise was strong, and I appreciated the exploration of grief, guilt, and friendship — but the execution felt a little flat for me. The book tackled some sensitive but important themes, and while the twist toward the end added some depth and intrigue, it took a long time to get there. The first 80% felt more like a light women’s fiction read than the suspense I was hoping for.
That said, the last portion of the book did redeem it a bit. The twist added an emotional punch and some unexpected drama that helped bring everything full circle, even if the ending felt slightly rushed. Overall, it wrapped up neatly.
This story might resonate more with readers who enjoy women’s fiction with a hint of mystery — something emotionally grounded but not overly dark or triggering. Personally, it felt a little too “light” for my taste, but I can see it appealing to those who like stories about friendship, forgiveness, and healing.
Also, the audiobook narration was great — it added warmth and helped keep me engaged throughout.
Trigger Warnings: Mentions of suicide, domestic violence, grief and loss
Thank you to NetGalley for the advance copy in exchange for my honest review
Clara, Isley, and Peyton are lifelong best friends who reunite to honor their close friend who passed away when they were younger. Despite the years that have passed, they still carry the guilt of a secret surrounding their friend’s death. When they receive an ominous note threatening to expose the truth, old wounds reopen. As the women navigate this reunion, they’re each facing their own personal challenges with relationships, family, and identity, all while trying to decide how to confront their past.
The story alternates between the present-day reunion and the past point of view of their late friend, gradually revealing what really happened. The premise was strong, and I appreciated the exploration of grief, guilt, and friendship — but the execution felt a little flat for me. The book tackled some sensitive but important themes, and while the twist toward the end added some depth and intrigue, it took a long time to get there. The first 80% felt more like a light women’s fiction read than the suspense I was hoping for.
That said, the last portion of the book did redeem it a bit. The twist added an emotional punch and some unexpected drama that helped bring everything full circle, even if the ending felt slightly rushed. Overall, it wrapped up neatly.
This story might resonate more with readers who enjoy women’s fiction with a hint of mystery — something emotionally grounded but not overly dark or triggering. Personally, it felt a little too “light” for my taste, but I can see it appealing to those who like stories about friendship, forgiveness, and healing.
Also, the audiobook narration was great — it added warmth and helped keep me engaged throughout.
Trigger Warnings: Mentions of suicide, domestic violence, grief and loss
Thank you to NetGalley for the advance copy in exchange for my honest review
August 11, 2025
Jill Lynn has a way with story that keeps a reader guessing. In this, her newest novel, she’s taken it to the next level.
When three lifelong friends gather in Breckenridge along with their husbands for a combined “friendcation/fundraiser” for an organization they care deeply about, each comes bearing secrets. When a mysterious note that says, “Tell the truth or I will” appears on the kitchen counter in the house where they’re staying, each woman wonders who the note is intended for. And could the “truth” be the one they’ve vowed never to discuss?
Throughout the weekend, circumstances unfold that push them to discuss the night their other friend took her life near the end of their high school years twenty-one years ago. Which also gives them a safe space to come clean about the hard situations each one is facing.
This story kept me turning pages, wondering how each woman would both handle her situation and if the three friends would be able to move beyond the one night that altered everything for them. I loved the characters, who made me laugh and cry through the story.
The setting of Breckenridge was its own character in the story. It came alive in the book, perhaps especially since I’ve been there.
Jill Lynn tackles several tough but current issues, including suicide and divorce. But she does so in a heartfelt, gentle way.
I always enjoy stories of layered friendships, and this book absolutely satisfies that itch for those who enjoy women’s fiction and friendship stories. The themes of connection and honesty and second chances are beautifully woven throughout the book.
If you enjoy small-town contemporary women’s fiction, you need to get your hands on this book.
***I received a complimentary copy of this book through the publisher. I was not required to leave a review. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.***
When three lifelong friends gather in Breckenridge along with their husbands for a combined “friendcation/fundraiser” for an organization they care deeply about, each comes bearing secrets. When a mysterious note that says, “Tell the truth or I will” appears on the kitchen counter in the house where they’re staying, each woman wonders who the note is intended for. And could the “truth” be the one they’ve vowed never to discuss?
