Maybe 3 1/2. The second short story was about 4 stars, but the first pulled it down. The first author may be award winning, but this was not her best effort. The story was dull, disjoint, had an obvious "bad guy," and employed a deus ex machina. In addition, there were things any good editor should have caught. Two were involving guns. At one point, one of the characters "slept with a rifle under her pillow." Not a gun, but a rifle. That was either one SMALL rifle or one BIG pillow. In addition, the same person later "slept with her rifle." I assume, after the pregnancy, she popped out pop-guns. I believe, in psychoanalytic terms, this is called "a fetish." The second story not only had two very strong characters, but, for the first time in ALL the books of this series I've read, the woman was allowed to be taller than the male.