What do you think?
Rate this book
Pine Springs #2
Every Reason Why
Wildly romantic, Every Reason Why is the second in the Pine Springs series—small-town Michigan, where there’s community, drama, heat, and heart.
Leah’s never truly known what it means to feel at home until she settles at Amity Court. But Jackson Hale wants to take it all away.
When Jackson inherits the historic mansion from his grandmother, Esther Hale, the last thing he needs is her bizarre final to allow Leah Raven, Esther’s perky tenant, to stay there until the house is sold. It’s infuriating and he doesn’t want her company.
Leah’s found a sanctuary within the walls of Amity Court, and she isn’t going to let some frustrated city businessman cash in his inheritance without resistance—not while there’s so much pleasure to be had in ruffling his feathers.
Although Jackson has learned not to rely on anyone, Leah, with her sunny smiles and silly jokes, soon starts to make that feel like a lonely choice. Forced to live side by side, the walls between them begin to crumble.
But with Jackson’s controlling father pressuring him to sell and a loan shark threatening not only the family business but Leah as well, the two will have to decide what matters the security of the lives they’ve built independently, or the chance at something real together.
Sometimes home isn’t a place—it’s finding the person brave enough to see who you really are.
Leah’s never truly known what it means to feel at home until she settles at Amity Court. But Jackson Hale wants to take it all away.
When Jackson inherits the historic mansion from his grandmother, Esther Hale, the last thing he needs is her bizarre final to allow Leah Raven, Esther’s perky tenant, to stay there until the house is sold. It’s infuriating and he doesn’t want her company.
Leah’s found a sanctuary within the walls of Amity Court, and she isn’t going to let some frustrated city businessman cash in his inheritance without resistance—not while there’s so much pleasure to be had in ruffling his feathers.
Although Jackson has learned not to rely on anyone, Leah, with her sunny smiles and silly jokes, soon starts to make that feel like a lonely choice. Forced to live side by side, the walls between them begin to crumble.
But with Jackson’s controlling father pressuring him to sell and a loan shark threatening not only the family business but Leah as well, the two will have to decide what matters the security of the lives they’ve built independently, or the chance at something real together.
Sometimes home isn’t a place—it’s finding the person brave enough to see who you really are.
393 pages, Kindle Edition
First published February 16, 2026
624 people are currently reading
3512 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 115 reviews
February 12, 2026
✨ grumpy x sunshine
🏡 small town romance
🕯️ slow burn
🚻 enemies to lovers
🫛 close proximity
I was extremely lucky to receive an ARC of the second book in the Pine Springs series and have loved every second of it. I didn’t realise how much I loved the grumpy x sunshine trope until Every Reason Why - this book hit the mark perfectly. The characters are multidimensional and feel real, with a slow burn between Leah and Jackson that’s impossible to ignore!
The themes of hardship and privilege, love and emotional abuse are woven together beautifully, adding depth to the romance. Sophie Hamilton has found the perfect balance, making this a must-read for fans of small town romance.
The cast of characters is brilliant from the strong and brooding MMC to the charismatic FMC and witty side characters. The representation of a debilitating health condition adds another layer of depth.
This book left me pondering - is home a physical place or is it a feeling? I’ll definitely be recommending this, and can’t wait for the next installment!
🏡 small town romance
🕯️ slow burn
🚻 enemies to lovers
🫛 close proximity
I was extremely lucky to receive an ARC of the second book in the Pine Springs series and have loved every second of it. I didn’t realise how much I loved the grumpy x sunshine trope until Every Reason Why - this book hit the mark perfectly. The characters are multidimensional and feel real, with a slow burn between Leah and Jackson that’s impossible to ignore!
The themes of hardship and privilege, love and emotional abuse are woven together beautifully, adding depth to the romance. Sophie Hamilton has found the perfect balance, making this a must-read for fans of small town romance.
The cast of characters is brilliant from the strong and brooding MMC to the charismatic FMC and witty side characters. The representation of a debilitating health condition adds another layer of depth.
This book left me pondering - is home a physical place or is it a feeling? I’ll definitely be recommending this, and can’t wait for the next installment!
February 21, 2026
2.0 stars. Book 2 of the Pine Springs series was a let down compared to book 1. I was incredibly bored and strongly disliked Jackson, the hero. Didn't find the story or the other characters all that interesting either. The author does her best to redeem "Jax" in the readers eyes later in the story, but it was too late for me. As far as suspense, it was weak.
This book had the read/listen option. I even hoped listening would help. It didn't, through no fault of the narrators.
Just not what I was expecting after how much I enjoyed book 1.
This book had the read/listen option. I even hoped listening would help. It didn't, through no fault of the narrators.
Just not what I was expecting after how much I enjoyed book 1.
November 12, 2025
4.5⭐️
After finishing the first book, More than Nothing, today I absolutely had to pick up an ARC of Every Reason Why. It’s safe to say I am a big fan of Sophie Hamilton!
This book had me gripped from the beginning. I normally hate dumbing down books to simply troped but… the grumpy sunshine AND forced proximity trope ??? amazing!!! I feel like it was done so well. I notice Hamilton does a good job at creating the best side characters as well.
I thought I had an idea of where the plot was going then we ended up on a whole side of the board I didn’t expect. Honestly though, I mostly get it wrong but it’s always fun to try.
I’m really excited to read more from her in the future!
P.S. as a Michigan girly I loved all of the names of the places they visited and also the euchre shout out!
After finishing the first book, More than Nothing, today I absolutely had to pick up an ARC of Every Reason Why. It’s safe to say I am a big fan of Sophie Hamilton!
This book had me gripped from the beginning. I normally hate dumbing down books to simply troped but… the grumpy sunshine AND forced proximity trope ??? amazing!!! I feel like it was done so well. I notice Hamilton does a good job at creating the best side characters as well.
I thought I had an idea of where the plot was going then we ended up on a whole side of the board I didn’t expect. Honestly though, I mostly get it wrong but it’s always fun to try.
I’m really excited to read more from her in the future!
P.S. as a Michigan girly I loved all of the names of the places they visited and also the euchre shout out!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Something about Sophie’s books really just hits all of the emotions, her characters are well thought out and are crafted in a way that fit the story perfectly. I thoroughly enjoyed this from start to finish.
I honestly didn’t think anything could read as well as Elenie and Roman’s story but I was so wrong. Leah and Jackson bring a different kind of raw and emotional connection. His disconnected and stand offish personality should be enough to send resilient, grateful for life Leah, running, but it does quite the opposite. From the moment she saw him at Esther’s funeral, Leah knew Jackson was more than just a handsome, haunted face.
Jackson is less than pleased to learn that not only has he been left Amity Court in Esther’s will, that Leah seems to come as part of the package. In the way of his need to sell the house, Jackson has zero time for Leah and her positive, sunny self. He may disagree with how his Dad wants to handle the situation, but he knows that both Leah and the house need to go. Bound by Esther’s lady wishes, this is really difficult and it forces Jackson to spend more time in the house and with Leah… this is where the fun starts 😏.
I wish I could see the vision that is Amity Court, there was so much love within the description of the house and I adored how it was such a central part of the story. Seeing Jackson’s walls come down towards both Amity Court and Leah was one of my favourite things, both characters have been through a lot and I was happy that they opened up to each other to let each other in. They both deserve everything but Leah’s story really made me personally want to seek out the best possible future for her! I felt like a protective sibling 😂.
There were some twists in this book that I didn’t see coming and honestly made me gasp in surprise! I loved Sam and Kash as side characters and the little group they formed that of course included Hazel was so sweet! Please don’t get me started on Alistar Hale 🫠 the rage that man made me feel was something else!! He angered me in SO many ways Landen Peake, Max, every single visit he made to Amoty Court are just a few ways 😂.