Throughout the weekend, circumstances unfold that push them to discuss the night their other friend took her life near the end of their high school years twenty-one years ago. Which also gives them a safe space to come clean about the hard situations each one is facing.
This story kept me turning pages, wondering how each woman would both handle her situation and if the three friends would be able to move beyond the one night that altered everything for them. I loved the characters, who made me laugh and cry through the story.
The setting of Breckenridge was its own character in the story. It came alive in the book, perhaps especially since I’ve been there.
Jill Lynn tackles several tough but current issues, including suicide and divorce. But she does so in a heartfelt, gentle way.
I always enjoy stories of layered friendships, and this book absolutely satisfies that itch for those who enjoy women’s fiction and friendship stories. The themes of connection and honesty and second chances are beautifully woven throughout the book.
If you enjoy small-town contemporary women’s fiction, you need to get your hands on this book.
***I received a complimentary copy of this book through the publisher. I was not required to leave a review. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.***
August 25, 2025
Reviewed at Happily Ever After Romance
Things We Keep Hidden is a haunting story of friendship, even sisterhood, between four high school friends who are now a trio of friends holding on to secrets from the night that Cece took her own life. Twenty years later, on a yearly vacation with their husbands, these women, Clara, Isley, and Payton, will face a threat that shatters their belief that a secret so long buried is close to being revealed. Each woman is holding on to secrets in their present-day life beyond what happened to Cece so many years ago. Tensions are running high, along with emotions that won’t stay contained for much longer. “Tell the truth, or I will.” There are so many different “truths”, and this gathering will either expose or heal; only time will tell that outcome.
First of all, a trigger warning. Although any reader should be aware simply from reading the cover description that these characters are dealing with suicide, drug use, domestic violence, depression, and more. If any of those subjects are a trigger for you, personally, continue with caution or simply walk away.
I enjoyed Things We Keep Hidden by Jill Lynn. It’s well-written, emotional, and kept me engaged from start to finish. My heart broke for so many characters, my anger rose for others, and throughout, I could feel the ties that bind these women, the love between them, and the heaviness of the secrets they all are carrying. Their story is one that will make you think about your own decisions, your own life, and wonder what you would do in their circumstances.
*I received an e-ARC of this novel from the publisher via NetGalley, and I sincerely thank the author or publishing house for their trust. It is my choice to leave a review giving my personal opinion about this book.*
Things We Keep Hidden is a haunting story of friendship, even sisterhood, between four high school friends who are now a trio of friends holding on to secrets from the night that Cece took her own life. Twenty years later, on a yearly vacation with their husbands, these women, Clara, Isley, and Payton, will face a threat that shatters their belief that a secret so long buried is close to being revealed. Each woman is holding on to secrets in their present-day life beyond what happened to Cece so many years ago. Tensions are running high, along with emotions that won’t stay contained for much longer. “Tell the truth, or I will.” There are so many different “truths”, and this gathering will either expose or heal; only time will tell that outcome.
First of all, a trigger warning. Although any reader should be aware simply from reading the cover description that these characters are dealing with suicide, drug use, domestic violence, depression, and more. If any of those subjects are a trigger for you, personally, continue with caution or simply walk away.
I enjoyed Things We Keep Hidden by Jill Lynn. It’s well-written, emotional, and kept me engaged from start to finish. My heart broke for so many characters, my anger rose for others, and throughout, I could feel the ties that bind these women, the love between them, and the heaviness of the secrets they all are carrying. Their story is one that will make you think about your own decisions, your own life, and wonder what you would do in their circumstances.
*I received an e-ARC of this novel from the publisher via NetGalley, and I sincerely thank the author or publishing house for their trust. It is my choice to leave a review giving my personal opinion about this book.*
August 1, 2025
Title: Things We Keep Hidden
Author: Jill Lynn
Format: 🎧
Narrator: Tanya Eby
Publisher: Harlequin Audio
Genre: Women’s Fiction- Family Drama with a bit of mystery
Pub Date: August 26, 2025
My Rating: 3.5 Stars Rounded up
Pages 336
Payton, Isley and Clara have known each other since childhood Once they finished college, married and moved to different areas they promised to get together yearly. Now the husbands join them.
