What do you think?
Rate this book
Emma Knightley Mysteries #2
Murder at Donwell Abbey
In this latest Regency-era mystery, Jane Austen’s clever Emma Knightley navigates shocking changes in her family—while meeting her match in a deadly adversary . . .
Emma’s spirits are elevated after she and husband George Knightley host a joyful holiday celebration at the Hartfield estate. But it’s instantly a bitter January when her father makes an unexpected announcement—he and Miss Hetty Bates have decided to marry. Not only must Emma relinquish her role as mistress of the household, but also accept the reality that the excitable Miss Bates will become her stepmother . . .
More unwanted news arrives during an extravagant betrothal ball at Donwell Abbey, the grand Knightley estate where Emma and George will soon permanently reside. Nearly every villager in Highbury revels in the dazzling affair—except Emma’s hardworking lady’s maid, Prudence Parr. To Emma’s horror, Prudence is found dead, sprawled across the stones of the library terrace . . .
The woman’s tragic fall is quickly ruled a terrible accident and whispers circulate around personal troubles leading up to her untimely demise. But Emma’s instincts tell her that something far more sinister is at play. Now, Highbury’s matchmaker-turned-sleuth vows to outwit a cunning criminal before an innocent man loses his freedom—or Donwell Abbey plunges into a darker mystery . . .
Emma’s spirits are elevated after she and husband George Knightley host a joyful holiday celebration at the Hartfield estate. But it’s instantly a bitter January when her father makes an unexpected announcement—he and Miss Hetty Bates have decided to marry. Not only must Emma relinquish her role as mistress of the household, but also accept the reality that the excitable Miss Bates will become her stepmother . . .
More unwanted news arrives during an extravagant betrothal ball at Donwell Abbey, the grand Knightley estate where Emma and George will soon permanently reside. Nearly every villager in Highbury revels in the dazzling affair—except Emma’s hardworking lady’s maid, Prudence Parr. To Emma’s horror, Prudence is found dead, sprawled across the stones of the library terrace . . .
The woman’s tragic fall is quickly ruled a terrible accident and whispers circulate around personal troubles leading up to her untimely demise. But Emma’s instincts tell her that something far more sinister is at play. Now, Highbury’s matchmaker-turned-sleuth vows to outwit a cunning criminal before an innocent man loses his freedom—or Donwell Abbey plunges into a darker mystery . . .
416 pages, Hardcover
First published November 25, 2025
84 people are currently reading
6200 people want to read
About the author
Vanessa Kelly
37 books1,766 followersVanessa Kelly is a bestselling author of historical mystery and historical romance. She has won multiple awards, including the prestigious Maggie Medallion for best historical romance. She is a USA Today, Barnes & Noble, BookScan, and Amazon bestseller several times over. To date, her books have been published in eleven languages. Vanessa also wrote USA Today bestselling contemporary romance and romantic suspense novels with her husband, under the pen name of V.K. Sykes.
After receiving her MA in English literature from Rutgers University, Vanessa spent several years in the Ph.D program at the University of Toronto, studying women authors of the 18th Century. She worked as a researcher for many years, and currently resides in Ottawa, Canada, with her husband.
After receiving her MA in English literature from Rutgers University, Vanessa spent several years in the Ph.D program at the University of Toronto, studying women authors of the 18th Century. She worked as a researcher for many years, and currently resides in Ottawa, Canada, with her husband.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 145 reviews
November 25, 2025
3.5 stars, rounded up cuz I love "Emma" so. This is the second installment of the "Emma Knightly Mysteries" in which Austen's Emma (now-married to George K.) inadvertently finds herself involved in murder cases and solves them as an amateur sleuth. And while I enjoyed the first installment a lot this one was less successful to me - at least from the mystery angle - I knew pretty quickly who did it, sigh. Something else that really pulled me out of the story, set in the Regency, was all the talk in about "set ups", "frame jobs" and "going down rabbit holes" - pretty sure that's not authentic to that time period. The characters were very well done - Emma was great as was her assistant here - Ms. Bates, who's been asked to be her step-mom by Mr. Woodhouse! Still enjoyable as an Austen retelling/JAFF. Will read it if there's another.
September 25, 2025
Thanks so much to NetGalley for the free Kindle book. My review is voluntarily given, and my opinions are my own.
I think my absolute favorite thing about this book was seeing Hetty Bates reprimand someone. ❤️ I loved that so much. The idea that she would have to deal with helping plan the marriage between her father and Miss Bates is just so ridiculously funny. Her future stepmother. 👩
There were so many red herrings that I had no idea who was the murderer. Have read a few mysteries this year that are so obvious, which is always disappointing. Not at all the case here. :)
Love how each character has been showing growth. Can't wait for the next book to come out! Definitely would recommend this book to anyone looking for their next cozy, even if they haven't read Jane Austen's book Emma. It isn't necessary to read first at all. This is a stand-alone book; you can read this one before reading the first one with no issues.
Also, for those looking for the smut rating, this is a totally clean book.
Definitely recommend!
I think my absolute favorite thing about this book was seeing Hetty Bates reprimand someone. ❤️ I loved that so much. The idea that she would have to deal with helping plan the marriage between her father and Miss Bates is just so ridiculously funny. Her future stepmother. 👩
There were so many red herrings that I had no idea who was the murderer. Have read a few mysteries this year that are so obvious, which is always disappointing. Not at all the case here. :)
Love how each character has been showing growth. Can't wait for the next book to come out! Definitely would recommend this book to anyone looking for their next cozy, even if they haven't read Jane Austen's book Emma. It isn't necessary to read first at all. This is a stand-alone book; you can read this one before reading the first one with no issues.
Also, for those looking for the smut rating, this is a totally clean book.
Definitely recommend!
December 4, 2025
Murder at Donwell Abbey by Vanessa Kelly
4 Stars
Book 2 in the Emma Knightley Mystery Series
Read this series if you enjoy:
✨ Regency settings
✨ Jane Austen continuations done right
✨ Cozy mysteries with heart and humor
✨ Smart, observant heroines
✨ Mysteries centered on family secrets
This was another delight to read after Murder in Highbury! Perfect for Austen fans and cozy mystery lovers. The author always captures the wit and spark of Jane Austen in these books while keeping you invested in the whodunit storyline.
Emma and her husband George host a holiday celebration at the Hartfield estate but things get wild when her father announces him and Mrs. Bates are engaged to be married! Emma's lady's maid Prudence Parr is found dead and Emma's instincts tell her something more happened here....once again, her and Mr. Knightley have to figure out what happened....
Overall, I just really enjoy my time in this series. I haven't read Emma myself, but it makes me want to next year!
Highly recommend.
Content: mentions of death, murder, generally clean with maybe 1 swear word but more so a natural word used during that time. I have no concerns with content overall.
Thank you to the publisher for a copy to honestly read and review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
4 Stars
Book 2 in the Emma Knightley Mystery Series
Read this series if you enjoy:
✨ Regency settings
✨ Jane Austen continuations done right
✨ Cozy mysteries with heart and humor
✨ Smart, observant heroines
✨ Mysteries centered on family secrets
This was another delight to read after Murder in Highbury! Perfect for Austen fans and cozy mystery lovers. The author always captures the wit and spark of Jane Austen in these books while keeping you invested in the whodunit storyline.
Emma and her husband George host a holiday celebration at the Hartfield estate but things get wild when her father announces him and Mrs. Bates are engaged to be married! Emma's lady's maid Prudence Parr is found dead and Emma's instincts tell her something more happened here....once again, her and Mr. Knightley have to figure out what happened....
Overall, I just really enjoy my time in this series. I haven't read Emma myself, but it makes me want to next year!
Highly recommend.
Content: mentions of death, murder, generally clean with maybe 1 swear word but more so a natural word used during that time. I have no concerns with content overall.
Thank you to the publisher for a copy to honestly read and review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
November 21, 2025
"Murder at Donwell Abbey" by Vanessa Kelly is book two in the “Emma Knightley Mysteries” series but can also be read as a standalone. I loved the first book, and this one was so fun as well! I love seeing Emma from Jane Austen’s “Emma” solve mysteries in this witty book that is a tribute to Jane Austen herself. The way Ms. Kelly writes and the grasp she has on the characters in the world of “Emma” makes one feel that they are reading a continuation of Austen’s work where the heroine is solving mysteries. And who better to solve mysteries than the sometimes-nosey Emma Knightley?! I love the witty dialogue and humor (there’s a great reference to excellent boiled potatoes!). Although it is a murder mystery, it is also mostly fun and cozy. The writing, historical detail, and mystery are all well done. I especially loved seeing Emma partner with her soon to be stepmother, Miss Bates, to solve the mystery. I could not fully figure out the mystery before the end, which is always the sign of a good mystery. I hope there are many books in this universe! Well done Ms. Kelly!