Another amazing book In the Pine Springs series.. Will there be another? 🙊
I honestly didn’t think anything could read as well as Elenie and Roman’s story but I was so wrong. Leah and Jackson bring a different kind of raw and emotional connection. His disconnected and stand offish personality should be enough to send resilient, grateful for life Leah, running, but it does quite the opposite. From the moment she saw him at Esther’s funeral, Leah knew Jackson was more than just a handsome, haunted face.
Jackson is less than pleased to learn that not only has he been left Amity Court in Esther’s will, that Leah seems to come as part of the package. In the way of his need to sell the house, Jackson has zero time for Leah and her positive, sunny self. He may disagree with how his Dad wants to handle the situation, but he knows that both Leah and the house need to go. Bound by Esther’s lady wishes, this is really difficult and it forces Jackson to spend more time in the house and with Leah… this is where the fun starts 😏.
I wish I could see the vision that is Amity Court, there was so much love within the description of the house and I adored how it was such a central part of the story. Seeing Jackson’s walls come down towards both Amity Court and Leah was one of my favourite things, both characters have been through a lot and I was happy that they opened up to each other to let each other in. They both deserve everything but Leah’s story really made me personally want to seek out the best possible future for her! I felt like a protective sibling 😂.
There were some twists in this book that I didn’t see coming and honestly made me gasp in surprise! I loved Sam and Kash as side characters and the little group they formed that of course included Hazel was so sweet! Please don’t get me started on Alistar Hale 🫠 the rage that man made me feel was something else!! He angered me in SO many ways Landen Peake, Max, every single visit he made to Amoty Court are just a few ways 😂.
Another amazing book In the Pine Springs series.. Will there be another? 🙊
February 21, 2026
There aren’t enough words to say how much I liked this book - it was an “easy to get lost in”, “shut out the rest of the world” type book. Romantic and a bit spicy. Grumpy/Sunshine trope for sure. A little forced/close proximity. Overall just beautifully written. Fun, witty and humorous characters.
We meet Leah, Esther Hale’s live-in assistant, and Jackson, Esther’s grandson. Jackson inherits Amity Court from his grandmother when she passes on, but this is the only place Leah has found a sense of home. Jackson is pressured from his father to sell Amity Court. But Leah isn’t going down without a fight. As they get to know each other, what can I say? Sparks fly.
This is my first book by Sophie Hamilton. Definitely picking up more of her work.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC to read and review. All opinions are my own.
We meet Leah, Esther Hale’s live-in assistant, and Jackson, Esther’s grandson. Jackson inherits Amity Court from his grandmother when she passes on, but this is the only place Leah has found a sense of home. Jackson is pressured from his father to sell Amity Court. But Leah isn’t going down without a fight. As they get to know each other, what can I say? Sparks fly.
This is my first book by Sophie Hamilton. Definitely picking up more of her work.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC to read and review. All opinions are my own.
December 4, 2025
Leah’s never truly known what it means to feel at home until she settles at Amity Court. But Jackson Hale wants to take it all away.
When Jackson inherits the historic mansion from his grandmother, Esther Hale, the last thing he needs is her bizarre final to allow Leah Raven, Esther’s perky tenant, to stay there until the house is sold. It’s infuriating and he doesn’t want her company.
This is book2 in The Pine Springs series and as good as book1.
I love all the side characters too. i live for upbeat romance with all the vibes and banter.
Sophie Hamilton delivers.
I absolutely binge read this one and enjoyed that our FMC was strong and feisty and totally unraveled our MMC.
Brilliant book.
can't wait for more in the series.
Kerry Kennedy Author
When Jackson inherits the historic mansion from his grandmother, Esther Hale, the last thing he needs is her bizarre final to allow Leah Raven, Esther’s perky tenant, to stay there until the house is sold. It’s infuriating and he doesn’t want her company.
This is book2 in The Pine Springs series and as good as book1.
I love all the side characters too. i live for upbeat romance with all the vibes and banter.
Sophie Hamilton delivers.
I absolutely binge read this one and enjoyed that our FMC was strong and feisty and totally unraveled our MMC.
Brilliant book.
can't wait for more in the series.
Kerry Kennedy Author
February 22, 2026
3.5 ⭐️
I read Every Reason Why by Sophie Hamilton as part of a readalong with Tandem Collective for their Chapters and Chat book club, and it was such a cute, easy to sink into contemporary romance with that cosy small town feel.
The story centres around Leah, who has built a life for herself in Amity Court, the home of her late employer Esther. When Esther passes away, her grandson Jackson inherits the house, but there is a condition in the will that means Leah is very much part of the deal. What follows is forced proximity, reluctant cohabitation, and a slow shift from tension to something softer and much deeper.
Leah was absolutely the sunshine in this grumpy x sunshine dynamic. She is unapologetically herself and it was genuinely refreshing. No matter what life has handed her, she chooses warmth. She chooses to see the good. There is something very comforting about a character like that.
Jackson is your classic good looking, grumpy, overworked MMC; with a complicated relationship with his family and more emotional baggage than he would ever admit to. On the surface he is closed off and driven, but as the story unfolds you start to see the hidden depths and the trauma he is quietly carrying. Watching him slowly unravel and rebuild was one of the stronger aspects of the book for me.
Their banter was top form. It felt natural and fun, and the chemistry built in a way that made the slow burn satisfying rather than frustrating. The forced proximity trope worked really well here, especially against the backdrop of a small town that feels warm and lived in. I would have liked more of that small-town vibe though!
I also really enjoyed the side stories. Learning more about Jackson’s family and the secrets woven through their history added an extra layer beyond just the romance. The supporting characters are likeable and add to that found family vibe that small town romances do so well.
Thematically, this book leans heavily into belonging, what makes a place feel like home, and how much of ourselves we are willing to risk for love. It is character driven, emotional without being overly heavy, and easy to read in the best way.
Overall, I really enjoyed this. It was sweet, heartfelt, and comforting, even if at times it followed familiar romance beats.
“I didn’t understand why Esther wrote that letter. I couldn’t see the point of her requests. But I get it now. It was all about you. You were every reason why.”
I read Every Reason Why by Sophie Hamilton as part of a readalong with Tandem Collective for their Chapters and Chat book club, and it was such a cute, easy to sink into contemporary romance with that cosy small town feel.
The story centres around Leah, who has built a life for herself in Amity Court, the home of her late employer Esther. When Esther passes away, her grandson Jackson inherits the house, but there is a condition in the will that means Leah is very much part of the deal. What follows is forced proximity, reluctant cohabitation, and a slow shift from tension to something softer and much deeper.
Leah was absolutely the sunshine in this grumpy x sunshine dynamic. She is unapologetically herself and it was genuinely refreshing. No matter what life has handed her, she chooses warmth. She chooses to see the good. There is something very comforting about a character like that.
Jackson is your classic good looking, grumpy, overworked MMC; with a complicated relationship with his family and more emotional baggage than he would ever admit to. On the surface he is closed off and driven, but as the story unfolds you start to see the hidden depths and the trauma he is quietly carrying. Watching him slowly unravel and rebuild was one of the stronger aspects of the book for me.
Their banter was top form. It felt natural and fun, and the chemistry built in a way that made the slow burn satisfying rather than frustrating. The forced proximity trope worked really well here, especially against the backdrop of a small town that feels warm and lived in. I would have liked more of that small-town vibe though!
I also really enjoyed the side stories. Learning more about Jackson’s family and the secrets woven through their history added an extra layer beyond just the romance. The supporting characters are likeable and add to that found family vibe that small town romances do so well.
Thematically, this book leans heavily into belonging, what makes a place feel like home, and how much of ourselves we are willing to risk for love. It is character driven, emotional without being overly heavy, and easy to read in the best way.
