I’ve been reading James Patterson books for over twenty-five years. During that time, like most of his fans, my favorite character has always been Alex Cross. He was Patterson’s first detective series that helped lay the foundation for his kingdom of several bestselling series and stand-alone novels. For me, Alex has remained a fierce, intellectual knight of moral character and the proper use of action.
I still remember reading the Alex’s first adventure, “Along Came a Spider” and almost cried when Alex, then a widower, faced the loss of his new love in an ending twist I would never forget. In the thirty years following, there have been some good (and excellent) adventures and some less-than-stellar outings along the way, but I generally looked forward to the end of each year when another Alex Cross adventure was published.
Now, in late 2025, the 34th book in the series – “Return of the Spider” – has been published, and I have completed my coveted annual reading journey with Detective Cross.
*** Be forewarned that this is a different type of Alex Cross novel; a flashback story that serves as a prequel to both ”Along Came a Spider” and the Detective Cross series as a whole. ***
“Return of the Spider” begins in the current day with Cross and his partner, John Sampson, are called to a crime scene in a desolate area of New Jersey. The property is connected to none other than Gary Soneji, a serial killer that was one of Cross’s most deadly of nemesis years ago. The investigators have found buried bodies, weapons, murder kits, and journals written by Soneji that tell in detail how Soneji studied famous serial killers and transformed himself from into a killing monster. As Cross turns the pages of Soneji’s notebooks titled “Profiles in Homicidal Genius” he discovers that his past connection to Soneji started sooner than he thought and there are even more secrets that will cause the detective personal pain and self-doubt.
We then turn back to a time in the past when Gary Soneji was actually Gary Murphy, an unhappily married traveling salesman who had was starting a secret life as substitute school teacher, and Alex Cross was a rookie homicide detective trying to prove his worth with the Washington DC Metropolitan Police Department. Alex is being trained by his work partner, John Sampson, who is also his best and most trusted friend. At home, Alex lives with his first wife Maria, who is pregnant with their second child, and his son, Damon.
Before he knows it, Alex is involved in multiple investigations, involving murder and gang retribution. To make matters worse, he is starting to see a pattern that feels like a serial killer copycat is at work. Little does he realize that Gary Murphy is learning how to murder and cover his tracks. As he transitions into Gary Soneji, he has even bigger plans that involve leading Cross and Sampson to follow evidence that blame others for his crimes. Will Alex make the biggest mistake a rookie detective could make…
This book was a double-edged sword reading experience for me. Reading prequels can be hard because you already pretty much know the outcomes of the plotlines and the characters since you’ve already read what happens to them after this one. For example, you already know who will live and who may not, as well as where their development or arc ends so that it is in sync with the previously read first book in the series. It’s really tough for the writer to add anything new or surprising unless it impacts or changes something in the current timeframe, which is unlikely with at least 33 previous books that follow this one already revealing pretty much everything that you need to know. I think you get where I am going with this.
So, the question is, what could Patterson add to the Alex Cross mythology with a prequel involving a serial killer that Alex will hunt down multiple times in the future until Soneji finally faces his demise? Well, the answer is surprisingly a good one for the most part. Patterson found a way to be reflective with the past, provide some learning lessons that our hero Cross had to experience, and even a surprising twist that makes Cross only doubt himself, but peels the onion on his own morality and humanity. Even knowing where the storylines were going, having this view into Cross’s early career and family life, Patterson made the pages fly by at record speed. Maybe I am still feeling nostalgic from watching the end of “Stranger Things” during the holidays, but reflection and memories can be a good thing.
That is why I think that hardcore Alex Cross readers will like this definite change of pace story. Even with the flashback approach, Patterson was still able to include his usual thriller elements, fast-paced tempo, and enough dramatic twists and turns from beginning to end. It definitely packed a lot of punches, but what worked best for me was seeing and feeling Alex in the early stage of his career and his great love for Maria, an important part of his life that we just never got to enjoy enough. There were also several mystery plots that moved back and forth smoothly and effortlessly due to Patterson’s crisp, focused, and tight writing style. I really appreciated the family scenes shared between Alex and Maria, as well as Alex and Damon. Because of knowing how Damon and Jannie will grow and develop in later books and being a father and grandfather), those moments were golden for me.
Overall, I think “Return of the Spider” was interesting enough that I had no problems devouring it in two evenings. I even think it was one my more favorite Alex Cross books even though you could see the ending coming pretty easily in my humble opinion. Although prequels don’t always work well, this one added an additional layer or two to the legacy of Alex Cross.
3.5 to 4 out of 5-stars for me.
And to be honest, I greatly appreciated not having to read another book in which Cross spent all of his time running around, chasing his never-ending fight with “M” and Maestro vigilante group. That plotline has gone on too long, the shark has jumped, and it needs to be wrapped up, sooner rather than later.