Content: I give this book a higher PG rating. Some examples of the content: someone is possibly drunk; the words “bloody,” “bastard,” and “da*n” are used; mention of ghosts; characters drink alcohol; mention of a bloody article of clothing that is found; vague se*ual innuendo; the Lord’s name is taken in vain.
TW: speculation of su*cide; racism; possible insanity.
4.5 stars rounded up!
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
Content: I give this book a higher PG rating. Some examples of the content: someone is possibly drunk; the words “bloody,” “bastard,” and “da*n” are used; mention of ghosts; characters drink alcohol; mention of a bloody article of clothing that is found; vague se*ual innuendo; the Lord’s name is taken in vain.
TW: speculation of su*cide; racism; possible insanity.
4.5 stars rounded up!
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
November 27, 2025
After enduring the shock that her widowed father is planning to get married- to MISS BATES!, the engagement ball Emma hosts for them at Donwell Abbey finishes with a murder. Vanessa Kelly delighted me right down to my shoe roses with her first Emma Knightley mystery, Murder in Highbury so I was ecstatic to press on with the next series installment, Murder at Donwell Abbey.
As I said, Emma’s family Christmas came with a shocking bit of news. Chatty, spinster Hetty Bates, her father’s long-time friend is soon to become her step-mother and mistress of Hartfield. Emma’s sister and brother-in-law, Isabella and John, are equally appalled. But, with the steady example of her husband, George, Emma quickly works through the shock to the extent that she can offer the couple well-wishes, swiftly plan an engagement ball, and begin adjusting to her leaving behind Hartfield with a new mistress and taking up life with George at his estate, Donwell Abbey.
However, the ball is not a resounding success. She discovers one of the guests is embarrassingly inebriated and then worse, a maid servant plunges from the upstairs window to her death. Emma is saddened by the maid’s demise, but also frustrated to be dealing, once again, with the coroner Dr. Hughes and the obnoxious village Constable Sharpe. Everyone thinks it is a sad and unfortunate accident, but Emma is struck by a few curious facts that make her pursue some inquiries of her own.
And, her detecting leads through some surprising twists and turns to a shocking truth and someone who doesn’t want that truth revealed.
Murder at Donwell Abbey, like the previous book, continues the blend of a sequel story line to the Jane Austen novel, Emma, for the well-beloved citizens of Highbury led by Emma Knightley. The historical setting and development of the characters is fabulously well done. Again, I am struck by how well the Emma character with her curiosity about people and her position in the village makes her a superb choice for an amateur sleuth. It certainly doesn’t hurt that her own dear Mr. Knightley is the local magistrate and respects her opinion even if he doesn’t always agree with her.
At first, I was at a loss as Emma to figure out the death because the evidence was sparse and there weren’t any strong threads to pull at. However, as Emma did what she does best- connecting with people, jumping to conclusions and checking them out, the trail to the truth emerges. It was gently-paced at first and very cozy in tone, but the tension built and there was an exciting climax scene to get the heart-pumping.
All in all, Murder at Donwell Abbey rivaled the first book for me and left me in a state of satisfaction and wanting another murder mystery for Emma to solve. Whether you’ve picked up Austen’s Emma or not, those who enjoy historical cozy mysteries should definitely give the Emma Knightley series a go.
My full review will post at Books of My Heart on 11.23.25
I rec'd an eARC via NetGalley and an ARC from Kensington Books and Austenprose to read in exchange for an honest review.
As I said, Emma’s family Christmas came with a shocking bit of news. Chatty, spinster Hetty Bates, her father’s long-time friend is soon to become her step-mother and mistress of Hartfield. Emma’s sister and brother-in-law, Isabella and John, are equally appalled. But, with the steady example of her husband, George, Emma quickly works through the shock to the extent that she can offer the couple well-wishes, swiftly plan an engagement ball, and begin adjusting to her leaving behind Hartfield with a new mistress and taking up life with George at his estate, Donwell Abbey.
However, the ball is not a resounding success. She discovers one of the guests is embarrassingly inebriated and then worse, a maid servant plunges from the upstairs window to her death. Emma is saddened by the maid’s demise, but also frustrated to be dealing, once again, with the coroner Dr. Hughes and the obnoxious village Constable Sharpe. Everyone thinks it is a sad and unfortunate accident, but Emma is struck by a few curious facts that make her pursue some inquiries of her own.
And, her detecting leads through some surprising twists and turns to a shocking truth and someone who doesn’t want that truth revealed.
Murder at Donwell Abbey, like the previous book, continues the blend of a sequel story line to the Jane Austen novel, Emma, for the well-beloved citizens of Highbury led by Emma Knightley. The historical setting and development of the characters is fabulously well done. Again, I am struck by how well the Emma character with her curiosity about people and her position in the village makes her a superb choice for an amateur sleuth. It certainly doesn’t hurt that her own dear Mr. Knightley is the local magistrate and respects her opinion even if he doesn’t always agree with her.
At first, I was at a loss as Emma to figure out the death because the evidence was sparse and there weren’t any strong threads to pull at. However, as Emma did what she does best- connecting with people, jumping to conclusions and checking them out, the trail to the truth emerges. It was gently-paced at first and very cozy in tone, but the tension built and there was an exciting climax scene to get the heart-pumping.
All in all, Murder at Donwell Abbey rivaled the first book for me and left me in a state of satisfaction and wanting another murder mystery for Emma to solve. Whether you’ve picked up Austen’s Emma or not, those who enjoy historical cozy mysteries should definitely give the Emma Knightley series a go.
My full review will post at Books of My Heart on 11.23.25
I rec'd an eARC via NetGalley and an ARC from Kensington Books and Austenprose to read in exchange for an honest review.
September 24, 2025
I was so pleased to receive this ARC from NetGalley since I devoured the first book.
*3.5 Firstly, I think this book should have been called DEATH AT DONWELL ABBEY to differentiate it from the first book in the series. Similar to the first book in the series I felt that this was overly long and dragged on at points, but was still enjoyable. The renderings of the characters feel true to the original work and I loved the cute moments between George and Emma. I wish there were more! I didn't see the end coming and the end of the mystery was a total surprise. That being said, I didn't find it as satisfying as the first book's mystery. I hope that Vanessa Kelly keeps writing these and includes Jane and Harriet more in the next one.
*3.5 Firstly, I think this book should have been called DEATH AT DONWELL ABBEY to differentiate it from the first book in the series. Similar to the first book in the series I felt that this was overly long and dragged on at points, but was still enjoyable. The renderings of the characters feel true to the original work and I loved the cute moments between George and Emma. I wish there were more! I didn't see the end coming and the end of the mystery was a total surprise. That being said, I didn't find it as satisfying as the first book's mystery. I hope that Vanessa Kelly keeps writing these and includes Jane and Harriet more in the next one.
December 28, 2025
I've finally finished Book #2, Murder at Donwell Abbey, of the Emma Knightley historical mystery series by Vanessa Kelly, and unfortunately, this was a difficult read for me.
The story as a whole did not capture my attention, as evidenced by the fact that it has taken me a month to finish reading it. It definitely wasn't a page turner for me, which is what I enjoy and look for in a historical mystery, and while I really liked Emma and George's characters, it felt as if the villain's character development was given short shrift in the body of the story, only for the reader to be TOLD at the end of the book what made his deeds and reasoning so dastardly. He became a sort of convenient scapegoat because no one was really paying attention to him - including me - rather than being an integral player in the book's mystery as a whole. Additionally, there were scenes which didn't seem to move the plot forward in terms of the evolution or the solving of the crime(s), so while I read them, I didn't appreciate that they were dead ends for the story - for example, Emma's sister and her family returning to London and then having to head back to Highbury to keep Emma's father company at Hartfield.
For me, it was a bit of a slog - and disappointingly so. I'm not sure I will continue with the series, although the covers are fun, and the idea behind the stories is a clever one.