Overall, I really enjoyed this. It was sweet, heartfelt, and comforting, even if at times it followed familiar romance beats.
“I didn’t understand why Esther wrote that letter. I couldn’t see the point of her requests. But I get it now. It was all about you. You were every reason why.”
November 23, 2025
4.5 Stars!
Another smash hit! I absolutely loved More than nothing, so I was SO SO happy when I got that arc of Every reason why!
It was so different from More than nothing, and not in a bad way! Sometimes, series of interconnected books set in the same location feel quite recycled, but this didn’t at all. There were glimpses of the familiar world and characters of book one, but they were not stifling or obvious. The world felt completely new and exciting, as it revolves around an old house, home of late author Esther and her secretary Leah, our FMC. Leah has been living there since being helped out of homelessness by Esther, and now faces a potential eviction, with no job and nowhere to go the prospects are bleak. She is allowed to stay, though, until the sale of the house goes through. And Jackson, our MMC, is the person that has inherited the house and that’s trying to sell it. He’s broody, grumpy and moody, the PERFECT mmc to thaw, in my opinion! :D Esther left some directions in her will meaning that Jackson has to spend more time in the property, and in Leah’s company, that he wants. ENTER FORCED PROXIMITY!
Leah is a ray of sunshine, always happy to help, friendly, quirky, funny. And Jackson can’t absolutely stand it. Until…. Well I won’t spoil the book for you because it’s AMAZING, the way that Leah manages to inch herself through Jackson hard shell is an emotional and heartwarming journey, not without hardship I must say! (I was shouting at them at some point, IYKYK). I’ll leave the discovery of the rest to you!
A nudge of appreciation for the Romantasy hints and mentions, they made my heart happy! And a massive bow to migraines disease representation! I felt seen, it felt so wholesome to see what I experience monthly on the pages of a book, raw, unfiltered and not downplayed as “just a headache”!
This book made me cry multiple times, and that’s all I want in a book, an incredible story, that makes me FEEL.
Another smash hit! I absolutely loved More than nothing, so I was SO SO happy when I got that arc of Every reason why!
It was so different from More than nothing, and not in a bad way! Sometimes, series of interconnected books set in the same location feel quite recycled, but this didn’t at all. There were glimpses of the familiar world and characters of book one, but they were not stifling or obvious. The world felt completely new and exciting, as it revolves around an old house, home of late author Esther and her secretary Leah, our FMC. Leah has been living there since being helped out of homelessness by Esther, and now faces a potential eviction, with no job and nowhere to go the prospects are bleak. She is allowed to stay, though, until the sale of the house goes through. And Jackson, our MMC, is the person that has inherited the house and that’s trying to sell it. He’s broody, grumpy and moody, the PERFECT mmc to thaw, in my opinion! :D Esther left some directions in her will meaning that Jackson has to spend more time in the property, and in Leah’s company, that he wants. ENTER FORCED PROXIMITY!
Leah is a ray of sunshine, always happy to help, friendly, quirky, funny. And Jackson can’t absolutely stand it. Until…. Well I won’t spoil the book for you because it’s AMAZING, the way that Leah manages to inch herself through Jackson hard shell is an emotional and heartwarming journey, not without hardship I must say! (I was shouting at them at some point, IYKYK). I’ll leave the discovery of the rest to you!
A nudge of appreciation for the Romantasy hints and mentions, they made my heart happy! And a massive bow to migraines disease representation! I felt seen, it felt so wholesome to see what I experience monthly on the pages of a book, raw, unfiltered and not downplayed as “just a headache”!
This book made me cry multiple times, and that’s all I want in a book, an incredible story, that makes me FEEL.
March 18, 2026
The return to Pine Springs in the interconnected standalone series is a bit of a departure from More Than Nothing. Where MTN focused more on the small down vibes and the chaotic personas that go with that, Every Reason Why is far more focused on individual character development. The kitschy friend group does help to balance out what could have been otherwise missing there, I love a generation defying book club.
Leah and Jackson stand on either side of an inheritance dispute, with Leah filing the role of the emotion based girl next door type everyone loves while Jackson is the city guy who has forgotten how to use his emotions. Comparatively speaking I felt the MCs in MTN were more multifaceted and developed although I did still enjoy the book overall. A bit less on the suspense side and more of the family drama. I do like the look of the dynamic for book 3 so I’m looking forward to seeing how that couple turns out!
Thank you Amazon Publishing UK | Montlake for providing this ebook for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
Leah and Jackson stand on either side of an inheritance dispute, with Leah filing the role of the emotion based girl next door type everyone loves while Jackson is the city guy who has forgotten how to use his emotions. Comparatively speaking I felt the MCs in MTN were more multifaceted and developed although I did still enjoy the book overall. A bit less on the suspense side and more of the family drama. I do like the look of the dynamic for book 3 so I’m looking forward to seeing how that couple turns out!
Thank you Amazon Publishing UK | Montlake for providing this ebook for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
January 17, 2026
Every reason why is another Pine Springs small town romance that has just as much mystery/intrigue as the first in the series. While book one was more high stakes in some ways, this book had a slowly unraveling secret while the love story was taking place. There characters from book one also made an appearance, which I’m a big fan of.
A great addition to the Pine Springs series, and perfect for fans of Grumpy Sunshine/Small town romance/forced proximity/found family/spicy chemistry
Thank you NetGalley and Amazon Publishing UK | Montlake for the advance reader copy
A great addition to the Pine Springs series, and perfect for fans of Grumpy Sunshine/Small town romance/forced proximity/found family/spicy chemistry
Thank you NetGalley and Amazon Publishing UK | Montlake for the advance reader copy
March 5, 2026
Great characters. Enjoyed seeing the romance between these two develop. Imo could have trimmed just a tad. Overall it worked and was a satisfying read - though I did enjoy book one more. Will definitely check out the next in the series
March 22, 2026
The MMC took the story down significantly for me as his portions were a beating for half of the listen. The FMC was great and a lot more forgiving than me. My only issue with her is that she she allowed his looks to override his sctions.
February 19, 2026
DNF as audiobook at 5% cause of dudes vocal fry. I just couldn't.
March 8, 2026
loved her first book, loved this just as much. I was desperate to finish it to find out how it ended but also didn't want to to end. looking forward to book 3.
December 5, 2025
Pine Springs is becoming one of my favorite interconnected standalone series—I loved book 1, so when I got an early ARC for book 2, I was so excited. This book can absolutely be read on its own, characters from book 1 only make minor cameos.
Every Reason Why has the coziest small town vibe, sprinkled in with the perfect amount of romantic suspense. I was invested from the very beginning, and stayed up until 4 am to finish because I couldn’t put it down.
✅ Forced Proximity
✅ Grumpy / Sunshine
✅ Small town
✅ Found family
✅ Rich hero
Both of the MCs are in their late 20s, and both are feeling lost and lonely at the beginning of the book but express it in very different ways.
Leah, our FMC, was orphaned as a child and spent her adolescence in foster care, where she never felt like she belonged or was wanted. When she aged out of care she became homeless, because she had no one to turn to. For a while she lived with her ex who constantly put her down, until she befriended elderly Esther, who took her in to her home and hired her as her publishing assistant. Despite her upbringing, Leah is still the kindest and sweetest person, and despite feeling unworthy, she can still stand up for herself and the people she loves. The book begins after Esther has passed away, and Leah is left alone again after losing a grandmother figure.
Enter our MMC, Jackson, who has inherited his grandmother Esther’s estate. There are stipulations, however. He needs to spend time—LOTS of time—at the house, while Leah is still living there. This just makes his life even more difficult than it already is, and he isn’t shy to express how grumpy he feels about it. Once we meet Jackson’s horrible parents and see how they have treated him, we realize why he is so down on life. He begins the story with his walls so high up and impenetrable, feeling like he has no one on his team.