Isley and her husband Trevor live in Denver and bought a vacation home called ‘The Haven’ located in Breckenridge, CO. They invited the friends for their annual ‘friendeation” stay at their new place. So the couples Isley and Trevor, Clara and Hank, Peyton and Liam plus their fifteen year-old daughter Regan as she had some issues and they felt they couldn’t leave her home with friends.
The group plans to enjoy an R&R but also to work on a fundraiser that honors their childhood friend Cece who committed suicide. Twenty years ago
However when a note stating Tell the truth or I will’; arrives they are all shaken. They realize they must confront that night twenty years ago when Cece took her life.
This is told from the POV of friends as well and Cece twenty years ago.
There is a mystery with Ceca’s death. However, I was like everyone else in thinking it was suicide since she had tried four years earlier. As I listened to Ceca’s story, I soon had doubts she would kill herself.
This story started out a slow family drama. In addition, to Ceca’s death and revealing what they experienced that night, there are some issues with the couples and their children.
I was pleased there is a HEA!
Want to thank NetGalley and Harlequin Audio for this early audiobook.
Publishing Release Date scheduled for August 26, 2025,
Author: Jill Lynn
Format: 🎧
Narrator: Tanya Eby
Publisher: Harlequin Audio
Genre: Women’s Fiction- Family Drama with a bit of mystery
Pub Date: August 26, 2025
My Rating: 3.5 Stars Rounded up
Pages 336
Payton, Isley and Clara have known each other since childhood Once they finished college, married and moved to different areas they promised to get together yearly. Now the husbands join them.
Isley and her husband Trevor live in Denver and bought a vacation home called ‘The Haven’ located in Breckenridge, CO. They invited the friends for their annual ‘friendeation” stay at their new place. So the couples Isley and Trevor, Clara and Hank, Peyton and Liam plus their fifteen year-old daughter Regan as she had some issues and they felt they couldn’t leave her home with friends.
The group plans to enjoy an R&R but also to work on a fundraiser that honors their childhood friend Cece who committed suicide. Twenty years ago
However when a note stating Tell the truth or I will’; arrives they are all shaken. They realize they must confront that night twenty years ago when Cece took her life.
This is told from the POV of friends as well and Cece twenty years ago.
There is a mystery with Ceca’s death. However, I was like everyone else in thinking it was suicide since she had tried four years earlier. As I listened to Ceca’s story, I soon had doubts she would kill herself.
This story started out a slow family drama. In addition, to Ceca’s death and revealing what they experienced that night, there are some issues with the couples and their children.
I was pleased there is a HEA!
Want to thank NetGalley and Harlequin Audio for this early audiobook.
Publishing Release Date scheduled for August 26, 2025,
August 4, 2025
Things We Keep Hidden is a dramatic change from Jill Lynn's previous titles, and I ended up absolutely loving this mystery that wove and weaved in ways I never could have seen coming.
The synopsis had me intrigued right from the beginning, as I loved the idea of the story focusing around three adult friends who reunite for a weekend of fun, while trying to keep the fact that their lives are falling apart from one another. As well, past secrets that they thought they'd long ago buried seem determined to emerge this weekend, and these three might just find themselves in places they never could have expected.
A wonderful, dramatic mystery that focuses on friendship, family, and the lengths we'll go to keep our secrets hidden where they belong, Things We Keep Hidden is truly Jill Lynn at her best. This story captivated me right from the opening chapters, and I ended up reading the second half in one sitting.
A wonderful, fictional tale that tackles deep issues sensitively and responsibly, this one ended up being everything I was hoping for, and was a story that stayed with me long after finishing it.
The author did a wonderful job of blending a well, written fast paced mystery together with a dramatic women's fiction storyline that provided healing and growth for three women who desperately so needed it.
I can't personally recommend this one enough, especially if you enjoy clean women's fiction with a touch of mystery, and I will definitely be looking forward to what this author chooses to give her reader's next.
Final Rating: 4/5.
Thanks so much to the author for allowing me to read and review this title!
I voluntarily read and reviewed a complimentary advance reader copy of this novel from the author as part of her street team. I was not required to give a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own, and this is my honest review.
The synopsis had me intrigued right from the beginning, as I loved the idea of the story focusing around three adult friends who reunite for a weekend of fun, while trying to keep the fact that their lives are falling apart from one another. As well, past secrets that they thought they'd long ago buried seem determined to emerge this weekend, and these three might just find themselves in places they never could have expected.
