MW Craven proves that his stellar crime debut The Puppet Show was no fluke and then some with this sequel featuring the charismatic pairing of DS Washington Poe with his traumatic and haunting background and the unforgettable genius that is the endearing crime analyst, Matilda 'Tilly' Bradshaw, on the autism spectrum, at the National Crime Agency. In Cumbria, Constable Graham Alsop of the Neighbourhood Policing Team is a problem solver running sessions at the library for the community after budget cuts and the closing down of police stations in the area. A young woman in a dreadful state staggers in claiming to be Elizabeth Keaton, speaking of her traumatic experience of sexual abuse for years after being abducted. The only problem is that she is supposed to be dead, and her father, famous celebrity chef Jared, of the well known local Bullace and Sloe restaurant with its Michelin stars, is in prison, serving a life sentence for her murder.
The man responsible for Keaton's conviction was Poe, and he is urgently called back to Cumbria where he has a remote home, Herdwick Croft, and his dog, Edgar. Supported by Detective Superintendent Gamble, Poe returns to the scene of the crime, the Bullace and Sloe kitchen where evidence of heavy amounts of blood were found. Elizabeth Keaton has provided irrefutable blood samples that prove that she is who she says is, and Poe follows this chain of evidence to ensure that it has not been tampered with. Poe found Jared to be a cruel, and sadistic personality, hidden behind his public persona of a affable and charming man in public and on his TV shows, in fact Poe is certain the man is one of the worst psychopaths he has ever encountered. Jared's legal team have mounted a challenge to his conviction, Poe knows he is in trouble when he meets Jared again, a man who is going to be free very soon. With Gamble suspended, DCI Wardle, his replacement. has Poe in his sights when Elizabeth disappears. With the net closing around him, Poe calls in Tilly, if anyone can counter the threats he faces, it's going to be her.
Tilly has grown in personal stature and confidence since we last saw her, she now runs her own team of IT nerds and geeks, and whilst she still makes unfiltered comments that disconcert and confound, she has learned to fit in a little more. DI Stephanie Flynn, gives up on trying to get Tilly to adhere to a dress code, understanding that this asset has to be managed differently and she does not get in the way when Tilly goes to help her good friend, Poe. In a complex and tangled investigation, it takes Poe and Tilly some time before they begin to see the chinks of light that allude to the murky truth. This is a fantastic read, entertaining, tense, suspenseful, full of comic humour and wit, and Craven, in Poe, and in particular, Tilly, indisputably has a winning set of protagonists whose relationship is a joy to observe. I cannot tell you how much I am looking forward to the next one in this highly recommended series! Many thanks to Little, Brown for an ARC.