The house soon becomes a sanctuary for Jackson for many reasons, and he starts dreading having to go back to the city. Jackson and Leah slowly build a relationship and it is so sweet!! I loved seeing Jackson’s walls come down and him realizing that Leah is actually on his team 🥹
I cried multiple times while reading this—when a book makes me feel as much as this book did, it is automatically 5⭐️ from me. Can’t wait for book #3 in the series!!
Every Reason Why has the coziest small town vibe, sprinkled in with the perfect amount of romantic suspense. I was invested from the very beginning, and stayed up until 4 am to finish because I couldn’t put it down.
✅ Forced Proximity
✅ Grumpy / Sunshine
✅ Small town
✅ Found family
✅ Rich hero
Both of the MCs are in their late 20s, and both are feeling lost and lonely at the beginning of the book but express it in very different ways.
Leah, our FMC, was orphaned as a child and spent her adolescence in foster care, where she never felt like she belonged or was wanted. When she aged out of care she became homeless, because she had no one to turn to. For a while she lived with her ex who constantly put her down, until she befriended elderly Esther, who took her in to her home and hired her as her publishing assistant. Despite her upbringing, Leah is still the kindest and sweetest person, and despite feeling unworthy, she can still stand up for herself and the people she loves. The book begins after Esther has passed away, and Leah is left alone again after losing a grandmother figure.
Enter our MMC, Jackson, who has inherited his grandmother Esther’s estate. There are stipulations, however. He needs to spend time—LOTS of time—at the house, while Leah is still living there. This just makes his life even more difficult than it already is, and he isn’t shy to express how grumpy he feels about it. Once we meet Jackson’s horrible parents and see how they have treated him, we realize why he is so down on life. He begins the story with his walls so high up and impenetrable, feeling like he has no one on his team.
The house soon becomes a sanctuary for Jackson for many reasons, and he starts dreading having to go back to the city. Jackson and Leah slowly build a relationship and it is so sweet!! I loved seeing Jackson’s walls come down and him realizing that Leah is actually on his team 🥹
I cried multiple times while reading this—when a book makes me feel as much as this book did, it is automatically 5⭐️ from me. Can’t wait for book #3 in the series!!
April 28, 2026
Thank you Net Galley and Publishers for sending me ARC!
3.75 Stars!!
Every Reason Why really pulled at my heartstrings! You know how sometimes you read a book and just get totally wrapped up in the characters' lives? That's exactly what happened here.
The author, Sophie, has this amazing way of creating characters that feel so real, like people you could actually know. I especially loved Leah. She's been through so much, from being an orphan and homeless to losing the woman who finally gave her a home. But even with all that, she's just this incredibly positive and warm person. She sees the good in everything, and it's really inspiring. I found myself rooting for her so hard, like she was my own little sister!
Then there's Jackson. He's this grumpy, closed-off guy who inherits his grandmother's house, Amity Court, where Leah lives. He really doesn't want her there at first, but his grandmother's will has a special condition that forces them to live together. So, you've got this classic "grumpy guy meets sunshine girl" situation, which I always love.
Watching Jackson slowly, slowly let his guard down and actually see Leah was so satisfying. He's got a lot of emotional baggage and a complicated family history, which explains why he's so guarded. But as he spends more time with Leah and in Amity Court, you see him start to heal and open up. And Amity Court itself felt like a character in the story; you could just feel all the love and history within its walls.
There were also some really unexpected twists that actually made me gasp out loud! I love when a book does that! And the side characters were great too, especially Sam and Kash. Plus, Jackson's awful dad, Alistar? Oh my gosh, he made me so angry every time he showed up!
The book touches on some deeper topics like homelessness and trauma, but it does it in a way that feels really honest and doesn't weigh the story down. It's about finding belonging, what "home" really means, and how love can help you heal.
Overall, I'd say this is a really sweet, heartfelt, and emotional read. It's one of those books that sticks with you long after you've finished the last page. If you're looking for a romance with depth, some good banter, and characters you can truly care about, you should definitely pick this one up!
3.75 Stars!!
Every Reason Why really pulled at my heartstrings! You know how sometimes you read a book and just get totally wrapped up in the characters' lives? That's exactly what happened here.
The author, Sophie, has this amazing way of creating characters that feel so real, like people you could actually know. I especially loved Leah. She's been through so much, from being an orphan and homeless to losing the woman who finally gave her a home. But even with all that, she's just this incredibly positive and warm person. She sees the good in everything, and it's really inspiring. I found myself rooting for her so hard, like she was my own little sister!
Then there's Jackson. He's this grumpy, closed-off guy who inherits his grandmother's house, Amity Court, where Leah lives. He really doesn't want her there at first, but his grandmother's will has a special condition that forces them to live together. So, you've got this classic "grumpy guy meets sunshine girl" situation, which I always love.
Watching Jackson slowly, slowly let his guard down and actually see Leah was so satisfying. He's got a lot of emotional baggage and a complicated family history, which explains why he's so guarded. But as he spends more time with Leah and in Amity Court, you see him start to heal and open up. And Amity Court itself felt like a character in the story; you could just feel all the love and history within its walls.
There were also some really unexpected twists that actually made me gasp out loud! I love when a book does that! And the side characters were great too, especially Sam and Kash. Plus, Jackson's awful dad, Alistar? Oh my gosh, he made me so angry every time he showed up!
The book touches on some deeper topics like homelessness and trauma, but it does it in a way that feels really honest and doesn't weigh the story down. It's about finding belonging, what "home" really means, and how love can help you heal.
Overall, I'd say this is a really sweet, heartfelt, and emotional read. It's one of those books that sticks with you long after you've finished the last page. If you're looking for a romance with depth, some good banter, and characters you can truly care about, you should definitely pick this one up!
February 12, 2026
3 stars.
This was a cute small town romance with an old house that needs fixing. (There is something in these let’s fix this old house together type of books that I love!) This is the second part of the series but works really well as a standalone, I didn't feel at all that I should've read the first part before this.
This was a good book but the miscommunication trope is always a problem for me - without that, this would've been a four star read. However I'm going to continue with the series, as the writing, characters and plot in general were good!
WHAT I LIKED: OMG when he was sick and she took care of him it was so sweet. I loved the scene where she read aloud to him. I also loved the concept of the Bed of Truth, it was funny! Side characters were good too.
WHAT I DIDN’T LIKE: I liked the first 70 % and then the miscommunication thing begun. I hated when they didn’t communicate. I mean, It’s not difficult to say: ”I didn’t invite him. Your dad did.” Instead they don’t talk and assume things. I actually had to skim some of the miscommunication madness because I just couldn’t stand it.
WHAT TO EXPECT:
Pov: dual, 3rd person
Heat: open doors
Pacing: slowburn
Communication: miscommunication
Third act:
Ending:
Main characters:
* City boy - small town girl
* Damsel in distress
* Enemies to lovers
* Grumpy - sunshine
* Opposites attract
* Physically very different
* Roommates
What?
* Forced proximity
* Found family
* Grand gesture
Where?
* Small town
Drama?
* Difficult past
* Family drama
* Imaginary love triangle
Other vibes:
* ”We’re just friends”
“You’re my someone. My own special someone. I love the inside of you twice as much as I love the outside of you. And let’s face it, Jax, you’re really pretty.”
This was a cute small town romance with an old house that needs fixing. (There is something in these let’s fix this old house together type of books that I love!) This is the second part of the series but works really well as a standalone, I didn't feel at all that I should've read the first part before this.
This was a good book but the miscommunication trope is always a problem for me - without that, this would've been a four star read. However I'm going to continue with the series, as the writing, characters and plot in general were good!
