What do you think?
Rate this book
Ardemore House mysteries #2
The Dead Come to Stay
An amateur autistic sleuth. A wry English detective. A murder case that thrusts them both into the wealthy world of the rare artifacts trade…
Jo Jones can't seem to catch a break. Trading in city life for the cozy, peaceful hills of the English countryside to take over her family estate should have been a chance for a “fresh start.” Instead, she's been driven further into the past than she thought possible—and not just her own. The estate is littered with traces of ancestors that Jo never knew existed, including a mysterious woman depicted in a half-destroyed painting. Then there’s the gossipy town politics Jo must constantly navigate as a neurodivergent transplanted American… And of course, the whole murder business.
When prickly town detective James MacAdams discovers a body in the moors with coincidental ties to Jo Jones, they're forced to team up on the case. The clues will lead them into the wealthiest locales of Yorkshire, from sparkling glass hotels to luxury property sites to elite country clubs.
But below the glittering surfaces, Jo and MacAdams discover darker schemes brewing. Local teens, many of them international refugees, are disappearing left and right. What begins as a bizarre murder case quickly plunges them both into the world of rare artifacts and antique trading…and a murderer who will do anything to cover it up.
Jo Jones can't seem to catch a break. Trading in city life for the cozy, peaceful hills of the English countryside to take over her family estate should have been a chance for a “fresh start.” Instead, she's been driven further into the past than she thought possible—and not just her own. The estate is littered with traces of ancestors that Jo never knew existed, including a mysterious woman depicted in a half-destroyed painting. Then there’s the gossipy town politics Jo must constantly navigate as a neurodivergent transplanted American… And of course, the whole murder business.
When prickly town detective James MacAdams discovers a body in the moors with coincidental ties to Jo Jones, they're forced to team up on the case. The clues will lead them into the wealthiest locales of Yorkshire, from sparkling glass hotels to luxury property sites to elite country clubs.
But below the glittering surfaces, Jo and MacAdams discover darker schemes brewing. Local teens, many of them international refugees, are disappearing left and right. What begins as a bizarre murder case quickly plunges them both into the world of rare artifacts and antique trading…and a murderer who will do anything to cover it up.
Audible Audio
Published August 5, 2025
38 people are currently reading
651 people want to read
About the author
Brandy Schillace
15 books281 followersDr. BRANDY SCHILLACE (skil-AH-chay) is an autistic, nonbinary author, historian, mystery writer and Editor (who grew up in an underground house next to a cemetery with a pet raccoon). Her mystery novel, THE FRAMED WOMEN OF ARDEMORE HOUSE, features an autistic protagonist: Jo Jones. Plus: An abandoned English manor, a peculiar missing portrait, and one dead gardener. “A must read for any mystery lover.” – says DEANNA RAYBOURN, New York Times bestselling author of KILLERS OF A CERTAIN AGE. (This will be book one in the NETHERLEIGH mystery series.)
***QUICK NOTE! I love talking with readers - for Book Clubs and 1:1s, find me now on Skolay: skolay.com/writers/brandy-schillace***
Brandy’s recent nonfiction, MR. HUMBLE AND DR. BUTCHER–described by the New York Times as a “macabre delight”–explores Cold War medicine, bioethics, and transplant science. Brandy’s next nonfiction book, THE INTERMEDIARIES, will tell the forgotten, daring history of the interwar Institute of Sexology in Berlin: trans activists, the first gender affirming surgeries, and the fight for LGBTQ rights in the shadow of the Nazi Third Reich. Rebels against empires, it’s a heart-stopping story of courage in the face of long odds.
And because she writes in two worlds, both of them weird, Brandy hosts a regular YouTube show called Peculiar Book Club. It features livestream chats with bestselling authors of unusual nonfiction, from Lindsey Fitzharris and Mary Roach to Carl Zimmer and Deborah Blum. She has appeared on Travel Channel’s Mysteries at the Museum, NPR’s Here and Now, and with Dan Aykroyd on THE UNBELIEVABLE (History Channel). Bylines at WIRED, Scientific American, Globe and Mail, WSJ Books, and Medium. She works as Editor in Chief for BMJ’s Medical Humanities, a journal for social justice and health equity.
Dr. Schillace is represented by Jessica Papin at Dystel and Goderich Literary Management.
http://brandyschillace.com/
@bschillace
***QUICK NOTE! I love talking with readers - for Book Clubs and 1:1s, find me now on Skolay: skolay.com/writers/brandy-schillace***
Brandy’s recent nonfiction, MR. HUMBLE AND DR. BUTCHER–described by the New York Times as a “macabre delight”–explores Cold War medicine, bioethics, and transplant science. Brandy’s next nonfiction book, THE INTERMEDIARIES, will tell the forgotten, daring history of the interwar Institute of Sexology in Berlin: trans activists, the first gender affirming surgeries, and the fight for LGBTQ rights in the shadow of the Nazi Third Reich. Rebels against empires, it’s a heart-stopping story of courage in the face of long odds.
And because she writes in two worlds, both of them weird, Brandy hosts a regular YouTube show called Peculiar Book Club. It features livestream chats with bestselling authors of unusual nonfiction, from Lindsey Fitzharris and Mary Roach to Carl Zimmer and Deborah Blum. She has appeared on Travel Channel’s Mysteries at the Museum, NPR’s Here and Now, and with Dan Aykroyd on THE UNBELIEVABLE (History Channel). Bylines at WIRED, Scientific American, Globe and Mail, WSJ Books, and Medium. She works as Editor in Chief for BMJ’s Medical Humanities, a journal for social justice and health equity.
Dr. Schillace is represented by Jessica Papin at Dystel and Goderich Literary Management.
http://brandyschillace.com/
@bschillace
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 87 reviews
August 10, 2025
A generous 3 stars.. but I do want to start off by saying I made the mistake of going into this without reading the first book in the series, and I think that’s pretty much essential to fully enjoy this one.
A LOT of this story seems to build directly on events and relationships from book one, so I struggled to connect with certain characters and backstories. I am assuming much of the development happened in that book.
I do think overall the mystery was thoroughly fleshed out and unique, and kept me guessing. And I did really love the additional found family dynamic and romance (because it’s me and I always love a little romance).
Two bit things that deterred me from rating this higher:
1) The conclusion I think leaned a little too heavily on the detectives’ narration and assumptions, rather than letting the mystery unravel more organically. I think if Jo’s storyline was a little less in focus, this could have been avoided.
2) I also think there were too many characters - although part of this problem I think is the continuous variation in how characters were addressed (first name, first and last, and last name was common for many of the characters).
Overall, while this wasn't necessarily a stand-out cozy mystery for me, it does have a classic English countryside charm and I can see how reading the first book could make you appreciate this one more! So basically - read the first book!!!
Thank you to Harlequin Trade Publishing & Hanover Square Press for an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
A LOT of this story seems to build directly on events and relationships from book one, so I struggled to connect with certain characters and backstories. I am assuming much of the development happened in that book.
I do think overall the mystery was thoroughly fleshed out and unique, and kept me guessing. And I did really love the additional found family dynamic and romance (because it’s me and I always love a little romance).
Two bit things that deterred me from rating this higher:
1) The conclusion I think leaned a little too heavily on the detectives’ narration and assumptions, rather than letting the mystery unravel more organically. I think if Jo’s storyline was a little less in focus, this could have been avoided.
2) I also think there were too many characters - although part of this problem I think is the continuous variation in how characters were addressed (first name, first and last, and last name was common for many of the characters).
