I was drawn to ‘Wreck’ by the promise of a humorous and poignant story; however, upon reading it I found it isn’t humorous, it isn’t poignant, and it isn’t a story. Instead, it’s a caricature of a middle-class family middle-classing that is so over-the-top and inauthentic that it feels like a parody of a really bad sitcom.
As I read it, the only laughter came from the characters themselves, as they repeatedly ROFLed at something unfunny one another had said, and the canned laughter I imagined playing while the sitcom actors hammed it up on set.
When it comes to poignancy, using an actual tragedy as a background for these characters going about their problem-free lives is not poignant; nor is having the characters spout platitudes at any given opportunity (“Sometimes things just feel bad anyways.” “It’s hard to be a person.” “We’re all just cadavers in the making.”); nor is the random, unearned and overly trite moral about how you ought to be grateful for and make the most of life while you have it because you don’t know when it will end, which is thrown in at the closing moment in lieu of an actual ending or a resolution to anything that has happened up to that point.
In terms of story craft, this too is lacking. Random cuts to scenes from the past that bear no relevance to the present frequently interupt the flow. Anything that even resembles conflict is resolved in the very next instant. The pacing is incredibly uneven, with long and unnecessary scenes at the beginning devolving into a series of disjointed, time-jumping snippets of scenes by the end. I could go on.
Overall, ‘Wreck’ is a bit of a wreck. No plot. No characters or goals to root for. No purpose. Aside from the distastefulness of the rape jokes, I found it unmemorable, and reading it was not a good use of my time. Fortunately, at only 240 pages, it’s very short, so I didn’t have to suffer it too long.
Many thanks to NetGalley, Catherine Newman and Transworld for the ARC.
⚠️ Cancer, car accident, suicide, death of a child, blood, rape jokes, drug use, medical procedures, health anxiety