WHAT I LIKED: OMG when he was sick and she took care of him it was so sweet. I loved the scene where she read aloud to him. I also loved the concept of the Bed of Truth, it was funny! Side characters were good too.
WHAT I DIDN’T LIKE: I liked the first 70 % and then the miscommunication thing begun. I hated when they didn’t communicate. I mean, It’s not difficult to say: ”I didn’t invite him. Your dad did.” Instead they don’t talk and assume things. I actually had to skim some of the miscommunication madness because I just couldn’t stand it.
WHAT TO EXPECT:
Pov: dual, 3rd person
Heat: open doors
Pacing: slowburn
Communication: miscommunication
Third act:
Ending:
Main characters:
* City boy - small town girl
* Damsel in distress
* Enemies to lovers
* Grumpy - sunshine
* Opposites attract
* Physically very different
* Roommates
What?
* Forced proximity
* Found family
* Grand gesture
Where?
* Small town
Drama?
* Difficult past
* Family drama
* Imaginary love triangle
Other vibes:
* ”We’re just friends”
February 25, 2026
Fabulous follow up!
This series is quickly becoming a new must read for me. Sophie Hamilton does a great job of creating moody, gritty stories and weaving in intrigue, angst, and so. much. romance. I adored her first story, More Than Nothing, and couldn’t wait for this next book.
Leah resides in a beautiful, but somewhat rundown, Victorian home called Amity Court. Her elderly landlord and friend, Esther, recently passed away, leaving the house to her grandson, Jackson.
Jackson’s first impression is rude, abrupt, and uninterested. He is tasked with fixing up and selling Amity Court asap, and wants Leah gone.
Stemming from a broken childhood in foster care, and never quite finding where she belongs, Leah tries her best to exist around Jackson—Always showing kindness and being true to her quirky self, even if she struggles with feeling accepted by others. Jackson has never really been shown kindness. Growing up in a cold family home where his wants and needs were ignored, and being privy to his father’s ruthless business dealings, Jackson doesn’t know how to act with Leah. Unbeknownst to the other, a level of attraction begins to grow, but it’s not until Leah shows a broken and sick Jackson true care and kindness that they give in to their growing feelings.
As Leah and Jackson begin to bring out a side of happiness in each other they’ve never known, a true belonging they’ve never felt, a shadow lurks. A deal Jackson’s father has made has consequences, and suddenly Leah is being followed and threatened. Business rivalries become dangerous, and a secret Esther has kept for years begins to come to light.
I loved this second installment in the Pine Springs Series. The level of romance/spice is so satisfying and I loved that the beautiful Amity Court was like another main character. I love how these stories are connected, but the main characters in each book aren’t tightly bound to the other, creating a true standalone. I can’t wait for the next one!
This series is quickly becoming a new must read for me. Sophie Hamilton does a great job of creating moody, gritty stories and weaving in intrigue, angst, and so. much. romance. I adored her first story, More Than Nothing, and couldn’t wait for this next book.
Leah resides in a beautiful, but somewhat rundown, Victorian home called Amity Court. Her elderly landlord and friend, Esther, recently passed away, leaving the house to her grandson, Jackson.
Jackson’s first impression is rude, abrupt, and uninterested. He is tasked with fixing up and selling Amity Court asap, and wants Leah gone.
Stemming from a broken childhood in foster care, and never quite finding where she belongs, Leah tries her best to exist around Jackson—Always showing kindness and being true to her quirky self, even if she struggles with feeling accepted by others. Jackson has never really been shown kindness. Growing up in a cold family home where his wants and needs were ignored, and being privy to his father’s ruthless business dealings, Jackson doesn’t know how to act with Leah. Unbeknownst to the other, a level of attraction begins to grow, but it’s not until Leah shows a broken and sick Jackson true care and kindness that they give in to their growing feelings.
As Leah and Jackson begin to bring out a side of happiness in each other they’ve never known, a true belonging they’ve never felt, a shadow lurks. A deal Jackson’s father has made has consequences, and suddenly Leah is being followed and threatened. Business rivalries become dangerous, and a secret Esther has kept for years begins to come to light.
I loved this second installment in the Pine Springs Series. The level of romance/spice is so satisfying and I loved that the beautiful Amity Court was like another main character. I love how these stories are connected, but the main characters in each book aren’t tightly bound to the other, creating a true standalone. I can’t wait for the next one!
April 17, 2026
Book number 2 in the Pine Springs series. Every Reason Why delivers exactly what you’d expect from a small-town romance—heart, tension, and a strong emotional core—while still leaving a bit of room for improvement.
Set in Pine Springs, Michigan, the story leans into that cozy, community-driven atmosphere where everyone seems connected and drama simmers just beneath the surface. The setting of Amity Court, a historic mansion filled with both warmth and conflict, works especially well as a backdrop for the story’s central relationship.
Leah Raven is easy to like from the start. Her optimism, humor, and determination to protect the life she’s built make her a compelling heroine. Jackson Hale, on the other hand, brings the classic grumpy, emotionally-guarded energy. His resistance to Leah and to vulnerability in general creates a dynamic that feels familiar but still engaging. Their forced proximity setup works nicely, and watching their walls slowly come down is one of the book’s strongest elements.
The chemistry between Leah and Jackson is undeniable, though this is also where the book may not work for everyone. Around the 40% mark, the story becomes significantly more focused on steamy scenes. If you prefer a more balanced romance with greater emphasis on emotional development, this may not be for you. I ended up skipping those spicy scenes and felt like I didn't lose much of the plot. Thankfully, the storyline regains momentum toward the end.
The external conflicts—Jackson’s controlling father and the looming threat tied to Leah—add stakes, but they could have been explored more deeply. This ties into the main drawback: while the characters are likable, more development (especially on Jackson’s internal struggles and Leah’s past) would have made their emotional journey even more satisfying.
Overall, Every Reason Why is an enjoyable read with strong character chemistry and a comforting small-town vibe. While the heavier focus on spice may not suit every reader, the heart of the story still shines through.
Thanks to NetGalley and Amazon Publishing UK | Montlake for a digital ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Set in Pine Springs, Michigan, the story leans into that cozy, community-driven atmosphere where everyone seems connected and drama simmers just beneath the surface. The setting of Amity Court, a historic mansion filled with both warmth and conflict, works especially well as a backdrop for the story’s central relationship.
Leah Raven is easy to like from the start. Her optimism, humor, and determination to protect the life she’s built make her a compelling heroine. Jackson Hale, on the other hand, brings the classic grumpy, emotionally-guarded energy. His resistance to Leah and to vulnerability in general creates a dynamic that feels familiar but still engaging. Their forced proximity setup works nicely, and watching their walls slowly come down is one of the book’s strongest elements.
The chemistry between Leah and Jackson is undeniable, though this is also where the book may not work for everyone. Around the 40% mark, the story becomes significantly more focused on steamy scenes. If you prefer a more balanced romance with greater emphasis on emotional development, this may not be for you. I ended up skipping those spicy scenes and felt like I didn't lose much of the plot. Thankfully, the storyline regains momentum toward the end.
The external conflicts—Jackson’s controlling father and the looming threat tied to Leah—add stakes, but they could have been explored more deeply. This ties into the main drawback: while the characters are likable, more development (especially on Jackson’s internal struggles and Leah’s past) would have made their emotional journey even more satisfying.
Overall, Every Reason Why is an enjoyable read with strong character chemistry and a comforting small-town vibe. While the heavier focus on spice may not suit every reader, the heart of the story still shines through.
Thanks to NetGalley and Amazon Publishing UK | Montlake for a digital ARC in exchange for my honest review.
February 5, 2026
❤️Every Reason Why❤️
Every Reason Why by Sophie Hamilton
Pub Date: 16th Feb 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
My ARC Review:
Oh I LOVED this!!