Overall, while this wasn't necessarily a stand-out cozy mystery for me, it does have a classic English countryside charm and I can see how reading the first book could make you appreciate this one more! So basically - read the first book!!!
Thank you to Harlequin Trade Publishing & Hanover Square Press for an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
August 8, 2025
After the events of the last book, Jo Jones is settling into Yorkshire in the cottage on Ardemore. The Jekyll Gardens on the estate are about to open and Jo is still investigating the mystery of her ancestors, but that doesn’t pay the bills, so she’s refurbished the attic space to rent out. However, the first booking doesn’t go as planned and a body turns up right before the Jekyll Garden opening.
Detective James MacAdams is called in to investigate this puzzling murder and isn’t surprised when he finds a connection between Jo and the victim.
Jo’s memory for detail comes in handy with the murder investigation, but she’s more involved with the mystery of her ancestors and the history between Jo’s mother and uncle. She gets more background from an unexpected source revealing information her mother never shared.
The Dead Come to Stay was another fun cozy murder mystery and I enjoyed seeing the relationships solidify and deepen. It was nice for Jo to get some answers and closure, as well.
I alternately read and listened to the audio version. I enjoyed Imogen Church’s performance of the female characters, but some of the male voices sounded stuffy and silly. Maybe it was to convey a bit of humor? Even so, I enjoyed the audio version overall.
I voluntarily read/listened to an advanced readers copy courtesy of the publisher. These are my thoughts and opinions.
Detective James MacAdams is called in to investigate this puzzling murder and isn’t surprised when he finds a connection between Jo and the victim.
Jo’s memory for detail comes in handy with the murder investigation, but she’s more involved with the mystery of her ancestors and the history between Jo’s mother and uncle. She gets more background from an unexpected source revealing information her mother never shared.
The Dead Come to Stay was another fun cozy murder mystery and I enjoyed seeing the relationships solidify and deepen. It was nice for Jo to get some answers and closure, as well.
I alternately read and listened to the audio version. I enjoyed Imogen Church’s performance of the female characters, but some of the male voices sounded stuffy and silly. Maybe it was to convey a bit of humor? Even so, I enjoyed the audio version overall.
I voluntarily read/listened to an advanced readers copy courtesy of the publisher. These are my thoughts and opinions.
June 1, 2025
I received a free copy from the publisher through Edelweiss and voluntarily reviewed it.
I really enjoyed the first book in this series and was excited to hear there would be a sequel. I buddy read with one with Sophia Rose. I read this one during a stressful time in my life and that did made it hard at times to fully enjoy the story, but despite that I still had a great time reading it.
The Dead Come to Stay has another mystery and Jo continues her search for answers about Ardemore House and her family. When a man gets murdered after staying in Jo's AirBnB room, MacAdams is on the case. The book is written from dual point of views again with chapters from Jo and MacAdams. I thought this worked well as Jo is the amateur sleuth perspective and then she also has her own quest for answers. While MacAdams is a detective and investigates the mystery that way.
The mystery was a twisty one with a lot of it not falling on it's place until late in the book when a vital clue changes everything, but despite that the mystery still has a sense of progression with new clues coming to light throughout the book. I had to smile at the coincidence of the other cozy mystery I was reading having a similar-ish type twist. I liked following along the mystery and seeing new clues come to light and then at the end have it all get resolved. It was a satisfying mystery. While Jo's storyline about answers could be quite sad at times, it was also illuminating as she finds some of the answers she was looking for.
I did at times struggle with the dual point of view as it could be hard to keep up with both plot lines and the switches could be on these type of cliffhanger moments and then when we got back to that point of view I needed a moment to reorient myself. Then again I probably would've had an easier time with that if I hadn't read it during such a stressful time. I also would've liked to see Jo have a bigger role in the mystery and more interactions with MacAdams, their plot lines are pretty separate for the most part and then intersect at certain points. It worked well, but I just wanted a bit more overlap.
I really like Jo as a main character I could relatable to her thought her being autistic was well written. I am autistic myself and I enjoyed reading about Jo. MacAdams is an interesting character as well and I liked seeing him slowly becoming a bit more open and closer to Jo. It's subtle, but I liked those few pivotal scenes were he was there for Jo. I hope there will be more books in this series as I want to read more about these characters and see their romance develop.
To summarize: This was a great sequel. It has a new mystery as well as Jo's search for answers continues. The mystery kept me guessing and had some nice twists while Jo's search for answers could be at times sad, but also brings her some of the answers she needs. I liked both Jo and MacAdams their points of view and both are likable main characters. At times I did wish their storylines would intermingle a bit more and I struggled sometimes with the point of view switches and having to reorient myself, but part of that is due to reading this during a stressful time. All in all this was a great read and I hope there will be more books in the series.
I really enjoyed the first book in this series and was excited to hear there would be a sequel. I buddy read with one with Sophia Rose. I read this one during a stressful time in my life and that did made it hard at times to fully enjoy the story, but despite that I still had a great time reading it.
The Dead Come to Stay has another mystery and Jo continues her search for answers about Ardemore House and her family. When a man gets murdered after staying in Jo's AirBnB room, MacAdams is on the case. The book is written from dual point of views again with chapters from Jo and MacAdams. I thought this worked well as Jo is the amateur sleuth perspective and then she also has her own quest for answers. While MacAdams is a detective and investigates the mystery that way.
The mystery was a twisty one with a lot of it not falling on it's place until late in the book when a vital clue changes everything, but despite that the mystery still has a sense of progression with new clues coming to light throughout the book. I had to smile at the coincidence of the other cozy mystery I was reading having a similar-ish type twist. I liked following along the mystery and seeing new clues come to light and then at the end have it all get resolved. It was a satisfying mystery. While Jo's storyline about answers could be quite sad at times, it was also illuminating as she finds some of the answers she was looking for.
I did at times struggle with the dual point of view as it could be hard to keep up with both plot lines and the switches could be on these type of cliffhanger moments and then when we got back to that point of view I needed a moment to reorient myself. Then again I probably would've had an easier time with that if I hadn't read it during such a stressful time. I also would've liked to see Jo have a bigger role in the mystery and more interactions with MacAdams, their plot lines are pretty separate for the most part and then intersect at certain points. It worked well, but I just wanted a bit more overlap.
I really like Jo as a main character I could relatable to her thought her being autistic was well written. I am autistic myself and I enjoyed reading about Jo. MacAdams is an interesting character as well and I liked seeing him slowly becoming a bit more open and closer to Jo. It's subtle, but I liked those few pivotal scenes were he was there for Jo. I hope there will be more books in this series as I want to read more about these characters and see their romance develop.
To summarize: This was a great sequel. It has a new mystery as well as Jo's search for answers continues. The mystery kept me guessing and had some nice twists while Jo's search for answers could be at times sad, but also brings her some of the answers she needs. I liked both Jo and MacAdams their points of view and both are likable main characters. At times I did wish their storylines would intermingle a bit more and I struggled sometimes with the point of view switches and having to reorient myself, but part of that is due to reading this during a stressful time. All in all this was a great read and I hope there will be more books in the series.
August 16, 2025
After delighting in The Framed Women of Ardemore House and that thrilling finish closing out the murder mystery, I was hoping upon hope that the author would follow up with another book that answered the questions about the secret family history and pursuing that flickering flame of a romance. Brandy Schillace introduces a bright neurodivergent Holmsian-like heroine recovering from a divorce and a jaded police detective unable to move on from his divorce, but open to the unique woman Jo presents.
The Dead Come to Stay is the second entry in the Ardemore House series and connects strongly to the first book though it also offers a fresh, clever murder mystery.
