9/10: 4.5⭐️’s rounded down to 4⭐️’s
Holy cow I ended up rambling and oversharing!! Reader be warned!
I thought this was going to be a five star book with how into it I initially was. But alas, I found some things in the story to go not exactly as how I would have preferred 🤦🏼♀️. If I want everything to go the way I would like, I should write my own book. Since that isn’t going to happen (and I cannot find the one I did start many years ago, you will not be seeing any books authored by me anytime soon as in never. I found some poetry and a short story from a creative writing class I took. Poetry was awful. Short story was kind of cute. It was about a lemonade stand.) I will just deduct a star from the books that don’t go the way I want.
Was most of the above paragraph necessary? Nope not at all, it’s like it’s impossible for me to not ramble on and on when I type. My dad’s response to a text message I sent him in response to his ‘do you need water?’ message was ‘you almost wrote a book’. It could have been a one word response. Obviously I talked about more than just water jugs being refilled. But still. Shorten that shit down self. (See I swear!! So all of my whining about swearing seems hypocritical) anyways…move along Marta. People have things to do besides reading about your water needs. I did not yet need water btw.
The book. So, Emma Cross. She is quite simply a delightful, likeable, dependable person. Which often creates problems for her because everyone basically likes her and people are drawn to her and seek her out for advice and guidance and help. Basically people have some unfair expectations of her and she is put in the middle of other peoples situations/chaos because so many people respect what she thinks etc. it’s a tough spot to be in and in turn make people unfairly upset with her when she doesn’t want to stick her beak in others business or when she won’t take sides. Eventually people get over it, but you know how people can be.
Technology isn’t needed to spread gossip in this town. Nope not at all. Good gosh do these people gossip. I can’t quite figure out how it all works, but it sure spreads.
And the number of murders. It kind of makes me think of Cabot Cove. Small, safe town but dang there are a lot of murders for Jessica Fletcher to solve. They gossip like crazy in MSW too. And every body basically loves Jessica. Emma is like Jessica’s spirit sister. I am surprised it took 3 books to make that comparison.
For the book summary, read the book summary provided by GR’s. I don’t have the thinking ability at the moment to put it into words that make sense right now. If you haven’t noticed I am a bit all over the board with this. 🙄.
It was another great cozy, lighthearted mystery. So many fabulous secondary characters. And several quite shady ones too. The fabulous outweighs the shady in this one. And the baby that stole all of their hearts….. some babies are just like that. You fall instantly in love with them and there is no possible way for you to not love them.
Fortunately for me, those 3 babies it happened with, with me, are much older now and I still am in their life.
The first time I held the middle boy, (not going to get into the soap opera like story. the circumstances of Robbie brought him to mind the most) but I honest to goodness did not want to give him back. It took an instant in my arms and I knew he was my ex’s baby because I don’t think I would have fallen instantly in love with him if he hadn’t been. I just knew. And as crazy as it sounds, I was immediately grateful he cheated on me because if he hadn’t, that tiny baby wouldn’t have been in my arms. Wouldn’t have become my little shadow. Wouldn’t have called me Harta instead of Marta when he was 3. Wouldn’t have gone on shopping trips out of town with me. Would y have been on the freshman football team last year and look in the crowd and waved at me and my dad when he spotted us in the stands 😊. Wouldn’t have his tin of cookies I gave him for Christmas in the pic we took because ‘they were his most prized possession’ (I made them with gluten crackers this time and when I explained how I wore a mask while making them (I have celiac disease) and changed my clothes right away and washed my hands about ten times afterwards, he joked I should have just worn a hazmat suit. Wouldn’t be a 15 year old who bakes me gluten free muffins and makes me tator tot hotdish, or put his hand on my shoulder as I tell him I am fine when I nearly pass out and lean against the fridge. Wouldn’t be here to let me hug him longer than he probably would prefer sometimes, but he will hang on until I am done.
That’s what little Robbie in this book made me think of. All of those things and so so much more.
Okay so none of the boys ever better read this review. I don’t think any of them know the middle boy is the result of their dad cheating. Not something they need to know. And shut up self. Just throwing all your business out there like this!! 🙄🤦🏼♀️.
Rating and whatever the heck the rest of that was: 11/2/25
Grammar correction (then I got sick of reading what I wrote😂 so the rest will remain for now!: later on 11/2/25
Small corrections/additions/deletions: 11/3/25
Ps. No hater comments on him cheating on me please. He happens to be a really great guy. He buys me tampons and chocolate for goodness sake!😂 I don’t condone cheating at all, but in my specific situation, it worked out to my benefit in the end I guess you could say! Just giving context on how some babies grab your heart and don’t let go. Doesn’t matter how they came into your life. You are just meant to love certain people I guess. And I was meant to love these boys.
Maybe I did just write a book😂. Dang this was long!!