Grumpy/Sunshine ☀️
Spicy romance 🌶️
Enemies to lovers ❤️
Forced proximity 😎
This had so many of my favourite tropes. We need more people talking about this series!
Romantic and spicy, Every Reason Why, begins with Leah attending the funeral of Esther Hale, her Author employer, friend, and landlord at Amity court. When Esther’s grandson shows up to claim his inheritance, and to sell Amity Court, Leah and Jackson find themselves forced to live side by side in the historic mansion. Over the space of the next few months, the walls between them start to crumble.
There’s is so much more to this story though, Jackson’s struggles with his father and stress about the family business begin to play a huge part in both of their lives, forcing them to decide what’s most important.
I love Leah as the FMC. She’s the epitome of sunshine! Her reaction to things sometimes made it seem like she’s a push over, but when we learn where her self doubt stems from, it only makes her more likeable rather than whiney which seems to be common in some other books. I think her back story plays a big part here.
Her character arc is so satisfying too! When you get to the scene with his dad, you’ll know what I mean!!
Jackson is broody, and a bit of a jerk. I actually really hated him sometimes to begin with, but again, his backstory saved him. To the point where I think his character arc was even sweeter than hers.
Credit to the author Sophie Hamilton for doing such a good job developing a character that I could easily love and hate in the same chapter.
I highly recommend this book for lovers on contemporary fiction. A very satisfying read with a perfect happy ending!
Thank you so much Net Galley and Amazon Publishing UK for the ARV in exchange for an honest review.
Every Reason Why by Sophie Hamilton
Pub Date: 16th Feb 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
My ARC Review:
Oh I LOVED this!!
Grumpy/Sunshine ☀️
Spicy romance 🌶️
Enemies to lovers ❤️
Forced proximity 😎
This had so many of my favourite tropes. We need more people talking about this series!
Romantic and spicy, Every Reason Why, begins with Leah attending the funeral of Esther Hale, her Author employer, friend, and landlord at Amity court. When Esther’s grandson shows up to claim his inheritance, and to sell Amity Court, Leah and Jackson find themselves forced to live side by side in the historic mansion. Over the space of the next few months, the walls between them start to crumble.
There’s is so much more to this story though, Jackson’s struggles with his father and stress about the family business begin to play a huge part in both of their lives, forcing them to decide what’s most important.
I love Leah as the FMC. She’s the epitome of sunshine! Her reaction to things sometimes made it seem like she’s a push over, but when we learn where her self doubt stems from, it only makes her more likeable rather than whiney which seems to be common in some other books. I think her back story plays a big part here.
Her character arc is so satisfying too! When you get to the scene with his dad, you’ll know what I mean!!
Jackson is broody, and a bit of a jerk. I actually really hated him sometimes to begin with, but again, his backstory saved him. To the point where I think his character arc was even sweeter than hers.
Credit to the author Sophie Hamilton for doing such a good job developing a character that I could easily love and hate in the same chapter.
I highly recommend this book for lovers on contemporary fiction. A very satisfying read with a perfect happy ending!
Thank you so much Net Galley and Amazon Publishing UK for the ARV in exchange for an honest review.
March 2, 2026
I absolutely absorbed this book. From the very first chapter of Every Reason Why, I knew this was going to be a book I would struggle to put down, and I was right.
“Never flirt at a funeral. As far as life lessons go, it was right there at the top.”
I love a grumpy vs sunshine dynamic, but for me, what made this one stand out was the depth and emotion behind it. This wasn’t just a book filled with banter and tension (although we absolutely did get this!), it was two people carrying around very real pasts, very real trauma, trying to navigate new found love whilst still attempting to protect themselves. Watching the layers slowly peel back and walls coming down felt incredibly intimate and honest.
Sophie Hamilton beautifully weaves in heavier themes of homelessness, chronic illness, and mental health, without them ever feeling forced. They’re handled with such care, and this book really reinforces that romance reads can have depth and still be filled with the most pure swoon moments!
I felt every single emotional moment with the vulnerability, the fear, and the learning how to trust when every instinct screams to shut back down. It’s difficult seeing parts of yourselves in characters sometimes - the people-pleasing, forgiving too quickly, the wanting to fix everything - but that’s what made this read hit even harder. It was deeply relatable.
I loved every single part of this story. The tension, the tenderness, the growth, and especially the way they showed up for each other in some of the most difficult moments. A five-star, whole-heart kind of read for me that all romance readers need to read!
“Never flirt at a funeral. As far as life lessons go, it was right there at the top.”
I love a grumpy vs sunshine dynamic, but for me, what made this one stand out was the depth and emotion behind it. This wasn’t just a book filled with banter and tension (although we absolutely did get this!), it was two people carrying around very real pasts, very real trauma, trying to navigate new found love whilst still attempting to protect themselves. Watching the layers slowly peel back and walls coming down felt incredibly intimate and honest.
Sophie Hamilton beautifully weaves in heavier themes of homelessness, chronic illness, and mental health, without them ever feeling forced. They’re handled with such care, and this book really reinforces that romance reads can have depth and still be filled with the most pure swoon moments!
I felt every single emotional moment with the vulnerability, the fear, and the learning how to trust when every instinct screams to shut back down. It’s difficult seeing parts of yourselves in characters sometimes - the people-pleasing, forgiving too quickly, the wanting to fix everything - but that’s what made this read hit even harder. It was deeply relatable.
I loved every single part of this story. The tension, the tenderness, the growth, and especially the way they showed up for each other in some of the most difficult moments. A five-star, whole-heart kind of read for me that all romance readers need to read!
December 9, 2025
I didn’t think I could love the second Pine Springs book half as much as I loved the first, but Sophie proved me wrong. I loved this book so much and I am so sad it’s over.
Leah is outgoing, bubbly and adorable. She’s eccentric and artistic, sweet and kind, caring and bright. She’s everything you could want in an FMC. She loves fiercely, and once you’re loved by her she will break the barriers of the earth to protect you, even if it hurts her.
Jackson is grumpy, misunderstood and undervalued man. He has spent his life trying to live in someone else’s shadow to please parents who resent him no matter what he does. Underneath his rough exterior and the stone walls he’s erected around himself, he’s funny and sweet and observant.
Of course, the grumpy man always needs a little sunshine. Together, Jax and Leah are the perfect team. She’d fight wars for him and he’d burn down the world for her. They both fought their attraction, but complete each other. It wouldn’t be a Sophie Hamilton novel without a little yearning and brooding, now would it?
If you like a small town, found-family, slow burn romance, this is the book for you. The supporting characters are some people we met in book one and got to know well, and some new folks. All of them are funny and nosy and lovable. It feels like you’re friends with all of them, and I think that’s what I love the most about Sophie’s books. I hated for it to end, so I guess I’ll have to re-read! Thank you, Sophie for allowing me to be a member of your ARC team!
Leah is outgoing, bubbly and adorable. She’s eccentric and artistic, sweet and kind, caring and bright. She’s everything you could want in an FMC. She loves fiercely, and once you’re loved by her she will break the barriers of the earth to protect you, even if it hurts her.
Jackson is grumpy, misunderstood and undervalued man. He has spent his life trying to live in someone else’s shadow to please parents who resent him no matter what he does. Underneath his rough exterior and the stone walls he’s erected around himself, he’s funny and sweet and observant.
Of course, the grumpy man always needs a little sunshine. Together, Jax and Leah are the perfect team. She’d fight wars for him and he’d burn down the world for her. They both fought their attraction, but complete each other. It wouldn’t be a Sophie Hamilton novel without a little yearning and brooding, now would it?