Jo is settling into life at her cottage on the Ardemore estate. The historic gardens are about to be dedicated, her cottage’s attic suite is now open for renters, and she’s becoming more and more settled in with her Yorkshire village neighbors and friends. Gwillam is still helping her research her family history and MacAdams is settling in as acting chief of the local constabulary while the chief post remains open.
But, an odd guest, a dead body on the moor, a mysterious hiker, and a surprising connection from Jo’s uncle Aiden’s past sets in motion two mysteries for Jo and James MacAdams’ to solve.
The Dead Come to Stay is mostly divided into Jo and James’ narrative points of view. He’s working the murder case delving into a wealthy architect and his country club friends, asylum refugees, and a mysterious Irishman who has a checkered present and a blank past. James has just been marking time until recently when Jo acted as a catalyst and now he’s thinking through what he wants in life and making some changes a little at a time.
Meanwhile, Jo’s speech at the Jeckyll garden dedication that made the Newcastle paper is seen by a person connected to her Uncle Aiden and that along with her ongoing hunt for clues using the painting to get at the truth behind her family’s murky past advance her search forcing her to face painful and surprising truths. Jo, being Jo, her knack for being in odd coincidental places related to murder, her observation and filing memory skills help James along with his case.
Brandy Schillace does great at writing a layered story of local color, culture, complex characters and plots, relationships, and current social commentary so it works for tone, pacing, and plot. I loved the diverse elements and tracking with both Jo and James. They have an unstated relationship build even when they are heading in their own individual directions. Found family versus blood family is explored as is how much wealth and power and corrupt people though also be used for good in the right hands.
The Dead Come to Stay ends so that this could wrap up the story because the main story arc is finished or lead into further installments in the series. I felt this was as strong or stronger than book one and definitely recommend it to cozy mystery fans who appreciate diversity of class, race, gender, and ability infusing their reads.
I rec'd an eARC via Harlequin Books to read in exchange for an honest review.
My full review will post at Books of My Heart on 8.6.25.
Buddy read with Lola @ Lola's Reviews.
The Dead Come to Stay is the second entry in the Ardemore House series and connects strongly to the first book though it also offers a fresh, clever murder mystery.
Jo is settling into life at her cottage on the Ardemore estate. The historic gardens are about to be dedicated, her cottage’s attic suite is now open for renters, and she’s becoming more and more settled in with her Yorkshire village neighbors and friends. Gwillam is still helping her research her family history and MacAdams is settling in as acting chief of the local constabulary while the chief post remains open.
But, an odd guest, a dead body on the moor, a mysterious hiker, and a surprising connection from Jo’s uncle Aiden’s past sets in motion two mysteries for Jo and James MacAdams’ to solve.
The Dead Come to Stay is mostly divided into Jo and James’ narrative points of view. He’s working the murder case delving into a wealthy architect and his country club friends, asylum refugees, and a mysterious Irishman who has a checkered present and a blank past. James has just been marking time until recently when Jo acted as a catalyst and now he’s thinking through what he wants in life and making some changes a little at a time.
Meanwhile, Jo’s speech at the Jeckyll garden dedication that made the Newcastle paper is seen by a person connected to her Uncle Aiden and that along with her ongoing hunt for clues using the painting to get at the truth behind her family’s murky past advance her search forcing her to face painful and surprising truths. Jo, being Jo, her knack for being in odd coincidental places related to murder, her observation and filing memory skills help James along with his case.
Brandy Schillace does great at writing a layered story of local color, culture, complex characters and plots, relationships, and current social commentary so it works for tone, pacing, and plot. I loved the diverse elements and tracking with both Jo and James. They have an unstated relationship build even when they are heading in their own individual directions. Found family versus blood family is explored as is how much wealth and power and corrupt people though also be used for good in the right hands.
The Dead Come to Stay ends so that this could wrap up the story because the main story arc is finished or lead into further installments in the series. I felt this was as strong or stronger than book one and definitely recommend it to cozy mystery fans who appreciate diversity of class, race, gender, and ability infusing their reads.
I rec'd an eARC via Harlequin Books to read in exchange for an honest review.
My full review will post at Books of My Heart on 8.6.25.
Buddy read with Lola @ Lola's Reviews.
July 26, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley, Harlequin Publishing, and my bookish Hive for the opportunity to read and review an advanced copy of The Dead Come to Stay by Brandy Schillace. This one was such a step up from the first book for me! Now that I’ve spent time with these characters, I’m fully invested — especially in Jo, who’s smart, neurodivergent, and always somehow near a dead body. It’s cozy and quirky, with just enough suspense to keep things interesting but not overwhelming. The growing relationship between Jo and the male lead got more focus in this book, which I enjoyed, and the side mysteries gave the plot a nice depth. If you’re more into mysteries than thrillers, this series hits a sweet spot. Definitely a 4-star read — I can’t wait for book 3!
December 16, 2025
3.5 Started strong
August 20, 2025
Though I don’t think the mystery here lived up to what we got in the first book in this series, this was an enjoyable and well-paced read.
I generally don’t put a lot of stock into the likability of characters (especially in this breed of mystery), but Jo and MacAdams are such a delight to spend time with that I would be remiss in failing to mention how much that contributes to these books. Jo is a unique heroine for the subgenre and a well-written one at that, and MacAdams, well, he just makes me happy.
That the mystery is a bit of a let-down compared to what we got in the first novel is a shame, though the story still has plenty of bright spots. The slowly unfolding mysteries surrounding Jo’s family are far better rendered and more intriguing than what I think was an overwritten and ultimately fairly convoluted central plot that was (sort of) about human trafficking/antiquities theft. It was a lot more depressing than interesting, and it failed to account for a lot of nuance on the antiquities side of things.
I also still wish these books had more atmosphere and a stronger sense of place, which feels like a must when billing something as a cozy mystery. But the flip side of that is that the characters are far more complex and compelling than what we get in most cozies, and the writing is both lovely and rife with subtle humor.
I’d like to see a more tightly plotted and more subgenre appropriate mystery next time, but there’s more than enough here to make this a series well worth reading.
*I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.*
I generally don’t put a lot of stock into the likability of characters (especially in this breed of mystery), but Jo and MacAdams are such a delight to spend time with that I would be remiss in failing to mention how much that contributes to these books. Jo is a unique heroine for the subgenre and a well-written one at that, and MacAdams, well, he just makes me happy.
That the mystery is a bit of a let-down compared to what we got in the first novel is a shame, though the story still has plenty of bright spots. The slowly unfolding mysteries surrounding Jo’s family are far better rendered and more intriguing than what I think was an overwritten and ultimately fairly convoluted central plot that was (sort of) about human trafficking/antiquities theft. It was a lot more depressing than interesting, and it failed to account for a lot of nuance on the antiquities side of things.
I also still wish these books had more atmosphere and a stronger sense of place, which feels like a must when billing something as a cozy mystery. But the flip side of that is that the characters are far more complex and compelling than what we get in most cozies, and the writing is both lovely and rife with subtle humor.
I’d like to see a more tightly plotted and more subgenre appropriate mystery next time, but there’s more than enough here to make this a series well worth reading.
*I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.*
July 16, 2025
3.5⭐️
I did that thing again where I accidentally requested the second book in a series from Netgalley. Luckily I don't think I missed too much by not reading the first book.
I really liked the way Jo was portrayed throughout this book. I feel like a lot of times, the personality traits of an autistic character are played up as almost comic relief. Instead both Jo and the way she interacts with James was authentically and respectfully portrayed. I liked the way that James lets her investigate the case but doesn't let her completely break the law like I've seen in some cozy mysteries. I also really enjoyed Jo's investigation into her family history. I wasn't overly impressed with the murder mystery aspect. It felt like it got overpowered by Jo's investigation into her family history.