2.5 stars rounded up to 3.
I received a copy of the book from NetGalley, and I am leaving my honest opinion voluntarily.
The story as a whole did not capture my attention, as evidenced by the fact that it has taken me a month to finish reading it. It definitely wasn't a page turner for me, which is what I enjoy and look for in a historical mystery, and while I really liked Emma and George's characters, it felt as if the villain's character development was given short shrift in the body of the story, only for the reader to be TOLD at the end of the book what made his deeds and reasoning so dastardly. He became a sort of convenient scapegoat because no one was really paying attention to him - including me - rather than being an integral player in the book's mystery as a whole. Additionally, there were scenes which didn't seem to move the plot forward in terms of the evolution or the solving of the crime(s), so while I read them, I didn't appreciate that they were dead ends for the story - for example, Emma's sister and her family returning to London and then having to head back to Highbury to keep Emma's father company at Hartfield.
For me, it was a bit of a slog - and disappointingly so. I'm not sure I will continue with the series, although the covers are fun, and the idea behind the stories is a clever one.
2.5 stars rounded up to 3.
I received a copy of the book from NetGalley, and I am leaving my honest opinion voluntarily.
February 1, 2026
3.5 Stars rounded to 4.
October 26, 2025
1816 Emma Knightley is shocked by the announcement by her father, that he is to marry Miss Bates. But even more so when at the engagement party held at Donwell Abbey a maid dies. But is it murder. What are the strange lights in the area. Emma decides to investigate with the help of Miss Bates. But more shocks are yet to come.
An entertaining and well-written cozy mystery with its cast of likeable and varied characters.
An ARC was provided by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
An entertaining and well-written cozy mystery with its cast of likeable and varied characters.
An ARC was provided by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
December 16, 2025
I seriously did not want to put this book down! Though I’m not totally sure if I feel right about reading murder mysteries for entertainment, this book is well-done. I enjoyed both the canon and original characters, and the writing was excellent: faithful to Austen’s style. Emma and Knightley’s banter was a highlight, as was seeing Miss Bates occasionally have some depth of character! There was a good balance of comedy with the seriousness one would expect in a murder mystery, and the victim was treated with appropriate respect and grief. It is an interesting concept to have Emma turn her clever mind away from matchmaking and toward solving mysteries.
I give this 4.5 stars (some reasons include the marriage of Miss Bates and Mr. Woodhouse seeming too out-of-character, and I guessed the murderer pretty quickly), but will round up to 5! I was thrilled to receive an eARC.
Thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Publishing for the free eARC. I post this review voluntarily with my honest opinions.
Content warnings:
Violence:
Romance: non-explicit comment between a husband and wife about what they did “last night”
Language: some swearing, including taking the Lord’s name in vain; some characters make racist comments against an Irish Catholic character
I give this 4.5 stars (some reasons include the marriage of Miss Bates and Mr. Woodhouse seeming too out-of-character, and I guessed the murderer pretty quickly), but will round up to 5! I was thrilled to receive an eARC.
Thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Publishing for the free eARC. I post this review voluntarily with my honest opinions.
Content warnings:
Violence:
Romance: non-explicit comment between a husband and wife about what they did “last night”
Language: some swearing, including taking the Lord’s name in vain; some characters make racist comments against an Irish Catholic character
September 1, 2025
I’m always thrilled to be along for the ride of another Emma Knightley mystery in the charming village of Highbury. This time we have the joyous news of an upcoming wedding between Mr. Woodhouse and Miss Bates. What fun!
In true murder mystery fashion, the happy engagement celebration comes to a screeching halt with the discovery of a body. Emma once again finds herself in the thick of an intriguing mystery. I always cherish another visit with my favorite Austen characters and this series is no exception. If you enjoy Austen continuations and murder mysteries, this is a book series you don’t want to miss.
Good to Know:
A few instances of profanity and God’s name in vain.
Thank you, Vanessa Kelly, Kensington Books, and Austenprose for the opportunity to read this book ahead of publication! All opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
In true murder mystery fashion, the happy engagement celebration comes to a screeching halt with the discovery of a body. Emma once again finds herself in the thick of an intriguing mystery. I always cherish another visit with my favorite Austen characters and this series is no exception. If you enjoy Austen continuations and murder mysteries, this is a book series you don’t want to miss.
Good to Know:
A few instances of profanity and God’s name in vain.
Thank you, Vanessa Kelly, Kensington Books, and Austenprose for the opportunity to read this book ahead of publication! All opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
December 1, 2025
What is a book that you couldn’t put down? I couldn’t put down Murder at Donwell Abbey by Vanessa Kelly!
Emma Knightley is surprised to discover that her reclusive father is engaged . . . to the always talkative Miss Bates! While hosting an engagement party for the couple, a person is discovered dead. Did they fall out of an upper story window or were they pushed? Emma is on the case to solve this crime.
My thoughts on the novel:
• This is the second novel in the Emma Knightley mystery series. You can read this novel as a standalone, but I think it adds to the story to read both books.
• This was a delightful mystery that was very readable. I read it quickly and didn’t want it down.
• I loved that the characters from Jane Austen’s Emma have their stories continued in this novel.
• The characters are true to Austen’s creations.
• Emma is a good sleuth with her eye for detail and for knowing everyone’s business. She doesn’t leave things alone until she gets an answer.
• I liked that Miss Bates becomes Emma’s mystery solving assistant. This character was fleshed out more in this novel while remaining true to the original.
• Emma and Mr. Knightley (George) make such a cute couple. I enjoyed their interactions.
• There were plenty of red herrings in this mystery to keep one guessing. It had a great climax and conclusion.
• It was a witty and fun book. I enjoyed the reference for “excellent boiled potatoes’ that I felt was an Easter egg for Austen fans (in particular fans of the 2005 Pride and Prejudice adaptation).
• This is a historical cozy mystery set during the Regency period.
• It is a clean read.
• This story is set during the Christmas season.
Overall, Murder at Donwell Abbey by Vanessa Kelly was a very entertaining cozy historical mystery novel and a great continuation of Emma by Jane Austen.
Book Source: Thank-you to @vanessakellyauthor @kensingtonbooks @austenprose for a review copy of this novel as part of the Austenprose PR Book Tour.
This review was first posted on my blog at: https://lauragerold.blogspot.com/2025...
Emma Knightley is surprised to discover that her reclusive father is engaged . . . to the always talkative Miss Bates! While hosting an engagement party for the couple, a person is discovered dead. Did they fall out of an upper story window or were they pushed? Emma is on the case to solve this crime.
My thoughts on the novel:
• This is the second novel in the Emma Knightley mystery series. You can read this novel as a standalone, but I think it adds to the story to read both books.
• This was a delightful mystery that was very readable. I read it quickly and didn’t want it down.
• I loved that the characters from Jane Austen’s Emma have their stories continued in this novel.
• The characters are true to Austen’s creations.
• Emma is a good sleuth with her eye for detail and for knowing everyone’s business. She doesn’t leave things alone until she gets an answer.
• I liked that Miss Bates becomes Emma’s mystery solving assistant. This character was fleshed out more in this novel while remaining true to the original.
• Emma and Mr. Knightley (George) make such a cute couple. I enjoyed their interactions.
• There were plenty of red herrings in this mystery to keep one guessing. It had a great climax and conclusion.
• It was a witty and fun book. I enjoyed the reference for “excellent boiled potatoes’ that I felt was an Easter egg for Austen fans (in particular fans of the 2005 Pride and Prejudice adaptation).
• This is a historical cozy mystery set during the Regency period.
• It is a clean read.
• This story is set during the Christmas season.
Overall, Murder at Donwell Abbey by Vanessa Kelly was a very entertaining cozy historical mystery novel and a great continuation of Emma by Jane Austen.
Book Source: Thank-you to @vanessakellyauthor @kensingtonbooks @austenprose for a review copy of this novel as part of the Austenprose PR Book Tour.
This review was first posted on my blog at: https://lauragerold.blogspot.com/2025...
November 26, 2025
I was delighted to return to this wonderful series that sees Emma Knightley turning into an amateur detective to solve mysterious murders. I do love Jane Austen, I do love cozy mysteries, and the author manages to create intriguing and engaging plots that keep me so engrossed that I usually read these novels in one sitting.
