What do you think?
Rate this book


Audible Audio
First published November 2, 2021
An Eggnog to Die For by Amy Pershing was an uncharacteristic choice for me–a Christmas murder mystery–but I have read this genre at Christmastime before, and enjoyed it. Pershing kept the blood and gore out of the story and made the murder–a blow to Santa’s ( ! ) head–a clean and tidy hit. The cover proclaims “A Cape Cod Foodie Mystery” which refers to the protagonist, Samantha (Sam) Barnes who writes restaurant reviews for the local paper. Sam knows her food and is always curious about ingredients whenever she dines out, so she is a perfect sleuth who transfers this culinary curiosity to the job of finding the identity of Santa’s killer.
The foodie part of the book featured plenty of subtle asides and cooking tips. The reader is suddenly taken out of the story and dropped into a cookbook with a narrative, then transported back to the story. I did not find this distracting as the tips were integrated so seamlessly. I learned some helpful hints and even had to do a bit of research to learn more. For example, I had no idea what littlenecks were. Far more often were Sam’s stream-of-consciousness italicized remarks. The reader gets deep inside her head and we know exactly what she is thinking. We have an inside view of the whole person as if we were sitting next to her as she lay beside us on a psychiatrist’s couch.
I found the motivations for murder by the possible suspects to be far-fetched. Pershing was stretching it to link some of the characters to the murder. Not likely reasons to inspire anyone to kill Santa. Before Sam identified the killer, while she was revealing possible suspects one by one, I genuinely considered that their motivations were so flimsy that, had I so much as cut in line ahead of any of them, they might plug me full of lead. So I could only shake my head and wonder, these people would knock off Santa because of that? No spoilers here, but when the real murderer was revealed, it wasn’t a total surprise, but I thought…Really? That person is the killer?
Pershing filled the book with Christmas content, as people prepare for the holidays on Cape Cod, but once Christmas is over–and the murder not yet solved–there is, obviously, no more reason to mention it. It was a Christmas story no more.
The author thanked three editors at the end of the book, but six extra eyes couldn’t fix two gaffes. One is:
“It’s like trying a put a name to that elusive spice you’re tasting in a new dish at your favorite restaurant.”
where the word after trying should be to.
But she got a character’s name wrong when she referred to Mrs. Mayo on the bottom of page 252 when clearly she had been talking all this time with Mrs. Lipman. Mrs. Mayo just appeared out of nowhere, and then we’re back to Mrs. Lipman again.