I did receive an ALC of this book and was quite excited that it was narrated by Immogen Church. She's one of my favorite narrators but I did find her American accent to be super jarring. I still loved her narration though!
Thanks Netgalley, Hanover Square Press, and Harlequin Audio for providing these ARCs to me!
I did that thing again where I accidentally requested the second book in a series from Netgalley. Luckily I don't think I missed too much by not reading the first book.
I really liked the way Jo was portrayed throughout this book. I feel like a lot of times, the personality traits of an autistic character are played up as almost comic relief. Instead both Jo and the way she interacts with James was authentically and respectfully portrayed. I liked the way that James lets her investigate the case but doesn't let her completely break the law like I've seen in some cozy mysteries. I also really enjoyed Jo's investigation into her family history. I wasn't overly impressed with the murder mystery aspect. It felt like it got overpowered by Jo's investigation into her family history.
I did receive an ALC of this book and was quite excited that it was narrated by Immogen Church. She's one of my favorite narrators but I did find her American accent to be super jarring. I still loved her narration though!
Thanks Netgalley, Hanover Square Press, and Harlequin Audio for providing these ARCs to me!
August 10, 2025
I missed the first book in the series, but that did not impact my enjoyment of this book! The real-life details of the mystery added so much to the manufactured cozy village. The characters were all deftly written and nothing felt too outside the real of reality, no small feat for a murder mystery with a cozy sleuth who really should not be involved in police work. A great addition to the cozy genre!
Thanks to NetGalley for the review copy.
Thanks to NetGalley for the review copy.
August 27, 2025
I enjoy Jo Jones’ autistic brain, the bar owner Tula, Gwylim the antiques dealer, and police officers Green and MacAdams. The narratives are well devised and brought to life.
If I were advising the author, I would suggest, “It’s okay to let a certain theme (I can’t say which without spoiling it) not replay again from books 1 & 2. It’s getting weird.”
I do love learning random tidbits on famous painters, Syrian antiquities and the like.
My note to the editor: Not that you bother to read this—I found more typos in the Kindle version of this one title than I’ve seen in years of reading many books. Have you turned editing over to AI? Come on now.
If I were advising the author, I would suggest, “It’s okay to let a certain theme (I can’t say which without spoiling it) not replay again from books 1 & 2. It’s getting weird.”
I do love learning random tidbits on famous painters, Syrian antiquities and the like.
My note to the editor: Not that you bother to read this—I found more typos in the Kindle version of this one title than I’ve seen in years of reading many books. Have you turned editing over to AI? Come on now.
September 4, 2025
This second in the series does not disappoint. The author deftly weaves mystery within mystery (Jo finding her family folded into the whodunnit). Same great cast of characters, same lovely setting. This time I thought the murder mystery was far more intriguing, although still allowing the reader to sort it out and solve the puzzle alongside the detectives.
I eagerly await more in this series.
PS: where were the editors? Typos, completely wrong word, additional words (e.g. she gave the an apple). A distraction but not enough to diminish the overall read
I eagerly await more in this series.
PS: where were the editors? Typos, completely wrong word, additional words (e.g. she gave the an apple). A distraction but not enough to diminish the overall read
December 7, 2025
This was so dull and boring I instantly forgot this book existed the second I put it down. Life is too short to read a book so unremarkable.
November 27, 2025
I read the first book in the series and I loved it. This one was awful. The writing was clunky. It was really boring and I just couldn’t get into it. It took me forever to get through. I can’t believe I just didn’t DNF it. I should have.
September 1, 2025
The story was diverting enough but the copyediting and proofreading of the ebook were terrible--truly embarassing for Harper Collins and distracting for the reader.
August 10, 2025
Author Brandy Schillace has had a busy year this year. First, their non-fiction book The Intermediaries launched and now they have had a second book released this year, a non-fiction book that is a sequel to their debut novel, The Framed Women of Ardemere house. The Dead Come to Stay is a great follow up novel, and follows Jo Jones' new life in North Yorkshire.
I really loved and love Jo Jones as a character, as she's one of the only autistic main characters I've seen out there in publishing and I love to see the representation. There is so much that comes with being autistic, or having any form of neurodivergency, that I think "normal" people don't realize is taking place behind the scenes. We see it even from the opening scenes when Jo second guesses every moment of her initial introduction to her lodger, is she saying or doing the right things, acting appropriately, responding appropriately, etc. It really wears on a person and while there is great understanding of what those with neurodivergency are going through, it's still not fully accommodated or accepted.
The Dead Come to Stay brilliantly shows how something like autism has so many strengths. We see Jo's attention to detail again, and how some of these things become key to solving the mysteries at the center of this novel. I also really liked the other primary plot point of trying to figure out her family dynamics and what happened to cause her mother to have cut all contact from her uncle and who her uncle was. Almost any reader can relate to the idea that there are looming family secrets that lie beneath the surface of all our family relationships. Coming from a family where my dad and aunt didn't know they had a brother until they had both graduated high school (only because they found child support checks), it was really easy to relate to just trying to figure out how you fit into all the drama that takes place before we are even born into a family.
I enjoyed the book, and I highly recommend checking out The Dead Come to Stay and any of author Brandy Schillace's backlog (both fiction and non-fiction). This review is probably a little different from others you've seen but there are enough reviews out there that summarize the novel that you can find if you'd like. I really enjoyed some of the very basic premise and building blocks of the book, family secrets being uncovered, navigating the world while thinking differently than those around, mysteries within mysteries, etc. I also read the book through ebook, physical, and audiobook. The audiobook is narrated by Imogen Church, who is a force in her own right. Whatever version you choose, I'm sure you'll enjoy it.
Please be advised that I did also receive a free e-version of the book from the publisher in addition to the purchased copies. Also, posting this of my own volition, if you're in the Minnesota area, the author will be at Magers and Quinn August 20, 2025. The event is free, but does require pre-registration. https://www.magersandquinn.com/event/...
I really loved and love Jo Jones as a character, as she's one of the only autistic main characters I've seen out there in publishing and I love to see the representation. There is so much that comes with being autistic, or having any form of neurodivergency, that I think "normal" people don't realize is taking place behind the scenes. We see it even from the opening scenes when Jo second guesses every moment of her initial introduction to her lodger, is she saying or doing the right things, acting appropriately, responding appropriately, etc. It really wears on a person and while there is great understanding of what those with neurodivergency are going through, it's still not fully accommodated or accepted.
The Dead Come to Stay brilliantly shows how something like autism has so many strengths. We see Jo's attention to detail again, and how some of these things become key to solving the mysteries at the center of this novel. I also really liked the other primary plot point of trying to figure out her family dynamics and what happened to cause her mother to have cut all contact from her uncle and who her uncle was. Almost any reader can relate to the idea that there are looming family secrets that lie beneath the surface of all our family relationships. Coming from a family where my dad and aunt didn't know they had a brother until they had both graduated high school (only because they found child support checks), it was really easy to relate to just trying to figure out how you fit into all the drama that takes place before we are even born into a family.
I enjoyed the book, and I highly recommend checking out The Dead Come to Stay and any of author Brandy Schillace's backlog (both fiction and non-fiction). This review is probably a little different from others you've seen but there are enough reviews out there that summarize the novel that you can find if you'd like. I really enjoyed some of the very basic premise and building blocks of the book, family secrets being uncovered, navigating the world while thinking differently than those around, mysteries within mysteries, etc. I also read the book through ebook, physical, and audiobook. The audiobook is narrated by Imogen Church, who is a force in her own right. Whatever version you choose, I'm sure you'll enjoy it.