In Murder in Donwell Abbey, the second book in the series, Mr. Woodhouse manages to shock his entire family when he announces his engagement to the family’s long-time friend, Miss Bates. And even more shocking, he wants to throw an engagement party at Donwell Abbey. However, the party ends in tragedy when a young maid, well-loved by everyone, is found dead. While the local constable is convinced that it’s a suicide, Emma is sure that the young woman was murdered and finds an unexpected ally in Miss Bates.
Murder in Donwell Abbey is another witty, charming, and entertaining novel and I enjoyed it even more than the first book in the series, Murder in Highbury. We see Emma both struggling with the fact that she will no longer be the mistress of Hartfield and excited that she and Mr. Knightley can now move to Donwell Abbey permanently. And while the peace of Highbury is disrupted by the presence of smugglers and Emma is busy helping Miss Bates organizing the wedding, she is determined to find out the truth about what really happened to her maid.
Murder in Donwell features the right dose of mystery and humor with a pinch of romance (between Emma and Mr. Knightley which I found adorable). The story is well-written and well-developed and the characters are familiar and intriguing. I can’t wait for the next novel!
In Murder in Donwell Abbey, the second book in the series, Mr. Woodhouse manages to shock his entire family when he announces his engagement to the family’s long-time friend, Miss Bates. And even more shocking, he wants to throw an engagement party at Donwell Abbey. However, the party ends in tragedy when a young maid, well-loved by everyone, is found dead. While the local constable is convinced that it’s a suicide, Emma is sure that the young woman was murdered and finds an unexpected ally in Miss Bates.
Murder in Donwell Abbey is another witty, charming, and entertaining novel and I enjoyed it even more than the first book in the series, Murder in Highbury. We see Emma both struggling with the fact that she will no longer be the mistress of Hartfield and excited that she and Mr. Knightley can now move to Donwell Abbey permanently. And while the peace of Highbury is disrupted by the presence of smugglers and Emma is busy helping Miss Bates organizing the wedding, she is determined to find out the truth about what really happened to her maid.
Murder in Donwell features the right dose of mystery and humor with a pinch of romance (between Emma and Mr. Knightley which I found adorable). The story is well-written and well-developed and the characters are familiar and intriguing. I can’t wait for the next novel!
November 5, 2025
Fascinating, Captivating, and Cozy
Murder at Donwell Abbey
Release Date: November 25, 2025
@vanessakellyauthor @kensingtonbooks
This novel captured my imagination completely, compelling me to keep turning the pages eagerly to uncover the unraveling mysteries. Emma‘s dad is absolutely hilarious—his constant fear of drafts and obsession with catching a cold or flu in every situation had me giggling out loud. Emma and her husband form such a charming and heartwarming team; their chemistry is truly delightful. I adore the quaint country setting that perfectly complements this Regency-era mystery, reminiscent of Austen's style. The characters are vibrant and engaging, each adding a unique flair to the story, while the suspense keeps you on the edge of your seat. I particularly enjoyed the witty banter and the beautiful writing style. This book was a true pleasure to read, and I felt like I truly got to know each of the characters on a personal level.
I received a complimentary copy of this book and read it with pleasure. I was under no obligation to leave a positive review.
#murderinhighbury #anemmaknightleymystery #vanessakelly #historicalmystery #cozymystery #regencymystery #austenesquefiction #janeausten #jaff #teamausten250 #kensingtonbooks #janeausten250 #bookstagram
Murder at Donwell Abbey
Release Date: November 25, 2025
@vanessakellyauthor @kensingtonbooks
This novel captured my imagination completely, compelling me to keep turning the pages eagerly to uncover the unraveling mysteries. Emma‘s dad is absolutely hilarious—his constant fear of drafts and obsession with catching a cold or flu in every situation had me giggling out loud. Emma and her husband form such a charming and heartwarming team; their chemistry is truly delightful. I adore the quaint country setting that perfectly complements this Regency-era mystery, reminiscent of Austen's style. The characters are vibrant and engaging, each adding a unique flair to the story, while the suspense keeps you on the edge of your seat. I particularly enjoyed the witty banter and the beautiful writing style. This book was a true pleasure to read, and I felt like I truly got to know each of the characters on a personal level.
I received a complimentary copy of this book and read it with pleasure. I was under no obligation to leave a positive review.
#murderinhighbury #anemmaknightleymystery #vanessakelly #historicalmystery #cozymystery #regencymystery #austenesquefiction #janeausten #jaff #teamausten250 #kensingtonbooks #janeausten250 #bookstagram
December 1, 2025
Reviewed for
Wit and Sin
All is well in Emma Knightley’s world after the events of last summer. She and George are happily living in Harfield, their siblings are visiting, and nothing could go wrong. That is, until Mr. Woodhouse makes a shocking announcement: he plans to marry Miss Bates! The Woodhouse-Knighley crew is somewhat alarmed that the chatty Miss Bates is soon to be a member of the family, but they quickly rally and Emma throws a party to celebrate the betrothal at Donwell Abbey. Then the unthinkable happens: Prudence Parr, lady’s maid at Donwell, is found dead on the terrace. Did she fall from her bedroom or was she pushed?
While George is Highbury’s magistrate, Emma isn’t about to sit around and do nothing. Emma’s Holmes has the unlikeliest of Watsons in her eldest nephew, Henry, and her stepmother-to-be, Miss Bates. I loved watching Emma put the pieces of the puzzle together, especially with Miss Bates who is surprisingly helpful. Vanessa Kelly excels at expanding the world of Highbury while still making it feel like the village of Jane Austen’s Emma. She also is fantastic at making the characters from Austen’s novel feel like themselves while allowing them space to grow as they live their lives beyond the original story. The new characters Kelly creates feel organic to the world and I was just delighted to be in it as Emma, George, and their loved ones uncover clues and hunt for the killer.
Murder at Donwell Abbey is a delightful story and I hope Kelly has many more Emma Knightley stories planned because the world is too good to leave. That being said, while this is a cozy mystery the mystery part is where the story did falter somewhat. Prudence’s death is only the beginning of what is going on at Donwell that George and Emma were unaware of. I really liked seeing the two of them – with the help of family and friends – put the pieces together. The mysteries that unfolded were interesting and the resolution of whodunit was satisfying. However, much of the why and how is explained after the fact in an infodump near the end which didn’t work for me. That being said, I still thoroughly enjoyed the book and I am very much looking forward to Emma’s next outing as amateur sleuth.
All is well in Emma Knightley’s world after the events of last summer. She and George are happily living in Harfield, their siblings are visiting, and nothing could go wrong. That is, until Mr. Woodhouse makes a shocking announcement: he plans to marry Miss Bates! The Woodhouse-Knighley crew is somewhat alarmed that the chatty Miss Bates is soon to be a member of the family, but they quickly rally and Emma throws a party to celebrate the betrothal at Donwell Abbey. Then the unthinkable happens: Prudence Parr, lady’s maid at Donwell, is found dead on the terrace. Did she fall from her bedroom or was she pushed?
While George is Highbury’s magistrate, Emma isn’t about to sit around and do nothing. Emma’s Holmes has the unlikeliest of Watsons in her eldest nephew, Henry, and her stepmother-to-be, Miss Bates. I loved watching Emma put the pieces of the puzzle together, especially with Miss Bates who is surprisingly helpful. Vanessa Kelly excels at expanding the world of Highbury while still making it feel like the village of Jane Austen’s Emma. She also is fantastic at making the characters from Austen’s novel feel like themselves while allowing them space to grow as they live their lives beyond the original story. The new characters Kelly creates feel organic to the world and I was just delighted to be in it as Emma, George, and their loved ones uncover clues and hunt for the killer.
Murder at Donwell Abbey is a delightful story and I hope Kelly has many more Emma Knightley stories planned because the world is too good to leave. That being said, while this is a cozy mystery the mystery part is where the story did falter somewhat. Prudence’s death is only the beginning of what is going on at Donwell that George and Emma were unaware of. I really liked seeing the two of them – with the help of family and friends – put the pieces together. The mysteries that unfolded were interesting and the resolution of whodunit was satisfying. However, much of the why and how is explained after the fact in an infodump near the end which didn’t work for me. That being said, I still thoroughly enjoyed the book and I am very much looking forward to Emma’s next outing as amateur sleuth.
November 14, 2025
An absolutely delightful addition to the series! I have come to love Emma and George as a sleuthing couple, with Emma as the energetic lead and George as the sometimes cautious and worried partner. While he's the magistrate, she's the go-getter who wants to plow ahead with her investigation. I love that it fits with the original characters any Austen fans knows and loves.
