One Night in Sixes by Arianne ‘Tex’ Thompson, genre: Rural Fantasy
Stars: 4.5
I confess, I struggled through the first fifth of the book. This was my first time to read Rural Fantasy, and I’m not sure what I expected. Honestly, Fantasy in general is not my go-to genre. I’m more of a mystery, thriller, historical fiction aficionado. That being said, I’m going to accept the blame for not being hooked in the first few pages. I chose to push through, though, as this book had been highly recommended by people I respect. During the initial struggle I tried to explain the story to my husband, and his immediate response was, “Oh like Star Trek? When Worf and Data and the others get trapped in the Ancient West on the holodeck…” And then it clicked for me. No, that’s not what it’s like (maybe DS9?), however, this story, setting, and cast of characters is as diverse, complicated, and layered as the Star Trek tales. Once I made that connection I was able to suspend my disbelief and relax into the story. I am so glad because I was well rewarded for the effort.
Others have summarized the story, so I’m not going to take the time to do that. Here’s the top three things that impressed me about One Night in Sixes.
1. Thompson draws on a rich and diverse heritage of myth and history to create her characters. She based her various characters on the mer-people of mythology, the indigenous peoples of the American Southwest, slaves and bi-racial people from various cultures, and those were just the ones I recognized. I took the liberty of looking up the author’s bio, and was not surprised to find an undergrad degree in history and a master’s degree in literature.
2. The linguistics made me happy. I quickly realized that each of the cultures Thompson created spoke a variation of either French, Spanish, or a phonetically based variation on what the cowpokes spoke in the old western movies. It was creative and fun. Some other reviewers found the made up languages frustrating and confusing, and commented on the glossary being in the back and not mentioned ahead of time. I’d like to counter that point by saying that readers who don’t like wading through the characters’ native languages can just as easily skip every italicized word, as it’s all clarified in the context.
3. The various themes were both obvious and subtle, and I found them thought-provoking. For example, Thompson addresses loss of freedom/slavery from a number of causes and perspectives, as well as self-imposed or situational lack of freedom, and lack of employment options. On one hand, there is no slavery in the town of Sixes as the community leaders are quick to point out, yet at the same time there are many who have been born into servitude and see it as an honor, and others who have placed themselves in servitude as penitence, and some like the main character of Appaloosa Elim who was bought as a child but became one of the family. Slavery throughout world history has been very complex, and human-trafficking is an on-going problem today. Thompson opens the door to consider various points of view, especially from the enslaved.
Of course there are always things readers dislike, and in an effort to make this review objective, let me mention a few items that left me a bit cold.
1. The opening. I know I already mentioned that, but it really was difficult for me to get into this fictional world. I honestly don’t know if that’s a failing on my part of that of the author. Then again, I tend to read stand-alones rather than trilogies, so maybe this is expected for this long of a story arc.
2. The author assumes the reader is already familiar with this universe, and there is very little introduction up front of the characters, their history, or their special abilities. By the time I got to the end of the story I had it mostly figured out, and now can’t wait to read the next book. Unless you are committed to reading the entire trilogy, it may be a bit frustrating to wade through One Night in Sixes to figure it out, and then be done. That could be a problem with the storytelling, or part of the genius. I really want to start the next book.
3. Marketing/cover design would lead one to believe this is a shoot ‘em up western with some Gothic elements. On the back it says “Fantasy” for genre. I bought it due to a recommendation, but wonder if part of my struggle starting the story was the expectation created by the cover art—which is very cool, but not relevant to the story.
When I initially finished this book, I thought it was a 3.5 star, but as I’ve gone about my business in the week following, I realize I’m still thinking over the characters, setting, and themes. The English teacher in me would love to use it teaching a high school or college class. I can think of so many activities and discussions this book would generate. One of the things I do love about fantasy and SciFi is that you can address really difficult current issues a bit removed and objectively by putting them in this type of fiction. I’ve upgraded my impression of the book because Thompson succeeded in doing what very few authors do—she made me think and created characters that I can’t forget. I hope in the next installment I learn more of the back-story of Dia and Twoblood especially.
I would absolutely recommend this book without hesitation. Although there are some complex themes, this story is appropriate for YA through adult readers. I believe readers who are willing to think and work a bit more while reading will be rewarded. If you are looking for a simple escape to pass the time, you might want to pass on this story. If you want to be challenged and draw on all you know of world history and world mythology, this will do it. To simplify matters, if you are a passionate Trekkie because of all the layers and complexity of the Star Trek universe, this will work for you. If you are in the Star Wars camp because you simply like a fast hero’s journey with a lot of action, and the guy gets the girl in the end, you might find this more frustration than you bargained for.