Please be advised that I did also receive a free e-version of the book from the publisher in addition to the purchased copies. Also, posting this of my own volition, if you're in the Minnesota area, the author will be at Magers and Quinn August 20, 2025. The event is free, but does require pre-registration. https://www.magersandquinn.com/event/...
August 17, 2025
BOOK REPORT
Note: I am posting the same Book Report for both of the first two books in this series.
On a whim, I picked up The Dead Come to Stay from the “new” shelves at the library a couple of Saturdays ago. Looked just like the right kind of British police procedural for me.
Didn’t get around to starting until yesterday, and the way I did was kind of odd for me. I had started a memoir written in an alternative fashion and gotten halfway through it, appreciating it more than enjoying it, when I suddenly realized that if I kept reading it I would wind up miserable with it, for all manner of reasons. So I put it down with the intention of picking it back up in a couple of days. (Some things are just so intense you have to take a breather.)
But, it was early in the afternoon, so I needed to start something else. Went with the Brandy Schillace; got a little more than three pages in and thought to myself, “Wait a dang minute here! Is this yet another book when the freaking publishers and their marketing minions have dropped the ball by not making it clear that this is a book in a series?”
Yep.
So, got The Framed Women of Ardmore House from Hoopla and slammed my way through half of it before having to adult. I was right—I loved the main protagonist, the dialogue, the supporting cast of characters, and the setting. Of course how could I not identify/empathize with Jo, with her tendency to blurt out everything she is thinking and a hyper-fixation on what to wear? Not to mention hyperlexia. And a tendency to melt completely down when overstimulated by bright lights and concurrent multiple types of sounds and too many people?!?
Can’t wait to read more in the series!
Also, here’s a link to the “about” section of Ms Schillace’s website: https://brandyschillace.com/about/
She is one mighty interesting—and very accomplished—person!
Note: I am posting the same Book Report for both of the first two books in this series.
On a whim, I picked up The Dead Come to Stay from the “new” shelves at the library a couple of Saturdays ago. Looked just like the right kind of British police procedural for me.
Didn’t get around to starting until yesterday, and the way I did was kind of odd for me. I had started a memoir written in an alternative fashion and gotten halfway through it, appreciating it more than enjoying it, when I suddenly realized that if I kept reading it I would wind up miserable with it, for all manner of reasons. So I put it down with the intention of picking it back up in a couple of days. (Some things are just so intense you have to take a breather.)
But, it was early in the afternoon, so I needed to start something else. Went with the Brandy Schillace; got a little more than three pages in and thought to myself, “Wait a dang minute here! Is this yet another book when the freaking publishers and their marketing minions have dropped the ball by not making it clear that this is a book in a series?”
Yep.
So, got The Framed Women of Ardmore House from Hoopla and slammed my way through half of it before having to adult. I was right—I loved the main protagonist, the dialogue, the supporting cast of characters, and the setting. Of course how could I not identify/empathize with Jo, with her tendency to blurt out everything she is thinking and a hyper-fixation on what to wear? Not to mention hyperlexia. And a tendency to melt completely down when overstimulated by bright lights and concurrent multiple types of sounds and too many people?!?
Can’t wait to read more in the series!
Also, here’s a link to the “about” section of Ms Schillace’s website: https://brandyschillace.com/about/
She is one mighty interesting—and very accomplished—person!
September 4, 2025
(This review appeared first on my website - CozyingUp.com )
Brandy Schillace’s next book in the Netherleigh series, The Dead Come to Stay, is a cozy mystery set in North Yorkshire. Picking up with The Framed Women of Ardemore left off, this second book involves the murder of a lodger at Jo Jones’ newly opened guest space in her attic.
Schillace intertwines the two main threads throughout each chapter, following both Detective Chief Inspector James MacAdams and the police as they investigate the murder and Jo as she discovers more about her family (both blood and found).
While the author does a great job job getting the reader up to speed on the events from the previous book, I was so intrigued by Jo’s story that I went back to read Framed Women before I got more than a few chapters into The Dead Come to Stay.
The characters in this series are what really make it. Jo Jones is neurodivergent and her attention to detail (as well as her past experience as an editor) means that she is aware of things that others may miss. MacAdams is both every British policeman you’ve read about, but yet nothing like any of them. My favorite character Detective Sergeant Sheila Green is MacAdams’ right hand and his conscience. In addition, Arthur and Chen who we meet in this book are sure to be new additions to my favorites list.
As someone who has been reading way too many “between the wars” cozy mysteries lately, this was just the contemporary cozy that I needed to read right now as I start working on my own. I’m definitely looking forward to more books in the Netherleigh series.
4 stars out of 5
Disclaimer: I received this book as a free eARC from the author. All views shared here are my own.
Brandy Schillace’s next book in the Netherleigh series, The Dead Come to Stay, is a cozy mystery set in North Yorkshire. Picking up with The Framed Women of Ardemore left off, this second book involves the murder of a lodger at Jo Jones’ newly opened guest space in her attic.
Schillace intertwines the two main threads throughout each chapter, following both Detective Chief Inspector James MacAdams and the police as they investigate the murder and Jo as she discovers more about her family (both blood and found).
While the author does a great job job getting the reader up to speed on the events from the previous book, I was so intrigued by Jo’s story that I went back to read Framed Women before I got more than a few chapters into The Dead Come to Stay.
The characters in this series are what really make it. Jo Jones is neurodivergent and her attention to detail (as well as her past experience as an editor) means that she is aware of things that others may miss. MacAdams is both every British policeman you’ve read about, but yet nothing like any of them. My favorite character Detective Sergeant Sheila Green is MacAdams’ right hand and his conscience. In addition, Arthur and Chen who we meet in this book are sure to be new additions to my favorites list.
As someone who has been reading way too many “between the wars” cozy mysteries lately, this was just the contemporary cozy that I needed to read right now as I start working on my own. I’m definitely looking forward to more books in the Netherleigh series.
4 stars out of 5
Disclaimer: I received this book as a free eARC from the author. All views shared here are my own.
November 27, 2025
This is sort of two investigations in one, though they do overlap. It's got hints of cozy, but also lots of police procedural. It all starts when Jo Jones' short term lodger arrives late one night, looking a bit disheveled. She feeds him tea and biscuits and he heads to bed. She doesn't see him again.
The next day, a man is found dead in a ditch not too far from Jo's home and ID reveals him to be her lodger, Ronan Foley. Of course she allows the local police cheif, James McAdams, with whom she's on good terms, to examine his room which provides few clues and a lot of questions about how he left the place.
Meanwhile, Jo is still intent on finding out more about a painting by Augustus Johns that she's inherited and, with the help of her archivist/historian friend Gwillam focuses on that, as well as her personal family history research. And yet, she can't quite let go the anomalies in the murder case.
The two investigations proceed more or less separately, but with various points of intersection: is that coincidence or meaningful? And why can't the police find any record of the dead man more from more than 25 years ago? Plus, everyone with any whisp of a motive seems to have an iron clad alibi. Clearly there's something they're missing.
I do suggest you read the first book before this one. And it would probably help to not wait too long between -- I feel like I might have missed a few details as it had been over a year since reading. But, I was generally able to follow well enough that details of the first came back to me. In the end, I enjoy her writing and how she portrays her characters, quirks and foibles and all: they're realistic in a very natural way vs trying to draw overt attention to aspects of autism, gay/trans characters, etc.