Emma and George are finally moving out of Hartfield and into Donwell! While throwing a party at Donwell for a newly-engaged couple (it's in the summary, but I almost don't want to ruin the surprise), Emma's maid is found dead, far beneath the maid's open window in the staff quarters. While investigating the murder, Emma find out that smugglers are bringing contraband through Highbury. Of course there's a connection between the smugglers and the murder, but Emma figures out how with the help of George and Miss Bates. The investigation is fast paced and there's even a suspenseful climatic scene at the end.
This story story Miss Bates into a stronger supporting role. Her character is developed more, but still in a way that honors the original. It was charming to see her working with Emma in this book.
My absolute favorite moments were when Emma and George were together. Though George is in London for parts of this book, the banter between the couple is charming...especially at the start of chapter 26.
Emma and George are finally moving out of Hartfield and into Donwell! While throwing a party at Donwell for a newly-engaged couple (it's in the summary, but I almost don't want to ruin the surprise), Emma's maid is found dead, far beneath the maid's open window in the staff quarters. While investigating the murder, Emma find out that smugglers are bringing contraband through Highbury. Of course there's a connection between the smugglers and the murder, but Emma figures out how with the help of George and Miss Bates. The investigation is fast paced and there's even a suspenseful climatic scene at the end.
This story story Miss Bates into a stronger supporting role. Her character is developed more, but still in a way that honors the original. It was charming to see her working with Emma in this book.
My absolute favorite moments were when Emma and George were together. Though George is in London for parts of this book, the banter between the couple is charming...especially at the start of chapter 26.
December 1, 2025
Thanks to Kensington Pub for the preview. All opinions are my own.
This was another entertaining Emma murder mystery. The tone felt a little more serious this time with an innocent maid as the victim instead of a person we love to hate. There are also smugglers and increased dangers in this installment.
I definitely didn’t figure out the culprit this time, and the accomplice surprised me a lot! Emma was quite brave! The biggest surprise was Miss Bates. While I’m still struggling with her engagement to Mr Woodhouse, she was a great help to Emma, and I enjoyed their growing relationship. I do wish Mr Knightley had to go to London less this book since I enjoy his and Emma’s time on page together.
Definitely check this series out if you’re a Austen mystery fan!
This was another entertaining Emma murder mystery. The tone felt a little more serious this time with an innocent maid as the victim instead of a person we love to hate. There are also smugglers and increased dangers in this installment.
I definitely didn’t figure out the culprit this time, and the accomplice surprised me a lot! Emma was quite brave! The biggest surprise was Miss Bates. While I’m still struggling with her engagement to Mr Woodhouse, she was a great help to Emma, and I enjoyed their growing relationship. I do wish Mr Knightley had to go to London less this book since I enjoy his and Emma’s time on page together.
Definitely check this series out if you’re a Austen mystery fan!
January 24, 2026
A tromp with Emma and George Knightley, with some murder and some mystery and some scones. Delightfully done.
November 21, 2025
Murder at Donwell Abbey is the second in the Emma Knightley mystery series. Cozy mysteries set during the Regency period, with Jane Austen’s Emma Knightley as the amateur sleuther.
This book seemed very true to the time period and to Emma's personality. You can clearly believe Emma would get involved in sleuthing.
One of the beloved staff at Donwell Abbey falls out her bedroom window. At the same time, Emma discovers that there is a smuggling ring operating in Highbury. Are the two connected? When their property manager is accused of being part of the smuggling ring and causing the death of the maid, Emma is determined to get to the bottom of things and prove their property managers' innocence. Even if it puts her in danger.
The mystery was interesting. I do have to say I was onto who the villains were, but the reveal was quite shocking.
I love the characters in this story, from Emma's dad and his fear of drafts to Emma herself and her headstrong ways. The story provided me with a few chuckles that lightened the mood of the serious subject of the story.
Overall, this was such a delightful story. If you are a fan of Claudia Gray's, Mr. Darcy and Miss Tilney series, then this book is for you.
Thank you to Kensington Books for the advanced digital copy of this book. My opinions are my own.
This book seemed very true to the time period and to Emma's personality. You can clearly believe Emma would get involved in sleuthing.
One of the beloved staff at Donwell Abbey falls out her bedroom window. At the same time, Emma discovers that there is a smuggling ring operating in Highbury. Are the two connected? When their property manager is accused of being part of the smuggling ring and causing the death of the maid, Emma is determined to get to the bottom of things and prove their property managers' innocence. Even if it puts her in danger.
The mystery was interesting. I do have to say I was onto who the villains were, but the reveal was quite shocking.
I love the characters in this story, from Emma's dad and his fear of drafts to Emma herself and her headstrong ways. The story provided me with a few chuckles that lightened the mood of the serious subject of the story.
Overall, this was such a delightful story. If you are a fan of Claudia Gray's, Mr. Darcy and Miss Tilney series, then this book is for you.
Thank you to Kensington Books for the advanced digital copy of this book. My opinions are my own.
November 30, 2025
The second book in the series, Murder at Donwell Abbey is another great mystery to solve with Emma Knightley. Now that her matchmaking days are behind her, Emma has taken up sleuthing with a surprising sidekick, Miss Bates. Austen fans and those who have never read the original classic will enjoy in this cozy historical mystery.
I received an advanced ebook copy and voluntarily leave this review. All opinions are my own.
I received an advanced ebook copy and voluntarily leave this review. All opinions are my own.
December 18, 2025
So fun! I continue to find Emma the most satisfying sleuth in the Jane-Austen-cozy-mystery universe. Love that Emma and Miss Bates were fully paired up to investigate this one, though I did miss Harriet. Particularly cute in this one is the depiction of Mr. Woodhouse, who manages to be sweet and hilarious in spite of the fact that an actual person who behaved that way would drive any person absolutely bonkers.
I hope Vanessa Kelly writes a dozen of these.
I hope Vanessa Kelly writes a dozen of these.
January 20, 2026
Emma Knightley is aghast when her father announces his engagement to Miss Hetty Bates! Miss Bates? That garrulous spinster, Mistress of Highbury and Emma's stepmother? Oh no! Mr. Knightley sees the bright side of things - now Emma and Knightley can remove to Donwell Abbey -alone! Or not quite because surely Miss Bates will need a lot of help to manage her new home. When Emma and George agree to host an engagement party for Mr. Woodhouse and Miss Bates at Donwell Abbey, Emma has it all in hand and even makes new friends. Until she doesn't. On the evening of the party, their only maid, Prudence, retires to bed with a headache; a guest behaves badly and Miss Bates hears a noise. When she calls on Emma to help her investigate the sound of the thud, Emma discovers the dead body of her maid on the Abbey grounds. Oh dear! Thanks to the indiscretion of the coroner and Constable Sharpe, word spreads through the party and the guests flee Donwell Abbey. Dr. Hughes declares Pru's death an accident or even suicide! Emma is shocked and even the the two remaining servants swear Pru would never do such a thing. Emma thinks there's more to Pru's death than the men are seeing and she's determined to see justice done. While exploring the Abbey with her nephew Henry and Harriet Martin, they stumble across evidence that a long disused cellar under the Abbey has, in fact, been used recently. This discovery later leads to evidence of smuggling in the area. Could the maid's death be related to the smuggling ring? Mr. Knightley is horrified when someone close to him is arrested for both crimes and Emma goes to war with Constable Sharpe. With the help of her nephew and Miss Bates, she will uncover the clues that lead to the real culprit. Can she figure it out before someone else - like herself- gets killed?
Another fun adventure with Emma Knightley. I figured out most of it from the clues (thank you to Harriet! She's the one who came up with the big ones) but not all of it. I like seeing a more mature Emma and her relationship with Mr. Knightley. However, I wasn't as involved in the mystery of an original character in the way I was with the murder of Mrs. Elton. Sure the maid sounds like she was a lovely girl but I didn't know her or care about her (or hate her) in advance to care enough about who killed her. I was more into the smuggling plot and couldn't put the book down until I finished. I did realize who the smuggler was but I wasn't sure if anyone else was involved.