A wonderful, dramatic mystery that focuses on friendship, family, and the lengths we'll go to keep our secrets hidden where they belong, Things We Keep Hidden is truly Jill Lynn at her best. This story captivated me right from the opening chapters, and I ended up reading the second half in one sitting.
A wonderful, fictional tale that tackles deep issues sensitively and responsibly, this one ended up being everything I was hoping for, and was a story that stayed with me long after finishing it.
The author did a wonderful job of blending a well, written fast paced mystery together with a dramatic women's fiction storyline that provided healing and growth for three women who desperately so needed it.
I can't personally recommend this one enough, especially if you enjoy clean women's fiction with a touch of mystery, and I will definitely be looking forward to what this author chooses to give her reader's next.
Final Rating: 4/5.
Thanks so much to the author for allowing me to read and review this title!
I voluntarily read and reviewed a complimentary advance reader copy of this novel from the author as part of her street team. I was not required to give a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own, and this is my honest review.
August 15, 2025
This story follows three women who have been friends since their school days. They are planning a “friendcation” at a vacation home in Colorado and somehow their husbands and a teen daughter are there, too. When a random, threatening note shows up in their house one evening, it sets off a serious of events involving confessions and secrets- all the stuff we love about a goods mystery/thriller. The ladies have a buried secret amongst them that dates back to high school. The thing is- the secret can potentially ruin their lives if found out.
While I did appreciate the breaking down of everything and the eventual resolution, I felt that the big scary secret was something of a letdown. I was imagining something truly awful enough that it justifies holding onto for what seems like 30+ years. IMHO- it wasn’t.
The other thing that irked me was that some of the dialogue between the wives and their husbands was a little cringe. I just couldn’t picture the men saying some of the stuff they did. Maybe that’s just a me thing, though. It made it harder to connect with the characters.
Anyway, it’s a fairly quick listen and the ending is about as tied up in a neat bow as you can get. I would say 3 stars for me but I can see how it might be more enjoyable to others. I think I’ve just read too many thrillers that it takes more to sort of blow me away plot- wise.
Thank you to #NetGalley and #HarlequinAudio for the ARC of the audiobook.
While I did appreciate the breaking down of everything and the eventual resolution, I felt that the big scary secret was something of a letdown. I was imagining something truly awful enough that it justifies holding onto for what seems like 30+ years. IMHO- it wasn’t.
The other thing that irked me was that some of the dialogue between the wives and their husbands was a little cringe. I just couldn’t picture the men saying some of the stuff they did. Maybe that’s just a me thing, though. It made it harder to connect with the characters.
Anyway, it’s a fairly quick listen and the ending is about as tied up in a neat bow as you can get. I would say 3 stars for me but I can see how it might be more enjoyable to others. I think I’ve just read too many thrillers that it takes more to sort of blow me away plot- wise.
Thank you to #NetGalley and #HarlequinAudio for the ARC of the audiobook.
October 23, 2025
“Things We Keep Hidden” is about 3 friends who reunite to save a program that honors their high school friend. Isley, Clara, and Payton come with their spouses to Breckenridge, Colorado, twenty years after CeCe committed suicide. The friends have never talked about that night; however, they are forced to deal with the pain and their part in her suicide when a note is found on the kitchen counter, “Tell the truth or I will.”
Who is the note for, or what secret is it referring to? Is it linked to the night CeCe died, or is it something else? Each woman comes to the vacation with a secret they haven’t revealed to their friends. Payton’s marriage is falling apart, and she brings her daughter on the trip because Payton feels Regan can’t be left home alone. Isley’s son almost killed a girl and is in rehab, and she went behind her husband's back and is feeling the guilt. Clara and her husband may lose the family farm. On top of all of the individual problems, they have to confront the night CeCe died and their part in it, something they have never spoken about among themselves or to their husbands.
At the end of the weekend, the secrets are revealed with a shocking twist.
Jill Lynn tells a story where there are a lot of parts, but they all come to a head in the end. I think she is a great storyteller and look forward to more of her books.
I listened to the audiobook, narrated by Tanya Eby. Her voice is evident, very easy listening.