The next day, a man is found dead in a ditch not too far from Jo's home and ID reveals him to be her lodger, Ronan Foley. Of course she allows the local police cheif, James McAdams, with whom she's on good terms, to examine his room which provides few clues and a lot of questions about how he left the place.
Meanwhile, Jo is still intent on finding out more about a painting by Augustus Johns that she's inherited and, with the help of her archivist/historian friend Gwillam focuses on that, as well as her personal family history research. And yet, she can't quite let go the anomalies in the murder case.
The two investigations proceed more or less separately, but with various points of intersection: is that coincidence or meaningful? And why can't the police find any record of the dead man more from more than 25 years ago? Plus, everyone with any whisp of a motive seems to have an iron clad alibi. Clearly there's something they're missing.
I do suggest you read the first book before this one. And it would probably help to not wait too long between -- I feel like I might have missed a few details as it had been over a year since reading. But, I was generally able to follow well enough that details of the first came back to me. In the end, I enjoy her writing and how she portrays her characters, quirks and foibles and all: they're realistic in a very natural way vs trying to draw overt attention to aspects of autism, gay/trans characters, etc.
July 28, 2025
Thank you to HTP Books/Hanover Square Press for providing me with a gifted ebook copy of The Dead Come to Stay through NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
The Dead Come to Stay is the second book in the Ardemore Series, and it is a cozy, twisty mystery set in Yorkshire and surrounding areas. I have not read the first book, The Framed Women of Ardemore House, but I definitely want to after reading this one. I really loved the characters, and I would love to know more about them from the first book. The FMC is quirky and lovable, and I enjoyed the slow burn romance that seems to carry over from the first book.
The book focuses on dual storylines, with one being a murder mystery and the other being a family secrets mystery. I thought the plot twists worked really well, and I liked the way Schillace wove the two different mysteries together and kept the characters connected even though they were following their own different leads. I enjoyed most of the side characters and their quirky personalities, but there were a good bit of them to keep up with, and it could be somewhat overwhelming at times.
𝐖𝐡𝐚𝐭 𝐓𝐨 𝐄𝐱𝐩𝐞𝐜𝐭:
* Dual Mysteries
* Family Secrets
* Found Family
* Stolen Artifacts
* Neurodivergent Representation
* Cozy Read
* Refugee Aid
* Very Slow Burn Romance
𝐈𝐬 𝐈𝐭 𝐒𝐩𝐢𝐜𝐲?
🥶 (No)
The Dead Come to Stay would be a perfect cozy read to add to your Fall TBR, if you love mysteries and forensics, secrets and more secrets, and a smart, lovable FMC searching for answers into her family's past.
The Dead Come to Stay is the second book in the Ardemore Series, and it is a cozy, twisty mystery set in Yorkshire and surrounding areas. I have not read the first book, The Framed Women of Ardemore House, but I definitely want to after reading this one. I really loved the characters, and I would love to know more about them from the first book. The FMC is quirky and lovable, and I enjoyed the slow burn romance that seems to carry over from the first book.
The book focuses on dual storylines, with one being a murder mystery and the other being a family secrets mystery. I thought the plot twists worked really well, and I liked the way Schillace wove the two different mysteries together and kept the characters connected even though they were following their own different leads. I enjoyed most of the side characters and their quirky personalities, but there were a good bit of them to keep up with, and it could be somewhat overwhelming at times.
𝐖𝐡𝐚𝐭 𝐓𝐨 𝐄𝐱𝐩𝐞𝐜𝐭:
* Dual Mysteries
* Family Secrets
* Found Family
* Stolen Artifacts
* Neurodivergent Representation
* Cozy Read
* Refugee Aid
* Very Slow Burn Romance
𝐈𝐬 𝐈𝐭 𝐒𝐩𝐢𝐜𝐲?
🥶 (No)
The Dead Come to Stay would be a perfect cozy read to add to your Fall TBR, if you love mysteries and forensics, secrets and more secrets, and a smart, lovable FMC searching for answers into her family's past.
September 29, 2025
2.75/5
I really struggled to get invested in this book. I did realize a little too late, that this was a sequel. Yes, this book follows separate events from the first book, but I think I was missing a little bit of context that I wish I had. I just wish that when I got this on NetGalley, it had said that it was a sequel (or connected to other books, at least).
I didn't find the characters to be that engaging and I didn't find the mystery to be all that exciting either.
I did appreciate that this had multiple things going on, I think that helped to keep my attention. There was the mystery, family drama and relationship drama. So there was always something going on. I just wish there was a bit more oomph to those things.
I did struggle to follow certain moments (there was a lot of reliance on guesses to solve the mystery, and that felt a little too lucky that those guesses and assumptions were right). I just wanted a little more concrete evidence and moments to back those guesses. I do have to say that the mystery was more unique for this kind of book, so I did appreciate that.
This is definitely a cozier mystery, so if you're looking for a new one, this might be a series to check out. Just know that it is a series, so try and read the first book first. That was a big ole oopsy on my end. Sorry.
Thanks to NetGalley for the audiobook ARC of this book in exchange for my honest review!
I really struggled to get invested in this book. I did realize a little too late, that this was a sequel. Yes, this book follows separate events from the first book, but I think I was missing a little bit of context that I wish I had. I just wish that when I got this on NetGalley, it had said that it was a sequel (or connected to other books, at least).
I didn't find the characters to be that engaging and I didn't find the mystery to be all that exciting either.
I did appreciate that this had multiple things going on, I think that helped to keep my attention. There was the mystery, family drama and relationship drama. So there was always something going on. I just wish there was a bit more oomph to those things.
I did struggle to follow certain moments (there was a lot of reliance on guesses to solve the mystery, and that felt a little too lucky that those guesses and assumptions were right). I just wanted a little more concrete evidence and moments to back those guesses. I do have to say that the mystery was more unique for this kind of book, so I did appreciate that.
This is definitely a cozier mystery, so if you're looking for a new one, this might be a series to check out. Just know that it is a series, so try and read the first book first. That was a big ole oopsy on my end. Sorry.
Thanks to NetGalley for the audiobook ARC of this book in exchange for my honest review!
August 1, 2025
I enjoyed this mystery! Second in a series, it's set in Northern England and features an amateur American sleuth (she never MEANS to sleuth, she just happens to be on the scene of the crime!), Jo, and a local detective inspector, James.
In this entry, a man staying at Jo's air bnb turns up dead the day after he checks in. The mystery turns out to have a lot to do with refugees and smuggled artifacts, and (of course) Jo gets caught up in solving it. It's a pretty standard mystery, with the highlight being the characters: Jo has autism and is very open about the challenges of and the advantages to her way of thinking. (Her attention to detail can be a real asset while crime solving!) James doesn't just appreciate her assistance, but is also nurturing a crush.
I did have a minor jump scare when Jo (a freelance editor) complains that the only people looking for developmental editing are romance novel authors ... she does go on to explain that she's simply not the right person to edit romance, so she can't be a satisfactory editor.
When I read a mystery set in England, I want a nice British narration, and that's what you get from Imogen Church. I was worried that American Jo would suffer, but Church does a great job with all of the different accents (including a "barely there" Irish clue!).
This objective review is based on a complimentary copy of the audiobook.
In this entry, a man staying at Jo's air bnb turns up dead the day after he checks in. The mystery turns out to have a lot to do with refugees and smuggled artifacts, and (of course) Jo gets caught up in solving it. It's a pretty standard mystery, with the highlight being the characters: Jo has autism and is very open about the challenges of and the advantages to her way of thinking. (Her attention to detail can be a real asset while crime solving!) James doesn't just appreciate her assistance, but is also nurturing a crush.