If you like a small town, found-family, slow burn romance, this is the book for you. The supporting characters are some people we met in book one and got to know well, and some new folks. All of them are funny and nosy and lovable. It feels like you’re friends with all of them, and I think that’s what I love the most about Sophie’s books. I hated for it to end, so I guess I’ll have to re-read! Thank you, Sophie for allowing me to be a member of your ARC team!
Review of advance copy received from Indie Reviewers
Jackson and Leah 🥹🫦 A gripping and intense couple! They had one of the slowest burns I have read about with so much angst and yearning! Thank you so much, Sophie, for this ARC 😏 A treat and what a story!!! What a strong fmc and an obsessed mmc!
Leah Raven 🥹 She is absolute sunshine and such a strong woman. She's incredibly brave and motivated, doesn't let life throw her down and fights with everything she is 🥹 When we first meet Leah, she is quiet and sunshine chaos 😂 And it doesn't lessen, infact it gets brighter and it had me giggling the way she had their friends, and her man running circles around her 😌 Beautiful, intelligent, brave, fierce, sunshine, protective, outspoken, incredibly talented and hardworking, assistant to his grandmom, supportive and honestly, his exact opposite 😏
Jackson Hale 😌 Hawt grumpy billionaire property developer 🫦 Jackson is a complete grump when we meet him and I was constantly side eyeing him 😂 His character held so much sorrow that you had to stop the side eye eventually 😩 He is a new person around Leah and can't understand why 😏 she calms him, and grounds him like no other 🥹 He can't help noticing her and her sunshine, her feistiness and their banter. There is nothing he won't do for her 🫦 Handsome, intelligent, grumpy, protective, jealous, kinky, obsessed, celibate and secret sunshine 😏
The slow burn had me gasping and kicking my feet. The spice when it hit was 😈🔥 The chemistry and angst sizzling!! The writing is absolutely incredible and gripping. I adored seeing Elenie and Roman 🥹 I can't to see the next couple in Pine Springs 😏
Leah Raven 🥹 She is absolute sunshine and such a strong woman. She's incredibly brave and motivated, doesn't let life throw her down and fights with everything she is 🥹 When we first meet Leah, she is quiet and sunshine chaos 😂 And it doesn't lessen, infact it gets brighter and it had me giggling the way she had their friends, and her man running circles around her 😌 Beautiful, intelligent, brave, fierce, sunshine, protective, outspoken, incredibly talented and hardworking, assistant to his grandmom, supportive and honestly, his exact opposite 😏
Jackson Hale 😌 Hawt grumpy billionaire property developer 🫦 Jackson is a complete grump when we meet him and I was constantly side eyeing him 😂 His character held so much sorrow that you had to stop the side eye eventually 😩 He is a new person around Leah and can't understand why 😏 she calms him, and grounds him like no other 🥹 He can't help noticing her and her sunshine, her feistiness and their banter. There is nothing he won't do for her 🫦 Handsome, intelligent, grumpy, protective, jealous, kinky, obsessed, celibate and secret sunshine 😏
The slow burn had me gasping and kicking my feet. The spice when it hit was 😈🔥 The chemistry and angst sizzling!! The writing is absolutely incredible and gripping. I adored seeing Elenie and Roman 🥹 I can't to see the next couple in Pine Springs 😏
February 18, 2026
Every Reason Why is the second book in Sophie Hamilton’s Pine Springs series. The story begins at the funeral of Esther Hale in the small town of Pine Springs, Michigan. In attendance are Esther’s best friend Hazel, her secretary/companion Leah Raven, her son Allistair and his wife and grandson Jackson, as well as her large group of friends. It will be several days before the reading of the will, but Leah already knows Esther’s estate will go to her grandson with the caveat that Leah be allowed to continue living in the house until she completes the work on Esther’s last mystery novel or until the house is sold.
What Leah doesn’t know is that the will also stipulates that Jackson spend a month in residence beginning when he takes possession, then every other weekend until it sells. Although Jackson works in an executive position in his father’s construction company, his true calling is in renovation. Unfortunately, Allistair will not even discuss adding this service to their offerings. But Jackson can certainly use his skills to improve the value of his grandmother’s house, which his father is pressuring Jackson to sell to help his company settle a questionable debt.
This is a very well told story that incorporates long held secrets, family drama, illicit dealings, and finding one’s own salvation. The characters are very well drawn and the imbedded threads of dyslexia, foster care, and homelessness are meaningfully written as are the numerous hidden gems. I very much enjoyed this book and I do recommend it!
What Leah doesn’t know is that the will also stipulates that Jackson spend a month in residence beginning when he takes possession, then every other weekend until it sells. Although Jackson works in an executive position in his father’s construction company, his true calling is in renovation. Unfortunately, Allistair will not even discuss adding this service to their offerings. But Jackson can certainly use his skills to improve the value of his grandmother’s house, which his father is pressuring Jackson to sell to help his company settle a questionable debt.
This is a very well told story that incorporates long held secrets, family drama, illicit dealings, and finding one’s own salvation. The characters are very well drawn and the imbedded threads of dyslexia, foster care, and homelessness are meaningfully written as are the numerous hidden gems. I very much enjoyed this book and I do recommend it!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This is the second book in the Pine Springs series set in a fictitious town in Michigan. The book is an enemies-to-lovers romance with intriguing characters, heart, “community drama” and a strong plot about a business deal going wrong which I thought was the best part of the novel.
Jackson Hale has inherited his grandmother’s home, Amity Court. But it comes with caveats: Esther Hale’s aide, Leah, must stay until she can complete assembling Esther’s last book and Jackson must live in the house for one month before he can sell. Jackson’s dad, Alistair, wants the house sold immediately because he’s in financial trouble. This forms the framework for the story which on the romance side plays out predictably but on the business side there are shady things going one - this adds a mystery element. Some of Esther’s friends, Hazel and Marjorie, add spunk to the book. But definitely Jackson’s father is someone you love to hate.
I didn’t know this was the second book in a series, but it is a stand alone. I liked the business story but found the romance between Leah and Jackson boring - yes, there’s steam, but to me it was merely that: fodder for the romantics who are more interested in that side of the story. But all in all it was a pretty good read. The book’s well written too.
I’d like to thank NetGalley and Amazon Publishing for allowing me to read this ARC.
#everyreasonwhy
#sophiehamilton
Jackson Hale has inherited his grandmother’s home, Amity Court. But it comes with caveats: Esther Hale’s aide, Leah, must stay until she can complete assembling Esther’s last book and Jackson must live in the house for one month before he can sell. Jackson’s dad, Alistair, wants the house sold immediately because he’s in financial trouble. This forms the framework for the story which on the romance side plays out predictably but on the business side there are shady things going one - this adds a mystery element. Some of Esther’s friends, Hazel and Marjorie, add spunk to the book. But definitely Jackson’s father is someone you love to hate.
I didn’t know this was the second book in a series, but it is a stand alone. I liked the business story but found the romance between Leah and Jackson boring - yes, there’s steam, but to me it was merely that: fodder for the romantics who are more interested in that side of the story. But all in all it was a pretty good read. The book’s well written too.
I’d like to thank NetGalley and Amazon Publishing for allowing me to read this ARC.
#everyreasonwhy
#sophiehamilton
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Ugh I just loved this book so much.
Every Reason Why is the second book in the Pine Springs series and while you don't need to have read the first one, I highly recommend that you do because I loved it also.
When Esther Hale passes away, her grandson Jackson inherits her home, Amity Court. Jackson begrudgingly works for his father's development company and has always been compared to his late brother Dominic. With his father making some bad business decisions, Jackson plans to spruce up Amity Court and get it on the market. The only problem is, Esther's tenant Leah Raven who has been tasked with working on Esther's novel.