Married Emma is much more mature and wise than she was only a few short years ago. It's funny to read her internal monologues about the spoiled Cox girls and their bad behavior. It's up to Emma to teach the younger girls how to behave. She has more finesse than Mr. Knightley had with her, however. I'm glad she's still friends with Harriet but doesn't require Harriet to visit every day. Huzzah for Harriet. An expectant mother, Harriet literally sniffs out a clue and comes to Emma with some more clues towards the end of the book. I like how Emma handled her investigation. She was never intrusive and only nosy once. She tried to be subtle and she was even kind to those beneath her station. She's come a long way! Emma and George are very sweet together. They manage to carve out some alone time at night in bed after Mr. Woodhouse has gone to sleep. Their playful banter is cute and he has stopped trying to tell her what to do/not to do. He has his investigation and she has hers. I also love how intelligent Emma is and how unashamed she is of her intelligence. She stands up to Constable Sharpe who has a low opinion of women.
Miss Bates surprised me in this novel. It seems like she can turn her nervous babble on and off and use it to her advantage. I worry her engagement to Mr. Woodhouse won't last. She enjoys being sociable and having parties while he's still reclusive and worries about the effects of eating cake. Of course Mr. Perry agrees with whatever Mr. Woodhouse thinks. Mr. Woodhouse is paying him handsomely LOL! The author managed to capture Austen's Mr. Woodhouse while giving the other characters more development to grow over time. Emma's sister, Isabella, is just like her father. She worries over everything and restricts her children from being children because of her anxiety. It's no wonder little Henry prefers staying with Auntie Emma at Donwell Abbey. She spoils him and he's allowed to roam and be a child. He's also free of his annoying younger siblings. I feel you kid! He's funny and mischievous. John Knightley is grumpy and sometimes teases his wife. He has a larger role to play in this story and shows why he's a very good lawyer! Mrs. Weston doesn't get to provide so much wise council to Emma in spite of Emma's best efforts. Mr. Weston is very indiscreet but he's a good friend and neighbor. He doesn't mean anything by spilling secrets, he just can't help himself.
We don't meet the maid, Prudence, until the night of her murder. She is very pale and claims to have a migraine. That's all we know for sure but Emma suspects a guest has been behaving badly towards Prudence. We only get to know Pru through others who were close to her. By all accounts she was a good girl from a good family. Her body smelled like strong spirits yet she was church going and never touched alcohol. She came from a prominent blacksmithing family in a nearby village and her father and brothers were protective of her. Needless to say, her death has gutted them and they want answers.
Mrs. Hughes, the housekeeper, knew Prudence best after her family. Mrs. Hughes has nothing but good to say about her young maid and is upset that someone snuffed out the beautiful life of a wonderful young woman. Even the buffonish footman, Harry, speaks highly of Prudence. Harry is big, bumbling and not too bright. I get the sense he's lazy too. Mrs. Hughes doesn't like him. She always has to tell him where to go, what to do and make sure he's in the right place at the right time. He's always turning up to help look into things around the Abbey for Emma. I strongly suspect he's gotten mixed up in something way over his head. Or maybe he's not such a fool as he appears.
The Cox children are all pretty awful. Anne is a selfish, jealous mean girl who never says anything nice. She's so catty! Her sister Susan is OK. She tries to be polite at least. Their brother William is trouble. He drinks to excess and behaves badly possibly harassing Emma's now deceased maid. Emma is positive William Cox is the murderer. Another theory is that William Cox was NOT bothering Prudence and she was jealous and quarreled with him and fell out the window, accidentally. I'm not sure William is intelligent enough to deliberately commit murder but maybe Emma's theory of a quarrel is correct. There are hints Pru was in love with someone. Mr. Larkin is brooding and terribly broken up about the death of a maid he claims he didn't really know. Could he have been Pru's love interest? I know Mr. Larkin isn't a murderer. He's served Mr. Knightley faithfully for years and is a good friend. Yet he doesn't have a solid alibi for the time of death.
Newcomers to the village include Squire Plumtree, who is returning after a lifetime spent doing business in London. He's ready to retire and hand the reins of his wool business to his son but Mr. Guy Plumtree has other ideas. He's the typical spoiled son who wants to live the life of a gentleman. He's jovial and friendly to all, especially the new curate, Mr. Barlow. Mr. Barlow is the complete opposite of Mr. Plumtree. Mr. Barlow is quiet, nervous and very shy. How on earth is he a clergyman? Mr. Clarke, the revenue officer for neighboring Leatherhead, seems decent and fair minded. He follows the evidence he's given and Mr. Knightley respects and likes the man.
The villain is very devious and nefarious. I suspected that character early on but I didn't realize what a dangerous criminal that character was.
Another fun adventure with Emma Knightley. I figured out most of it from the clues (thank you to Harriet! She's the one who came up with the big ones) but not all of it. I like seeing a more mature Emma and her relationship with Mr. Knightley. However, I wasn't as involved in the mystery of an original character in the way I was with the murder of Mrs. Elton. Sure the maid sounds like she was a lovely girl but I didn't know her or care about her (or hate her) in advance to care enough about who killed her. I was more into the smuggling plot and couldn't put the book down until I finished. I did realize who the smuggler was but I wasn't sure if anyone else was involved.
Married Emma is much more mature and wise than she was only a few short years ago. It's funny to read her internal monologues about the spoiled Cox girls and their bad behavior. It's up to Emma to teach the younger girls how to behave. She has more finesse than Mr. Knightley had with her, however. I'm glad she's still friends with Harriet but doesn't require Harriet to visit every day. Huzzah for Harriet. An expectant mother, Harriet literally sniffs out a clue and comes to Emma with some more clues towards the end of the book. I like how Emma handled her investigation. She was never intrusive and only nosy once. She tried to be subtle and she was even kind to those beneath her station. She's come a long way! Emma and George are very sweet together. They manage to carve out some alone time at night in bed after Mr. Woodhouse has gone to sleep. Their playful banter is cute and he has stopped trying to tell her what to do/not to do. He has his investigation and she has hers. I also love how intelligent Emma is and how unashamed she is of her intelligence. She stands up to Constable Sharpe who has a low opinion of women.
Miss Bates surprised me in this novel. It seems like she can turn her nervous babble on and off and use it to her advantage. I worry her engagement to Mr. Woodhouse won't last. She enjoys being sociable and having parties while he's still reclusive and worries about the effects of eating cake. Of course Mr. Perry agrees with whatever Mr. Woodhouse thinks. Mr. Woodhouse is paying him handsomely LOL! The author managed to capture Austen's Mr. Woodhouse while giving the other characters more development to grow over time. Emma's sister, Isabella, is just like her father. She worries over everything and restricts her children from being children because of her anxiety. It's no wonder little Henry prefers staying with Auntie Emma at Donwell Abbey. She spoils him and he's allowed to roam and be a child. He's also free of his annoying younger siblings. I feel you kid! He's funny and mischievous. John Knightley is grumpy and sometimes teases his wife. He has a larger role to play in this story and shows why he's a very good lawyer! Mrs. Weston doesn't get to provide so much wise council to Emma in spite of Emma's best efforts. Mr. Weston is very indiscreet but he's a good friend and neighbor. He doesn't mean anything by spilling secrets, he just can't help himself.
We don't meet the maid, Prudence, until the night of her murder. She is very pale and claims to have a migraine. That's all we know for sure but Emma suspects a guest has been behaving badly towards Prudence. We only get to know Pru through others who were close to her. By all accounts she was a good girl from a good family. Her body smelled like strong spirits yet she was church going and never touched alcohol. She came from a prominent blacksmithing family in a nearby village and her father and brothers were protective of her. Needless to say, her death has gutted them and they want answers.
Mrs. Hughes, the housekeeper, knew Prudence best after her family. Mrs. Hughes has nothing but good to say about her young maid and is upset that someone snuffed out the beautiful life of a wonderful young woman. Even the buffonish footman, Harry, speaks highly of Prudence. Harry is big, bumbling and not too bright. I get the sense he's lazy too. Mrs. Hughes doesn't like him. She always has to tell him where to go, what to do and make sure he's in the right place at the right time. He's always turning up to help look into things around the Abbey for Emma. I strongly suspect he's gotten mixed up in something way over his head. Or maybe he's not such a fool as he appears.