I did have a minor jump scare when Jo (a freelance editor) complains that the only people looking for developmental editing are romance novel authors ... she does go on to explain that she's simply not the right person to edit romance, so she can't be a satisfactory editor.
When I read a mystery set in England, I want a nice British narration, and that's what you get from Imogen Church. I was worried that American Jo would suffer, but Church does a great job with all of the different accents (including a "barely there" Irish clue!).
This objective review is based on a complimentary copy of the audiobook.
July 23, 2025
My thanks for the ARC goes to NetGalley and Harlequin Trade Publishing, Hanover Square Press. I'm voluntarily leaving a review.
Genre: Mystery, Crime Fiction, Mystery Thriller
Spice Level: Nothing terribly spicey
Gore Level: Medium—the descriptions are not too intense, but there are bodies
Language: Peppered with profanity including f-bombs
THE DEAD COME TO STAY introduces an unexpected world of antiquity thefts, and I loved it. Of course, I love everything to do with art and antiquities, so that is not a big surprise.
This novel comes after The Framed Women of Ardemore House, but it could stand alone. I still think you'll enjoy it more if you read these in order.
James, the police officer, is incredibly reluctant to involve Jo in another murder case. The problem is she's right in the thick of things again. I love her character and how she is true to herself. Even she doesn't want to have to investigate another murder, but the clues are more apparent to her than others. What's a woman to do except put on the sleuthing hat?
This is another twisty mystery, and I definitely enjoyed it.
I think mystery lovers will gravitate to this one—I wouldn't exactly cause it cozy because of the cursing. But there is a slow-burn romance plot.
Happy reading!
Genre: Mystery, Crime Fiction, Mystery Thriller
Spice Level: Nothing terribly spicey
Gore Level: Medium—the descriptions are not too intense, but there are bodies
Language: Peppered with profanity including f-bombs
THE DEAD COME TO STAY introduces an unexpected world of antiquity thefts, and I loved it. Of course, I love everything to do with art and antiquities, so that is not a big surprise.
This novel comes after The Framed Women of Ardemore House, but it could stand alone. I still think you'll enjoy it more if you read these in order.
James, the police officer, is incredibly reluctant to involve Jo in another murder case. The problem is she's right in the thick of things again. I love her character and how she is true to herself. Even she doesn't want to have to investigate another murder, but the clues are more apparent to her than others. What's a woman to do except put on the sleuthing hat?
This is another twisty mystery, and I definitely enjoyed it.
I think mystery lovers will gravitate to this one—I wouldn't exactly cause it cozy because of the cursing. But there is a slow-burn romance plot.
Happy reading!
August 5, 2025
As an avid reader, historical fiction is by far my preferred genre, though classics, history, and biographies often catch my attention. Even an occasional science fiction, adventure, or spy thriller makes it onto my reading list.
I recently read a historical fiction novel about Agatha Christie that prompted me to research her life and question why I had never read any of her books. This led me to The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, purportedly one of her best works. While I enjoyed it, I must say it didn't convert me into an avid mystery reader.
Then came an opportunity to read another mystery — The Dead Come to Stay by Brandy Schillace. I was surprised to find I enjoyed this mystery far more than the Agatha Christie novel.
I was captivated by the intricacies of multiple plots masterfully interwoven and, to my delight, enriched with historical fiction elements. The author’s inside glimpses to the worlds of fine art, rare artifact trading, international refugee trafficking, and the unique perspective of a neurodivergent protagonist created a mystery I feel fortunate to have discovered. I'll definitely be seeking out my next Brandy Schillace read.
I recently read a historical fiction novel about Agatha Christie that prompted me to research her life and question why I had never read any of her books. This led me to The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, purportedly one of her best works. While I enjoyed it, I must say it didn't convert me into an avid mystery reader.
Then came an opportunity to read another mystery — The Dead Come to Stay by Brandy Schillace. I was surprised to find I enjoyed this mystery far more than the Agatha Christie novel.
I was captivated by the intricacies of multiple plots masterfully interwoven and, to my delight, enriched with historical fiction elements. The author’s inside glimpses to the worlds of fine art, rare artifact trading, international refugee trafficking, and the unique perspective of a neurodivergent protagonist created a mystery I feel fortunate to have discovered. I'll definitely be seeking out my next Brandy Schillace read.
August 9, 2025
I loved this second novel about book editor Jo Jones’s zany, murder-mystery-filled life in Yorkshire, England. Jo, who happens to be autistic, is an American transplant who keeps getting mixed up in local murders. The funny, thoughtful characters from author Brandy Schillace’s first Netherleigh novel are back; we learn more about Jo’s extended historical family – the one whose past was mixed up in the murder in the previous book.
I loved experiencing the interior lives of Jo - amateur sleuthing her way through the mysteries unfolding around her - and detective MacAdams - puzzling his way through the intricate pieces of the human dramas that led to the murder.
What’s exciting and new here is the contemporary twist at the core of the plot: this is a murder mystery set now: not in the 1920s, not in Inspector Morse-land. But what I loved the most is the funny style and the feeling of rest and escape that is the gift of diving into this book.
I read this as a digital ARC. My pre-ordered copy has now arrived; I’m going to now re-read the first Netherleigh novel and then re-read THE DEAD COME TO STAY in glorious hard copy!
I loved experiencing the interior lives of Jo - amateur sleuthing her way through the mysteries unfolding around her - and detective MacAdams - puzzling his way through the intricate pieces of the human dramas that led to the murder.
What’s exciting and new here is the contemporary twist at the core of the plot: this is a murder mystery set now: not in the 1920s, not in Inspector Morse-land. But what I loved the most is the funny style and the feeling of rest and escape that is the gift of diving into this book.
I read this as a digital ARC. My pre-ordered copy has now arrived; I’m going to now re-read the first Netherleigh novel and then re-read THE DEAD COME TO STAY in glorious hard copy!
September 10, 2025
I truly enjoyed the first novel in this series, so was eagerly anticipating the second instalment. With a neurodivergent protagonist, some subtle humour, and some peculiar and nefarious characters, there is a lot here to hold a reader’s interest.
This time out, Jo Jones encounters the dark crimes of people smuggling, antiquity theft, and yes, even murder...
I enjoyed the dialogue between Jo and the local police detective, James MacAdams. We are privy to the growing attraction between the two and come to know them better than in the first book.
For some reason, I just didn't seem to engage with Jo on the same level as with the first book, though the author's writing style was just as skilled.
Jo's search for some connection to her 'family' via their colourful legacy seemed to overshadow the current day murder mystery. Some of the plot seemed unwieldy and convoluted.
If you enjoy books with quirky characters, dark crimes, and a budding romance, then I feel you'll really appreciate this series by the talented Brandy Schillace. It is a cozy mystery, yet it has serious themes running throughout.
This time out, Jo Jones encounters the dark crimes of people smuggling, antiquity theft, and yes, even murder...
I enjoyed the dialogue between Jo and the local police detective, James MacAdams. We are privy to the growing attraction between the two and come to know them better than in the first book.
For some reason, I just didn't seem to engage with Jo on the same level as with the first book, though the author's writing style was just as skilled.
Jo's search for some connection to her 'family' via their colourful legacy seemed to overshadow the current day murder mystery. Some of the plot seemed unwieldy and convoluted.
If you enjoy books with quirky characters, dark crimes, and a budding romance, then I feel you'll really appreciate this series by the talented Brandy Schillace. It is a cozy mystery, yet it has serious themes running throughout.
October 24, 2025
This is primarily a dual POV story.