What I love about Hamilton's books are the depth. Jackson, the grump, and Leah, the bright, sunny one both have their own troubles. Leah has never really had somewhere that felt like home and now Amity will be taken from her. Jackson will never hold a candle to Dominic in the eyes of his family.
The relationship and how it develops between these two is beautiful. There is a really gorgeous caretaking scene which was probably one of my favourite takes on that trope and the pacing worked so well. I believed that Jackson was warming to Leah and it felt real.
This is a romance but as a thriller and crime lover, I always enjoy when that genre is incorporated too. All in all, it gave me everything I wanted and Leah is such a strong character who I want to be friends with!
Bring on the next one!
Every Reason Why is the second book in the Pine Springs series and while you don't need to have read the first one, I highly recommend that you do because I loved it also.
When Esther Hale passes away, her grandson Jackson inherits her home, Amity Court. Jackson begrudgingly works for his father's development company and has always been compared to his late brother Dominic. With his father making some bad business decisions, Jackson plans to spruce up Amity Court and get it on the market. The only problem is, Esther's tenant Leah Raven who has been tasked with working on Esther's novel.
What I love about Hamilton's books are the depth. Jackson, the grump, and Leah, the bright, sunny one both have their own troubles. Leah has never really had somewhere that felt like home and now Amity will be taken from her. Jackson will never hold a candle to Dominic in the eyes of his family.
The relationship and how it develops between these two is beautiful. There is a really gorgeous caretaking scene which was probably one of my favourite takes on that trope and the pacing worked so well. I believed that Jackson was warming to Leah and it felt real.
This is a romance but as a thriller and crime lover, I always enjoy when that genre is incorporated too. All in all, it gave me everything I wanted and Leah is such a strong character who I want to be friends with!
Bring on the next one!
February 20, 2026
Back to Pine Springs for round two and this one completely stole my heart. Every Reason Why by Sophie Hamilton delivers grumpy/sunshine, forced proximity, small-town charm, and emotional depth inside the walls of Amity Court, and I was locked in. Jackson starts off as a Grade A emotionally constipated nepo grump, but watching his icy edges melt under Leah’s steady, luminous sunshine energy was chef’s kiss. Leah is compassion and resilience wrapped in whimsy, and I adored the dyslexia and migraine representation woven so naturally into their story. The forced proximity via Grandma Esther’s will created the perfect slow-burn tension, layered with family pressure, grief, secrets, and that third-act whammy I absolutely did not see coming. The romance felt earned, the banter had me laughing, and yes — there’s a cat, which automatically adds bonus points. The audiobook narration by Marjorie Lakewood and Brandon Utah was phenomenal — distinct voices, emotional nuance, and that kind of delivery that makes the pages dance. This story balances heartache, healing, and swoony payoff beautifully. Cozy but layered. Emotional but hopeful. Slow burn but satisfying. Pine Springs continues to feel like coming home — and I’m already impatiently waiting for book three (Florence, I’m looking at you 👀).
February 3, 2026
Review of *Every Reason Why*
by Sophie Hamilton
Narrated by Marjorie Lakewood; Brandon Utah
**4⭐️**
Jackson lives and breathes the family business. A grumpy, focused, no-nonsense man, he is constantly trying to make up to his parents for the loss of his brother years earlier. When he discovers that his grandmother has left him a rundown house—complete with a cheerful tenant—he knows he doesn’t have time for either.
Leah adores her elderly friend, Esther Hale, and is grateful to live in the broken-down home, even if it means sharing space with a grumpy roommate. She is a breath of fresh air, though at times she leans a little too much toward people-pleasing. Thankfully, she grows throughout the story.
The friendship-turned-romance between Leah and Jackson is beautifully strengthened by their shared need for love, healing, and belonging. The author does a wonderful job highlighting the raw vulnerability in both characters, making their journey feel genuine and heartfelt.
That emotional depth is why this story earns four stars from me.
Thanks to NetGalley and Brilliance Publishing for the opportunity to read and review.
by Sophie Hamilton
Narrated by Marjorie Lakewood; Brandon Utah
**4⭐️**
Jackson lives and breathes the family business. A grumpy, focused, no-nonsense man, he is constantly trying to make up to his parents for the loss of his brother years earlier. When he discovers that his grandmother has left him a rundown house—complete with a cheerful tenant—he knows he doesn’t have time for either.
Leah adores her elderly friend, Esther Hale, and is grateful to live in the broken-down home, even if it means sharing space with a grumpy roommate. She is a breath of fresh air, though at times she leans a little too much toward people-pleasing. Thankfully, she grows throughout the story.
The friendship-turned-romance between Leah and Jackson is beautifully strengthened by their shared need for love, healing, and belonging. The author does a wonderful job highlighting the raw vulnerability in both characters, making their journey feel genuine and heartfelt.
That emotional depth is why this story earns four stars from me.
Thanks to NetGalley and Brilliance Publishing for the opportunity to read and review.
Read
February 5, 2026Leah Raven ha perdido a la persona que más estabilidad le daba en su vida y ahora vive con el miedo constante de volver a quedarse sin un lugar al que llamar hogar. La muerte de Esther no solo la deja sola sino también en una posición incómoda dentro de una casa que ya no le pertenece del todo. Cuando Jackson Hale aparece para hacerse cargo de la herencia, queda claro desde el primer momento que no quiere complicaciones ni vínculos emocionales y mucho menos a Leah viviendo bajo el mismo techo.
Jackson llega cargando presiones familiares, decisiones empresariales urgentes y una relación tensa con el pasado. Amity Court es para él un problema más que necesita resolverse rápido, aunque su abuela haya dejado condiciones imposibles de ignorar. Obligados a convivir, Leah y Jackson se mueven entre silencios incómodos, roces constantes y una atracción que ninguno de los dos planeaba enfrentar.
Mientras la casa guarda secretos y viejas historias salen a la luz, ambos tendrán que decidir qué vale más, huir de lo que duele o quedarse el tiempo suficiente para entenderlo.
Gracias NetGalley por el ARC.
Jackson llega cargando presiones familiares, decisiones empresariales urgentes y una relación tensa con el pasado. Amity Court es para él un problema más que necesita resolverse rápido, aunque su abuela haya dejado condiciones imposibles de ignorar. Obligados a convivir, Leah y Jackson se mueven entre silencios incómodos, roces constantes y una atracción que ninguno de los dos planeaba enfrentar.
Mientras la casa guarda secretos y viejas historias salen a la luz, ambos tendrán que decidir qué vale más, huir de lo que duele o quedarse el tiempo suficiente para entenderlo.
Gracias NetGalley por el ARC.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This was a spicy romance novel taking place at Amity Court in small town Michigan. Jackson grandson of Esther inherited her home that was in need of deep repair. Feeling pressured by his dad to save the failing family business he wanted nothing more to sell and help. When going over the will Esther forces Jackson to allow her book editor Leah to reside in the residence until the final edits were done. The forced proximity brings new emotions, hurdles and more between the two. The weight of decisions is weighing on Jackson and Leah seems to be the only light.
The writing was clear, flowing and easy to read. The spice was thoughtfully done, and the characters were likeable. I really enjoyed Hazel! A nice light-hearted, feel good read.
My main critique; I was expecting more of the Michigan element, describing the scenery outside Amity Court. Especially because it was emphasized in the summary of the book. Other than being told it was in MI I would have never known by reading. Also, I enjoyed the ending but it left a main point of the book unanswered.
The writing was clear, flowing and easy to read. The spice was thoughtfully done, and the characters were likeable. I really enjoyed Hazel! A nice light-hearted, feel good read.
My main critique; I was expecting more of the Michigan element, describing the scenery outside Amity Court. Especially because it was emphasized in the summary of the book. Other than being told it was in MI I would have never known by reading. Also, I enjoyed the ending but it left a main point of the book unanswered.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 115 reviews