The Cox children are all pretty awful. Anne is a selfish, jealous mean girl who never says anything nice. She's so catty! Her sister Susan is OK. She tries to be polite at least. Their brother William is trouble. He drinks to excess and behaves badly possibly harassing Emma's now deceased maid. Emma is positive William Cox is the murderer. Another theory is that William Cox was NOT bothering Prudence and she was jealous and quarreled with him and fell out the window, accidentally. I'm not sure William is intelligent enough to deliberately commit murder but maybe Emma's theory of a quarrel is correct. There are hints Pru was in love with someone. Mr. Larkin is brooding and terribly broken up about the death of a maid he claims he didn't really know. Could he have been Pru's love interest? I know Mr. Larkin isn't a murderer. He's served Mr. Knightley faithfully for years and is a good friend. Yet he doesn't have a solid alibi for the time of death.
Newcomers to the village include Squire Plumtree, who is returning after a lifetime spent doing business in London. He's ready to retire and hand the reins of his wool business to his son but Mr. Guy Plumtree has other ideas. He's the typical spoiled son who wants to live the life of a gentleman. He's jovial and friendly to all, especially the new curate, Mr. Barlow. Mr. Barlow is the complete opposite of Mr. Plumtree. Mr. Barlow is quiet, nervous and very shy. How on earth is he a clergyman? Mr. Clarke, the revenue officer for neighboring Leatherhead, seems decent and fair minded. He follows the evidence he's given and Mr. Knightley respects and likes the man.
The villain is very devious and nefarious. I suspected that character early on but I didn't realize what a dangerous criminal that character was.
October 27, 2025
I loved Auntie Emma and nephew Henry! Glad I got advanced reader's copy from Austenprose.
August 9, 2025
I enjoyed this cozy historical mystery more than the first in the series, in part because it didn't feel like it was trying so hard to connect to Austen's original. (Although a surprise engagement between original characters does set the stage for the plot of the book.) Like an Austen novel, it moves at a somewhat leisurely pace but still held my interest and even had me laughing out loud a couple of times.
Review based on a DRC received through NetGalley.
Review based on a DRC received through NetGalley.
December 6, 2025
*I received an e-arc for review via Netgalley. Thank you to Kensington Books and Austenprose for the opportunity. All thoughts are my own*
4.5 rounded up to 5
Murder at Donwell Abbey is book number two in the Emma Knightley Mystery Series. I was so excited for this book, and it did not disappoint! The story compelled me to read from beginning to end, and I had fun figuring out whodunnit. Perfect for Austen fans and fans of cozy mysteries!
Emma and George Knightley host a fun holiday celebration at the Hartfield Estate. January begins with Mr. Woodhouse making an unexpected announcement-he and Miss Hetty Bates have decided to marry! Emma comes to grips with the fact that she’ll have to give up her role as mistress of the estate and that Miss Bates will become her stepmother.
During a betrothal ball for Mr. Woodhouse and Miss Bates at Donwell Abbey (where Emma soon will reside with George), something dreadful happens! Her lady’s maid Prudence Parr is found dead, sprawled across the stones of the library terrace!
The woman’s tragic fall is quickly ruled an accident, but rumors begin to circulate about her personal troubles leading up to her demise. Emma’s instincts tell her that something far more dire has occurred. Emma decides to investigate and outwit a cunning criminal to save an innocent man.
I absolutely loved the witty banter in this one! Emma is one of my favorite Austen characters, and it’s so fun reading a “continuation” of her life and seeing her as a sleuth. It was also so fun to see her teaming up with her future stepmother, Miss Bates! Her nephew Henry was also an absolute delight! I of course loved seeing more of Emma and George working together as well.
I highly recommend this one! I really hope that author Vanessa Kelly writes more in this world, as I’m definitely on board for more Emma on the case.
4.5 rounded up to 5
Murder at Donwell Abbey is book number two in the Emma Knightley Mystery Series. I was so excited for this book, and it did not disappoint! The story compelled me to read from beginning to end, and I had fun figuring out whodunnit. Perfect for Austen fans and fans of cozy mysteries!
Emma and George Knightley host a fun holiday celebration at the Hartfield Estate. January begins with Mr. Woodhouse making an unexpected announcement-he and Miss Hetty Bates have decided to marry! Emma comes to grips with the fact that she’ll have to give up her role as mistress of the estate and that Miss Bates will become her stepmother.
During a betrothal ball for Mr. Woodhouse and Miss Bates at Donwell Abbey (where Emma soon will reside with George), something dreadful happens! Her lady’s maid Prudence Parr is found dead, sprawled across the stones of the library terrace!
The woman’s tragic fall is quickly ruled an accident, but rumors begin to circulate about her personal troubles leading up to her demise. Emma’s instincts tell her that something far more dire has occurred. Emma decides to investigate and outwit a cunning criminal to save an innocent man.
I absolutely loved the witty banter in this one! Emma is one of my favorite Austen characters, and it’s so fun reading a “continuation” of her life and seeing her as a sleuth. It was also so fun to see her teaming up with her future stepmother, Miss Bates! Her nephew Henry was also an absolute delight! I of course loved seeing more of Emma and George working together as well.
I highly recommend this one! I really hope that author Vanessa Kelly writes more in this world, as I’m definitely on board for more Emma on the case.
December 24, 2025
3.5 stars
Murder at Donwell Abbey presents Emma Knightley née Woodhouse as an accidental sleuth. It is populated by many beloved characters from the original Emma by Jane Austen, and the author does a good job capturing their speech habits and mannerisms. A maid dies at Donwell Abbey during a party; did she kill herself, or was she murdered? Why was she upset the last time Emma saw her?
I enjoyed the book. The relationship between Emma and George is a bit saccharine; they are clearly still in the honeymoon stage of their relationship. Miss Bates and Mr. Woodhouse are engaged, and theirs is an interesting relationship. Emma’s sister Isabella is well on her way to inheriting Mr. Woodhouse’s fretful ways, but her son Henry is a nice addition to the story. This is definitely a cozy mystery offering the reader a chance to spend more time with the people of Highbury. Emma has turned from matchmaking to investigating. I didn’t notice any glaring issues with the depiction of the Regency time period (aside from a reference to going down a rabbit hole, which comes from the 1865 adventures of Alice). It did make me think about how crazy it was to live in one home with your wife and her elderly parent while fulling staffing your own home with servants even though no one lives there.
Many readers seem to prefer this book over Murder in Highbury, but I liked the first book better. Like the first book in the series, this one was about 100 pages too long. It was draggy and repetitive at times. Still, I will probably read a third book if there is one.
I read an advance reader copy of Murder at Donwell Abbey from Netgalley.
Murder at Donwell Abbey presents Emma Knightley née Woodhouse as an accidental sleuth. It is populated by many beloved characters from the original Emma by Jane Austen, and the author does a good job capturing their speech habits and mannerisms. A maid dies at Donwell Abbey during a party; did she kill herself, or was she murdered? Why was she upset the last time Emma saw her?
I enjoyed the book. The relationship between Emma and George is a bit saccharine; they are clearly still in the honeymoon stage of their relationship. Miss Bates and Mr. Woodhouse are engaged, and theirs is an interesting relationship. Emma’s sister Isabella is well on her way to inheriting Mr. Woodhouse’s fretful ways, but her son Henry is a nice addition to the story. This is definitely a cozy mystery offering the reader a chance to spend more time with the people of Highbury. Emma has turned from matchmaking to investigating. I didn’t notice any glaring issues with the depiction of the Regency time period (aside from a reference to going down a rabbit hole, which comes from the 1865 adventures of Alice). It did make me think about how crazy it was to live in one home with your wife and her elderly parent while fulling staffing your own home with servants even though no one lives there.
Many readers seem to prefer this book over Murder in Highbury, but I liked the first book better. Like the first book in the series, this one was about 100 pages too long. It was draggy and repetitive at times. Still, I will probably read a third book if there is one.
I read an advance reader copy of Murder at Donwell Abbey from Netgalley.
December 27, 2025
Thank you to @vanessakellyauthor, @kensingtonbooks, and @austenprose for the #gifted book!
I was absolutely delighted to dive into the second installment of the Emma Knightley series, where Jane Austen’s Emma Knightley returns as a sharp-witted sleuth!
This time around, Emma finds herself entangled in a shocking murder mystery at Donwell Abbey. With her remarkable determination and clever intellect, she plunges headfirst into the investigation, determined to unveil the truth behind this unsettling crime.
