While I appreciate many ideas and principles presented in these pages, the lack of a strong, biblical foundation was disappointing.
Pros:
-Their discussion on being made in the image of God.
-They acknowledge the realities of sin and our fallen world. (This isn’t until the second half of the book, so the layout is confusing.)
-They share some examples and ideas that may be helpful if you already have a strong foundation of biblical parenting.
-They mention the value of ALL life, including unborn children in the womb.
-They place a high value on connection with children.
-They have a heart for children and families to thrive.
-The authors rightly encourage looking beyond misbehavior and seeking the heart. They rightly desire to go beyond merely managing behavior.
Cons:
-While they discuss Jesus and His example, they do not present the full gospel.
-The tagline for the book is “A Jesus-centered guide to parenting with peace and purpose.” However, rather than being built on a solid foundation of who Christ is, they discuss Jesus then move on to navigating behavior and problem-solving apart from the truths of scripture.
-The tone of the book is very arrogant at times.
-The authors rightly acknowledge that children are made in God’s image and are worthy of dignity, honor, and, respect. However, they over-share examples of their own children in a way that does not honor nor respect them. They share their childrens’ weaknesses, mistakes, and sins. (There is even an incredibly unkind commentary on how their child smelled.) Children are not content and they cannot give informed consent to have their stories shared. While it can be helpful to give examples of principles in a parenting book, this must be done in a way that honors each child.
While much of their teaching sounds good on the surface- they discuss Jesus and quote Scripture- it falls short of the rich truths of the Bible.
For example, they discuss modeling Jesus and His love and connection. However, there is no discussion of the gospel: the good news that Jesus Christ, fully God and fully man, came to die on the cross for our sin. That through his perfect life, death, burial, resurrection, and ascension, we can come to Him: we can be redeemed and made new in Christ. God made us in His image. We all sin and fall short of the glory of God. Through the blood of Christ we can receive forgiveness and be redeemed. This eternal life is only found in Christ.
These redemptive truths should deeply affect our Christian parenting. Mistakes, sins, and conflict are all opportunities to look to the cross and the redemptive work of Jesus Christ. While ideas and tools to navigate misbehavior and conflict are incredibly helpful, we must first have a solid foundation of God and His Word.
Also, while discussing abiding in Christ, the authors state this is “resting in who he made us to be.” However, abiding in Christ means to rest in Christ Himself. While we prayerfully abide in Christ and seek to grow into who God made us to be, this is in His strength and not our own. This may seem like a small difference, but it reveals a larger concern: the book seems more concerned with behavior management than Christ Himself.
If a parent or educator already has a strong biblical foundation for their parenting, they may benefit from some of the ideas presented in this book. There are some good thoughts, ideas, and principles. They do an excellent job discussing the high value of children and how we are made in God’s image. They rightly prioritize the value of connecting with our children.
However, due to the lack of a strong, biblical foundation, I would not recommend this for all families.