Jo, an American, now owner of the big house with a complicated family part that Jo is trying to research, a continuing saga from the first book in this series, using a painting she found in the adjacent house, she’s now living in. She’s also opening the gardens on the land with a UK heritage foundation and fixed up the upper floor of her house to rent — which is where all the complications later stem.
James MacAdams is the police detective in town who we met in the first book. He’s investigating the murder of Jo’s first renter on the first night, found the next morning. This murder opens up early histories of some of the residents, and puts the detective in jeopardy.
Jo, being Jo, with her photographic memory, hyper-focus mind, and extraordinary leaps of logic, gets involved by being in the wrong place at just that moment.
This flow of this story worked better than the first book that seemed disjointed to follow. Unfortunately, the characters weren’t memorable. I read this over about a week, but each time I picked it up, I couldn’t remember who any of the characters were and had to look them up.
Jo, an American, now owner of the big house with a complicated family part that Jo is trying to research, a continuing saga from the first book in this series, using a painting she found in the adjacent house, she’s now living in. She’s also opening the gardens on the land with a UK heritage foundation and fixed up the upper floor of her house to rent — which is where all the complications later stem.
James MacAdams is the police detective in town who we met in the first book. He’s investigating the murder of Jo’s first renter on the first night, found the next morning. This murder opens up early histories of some of the residents, and puts the detective in jeopardy.
Jo, being Jo, with her photographic memory, hyper-focus mind, and extraordinary leaps of logic, gets involved by being in the wrong place at just that moment.
This flow of this story worked better than the first book that seemed disjointed to follow. Unfortunately, the characters weren’t memorable. I read this over about a week, but each time I picked it up, I couldn’t remember who any of the characters were and had to look them up.
August 22, 2025
The Dead Come to Stay pulled me in with its cozy atmosphere, layered mystery, and a cast of characters that felt both quirky and real.
Jo is settling into her new life in Yorkshire. She’s sharp, observant, and has a quiet strength that makes her easy to root for. When a body turns up near her cottage, Jo finds herself tangled in a murder investigation alongside Detective James MacAdams. Their dynamic was interesting.
The story follows two mysteries at once: the murder and Jo’s search into her family’s past. I liked how both threads were woven together. There were plenty of twists, and I was surprised by some of the reveals.
The setting was another highlight. The village, the estate, and the surrounding countryside were described in a way that made me feel like I was right there. It had that classic cozy mystery charm but also touched on deeper themes.
Even without reading book one, I felt connected to the characters and curious about their backstories. I’ll definitely be going back to read The Framed Women of Ardemore House next.
Jo is settling into her new life in Yorkshire. She’s sharp, observant, and has a quiet strength that makes her easy to root for. When a body turns up near her cottage, Jo finds herself tangled in a murder investigation alongside Detective James MacAdams. Their dynamic was interesting.
The story follows two mysteries at once: the murder and Jo’s search into her family’s past. I liked how both threads were woven together. There were plenty of twists, and I was surprised by some of the reveals.
The setting was another highlight. The village, the estate, and the surrounding countryside were described in a way that made me feel like I was right there. It had that classic cozy mystery charm but also touched on deeper themes.
Even without reading book one, I felt connected to the characters and curious about their backstories. I’ll definitely be going back to read The Framed Women of Ardemore House next.
August 30, 2025
I enjoyed this book a great deal, enough to read it in a day. I like the main characters, and I found it entertaining. Sadly, I saw something coming as soon as the crime happened, but was still interested enough to keep reading. I did find the crime a little complicated, or maybe it was my tired brain.
Unfortunately, I have the same complaint as in the first book. Proofreading! Editing! This needs to happen. It seemed especially annoying in a book about an editor. There were just so many wrong word choices, typos, and factual errors that it was constantly taking me out of the story. I bookmarked them, and I ended up with 42 errors. From calling a character by the wrong name, to your/you're and its/it's errors, and weird ones like through/throw, to odd mistakes like an incorrect movie reference. Each one isn't huge, but altogether, it made it feel like no one read this before it was published, and it was very distracting.
I enjoyed the book enough that I'm looking forward to the next one, but I really do hope it gets some proofreading. :(
Unfortunately, I have the same complaint as in the first book. Proofreading! Editing! This needs to happen. It seemed especially annoying in a book about an editor. There were just so many wrong word choices, typos, and factual errors that it was constantly taking me out of the story. I bookmarked them, and I ended up with 42 errors. From calling a character by the wrong name, to your/you're and its/it's errors, and weird ones like through/throw, to odd mistakes like an incorrect movie reference. Each one isn't huge, but altogether, it made it feel like no one read this before it was published, and it was very distracting.
I enjoyed the book enough that I'm looking forward to the next one, but I really do hope it gets some proofreading. :(
December 16, 2025
I was very excited for this book because I enjoyed the first book in the series so much.
Sadly, I did not enjoy this book near as much.
I think that if you hadn’t read the previous book you would be COMPLETELY lost. This book relies heavily on the previous book.
I found the switching back and forth between 2 story lines hard to keep track of. Having 2 separate story lines and lots of characters really drags out the book. It’s like reading 2 books mixed together. The audiobook is 12 hours long. It felt like it went on and on and I just wanted to get to the point.
In the first book I love how the main character is portrayed and you get insight into being autistic. In this book (perhaps it was due to the narrator) the main character seems more young and immature than autistic. I kept forgetting that she is supposed to be a grown divorced woman and NOT a lost and confused 17 year old.
If you’re not familiar with the author and their style you might not enjoy the long slow 12 hour journey through this book.
Most definitely read the books in order.
Sadly, I did not enjoy this book near as much.
I think that if you hadn’t read the previous book you would be COMPLETELY lost. This book relies heavily on the previous book.
I found the switching back and forth between 2 story lines hard to keep track of. Having 2 separate story lines and lots of characters really drags out the book. It’s like reading 2 books mixed together. The audiobook is 12 hours long. It felt like it went on and on and I just wanted to get to the point.
In the first book I love how the main character is portrayed and you get insight into being autistic. In this book (perhaps it was due to the narrator) the main character seems more young and immature than autistic. I kept forgetting that she is supposed to be a grown divorced woman and NOT a lost and confused 17 year old.
If you’re not familiar with the author and their style you might not enjoy the long slow 12 hour journey through this book.
Most definitely read the books in order.
August 8, 2025
Jo jones has settled into her new home in North Yorkshire, and she's still looking into her family history. When a body turns up with surprising connections to her, she and MacAdams are thrust into the world of real estate, refugees, and stolen relics.
This was a delightful second installment. I'll admit that halfway through I was worried about all of the many threads of the mystery being sewn up, but the ending to both the mystery of this book and the larger threads that were left hanging from the first book was gratifying. Jo and co all grow realistically in this installment, and I love the growing relationship between Jo and MacAdams. My one quibble is that there are just a few too many narrators; the chapters alternate POV's, and while I can handle alternating between Jo and MacAdams, adding in additional characters gets to be a bit much for me.
4.5/5 rounded up to 5. I really hope Jo and MacAdams get further installments!
This was a delightful second installment. I'll admit that halfway through I was worried about all of the many threads of the mystery being sewn up, but the ending to both the mystery of this book and the larger threads that were left hanging from the first book was gratifying. Jo and co all grow realistically in this installment, and I love the growing relationship between Jo and MacAdams. My one quibble is that there are just a few too many narrators; the chapters alternate POV's, and while I can handle alternating between Jo and MacAdams, adding in additional characters gets to be a bit much for me.
4.5/5 rounded up to 5. I really hope Jo and MacAdams get further installments!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 87 reviews