What I love most about Emma is her incredible knack for piecing together the most intricate puzzles. The writing is just brilliant, featuring razor-sharp dialogue that truly brings the characters to life. The vivid descriptions of the Abbey and the surrounding town painted such a charming picture!
Emma’s father is the quintessential crotchety old man, and it's wonderfully entertaining to see how she navigates their dynamic, especially with his future bride, Miss Bates. And let's not forget the heartwarming bond she shares with her nephew, Henry—such a lovely touch!
I adore Emma and her family, and I can’t help but hope this series keeps going so we can solve more thrilling mysteries together!
I was absolutely delighted to dive into the second installment of the Emma Knightley series, where Jane Austen’s Emma Knightley returns as a sharp-witted sleuth!
This time around, Emma finds herself entangled in a shocking murder mystery at Donwell Abbey. With her remarkable determination and clever intellect, she plunges headfirst into the investigation, determined to unveil the truth behind this unsettling crime.
What I love most about Emma is her incredible knack for piecing together the most intricate puzzles. The writing is just brilliant, featuring razor-sharp dialogue that truly brings the characters to life. The vivid descriptions of the Abbey and the surrounding town painted such a charming picture!
Emma’s father is the quintessential crotchety old man, and it's wonderfully entertaining to see how she navigates their dynamic, especially with his future bride, Miss Bates. And let's not forget the heartwarming bond she shares with her nephew, Henry—such a lovely touch!
I adore Emma and her family, and I can’t help but hope this series keeps going so we can solve more thrilling mysteries together!
November 25, 2025
Emma and George Knightley do it again! I adored this reimagined power couple in Murder in Highbury, but in Murder at Donwell Abbey, they shine even brighter. Emma steps deeper into her role as a Regency-era sleuth—sharp, observant, and unafraid to follow her instincts—even when those instincts place her directly in harm’s way.
The story begins with a shock: Emma’s father is marrying Miss Hetty Bates. Emma tries to welcome the excitable spinster into the family with grace, though relinquishing her role as mistress of Hartfield stirs more emotions than she expects. As engagement festivities swirl, she and George prepare to settle permanently at Donwell Abbey. But celebrations quickly turn dark when Prudence Parr, one of the Abbey’s hardworking maids, is found dead during the betrothal ball.
What first appears to be a tragic accident soon unravels into something far more sinister. Emma’s instincts tell her the pieces simply don’t fit—and once she starts pulling at threads, secrets spill from every corner of Highbury.
What makes this series shine is the relationship between Emma and George. Their banter, affection, and profound trust in one another make them irresistible to follow. George never stifles Emma’s curiosity; instead, he admires her courage while offering his own magistrate-level steadiness. Their partnership is warm, balanced, and deeply endearing—a true Regency marriage of hearts and minds.
The mystery itself is layered with clever clues, suspicious characters, and just enough misdirection to keep you on your toes. And then, as Vanessa Kelly loves to do, everything culminates in a high-stakes, breath-stealing finale. For a few pages, I genuinely feared certain characters wouldn’t make it out alive—but the resolution is both satisfying and emotionally earned.
Emma and George once again welcome readers into their world with grace, humor, and a touch of danger. I loved every moment with them and can’t wait for their next investigation.
The story begins with a shock: Emma’s father is marrying Miss Hetty Bates. Emma tries to welcome the excitable spinster into the family with grace, though relinquishing her role as mistress of Hartfield stirs more emotions than she expects. As engagement festivities swirl, she and George prepare to settle permanently at Donwell Abbey. But celebrations quickly turn dark when Prudence Parr, one of the Abbey’s hardworking maids, is found dead during the betrothal ball.
What first appears to be a tragic accident soon unravels into something far more sinister. Emma’s instincts tell her the pieces simply don’t fit—and once she starts pulling at threads, secrets spill from every corner of Highbury.
What makes this series shine is the relationship between Emma and George. Their banter, affection, and profound trust in one another make them irresistible to follow. George never stifles Emma’s curiosity; instead, he admires her courage while offering his own magistrate-level steadiness. Their partnership is warm, balanced, and deeply endearing—a true Regency marriage of hearts and minds.
The mystery itself is layered with clever clues, suspicious characters, and just enough misdirection to keep you on your toes. And then, as Vanessa Kelly loves to do, everything culminates in a high-stakes, breath-stealing finale. For a few pages, I genuinely feared certain characters wouldn’t make it out alive—but the resolution is both satisfying and emotionally earned.
Emma and George once again welcome readers into their world with grace, humor, and a touch of danger. I loved every moment with them and can’t wait for their next investigation.
November 30, 2025
This is my second time reading Vanessa Kelly’s mystery adaptation of Emma and she did not disappoint. Murder at Donwell Abbey is the second book in the Emma Knightley historical mystery series. I loved how the author included the perfect amount of humor paired with a deliciously twisty mystery.
After celebrating the holidays, Emma’s father announces his engagement to Miss Bates (this is a shocking revelation for all Jane Austen fans). The realization that the same Miss Bates will soon be Emma’s stepmother and that she will have to relinquish her role as mistress of Hartfield is a bit much for Emma to grasp but George has planned for them to finally move into their residence at Donwell Abbey. Whilst an engagement ball is well underway at Donwell Abbey, Emma’s lady’s maid (Prudence) is found dead. As the tragic accident is ruled an accident, Emma is convinced of something more sinister. Emma uses her sleuthing skills to catch Prudence’s killer.
This mystery series is so well written. I enjoyed every bit of the wit and charm of each of the characters. There have been many adaptations of Jane Austen books but so few are as entertaining as Vanessa Kelly’s series. If you enjoy mysteries and Jane Austen novels, you will enjoy book two in this series!
Many thanks to Vanessa Kelly, Kensington Books, and NetGalley for the ARC. This book was a delight to read. This review is voluntary. All thoughts are my own.
After celebrating the holidays, Emma’s father announces his engagement to Miss Bates (this is a shocking revelation for all Jane Austen fans). The realization that the same Miss Bates will soon be Emma’s stepmother and that she will have to relinquish her role as mistress of Hartfield is a bit much for Emma to grasp but George has planned for them to finally move into their residence at Donwell Abbey. Whilst an engagement ball is well underway at Donwell Abbey, Emma’s lady’s maid (Prudence) is found dead. As the tragic accident is ruled an accident, Emma is convinced of something more sinister. Emma uses her sleuthing skills to catch Prudence’s killer.
This mystery series is so well written. I enjoyed every bit of the wit and charm of each of the characters. There have been many adaptations of Jane Austen books but so few are as entertaining as Vanessa Kelly’s series. If you enjoy mysteries and Jane Austen novels, you will enjoy book two in this series!
Many thanks to Vanessa Kelly, Kensington Books, and NetGalley for the ARC. This book was a delight to read. This review is voluntary. All thoughts are my own.
January 16, 2026
Murder at Donwell Abbey is book two in the Emma Knightley Mysteries by Vanessa Kelly. Emma Knightley and her husband George are celebrating Christmas at the Hartfield estate when her personal maid, Prudence Parr, falls out of her bedroom window. Emma Knightley not only had to contend with the unexpected news from her father, but she also had to find the killer of Prudence Parr before an innocent man took the blame. Readers of Murder at Donwell Abbey will continue to follow Emma Knightley to discover what happens next.
Murder at Donwell Abbey is the first book I have read by Vanessa Kelly, and it was ok. I think I have read too many of these cozies, so the plots seem to run into each other. In parts, I found it slow. I will not read another book in this series. I understood the problems smuggling caused for communities in England and why it was big business for poor communities.
I enjoyed Vanessa Kelly's portrayal of her characters and their interactions throughout this book. Murder at Donwell Abbey is well-written and well-researched by Vanessa Kelly. I like Vanessa Kelly's descriptions of the settings in Murder at Donwell Abbey, which complement the book's plot.
I recommend this book.
Murder at Donwell Abbey is the first book I have read by Vanessa Kelly, and it was ok. I think I have read too many of these cozies, so the plots seem to run into each other. In parts, I found it slow. I will not read another book in this series. I understood the problems smuggling caused for communities in England and why it was big business for poor communities.
I enjoyed Vanessa Kelly's portrayal of her characters and their interactions throughout this book. Murder at Donwell Abbey is well-written and well-researched by Vanessa Kelly. I like Vanessa Kelly's descriptions of the settings in Murder at Donwell Abbey, which complement the book's plot.
I recommend this book.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 145 reviews