1.5*
Copied from bookclub notes so I don't have to spend any more time thinking about this book to write a full review:
Some nice writing but it's lost amongst a lot of pretentious wordiness most of the time.
Quotes I liked:
-Drunk on cider and violence
-She filled the hall with a sound borrowed from the animals at the abbatoir: agony, outrage, shock.
-an acquired head injury has scuttled his childhood while sealing him within it forever
-picking through the ashes of her life...had exhausted her.
-she strolled with the shadow of his ghost through town
-Weaving the towns proud history seamlessly into prouder fantasy
-She had slotted the Rubik's cube of his soul in to place a long, long time ago
-Joy felt like a controlled burn was happening in her soul. The detritus of years of hurt and confusion were being burned away.
-If someone as beautiful as Nobuko could live her for who she was, why couldn't she love herself? It was a realisation she struggled to keep alight once she found herself in Bodkins.
-she didn't wnat to correct the path of anyone who'd put in the effort of carving out their own (Ginnys transition)
She love Artemis, and Aryemis loved her, but no force on Earth could make Artemis love herself.
The majority of the time, the book feels like it's trying to be clever and witty, but I found it really hectic and not funny. Just not my kind of humour and it felt like it was trying too hard.
There are a lot of very very detailed descriptions of the characters and their backstories, and the towns history, and it feels like it bogs down the narrative. I feel like I don't actually get to know the characters or gain a perspective of the town because I'm being bombarded by constant lengthy descriptions and a bulk of information at a really fast pace which I actually found quite stressful but also a bit boring because I just don't care about anyone. Too much history but it also relies on assumed knowledge of the area.
Don't love the language- cunt, wander, drongo- lots of swearing and slang. It definitely sets the scene but it was just a bit much for me and was extra bogan. Felt like a parody of a country town, like it was poking fun but it went too far.
Interested in readership outside of Perth- a lot seems to rely on already having prior knowledge of and understanding of the area such as the South West, places nearby like Donnybrook and Balingup, what it means to work on St Georges Terrace, the use of Fremantle Limestone, the area of Peppermint Grove, etc.
Detailed description of the Anime Joy had worked on did feel like it connected to something the author was trying to say, but it also felt disconnected to me from the story of the town, like it was just chucked in there to add some difference. The manga creator was "disappointed by the fact that no one understood he was making fun of the mediums tripes and cliches and fed up with the manganese publishing industry itself" self insert?
I feel like I wanted to like Joy, and there was a lot about her history and relationships that could have led to an emotional connection- like her relationship with Nobuko feleing so natural, but then he returned to Bodkins and her 'fire goes out' and she just marries Glen and that's really glossed over and he just disappears?
I liked the brief appearances of Ginny and would have been interested in more of a connection to her, especially as her transition and her connection at the end with Ophelia were just mentioned really offhandedly.
The very end where there are just brief updates on some of the characters was one of the nicest parts to read and made me wish we'd got to known them more as more fleshes out characters and not just caricatures or part of the joke of the town.
Writing skill is there, but the author has chosen to lean into a style that I personally don't find clever or particularly funny. It feels overdone and a bit forced, and kind of all over the place with a strong sense of self-insert especially in regards to the anime aspect. I get the feeling the author is just trying to be "not mainstream" but beyond that I'm not sure there's a lot of direction to the book as a whole. This kind of humour will probably appeal to some but it doesn't to me, and I wouldn't have finished this if it weren't a BC pick