Who is the note for, or what secret is it referring to? Is it linked to the night CeCe died, or is it something else? Each woman comes to the vacation with a secret they haven’t revealed to their friends. Payton’s marriage is falling apart, and she brings her daughter on the trip because Payton feels Regan can’t be left home alone. Isley’s son almost killed a girl and is in rehab, and she went behind her husband's back and is feeling the guilt. Clara and her husband may lose the family farm. On top of all of the individual problems, they have to confront the night CeCe died and their part in it, something they have never spoken about among themselves or to their husbands.
At the end of the weekend, the secrets are revealed with a shocking twist.
Jill Lynn tells a story where there are a lot of parts, but they all come to a head in the end. I think she is a great storyteller and look forward to more of her books.
I listened to the audiobook, narrated by Tanya Eby. Her voice is evident, very easy listening.
August 1, 2025
Always curious to dive into a friends with secrets novel and this one had alot happening, this isn't just your average clean romance story.
The last time lifelong friends Payton, Isley and Clara were together, Clara broke their unwritten rule and brought up the one thing they never talk about. And now, more than twenty years after their friend Cece took her life, they must confront that night as the three women and their husbands—plus one unexpected guest—gather at Isley’s Breckenridge vacation home. With tension already simmering just below the surface of their relationship, they’re each left shaken when a cryptic note Tell the truth or I will.
Who is the message for and what does it refer to? The women fear it could be linked to the truth they’ve kept hidden since the night Cece died…or maybe it has something to do with one of the problems they’ve each brought with them.
Isley’s son is in rehab after narrowly avoiding jail time, spurring her to a reckless act of her own. Clara, usually so careful to follow rules, is haunted by the one night that she didn’t. And Payton has been in denial regarding her husband’s so-called “plan” for their marriage.
As the weekend unfolds, all three will revisit the bonds they share and the challenges that have shaped their lives. And by the trip’s end, a truth that shocks them all will be revealed.
The last time lifelong friends Payton, Isley and Clara were together, Clara broke their unwritten rule and brought up the one thing they never talk about. And now, more than twenty years after their friend Cece took her life, they must confront that night as the three women and their husbands—plus one unexpected guest—gather at Isley’s Breckenridge vacation home. With tension already simmering just below the surface of their relationship, they’re each left shaken when a cryptic note Tell the truth or I will.
Who is the message for and what does it refer to? The women fear it could be linked to the truth they’ve kept hidden since the night Cece died…or maybe it has something to do with one of the problems they’ve each brought with them.
Isley’s son is in rehab after narrowly avoiding jail time, spurring her to a reckless act of her own. Clara, usually so careful to follow rules, is haunted by the one night that she didn’t. And Payton has been in denial regarding her husband’s so-called “plan” for their marriage.
As the weekend unfolds, all three will revisit the bonds they share and the challenges that have shaped their lives. And by the trip’s end, a truth that shocks them all will be revealed.
August 26, 2025
I was really surprised by how much I enjoyed this book! I’m used to more extreme psychological thrillers, but this was more of a tame mystery with lots of misunderstandings and secrets hidden amongst a group of friends. Clara, Payton, and Isley grew up as best friends. Their best friend, Cece, died from an apparent suicide when they were teenagers. A foundation to promote mental health awareness and suicide prevention was created in Cece’s honor, and these friends and their husbands are meeting up to try to improve the likelihood of this foundation continuing since it is starting to lose funding. When the crew is out, a note is left at the house stating that they need to come out with the truth or it will be told for them. We keep listening to the story and find out that all parties involved have some secrets they are hiding.
I loved the way Tanya Eby narrated this book. She did an excellent job jumping amongst characters. The author, Jill Lynn, did such a great job making the reading continue to guess what was actually going on! I thought it was really nice listening to a group of older people in a mystery as a woman who is turning 40 this year! The problems and secrets in the book were all somewhat relatable, so the outcome was very fulfilling. I highly recommend this book!
I loved the way Tanya Eby narrated this book. She did an excellent job jumping amongst characters. The author, Jill Lynn, did such a great job making the reading continue to guess what was actually going on! I thought it was really nice listening to a group of older people in a mystery as a woman who is turning 40 this year! The problems and secrets in the book were all somewhat relatable, so the outcome was very fulfilling. I highly recommend this book!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 122 reviews