A bold reconsideration of women in art - from the ‘Old Masters’ to the posts of Instagram influencers.
A perfect pin-up, a damsel in distress, a saintly mother, a femme fatale....
Women’s identity has long been stifled by a limited set of archetypes, found everywhere in pictures from art history’s classics to advertising, while women artists have been overlooked and held back from shaping more empowering roles.
In this impassioned book, art historian Catherine McCormack asks us to look again at what these images have told us to value, opening up our most loved images - from those of Titian and Botticelli to Picasso and the Pre-Raphaelites. She also shows us how women artists - from Berthe Morisot to Beyoncé, Judy Chicago to Kara Walker - have offered us new ways of thinking about women’s identity, sexuality, race and power.
Women in the Picture gives us new ways of seeing the art of the past and the familiar images of today so that we might free women from these restrictive roles and embrace the breadth of women’s vision.
An excellent reexamination of classic and modern art through an intersectional feminist lens. (featuring illustrations!!) In this book, McCormack attempts to change the narrative pushed on women over centuries of being exposed to artwork that objectifies them and puts them into a box. Each chapter dissects a different archetype of women as muses and features an antithesis to them. My favorite chapter was the last one, called “Monstrous Women”, which looks at feminine figures who were wrongfully villainized in mythology (and real life) and used as a means to keep women in their place. A truly great read. (Minus one star because the language sometimes made the narrative hard to follow.)
Catherine McCormack legt in Women in the Picture eine scharfsinnige Analyse der westlichen Kunstgeschichte und Populärkultur vor, in der sie die Darstellung von Frauen als Spiegel patriarchaler Machtstrukturen entlarvt. Mit präzisem Blick verfolgt sie die archetypischen Bilder von Venus, Madonna, Jungfrau und monströser Frau und zeigt auf, wie diese Ikonen Frauen systematisch auf Rollen der Verfügbarkeit, Reinheit oder Bedrohung reduzieren. McCormack argumentiert dabei, dass solche Bilder nicht bloß ästhetische Objekte sind, sondern aktiv gesellschaftliche Normen formen und festigen – und damit weit über den Rahmen der Kunst hinauswirken. Besonders kritisch beleuchtet sie Werke wie Titians Vergewaltigung der Europa, das Gewalt gegen Frauen ästhetisiert und romantisiert. Solche Darstellungen, so McCormack, schreiben nicht nur historische Erzählungen fort, sondern legitimieren subtil die Objektivierung und Entrechtung von Frauen. Ihre Analyse legt offen, wie weibliche Sexualität und Fortpflanzung in der Kunstgeschichte weniger als Ausdruck weiblicher Autonomie denn als Projektionsfläche männlicher Machtfantasien inszeniert wurden. Auch die unsichtbare Arbeit der Mutterschaft wird von McCormack thematisiert – als ein zentraler, aber oft verdrängter Aspekt weiblicher Erfahrung. Gleichzeitig verweist sie auf die Widerständigkeit zeitgenössischer Künstlerinnen, die tradierte Narrative bewusst dekonstruieren und alternative Sichtweisen auf Weiblichkeit und Identität entwickeln. Frauen erscheinen nicht mehr als passive Objekte, sondern als handelnde Subjekte mit eigener Stimme und Geschichte. Women in the Picture wird so zu einem leidenschaftlichen Plädoyer gegen die fortwährende Ästhetisierung weiblicher Unterwerfung – und zu einer Einladung, unser Sehen und Verstehen von Kunst grundlegend zu hinterfragen.
First of all, i might be a little biased because this is my first book that touches the topic of objectification and marginalization of women in art but this was seriously so well written. The proper explanations, the descriptions of the pieces and the mentions of previously learned information all made this into such a easily followable text that i have nothing bad to say about it. It was amazing. The structure, the selected pieces as examples, the connection between the ancient times, medieval ages, mythologies and the present give the reader such a wide yet perfectly relevant overview of the issue. I also loved the way the book was divided into chapters based on influential archetypes and it made me realize so many things that now seem so obvious. Every woman, every man every artist and non artist, everybody should read this book, because what it explains shapes our society till this very day.
I want everyone in the world to read this book. I almost worry it's geared towards women when it should be the men in our lives who read this and understand how the stories and myths from the start of civilization have shaped how we view women now. Wild! She opened my eyes and my heart and it will be one of my favorite books of all time!!!
An overview of the tropes used in classical art and how these appear today in current mediums, and how these images are still used as tools to value and devalue women.
Women in the Picture is a deeply engaging examination of how woman has been represented, or misrepresented, throughout Western art over centuries.
What I particularly enjoyed about this book is the fact that McCormack does not simply critique but also offers alternative ways of seeing and foregrounding women artists, thinkers and subjects.